10 Spadroons that don't suck!

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
2 Video Views·Mar 19, 2026
Spadroons are often ridiculed, sometimes fairly, but often by those who do not understand them, or that there is a broad spectrum in terms of their quality and effectiveness. Here we look at when spadroons were done right and were actually really good swords.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Spadroons suck, right? Actually, no. There are some fantastic examples from a functional perspective.
So let's dig into 10 great examples of the spadroon.
Hi, I'm Nick Thomas, and welcome back to the Academy of Historical Fencing.
It's really fashionable to hate on spadroons and ridicule spadroons.
And in reality, that's kind of quite a modern perspective for the most part.
So in a recent video I put up about swords that absolutely suck,
there were a number of spadroons.
But you'll notice I mentioned that there were some really good examples as well.
And so today we're not going to look at any of the bad examples.
This is going to pick the very best, really good examples.
Now when I talk about good or bad for the spadroon in this particular video,
I'm talking about functionally.
Because aesthetics are important in both military and civilian swords.
But when it comes to the spadroon, what you really want to know right now is,
are they going to be good as a fighting sword, as a sword to defend your life with?
I'm going to show you a range of absolutely fantastic spadroons
that are both, in many cases, beautiful but also functional.
Some will be from my personal collection.
Some will be that I've handled at museums.
Others that have come up at auction houses.
And there's going to be quite a spectrum.
So stick around.
I said 10.
It's actually 14 because I got carried away.
And there were so many fantastic examples that I wanted to show you.
And there were even some honourable mentions at the end of oddities and things
that didn't quite make the mark or aren't quite spadroons.
So stick around.
You're going to see a lot of fantastic and beautiful swords.
So very briefly, what is a spadroon?
Well, a spadroon is a straight medium length sword
that is designed for both cut and thrust
and emphasises agility and speed over all else.
And that means it can't have too much mass up here at the tip
because it's supposed to be fast.
And it cannot have too much hand protection
because that restricts wrist mobility and also adds weight.
And so generally speaking, spadroons cap out in the weight range
around the early 800 gram mark.
And in blade length, they're usually around about 82 to about 85 centimetre.
That's around 32 to 33 inch roughly.
There could be a bit of variance, but that's the standard.
Now, in the video about bad swords, we established that some spadroons,
the bad ones, tend to have overly flexible blades,
too little mass to actually deliver significant damage
and hilts that compromise protection.
And that made them bad swords.
So in this video, we're going to look at the ones where they did it right.
You know, sometimes what is actually a spadroon
can actually be quite complicated.
If we look at this absolutely stunning scroll hilt
sort of sabre, not a sabre that I got recently,
this will have a video of its own very, very soon
because this is a non-regulation British officer's sword
that is truly fantastic.
But it actually follows kind of the spadroon type specification
of, you know, being quite nimble here at the point.
It's straight, it's of a kind of spadroon type size,
although this is a bit too heavy.
So in this video, we're going to stick to things
that are absolutely definitely spadroons.
But, you know, this kind of shows you that even in the mid
and going into the late 19th, even early 20th century,
Britain was still using very much spadroon type concepts
even after having gone to sabres.
Let's kick off with this absolutely stunning,
probably British spadroon from about the 1770s to the 1780s.
And this one just does it all right, doesn't it?
I mean, aesthetically,
it's one of the most beautiful things I've seen anyway.
But also functionally, the blade has good reach.
It's one of the longer end of the spadroons,
although it's still nimble.
You can tell it's got quite a rigid blade to it
due to that sort of blade profile structure.
The guard has really good coverage
whilst being pierced to keep it light and fashionable.
But those piercings aren't so wide
that they allow the points in.
This one just has it all.
Now, I can't give you any stats for this
because this was a sword that came up for sale,
but just look at it.
It has everything, both as a fighting sword
and a functional one.
When we talk about spadroons as fighting swords,
that is significant because so many people
from this modern lens, modern viewpoint,
just think these are dress swords,
something that you wear to the dance, to the ball,
that kind of thing.
But the spadroon, the military spadroon,
was intended from the start as a fighting weapon
to go and lead troops on the battlefield
or defend your life with.
And this idea that it's excessively light
or excessively nimble or it compromises too much
is actually looking at it from the wrong perspective
because if we look at the development of the spadroon
throughout the 18th century
before it became patent standards, for example,
in the British army,
so many fencing masters and military swordsmen
were talking about how fantastic spadroons were
and how important it was to emphasise agility
and speed in the fight
to make sure you get to the target first
rather than having something that delivers massive blows.
And eventually that started to take stock in the army.
And in fact, rather than being excessively light,
spadroons were introduced as a patent standard,
a regulation standard,
to give officers beefier swords
because again, they were carrying very light hangers
and small swords quite often,
very, very, very light blades
that couldn't do an awful lot.
And the spadroon was brought in as an attempt
to standardise something beefier.
So don't look at it as an excessively light sword.
For its time, the spadroon was giving officers
something a bit more formidable to fight with.
And officers were expected to fight.
They were expected to lead from the front.
In the Napoleonic period,
British officers died in larger numbers percentage-wise
than the enlisted men
because they were leading from the front.
They were getting into combat.
They were leading the sieges and assaults and skirmishes.
Also, the British empire had officers all around the world
that could end up in skirmishes, brawls,
and self-defence scenarios.
And the sword was typically their only method of defence.
And so it was actually intended to be used.
So on to number two,
let's get on to the 1796 Infantry Officer's Sword.
This is the one that gets ridiculed so much.
It is the example that everybody holds up
as a terrible spadroon.
And in reality, yeah, they had some issues.
But again, we're not going to talk about the bad ones.
We're talking about the good ones.
So with the 1796,
yes, there's loads of those really bad ones out there,
but there are actually loads of really good examples.
And I have three here.
Now, how are they good?
How do they do it right when so many didn't?
One, they have fixed shell guards
because the hinged guard on this patterned sword
was never intended to be standard.
It's something that certain officers purchased.
And it is a massive compromise for the sword
just to make it slightly, you know,
sit more flush on the uniform.
So unbelievably unnecessary
and so compromising as a weapon.
And again, as a weapon of self-defence,
that is so vitally important.
So overall on the hilt,
if you make it beefy enough
and you don't have a hinged guard,
this is actually reasonably decent.
Actually has more hand protection
than many contemporary swords of its time.
Now onto the blade.
To do a spadroom blade right,
you cannot have it be too light
and you cannot have it be too flexible
because if it's too light,
it cannot deliver good cutting blows
and it cannot parry formidable sabres
and bayonets particularly well.
If it's too flexible,
it can't penetrate particularly well
against the thick uniforms.
So you need it to have reasonable rigidity.
And if we look at this one now,
this one actually is as formidable and rigid
as many good strong sabres and back swords and similar.
And yeah, actually what a spadroon often is,
is a back sword.
So, so many back swords people absolutely love
and then they look at a spadroon
and don't realise that so many spadroons are back swords.
And when they're made well,
they are literally just a back sword.
So this is a 750 gram beefy spadroon.
It's rigid.
It has good mass.
It has a good guard.
This is a really good example.
And it's not a one-off
because in fact we have this one here,
which is, it's only 700 grams,
but it maintains a decent shoulder.
The blade is reasonably formidable.
The guard is solid and this is pretty good.
And this sergeant's variance,
you notice in that video about bad swords,
I showed a sergeant's sword that was absolutely terrible.
Well, this is a 720 gram beefy one,
which actually has a 12 centimetre balance.
It actually feels quite cutty, more sabre-like.
And this is actually a really good spadroon.
And yet it's still nimble enough at the tip
to be very much a spadroon.
At number three,
let's get onto something more exotic.
And that is this flamberge-bladed,
slot-hilted spadroon in the Greenwich Maritime Museum.
So yes, this is a naval officer's sword
and it just has absolutely everything, doesn't it?
It's kind of based upon and similar
to this beautiful 1803 sabre that I have,
although it has the spadroon blade.
And in this case, it's flamberged,
which is that wavy type flame flambard type construction,
which people endlessly argue about why it was done,
whether it was fashion,
whether it cut better, whatever else.
It could be so many things
and I've seen some interesting tests on them
where they did actually slice really, really well.
But let's not change the subject.
That is a spadroon
and it is just fantastic.
That has fashion.
It has intimidation.
The guard is actually good because slot hilts are good.
And in that case,
it has that additional outer guard with the felled anchor.
So it has even more hand protection.
It's made even more beautiful.
What more could you want out of a spadroon than this?
And it has a back strap,
which yes, some spadroons do have back straps.
And in fact, that in many ways makes it even better still
because back straps do allow you to get the point online
in certain grip positions even better.
So I think this sword is up there
as just one of the all-time best spadroons,
even though it's wacky and wonderful
and having flamboyant on a spadroon,
it's not unheard of.
I've seen probably another 10 examples around.
They're very, very rare, but they happen.
And I think that's just absolutely awesome.
How could you not love that sword?
At number four, the Italian M1833 Albertina.
This is a really interesting sword.
And again, I actually ridiculed Italian cavalry sabers
in that video about bad swords.
And yeah, I don't think they're very good.
It doesn't mean the Italians didn't make some good swords.
In fact, they made many good ones.
The Albertina is a spadroon.
They can sometimes be a little bit heavy enough
to be broad swords,
but frequently they are typically spadroon-type spec.
And they have this sort of metal finger loop
for sort of two fingers to go through,
which is kind of nice.
It kind of harks back to the rapier, if you like,
where you'd put the index finger over the cross guard.
And some swords do have leather loops
to do something similar,
but the fixed loop does an interesting job.
And those Italian Albertina swords,
they have that nice, strong, formidable guard.
I think they just overall...
They're quite beautiful swords.
I've handled a few.
They do handle quite well.
They're kind of often at the slightly beefier end of spadroons,
but still quite spadroon-like.
I really appreciate them.
I think they're a really cool sword.
And at number five, we have this truly phenomenal sword
in the Royal Armouries collection,
which I handled during a handling session.
Now, in the collector's world,
this is often called an attack hilt,
and that is where you have branches,
usually connected to the knuckle bow,
that move and lock into position
to give you additional protection.
The idea from a collector's term is
the sword has features that you would deploy
when you go into an attack, okay?
So it's a very modern term,
but it's sort of useful to understand
what we're dealing with here.
And while this sword is just...
It's just phenomenal, isn't it?
Okay, it doesn't have fantastic thrust protection
through the front,
but overall, it has additional cut protection,
which if you're on the battlefield,
you're going to be dealing with lots of the time.
And it's just an absolutely beautiful sword
and an example of kind of quite an early spadroon
that actually has some fantastic engineering in it.
So it's just...
It's got to be on the list.
It's beautiful.
And then we have this just really simple steel
utilitarian spadroon,
also from the Royal Armouries Collection,
seen in this handling session I was doing again.
And just look at this.
It's boat shell like this,
but look how just simple it is.
Simple steel guard.
The grip has got some really nice texture to it.
This is a sword that's been designed
to be entirely functional.
So there's no flash on this sword.
There's no panache.
There's no decadence.
It's just fantastically functional.
Boat shell guards are good.
The grip is good.
The blade is nimble.
So this is a really good example of a utilitarian spadroon
that kind of has everything.
Number six, the sword we started the video with.
So this is a British heavy cavalry dress sword.
Although don't let that name put you off
because it was also called the dismounted service sword.
So the idea being is that when a cavalry officer
in the heavy cavalry was not doing cavalry duties,
this is the sword they would wear
because it would be more convenient
and not so cumbersome
because their undressed swords,
their battlefield swords were big brutes.
So this is kind of daily service,
although they were also favoured
by certain senior officers as well.
So they did see some battlefield use,
but also a lot of self-defence type applications.
Now this blade actually follows the kind of form
of the Scottish or Highland type broadswords.
And sometimes they are really quite beefy.
They're often a little bit beefier
than the 1796 infantry officer swords,
but you can still see it's quite narrow.
It's still very spadroon like.
This is just over 800 grams.
It has an absolutely gorgeous boat shell guard design,
which is far superior to the double shells
of the 1796 infantry
because with the boat shell
where it curves forward over the guard,
you have increased protection here to the fingers,
which is a vulnerability that you get
with symmetrical or simple shells on the 1796.
This boat shell is stronger with more coverage.
I think it looks sexier.
And this blade is a bit more formidable
than your average 1796.
So this actually would have been
the better infantry officer sword
if they'd actually gone to this one instead.
But there we go.
They were, as I said,
used by some senior officers in the British army.
And in fact, many European nations
used something exactly like this for their officers.
So this is a phenomenal example of a spadroon.
And in this case,
a dismounted service cavalry officer's sword.
Number seven, we have this just fantastic sword
in the New York Met collection.
And it's an example of a sort of early British
sort of shell guard design
where it has additional branches,
which give that protection a bit like a boat shell.
And the blade on this is from the early 17th century.
So it's got a very old German blade on it.
And you might look at this and say,
that's not a spadroon.
It's too heavy.
But in reality,
a lot of these German blades were incredibly thin.
So this sword only weighs 822 grams.
And when I showed you this boat shell, for example,
which is about 810.
So that sort of early German bladed British spadroon
in that New York Met collection
is actually very, very similar
to what I'm showing you here.
So it still is quite spadroon-like
and truly fantastic.
And using old blades was something that did happen.
So you will find in the Napoleonic period,
you know, hilts like boat shells
with really old, like Andrea Ferrara
or other types of older family blades, heirlooms,
or just sort of beautiful older blades.
At number eight, something French.
You might think as a lover of British swords
that I hate French swords,
but that's not actually true.
I do dislike some of them,
but in fact, the French made some good designs
and some very high quality swords.
So actually some of them are really, really good.
In this case, this spadroon,
it was made in 1821.
And I believe it's the 1816 pattern.
It was probably for a gendarme sergeant.
And what does it do right?
Well, you notice it's got a folding guard,
which I talked about at the start of the video
being absolute rubbish.
And in most cases,
folding guards are too much of a compromise.
But in this case,
the French engineered something
really, really clever.
For a start, it has a button lock mechanism
so you don't have a flappy guard,
which is excellent.
And then the way it's constructed,
I mean, that click,
it's just so incredibly satisfying.
And it's so incredibly strong.
It locks into place really well.
It doesn't move.
It will take a really good cut.
So this is an example of a folding guard
that actually functions correctly
and I would be happy to use.
Also, the blade is really nicely done.
So this is a hollow ground diamond section,
which means it's really rigid.
So this is about as heavy
as my boat shell sword I showed.
So it's around just over 800 grams.
It's quite meaty for a spadroon,
but still very, very spadroon-like.
But yeah, it has fantastic rigidity,
and yet it flattens out
into a reasonably good cutting edge,
flattened diamond up here.
But yeah, this hollow ground diamond up here
gives it so much rigidity here in the fort.
So it parries really, really strongly.
So this is, I hate to say it,
so much better than most 1796
British infantry officer's swords.
Although the good ones were this good,
but so many weren't.
And yeah, there you go.
This was missing a bit of the grip.
This would be wire wrapped.
It would be a bit thicker
and a bit nicer on the grip here.
But there you go.
There is a French spadroon
that's actually really good.
At number nine, we have a slot hilt spadroon.
So if we look at my 1803 officer's sword here
with this slot hilt,
the spadroon I'm showing
has exactly the same kind of hilt construction.
Now, this sword was probably made
for the American market.
So in the early 19th century,
it was very, very common for Americans
to purchase British swords
and often of British designs.
And so you can see very much
the 1803 type hilt
fitted with a spadroon-type blade.
And the 1803 hilt is really a good one,
is that it's a lot tougher
than the double shell guards
of the 1796 spadroon,
although it's not quite as wide.
There's not so much difference.
And it has this sort of angular protection
that boat shells have
that actually make it quite formidable.
It offers more protection than it looks.
And it is also a beautiful design,
so all around a really good design.
And you can tell this spadroon
has just been made quite beefy.
It's made by one of the best makers
by Gill of the day.
And yeah, surely for the American market
because it has no royal ciphers on it.
And it's of the type that Americans
were using very often
in the early 19th century.
Just a good all-rounder, fantastic spadroon.
At number 10, we have these two swords,
which I'm going to show,
a kind of joint number 10,
because they're very, very similar designs
where they have a very asymmetric guards
with incredibly beautiful,
elaborate outside guards on them.
One is from an auction house,
and one is from the New York Met collection.
And just all around,
they have enough inside protection.
They have loads of outside protection.
The blades are reasonably formidable.
What's not to like?
They just are fantastically beautiful
and effective spadroon designs
that are sort of almost basket hilts.
Up next, we have these Swedish officer's swords
from the kind of late 18th
and into the 19th century.
Now, Sweden tended to make
most of their military swords incredibly beefy.
So sometimes when you look at something
that looks spadroon-like in Swedish service,
it's so heavy, it's like a cavalry sword.
But in this case,
these officer's swords are actually
made on the sort of lighter end of the scale
for kind of British and French service.
These will be still heavy spadroons,
but they are still spadroons.
And you can tell the hilts
are kind of small sword-like,
but the blades are made nice and beefy.
So the Swedish officer's swords of this period
tended to be just really formidable spadroons
that are just fantastically good designs.
Onto what I would call a cage guard,
because that's what it looks like.
And this is believed to possibly be French,
but it could be British.
And while it looks like that sort of cage,
doesn't it?
It's just a functional design.
It's not the prettiest,
but there's something to be said
for utilitarian aesthetics.
And this one has it.
It's just a good spadroon
with more hand protection than most,
and why not?
And yet it's still comfortable to wear.
It still has fantastic grip mobility
or wrist mobility.
So last on the list would be
the Scottish First Royal Scots Regiment
officer's swords.
And they used the 1796
Infantry Officer's Pattern Hilt,
but they went for much wider blades.
Now, in most cases,
they still fit into the spadroon category.
And the blades look a little bit
like the sort of boat-shell heavy cavalry
dismounted service sword that I showed.
Although in some cases,
they go to such extremes,
like this example in the Royal Armouries collection,
which is definitely no longer a spadroon.
But in most cases, yeah,
they were kind of more that
highland-type, narrow-type blade
that is like a heavyweight spadroon.
And these are just examples of,
again, a really well-made 1796.
Because the 1796
didn't have to have a super narrow blade.
It had to be one inch minimum here
by 32 inch long.
But you could go as wide as you want.
So theoretically,
you could go incredibly beefy
and go with an acute taper,
as a lot of those blades did,
and have a formidable spadroon
that's still really fast at the point.
And so those First Royal Scots
officer's swords were actually fantastic.
There are also a few examples
that are really worth showing briefly
that just have phenomenal guards.
Like this English example,
which just has a hilt
that is just so way ahead of its time.
And then this other,
which actually has a thumb ring,
which is an unusual thing to see on a spadroon,
but can happen.
And again, this hilt is just,
again, fantastic.
Now onto the honourable mentions.
There are a number of spadroons out there
which have fantastic outer guards,
but very minimalist inner guards.
And I think that is far too much of a compromise.
As someone that fights with these swords in sparring,
often I understand the limitations of these guards.
And to have no thumb protections,
this is the inside of the guard,
to have no thumb protection at all
is such a massive, massive weakness.
If your thumb gets hit,
there's a good chance
you're going to drop the sword
or even lose your thumb.
It is too much of a compromise
when you could just have a small amount of guards.
So many hilts,
like three-bar sabres, for example,
just have a little bit of hilt protection
or slot hilt sabres and spadroons,
just a little bit enough to cover that thumb.
And that is enough protection
to keep the thumb safe in most instances.
So these are beautiful sort of spadroons
that almost make the mark,
but by having no inner protection,
they can't be good enough for my list,
but worth an honourable mention.
And then we have the thick chad spadroons
that are not spadroons anymore,
but they're spadroon-influenced or inspired.
And they've been made so incredibly thick and beefy
that you would certainly call these broadswords,
but they're kind of spadroon-adjacent
because they've borrowed from the spadroon blade aesthetic.
And I think they're worth showing here
because they show some of the influence of the time
and I think you'll enjoy seeing them.
And so there we go,
some spadroons that actually really did it well.
The spadroon was intended to give officers
a better sword than they'd had before,
to give them something beefier than their short,
lightweight hangers and their thrust-only small swords.
And in fact,
although the spadroon did die off in British service,
it continued on in many, many other nations
and many sabres that followed on from it
were of sort of similar type specifications.
So the concept didn't entirely die
and they were really, really well-loved by many.
So yes, the spadroon design,
it's prone to having some issues
if you design it too flexible,
too light,
with too much of a compromised guard.
And yet in many cases where it's done well,
you actually ended up with a really good sword
that emphasised speed and dexterity
to get to the target first.
And that often was enough to win a fight.
And there you go.
So spadroons, they can be absolutely fantastic.
I hope you've enjoyed the video.
Please like and subscribe.
If you want to help out the channel,
you can always join our membership program,
but there's no pressure to do so.
I really hope you enjoyed the video.
I'll see you in another one.
