Different training swords for HEMA, Steel, Nylon, Wood, etc.

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
22 Video Views·Dec 16, 2024
A look at the different materials and types of training swords that have and are being used for HEMA, and our opinion on what works best and why. There is so much more to this discussion, but this is an introduction.
Hello and welcome to another article from the Academy of Historical Fencing.
Today I'm going to be talking about the different materials that we use for our training swords
and this is a topic that comes up quite a lot all the time and has done for years.
By the material we mean do we use wood or synthetic or aluminium or steel,
there's a few other options as well, is what do we use and why.
And there's still a lot of conflicting sort of belief on this and there are different schools
around the world doing different things. So I'm going to give you an overview of
what we've used over the years, what we use now and why we use them.
Now quite a few years ago the simple answer was there was only steel.
So you bought something like, well this is a Regeni Sabre but like this, basically a
steel sword which is roughly of the weight and feel of an original and obviously if you have
a sword that is of the weight and feel of an original it will largely hit like the original.
Obviously it's not sharp so that is an advantage but in terms of blunt force trauma and potentially
rigidity as well you're talking about being similar to an original sword.
Now that obviously has some advantages but it's realistic
and disadvantages in that it's going to hit largely like the real sword.
So over the years I've heard a lot of people say why would you use anything but steel,
why not just go for the real thing? Well it's not the real thing, it's blunted steel
which is a compromise in itself because a blunt sword does not feel on contact with another sword
like a sharp sword does and it does have some limitations of safety as well as cost.
So there is no perfect solution for a training sword and I would say anybody that tells you
you should only ever use one particular type, well I would suggest they need to get off their
high horse because there's so many great training swords out there, so many options to expand what
you're doing both in terms of different weapon types as well as different experiences in the
fight. So a quick overview, that's how things started, I mean not obviously with the Rugeni
Saber but with blunt steel swords. A lot of the swords years ago were just reenactment blunts
which often are very rigid and not particularly great in terms of handling characteristics either
but blunt swords they can still have their place, depends what sword you're looking at.
Blunt long swords have gone out of favor with a lot of people now in favor of feathers or
fetish birds which are things like this. This is my Rugeni, rather well used feather and
they're really doing very well in terms of popularity. The feather is characterized by its
thin blunt safe blade that typically has quite a broad shield which is this section you see here
and usually flex quite well, better than a blunt sword will and usually are lighter and a bit safer
than a blunt sword and I do say usually because feathers can range an awful lot in terms of
weight handling and the way they're built. Some of them can be full weight and full handling
characteristics of a sharp sword whilst being blunt and others are built to be a bit safer.
So you see a lot of people have moved on to using feathers and with things like the sabers
this effectively is a blunt version of an original blade just with a rock tip on it
and something like sabre I think that works incredibly well. This is about 800 grams or
850 grams something like that so it represents the original sword quite well and it doesn't
have the immense cutting power of say in terms of blunt force trauma of a 1.8 kilo sort of monster
that you might expect of some big two-handed swords. So I think for a one-handed sword like
this a blunt sword is ideal. Also we're not doing as much thrust work with a sword like this most
of the time so more focused on the the cut so we don't need as much flexibility it's not like a
rapier where we're constantly using thrust work where if you were being hit by this as much as
you would do a rapier it's really going to start to get uncomfortable but it's safe enough and
it's realistic. So I think something like a military sabre or possibly even some smaller
arming swords, something like that, blunt is ideal. For rapiers, obviously I've been a rapier instructor longer
than I have instructed on anything else and I would say steel is great for that especially great
because rapiers don't have the cutting power of a lot of things like a sabre so they become safer
so you have a full weight rapier which you can use at pretty much full contact levels
quite safely. So for rapiers and for a sabre like this, excellent, I would say go for full weight
blunt blades just with a little bit of flexibility. Now don't take that to mean all sabres
because there are plenty of sabres that are awfully heavy. If you look to some cavalry sabres, some
hussar sabres and even just earlier parts of the period sabres you're talking about things that
weigh 1.2, 1.3 kilos or even more occasionally so you're talking about real monsters but in terms
of representing say British pattern sabres, excellent, blunt is really good. So steel, what do I think
about steel? Well when we started our club, in fact we've been training since 1995 and we started the
AHF and actually started teaching people in 2006. For all those years and the first few years of the
AHF we only had steel, it was the only option we had, blunt steel and it is nice in the hand, it feels
better in binds than any other material really does. However it is expensive, it does have some safety
limitations even with some of the best kit that's available today, things have got a lot better
certainly with equipment, you still have to be a bit careful and there are a few
limitations and there are a few safety risks as well as the fact that I really encourage people
to have an eclectic approach to their fencing and study a range of weapons. I think it's a
poor martial artist who really only understands how to use and encounter one other style or one
other weapon. I really think you should be able to pick up a great range of weapons and be able to
use them very successfully and fight against those weapons with whatever you have to hand.
So I believe you should go with a range of weapons, I would recommend you at least have
one steel sword and do spa with it providing you've got the safety gear and are happy to do so.
So yes, blunt steel is a recommendation, it's not the be all and end all, I think you should have
other things as well, yes have some blunt steel. And the feathers, I think they work pretty well,
I think some feathers have got a little bit on the large side to the level that I'm not even
sure what they're representing anymore and they are being used in potentially an overly
sported manner, but that's a topic for another day. Feathers, they are a good thing, often.
And on to what are the types of things they have been. Well, this is a shinai which is a Japanese
training sword which is in fact incredibly well designed. It's pieces of bamboo that are bound
together and on impact they make a lot of sound which of course is great for videos as well,
but they take out all the impact because it's a nice flexible wood, it's very very strong
and the way it's all bound together it takes so much of the impact out of it to the level that
they hit really really light, incredibly light. You could really go into a lot of your sparring
with just a simple pair of padded or lightly protected gloves and a mask and you'd be safe
for most things with a shinai. It's a very light hitting training sword and in many ways it
represents a European sword better than it does the katana that it's trying to represent. Two
reasons really, one because it's straight which is like a lot of long swords that people are
training for as opposed to the katanas which are lightly curved and also because its overall
dimensions represent a longsword really quite well. It does represent something like a
typical longsword, something like an albion leftenau really really well and it's a little
bit long for most katana. So in that regard it's worked quite well. The limitations of it are that
one it has no definable edges. You've got this string to actually tell that's the back edge
but in the fight it's very very hard to tell and it obviously handles the same on all sides as
opposed to the characteristics that we get in longsword or any other European sword of having
a back edge, a true edge and flat and that is relevant to the fight, very relevant in fact.
So you've got no definable edges which is slightly annoying and no flexibility on that either. Again
on the flat plane on a lot of European swords you'd expect a bit more flex and that will affect
how you use it as well. They also don't flex much on thrust. I have seen some impressive
photos and videos where they have been forced to flex but they will hit very hard. You take
that to the throat or the sternum it really hits hard on the thrust and with European swords we
want to do a lot of thrust work even with European longsword. European longsword was
not about just bashing people away with the comparatively dull edges as people would have
believed. So we want to do a lot of thrust work. They're not great for that. They don't have
sustainable edges. They don't have an actual quillen or crossguard as European swords would
typically have. People did add them over time and people used wood and even more plastic to make
those so that could be modified. And the overall weight, they're incredibly light, incredibly light
and again people did modify them. They put ruthen lead around here a bit like you'd have a shield
on a feather so they could be improved upon but ultimately they bounce very badly on impact.
They don't have sustainable edges. They've not got on the thrust so they're not a great training sword.
What they have in their favor is they hit very very light on the cut and they're very very cheap
to buy and readily available. So they do have that in their favor and we did use them for a few years
as beginner swords because again in the early days of the AHF all we really had access to were
very expensive steel training swords so we used the Shinai completely unmodified as just a basic
entry-level trainer. I don't think that's necessary anymore for the simple reason that we've now got
a range of quality synthetic training swords like this from the Nightshot. Now I'm not saying this
is a perfect training sword at all although I'm not even sure what a perfect training sword is
because there are pluses and minuses to all of them. But a Nightshot training sword like this
has sustainable edges. It actually looks and feels like a European sword. It flexes nicely on the
thrust and it doesn't have the bounce issues on the edge that the Shinai does. It still has some
bounce. It bounces a bit more than steel but nothing like the Shinai does. The disadvantages
to this over Shinai is it does hit a lot harder on the edge but a lot lighter on the thrust
so that's a slight disadvantage. All that means is that you need slightly better gloves and you
want some joint protection because you take a high power impact from this on your elbow or your knee
cap and it will do some damage as opposed to the Shinai which it's going to hurt but it won't do
the damage that this hard plastic does. Overall I'd say there's no point in the Shinai anymore.
If you want a cheap, quite safe, entry-level weapon get a Nightshot
synthetic sword. That's just the answer to it. So I wouldn't bother with the Shinai anymore.
The other thing to consider of course is other types of wood. Over the years it's very traditional
to use wooden wasters if you like they're called. Are there any points in using those anymore? I
would say no. The reason they were used historically is because again comparatively safe.
Well this is comparatively safe. Very, very cheap. Well again these synthetics are cheaper
than most wooden swords these days so that doesn't really count. Are they any more realistic
to wood than using this? In that you can get them a bit more rigid but again you go to the
black fencer stuff and you've got the rigidity there and wood has some awful issues in terms
of handling. It doesn't tend to handle particularly well and it chips really badly and tends to crack
and break and even potentially become quite dangerous when it splinters. So I don't really
see the point in using wood anymore. I have done and I don't see the point anymore. We've got so
many better options. Of course in terms of other wood it was very common to use a dowel if you like
on some kind of leather basket called single stick and that was quite a safe training option
particularly in the 19th century. You can use things like rattan or bamboo for that
as well as a range of hardwoods but if you use things like a rattan or a bamboo you've got
something that's got a bit of flex and a bit of play in it so again it can hit lighter. That has
a few advantages over some of the other options but again I would far rather use this. I've used
all kinds of different woods for basket hilts and I would say this is better. It's cheaper,
simpler to actually just purchase and it handles pretty damn well. Any disadvantages it has
it has plenty of advantages over using that wood. So there's the wood option. What else do we have?
Well, aluminium. That is aluminium not aluminum. We are British remember. What do I think of aluminium?
Well, for a few years people started to use it particularly for things like the mesa, Lang's
Mesa or Bruce's Mesa. Why? Because it's incredibly cheap to buy, cheap to work with and you can
purchase these at the time for about £35 which was an incredibly cheap way of getting a training weapon
which handles close to steel. On the binds I've heard people complain over and over that they
don't get the feel through aluminium that you do with steel. I've never found that but I think that
you can feel through aluminium perfectly well. I don't think that's an issue. In terms of when they
bind on each other, in some regards I find that aluminium is more realistic on binds than steel
and the reason for that is because it's soft and it burrs really badly, really easily and as a result
when they impact they have that kind of slightly damaging stickiness when you get edge on edge.
If you get two sharp swords and the edges connect you will take a little bit of edge damage and they
will stick slightly to one another and that's characteristic that you do not get with blunt
training swords. You only get it when you've got something that has a very thin edge or easily
damageable like that. So in some regards these did actually have a similar effect on binding actions
to sharp on sharp steel which was quite nice but of course the problem with that is yes they are
taking this damage all the time and you're having to do constant repairs on them. If you want to use
drills you won't take so much damage and that's fine but again if you want to use something for
drills why not just get synthetic. It's still cheap and it works really really well.
The other consideration with aluminium is it's not flexible.
If it's actually substantial enough to represent the sword anyway.
If it is flexible it'll just bend and stay in place. So yeah on the thrust these hit like hell
on the cut they hit rather hard as well there's just no play in them whatsoever
but they were cheap and they were much closer to actually sharp steel than most other things
out there at the time. But would I recommend aluminium swords anymore? Well not really. There
are cheaper and cheaper steel options available these days. You can go to people like Pito Regheni
and get quite affordable blunts or feathers depending on what you want and if you want
something that represents steel a lot cheaper you can get a range of synthetics from the
night shop or for more realistic realistic options Black Fencer and Purple Heart Armoury in the US.
So that was aluminium. I haven't used these for years now. We did use them for a long time
but I don't think they've really got much of a place in HEMA at the moment.
Okay so I think that takes us through all the options. In terms of what we use in the club
commonly today we've ditched aluminium, we've ditched shinai, we've ditched most blunt steel
swords except things like some side swords, rapiers, sabres and things like that. Whereas
the majority of things we're using like long swords and the earlier pattern curved sabres
we're using synthetic. So if you see what we do in the club we probably have about a 50-50
usage of steel which will be a mix of blunt and feather depending on what type it is
and synthetic swords which if you want the very safe easy option night shop basket hilt still
very very good a lot safer to use on terms of impact damage than Black Fencer and Purple Heart.
If you want the realistic synthetic go Black Fencer if you're in Europe or consider
Purple Heart in the US although again you can get Black Fencer in the US as well now.
That's what I recommend. The last option which I haven't got here today is the padded swords
which are made by Spez and there's a few other companies that make them as well.
They look horrible really but they do have a place. I don't think I've actually put any
videos up of them but we do use them in the club from time to time and they've got hardcore
and then they're padded on the outside. They're a bit like a LARP sword and what place do they have?
Well the useful thing with those is you can just reduce your kit down completely. Now what we've
done with instructors and more advanced students so I wouldn't recommend this to all but the more
advanced students is you can use them with nothing at all no fencing mask no gloves nothing and that
will teach you some valuable lessons about protecting your head. Fencing mask these days
is very tough if you put a mask protector on it's even tougher again and people have a tendency to
just not worry too much about their head and they really should and if you go into a fight with one
of these foam sabers which can hit pretty hard not enough to do serious damage although you should
be concerned about your eyes and your teeth of course you will quickly learn to really worry
about protecting your head. So the padded Spez swords that the sabers for example I think they
have a valuable place they're quite an interesting training tool not one that you need to use often
but they do have a they can teach some valuable lessons if you like. That's my recommendation
is blunt steel and feathers are very very useful they are in many ways the most realistic in terms
of the overall feel on contact in the fight but when you're talking about realism there's more
to realism than just edge on edge because if you wanted realism you would use sharps and
there are very limited things you can do with sharps without killing one another.
If you then look to safer options like the synthetics is they allow sometimes a greater
range of activity some actions that will be a little bit dangerous with steel become more
realistic with this and they're still pretty close to using a steel sword these sort of
sabers for example are incredibly close to using steel. I interchangeably in one night go from using
steel saber to a black fencer they represent a slightly different period saber but even so
they're pretty damn realistic these things. So that's what my recommendation is. Synthetic
which I wish everyone you go for it's excellent it's a good beginner tool it's a good advanced
tool it's good for expanding your range of weaponry you want at least one or ideally a
few steel feather or blunts for a range of other weapons and consider things like padded just as a
other lessons on top if you like so this is a triangulation of different training tools
I wouldn't get stuck with one of them if you only use steel blunt or steel feather I don't think
you can actually learn all the lessons you really need to learn and if you only use synthetic you're
not going to know how steel handles so I'd recommend a bit of a mix. If you're just starting
out I definitely recommend you go with something a bit safer to begin with it's cheaper and there's
less technical problems to worry about. So that's my recommendation thanks for watching
