I thought it would be neat to try Les Carmes Haut Brion as it is getting a lot of media attention. I tried it along side the 2nd wine of La Mission (La Chapelle de la Mission Haut Brion)
In 2010, Les Carmes Haut Brion was purchased by Patrice Pichet, head of the Bordeaux real estate company, Groupe Pichet. In 2013, the Pichot group began a complete renovation of the chateau and wine-making facilities. In total, the entire hectare vineyard of Les Carmes Haut Brion is 29.6 hectares, of which 22 hectares grow vines. However, only 7.6 hectares of vines are used to produce Les Carmes Haut Brion (the rest is used to produce its 2nd wine, Le C des Carmes Haut Brion) The vineyard is planted to 41% Merlot, 39% Cabernet Franc, and 20% Cabernet Sauvignon. With the 2015 vintage, Les Carmes Haut Brion started to vinify about half of their fruit whole cluster. About 4000 cases of this wine is made each year. The blend of the 2017 vintage is 41% Cabernet Franc, 30% Merlot, and 29% Cabernet Sauvignon
Hello everyone, Trophy Wine Hunter. Welcome back to my YouTube channel.
Today I'm doing a really neat tasting. It was spurred by the announcement that
Les Carmes Au Brion just got a hundred points from a number of people in the 2022 vintage.
So I've heard a lot about this winery. It seems like a really hot winery in the media. So I
thought, hey, I haven't really tried it so I should really try it myself. So I thought it
would be nice to do a comparative tasting. These are both 2017 vintages of Les Carmes Au Brion.
And then I picked up the second wine of Le Mission Au Brion. It's called Le Chapelle
Le Mission Au Brion. And I thought that would be kind of a fair tasting. In fact,
at BC Liquor Stores, this second wine of Le Mission Au Brion is actually more expensive
than Les Carmes. So again, that's another reason to kind of try this out. So let's talk a little
bit about the two wineries. So Les Carmes Au Brion is really, it is a good winery. It has a long
history, but it's never really been really that great a performer. It's been decent. It really
changed in 2010 when a person called Patrice Pichet, who is the head of a big real estate
company, purchased the property. And his group Pichet purchased it. And they started adding to
the vineyard. So they have in total, I think about 22 hectares, something like that. And then in 2013,
they started to overhaul the whole winery. They replanted everything. So a lot of renovation has
gone into this winery. Although the winery has about 30 hectares, only about 7.6 hectares are
used for the production of Le Carme Au Brion. They have other wines and their blend is completely
different. What's notable about Le Carme Au Brion is that in the vineyard, it's 41% Merlot, 39%
Cabernet Franc, and 20% Cabernet Sauvignon. And they're going to try to continue to bring up the
Cabernet Franc distribution or portion in the vineyard and the wines in the future. Historically,
Le Carme has had Cabernet Franc in the vineyard, and it's because of their soil and their placement.
They are close to, because of their namesake, they are close in location to Au Brion. Let's
look at the corks and the labels. So this is Le Chapelle, Le Mission Au Brion. Again,
you should expect a good cork. I like the design of Le Carme's cork. That's nice.
Both of them are nice and long. Let's look at the label. So this is Le Chapelle, Le Mission Au Brion.
That must be their vineyard. And again, owned now by the domain Clarence Dillon
Group. Nice little mark on the top of that.
Not a lot on the back of the label, like most Bordeaux's. That's 13.5% alcohol.
Let's go over to Le Carme's Au Brion. Again, that's what it looks like.
Nothing on the back except a nice label. And I'm going to go up on the top here to see if we can
see the difference in the color. I don't think there's a lot of difference in the color. They're
both 2017. You know, it looks like, I thought last night that Le Carme was a little bit darker color.
Now it looks like Le Mission is a little bit darker color. Maybe I could say it's a little
bit duller in terms of color than Le Carme, but it's really hard to tell. I would say fairly equal,
but if I had to say, I would say Le Carme is a little bit more brighter in terms of the
intensity. And this is the Le Mission here is a little bit
duller in terms of the, or maybe even darker in terms of the color.
Beginning with the 2015 vintage, they started to use about half of their grapes were whole clusters.
They ferment with the stems. They use all new oak. So it's 40 and about 4,000 cases are produced.
With the 2017 vintage, the blend was 41% Cabernet Franc, 30% Merlot, and 29% Cabernet Sauvignon.
So it's quite an up and coming winery. Really high scores in the last couple of years,
and that's why I kind of wanted to taste it for myself. Historically, it's been known as a lighter
style wine, maybe because of its Cabernet Franc and fairly early drinking. Although of course it
can last a little bit, it can last longer, but in general, a little bit earlier drinking than
its neighbors. Let's turn also before we drink to Le Chapelle, Le Mission Aubryon. So the name
Le Mission Aubryon comes from in 1600s, this winery was bequeathed to the congregation of
the mission. And that's how it's called Le Mission Aubryon. It's had a very storied history. And in
fact, although it's close to Aubryon, it's nothing like Aubryon wine because of the topography and
the soil types and also the location. It's totally different in terms of the blend and
things like that. So even though it's close, it's really not that close, quite frankly.
Again, let's talk about the modern history because this is not really a full on review.
I'm just going to do a quick comparative and then we're going to taste. In 1983, it was purchased by
Clarence Dillon group who are the owners of the Aubryon. And so the vineyard is about 46% Cabernet
Sauvignon, 43% Merlot and about 10% Cabernet Franc. So this wine, Le Chapelle, which is their second
wine debuted in 1991. And for the 2017 vintage, it was 49% Merlot, 8% Cabernet Franc and 42%
Cabernet Sauvignon. So I thought it would be a nice compare and contrast. 2017 is generally
an earlier drinking year. So I thought it'd be nice to do that. The other thing is I actually
was able to buy these in liquor stores. So that was nice also. There should be a little bit of
difference because the Le Carme has more Cabernet Franc and Le Chapelle, Le Michon Aubryon is
basically a Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon blend. And I thought it was a fairly fair comparison.
For those people that actually think that Le Carme is comparable to Aubryon or Le Michon
Aubryon, I don't think so. And I think there's two reasons for that. One, it has only had a very,
very short history of excellence. Even if you believe all the ratings, we're talking about
maybe five years or six years of excellence. And again, in the Bordeaux world, in the wine world,
that is really not enough history. That's just a speck in the history. So really they need to show
20, 30, 40 years of real excellence before I think they can be considered that. Secondly,
just from a climatic or from an area perspective, it will be difficult to rival Le Michon and also
Aubryon just because of where the location of the soils are, the grape types, their vines are young.
It will be quite, quite difficult. And although that group has spent a lot of money to change up,
first of all, your soil, your location is going to be at a disadvantage. And secondly,
your vines are young. So they've just replanted all the vines. Whereas you've got with Aubryon
and Le Michon, this long history, maybe 60, 80 years of excellence and of growth and of
understanding the grapes and how they interact with the soils there. So just from a rational
point of view, I don't think there would be a reason that you would think that they were
on equal footing. Having said that, I mean, every wine in a given year can taste really good. And so
that's why I thought it was not a fair comparison to compare Le Carme to Le Michon or Chateau Aubryon.
So let's go with the tasting. I will let you know that I have had this open now for a night. I had
this last night with my friends at dinner. We had it with steak and it was wonderful. We did decant
both wines and we drank them over, I'd say a two hour period, put them in the fridge and now this
is the next night. So let's taste them. So let's start with Le Carme because I'm so interested in
this wine. I wanted to taste this because it's really, there's been a lot of press on this wine.
So on the smell, this is the second day. On the first day, I thought it was quite full in terms
of the smell. A little bit, so it was black fruit, tobacco, a little bit of tar, that type of stuff.
So I thought it was quite a nice medium type wine. It wasn't hugely tannic and hugely
full-bodied, but it was quite nice drinking and it went really well with the steak. So today,
on the smell, you smell a little bit more mineralliness and earthiness. The fruits
dissipated a little bit. You smell like new oak, but not toasted oak. So a fresh kind of oak,
almost to a cedar and a little bit menthol, but it smells light in terms of style
and that's what I would expect with Le Carme. So lots of fruit, good acidity, almost like tart cherry,
fresh juicy plums, black plums. On the aftertaste, it's got a minerally and earthiness
to it and I think that is the Cabernet Franc. A little bit of greenness on the aftertaste.
I would say it's medium-bodied. It's not a heavy wine. It's a kind of a lighter style wine.
I agree with that. Nice drinking, but I think it's actually lost a bit of its steam as compared to
last night. And you know what it reminds me of? There used to be this wine that Robert Parker
hailed as a really great wine. I think it's called La Roques and everyone was drinking that wine
for a while. I drank that wine and when it came out of the bottle, it was like
magnificent and everyone agreed. But as you taste it through the night, it got like
lighter and lighter and that's kind of what Le Carme reminds me of. So it was really nice out
of the bottle and honestly when I tasted these together last night, I thought this was a much
better wine and most people agreed in our table. Most of us agreed that this was a better wine
or we preferred it more. But right now, it's actually dissipated quite a bit in terms of the
it's went back to a fairly light style and it's again one of these wines for me, I don't think I
preferred as much as I did last night. So I know the wine spectator rating is 93 points.
I'm going to go with if I just tasted it last night, I probably would have agreed it.
But now that I have a second tasting of this wine, I'm going to go 91 points on this wine.
Yeah, definitely it's not heavy in terms of the mid palate.
It's got a good aftertaste, gravelly again, lots of fruit, luscious fruit, but it doesn't really
have a depth of flavor. But good drinking wine. Let's go to Le Mission, sorry, Le Chapelle,
Le Mission Habillon. So again, when we compared this last night, I thought this was the lighter
of the two wines and the intensity of flavor wasn't there. On the smell today, this is very
perfumey. It has again, dark fruit, but a perfume, a very nice perfume smell like aromas of roses
and maybe like tulips, very fragrant in terms of the smell. Definitely a different smell.
I would say the Carm is a much more earthy type of smell, and this one is a little bit more
perfumey. And I think it was reversed last night. I thought it was, when we first came to the bottle,
I thought the Carm was a bit more aromatic and this was a little bit less giving. And now I
think it's actually opened up a bit more. Yeah, it's completely reversed from yesterday.
This wine is now fuller than the Carm. It's more tannic. It's showing more structure,
deeper taste. I would say it's not as balanced as the Carm. I think the Carm is a very pleasing
in the palate drinking wine. The Mission is a little bit more structured, I think,
to me. It got more tannins actually. So yeah, even though it's a second wine. So
I don't know, this is a real toss up. I would say, I know Wine Spectator has this at
89 points. I'm going to put it at 91 points too. I think they're very similar wines,
but very different in terms of the approach. I think if you're drinking this immediately,
and again, it could be the vintage, but just based on my kind of feel of these two wines,
if you were going to just drink it during a dinner, I would clearly think the Carm is a
better wine to drink. But over time, I think if you're going to age these wines,
at least with the 2017 vintage, I know I can't speak about other vintages of the Carm,
but I would say this wine would be fairly early drinking. I don't think it's, I think it's you
drink now and then within 10 years, whereas even the Chapelle, I'd say you'd wait five years.
And I think it will drink longer. It will last longer. And I just think that the quality of
the tannins is a little bit better and the strength of the blend, it's a little bit more,
there's a little bit more body and weight into this wine, even though it's a second wine.
So I would say on a long-term basis, I think this would probably be a better wine. Let's say,
if you look at this 15 years from now. So I thought it was, it's a really interesting tasting.
Again, it could be, you know, my own prejudice against the Carm, but for my tasting of it,
I would say it's a really, it's a very good wine. Probably not at the level of the Michelin Opion
or Opion, probably not even, you know, if you talk to it, I would say not even at the level of,
let's say, a Grand Prix Ducasse. Yeah, for sure not a level of Palmer, not a level of Bechamel,
not like that. It's definitely, it's a great wine. For, and again, the price right now,
it's creeping up. At liquor stores here, it's about $170, which I think is a fair price. It's
okay. It's getting expensive for what it is. I think it's a very popular wine for people to
drink at these days, but I'm not sure it's really worth the value. So I'm not going to go out
and rush out to buy the Carm, let's put it that way. I think it's a good wine, but
don't think it's a steal at $170. That's kind of my view.
Hope you've enjoyed this tasting. Until next time, happy drinking.