What wines to drink over Christmas | Red, Whites, Sparkling

Wine Chronicles
13 followers
#wine #winelist #drinksissue
The Australian Weekend Magazine's Senior Wine writer Nick Ryan is joined by GQ Australia's Will Lennox to go through his top picks from the 2025 Wine List. From the best cheap red to the most dazzling sparkling, the lads dive deep into what makes these picks from the top 100 list so special.
For the full list visit
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/week...
AI Generated·May contain errors
I mean that is a seriously good glass of wine for 22 bucks.
It's at the show, it's at the show mate.
Two boys who have both done their time in the great bottle shop at Five Way Cellars in Paddington, Sydney.
Hello Cookie.
Look what you did.
You've turned both of us into lifelong booze hounds.
I'm lucky enough to be joined by the great Nick Ryan, Senior Wine Writer for The Australian.
Nick, why Winclare?
Well I half suspect, Will, that you've been sent down by the paper to make sure I've done the work
for this year's top 100 wines.
But I can assure you the work has been done, the wines have been tasted, the wines have been ranked
and we have an amazing collection of 100 top Australian wines that we can look at over the next little while.
Here in the recently rejuvenated Rising Sun Hotel in the beautiful village of Auburn in the Clare Valley.
The sun is breaking out through the clouds.
We might even get out into some vineyard later today, I'll show you around.
But before that we want to look at some of the top wines from this year's top 100 wines list.
Enough talking.
Yeah, enough talking.
I think it's the longest I've sat in a front bar without a glass in my hand.
So I think we need to go and have a look at some of these wines.
So Nick, we're getting close to the pointy end of the year, to silly season, which is the perfect time for bubbles.
Tell me what you've chosen for Sparkling of the Year.
So this is our Sparkling of the Year, which then by default is also our Tasmanian Wine of the Year.
But this is a very special release this year.
This is from the House of Arras, from the masterful Ed Carr.
So this is the EJ Carr Late Disgorged 2006.
So no one has done more to put Tasmania on the global map for sparkling wine than Ed Carr.
16 years on yeast leaves.
So this has sat up until its disgorgement in late 2024.
16 years sitting on all that yeasty, delicious sediment that sits in the bottle before disgorgement.
What we get through that is both, you know, a complexing quality, you know, all those sort of brioche-y,
bready sort of flavours and things that we like to talk about when we talk about great sparkling wine.
And amazing preservation effect that those yeast leaves keep these wines incredibly fresh over a long period of time.
So this is sparkling wine on a truly, quality-wise, the match for just about anything else you'll find anywhere in the world.
Cheers Will. Cheers Ed.
Oh, that's so good.
That sort of preserved lemon, grapefruit pith, oyster shell, some sort of fine sort of toasty character to it.
Just a finesse and drive. Chardonnay dominant, Pinot Noir about a third,
but just really lovely, fine sort of chalky saline quality through the finish as well.
That is seriously great sparkling wine.
That's our sparkling wine of the year.
So Nick, Australia makes a lot of great white wine.
Sure does.
But there can only be one top for 2025.
So tell us what you pick.
Yeah, look, in a really strong field and so much great white wine across the country that we looked at this year,
there's always going to be a strong chance it'll be Chardonnay out of Margaret River from 2023.
2023 is an outstanding vintage in Margaret River and I think we'll start seeing a lot of the Cabernets come through.
Maybe, you know, if I was a betting man, I'd be looking at some 23 Cabernet for next year's list.
But this is the 2023 Flametree SRS Chardonnay from the Warcliffe subregion of Margaret River.
The great Cliffy Royal.
There's a lot of very attention grabbing and high profile Chardonnay out of Margaret River and brilliant,
brilliant producers and there are several other 23 Margaret River Chardonnays in this year's list.
But there's just something about this wine.
I've always loved the Flametree wines.
I've always loved the way Cliff Royal goes about it.
There's a finesse and a subtlety to, you know, Cliff's wines as well as giving you still all that great complexity
and power and drive that we love out of Margaret River Chardonnay.
So, for this year, so best white wine and as a result, the best Western Australian wine this year as well.
It's the 2023 Flametree SRS Chardonnay from Margaret River and he spills it on the table as he pours it
and we haven't even really been drinking Will.
Here's the Margaret River Chardonnay from a great vintage like 23.
You mentioned there was a lot of Chardonnays and a lot of 23 Chardonnays in this list as well.
What made this one stand out in particular?
There's just a finesse and a precision and a quite calm to this wine.
It's not as flashy and showy as some of the others, but very finely detailed and artistic.
It's fabulous.
So, Nick, every time I think I know a little bit more about wine, something else comes up.
There's a bit of semaphore on this and there's a ceramic bottle in front of me.
What am I looking at?
Yeah, look, these will are a couple of the quirkier wines on this year's list
and they're in the list first and foremost because they're great drinks,
but I also wanted to shine a little light on some of the more interesting sort of winemaking methods
that are being deployed around the country and some interesting stylistic shifts.
So this little ceramic jug that looks like the kind of thing that an old Western hobo would be drinking from
is actually a beautifully made little ceramic bottle
and it contains the 2023 Super Gertie Riesling from Ben Martz.
Not far from where we are right now, Martz is about three or four Ks just up that way.
He makes some of the best Cabernet Franc in the country, but this is what he calls his Super Gertie Riesling.
This is a really sort of wild, wacky take on Riesling.
It's skinsy, it's a little wild and ropey.
It's not the classic, conventional, linear, clear Riesling that you expect
or that purity of citrus and slate.
It's an incredibly interesting wine.
Lots of texture, some really interesting aromatics and flavours through the wine.
Just something wonderful from the crazy and bizarre mind of Ben Martz.
Bang, Super Gertie Riesling.
This is the Subsea Estate Pure Ocean Semillon.
Now one of the things that's been quite a bit of a trend in wine around the world the last few years
is putting bottles, maturation of things underwater.
Subsea maturation, so to speak.
This is a next step up.
This is actually wines that go in sort of fermenting vats that are anchored to the ocean floor
that move with the ocean currents.
So it is the wine still on yeast lees under there.
So it's an unfinished wine going down under the ocean.
Not bottled wine, but wine in still its fermentation vessel
and then sitting under the ocean off the coast of Margaret River
on an old abalone lease off the coast of Margaret River.
Really interesting stuff.
Everyone's going to be doing this in 10 years' time.
I kind of doubt it, but I love the thinking behind this, the vision behind this
and the bravery behind this.
It comes up with a pretty fantastic result.
Something I'm always looking for when I'm searching for a bottle of wine for the evening
is a great bargain that can be found at the top and the bottom of the racks.
What have you picked for bargains this year?
Yeah, look, aren't we all, Will?
It would be nice to drink Grand Cru Burgundy and Hilla Grace every night,
but the reality is that we don't.
These are the wines that cost about as much as a couple of schoomers in a pub
and I think that we're getting wines of this quality
at that kind of price is pretty special.
The fact that they're both Cabernet-based,
maybe that says something about the market for Cabernet fruit,
but I'm taking it on as a personal project
to try and get people more excited about great Australian Cabernet.
So here, over there, that we've already got into already
when I showed you earlier, Will,
is that's the Bownaves The Blend 2022.
You'll pick that up for around 20 bucks.
Cabernet Dominant Blend from Kunawara,
some of the great vineyards of Kunawara.
The Bownaves family have been involved in viticulture in Kunawara
for a really long time, make beautiful, beautiful wines
that are just classically Kunawara,
have that finesse, detail to them.
So this is a blend of predominantly Cabernet Sauvignon,
about 60-odd percent, there's Merlot in there,
Cabernet Franc, a little Petit Bordeaux,
the classic Bordeaux blend.
And I just think at that kind of money,
like I said, for less than the price of a couple of schooners
or pints or whatever we are in the country,
I think in this country we can't standardise...
Got to be careful of auto standards here.
We're a national newspaper, but we can't standardise rail gauges
and we can't standardise beer sizes.
It's always been a great Australian failing.
But for the price of a couple of beers of any size in a pub,
these wines really over-deliver.
That's the Bownaves Blend.
This is the 22 Barry & Sons Cabernet
from here in the Clare Valley.
Recent wine of show at the Clare Valley show.
Wow.
So an amazing performance for a wine that goes,
you know, retails around $22.
You can't come to the Clare Valley
and not have some interaction with the Barry family.
You know, huge influence over the Clare Valley wine scene
for a long time since Jim Barry came here
as one of the earliest graduates
of the Roseworthy Winemaking School,
established himself in Clare
and established the family winery here.
So his kids, Peter, his son,
who has recently retired from running the business for a long time,
and now, you know, Tom and Sam Barry,
who run operations today.
So when we talk about Barry & Sons,
it can roll down several generations,
but specifically here,
talking about Peter Barry and his two boys, Tom and Sam,
doing fantastic things.
I love Clare Valley Cabernet.
We talk a lot about Cabernet and Kunawara.
We talk a lot about Cabernet in places like Margaret River.
There's a very, very great Cabernet from the Yarra Valley
on the list this year.
Actually, there's two.
So the Clare Valley Cabernet, I think,
probably is a little undersung.
I think it's the best red variety up here.
The fact that you're getting wines, you know,
at this kind of money with great varietal definition,
balance, purity, finesse.
I mean, that is a seriously good glass of wine for $22.
You can't go wrong.
We're lucky enough to be joining you in South Australia.
What's the local pick this year?
Will we let you leave?
That's the more important thing.
You know, from a South Australian perspective,
our South Australian wine of the year is unsurprisingly Grenache.
I've said for a long time, and I actually,
with a couple of very small exceptions around the country,
you know, great southern WA and then the southern part
of Margaret River, there's some pretty good Grenache.
There's some pockets in Victoria too.
But on the whole, I always say, you know,
Grenache is a purely South Australian thing.
It's like saying dance and chants properly and serial killers.
You know, Grenache is a South Australian thing.
And this year I've seen so much great Grenache, you know,
especially out of Auclair and Vale, out of the Barossa too.
So it's hardly surprising that the wine of the year,
the South Australian wine of the year is Grenache.
It's actually the first ever release of this particular wine.
It's the SC Panel Sunrise 99 Grenache from 2022.
Steve Panel has, you know, done more than most people
to elevate Australian Grenache over the last decade or so.
And, you know, we are at a point now with, you know,
the stuff that Steve does, you know,
what Pete Fraser's been doing at Yangara, what, you know,
Amelia Nolan's doing at Alkina,
Marco Cirillo's doing in the Barossa,
what, you know, David Gleave and Rene Hirsch have been doing
at Willunga 100 and Giles Cook at Thistledown.
And there's so many great Grenache producers at the moment.
Jules Forward and Bernice Ong at Ministry of Clouds have got
something pretty special that just missed the mark,
missed the cut-off this year in terms of time,
but I tasted it last week and I'll be doing something on that
in coming weeks.
There's a really special Grenache coming out of Ministry of Clouds
as well.
But right now Australian Grenache is having a moment and it's
because of guys like Steve who have taken, you know,
these great old vine Grenache resources we have in South Australia
and have elevated them beyond the afterthought that they once were.
And, you know, anyone who gets fragrance out of Grenache,
that's kind of easy.
The great Grenaches we produce now have structure to them as well.
People used to sort of say, you know,
Grenache was poor man's pinot noir.
I actually, I think sometimes it's even more useful to think about,
you know, great Australian Grenache in Nebbiolo terms,
in, you know, fragrance but tannin and structure.
So I think Steve has always been a master of that, you know,
and you really see it.
And this is perhaps the most personal release of his so far.
This is from a patch of the old vines in the Little Branch vineyard
that he and his wife Fiona bought.
So these are in 22, these vines were 99 years old, hence the sunrise 99.
They're on the side of the vineyard that gets the morning sun.
Beautiful old vines in Blewett Springs in the, you know,
the Little Branch vineyard.
So this is really, really special dirt, special vineyard and wine made
by someone who, you know, really understands that vineyard,
cares for that vineyard, loves that vineyard and is in tune
with that vineyard.
So this has been one of the, you know,
the most highly anticipated releases of the year
and it is absolutely outstanding.
I'm glad I've got a bottle to share with you because there's not many
of them, Will, not many of them.
So stealing this from photography but it's worth it.
Thank you for sharing.
It's that beautiful Grenache fragrance, those sort of dark raspberry,
dark cherry sort of characters.
But that wine in the mouth is something else.
That's not, to most people, you know, they have this view of Grenache
as being slightly, not wishy-washy but, you know, a little more ethereal,
you know, fragrance but not much substance.
This has real substance, real structure, real texture,
really a connection.
It mellows out.
Yeah.
As a proud New South Welshman myself, what have you got
from the home state for me?
Okay, so from New South Wales, it took me, you know,
as a South Australian it took me a long time to understand the beauty
of New South Wales wine and I had to move to Sydney for 20 years
and it finally got drummed into me.
And I am, now I have to be quiet when I'm back here to talk
about how much I love, you know, the Hunter, Canberra District,
Mudgee, Orange, amazing stuff happening in Orange at the moment.
But this year's top wine from New South Wales is a venerable classic
and maybe one of the best examples of it I've ever seen
and I think I've tasted every vintage of this wine ever made
and this may be, you know, this is absolutely in the very,
very top tier of vintages for the great graveyard vineyard
from Brokenwood.
This is the 2023 Brokenwood Graveyard Vineyard.
For those who may not know the full story behind Graveyard,
it is not a vineyard planted on a graveyard.
Fertiliser is not that expensive and that hard to come by.
It is actually a vineyard planted on a parcel of land that was
originally designated to be the graveyard for a shire or town
or parish or whatever you might be calling it,
what it was called in those days, of the Colburn.
But this is one of the great vineyards, Shiraz vineyards,
in Australia, one of the great Shiraz wines in Australia.
It's just always typified what is great about Hunter Shiraz,
which is a suppleness, a proud, medium-bodied quality to it
and an ability to age like I think no other Shiraz in Australia.
I would still say that Hunter Valley Shiraz ages,
and I've seen stuff back to the 40s, I think Hunter Valley Shiraz
ages in a different way to any other Shiraz in Australia.
If I was – and I'm putting some of this wine in the cellar,
but if cellaring great Australian wine is something that you're into,
put this down and your grandkids will drink it.
You might not, but your grandkids will drink it.
So this is the 2023 Graveyard Shiraz from Brokenwood.
I'm dying to try it.
Oh, look at that puns.
That is everything you want from Hunter Valley Shiraz.
There is that dark, plummy fruit, but again, it's not dense.
It's not chewy.
You're not having to force your way through that wine.
It just sits so comfortably on the palate.
So there's fruit intensity there without weight or heft.
Really lovely suppleness of texture.
And then those sort of really fine, silty, sandy tannins start to kick in,
fan out, and really just take that wine for quite the journey
through the finish.
Really lingers on your palate.
Yeah, that is seriously, seriously great.
Shiraz is a coat of many colours in this country and, you know,
it makes wines as beautiful, as elegant, as supple,
and as long-lived as this 2023 Graveyard Vineyard from Brokenwood.
So here's the Australian Shiraz.
Here's the Hunter Shiraz.
Here's the great Australian classics.
What sort of grapes have we got going around us?
So this is actually, of all the things we could have gone
and found ourselves in in the Clare Valley,
this place that is so famous for Riesling, makes amazing Shiraz and Cabernet
and blends with Cabernet and Malbec,
we're actually in a Gewurztraminer vineyard.
There are not that many Gewurztraminer vineyards around the country
at the moment, so that's something kind of special.
And the Skilligalee Gewurzt has always been close to my favourite Gewurzt
in the country.
Well, there can only be one.
Wine of the year, yeah, there can only be one,
and it's something I agonise over for quite a long time
through this whole process.
So many wines that could be that one,
but in this year, in 2025, it's a beautiful wine from the 23 vintage
from the Yarra Valley, from one of the greatest estates,
not just in this country, but if you ask me, in the world,
some of the finest Cabernet made anywhere on the planet.
It's the 2023 Mount Mary Quintet.
Just a thing of beauty.
Always one of the great wines released in this country in any given year.
In a year like 23, absolutely outstanding.
One for the ages.
This is pretty special.
You know the story of Mount Mary well, as most people probably watching do.
So this was a property established in 1971, the year of my birth,
but the wines look a lot better than I do.
It is established by John and Marley Middleton.
The Middleton family still run the property.
Sam Middleton, their grandson, is the winemaker.
Wines have always been great, but I think under Sam they are better
than they ever have been.
They've been elevated to somewhere really special.
What I love about great Yarra Valley Cabernet, and this is the pinnacle
of Yarra Valley Cabernet to me, is its fine detailing.
These are wines that are in high definition.
You can watch standard television and then you can watch
super high definition stuff, and that is what's happening here.
There's so much detail, so much intricate etching in a wine like this
that I just think these are really special wines and we should celebrate
in this country where we have examples of wines that are just as good
as they get anywhere in the world.
We all venerate Bordeaux and the great wines of Bordeaux.
This wine, and I've done it on many occasions, I've slipped this wine
into tastings of great Bordeaux and it always stacks up.
The comparison is pointless and almost odious because we don't need
to compare Mount Mary to Bordeaux because Mount Mary is Mount Mary.
It is great Yarra Valley Cabernet, it is great Australian red wine,
and it is our 2025 Wine of the Year.
So to the Middleton family at Mount Mary, cheers and thank you for your efforts.
