BAROLO vs BAROLO: Blind Tasting 5 Villages (Is Village Identity Real?)

Wine Chronicles
13 followers
Hi everybody! This is Agnes from No Sediment and today we are going to do burgundy things
in Barolo. We are going to taste and compare five Barolos from five different villages.
It is so common to taste Pinot Noir from various villages, various Premier Cru and Grand Cru sites
from different climates and compare the slightest differences between them. That is the burgundy way
and Pinot Noir is perfect for that because it can show even the smallest differences between its
terroir. And guys, terroir is not just the soil. It is elevation, aspect, wind, every single
environmental factor that affects the vine. And yes, it is also winemaking and the winemaker's
hands and thoughts as well. You know, my favorite grape variety is Nebbiolo and it happens to be
just as magical as Pinot Noir and it also happens to respond just as sensitively to where it is
grown as Pinot Noir does. There are 11 communes that can make Barolo wine. The most famous is,
of course, Barolo itself. After all, the entire DOCG is named after it. There are different schools
of thought. Those who believe that the greatest Barolo is made by blending fruit from various
villages and sites together and those who believe that single site or single vineyard
wines is where the true grandiosity of Barolo shines. Today, we are going to please the latter
ones and explore differences between five Barolo communes. We will follow that with a tasting of
wines from these five villages and experience those differences in blind. Please do not expect
deep dive into soils from me. I think soils are extremely important when talking about wine,
but it is the structure, water retention and drainage, health, biodiversity and pH of soils
that matter more than simply knowing when they formed. And if I tell you that the soils formed
in Tartonian period, it tells you nothing about their structure and their health. It is important
to know that even though producers might be located in a specific commune, it does not mean
they own vineyards only within the borders of their village. Many will have vineyards outside
or buy grapes from other areas. So for a real village distinction, I would suggest looking
for wines that actually state a single commune on the label. One could argue that we could simply
compare different plots or MGAs, but in my opinion, they offer more of their own unique character
rather than a stylistic generality of its commune. We are going to taste wines from two western
villages, Lamorra and Verduno. Lamorra is the largest commune in terms of vineyard area. It
is also responsible for some of the highest vineyards in Barolo, ranging from 230 to 500
meters above sea level. Of course, we have to mention soils here, which are extremely complex,
dominated by younger Tartonian formations rich in clay and silt. Lamorra vineyards are mostly
defined by eastern exposure. All of these factors, of course, have huge impact on wine,
which is why Lamorra is often associated with stylistically producing wines of lighter and more
perfumed character. They are often more approachable in their youth, offering softer and lighter
tannins and lighter body. That said, these wines still offer magnificent aging potential,
just as the best Barolos do. Verduno is one of the smallest communes we will taste today.
It is also not one of the original five, but it has become increasingly important,
especially if we start name-dropping. The famous Monvillero vineyard is located here. Verduno is
northeastern extension of Lamorra and is often grouped with Lamorra when it comes to style.
It enjoys cooling alpine influence and offers wines with finesse and elegance similar to those
of Lamorra. Next, we have villages of Serralunga d'Alba and Monforte d'Alba, both with older
Serravalian soils dominating their vineyards with high content of calcium carbonate that often yields
more concentrated and richer wines. Serralunga d'Alba, this is where I started my Barolo journey
and where I fell in love with the wines. It is the most eastern village of Barolo,
and like Barolo itself, is entirely within the DOCG zone. We have the oldest soils here,
Serravalian soils that are extremely rich in clay, limestone and silt. What I think is extremely
important is that Serralunga has its vineyards exposed both to eastern and western side.
Southwest-facing vineyards get exposure to that really intense sun, while the morning sun is
gentler to the wines. Wines from Serralunga are always linked with power, structure and tremendous
aging capacity, but I don't believe they lack finesse and elegance either. Many argue that
Serralunga is more Barolo than Barolo itself, and it might be true. When you read general books
of what Barolo is, they often match exactly what we associate with Serralunga. Power, intensity,
full body and the texture of tannin. It might be the case that Monforte d'Alba is the most
difficult village to generalize about. Talking soils, this area features the older Lequio
formations shared with Serralunga, but also sandstone and fossil marbles shared with La
Morra. Similarly to Serralunga, wines here are planted on opposite sides on eastern and western
exposures, with the eastern side experiencing that cooling effect coming from the Alta Langa.
Similarly like La Morra, this village also offers some of the highest vineyards of Barolo,
with elevation between 200 to 500 meters above sea level. With all these differences, of course,
it becomes very difficult to generalize about the wine style of Monforte. Still, more often than not,
it is grouped with Serralunga, responsible for concentrated, dense and highly structured Barolos
made for long cellaring. Barolo is the village this famous wine got its name from. It is one of
the three communes whose entire area falls within the Barolo DOCG. You will find both younger
Tortonian and older Serravalian soils here. As a result, wines from this area are often described
as having best of both worlds, showing perfume and elegance, as well as rich body and tannic
structure. I myself find wines from this area really hard to define, and I think it really
comes down to each producer. And some of the greatest names from here, think of Bartolo
Mascarello, stand by the idea that great Barolo has always been a blend from various sites and
villages. So maybe it is Barolo village that represents the essence of Barolo itself and best
of Barolo villages. Now let's move under the roof and taste wines we just discussed. All right, now
that we are inside, in the warmth, we can actually taste these wines from five different communes
and see do the theory that we discussed before actually really holds up in the glass.
So we will start with wine number one. So all of these wines are from five different producers,
from five different communes that we discussed before, and they all are from 2021 vintage, one of
the greatest vintages for Barolo and Barbaresco wines by the way. So if you want to stack up your
cellar with Barolo wines, this is exactly the vintage you want to have. By the way, these wines
were poured by my cameraman, so I don't know which one is which. So as I said, let's start with wine
number one. Okay, so of course we do have that fragrant aromatics of Nebbiolo grape variety,
and it is pale in color. We do not expect very intensely, deeply colored wines from Nebbiolo
grape. Even if it is a relatively young vintage as 2021, it will already have some of that orangey
or brick hint to the color. So that is very typical of the grape variety itself. And like fresh
raspberries, strawberries, sour cherries on the nose, you do have some floral element as well here. So this
is quite fragrant wine with this really intense nose of red berries and some maybe some roses or
rose stems even. And of course we do have that very typical earthiness, that hint of earthiness
from Nebbiolo. It is not very expressive in this wine though, you maybe just pick up some hint of it.
So it is mostly dominated by these fresh berries and that floral element. Let's taste it. It is an
early morning, and tasting Barolo in the morning can be quite a shock to your taste buds, so I have
to embrace myself. All right, it wasn't that bad, and by bad I mean the shock. The shock wasn't that
intense here. I would say that this one is more towards the elegant style. You know, we do have
really expressive drying, you know, high levels of tannins, but those tannins are managed beautifully.
There is elegance to the tannins. They are maybe not as big and not as punchy. They are more towards
silky. If at all we can call Nebbiolo tannins silky, then this actually it is. There's beautiful
elevated acidity. I don't think that this wine is too rich and too big, bold. You know, sometimes when
you read books about Barolo wine, they usually say this is big, bold, full-bodied wine, age-worthy,
structured wine. Of course, there are examples like that, but this wine number one, in my opinion, in my
personal view, is more towards the elegant, you know, style. And we do have that structure from the
tannins. We do have that elevated, lively, almost brisk acidity, but there is that fruit, there is that
calmness, there is that not-in-your-face presence. I think it is lovely. I will give this wine 93
points. So, let's move to wine number two. All right, this has more intensity. If this was, if
wine number one was more fragrant, you know, like you have to catch it a little bit. This one shows
that really ripe, crunchy though, cherry, red cherry flavor right in your face. But it is not
like in any way bold or, you know, rich or like Cabernet Sauvignon cake. It is still very tied
back and with some time in the glass, it also starts to show some of those truffly notes,
especially white truffle. Of course, it is not the same as you just lift the dome of the truffle and
it just fills the room, but you feel it somewhere in the background, you know, that slightly
mushroomy, that porcini, that white truffle, that forest, you know, dump earth element in it. And
this is something that I love Naviolo so much for. And if we had like strawberries, raspberries,
a mix of red berries in the wine number one, this one is really dominated by that bright cherry
character. Let's taste it. All right, so wine number two, there is way more presence, structure,
body on the palate. It also seems somehow warmer when it comes to alcohol. So for wine number one,
I didn't pick the alcohol at all, even though it was my first wine of the day. So for wine number
two, following and still showing some of that warmth, it made me question if the alcohol is
really that well integrated within wine itself. But of course, we can only understand that, you
know, when we re-taste it. I think that wine number two really shows the typical Naviolo
tannin. It is elevated, it is a bit coarse, it kind of have that sand papery texture on the palate.
And I do feel it still. It is also much fuller bodied, you feel more presence,
the mid palate is way more richer and rounder, more intense here. The acidity is nicely integrated,
you feel that it's really high and it's lively. But it is part of the fruit, something that I do
enjoy myself a lot. I will give this wine 92 points. So let's move to wine number three.
So somehow wine number three to me shows more resolved fruit or crushed fruit or, you know,
fruit that has been picked and just stayed on the table, you know, in the bowl for a while. You do
have these strawberries, but they're second day strawberries. You do have raspberries, but they
are second day raspberries, you know. So something crushed with some juices already leaking from the
raspberries themselves, maybe slight oxidation, but not like oxidation that is uncontrolled and
unwanted, but just, you know, something that adds a bit of complexity here in the wine number three.
It almost have like a syrupy element, but not syrupy or something cooked.
You know, I have these memories from my great grandmother, and she would, you know,
start to cook a jam from strawberries, raspberries, cherries. And then at the very
beginning, when it just starts to boil, she would just scoop off the foam and it would be just like
this fruit bomb, that really intense flavor. So this on the nose reminds me of those childhood
memories. And I want to say that I am looking for some of that earthiness I expect from Nebbiolo,
some of that floral character. I don't find it that much here, though. It is really dominated
by these, you know, fruit flavors. Let's taste it. Now, maybe it is a buildup of an alcohol,
I don't know. I mean, the first sip was something so beautiful and lovely and juicy.
And I had in my mind, like, isn't this lovely? This is the first sentence that I just heard
when I tasted this wine. But then when I spit it out, I had that, you know, that warm sensation
from the alcohol. But it did dissipate really quickly. And while I am talking with you,
it is the fruit that I feel on the aftertaste. It is the tannin, the texture that I feel. And
tannin here is very, very different from the wine number two. It shows more elegance. It might
still be that sandpapery character, but with a much finer, you know, sand on it. So not as
maybe broad and not as rustic, if I may say so. So the tannin here is really beautiful. It is
not as elegant as wine number one. It does show more of that Nebbiolo soul, but I think I do
enjoy this wine quite a lot. I think it's really good. I will give this wine 94 points. Let's move
to wine number four. Somehow this wine seems the biggest, the like largest, with the biggest soul
of them all. Like even when you smell the nose here, it does show strawberries. It does show
cherries, but the cherries are, you know, towards the black character. The strawberries are much,
much riper, you know, strawberries that you have left on those small bushes for two extra days to
ripen. And when you pick them, they almost disintegrate in your hand. But there's also
some smokiness, and literally when you close your eyes, you feel like you're entering the forest,
like you feel all those, you know, autumn leaves on the forest floor. You feel all that flora and
fauna, you know, in around you. It almost smells of moss right after rain. It is so seductive,
but you feel, you know, in the background, you feel bone, you feel power, you feel structure,
like before even tasting this wine, I know it's going to be like, I have tannin texture, I have
mud palate, you just feel within it. Let's taste it finally. And you know what? I wanted to tell you,
and you know what? It's not, it's really elegant, but then the aftertaste kicked in. So the very
first sip, the very first impression seems lovely and light, really elegant, almost like with wine
number one. But then the wine slowly creeps upon you, and then it just starts to show its muscles,
like I am here, didn't you hear me? You know, talk with me, talk with me. Yeah, so this is
really interesting. And it keeps evolving in the glass, like right now, I have notes of toasted
nuts. Yes, so this right now is one of the most structured wines that we have had in the tasting.
You just know that this wine is made for longer cellaring, like I can enjoy it right now, I don't
mind, I don't mind young Varolos really. But you also know that after 10 years, it will still have
enough flesh, body and texture to survive that and age even more. And this is interesting,
because I really put my mind into these wines when I was purchasing them. So all of them are
around same price category, they're all around 50 euros. So wines that does not necessarily cost
fortune, but for sure can age 10, 20 years, absolutely. Of course, we also have to understand
that this is the vintage doing 2021 was superb vintage. And it might not be the case, you know,
with different vintage. But before we move to my number five, I will score this wine
93 points. Let's move to wine number five now. Alright, so we have another really fragrant baby
in our glass, mostly cherries and raspberries. Actually quite a lot of raspberries in this one.
But this also shows that earthiness and intensely that note of roses and rose stems. You know,
sometimes when they talk about Nebbiolo, they say it smells of roses and tar. I always find it,
it smells more earthy. And there's definitely that red berry character, which we felt in all
of these wines. So maybe not as intensely with roses and tar, but that really beautiful cherry
or raspberry pie. So really right in character. So wine number five seems to me like this really
delicate and light wine. It has really high acidity like elevated and I would say that
acidity defines this wine. The tannin is elevated but not as prominent and not as rustic and not as
big as with any of these wines. But it could also be due to the fact that wine number five is
following wine number four, which was really intensely packed. What is interesting also on
the palate in wine number five is something like I pick up some of that green element, like almost
the same rose stem that I feel on the nose. I can almost pick it up on the palate. I cannot say that
this is the most exciting part of it, of the wine. I think on the palate I always prefer a bit more
food driven wine. You know texture is fine, mid palate is fine, acidity is good. When I pick up
something green, especially Nebbiolo, it seems slightly odd to me. So for wine number five I
will give 91 points. We have tasted and scored all five wines and I think it is time to reveal them.
But before we do, I just want to give a quick conclusion. And according to what we previously
discussed, I would want to say that wine number two and four and maybe three, because it was also
quite structured. So wine two and three and four comes from either Monforte or Serralunga, because
we are expected the most structured and most age-worthy wines from these communes. And then
wine number one and wine number... Hello! Sorry!
And wine number one and five would be Verduno or Lamorra, because these wines showed maybe the
body, you know maybe the most immediate appeal and maybe like a slightly silkier tannin in their
texture and elevated acidity. But now we have to reveal the wines and see, because we have to
understand one thing. One thing is really important. Winemaker plays a crucial part. Sometimes winemakers
want to highlight the expected style from their terroir. And sometimes winemakers just simply
want to make a different style or they just want to make, you know, a style that represents
them more than maybe the terroir or their unique plot. Because it could be the case that
we are in Lamorra and they have this very unique plot, terroir, that just makes bigger, bolder, more
intense wines. It's completely okay. So let's start with wine number one that I gave 93 points.
So it is indeed from Verduno. So this is something that we got correct. It is Fratelli Alessandria.
It is actually really good. Top, top producer. And I think this wine spoke beautifully with me.
I loved it in the glass. It definitely offers this more immediate appeal, but I do not think
that you cannot age this wine. You for sure can age this wine. It will develop more earthiness
with time. So what a beautiful bottle. Thank you. Let's move to wine number two, which I gave 92 points.
All right. So we are in Barolo. So I was thinking that two, three, and four. So amongst those three,
there must be Barolo. To be completely honest, I was thinking that Barolo Village was wine number
three, personally. So I have mixed those up. But Vaira, it is a really good producer. It actually
has been in the wines potato top 10. I think it was last year. So we do think that they make amazing
wines. They also make wines that are not in your face, even though it was really intense on the
So let's move to wine number three, and that will be
Domenico Clerico, Monforte di Alba. So we know that they harvest only grapes from
Monforte di Alba. Monforte is very similar stylistically to Serralunga. I have always
been more into Serralunga style, you know. But I think Monforte also offers this really beautiful
texture and age-worthiness. And I actually, I think I gave this wine 94 points. So this was
the highest scored wine. And when we were preparing for this tasting, I was a bit reluctant to
purchase Domenico Clerico because Domenico Clerico is known, you know, for more modern approach.
But a salesperson at the shop, he convinced me. He told several times that this is the best,
the best producer in the area. And I most certainly must try it. And look at that,
we gave it the highest score. So 94 points. Let's move to wine number four, which I gave 93 points.
And it is my love. It is Enrico Rivetto. It is 2021 vintage from Serralunga. So I am happy to
say that structure never lies. It was really the biggest, the most structured wine. And I have to
say my greatest thanks to Enrico because it is his promises, premises, it is, it is his premises.
We are filming this video right now. So thanks, thanks to him, we can actually go inside in the
warmth and film a beautiful video and tasting all these wines. So if you have not tasted his wines
yet, make sure to seek them out. Most importantly, if you are ever in Barolo, make sure to visit his
estate. It is unique. It is different from any other estates you will visit in Barolo. I promise
to you because his vineyards are buzzing. His vineyards are full of colors. His vineyards are
not your regular, you know, same old lines of wines. They are healthy. You will see animals
here. You will see biodiversity here. It is something that is really important and it is
something that his heart and passion is in. And yeah, so we have to support those who care about
the land and who care about the environment and society around them. So thank you Enrico for this
wine. And thank you Enrico for this room. Let's move to wine number five, which I gave 91 points.
Okay, so we are in La Morra. To be honest, I am a bit disappointed. I was really expecting this
wine to be one of the highest scored wines. Of course, 91 is not, you know, low score wine. It is
still beautiful and really elegant. But I do think of Odero as one of the top, top producers from this
area. And somehow, at some point, I did consider in my mind that it could be Odero. Of course,
because of the, you know, the elevated acidity and that lightness of the body, I was expecting
it to be either Verduno or La Morra. But I think stylistically, they also make that kind of wine.
And somewhere in my mind, I did question myself, is this like a stylistic choice? And maybe I did
not score it, you know, properly, because like that green element is not necessarily something
that I enjoy personally. But it could add an extra dimension and extra like kick of complexity
into the wine. So that could be a conscious decision by a winemaker. So here you go. Oddly
enough, these wines actually did line up quite perfectly where they were expected to be, where
they were coming from. So yes, these wines really did show what the books offer to you. So finally,
because in majority of these cases, I find myself saying one thing in theory to you, and then the
tasting offers completely different picture. So for once, we are happy to say out loud that books
doesn't lie, that certain studies actually show that there is difference amongst these communes.
And they do represent, you know, more structured and more full bodied wines. And they do represent,
you know, more elegant, more acidity driven wines. Thank you very much for watching. And let me know
in the comment section below if you already maybe have picked up some specific commune or, or maybe
producer that you prefer better than others. And please make sure to watch this video next.
