Estranged fathers: dealing with parental alienation

Gentleman’s Guide to Love
21 followers
I'm Dr. Orion Teraban, and this is Psych Hacks, Better Living Through Psychology.
And the topic of today's short talk is estranged fathers.
Unfortunately, this is not an uncommon problem in today's day and age.
It's also a fairly complex problem with lots of fringe cases,
so we're going to be painting with a fairly broad brush today.
Now, while there are some men who are textbook deadbeat dads, who disappeared the minute they
found out the woman was pregnant and stayed away for good, there are also lots of men
who would be much more involved in their kids' lives if they could.
And today, I'm going to be talking primarily about this second class of men.
Involuntary estrangement can occur for a variety of reasons.
In many cases, it's due to a combination of custody agreements and inappropriate gatekeeping.
In the wake of divorce, women are awarded primary or sole custody of children 70 to 80 percent of
the time. What's more, some of these women will emotionally alienate the children in their care
from their fathers. After years of little to no contact, during which time the children
were potentially told a very one-sided story about the men in question, fathers can face
an extremely difficult battle to reestablish a connection with their kids.
Even when they are successful, and this is far from certain, it can take a very long time,
as the beliefs we develop in childhood can and do persist for a lifetime.
Of course, men can legally challenge this arrangement, but this can be expensive,
bureaucratically difficult, and emotionally grueling.
Many of these men have already gone through the ringer of the family court system once,
and this was the outcome they received. As a consequence, they are often less than hopeful
that engaging with the same process again will produce a different result.
In any case, there are lots of reasons why this can happen, and it's certainly not always because
the fathers involved are bad men. It's an extraordinarily painful and helpless and hopeless
position for these men to be in. Over the years, I've met with many men in this situation who have
come to me for guidance. Is there anything I can do to change the situation? How can I keep the
connection with my child alive in the wake of my ex's gatekeeping? How can I ensure that my
children don't hate me? These are all tough questions, especially because, we have to be
honest, fathers don't have a lot of rights under certain agreements, and as previously mentioned,
these can be very hard to change. So there is often a measure of acceptance required to navigate
this challenging situation with equanimity. But here's the thing. For better or worse,
family stories are long. Friends, lovers, colleagues all come and go, but family relations
last a lifetime. Irrespective of the preferences of the individuals involved,
you will always be those children's father, and they will always be your kids. There is literally
nothing anyone can do about that. And sometimes, in these long family stories,
there are empty chapters. But that doesn't necessarily mean that the story is over.
Just because people fall apart from each other at one point in the narrative
doesn't mean that they can't come back together further into the story.
What I'm saying is that if you're a father who is estranged from his children,
you might have to play the long game. Rely on the fact that family stories are long
and bide your time. In the worst case scenario, you will have to wait until your kids turn 18.
Eventually, your children will become adults, and as adults, they will have to make up their
own minds about things, including, very notably, their parents. They may even come to you with
questions. However, there is also the possibility that after years of emotional alienation,
they will feel no particular motivation to establish a relationship. Think about what
that mother might have been saying throughout their childhood. He never really loved you.
If he wanted to be in your life, he would. He never called or wrote or made an effort,
etc., etc. This will be an extremely difficult narrative to counteract after the fact.
But that doesn't mean that there isn't a way to do so.
Let's get concrete. The strategy I'm going to share with you today was actually taught to me
by one of my professors in grad school. He was a clinical psychologist who specialized in men's
mental health and fatherhood in particular. And he taught this to me because he unfortunately
saw this situation in his office all the time. And I can attest that the strategy has a good
success rate. I've shared this approach with a number of men I've personally counseled,
and it's produced the desired result in every single case.
So what is it? If you're a father who is emotionally estranged from his children,
all you need to do is get your hands on a cardboard box. Nothing fancy. Any cardboard
box will do. Now, we're going to call this your evidence box. And as the name suggests,
we're going to fill this box with evidence of your love, effort, and dedication.
Every week, you're going to write your kid a letter, like an old school letter, and you're
going to send it via certified mail. And that little certified receipt goes right into the
evidence box. Either your child actually receives the letter, which is good, or you build a slightly
stronger case against the mother's alienating narrative, which is also good. And you write
that letter every week, come rain or come shine. Next, milestones. Every birthday, every Christmas,
every important event that you are not able to attend, you buy your kid a little present
and write out a little card. If you cannot reasonably ensure that your child will receive
them, then you put them into the evidence box with their receipts attached. The receipt
is important. It's not about the money involved. The receipt is to establish the date of the
purchase. It helps to establish the counter narrative that you, in fact, had been trying to
be an involved parent the entire time. And again, you're going to fill this box with acknowledgements
of your child's development religiously. Don't miss a single important occasion.
Now, obviously, the strategy is going to require a little money and more than a little discipline,
but it's highly effective at changing hearts and minds. Without your evidence box, if and when you
do reestablish contact with your children, what will prevent the exchange from devolving into a
he said, she said argument? After all this time, why should I believe you? Mama was there for me
all those years. You're just showing up now. It's going to take more than words to convince me.
This is, after all, a fairly reasonable position for the child to take.
However, with an evidence box, you now have a leg to stand on your love, effort and dedication
have been documented and preserved. And now Mama's got some explaining to do.
Depending on the story she's been pushing in your absence, there is now at the very least
the introduction of some reasonable doubt with the revelation of this new information.
And this is just in the event of the worst case scenario where you have to wait until your
children age out of their custody agreements. In many cases, mothers will relax their gatekeeping
with consistent effort. You don't need to tell the mother about the evidence box. In fact,
you probably should. However, if you persist in sending certified letters to your kids
every week, she might just soften her stance. I'm not saying it's necessarily right, but she
might have certain expectations with respect to how you need to show up for your kid.
And demonstrating that you can be a stable presence in that kid's life can go a long way.
Again, I've worked with a number of guys in this situation, and the evidence box worked.
And they didn't have to wait until their children turned 18. It took a few months to a few years.
But in every case, the consistent effort overcame their ex's gatekeeping, and they were able to
reestablish relationships with their children. So that's how you deal with parental estrangement.
Hopefully, you don't need to use this strategy, but there it is. What do you think? Does this
fit with your own experience? Let me know in the comments below. And please, send this episode to
someone who you think might benefit from its message. I know you know some guy who needs to
hear this. It's word-of-mouth referrals like that that really help to make the channel grow.
There's also a few other things. You can go to my website and sign up for my free weekly
newsletter for which I write original content, or book a one-on-one paid consultation with yours
truly. There's also my book, The Value of Others, where I go into the economic model of relationships
and my private community, The Captain's Quarters, where I host live, bi-monthly group consultations
and host Q&As with invited guests from all over the internet. The links to everything are in the
description below. Check it out. There is a lot of great value down there. As always,
I appreciate your support, and thank you for listening.
