Immortality and Personal Consciousness? | John Polkinghorne

Human & Consciousness
3 followers
1 Video View·Mar 28, 2025
In memory of John Polkinghorne, 1930-2021, a passionate believer in the unity of knowledge.
Human beings yearn to live forever. But our only hope is some kind of non-physical reality like a personal God, alternative God, or cosmic consciousness. What would be the nature of such immortality? Would we retain our individual sense of self? Or would our drop of personal consciousness be subsumed within a vast ocean of cosmic consciousness? It would make a difference.
The Rev. John Charlton Polkinghorne was an English theoretical physicist, theologian, and writer. He was professor of Mathematical Physics at the University of Cambridge, and he resigned his chair to become an ordained Anglican priest.
John, when religions in general and Christianity in specific talks about eschatology, life after
death, the resurrection, obviously it's only in the most general terms, but I really want to
figure out how much we can really speculate in an intelligent way about this, because
if it doesn't work and there are internal contradictions, maybe the whole thing doesn't
work. So I want to push it. I want to push it and see what it means. So if we're talking about an
afterlife, what will it mean for us as individual personalities? I think that's a very important
question to pursue, because if it isn't coherent, it can't be a coherent hope. That's clear. If you
start thinking about these things, you soon see that you are going to have to satisfy, if there
is a destiny beyond death, two criteria, one of continuity and one of discontinuity. Continuity
says it must be Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, or whoever it is, who live again, not just new
characters given the old name for old time's sake. So what could be the carrier of continuity
between life in this world and life beyond death? The traditional answer has been the human soul.
That's usually been thought of platonically as a sort of spiritual substance that's separated at
death. Immortal, can't be destroyed. Maybe immortal, maybe preserved. I think we can't think of human
beings in that way. We are, I think, packaged deals, psychosomatic unities. So have we lost the idea
of the soul? Well, I don't think we have, but we have to reconceive it. The soul is presumably the
real me and it's almost as difficult to know what the real me is in this life as it might
be beyond it. Here am I, elderly academic, here's that school boy with the shock of black hair and the
school photograph about 10 years ago. What makes me the same as him? You might think it's material
continuity, but that's an illusion because the atoms that make up our bodies are changing all
the time. I'm atomically distinct from that school boy. So what makes me the same? I think
in some sense it is the pattern in which those atoms are formed. Pattern that carries things
like my memories and things of that nature. That's the continuity. It's the information pattern
carried by my body, which I believe is the soul. Now when I die, of course, that soul,
well, that pattern will dissolve. But I believe it is perfectly coherent to believe that the faithful
God, who is the only ground in my view for hope of destiny beyond death, the faithful God will remember
the pattern that is me, hold it in the divine memory. Now that isn't my life after death because I need
to be embodied if I'm to be truly human. So the Christian hope is not spiritual survival, but
death and resurrection. And so God will re-embody that pattern in a new environment of God's choosing.
That's where the discontinuity comes in because there's no point in re-embodying me
if I'm going to die again. So it has to be a different kind of matter in which I'm
embodied. And that is, I believe, the matter of a new creation. Okay, let's look at some of the
pieces here. If this information pattern that is in the mind of God that's being remembered after
our death, after our death, that's not conscious, that's not living. It has to be re-embodied.
In my view, yes. So after we die, there's no consciousness, no existence until if, when there's
a resurrection. Yes, it's possible, of course, since the time of the world to come and the time of this
world is distinct, it's possible that we go from one to the other at the moment of death. But there
might be an intervening period, and that was very extensively discussed over the centuries.
Soul sleep was the way that was often spoken about. So there would be, there would be, it would not be
a fully human life. If you're just held as a pattern in the mind of God, that's not a fully
human life. And whether that's conscious or not, you think it's probably not conscious, but you're
you're not sure. I'm not sure. I'll wait and see, I think, is the answer. But I, yeah, that's a separate question.
Okay, now here's a problem that I face. I can go with you that our lives are an information pattern
in the mind of God, and then there's a resurrection, and God re-embodies that, and we come back to
ourselves. But if God could do that for one, he could do that multiple times. It's the same pattern.
I mean, you just reproduce it, just like you're reproducing, copying a hard drive on a computer,
maybe a little more complicated. And now suddenly you have, you know, 50 John Polkinghorns and, you
know, maybe only three or four Robert Kuhns, and, you know, who's me? Well, God doesn't do stupid things.
And I think just to reproduce clones of people would be a stupid thing. What would be the point of it?
The point of it? Well, only God has the power to do this, and I think God will use that power
in accordance with the divine nature. That's to say, will use it responsibly, if one may use
that language, and won't create lots of clones. I'm puzzled. I know a lot of philosophers
talk about the person are worried about this question of doppelgangers and things of that
nature, but I think it's a foolish worry. If you believe the only power to do that is the divine
power, which will always be used suitably and properly. The question is, could God do that
if God had that power? And here's the problem. If God could do that, in principle, that would seem
to add some incoherence to the whole picture, because it's impossible to have multiple states
of our individual personality. Things are exactly the same and distinct. That's a contradiction.
You have to understand what is meant by saying that God is almighty. It doesn't mean that God
can do absolutely anything. The rational God cannot decree that two plus two equals five.
God can do anything that is in accordance with the divine will. That is to say, in accordance with
the divine nature. God is not restrained from the outside, but God is internally
restrained by the consistency of the divine nature. I'm suggesting that a tiny part of
that consistency is that God will not foolishly reproduce clones of people.
Okay, but whatever it is, if you believe in the resurrection, it's going to be pretty good, right?
I believe so, yes. Something to look forward to.
