The word tariff has been heard a lot lately in the news, in political commentary, on social media, and even on retail websites. Regardless of political leaning, all Americans have become increasingly conscious of the concept of tariffs because of President Donald Trump’s promised plans to levy them against foreign countries. Some people think this sounds like a great idea, while others insist that it spells financial disaster. The president has mentioned his intention of using tariffs to replace the income tax. While this might seem like a radical notion, an examination of American political history reveals that the battle over income tax versus tariffs is an old one. Although the federal income tax as we know it was not implemented until 1913, the idea of a graduated income tax on American citizens dates back to the War of 1812. Although that tax never came to pass, the first income tax would be temporarily imposed on wealthier citizens during and directly after the Civil War to fund that costly military conflict. After it expired, many people argued that a graduated income tax would shift the burden of funding the government from poor laborers, through tariffs, to rich business owners. However, could tariffs support the huge US government of the 21st century?
Welcome to Epoch Insights with Tiffany.
My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Tariff is a word which we've heard a lot lately.
In the news, on social media, in political commentary, and on the websites of a lot of
retailers.
President Donald Trump has promised to impose tariffs on a lot of countries, and many people
think that spells disaster for the American people.
On the other hand, many see it as an excellent thing.
Which brings up the old debate of what tariffs really are, whether they help or whether they
hurt, and the impact they can have on the American economic system.
On the cover of the opinion section of the latest issue of the Epoch Times, there is
an article by Jeffrey Tucker.
He usually has this position of honor in the opinion section because his articles are very
well-versed in economics and the historical insight that needs to be offered to really
understand what's happening politically as well as economically today in the world.
This latest article is called, Replace the Income Tax with Tariffs, and it brings up
the age-old debate of taxes versus tariffs.
Now in reality, tariffs are a form of tax.
The question is just when and how these taxes are paid.
Because one way or another, the government must be funded, and the only way it can be
funded is through tariffs or taxes.
Tariffs are fees or taxes, you could say, that are paid when goods are shipped into
the country.
Now, who pays these tariffs?
They're paid by importers, and indirectly by producers, and eventually by consumers.
And that's the point that people have been making when they're against tariffs.
The price of everything is going to go up because of all these tariffs of goods coming
in.
In contrast, taxes are something which are paid directly by the consumer.
What is the history of the income tax?
There's an old saying, I'm sure we've all heard, that some of the only things upon which
you can rely are death and taxes.
And it's true that throughout the history of the world there have been different forms
of taxes.
Yet, the income tax in the United States does not date to 1776, or the writing of the Constitution.
As a matter of fact, as this article points out, there was a time when you could keep
every penny you earned.
You did not have to file with the federal government, telling them what you earned and
giving the feds their cut.
Your finances were your business and no one else's.
You had the right to earn, own, and keep property, and it was sacrosanct, guaranteed by US law
and tradition.
That's the opening paragraph of the article.
But I must say that Mr. Tucker is simplifying a little there, because as I'm sure he himself
would acknowledge, the income tax has a complex history.
He mentions that this time was before 1913.
There was no income tax.
That's not strictly true, though.
An income tax was first suggested around the time of the War of 1812 to fund that war.
Anytime there's a war, the government has a lot of debt and they want the people to
help with that.
But it never actually carried through.
And even then, when it was suggested, it was to be a small percentage, very small, and
only for people who earn above a certain amount.
And while that amount doesn't sound like much now, it was quite a minority at the time.
The first income tax, which actually took place, was put into effect during the Civil
War.
It was intended to help fund the Civil War.
And it expired in 1872.
Again, it was only people who earned over a certain amount, so it was mainly the very
wealthy, who were affected at all by that tax.
After it expired in 1872, many people moved that there should be a regular income tax.
The particular movements who were in support of it were the Greenback movement, and that
was a party which was advocating the use of paper money instead of gold, the Labour Reform
Party, the Populist Party, the Socialist Labour Party, and the Democratic Party.
They all advocated for a graduated income tax of some kind or another to shift the burden
of funding the government from poor labourers, through tariffs, to rich businessmen.
And there we have the very crux of this whole conflict.
It usually is people who are more, at least claiming that they're for the common people,
which would be Democrats at that time, or Socialists, Labourers, Greenbacks, and Republicans
historically were business owners.
So they didn't like the idea of an income tax, because they would be the ones who'd
be hit the hardest, you could say.
The next definite act that took place to forward the income tax was in 1894.
The Wilson-Gorman Tariff Act, also known as the Revenue Act.
It was the first attempt at a peacetime income tax.
It was to be 2% on households over $4,000 a year, which was less than 1% of the population.
This was originally intended as a tariff reform act, because tariffs were very high at that
time.
So Wilson and Gorman came up with this idea, and as a matter of fact, some of the main
congressmen who were in support of it didn't even like the idea of an income tax, but they
thought that the current tariffs were worse.
So they thought this was the only way to even try to do it.
And so it would reduce tariff rates and replace it with the income tax.
However, the next year, 1895, a landmark Supreme Court decision reversed it.
It was Pollock v. Farmers Loan and Trust Company.
That struck down the income tax as an unapportioned direct tax.
Chief Justice Melville Fuller, who was one of the leaders in this decision, held that
a federal tax on income was unconstitutional unless it was reflected by some kind of representation
in the House of Representatives.
This was an unpopular ruling.
But the way it was worded kept anyone from proposing another income tax for quite a while.
Because of what he said about apportionment, that made it very difficult for them to work
it.
It was considered an unworkable ruling.
Because how would you apportion it?
And apportionment mainly means where something is divided across the population.
And they couldn't figure out a way to make it work.
Until 1909, when basically they didn't care anymore.
And President William Howard Taft proposed a 2% federal income tax on corporations in
just a speech to Congress.
So then, an income tax amendment was proposed by Senator Norris Brown of Nebraska.
On July 12th, a resolution proposing the 16th Amendment was passed by Congress and was submitted
to state legislatures.
It wouldn't be until 1913, specifically on February 3rd, that it was ratified by Delaware,
the 36th state.
And eventually, 42 of the existing 48 states would go on to ratify this and agree with
it.
The other six never did agree with the income tax.
And to this day, not every state has a state income tax.
But there is the federal income tax.
By 1913, the political climate had changed a lot during those years.
Democrats had retaken both the presidency, with Woodrow Wilson being elected in 1912,
and both houses of Congress.
The Republican Party was divided and weakened at that time.
Inflation was high, and people blamed federal tariffs.
So it seemed like a good thing.
Now, looking back to some points that Jeffrey Tucker made, it seems like a simple enough
case.
We used to have tariffs, we replaced them with the income tax, technically the income
tax is un-American, let's just go back to tariffs.
But as Jeffrey Tucker points out, in 1913, not really that long ago, just a little over
a hundred years, the government at that time was much smaller.
In fact, going back to 1885, more when these issues were first being debated with the income
tax, government spending, when adjusted for inflation, was 0.05% of what it is now.
It's a tiny fraction.
So the amount that could be gotten from tariffs, even with all the inflation adjustment, if
we switched over to tariffs, we couldn't possibly have enough tariffs to fund the government
at the rate it's currently spending.
The only solution, looking at the whole thing logically, is some severe government cuts,
such as have never been seen in the United States before.
As the article mentions, people like Elon Musk have been mentioned some drastic cuts.
There have been many talks of cutting government spending for years, but usually when they
say that, it just means that they'll cut the rate of increase of government spending, not
actually stop spending less and go back.
That would be quite a change.
And we see why a long time ago, when the government didn't spend nearly as much, it could seem
like maybe it would be more fair to tax the people who have more money.
If you think about it logically, why should the poor working people have to pay just to
get the basics they need to live and make all the prices go up because of these tariffs
to get the goods into this country?
Why shouldn't we let the rich people pay?
But the income tax is much higher now than it was then, and it's not just the rich business
owners who are being taxed.
Everyone feels the pain of the income tax.
And it's interesting if you watch old movies to see how some people still didn't agree
with it.
Most notably, Frank Capra's famous 1938 film, You Can't Take It With You.
In it, Lionel Barrymore's character, who everyone calls Grandpa, is a very fun-loving man who
believes in a lot of principles, but he has his own ideas.
And a man from the Internal Revenue comes and starts asking him about his back taxes.
And he starts a playful argument with him, saying that income taxes are un-American.
And he says, if I give you this money, what are you going to give me?
And the man really doesn't have a good answer.
He's like, go pay for all the roads, pay the salaries.
What about pay for the Constitution?
He says, well, that was paid off a long time ago.
And he argues, the government isn't really doing anything for me, so why should I pay
for the government?
And I think Frank Capra just included that as a little joke, because the real-life actor,
Lionel Barrymore, a staunch lifelong Republican, was very much against the income tax.
If you consider a man of his generation, he was a grown man, a member of working society
when the income tax was passed in 1913.
You could see him being very much against it then, and he refused to pay it a lot.
As a matter of fact, Louis B. Mayer, the studio head of MGM where he worked, actually paid
off his back taxes to keep him from going to jail, because he knew that he wouldn't
do it out of principle.
He'd rather go to jail, because he disagreed with it.
And now we're just all so used to it, that it seems like a normal part of life.
But looking back at the history, and how some people thought it outlandish, and some people
thought it was a good idea, and the different people who have been supportive of it.
And, when you really think about it, it is concerning that parties like the Labour Party
and the Socialist Party were proponents of an income tax, because, as we know, labor
is often just a term for socialists, and it's one of those things that sounds like a good
idea in theory.
Let those who have more take the burden of funding the government.
But in actuality, it impedes upon the American dream, and the idea of owning property, and
especially property was one of the most points of contention in the early days of the income
tax, because it was considered very un-American to tax someone on the revenue he got from
renting his property, versus his property, and now there are taxes on everything.
But looking at this, I think it's important for all of us, Americans, to look at history
before we just make up our minds about current political issues.
There's nothing new under the sun.
So many things have happened in our American history that doesn't make it into your average
grade school American history book.
There's a lot more to our history than the Paul Revere and the Constitution, and then
Abraham Lincoln, and now here we are.
So much happened during all that time, and if we educate ourselves about these topics
and find out more about what happened when this legislature was passed, and how it's
changed over the years, we can make more informed decisions when voting, when conducting
business, and be aware of what's really happening with our elected officials.
Thank you for spending this time with me talking about the history of the income tax, and comparing
it with the other option for funding the government, tariffs.
If you enjoyed this video, I hope you'll like it, subscribe to the channel, share it with
your friends, and leave a comment letting me know what you think about the income tax
versus tariffs.
Thank you for watching!