Lecture 26: Corrosion, Corrugation and Rail Failures - I

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Jul 23, 2024
In this lecture, corrosion and rusting in rails, their causes and remedial measures, and corrugation in rails, their effects and remedy, failure in rails, and their causes has been discussed.
[Music]
[Music]
dear students and participants of the
course on Railway engineering
now today we are going to talk about the
aspects which were left in the previous
lecture in the previous lecture we
started with the
buckling and when we talked about the
hog rails and the batter rails two more
aspects we thought of discussing in the
lecture were corrosion and the
corrugation of rails and those are the
two aspects which were not covered so
today we'll be taking up those
particular aspects also along with the
next thing which will come that is the
rail
failure and within the rail failure
we'll talk about the causes we'll talk
about the
classification the location and the
position of those ra
failures let's see how much we are able
to cover today considering all of these
aspects starting with the corrosion and
the rusting of the
Rails now in this case the corrosion is
one aspect which is always going to be
there when you're talking about a metal
like a
steel so here when you're talking about
any such metal which can get corroded
because of certain actions of chemicals
or the actions of the environment in
terms of moisture or climatic conditions
which are prevailing for a longer period
of time at any of the location there's
always a possibility that the corrosion
and the rusting may
happen so this corrosion it is not
caused so much by the dampness as by the
acid gases which are dissolved in the
film of
moisture dampness is of course going to
cause the corrosion but the gravity that
is what we are talking here so if there
are some acid gases which have got
dissolved in the moisture and that
moisture remains there for a long period
of time and It Coats the
rails that means at the top of the rail
that moisture is coming so if we talking
about a rail
section so this is the rail section
which is being placed at the top of the
sleeper and in this environment the
there is a moisture so finally all this
moisture will be there on the top of
this
rail so there is a sort of a coating
which will happen and in this coating if
there are acids the fumes are
there then this is further
dangerous the corrosion is generally
noticed on the web and foot of the rail
so this is the web section and this one
is the for Section so area which is
being exposed that is one thing second
thing is the thickness being provided
here similarly the thickness being
provided here as compared to the Hat
section third the total area which is
being exposed the surface
area which is
exposed that is also is having a problem
so this is the area or you can say these
are the two
areas which are going to be affected
more corrosion is location specific and
it can be heavy at certain locations so
this is an important aspect again you
may find that for the same rail
section having the same mineral
composition being placed on the similar
type of the uh sleepers with the
fastenings
it may not be corroded at one location
but getting corroded at another
location and if it is getting corroded
at that particular location that we need
to identify what are those specific
factors which may be causing that
corrosion so this is important
aspect so let us talk about some
locations which may be prone to the
corizon of a rail very first one the
platform
lines where the trains make prolonged
HS see the train has been taken this is
a
platform and this one is a main
line but there is a line on the back
side where the buffer is
provided and on this particular line the
train may be stopped and may be kept in
waiting to come on the main track for
use so if this is a location where the
train is being kept for a longer period
of time then this may cause an issue
similarly even on the platform if say
the train stays longer the train is
going to stay here for 30 minutes and
there are many such trains which happen
just stay there for such longer periods
at this particular
station then this section this is again
liable or or it is going to be getting
affected in terms of a
corrosion the sidings where the saline
or the corrosive goods are dealt
with now as I said this is one case
another case is that this line can
go to a
location like this whereas it may be
straight
also and there can be
further another
track so these are
sidings and say on this particular side
we have a
platform where the material is being
either dumped means they been taken out
of the wagons are being placed on the
wagon so here such sort of activities
are going on and this activities will
keep going for a longer period of time
because we talk about a good strain it
may be having something like 40 plus or
50 plus
Wagons at this location if the goods
which are being handled they are sine in
nature or corrosive in nature then also
there is a possibility that on these
sidings the rails may get
corroded then near water hydrants due to
insufficient
drainage so if you have this uh track on
which the train is going to stop for a
longer period of time as we
discussed there may be a requirement
that there are water hydrants being
provided here and then there can be
another track on the other side and a
platform on this side so this is
platform number one this is platform
number two and it can be platform number
three or the other side so in between
these two tracks the these water
hydrants are provided so that if there
is a requirement to fill the water in
the boggies that can be done by using
the same water hydrant which are placed
in the central location at this point
when the water is being filled and then
it is being the pipe has been taken out
there is a possibility that water
will get is spilled on the surface and
if at this location the good drain is
not provided then this water which has
being filled it will not come to this
strain it will remain
there and this is also become a
condition where the rusting will start
and finally the rails may get corroded
tunnels and deep
cuttings specifically in the case of
tunnels because it's a long tunnel which
is provided and the track is being
passing through
it so if it's very long then whatever
fumes are there whatever humid
conditions are there inside that that
will not getting dissipated it will
remain there for a longer period of time
and because of those reasons in this
area there is again a possibility of the
corrosion or the rusting of the Rails
industrial belts for the obvious reasons
as we talked here that there can be a
possibility of handling saline of the
corrosive Goods so in the case of
industrial belts what type of material
is being held what is being
transported so there can be a issue in
this case also now the measurement of
depth of
corrosion this can be done as vertically
and lateral
Direction and when we say that it means
it's a reduction in the bottom FL width
of the
rail so when we said that there is
a
web so this is a flange
width and it may happen that slowly and
slowly it is getting into this form it
means either it is getting chopped off
it is broken or this corrosion has
started infiltrating
it so we have to identify whether up to
this point it has happened or this or
this point whatever is the extent with
respect to the actual size of the foot
of the rail here it shall be done using
the Straight Edge and the fer gauge or
any other suitable device at a fixed
periodicity of
once in a year on every 100 sleepers
removing the elastic rail clips and
liners these elastic rail clips and
liners they are basically the
fastenings which are used
for rail
to sleeper
connection and when we're taking up the
FES Lings we will be discussing about
these types of uh items there what it
says is that we can use any of the
system can be a straight edge can be a
fer gauge or can be any other such
device where we can identify what is the
amount of rusting which has happened but
periodically it has to be done at least
once in a year and as a
sample 100 sleepers needs to be removed
and then examine that what is happened
at that particular location so what is
the prevention of this problem one is
the use of anti-corrosive pains now
these anti-corrosive
paints they can be the bituminous paints
and these bituminous paints can be used
on the new rails in the areas where
there is a possibility of corrosion
taking place we have talked about number
of areas where this type of a thing may
happen another can be that we can go for
the
metallization and this
metallization is done in the severe
corrosion prone
areas where things like the bituminous
painting and these type of things may
not be walkable then then you have to go
to further
aspect then when we are going for this
Jin metallization then how it is to be
done you have to prepare the surface
it's not that you have simply gone there
and you have sprayed it and that Jin
metallization has happened and this
surface preparation there are certain
guidelines for it what it says it should
not be done when the ambient temperature
is below 10° Cen or above 50° Cen in the
raining Seasons that is in the during
the night in the winter before 8:00 a.m.
in summer between 11:00 a.m. to 3 p.m.
or in the extremely windy Misty or Dusty
conditions so there are a number of
conditions being written
here so you have to look at the climatic
conditions you have to look at the
temperatures you have to look at the
time in a day when that temperature is
varying Beyond certain limits so all of
those combinations are being talked
here so it's already said the
temperature is below 10 or above 50°
centigrade in terms of an ambient
temperature if it's a rainy season there
is any time when the rains can be there
so at that time you should not go for it
because whatever you do will get washed
out during the night time in the winters
before 8:00 a.m. or in the day time when
the temperatures are going to be very
high so between 11: and 300 p.m.
another way of doing it is a greasing
and sealing of the liner contact
area and these liners as we discussed
they are basically the fastenings which
will come at an interface of a rail and
a
sleeper so at that bottom where the
slipper is provided and the top of
that a rail is being placed so there
will be a liner which is being embedded
here
so on the basis of the size the contact
area of the liner will be
there what it says is in identified
corrosion prone areas the rail liner
seat should be greased using graphite
gree is 408 1981 gr o that means grade o
specification after the proper cleaning
so there is a requirement of a greasing
at this
location and what type of Grease is to
be used is also being
defined the grease is also applied all
around the liner so whatever this liner
is being provided it can be in this
shape or it can
be in this shape also so that it takes
up the
fastenings so in this case it is applied
all along whatever the shape is being
provided here
all around the liner and the rail foot
on the gauge face side that is rail foot
is this one this is
foot and there is another rail on this
side that means this is the area where
the gauge G will be provided so that's
this becomes the Gaze
side similarly for another rail this
becomes the Gaz side
so on this particular side we are doing
it and why we are doing it because on
this particular side only when we talk
about a wagon which is moving at the top
of
it passenger wagon which has
Laboratories inside so there is a
possibility that
the open type of system it is being used
then all that dis discrete will be
coming at this particular location so so
that's the problem and if that goes
inside it will cause the corroding
effect so we need to control
this then rail Fang and web should be
kept free of the
mark So this area as well as this area
that has to be keep free of Mark so
periodical checks needs to be done and
the cleanings has to be carried
out then shifting of the liner locations
longitudinal shifting of the ler
location from the sleeper seat can be
done when the corrosion is less than 1.5
mm so there is a value being specified
here now so when this can be done or
when it cannot be done the train
watering Arrangements shall be avoided
on the runs through main lines as far as
possible most of the time on the main
lines the trains are not going to stop
for a longer period of
time so there may not be a requirement
of those watering Arrangements but yes
there are some acute conditions in which
even in one particular passenger bgy
there is a requirement to fill the water
so some such arrangements are always
capped as far as possible if we can
avoid these watering Arrangement on the
mail line then it will going to be more
helpful proper drainage that has to be
ensured and not only on these particular
main lines where the watering
Arrangements has to be has been done but
also in the case of yards or the station
lines including the washing lines where
the trains are going to be washed and
cleaned or there are washable aons or
train watering lines if they are being
dedicated being defined at one
particular location at those cases the
proper drainage shall be taken care of
so this is also an important
aspect then periodical cleaning of the
rubbish that needs to be done and that
has to be done in the goods shed siding
lines so siding lines and the proper
problems which may be faced in the
siding lines we did talked about
previously another way of doing with the
working with these type of conditions is
to use a different type of a rail so
here when we say different type of rail
we are talking about the the mineral
compositions which have been
Incorporated here so one such case is a
copper mum CU Amo rail sections so in
these particular areas where the
corrosions are more these are the
corrosion resistant Trail sections it
can be used there can be another one
that is nickel chromium Copper Rail so
any of these two types of a specific
rail sections can also be used in those
severe areas where the corrosion is
severe now these corrosion resistant
attributes of these rails they are
account of the fact that they produce
fine rust
layer which inhibits increase of
moisture and chloride ions forming a
protective layer all along the ra
section so so this is the mechanism
which will be there when you are using
these type of RA
sections now let us talk about another
aspect that is corrugation of rails now
in the case of corrugation of
rails in the case Center locations the
rail table when we say rail table we are
talking about the
surface on the
head it develops rigid and Hollows that
means if I talk about top of the rail
section so this type of a problem may
come
up so if this W pattern has got created
so if you look at in the photograph
which is being shown on the right hand
side from this portion
to this portion there are certain
patches if you see very minutely there
are dark and the light patches being
shown here on this section there is no
issue it's a totally one type of a
section so here the corrugations have
happened in this particular patch and
this is how they are looking and that's
where there will be the ridge or the
hollow
now higher normal load operations more
than 20 tons can lead to the development
of the longer pitch corrugations on the
running surface of the rail what does
that mean when we see the pitch is going
to be there so this pitch we are talking
that at what particular distance this
high and
low uh levels are going to be there so
when we talking about this this can
increase if the loads are more than than
20 tons which are coming at a
location the rail corrugations they
occur when compressive stresses in the
rail head at the contact Point goes
beyond the yield point and the plastic
deformation of the rail top takes place
which forms waves due to movement of
trains and subsequent work hardening
what does that mean so we talking about
the occurrence of the compressive
stresses on the rail head so the the
wheels are moving at the top of it but
when the these wheels moves they are
putting the pressure on the rail
head so there is a contact area through
which this is
happening now this particular pressure
which is being exerted if it is going
beyond the strength
characteristics of the rail section
which is being
used so if you have talked about the 52
kg per meter or 60 kg per meter 90 or
whatever else section 72 UTS 90 UTS 110
UTS real
section so depending on the strength
characteristics whatever the loads are
coming if they are going beyond the
yield
point then there is a
problem and because of that high stress
which is coming at a location it has not
being able to sustain a plastic
deformation may take
place and this plastic deformation when
it happens it means now it is not a hard
surface it is a bit plastic in nature
which has a possibility of flow so as
the wheel will move it will create a
wave and this wave will also move and
that's the reason why these type of wavy
patterns in terms of the ridges and the
shallows will get
created so this is an issue now once the
loads are there not there the rails are
in a normal condition the temperatures
are normal and for a long time there is
no such activity of the movement of the
train at this particular
track then the hardening will take place
and finally you will find that this
irregular surface at the top is going to
be
formed then the plastic flow of the rail
material on account of the wheel rail
contact stresses it exceeds the material
Shakedown
limit and the combine vertical Resonance
of the Wheel sets on Spring masses and
the track this is also and aspect that
you're talking about the rail you're
talking about the wheels and you're
talking about the other masses which are
there on the wheels we did talk about in
the case of uh very specifically for the
steam engines or
locomotives various types of those type
of Weights which were there which were
creating an
impact so uh here if there is a combined
effect of all of these things together
so a resonance sort will get created and
this resonance will work in the vertical
Direction and that will also create the
corrugation now when the corrugation has
occurred now how it is going to create a
problem is it a problem or it is not a
problem that's what we're talking so
what are the
impacts it increases the dynamic wheel
loads and the vibrations obviously
vibrations are going to increase because
the train wheel is moving at the top of
this irregular surface
it will also cause uh the resistances if
you remember the track resistances we
did talk about they were because of the
track
irregularities and the dynamic wheel
loads will also increase because these
Dynamic wheel loads they are related
with those type of impacts along with
the speeds there is an increase in the
rate of deter of the track and the
vehicle components this is also a
problem and that's where the higher
maintenance activity will be required at
this point and it will increase the cost
it will also be more periodical in
nature now this corrugation of rails
this is generally found in case of 72
UTS rail sections whose yield strength
is lower for the movement of the
locomotives and the box and wagons so
depending on what type of locomotives
have been used if you remember in the
case of locomotives we did talk about
the Axel loads we did talk about uh uh
the total load of a locomotive which is
coming on the top of the rails and that
was creating uh impacts in terms of the
attactive effort or power which is
required for a locomotive and this box
and wagons which are again having
weights and then the further weight will
be there in terms of the material which
is being placed inside it so gross
weight we are talking here so all of
these things they will make a problem in
terms of the 72 UTS rail sections if
they have been
used then this corrugation varies in
size and shape we already said it is
going to vary in terms of location and
it may occur at irregular intervals it
may happen that at one location it was
there then it is straight there's no
problem then again it is happening so it
may be some kilometers Beyond it may be
some meters Beyond and then you will
find that it is a small distance and
again that is happening so it's nothing
like it's a fixed phenomena which is
happening it's a culmination of number
of aspects which are contributing
together now factors which propagate
corrugations are the Metallurgy and the
age of the Rails age of the Rails when
we see we are talking about the service
life of the rail and this service life
of the rail is being defined with
respect to gross million tons uh which a
rail section can
handle so if there is a high nitrogen
content in the rails in terms of the
metallurgical aspect there may be a
problem the effect of illation at the
time of rolling and straightening of the
Rails if uh this work is is going on and
then if there is a oxil then this also
May create some
issue then physical and environmental
conditions of the track so there can be
a steep gradient here so when you talk
about a steep gradient and the rail is
being laid at the top of which the wheel
is
moving so so as to go at the top we have
seen that the resistance which is being
caused due to the gradient is very high
so more power is required so it means it
has to place more effort here so that it
can move in the forward Direction so
there these particular locations may get
this type of a system yielding
formations the overall system which is
being provided at the bottom the
formation at top of that then Vost so if
that formation itself is yielding then
the track stability is a problem there
long tunnels
there also it has been observed and the
electrified sections also has been
observed to have this type of uh
corrugations but the reason why exactly
it happens is not very clearly known and
train operations high speeds and the
high Excel loads we did talk about the
Exel load in terms of the 20 tons and
more than 20 tons which are coming
repeatedly on the rail section which is
having a yield strance uh which is not
compatible with that we have not used
the high high strength rail section
maybe 90 UTS or 110 UTS at that location
when the speeds are high then it is
causing a impact in terms of the static
loads getting transformed into Dynamic
loads and those Dynamic loads are uh
some times maybe of 70% higher 50%
higher 40% higher depending on those
speeds then starting locations of the
trains when the train starts at a
particular location say uh at a
plateform
so here again because of the inertial
effect we did talk about the creep
Theory and we talked about that if this
happens below the wheel and it is going
to start then it has to make a push so
as to go ahead and at that location on
the rail section if this is happening
then there may be a possibility wherever
these things will happen corrugations
may appear locations where the brakes
are applied to stop the train so these
are the locations where the creeps are
ible at the same time these are the
locations where the corrugations can
also come
up atmospheric factors high moisture
content is specifically in the coastal
areas when this moisture content can
also be there in the tunnels and that's
the reason where we talked about the
tunnels uh there is a possibility of uh
these corrugations presence of
sand now presence of sand you may say
that this sand is available throughout
the length of a rail but then why
on a particular rail section it is
happening and not on the complete track
which is passing through say a coastal
area or a desert
area in both of the cases the sand will
be available so if the sand is there and
it comes and gets deposited at the top
here and when the wheel moves on the top
of this particular cushion which has
come up on the real had so AB action
will be there depending on the quality
of that sent depending on the amount of
that send that ABM action may be higher
at one location maybe lesser at another
and maybe higher at another location and
that will result in the corrugated
condition now when train moves on a
corrugated rail track it creates a
roaring
sound there's sort of a sound will come
up and because of these rolling sounds
which will be there uh these type of
rail sections they're also being termed
as the Roaring rails and the phenomena
is the Roaring of
rails so this is happening because when
this type of a system will be there and
the wheel is moving at the top of it
here there will be some air
packet and then again the wheel will
come here so this air because of this
air packet this roaring sound will be
coming and this causes inconvenience to
the passengers there will be rapid
oxolation of rail loosening of keys V of
fittings disturbances to the packing of
the Bellas so whatever the things which
are being provided below everything May
got disturbed because of these type of
phenomena now these can be removed by
the grinding of the rail heads there are
two types of equipments which are used
one is the hand of the motor driven
trolley so you might have seen a trolley
which is being pulled at the top of the
uh track where maybe few persons are
sitting and then uh there are certain
mechanism at the bottom of it and it
will try to grind the surface the top
surface which is being corrugated it
will be grinded and being brought to a
one particular level the another one is
the rail grinding train so you can see
the rail grinding train being shown on
the photograph on the right hand
side so this rail grinding train it
moves at a speed of 30 km/ hour and then
simultaneously it will be grinding both
of the rail
sections so there is an equipment on
this side there is an equipment on this
side will keep grinding and slowly and
slowly this trrain will keep moving at
the top of the rail sections and whole
of the section is going to be made free
of the corrugation so these are the
various ways in which it can be
removed now let us talk about the rail
failure now rail failure if the rail
examination indicates the defects in any
part of the rail which are considered
detrimental to the real life as well as
which may make the real not usable
further and may cause occurrence of a
hazardous situation hazardous situation
means there is a possibility that the
derailment may also
happen so if that sort of a situation is
getting to be created then that rail is
being marked as
failed so what we see is the detriment a
situation which is detrimental to the
rail with respect to its
usability and that usability is being
talked in terms of the service
life which is left and with respect to
the possibility of a situation which may
get created and can be termed as a
hazardous in such a condition the remedy
is to replace the affected rail on the S
ction that's the only remedy if it has
gone beyond such serviceable limits all
rail failures should be recorded as per
the standard guidelines except the
following cases if the real failure
occurs in a non rolling line so it's not
a Mainline it's it's not in use nowadays
so it has being abandoned or any such
thing is there then in that case uh we
need to uh not to record that then
nonstandard or obsolete rails if they
are there so for those particular cases
also it is not recorded because these
have to be finally
replaced okay these are not going to be
in use accidental damages which may
happen to the rail sections and such as
wheel Burns or scabbing buckling we have
talked Kink's conditions we have talked
there may be a
derailment there can be abnormal
slipping of the locomotive and because
of the slipping of the locomotive there
will be rubbing action at the top of the
rail heart and this will be also a one
type of a induction of a type of a ra
failure here then excessive V loss of
the
section some material has gone out so it
is a loss in terms of the sectional area
it is in terms of the sectional weight
also it can be because of the corrosion
because of the battering elongation of
holes so there are again a number of
issues due to which a certain things
have happened and they tell you that you
have to go for a
replacement so in those replacement then
obviously you cannot do anything
further now in most cases it is possible
to determine the cause of the rail
failure by visual examination you may
find that it has broken down or there
are cracks which are appearing or
sometimes they are minor in nature they
are very inside then you can go for an
ultrasonic detection so
usfd is what can be used
here without the need of metallurgical
investigation now there are it means
there are two classes here when it says
the failure is happened in such a manner
that you have to go to check that what
has happened in terms of its
manufacturing condition is there a
problem in terms of the various types of
minerals which have to be used in
different proportions so what is the
composition or there is some other issue
so the that metalogical investigation is
being done in some of the cases and that
again we will be discussing in one of
our discussion forward these causes of
the rail failures the inherent defects
in the rail which may be manufacturing
defects as I said related to the
chemical composition there can be piping
there can be seams there can be laps
there can be hard form segregation or
guide marks these are the different type
of inherent defects which are there or
there may be the defects which are
coming because of the rolling action of
uh the locomotives of the Wagons at the
top of it so which may be induced by
this it may occur in terms of the flat
spots in the tires engine Burns is
skiding of Wheels SE braking all of
these may also induce a failure at a
particular
location then abnormal traffic we did
talk about the value say 20 tons or
something so this effects say High
loading conditions causes the stresses
which are going beyond the permissible
stresses or the yield limits so there
also excessive Corone of rails this
leads to the development of cracks in
the regions with the high concentration
of his stresses again corosion and the
stresses they have got got correlated
here and this corrosion caused due to
the various weather conditions presence
of corrosive salts constant exposure to
moisture humidity uh near ashpit in
tunnels Etc so corrosion we have already
talked about that what are the reasons
due to which the corrosion of a rail can
take place so those are situations which
are being placed
here badly maintained joints so
maintenance is always a important issue
if it is not being done there are loose
fittings then that position will become
a location where the stresses will get
induced and it will it will not be in a
position to resist those stresses and
eventually there may a failure then
defects in the welding if the welding is
being done in terms of cwr lwr or
cwr it can be because of the composition
of the thermit weld metal which is being
used for the melding or it can be the
defective welding technique which is
being used at that
location both of these may also make an
impact and the improper maintenance we
already did talk about it and
derailments is already one of the bigger
reasons due to which the rails may fail
so we can stop here we will be
continuing with the classification of
rail failures and some of the rail
failures in the next lecture so till
then we uh close this particular lecture
we will be meeting in the next lecture
with the rest of the material to be
covered thank you and bye
[Music]
a
[Music]
