Lecture 36- Short Story in the Modern and Post-modern Era I

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
177 Video Views·Jan 11, 2025
[Music]
[Music]
good morning and welcome back to the
lecture series on uh we are discussing
short story in the modern and postmodern
era so today we are going to start uh
with uh the theorization of the genre of
short story before I start with this new
discussion I recall uh I was talking
about uh mad M uh a few lectures back um
I just wanted to add uh as an
afterthought how mother M's laughter in
death can be compared with uh Helen
Sour's essay laugh of the Medusa so so
Margaret Atwood famously says that men
are afraid that women will laugh at them
and women are afraid that men will kill
them so uh in this powerful essay by
Helen 6os Medusa is uh shown as uh the
beautiful woman that she is and uh she's
laughing she's almost uh scoffing in uh
joyon um in dis regard to the Freudian
ideas of castration uh and and the
leanian uh perception of the woman in
terms of uh a lack so helenos uh
introduces a French term and lature
feminine or women's writing as a
counterculture movement uh to debunk the
systematic operation and silencing that
women have uh time be memori faced
within the phow Centric the male Centric
uh tradition uh we know that Jac l
uh posited the symbolic uh structure of
languages operating through uh the
principle of binary opposition so the
French feminists uh aim at overthrowing
this kind of a fixed symbolic structure
uh through exploring alternative uh
relations that might be possible between
the woman's uh desire in the woman's
language um we are reminded how Helen
6os uh uh famously says write writing is
for you you are for you your body is
yours take it uh so aure feminine is
possible uh through reconciling a woman
uh with her body it uh deploys a
language uh that is full of f word play
uh ambiguity fragmentation slipperiness
and uh unusual images all of which uh
are attempts at uh making a Rapture uh
to the sense of normative uh language
normative use of language within a
masculinist uh discourse so uh Medusa's
laughter stands for uh the aspects of a
woman the aspects of the feminine uh
that defies representation the
unrepresentability of the feminine now
coming to Madame B's laughter in death
uh this this can be uh just opposed with
I mean uh you know the the laughter uh
of Medusa can be justos with Emma's
laughter in death uh in her laughter uh
in her in her death when she attempts
suicide and she's about to die Emma
scoffs at the inadequate society that
cannot Supply a language for uh positing
for holding her desire so the repetitive
fi language that we have already
discussed about when we were talking
about Madame Boi and uh you know the the
failure of forms at all levels in this
novel stand for the failure of the woman
uh in her attempt at uh etching herself
through uh her own standards through her
own discourse uh kind of etching out uh
her own discourse and her own space
within the society and a failure with
that uh an impossibility of that the
society the demands of the society and
the demand of the woman uh cannot meet
at any place there is no reconciliation
so as much as Emma um and her seeking
for aristocratic life remain
unrepresentable uh in life as long as
she lives uh she becomes a Timeless
Rebellion who is unsettling the standard
uh meanings the traditional meanings of
domestic in her death so through the
Staggering movement of uh flir's mother
MRI which revolves around this pesus
depiction of Emma Boi uh FLIR who is
also seen as her Alter Ego points to the
impossibility of this becoming of an
equiture feminine both uh in the society
uh in which Emma lives as well as uh
clar's immediate Society right so now
coming back to short stories in genre we
need to understand uh some of the
characteristics that have been uh
Associated uh with the typical short
story form uh the short story is uh
traditionally seen as a compressed
cohesive and a plotted form so the
concept of totality of being there alog
together and at once as well as that of
gravity intensity um suggestiveness
Unity of effect uh uh uh a closure
towards the end and uh a unity in design
are explored through this uh genous uh
theoretical discussions so the focus of
the short stories uh formal structure is
mostly uh a product of 20th century
critical thought uh so critics uh uh
critics uh in the 20th century start uh
trying to uh you know they they try to
uh note down certain enumerate the
features that uh make up the short story
um the Aesthetics of the genr form
attracted the interest of different
critics and narrative theorists uh in
the uh 1960s so the period of the
international dissemination of Russian
formalist writings of the 19 20s um when
we talk of formalists we have in our
mind uh Boris ien bomb we have
victori and then the emergence of uh
structuralism with Vladimir prop and um
structuralist anthropology with Claud
listos as well as the philosophy of
culture with uh AR cider so the
development of the short story is
constitute uh concurrently uh is
constituted concurrently with the rise
of the popularity of nurology uh with uh
the Inception of reader response
criticism discourse and Analysis
discourse analysis and cognitive science
so the short story uh form has its roots
in uh mythology and biblical verse
narratives in medieval sermons and
romance fables fils ballads and
emergence of the German Gothic in the
18th century uh its legendary Roots uh
are mediated uh via romantic influence
and uh they had to its legendary Roots
uh that are mediated via romantic
influence had to adjust to the uh mes
and Ry syblon Ry syblon are very very
similitude the very similitude standards
of the uh 18th and 19th Century realism
the realist movement and the Romantic
Movement have had a great influence on
the form of uh short story so Charles
May observes that the short story uh has
from his beginning being a hybrid form
combining both the metaphoric mode of
the old Romans and the metonymic mode of
the new realism uh as a form uh
short story uh can be uh compared uh
with uh I mean uh the short story when
compared with other genres like uh
poetry drama epic or novel um is uh
relatively uh seen as um neglected its
theoretical premises have been
formulated much later as compared to uh
other genres like poetry drama epic and
novel so as Charles me argues a genre
only truly becomes a genre only truly
comes into being uh when the conventions
that constitute it are articulated
within the larger conceptual context of
literature as a whole
unquote so uh theories about the short
story as a genre tend to be
interdisciplinary
and uh gender bending right discussions
of the short story relate the form to
myths to Folklore romance genre Theory
cognitive science narratology uh
discourse analysis as well as Visual
Arts so short story draws both on the
lyric and the novel from the very
beginning and yet uh within it it
confines it uh displays a uh a protein
diversity it can uh contain within
itself uh a wide range of uh
possibilities so uh the short story has
uh genres of its own invention within
short story uh an area of possibilities
uh can be experimented and explored uh
so the short story is those related to
the novel and the lyric and the lyric
form uh as well as the uh essay uh the
letter the cinema uh the photograph uh
as well as the visual arts painting uh
sculpture so we see for example uh
experiment
experimentation uh through through
intervie short story and photograph in
the case of uh Julio Cora's short story
and in the case of uh I mean CL Hansen
theorizes short story by looking at how
it uh uh incorporates qualities of
Visual Arts painting and uh sculpture so
due to its long standing theoretical
neglect the short story appears to be a
form uh at the margins uh contrary to
Edgar alen Po's original Vision the
short tail uh uh later on uh you know
came to be associated with the avenging
powers of the oppressed and undervalued
since it was perceived as eccentric and
uh you know coming from the bottom of
the hierarchy of Arts so Frank Conor an
Irish uh author was the first to
describe the short story as having a
subversive qualities he described short
story as a voice of the lonely
representing the voice of the lonely or
that of the outlawed figures wandering
about the fringes of society uh
according to OK Conor the short story is
a genre that never had a hero and its
protagonists have been Collective groups
of uh submerged populations uh further
we see Mary Louis Pratt connecting the
short story uh with uh you know
political gender and Regional questions
short story carrying uh you know uh
oppressions uh at you know carrying the
question of Oppression that happen at
different uh levels so Mary Mary Lewis
Pratt connects the short story um as uh
carrying the burden of oppressions from
different levels uh oppressions uh at
the level of the political the gender
and the regional and the is very much in
line with what okon um already uh says
so uh Mary Lewis PR for example says
that the form of short story flourishes
in regions where uh new groups uh you
know new social groups are seeking to
affirm their voice uh within emerging uh
National literatures or in the process
of
decolonization here Hansen endowed the
form with the capacity of expressing the
repressed knowledge of a dominant
culture all these critics therefore
argue that the short story thrives in
all such societies where there are you
know no fixed cultural framework
especially in colonial contexts and
therefore this form is linked to
Marginal people uh women um to Outsiders
of a society all of whom are plagued by
a sense of Exile and existential
isolation or existential crisis uh for
these subjects for these peripheral
subjects the Vol volatility of cult the
volatility of class structure accounts
for the genous experimental nature so we
see that till a recent past those who
theorized about the genre of short story
where not not literary critics but
practitioners of the form themselves uh
since the 1960s however there has been a
steady increase in interest in short
stories and since the late 20th century
um critical and theoretical studies of
the genre have flourished so uh we see
short story you know eminent short story
writers such as Edgar aleno Hermon
Melville Anon shov uh in the 19th
century and then Henry James flaner oor
Julio cazar udor rati among uh you know
other poets from the 20th century who
are trying to theorize the uh short
story as a form as a channel so Po's
critical comments towards the middle of
the 19th century are uh in fact
responsible for the birth of the short
story as a unique uh genre uh as the
first first short story theorist who uh
brings in uh discussion you know uh you
know so so po brings in uh discussions
about the form about the style length
design uh authorial goals and reader
effect Vis A the short story and develop
the framework within which the short
story uh is discussed uh even today uh
po placed the short story uh second only
to the lyric form in the pantheon of the
artistic uh gen status and gave it a
very high
ranking so
uh Po's main contribution uh to
theorizing short story uh was to give
the short narratives attention uh which
imbued it with the distinctive qualities
of poetry uh and I'll tell this how I
mean I I'll explain this further
uh when as we as we discuss uh the short
story uh and its form uh so how the
short story has certain uh important
similarities with uh the genre of poetry
so uh like uh we know the poem uh the
way the new critics have understood poem
the poem has its inner organization the
poem uh has its uh a well uh bounded
structure and uh a kind of uh you know
pattern uh where uh individual uh words
do not matter but the effect overall uh
is much more important in the in a
similar way uh for a short story it's uh
Compact and UniFi ified form the Compact
and unified form of a short story uh is
is very much symptomatic very much
typical of its form uh a short story in
other words is known by its uh you
compactness and its Unity uh which it
shares with the lyric uh and and which
allows the short story uh to achieve
effects that are uh unatt able in a
novel so a novel May uh you know
experiment in different ways it's a uh a
passage in time I mean the the way we
see events developing in time
concatenated in time uh entail u a lot
more experimentation that uh than that
is ever uh you know possible in a short
story a lot more experimentation than
that is ever possible in a short story
due to the scope of uh time and
temporality also the the the time the
space that a novel uh occupies uh is not
possible for a short story a short story
has to uh you know tie up its Loose Ends
within a shorter span of time uh and so
uh uh po also observes that uh a short
stories brevity and intensity
uh creates a strong undercurrent of
suggestion the language itself uh
differs um differs a lot from that of
the novel uh po was the first to
consider uh endings as uh you know
crucial elements in compositional
strategies and he defined the short
story in terms of um once's reading
experience so uh Charles May uh
important work short story theories is a
compilation of essays that combine
numerous viewpoints uh on the short
story and uh uh Ma's work opens up new
directions for further study within the
form and it is primarily responsible for
the development of a subject of the
short story Theory so in new short story
theories May Rose to prominence as a uh
uh you know
one of the seminal critics that uh
theorized short story it became a work
uh you know uh that is referred for the
study of the genre of short story and a
collection of the Frameworks that are
used uh uh for for uh readily analyzing
short story so uh with uh May's new
short story theories we find uh some of
the we as readers we have some ready
features uh that uh Define the short
story uh M's uh reality of artifi
further delivers uh a detailed critical
history to the form uh by tracing the
origins uh shape influences and
evolution of the short story form so
tracing the evolution of the short story
form uh right from his Beginnings uh to
the present dat so with this I would
like to conclude uh today's lecture and
I will meet you again for another round
of discussions thank you
[Music]
a
[Music]
