Lecture : 14 Preventive measures and advantages of galvanic corrosion

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 4, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
welcome
back to the course correction failures
and analysis today we have
lecture fourteen and today's topic will
be
ah bit of galvanic corrosion because in
the last lecture if you recall
that we talked about ah the coating of
coating philosophy whenever there is a
galvanic
corrosion situation is arising whenever
there is a galvanic situation
galvanic corrosion situation rather ah
that time we talked that ah cathodic
part
should be coated ah preferentially ah
even you can leave the anodic part still
that will be fine
ah but still the cathodic part ah
should be protect should be should be
coated in case of the
in case if you would like to go for a
coating
ah so that part needs explanation and
the second part is
we would like to see that the corrosion
ah galvanic corrosion
the advantage of galvanic corrosion so
it will be a bit
kind of
oxymoron that corrosion is advantageous
so we will see that in fact galvanic
corrosion is
advantageous
now ah this is lecture
oh sorry
corrosion failures
analysis
lecture fourteen
topic
galvanic corrosion
and second is we talk about will step
into
ah d alloying
or in other term it call it is called ah
selective bleaching
now coming to the part what we would
like to discuss is the coating
philosophy
in case there is a galvanic
two metal
corrosion so here i have to mention two
metal because galvanic corrosion
which is inherent to
preferential cathode and anode that can
all also be possible on the same metal
so but here it is
basically in case of two metal corrosion
now that time for example let us say
you have two components two parts of a
component one is
cathode
and one is anode and preferentially one
is cathode is anode
so now that time ah if one has the
possibility to code
so then its better to quote the entire
part
entire part so that would give best
solution
best protection
now if lets say the anode part cannot be
coated lets say the anode part is inside
ah inside the pipeline or something
so that time it is better to code the
cathode part
so but before that let us see what
happens if we
code the anode part only
so let us say this anode part is coated
anode part is coated cathode part is
left open
now once we have this situation this
coating let us say there is a
possibility of mechanical damage
so if there is a mechanical damage a
small segment is opened up let us say
so this segment this metal part is open
to the environment
now if it is in acidic media let us say
there is a cathodic reaction which is
this so this
cathodic reaction would happen on the
cathode surface
and let us say the anode part is
thats a zinc and cathode part lets say
copper
ok so the zinc would dissolve or
if it is a cathode part if it is ah
iron still it would be possible this
particular situation can
appear and in case of iron let us say it
is stainless steel
stainless steel fine so that time also
it is possible ok
so now this reaction is taking place on
the entire cathode surface
so that means this it needs electron so
this electron would be
provided by the anode area
and here anode section which is exposed
is this much
this much is the section which is small
anode area
and the section where cathodic reactions
are taking place
is basically large cathode
so that means the small anode area would
supply huge amount of electrons to the
cathodic reactions taking place on a
large
and cathode part and that would lead to
a
huge amount of corrosion on that exposed
part of that anode
and that would fail the system fail the
structure very quickly
so this is no no this is a
very bad protection
i will exp i will bring come back to
this particular example you will see
also
ah in the in the in the bathroom
fittings
we do miss do do we we do
commit this mistake coating the cat
anodic part and leaving the cathodic
part we will i will talk about that but
before that in order to have such
situations so that means here is a large
cathode and small anode area is coming
into picture and the large small anode
will corrode heavily
now if there is an option
to quote one part so then its better to
quote the cathode part
i will come back to this this is anode
this is cathode
now if we coat this part
if we code this part then we
do not have a space for this cathodic
reaction
because cathode this k this if it is a
stainless steel lets say
stainless steel and this is mild steel
ok so in this case also if the couple is
stainless steel and mild steel
then also this situation would arise but
in this case if it is a mild steel and
stainless steel or copper zinc
if we cover up copper area or stainless
steel area
then you do not have this reaction
rather this on this surface since it is
dipped into
into acid everywhere you will have
uniform cathodic and anodic reactions
and the corrosion mode will be uniform
rather than localized
in this case the corrosion mode would be
very localized
around this area but here it will be
spreaded and so the corrosion rate of
the anode would be less
comparatively compared to this because
this is localized so entire corrosion is
taking place at that section
so the cross section thickness would
also reduce which actually takes the
load
now so this is better better than this
so reasonable
protection ok
fine so now lets
so that means its very clear that
cathode should be pro cathode should be
coated
whenever this situation arises so this
is a kind of thumb rule
ok now coming back to this let us see
whether
this is possible in an actual situation
now if you have notice that in
bathroom fittings we have a pipeline
which is a mild steel
ok then you have pipeline fittings
which is the tap
ok and this is the tap
and this one and this one
they are connected by a small iron
insert
and this pipeline this is generally mild
steel
ok this is a small section which is a
small
like this where we have threads
and that thread is connected to the
fittings to the
main pipeline
now this main pilot nowadays people are
using plastics
people are using plastics previously
people used to use mild steel
pipe now they are using pipe plastics
but now
after that in order to protect this
small inserts
we either use ah
a kind of petroleum coating part or
we just paint this part
we paint it and this this fittings this
is the fittings
they are generally stainless steel made
stainless steel made now fittings
basically its a shiny thing and it
actually gives you
a very good look so that is what you
leave it open
and it does not corrode if you see that
fittings that it remains silent
remain it remains shiny even after
two three years it does not happen
anything but have you noticed that
if there is a problem in some pipeline
you have to open the fitting
this part this mild steel part is
heavily corroded
and thats what it is very difficult to
open sometime sometime that
entire insert comes out with the
fittings so
it is a common failure in that
particular
kind of situation so that time what
is happening there because its painted
that paint is not like a kind of
permanent paint there will be
there will be perforation and mechanical
damage is also possible
let us say a small opening is forming
small opening is formed in that case
now this is carrying water
or there could be ah it can
this water even if you consider potable
water this is
mildly corrosive even if it is mildly
corrosive
still this happens because now and this
is containing oxygen as well as h two o
and in the normal circumcision the
cathodic reaction that will take place
o two plus two h two o plus
four e equal to four o h minus
so this 4 2 4 electron that is needed
should be supplied by some anodes
now when this coating is done no problem
because that time
ah the stainless steel will have its own
protection
but inside is not protected remember the
inside part is not protected
now question is if that inside part will
have its own corrosion because to supply
and in the beginning
and this inside part is a very small
segment so the inside part
is corroding because that time this iron
two equal to fe plus two that is forming
from the inside part and since it is a
small section and the the
fitting is little larger so then
you have that differential area factor
is coming into picture
and stainless steel is acting as cathode
this is catching as cathode
where this reaction would take place and
the small insert
this insert
acting as anode ok
so now heavy corrosion is taking place
in that inserts but
now there is another in instance coming
in
that time when we have only the bottom
the inside part is
exposed to the electrolyte then this
process is taking place from the inside
part now once we have
the outside part also exposed the
corrosion because outside also there are
moistures the outside part is also
having corrosion
now since this reaction is continuing on
the cathode part
then since this is opened up
so this will also supply electron to
this sections
and finally what would happen there will
be localized corrosion also
so that means is a small segment inside
is corroding
outside is also corroding wherever that
paint is exposed
and finally you have a heavy corrosion
in that small iron inserts
ok solution you can use some plastic
inserts heavy plastic inserts
or you just lets say you have used iron
inserts
you do not paint it if you do not paint
it the problem of this
corrosion pattern would be less it will
last longer
but the best solution would be use a
plastic painted plastic plastic inserts
which connects the stainless steel
fitting to the plastic pipe
so that would solve the problem so this
is a classic example of this kind of
situation
by the small anode
which is the insert and large cathode
which is the fittings and that would
lead to
a serious galvanic corrosion
iron insert fine so this is one such
example that what is the
ah situation ah if we have cathode area
exposed and small anode area this is a
practical problem
that is faced in the bathroom fittings
now another example i would like to
mention so that part
i would request you to go to the book
written by fontana and green
corrosion engineering is a fantastic
problem that they have explained
the problem is such that
this is a large tank
and this tank is made of mild steel
m s pipe m s tank
right now after 20 years
it was replaced and while replacing
people thought that the bottom part
because bottom part is mostly
having corrosion related issues they
thought that the let us protect the
bottom part
and while doing that in the new tanks
they put
a stainless steel clad at the bottom
s s clad
ok so this i am explaining from the book
what is given in the book by written by
fontana and green
corrosion engineering for ah academic
purpose
for actually teaching purpose now
so this is
the cadet plot and this is also mild
steel
right in fact ah
its there only
this is this
this is this now
this part where stainless steel this is
top is mild steel and then
bottom is stainless steel so that part
because
people thought that is a galvanic effect
can appear so its better to
cover up the anode area so the anode
area
is covered up and it
extended till this point
ok so this is a phenolic paint
phenolic coating
right so this is the situation now what
happened
with this situation when operation
started people saw that the thing was
leaking the tank was leaking around this
job
wherever the stainless steel clad and
the mild steel is getting welded
was welded ok so that section
the leakage was taking place and the
leakage was mostly
ah around this job around that weld zone
and close by
to that well job
now they thought that and this leakage
was taking place very quickly
and they were wondering that the
phenolic coating has not been properly
made properly
so they what they did they removed the
coating
repainted ok but still
problem persisted they wanted to see
whether the galvanic effect is serious
here
so what is the first thing they thought
the coating is bad
so repenting
that actually involved lot of cost
because in order to do that
one has to do all sort of short
blastings and all those things in order
to sand blasting in order to remove the
entire paint
now that did not work
still that leakage happened this is
leakage
around that job second part they thought
that the galvanic effect is serious
so then what they did they did an
experiment
ah that experiment was in a in the same
electrolyte for the
the water that is being contained in
that particular tank
so they had a mild steel
and stainless steel ah
couple exposed it to that solution
and what happened ah not much of
galvanic effect was noticed
so in this case not much of
galvanic effect interestingly that time
when the experiment was done
equal area was taken
and they still thought that still there
is a chance of corrosion so they thought
that let us boil it
boil that water and that while boiling
the gases got removed
and the corrosiveness drops down
but still the problem persisted ok
fine ah then what was the solution then
what happened
notice that since phenolic coating is
not
impervious there is a porosity there are
things like that so the porosity because
of that porosity
water can seep in or electrolyte
can seep in
and there will be a possibility of
electrolyte metal contact
now since this bottom part which is
stainless steel part
is exposed and there are oxygens so the
cathodic reaction
was taking place on the entire
cathode area
entire cathode area so would supply
electron so now question is because of
that particular cpg and because the
because the failure of that particular
ah the imper pervious pervious nature of
that particular coating
around this zone the galvanic effect
was failed why
there are other portion also it is
getting that particular
ah metal the mild steel electrolyte
contact but still
around this joint galvanic was felt
galvanic effect was felt because
electrons so this electron those are
needed these electrons are needed here
electrons are needed here so in order to
supply that
the entire segment would supply electron
now since galvanic corrosion also has
this factor of
resistance okay so the resistance would
would prevent the electrons to move
freely from higher
move freely from if it has to migrate
over a large distance even if it is a
metallic conductor
still it will be having that effect that
resistance offered to the metallic
conductor
to the electron flow if it is a wide
distance
cathode and anode so the best
possible way to avoid that resistance
factor by the electron
is it should try to come close to that
segment
around this zone around this zone
electron would come
electron would come so the corrosion is
mostly there in this zone
in this job
ok and since we know mild steel
is an anode
and stainless steel is cathode
so mild steel wood corrode and stainless
steel will act as a cathode for the
cathodic reactions
at the same time its actually a small
area
and this is large cathode
so that is what the aggressiveness of
corrosion in that small area
anode around that region where
the clad is welded to the mild steel
on the side walls those segments is
vulnerable for
higher degree of corrosion and there
could be possibility of leakage and that
is what happened
so the solution was if you
and they what they did they coated the
bottom part
they coated the bottom part
so once it is coated bottom part now you
are actually
decreasing the area needed for the
cathodic reactions
or the preferential cathode and
preferential anode that particular
factor
it is stopped so thats what this tank
the problem is solved so thats what this
is also a typical
area ah the painting philosophy that the
cathode area is painted
leaving the anode area so this anode
area if you leave no problem but
its better to quote the entire segments
rather than only coating the bottom part
because there is no
there is a possibility we can code
entire segment
but still if you quote only the bottom
part which is a stainless steel clad
still the problem can be solved to a
great extent so this
what i wanted to explain that coating
philosophy in case there is a
possibility of galvanic effect
cathode should be coated leaving anode
unquoted so that would also still
give a very good or reasonably good
corrosion resistance or corrosion
protection
let me show you ah some example of
ah nail corrosion which is basically
galvanic corrosion ah where
if you recall that i talked about the ah
corrosion of a nail when it is inserted
in a into an object
ah the screw that but the outside of
that nail which is exposed to the
environment that does not get corroded
much
corrosion still happens but its not
heavily rusted
but if we can see the inside part
for a long way after a long use that
inside part
can get corroded heavily ok ah
let me show you some of my collections
so this is one collections if you see
this is a kind of
handle which is fitted to a door ok
wooden door
now if you carefully see that there are
two screws
one screw is here one screw is here
if you see carefully this is the one
screw ah
this is the screw and another screw is
ah here if you see this so this is the
another screw
okay now this head of the screw
in fact i could not take it out the
screw is
fastened to the so tightly fastened
because of the corrosion products
at the b at the at the where
this particular slit is inside that slit
the corrosion product is so heavy
it has ah got it it got fastened heavily
ok there is no welding remember but its
basically mechanical locking has
happened because of the corrosion
products
now if you see those screw parts the
inside part the inside part is basically
a small part which is coming out if you
see this
the the
if you see the pen position the nip
position
the screw top part is actually bottom
part is protruded here also it is a
protruded part
if you see this portrait part the
protruded part
its there is a long screw but thats
long screw the some part has actually
gone inside and little bit of part
has gone out if you see this the small
thing gone out
now if you see the top part top part is
corroded but still it maintains that
thread part
you know that that the slit part in a
screw
there will be always a small slit going
through going through the center of that
particular screw head
it is there it is still there here also
if you if you find
it is still there it is still there ah
this particular
head part so this is the head part head
part is still there
ok but the inside part is completely
almost completely corroded
now you let us understand this
particular phenomena the top part
is all the time having in contact with
the moisture and oxygen
and the part which is inside that
is having less oxygen but point is
over the period that wood would allow
little bit of moisture to slip in
and there would be little bit of oxygen
to say pin and the oxygen concentration
would decrease
as you start from this point this edge
point to the inside of that particular
wood
so that means the differential aeration
cell is forming the inside part
the extreme inside part is having the
least
oxygen content and the top part is
having the maximum oxygen current
the top part would become cathode the
inside part which is
very inside deep inside the particular
wooden
stuff that is actually anode so the
corrosion would be
concentrated in that anode part and
cathode part would be the top part so
that so the top part
is actually maintaining its shape as
well as its the groove is also
we are able to see that groove but the
inside part
is almost eaten away because the
corrosion and this is a classic example
of
differential aeration cell ok so the
inside is having less oxygen anode
outside more oxygen cathode so cathode
would not corrode much
the bottom part would corrode high so
now another
so this is let me show you another
example this is the wooden stuff
it was see i generally collect materials
from ah
i look for for this kind of examples
look for this kind of examples wherever
i find such situations i
take those situate those things and then
store in my
bag just to demonstrate it to my
students
now here also if you see this this is
the wooden thing which was
fixed to a kind of object now if you see
the top part of this particular
screw the top part you see this top part
still its corroded yes it its corroded
its not
like shiny but the groove is completely
visible if you see the groove this
groove is there
ok but if you see the inside part
it is not for a long duration use it was
maybe a couple of months and then what
happen if you see this
screw part inside part the thread of the
screw has completely gone
if you see the thread of the screw is
completely gone but at the same time the
corrosion that rust deposit is also
there
ok so that rust deposit the rust deposit
is also there
and the truss deposit is forming because
of the com differential aeration for
cell formation the top part is
exposed to the environment lot of oxygen
so cathode area would
form here and the bottom part which is
inserted into one another object that
bottom part
is not getting sufficient oxygen so it
will become anode
so then differential aeration cell
formation the bottom part
the insert inside part would corrode
high the bottom part
top part will get corroded will get
protected okay
so this is one classic example of
differential error
differential ah different aeration cell
formation
and preferential cathode and anode the
previous part also
it is basically a preferential cathode
and preferential anode
the inside of an of the nail is actually
anode
and outside is cathode so this example i
just wanted to show you
ah for your understanding that galvanic
corrosion
now coming to the second part what has
been said
is basically advantage of
galvanic corrosion
now one advantage is use of sacrificial
anode
fine so this is used like widely
talked about example is galvanization
where zinc coating
on top of steel or mild steel you can
say normalcy
now this is one there could be
possibility of use of magnesium
or aluminium for sacrificial anode
and one common example of magnesium
anode
is in our geyser ok so if you see modern
day geyser
its actually having a magnesium rod
inserted
on top of it because nowadays this
geezers are made of
stainless steel normal steel okay
stainless steel you can use
but in fact that previously it used to
ah it was made by a copper ah shading
copper copper sheet but now it is
stainless is still
still made so thats what the magnesium
rod is inserted which gives the
protection
to the steel casing of that giza
in fact sometimes you might notice that
when you take the water out
it actually ah smells bad so that
actually
that bad initial first time say for
example you have heated the
water and you left it for some day
the first flow of water you would see
that
its having little smell so that smell is
coming because of the magnesium
corrosion products
ok so this is another example so these
are
used these are used for ah sacrificial
anode protection of pipelines
cross country pipelines they are
protected by this sacrificial anodes
fine so the another use is dry cell
battery
ok so there what happens you have a
casing
which is made of zinc and then
you have a graphite
cathode so this is cathode
fine and this would so this is the
casing
which is zinc casing which is anode
fine and now what happens
here you have nh4
cl these are the things that are added
zinc chloride
and manganese oxide so these are the
ingredients we have in this basically a
kind of pest
and now what happens these are the
following reactions that take place zinc
two e zinc plus plus which happens in
the zinc surface
this is anodic reaction
fine and then the cathodic reactions so
then
two nh ah
in fact nh4 minus
which is coming from here reacts with
two electrons which is taken by this
it will go to ammonia
plus h2 and then manganese oxide
it reacts with this hydrogen which forms
m n two o three plus h two o
so these are the reactions that take
place so now you see
the electrons this is the battery
voltage it gives you a
certain voltage fine so now
ah what happens this electrons
are supplied by zinc and that electrons
are taken by this reaction so these
cathodic reactions happens on this
surface so its a galvanic preferential
cathode preferential anode
but it actually gives me electricity ok
so the battery is used for that
so these are the two advantages i can
think of
we can talk about the advantages of
corrosion in a
subsequent lectures in the subsequent
lectures when we talk about ah d
alloying you will see that ah actually
ah
this d alloying ah factor can be used to
make
ah exotic materials so ah
lets stop here we will talk about ah d
alloying in the subsequent
in in the next lecture we will start
with the alloying fine
thank you
[Music]
do
[Music]
you
