Lecture 37 : Cavitation corrosion, Fretting corrosion and their preventive measures

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 4, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
hello everyone so we will start lecture
37
the course is corrosion failures and
analysis
we have been talking on erosion
corrosion then we started talking on
cavitation damage
and today we will talk about ah some of
the protective measures one can take to
prevent materials from cavitation damage
and then we will
start discussing on
ah start discussing ah
fretting corrosion which is also falling
under
ah erosion corrosion
so the course is
corrosion failures and analysis
and lecture thirty seven
topic will
control corrosion
with the spatial emphasis on
cavitation
and ah fretting corrosion
fetting corrosion now ah if we ah
if we have we have seen that the
cavitation damage happens when
bubble collapses
on top of a metal surface
and that leads to
micro jet impact on the metal surface
and
also the shock waves so that lead to
deformation on the material
and that deformation
can damage the passive film
before it gets repassivated
or it can deform and then that deform
surface can
go through little bit of extra
corrosion
process corrosion damage or corrosion
degradation
before another bubble forms
and this bubble is not air bubble this
is
happening due to
boiling of
fluid and if we consider water system
then boiling of water
and that happens because the
decrease in pressure and if we could
recall the phase diagram
as well as
the pressure line that is existing
ah in the suction
eye region as well as discharge region
of an impeller impeller
of a centrifugal pump where the impeller
motion
gives rise to that pressure difference
at different points
that means suction eye as well as
discharging
and those ah
those
pressure lines if it intersects the
vapor pressure line
of that particular liquid or that
particular water
at that temperature of the water then
definitely
boiling happens and
bubble can collapse now if we recall
just
ah
so if we could see that this is the ah
pressure basis distance
and this is a suction zone
this is the i zone
and this is the shear zone so now
ah
this is suction
of a pump
so the
pressure line means i am considering
this
and the vapor pressure line
ah
which is this one which is p
t and correspondingly if i draw phase
diagram pressure versus temperature of
water
so this is the diagram this is solid
this is liquid this is vapor or steam
and if we consider one atmosphere
pressure
then
corresponding boiling temperature is 100
degree celsius but it can also boil lets
say this is my temperature what i am
considering here the temperature of the
fluid and that boiling temperature
boiling pressure would be this
so this is p t
now
ah if the ah
pressure reaches
p t then definitely ah and if that
pressure go goes below this so at this
point liquid and vapor they coexist
because that is an equilibrium
now if the pressure goes down then steam
forms goes up liquid form so that means
between suction i and discharge
points
if this line
the if the pressure drops below this
particular point then definitely boiling
happens and if pressure goes beyond that
point
this point then
those ah bubbles that boiling happens
and then bubble forms steam bubbles
forms and that steep bubbles will
collapse now if this is the situation
definitely no bubble will form because
ah its not able to reach to that
equilibrium
boiling pressure at that temperature of
the liquid
but if it is
like this
this is let us say p t prime
let us say
if we draw another pressure
temperature diagram so this is the
diagram
now if this is my t prime and this is my
pressure
p t prime
so now if this is that condition co
pertaining to this
then definitely
ah
at this point boiling happens when the
pressure drops below
ah
this pressure
and then bubble forms
and that water when it goes to the
discharge on pressure goes up
and then at this point ah those
boil bob bubbles that have formed
containing steam they will collapse
because the pressure is going
above this
initially when
suction to i
suction to i
pressure drops
boiling happens bubble forms
and then this part is from i to
discharge
pressure increases
bubbles collapse so that way at this
point actually
the cavitation happens that impact
happens and that impact happens because
you have this bubble and that bubble
collapses like this
and then the micro jet
hit the surface at this point at a very
high speed and then that gives a huge
pressure close to around 500 mega pascal
that can deform the surface and even if
it is a passivating metal that can
ah
remove the passive layer
and before the another bubble forms it
can repassive it if it is a strongly
passivating metal so the by that time we
have little bit of material loss so that
is the loss of metal through cavitation
so now if we have to find out ways to
prevent it
ah first of all if we try to look at
some of the preventive measure
first is of course better material
because anyhow we cannot stop bubble
formation if we try to create a negative
pressure in order in case of pumps or in
case of propellers where propellers move
at a high speed so that
the shape moves in the forward direction
so we have with that that bubbles will
be created so in order to avoid that
ah cavitation due to bubble collapse so
we have to have a better material better
material in the sense that stainless
steel
stainless steel has got a very good ah
cavitation resistance
compared to
ah carbon steel ok it has rather a very
extremely high cavitation resistance
compared to
carbon steel
now then we can use coating
let us say a sterilite coating
then
an austeni stainless steel means even we
can use
precipitation hardened stainless steel
ah
this is normal one even three zero four
or three one six
so these kind of ah stainless steels one
can use ah
then precipitation hardening
nickel chromium alloy
ah like in conel
six two five
or seven one eight
people can use ah
hastelloy which is nickel
molybdenum
chromium alloy
hastelloy it is a astralis c
ah
people can use monel
nickel
copper aluminium
even
one can use
manganese bronze
and where cavitation is not that severe
ok so then in that case in the mild
cases people can also use carbon steel
so these are the kind of better
materials one can think of ah
second is ah
operating
pump
beyond
ah boiling pressure
at that
liquid temperature
ah if we try to understand this
statement so for example
in this case
in this case
ah i have the boiling pressure ah which
is cutting
this suction i and discharge lines
ah in such a way that
boiling and
collapse of bubbles are both possible
but if the
this line this entire this particular
pressure line within the pump
lies above the
pressure where boiling happens
at that
temperature of the liquid for example if
the temperature of the liquid so this is
my boiling pressure
now if all those pressure lines in the
eye suction as well as discharge they
are above that pressure line definitely
boiling possibility is not there
now third point
ah if you see if we recall that once
deformation happens let us say it was a
flat surface and after deformation there
is a small dip ok
and this dip can provide nucleating
sites for bubble formation or bubble
nucleation so here another bubble can
form so this particular
dip is possible because there is a small
deformation but in the beginning if the
surface is rough
then definitely that formation
nucleation of bubble will be much easier
so smooth surface
ah
that reduces
cavitation
maintenance of smooth surface
ah adding
inhibitors
ah chemicals like nitrates ah
chromates
those actually ah avoid cavitation
so this kind of inhibitors which is
chemical added
to
prevent corrosion
cathodic protection is
another way out
in that regard sacrificial zinc or
magnesium pieces can be used
now here if the
cathodic reaction product is hydrogen
that hydrogen gas on the surface this is
the surface that hydrogen gas can create
a cushion
for those
bubbles
which are forming
ah and if they burst
so that bursting due to bursting there
is a shock wave so that shock waves
can be ah absorbed to a great extent by
the cushion of that hydrogen layer
hydrogen gas layer that is forming due
to the cathodic reaction product which
is basically cathodic reaction product
so this is one way to prevent
so these are couple of methods people
can think of
and there are modern routes for example
there are reports like ah
sex
design periphery design modification
design modification means
[Music]
if we
try to
operate
for example propeller if we consider a
propeller that propeller when propeller
moves ah there is a trail of bubbles
that forms
in youtube there are nice videos on this
if one can go and look at it when
propeller moves propeller rotates there
is a trail of bubbles
which are
moving along with the
along with the ship
now ah
if we reduce the speed of that propeller
definitely bubble formation would be
less
because the pressure difference would be
less but if we reduce that
ah speed of the rotation then definitely
it will reduce that it is the thrust
which actually taking the ship
forward
but in order to maintain that same
thrust at the same time it can be
reduced the speed can be reduced the
rotation speed which actually avoids
bubble formation or the pressure
difference
ah that can be done if ah
number of blades can be increased so
there are reports that ah by increasing
the number of blades
and there are other design modifications
ah which can actually reduce the speed
of rotation
which or in in other way which reduces
the pressure difference but the thrust
is maintained so
so that is one way of doing ah so
basically a design modification of that
particular ah propeller so these are
couple of ways one can think of reducing
cavitation damage and if you want to see
cavitation
you can go to google you just search
gravitation damage you will find
thousands of images and
some of the images you would notice that
ah
even the blades of the
impeller is completely washed off
because ah the dents those have formed
because of this micro jet formation and
deformation
as well as in parallel the corrosion is
taking place
so that will actually ah
take off
the take away or the chip of that
particular material
and that
if that material goes off definitely
the thrust is reducing
so the pump will reduce its efficiency
the amount of water that it has to
discharge will definitely be less
at the expense of energy what we are
consuming due to the running of that
pump
now ah so those are the kind of serious
defects that can be observed
ah in case of cavitation damage
now let us look at another form of
erosion corrosion which is fretting
corrosion
see if we recall we have discussed in
the beginning of
erosion corrosion that fretting happens
when
two meeting surfaces are tight fitted ok
and there is a small very small even few
microns
level of amplitude of vibration so that
particularly to a kind of fretting
action between those interfaces
now if we have corrosives then it can
also lead to ah corrosion of that
particular thing now in this in the case
of fretting attack
it might happen in the dry condition
also so dry condition definitely there
will be a possibility of oxidation
and ah oxidation is nothing but ah
corrosion because when we char check
about oxidation ah
oxidation why we are saying oxidation is
a corrosion that means
we have oxygen removing two electron
going to
o minus minus and metal
sorry this is accepting two electron and
metal
leaving
two electron then metal plus plus
and these two react and form metal oxide
now this can happen on the metal surface
if we see the oxide layer this is m o
layer
and this reaction happens
at this surface
and this reaction happens at this
surface so there depending on
ah the which one is diffusing in or out
accordingly it will be decided where
this reaction happens and where this
reaction happens
now ah in order to and that particular
thing has been talked in previous if we
go to corrosion 2 lecture series
corrosion 2 you will see that on
oxidation this kind of mechanism has
been explained but if we see that this
particular if we have if we see that ah
this particular
if metal
leaves two electron and metal plus plus
ion is forming so that means this
surface becomes anode
because this one is anodic reaction
now this is cathodic reaction its a
electron acceptance accepting oxygen
acceptance accepting ah two electron and
forming o double minus so this is
cathodic
ok so now this particular part is
anode and since cathodic reaction
happens on this plane
which is cathode
and this is metal part
this is oxygen gas part
now this metal
can
migrate
and reach to this surface and then
combine with o minus and form m o so
that time this particular interface will
grow
other way around if this oxygen
ion that can move so this is metal line
moving this is oxygen ion moving so it
can come to this surface
and here metal ion and oxygen ion can
combine and form metal oxide so that
time this particular section will grow
ok this particular oxide will grow into
the metal and in this case oxide will
grow into the oxygen gas layer
so now you see that there are ah
there are ah
four components here and for
electrochemical reactions at the
corrosion reactions we have must have
four components one is cathode anode
electrolyte and
ah conductor now if we see that this
ions are moving through this metal oxide
so this is acting as
electrolyte
now if this
metal ion is forming so this is but this
reaction is taking place at two electron
so that can go through that
metal metal oxide and can reach to this
section and then it combines with this
oxygen atom forms oxygen to minus
so that means it is also acting like ah
acting as
conductor
so that means all four components are
there this is one
this is two this is three this is four
so that means it is an electrochemical
reaction and corrosion is nothing but an
electrochemical reaction so this is also
degradation of metal but it happens
without the presence of
hydro h2o this is not taking place in
aqueous medium now ah this fretting
action can happen when
there are three criterias of course
one is
the interfaces
this is criteria
for fretting
interfaces ah
must be under load
so that means if we
take this two surfaces
so this is two surfaces they are under
load so they are tightly fitted
second is
there should be a vibration
there should be a vibration and that
vibration could be very small few
microns
now ah
third part is
when this vibration and load both are
taking place
that both the actions that means load
as and vibration
should
[Music]
create a situation of deformation
or where
leads to
lead to
deformation
or where
ok so that must be this three condition
must be made
and then of course you have this all
three condition all three conditions are
necessary for fretting
now along with that if you add
corrosion action
then definitely we call it as a fretting
corrosion
now there are two ah modes of fretting
attack one is if we try to see the modes
fretting corrosion
one is ah
wear oxidation
and second is
oxidation wire
now if we try to look at
two
mechanism this is wear oxidation
if we try to look at two meeting
surfaces that meeting surfaces
we cannot make it ah
there will be definitely some ah
wavy nature
on that on that meeting surfaces
aspirations would be there
now
if the surface is like this
this is one surface the other surface
could be like this
so these are the two surfaces and if you
carefully notice
that this is one point this is another
point
this is one point this is one point
where
those metal surfaces are are actually
meeting
at the point of reaches
ok
now since it is under load
it is under load
and there could be a small degree of
ah friction that initial friction so
that will lead to a some sort of heat
and that load as well as heat that can
cold wet this section so this is
sections are basically
cold welded
due to
heat plus load
and this heat is coming due to fretting
action ok now once they are
welded this is cold well because the
temperature
may not go ah beyond that 0.5 t m
t m is the melting point ok so now that
time
ah we have
this welded portion if the second stage
this is the first stage let us say
first stage and the second stage
if rating action again occurs
that cold weighted portion
may get
chipped off ok so that particular action
leads to a small debris formation so if
this portion
this portion actually breaks off so
we have ah this moves little forward and
this most little backward so this
portion will break off and that break
off will lead to
ah small small particle formation so
this is breaking off
breaking of ah welded portion
and that leads to small small
small
particle formation
since this is exposed to ah atmosphere
of course there will be oxygen
and the small particles when they are
forming because of the floating action
there will be a lot of heat
so this heat plus oxygen
they will oxidize the third stage
oxidation of small
particle ok because of heat and oxygen
and that is what at the feet at the foot
of it there will be small small tiny
oxide particles
ok so here we have
debris oxide debris and that debris is
coming due to the breaking of of that
welded portion and particle formation
and oxidation of small particles
now this particular thing continues so
that means
this will continue so again the next
cycle another
ridge portion will
ah have
will be will get cold welded and the
second fretting action they will get
chipped off
small particle formation oxidation of
the small particles forming oxide debris
so like that way it keeps on ah removing
the material and this is typically
ah
first oxidation first gold rolling is
taking place and then where action is
coming into picture so this where action
is coming into become then oxidation so
thats what it is called wear oxidation
ok because where action is coming first
and then oxidation of those worn out
particles this is about wear oxidation
so there is one more which is oxidation
where
where oxidation happens first
now
if it is same thing the interface is
rough
ok those are micro
roughness
very small ah
protrusions are possible on the surface
now those protozoan are meeting
so like that way this is the another
interface
now this is under load
now this happens this oxidation where
happens in case of passivating metal
now if we try to see the
ah
if we make it little thicker that
interface
so this is a thick one now we have ah
oxide layer so that oxide layer is
forming
just below that interfacing
layer
so this layer is forming because it is a
highly
passivating metal
so this blue one is that oxide layer
fine
now if the fitting action happens
this region so where they are in contact
they will chip off that oxide will chip
up so now if i try to look at
this part and zoom it
its actually
like this
and initially it was like this so this
is contact point
now
this is the contact point
and
oxide layer is there
next such section
we have
this flat portion is forming
an oxide layer will stay here
center part will not have any oxide
layer because oxide layer got chipped up
because of the fretting action
now
since this material is
highly ah
passivating nature and there is oxygen
so it can react and that heat is there
because it is a severe wear action so
floating action which leads to little
lot of heat and that oxygen can react
and from passive layer or the oxide
layer on top of it
and the second time
again
this if they are tightly fitted let us
say if this is tightly fitted now
tightly fitted now now everywhere we
have
oxide layer
after getting chipped off
the second time also
this will again chip off like this
this is ship up like this and then again
ah this oxide layer would form ah
between two fretting action ok so like
that way ah oxide particle will also
form in the root of it in this portion a
lot of oxide debris will
accumulate
and this oxide debris is not the because
of the oxidation of
particles metal particles its basically
the removal of oxide layer
during the fretting action and then
again the oxide layer reforms
so that way the
oxidation happens first and then the
wear of that oxide layer happens so
that's what it is called oxidation wire
now it is very difficult to ah
isolate these two mechanism ah mostly
both the mechanism happens together so
together they happen
ok because its lot of heat due to
fretting and there is oxygen so thats
what that both the mechanism could be
possible and cold welding is also
possible so thats what
this two mechanisms are is very
difficult to
ah isolate from each other so we better
its basically combination of both the
processes lead to a flattening corrosion
ok now ah if we try to find out ways to
protect
protective roots
methods
now
if you see that both the cases both the
mechanism where oxidation or oxidation
where we have friction in friction
coming into play now thats what if we
use lubricant
so then definitely the lubricant can
reduce friction
and that will definitely reduce fretting
corrosion floating damage
now it also gives you another advantage
ah since you could see that
ah after where in case of air oxidation
oxidation of
ah tiny metal particles happen
and whereas happens and whereas in
oxidation where ah first oxide layer
gets chipped off and then further
oxidation of the metal surface exposed
metal surface happens
so that way
ah
the flatting action continues
so in this case
also it reduces entry of
entry of
oxygen to the
fretting surfaces
ok now second is smooth surfaces
smooth surface means definitely those
ridges will not get number of ridges
will be less
and they will also get a much lesser
load ah to get welded or to get
that metal if the oxide layer is
covering that metal surface the oxide
surface would not get a chance to get
chipped off because the smooth surface
will have less number of aspirations so
now this smooth surface also avoid also
leads to a
lower
coefficient of friction
so that is also possible so friction
force will be less
so the smooth surface can also prevent
fretting ah now third is better material
and here its not about one material both
the materials are to be considered
because for example in case of fish
plates we have rail material as well as
the
fish plate itself so between that fish
plate and the rail we have fretting
surface now better material we have to
have a combination of those
materials for example if we try to see
ah
let us say one can use hard stool steel
versus
on
hard tool steel
and now you see this hard word is there
so that means the
harder the surface higher will be the
wire resistance that is a kind of
ah thumb rule but it is not always true
but at this moment if we only see that
hard surface the harder the surface
better would be the wire resistance
which will be the fretting resistance
but that is not all the time too but
this is in general i am saying
now ah
this is one better material means let us
say hardened
carbon steel
and
harden
carbon steel now when we talk about
hardened carbon steel hardened hardening
can be can be possible if we do cold
rule
cold rolling ah cold rolled steel or
ah cold rolls cold rolling is one of the
process to increase the hardness of a
carbon steel so that is one sometimes
it can be
gaskets can be used
rubber gaskets so what it helps what it
does it actually prevents oxygen to
enter into the fretting surfaces so
thats what oxidation is avoided
so these are the couple of routes which
way
one can think of
reducing
fretting
damage
so let me stop here so we will
continue
our discussion on stress corrosion
cracking from the next class onwards
so on the fretting ah on the on on the
erosion corrosion we have talked about
general election corrosion then we
talked about cavitation and then finally
floating corrosion so ah
erosion is ah to some extent complete
ah let us move to ah move on to another
topic which is test corrosion from the
next class onwards till then thank you
[Music]
do
[Music]
you
