Lecture 16- Pride and Prejudice V: Theme, Form & Style - II

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
33 Video Views·Jun 7, 2024
In this lecture, we continue our close reading of the opening pages of the novel, focusing on theme and style.
About the course:
In this course "The English Novel: Interdisciplinary Approaches", students will learn how to approach novels from the perspective of authorial backgrounds, narratology, adaptation theory, and new work in literary theory, including environmental and medical humanities. This course will imbibe the students with the most sophisticated and innovative skills of interpreting novels, and a critical appreciation of novels.
[Music]
[Music]
hello Learners and welcome to the fifth
lecture in the module on Pride and
Prejudice in the previous lecture I
discussed briefly the opening sentences
of the novel and
I gave a sense of how Jane Austin uses
the literary device of irony to describe
grave social
inequality uh specifically the lack of
opportunities available to women in 18th
and 19th century England uh with regard
to owning property and
having Financial well-being more
generally this inequality this problem
that existed in the Society of her time
was described in a way that was very
humorous and and very stylish there was
uh a sentence in which the readers were
jokingly told that when a wealthy man
moves into a neighborhood the families
and and especially the parents of young
single women uh begin to think of that
uh wealthy young man as the property of
one of their
daughters this is an instance of uh
irony at work because the reality that
the sentence is referring to is the
inability of women and especially those
single women to own property however it
despite this inequality and in fact
because of this inability of of women to
own property they began to view marriage
as the only means of securing a safe and
sustainable future and therefore it led
to a predatory gaze with which uh single
men with uh
were seen as the property or potentially
as the property of these these families
whose daughters might profitably marry
this uh this uh single man now let us
continue reading uh these opening
sentences and see
how from this opening the novel sets up
its action uh establishes its character
s and generally uh creates an engaging
story for the reader now the first
sentence which I read out in the
previous lecture are uh spoken or
uttered or written by the omniscient
narrator uh immediately after this
sentence we hear a character's voice the
narrator has mentioned that people think
in a certain way that
for families in these Villages a single
man man with Fortune appears to be the
potential property of their daughters
immediately after this the narrator
stops uh goes silent and lets characters
speak the first character says this and
and I'm going to read uh from Jane
Austin's words now my dear Mr Bennett
said his lady to him one day have you
heard that NE Field park is let at last
Mr Bennett replied that he had not but
it is returned she for Mrs long has just
been here and she told me all about it
Mr Bennett made no answer do not you
want to know who has taken it cried his
wife
impatiently you want to tell me and I
have no objection to hearing it this is
Mr
Bennett this was invitation enough says
the
narrator why my dear you must must know
Mrs long says the netherfield is taken
by a young man of large Fortune from the
north of England that he came down on
Monday in a chain and Fort to see the
place and was so much delighted with it
that he agreed with Mr Morris
immediately that he is to take
possession before
mlus and some of his servants are to be
in the house by the end of next
week what is his name
Bingley is he married or single oh
single my dear to be sure a single man
of large Fortune 4 or 5,000 a year what
a fine thing for our
girls how so how can it affect them My
Dear Mr Bennett how can you be so
tiresome you must know that I'm thinking
of his marrying one of them is that his
design in settling here design nonsense
how can you talk so but it is very
likely that he may fall in love with one
of them and therefore you must visit him
as soon as he comes so you can see how
in the first page before the reader has
completed reading the first chapter of
the novel The Reader gets a sense of the
dynamic at stake in this
novel the dynamic may be summarized thus
uh there is a character uh Mrs Bennett
who is striving who is uh hoping
fervently and and wishing that through a
a quirk of circumstance through
a series of coincidences or accidents or
otherwise a chain of events which is not
designed or or scripted but is uh but
occurs through the natural order of
things through some such
Arrangement this uh this young and
Wealthy single man who has arrived uh in
the nearabout of their town of their
place of living uh falls in love with
one of her daughters that is what she
wants that is her primary goal and
intention uh as a parent and especially
as mother she cares deeply for the
well-being of her children and
especially her
daughters and uh she's she's very aware
that as uh women as as girls the only
way for them to have a secure future is
to marry a man with a great deal of
wealth uh she knows these facts and
therefore when she hears that a wealthy
man has is about to move into their
neighborhood she ferly hopes that uh
this uh event can lead to another event
which is uh his falling in love with one
of her daughters now the interesting
thing to note in the scene is that the
narrator the the omniscient allseeing
third person narrator whom Jane Austin
deploys to convey this information to
readers arranges so that we learn about
this desire and this um uh somewhat
difficult situation in which Mrs Bennett
is from a conversation that she has with
Mr Bennett her husband
it is important to note how Mr Bennett
plays ignorant he pretends to be
ignorant he he pretends to not
understand the source or the reason for
his wife's excitement and uh anxiety and
a combination of uh excitement and
anxiety which generally causes her to be
in a somewhat agitated State and uh he
he does not do this out out of uh out of
uh sheer lack of understanding or
knowledge uh it will become very clear
to readers later on that Mr Bennett is
is very well aware very shrewd very
sharp very Discerning
and uh he enjoys he he derives some
pleasure from uh forcing or from hearing
Mrs Bennett's wife clarify the things
that uh she takes for granted and she
hopes that others would also take for
granted uh what are these things what I
just explained uh how this situation can
turn into a a happy ending uh can can
lead to the beginning of a new future
for one of her daughters now she Mrs
Benner that is to say uh requests and uh
places a a very strong injunction on Mr
Bennett to go and call on this this
gentleman whose name is Mr Bingley and
uh to ensure that the families begin a
correspondence that they begin a social
intercourse they they meet for lunch uh
they meet for uh evenings out they
they're invited to dances and so
on we are introduced to these characters
uh that is this uh rich wealthy young
man who has just moved into this Country
Village along with another character in
the very next chapter in which there is
a ball and um a lot of people meet each
other uh in this uh chapter the the
narrator introduces both this man who
who whose uh imminent arrival has
produced such agitation in in Mrs
Bingley and another character
um Mr Darcy um I I want to read the
paragraph which introduces Darcy because
it says something very crucial about how
this novel invites us to view
individuals and human beings uh what
kind of demarcations social uh factors
economic factors and generally how this
novel identifies human beings as
characters so at the ball from the
perspective of the reader uh for the
benefit of of the reader who is not
there the narrator describes people this
is what Austin's narrator writes Mr
Bingley was good-looking and
gentlemanlike he had a pleasant
countenance and easy unaffected manners
his sisters were fine women with an air
of decided fashion his brother-in-law Mr
Hurst merely looked the gentleman but
his friend Mr Darcy soon drew the
attention of the room by his fine tall
person handsome features noble mean and
the report which was in general
circulation within 5 minutes after his
entrance of his having 10,000 a
year now the structure of this last
sentence is crucial to understanding
something u a very fundamental truth
about the social universe
that Jane Austin's novel describes and
the the universe which lays down The
rules for interactions within human
beings uh the sentence Begins by
describing qualities
of the individual uh material qualities
of his uh of his face of his shape of
the way he appears and ends by
mentioning a number uh 10,000 a year uh
two numbers if you uh if one is being
specific the the first number is the the
amount of money that uh he earns or or
he gets and the second number is the the
period over which he gets that money and
and the combined effect of these two
numbers is that
they situate this individual in the
social and economic hierarchy of 18th
century England right and uh the number
£10,000 a year places Mr Dary at the
very top of that hierarchy right uh we
have just read a passage in which we we
learned that Mr Bingley the the other
young man wealthy uh single and wealthy
young man who is just move to this
neighborhood uh has about 4 to 5,000 a
year so this is uh even more uh exciting
or or should be even more exciting and
and should produce even more
agitation anxiety and excitement uh for
someone like Mrs Bennett who was uh
excited enough who could barely contain
her excitement at knowing that Mr
Bingley has four four or 5,000
year and so the the signs all point in
One Direction that Mr Darcy's arrival uh
as an invite as a friend of Mr bengle
should produce even more
excitement however that's not quite what
happens right and as the REM uh as the
remainder of this paragraph makes it
clear uh and and let us read to find out
what is the consequence or or what is
the effect of these two kinds of
information on on one hand the
appearance of Mr dasi which is quite
pleasing and generally very agreeable
and um on the other hand his U his
economic position which is also very
very intimidating and I'm sure very
exciting for potential sutors the
gentleman pronounced him to be a fine
figure of a man the ladies declared he
was much much handsomer than Mr Bingley
and he was looked at with great
admiration for about half the evening
till his manners gave a disgust which
turned the tide of his of his popularity
for he was discovered to be proud to be
above his company and above being
pleased and not all his large estate in
derbish could then save him from having
a most forbidding disagreeable
countenance and being un worthy to be
compared with his friend what we see in
this passage is um a key introduction
and the use of a word which gives the
novel its title that word is is proud uh
and I'm sure uh attentive readers will
have noticed uh how this word produces a
very strange and um
disconcerting effect on readers who have
so far been predisposed to admire and
appreciate this character right so this
quality of uh Pride uh the inclination
that this person has to be
proud this counters all the good work
that his appearance and his wealth have
done so far in producing a favorable
reception for him in this country
Village right
um not only is is he not liked but he is
especially disliked because despite
being a good friend of uh of Mr Bingley
he has the exact he has exactly the
opposite
characteristics uh and how is uh Mr
Darcy's prde understood and
demonstrated he seems to be above his
company above being pleased and not all
his large estate in derisha could then
save him from having a most forbidding
disagreeable countenance so we see
something quite contradictory happening
here so far we have been given to
believe that wealth alone
determines the the value uh the the
pleasantness and the worth that that is
associated with the man right uh so far
we've we've been given to believe that
uh if a single man is wealthy then
that's all he needs to do to attract uh
a legion of single women who will all
want to secure his hand in marriage uh
here however we read something else we
we find that it is not enough to be
wealthy in fact even though Mr Darcy has
a greater uh amount of weth and his
estate in Daisha right and it's it's a
supposedly a very large estate so far we
have not had any direct evidence from
the narrator or any of the characters
who've visited or seen this estate but
uh his reputation has traveled with him
and from this reputation rumors and heay
the narrator is able to confirm with the
with some degree of confidence that he
has a large estate which ensures that he
has that very large income of £10,000 a
year uh despite having this very large
income his uh personal Behavior his his
attitude and in particular his pride uh
undoes everything that would make him
attractive and he's considered uh
disagreeable forbidding and generally
unworthy
now immediately after this chapter we
read a chapter in which the daughters of
Mrs Bennett and uh among these daughters
there are two of them who whom on whom
the the novel focuses our attention in
Greater detail they are Jane and
Elizabeth Elizabeth as as we'll soon
find out uh will be the the protagonist
of the
novel and uh the narrator
will provide Elizabeth with a great deal
of
authority the narrator will trust
Elizabeth's perspective because
Elizabeth's perspective will come
closest to describing uh what is
objective and and what is true in the
chapter immediately after the ball we
witness a conversation between Elizabeth
and
Jane and uh in this
conversation the two sisters exchang
notes on what they had perceived in the
character
of of these guests uh who are these
guests uh Mr Bingley who is about to
move into the neighborhood uh his friend
Mr Dari who's traveled with him and U Mr
bingley's sisters right uh now at back
home from this ball Elizabeth and Jane
are talking and Jane has just made a
comment about how Mr Bingle sisters are
quite agreeable uh women and in response
this is what Elizabeth um has to say and
and think uh in the words of Austin's
narrator Elizabeth listened in silence
but was not
convinced their behavior that is Mr ble
sisters their behavior at the assembly
had not been calculated to please in
general and with more quickness of
observation and less pliancy of temper
than her
sister and with a judgment too
unassailed by any attention to herself
she was very little disposed to approve
them they were in fact very fine ladies
not deficient in Good Humor when they
were pleased nor in the power of being
agreeable when where they chose it but
proud and
conceited they were rather handsome they
had been educated in one of the first
private seminaries in town had a Fortune
of
£20,000 were in the habit of spending
more than they ought and of associating
with people of rank were therefore in
every respect entitled to think well of
themselves and meanly of others they
were of a respectable family in the
north of
England a circumstance more deeply
impressed on their memories than that
their brothers fortune and their own had
been acquired by
trade uh this
long description of Elizabeth's uh
critical thinking or her ability to
weigh a great deal of information
background information contextual
information before reaching a conclusion
or before granting her approval to
whether or not she admired or liked a
certain
individual uh gives us a sense of how
the narrator approaches Human
Relationships right the the novel is
written in a time when there was a great
deal of emphasis on propriety on not
being kind or being proper but uh
showing that one was in fact
kind the novel is written when people
set a great deal of uh emphasis on on
appearances and then therefore it
becomes even more important for
individual observers to to use the
critical faculty of thinking uh how much
one is uh displaying and and and what is
truly uh meaningful or or an act of true
kindness Elizabeth is a very Discerning
Observer of human
interactions and therefore
she she observes very clearly and she
critically analyzes what these bingly
sisters were doing and her conclusion is
that the bingly sisters had
everything in their favor they occupied
a material and social position which
made it easy for them to display a
certain kind of attitude and behavior
towards others right and she calls that
uh Pride right she the the last sentence
of the first half of this paragraph the
the words proud and conceited are used
right
and Elizabeth understands uh Elizabeth
forgives Elizabeth uh accepts that for a
certain kind of individual born and
raised in a certain way a certain
Behavior a certain kind of behavior
comes
natural and uh in the case of the bingly
system going to private seminaries
having a Fortune of
£20,000 Etc these things uh necessitated
almost automated uh a kind of behavior
right and so there was nothing to admire
U but but of course there was nothing to
to uh dislike in in this Behavior either
and so we see how Jane is uh so much
more forgiving and Elizabeth is uh so
much more Discerning uh in in this
conversation the last sentence uh
of this the summary of Elizabeth's uh
understanding and U consideration is is
important for understanding class in
this
novel now in Elizabeth's view the the
benglish sisters came from a respectible
family in the north of England and this
was a
circumstance more deeply impressed on
their memories than that their brother's
fortune and their own had been acquired
by trade right uh what does this
sentence mean it it's a very subtle
indication of how attitudes towards
class were changing and
how different individuals thought in
different ways about class right now
Elizabeth is uh very sharp in in
observing that for the bingly Sisters
their present circumstance right which
is that they were born to a respectable
family in the north of England that is
more important or that has come to seem
to be more important than another fact
which is that their fortune that the
brother's fortune and their own had been
acquired by trade the word trade here
indicates
that the wealth that the balies have is
uh new money right uh it was not
inherited through their connection to
royalty or by the fact that that they
inherited land rather they made their
Fortune through owning businesses right
these are the two kinds of ways in which
uh wealth was generated in Austin's
England and there was a a very deep deep
seated uh social condescension towards
new money right uh as we'll soon find
out uh the difference between Bingley
and Darcy is the difference between new
and old money Darcy's 10,000 pound a
year which uh we've just been uh about
which we've just been told comes from
land that he has inherited uh they don't
have business interests and that money
has not come from trade right
so Elizabeth has
discerned a certain desire a
certain um inclination in the Bal
sisters to think of themselves in a
certain way Elizabeth does not believe
that money or wealth acquired from trade
is better or worse than wealth acquired
uh through
through inheritance rather Elizabeth has
noticed that the bingly sisters are
conscious of a social condescension and
they would like to be seen as coming
from older money than from newer money
so it is this uh this discernment it is
this observation that uh the Bly sisters
not only have a certain amount of wealth
but would be but would rather be thought
of as having a certain kind of wealth
which disposes Elizabeth to think of
them in a less than ideal manner um and
and this is also an indication of uh How
Deeply these uh lines of class division
run through Austin's novels and how
different characters become real for for
us uh readers in the way in which they
perceive these these class
divisions now continuing uh this
discussion of uh very subtle but but
very real and and very deep class
divisions in the novel we are introduced
to another family that that is that of
the lucases who are the immediate
neighbors of the
benets uh the the fourth chapter of the
novel begins uh within a short walk of
long born lived a family with whom the
bennets were particularly intimate so
William Lucas had been formerly in trade
in meritan where he had made a tolerable
fortune and risen to the honor of
Knighthood by an address to the king
during his
meraly the distinction had perhaps been
felt too strongly it had given him a
disgust to his business and to his
residence in a small Market town and
quitting them both he had removed with
with his family to a house about a mile
from meriton denominated from that
period Lucas Lodge where he could think
with pleasure of his own importance and
Unshackled by business occupy himself
solely in being civil to all the world
for though elated by his rank it did not
render him supercilious on the contrary
he was all attention to everybody by
Nature inoffensive friendly and obliging
his presentation at St James's had made
him courteous
so in this description of uh of Mr Lucas
and uh actually Sir William Lucas to be
precise we understand more clearly what
Austin's narrator meant when she
described uh Elizabeth's perception of
how the Bly sisters view their wealth as
coming from trade uh cilam Lucas is an
example of uh of man who who has made
his uh Fortune from a kind of trade
right but uh
after generating a certain kind of
income he decides to to change his uh
his his occupation and to move away from
the associations of trade and to make a
certain sacrifice uh what is that
sacrifice he decides to unshackle
himself from business and occupy himself
in being civil to all the world now this
is the decision that Mr Bingley and uh
his ancestors have not made they have
decided to continue to make their income
and their wealth from trade and to
accumulate more and more wealth through
trade and bu that source of income to
consolidate their position in this
social Universe uh we see a contrast
between William Lucas who subscribes to
a very old way of thinking uh in whose
view uh wealth that is produced from
trade is not as desirable as wealth that
is
inherited and uh this is the difference
between Mr Lucas uh and Mr
Bingley and uh this is also the the
difference or this this indicates the
sacrifice that Mr Lucas makes when he
decides to uh hold on to the title of
Sir William Lucas that is after he has
been awarded this
Knighthood by uh by the king and uh
gives up his uh uh financial and and
material interests in trade uh we will
continue the discussion of class and in
particular focus on this this household
of of the lucases and uh understand how
these different understandings of wealth
class have a very uh fundamental and
defining impact on the women in in these
two families and we will continue that
discussion in the next lecture
[Music]
a
[Music]
