Lecture 11: Traction and Resistances

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Jul 23, 2024
In this lecture, the traction of locomotive, associated factors, and resistances which are caused due to rolling stocks and track profile i.e. gradient has been discussed.
[Music]
[Music]
dear students and participants of the
course on Railway engineering
now we are going to start with another
topic this is related with traction and
resistances in the previous lecture we
discussed about
Bast the functions of the bast the
requirements of the bast cushion which
is provided as a part of a
track the depth of that cushion and
there we have discussed about the
minimum depths which needs to be
provided under different conditions on
the
track the specifications of the Bast
were then
discussed therein we also talked about
the oversiz and undersiz Bast and what
are the cases where the bast which has
been received for the construction of
the track can be
rejected next to that we discussed about
the sampling techniques and then finally
we talked about the various types of the
Bellas which can be used on a track and
there we identified there are few cases
which cannot be used on the main track
completely or as a permanent way they
can be used temporarily but after some
time they have to be replaced by a
better
ban now in today's discussion we are
going to talk about traction and then
after traction we'll be discussing about
the
resistances now there are different type
of resistances which are offered on
track but in today's lecture we will be
taking up the Rolling Stock r
resistances and the resistances which
have been caused by the gradient which
is a part of the track profile or the
alignment now coming to the
traction the traction is what that it is
a source through which the locomotive
gets driving power so our interest is
the driving
power whatever is the source which is
there at the back end is a secondary
concern but when we talk about the
sustainability issues then you will say
that there are certain things or certain
types of the tractions which are coming
which have been used on the railways
should not be used further so in that
form if we talk about the various
sources there can be three different
sources one is electric condition
another is Diesel and the third one is
esteem the esteem locomotives have been
in use from the very starting on the
railways and that has been true for the
Indian railways
too and slowly and slowly those esteem
locomotives they were replaced by the
Leal
locomotives and then as a new trend when
we are going for the electrification of
our total Network wherein out of 68,000
around 50,000 has been already
electrified we are moving towards the
electric traction and the electric
locomotives now if you look look at the
today's scenario on Indian railways we
still have 39 locomotives which are
steam
locomotives that means they're using the
power which is being generated by the
stream and then they Propel or haul the
train or the wagons which have been
attached to that
locomotive we have 4747
locomotives of diesel and if we talk
about the broad gauge the ineffective
percent utilization is 9. 79% that means
only this much are the locomotives which
are not in use or they are not
effectively used but otherwise rest of
the locomotives are in use and they have
been used at what or the other part of
the track throughout the
country coming to the electric
locomotives we have
8,429 locomotives as of today for and if
we talk about the ineffective percent
utilization is further lesser it is
5.85% only for the broad guge so that
gives an idea that whatever locomotives
we have the Indian railways is utilizing
those locomotives to the maximum
possible extent so that none of the
Rolling Stock remains in the yards or in
the sheds without any
use now if we talk about electric there
is a possibility that the traction can
come in terms of alternate current or
direct current so it can be an AC or DC
condition and this 8429 locomotives that
is for
both now this direction or power which
is coming through either the steam or
the diesel or the electric condition it
has a bearing on majorly the first two
conditions that is the load carrying
capacity which is also being defined
as hauling capacity
and that defines that how many wagons
can be attached to a locomotive and the
locomotive will carry those wagons on a
plane terrain or on slopes or on curves
so whatever is the type of the track
which has been
provided another important issue is
speed the power which is available to a
locomotive will Define that at what
particular speed it can operate so there
can be a maximum speed and there can be
a permissible value at which that
locomotive has been utilized or we can
say that there is a
operational
speed so these two values are going to
be
there and nowadays when we are talking
about the high speed conditions we are
looking for 160 kilm per hour or Beyond
160 km/ hour so this particular ction of
the power or the traction becomes
important now once we have talked about
this the other two criteria which can be
there is economy and efficiency of
service economy is in terms of the
cost and that cost can be of
locomotive it can be with respect to the
fuel consumption
and it can be also with respect to the
maintenance
cost so all of these things needs to be
looked at when we are talking about the
economy Associated here and efficiency
of
services that whether they are going to
be delays because of any of the reasons
whether how much reliable is those type
of locomotives to provide the services
and when they provide the services those
things being done within the given time
frame so that type of efficiency this
efficiency can be talked in terms of
time it can be talked in terms of uh the
efficiency of use of the resources the
fuels it can be talked in terms of the
turnaround conditions it can also be in
terms of the thermal efficiency so there
are different factors which can further
be associated with
this now when we have an idea that these
are the points which needs to be
considered let us have a comparison
across two of the locomotives which are
still in use that is electric
locomotives and Diesel
locomotives there are a number of points
of comparisons and we are going to look
at all those points one by
one the very first one is the source of
energy from the name itself when we take
up the electric locomotives will be
getting the electricity as a source of
energy whereas in the case of diesel
locomotives it is on the basis of the
diesel which comes out of the
refineries so this diesel is already
available as a one output and is being
put as an input here and electricity is
being generated at some other location
and then it is being brought to the
track by the use of the overhang
conditions of wires through which it is
finally taken to the location
another case can be the engine design
and weight now if we talk about engine
design and weight the electric
locomotive is a bit complex in
design but it is
lightweight it is lightweight because
the power is not being generated on the
locomotive
itself and due to that reason the
various types of equipments which
otherwise could have been required say
if you talk about diesel
in the case of diesel it is being
generated on the locomotive itself and
therefore there are different type of
equipments which are being placed there
and that increases the weight of the
diesel locomotive so here the electric
locomotive is lightweight but as far as
design is concerned internally it is a
complex hauling capacity that is how
many wagons how much load that
locomotive can carry so electric
locomotives are found to be better and
it is because the torque which is
available with these electric
locomotives is more stady in nature as
compared to the maybe the diesel or if
you talk about the steam engine also
here that there there is much more
problems in terms of that STD torque so
again the electric locomotive has a
upper hand here the Tractive effort
available now of course there are
different levels of Tractive effort
which are available in diesel as well as
electric locomotives if you remember
then we talked about the Norman cature
of the
locomotives and there we said that it
can be w a so when we say w a w was for
broad gauge a was for electric traction
AC traction and G was for goods and
there we also talked about the speed we
also talked about the Accel load and
there we also talked about the overall
weight so there are variety of such
locomotives which are available but as
far as the overall compar condition is
there we can say that electric
locomotives has a relatively higher
position here as compared to the
diesel then
speeds because the Tractive efforts are
better available in the electric
locomotives therefore the higher speeds
can also be achieved for the electric
locomotives the power utilization power
utilization is high in the electric
locomotives because there is no wastage
in fact in the case of a diesel engine
also or diesel locomotive also the
wastage is not there subjective at the
time when it is Switched Off but when it
is working then there is some wastage
though that wastage is still not very
high but relatively if we talk about
these two uh type of locomotives then
yes there is a
difference another point of comparison
can be fuel consumption now how much
fuel is being
consumed obviously in the case of diesel
Loc motive because the generation is
there on the locomotive itself therefore
there is a direct fuel consumption and
is high but we talk about the electric
locomotive then nothing is being
generated there it is being taken to the
locomotive through the wires so
generation is somewhere else and that is
not being taken into the account in this
particular case so some people can see
that there is a diverse idea there is a
uh idea against this particular point
that the diesel locomotives are
consuming more if we account for the
electricity generation the picture may
be different also or equal
also another issue with the diesel
locomotive when the fuel consumption is
being talked is that it needs
refueling after certain
distance so there will be a station
where this diesel locomotive will be
filled again with the diesel and then it
will be moving forward
shed requirements the shed requirements
in the case of diesel locomotive uh
quite variety of equipment may be
required because the type of
installations which are
there and therefore a typical or
specific shed requirement will always be
there in the case of dis locomotive but
if you talk about a electric locomotive
also there will be requirement of some
different type of equipments on a number
of equipments maybe a bit lesser
repair and Renewables which are to be
looked here so there is a less
maintenance which is required on
electric locomotives again the reason
being the type of equipment or the
number of equipment which has been
boarded on the locomotive itself they
are less so that from there it comes out
to be a lesser maintenance requirement
the flexibility of use diesel locomotive
has been found to be more flexible under
the varied weather conditions
so here at this point the diesel
locomotive has an upper hand as compared
to the electric locomotive the rate of
acceleration it is best in the case of
electric locomotive but is it is still a
good in the case of diesel locomotive
also but because we are making a
comparison that's why this is best and
that may be
better then continuing with the points
of
comparisons the cost is another point
the cost of locomotive the electric
locomotive is being observed to be
costlier as compared to the diesel
locomotive the thermal efficiency
thermal efficiency in the case of
electric locomotive is very high it is
around
90% And this is because of the
centralized system and because of the
minimum emissions which are there if we
talk about the emissions the emissions
are also Less in the case of diesel
locomotive to but the thermal efficiency
in the case of diesel locomotive as
compared to the electric locomotive is
quite low then pollution and Hazard now
pollution and Hazard because no
emissions are there in the case of
electric locomotive there is no noise
which is being produced whereas if we
talk about the diesel locomotive because
the Machinery is working there itself to
generate the power so the noise is going
to be there there is no heat at again in
the case of diesel locomotive there is
going to be heat so electric locomotive
again is better on this count as
compared to the diesel locomotive and we
can say that electric locomotives as
such are pollution
free then slipping on or addision with
the track now slipping on or addision
with the track is being defined in terms
of the ratio of the attactive effort to
the
weight now this ratio of attractive
effort to the weight if we talk in this
particular form it has been observed
that more or less both of the
locomotives the diesel and electric
locomotives comes at par with each other
so uh we are not putting something like
a best better or good uh type of adverb
here then life of locomotive life of
locomotive though more or less they have
similar lives but if you talk in terms
of the economic life that it provides
your
service at economical level then in that
particular case the electric locomotive
has 30 years of economic life as
compared to the 15 years of economic
life of the diesel locomotive so this is
also another important aspect that uh
when we are using electric locomotive
then it allows us to go ahead for at
least 30 years and then after only there
will be a requirement of some changes
Replacements the next Point here is the
Hol now relatively higher number of
coaches can be attested to the electric
locomotive because the attractive effort
which is available to the electric
locomotive is higher so it can just pull
more number of wagons the ratio of
horsepower to weight it is lower in the
electric locomotives as compared to the
diesel locomotives the track riding that
means how you feel when you are uh being
driven by a electric locomotive or a
diesel locomotive so it more smoother in
the case of electric locomotive as
compared to the diesel
locomotive and finally if we talk about
the
suitability the suitability of the
electric locomotive is there for heavy
loads for moving on the gradients to
achieve high speeds to even work under
the underground tracks so those
suitabilities are there but when you
talk about the diesel locomotives yes
these can also be used for the heavy
load conditions but then for the
intermediate traction
efforts or one thing which can we add
here for the case of diesel locomotives
is that it can be used in the varied
weather conditions as we discussed
previously so that's a another side
where some positive things comes for the
diesel locomotive
also now let us come to the resistances
to the traction now these resistances to
the tractions they can be classified as
resistances duing Rolling Stock
resistance is due to track profile then
due to the Tractive effort and finally
due to wind so there are four types of
resistances which can be there in the
case of Rolling Stock again we have
resistances due to the parts where the
speed independent conditions are there
are not governed by the speed or there
are possibilities where they are
governed by the speed so speed will
become one of the parameter or an
attribute in that particular calculation
and the third one is the atmospheric
condition where we assume that the wind
is not blowing in the case of track
profile again we have one as a gradient
and another one as curve and if we talk
about the attractive effort then it can
happen in terms of uh say the starting
or the
acceleration so these are the Vari
resistances which can be offered and if
these are being offered then the
locomotive has to counter these
resistances so that it can take and haul
uh the wagons or the Train on that
particular track so these two are
correlated so we say that resistances
resistances are correlated with the
hauling
or or we can say the hauling
capacity now let us start with the that
this resistances so as we discussed
there are train resistances which are
due to the Rolling Stock there are
resistances due to track profile there
are traction losses which are due to the
starting or the acceleration of the
locomotive on a track and finally they
are wind resistances we will be taking
up these resistances one by one into
today's discussion we will be able to
complete the first two that is the
resistances which have been offered by
The Rolling Stock and the resistances
which are there due to the track profile
now when we talk about the resistances
due to the Rolling Stock if you go back
we can see that in the case of Rolling
Stock we talked about three the speed
independent speed dependent and
atmosphere and within speed
independent there are other cases like
zal friction rolling friction track
resistance and internal part
friction on the case of the speed
dependent what we have is a due to the
track irregularities due to Vertical
movements and flange
action so these are various things which
will be there they're starting with the
resistance due to the Rolling Stock
independent of speed dependent on speed
and the atmospheric resistances as we
just talked pre just now so starting
here with the resistances which are
independent of speeds there were four
such cases the zal resistances the
resistances due to track and all so here
the first one is that there is a
friction which is being imposed due to
the train components and we say train
components we are talking about the
locomotives and wagons and their
components so their components can be
what their components can be the
lubricants being used type of bearings
being used and the temperature effects
which can be there which will heat up
this type of uh components which have
been used there roller bearings coupled
boxes so all of these things they also
cause or they also create some
resistances and these resistances they
are known as zal friction say in the
case of a roller bearing the resistance
is .5 to 1 kg per ton so if the
locomotive is going to haul 1,000 tons
then you can understand that how much of
the resistance is going to be be there
so it is 1,000 tons means 1,000 kg
effect is going to be there or one ton
effect is going to be there similarly in
the case of coupled boxes it is 1.3 to
1.5 kg per ton and that to related we
are talking about a hard
grease then there can be another
friction which is between the steel
wheels and the steel rails so
continuously the wheels are moving at
the top of the rail so that friction
will also be there the another one is
the track resistance due to the wave
action of rails if you remember uh in
the previous lectures I talked about
that that if you have a rail being
provided like
this and there is a
wheel which is moving at the top of that
with some speed
V so there is going to be a deformation
here I can say this is a sort of a
deflection which will get created
because of the load which comes through
this
on the rail
system and when this happens it causes a
bit raising effect of the rail at the
front of it and if this wheel comes to
another location here as it keeps moving
so again there will
be this type of a deflection which will
happen but in between wave gots created
and this wave
gets moving along this rail section with
the movement of the train or the wagons
or the locomotives so that action which
is there this also poses
resistances and resistance can also be
there due to the internal parts like
cylinder and rim of the driving wheels
and all those things all of these
resistances they have been combined
together and they have been written here
as
rt1 and this rt1 is equals to
0.16 multiplied by W where W is the
weight of the train in
turns now if we talk about this weight
of train in turns say for an example if
there is a freight train which is of 42
bcn wagons then this 42 bcn wagons this
will weigh 2560 tons just try to
understand that how much weight it is
going to carry and if it is a box and
wagon and there are 58 such wagons which
have been provided then it may be
carrying a weight of
3828
tons so this is the amount of load which
is being carried and if we bring this
load here as
W and multiplied with
0.16 we get a substantial value in terms
of the resistance which is being offered
here and this is independent of his
speed this is only because of of the
locomotives and wagons and their weights
and their couplings and their various
other
components now just to give an idea that
if say we are connecting three AC
coaches four AC coaches and then within
the AC coaches also they are different
or we are connecting the coaches which
are of a second sleeper type and
likewise then in the case of AC chair
car it may have a 47.3 tons when it is
loaded AC first can have 43.5 tons of
load AC3 Tire can have 48.8 tons of a
load ac2 Tire 46.7 2 tons Pantry itself
can also have a load of 48.2 tons the
second class can have 49.1 tons the
generation van can have 56.8 tons and
the locomotive itself can have a weight
of maybe from 112 or 110 tons to 123 or
even more so when you take all of these
together then you can very easily come
up with the values now here this is a
train resistance independent of a speed
all the things are being shown that the
zal resistance is there so here when you
see
a this is zal resistance which is being
caused due to the various components of
locomotives or wagons what you can see
this is a constant
value so it has nothing to do with the
speed whatever is the speed is there it
is constant but when you talk about the
flange resistance which is defined here
as B this flunge resistance it starts
increasing and the rate is not very high
it is a just a mild
slope but if you talk about the air
resistance that air resistance is being
governed by the square of the speed and
that's the reason we got this escalated
value so you will find that it starts
increasing at a very faster rate as soon
as the speeds starts increasing much
more so if you talk about the lower
speed Spectrum there the zal resistance
is the highest one and it is causing the
effect but as you go ahead and you come
to the higher speeds then it shifts to
the air
resistance now come to the dependent on
speed in the case of dependent speeds
the problems can be with the train is
moving at a speed now why the
resistances come it can come because of
the track
irregularity it can be there because of
the vertical movement of wheels on the
rails because of the improper joints or
because the maintenance has been not
done in the right manner or it may also
happen because of the flange action and
flange action when we see it is that the
the flange is
moving in the One Direction
so so the flang is there so it it keeps
moving here in this form on the track so
this because of that reason also there
will be the effect and it has been
observed that the resistances they are
proportional to uh one by length that is
inversely proportional here of the resid
base or it is proportional to the speed
of the train and square of that so the
train resistance here it's being defined
as rt2 and the formula for that is
0.4 * 08 into W into V where W again is
the weight of the train in turn and V is
the speed of the train in kilometers per
hour so this is another
formula now if you talk about the speeds
in the different locomotives WAP 5 160
W4 140 wap1 WAP 7 130 W4 this is 120
then W A6 again 120 in the case of goods
so this was for
passengers this is wap4 and this is for
goods W7 and 9 has 100 km/ hour speed
then W 9h is 90 5 A and B 5 h a HB it
say 80 kilom per hour speed so
accordingly you will find the
resistances are also going to be
varying here this graph shows that with
the speed increase as it is increasing
here what happens to the force which is
there so attactive effort up to certain
level as you can see here see roughly
around of 20 uh m/ second
that remains constant and after that it
starts is reducing
exponentially now if we talk about the
atmospheric effect in the case of
atmospheric effect it acts what is
happening is the atmosphere is
everywhere so it is creating an effect
on the ends as well as on the sides of
the wagons and the locomotives but we
assume that the wind is not blowing
that's the wind resistance is a separate
resistance which we will be discussing
So based on that this rt3 is been
computed but it is being affected by the
square of the speed and it is given by
006 W into square of V multiplied by W
multiplied by
v² again W and V have the same notations
so finally if we talk about the total
train resistance RT this is nothing but
this is 0016 W plus
8 W into V plus
00 6 W into square of V now let us look
at one of the numerical here there is a
train which weighs 12200 tons and runs
at a speed of 80 km/ hour on a broad
gauge track we have to calculate the
train resistance now in this case the
train resistance rt1 is going to be with
respect to the independent and dependent
on speed so we and atmospheric
conditions are the three such formula
are there which are available to us
which we have just discussed W is 1,00
tons and the speed V is given as 80 km/
hour so if we put those values here what
we get is 1.92 tons of uh the
independent condition 7.68 for the speed
dependent condition and 4.68 for the
atmospheric condition which together
comes out to be 14.28 tons so this is
the amount of resistance which is going
to be there for this case now there's
another numerical which we're taking
here here there is a train which carries
12 wagons and we are being given the
classification of the wagons that they
at one ac2 tire three AC3 tire and rest
are the second sleeper
coaches now once this data is being
given then we have already seen that
what are the values of the weights for
these particular uh wagons so we will
take those weights so if we take those
weights we'll get some value here so we
calculate the weight of the Train the
weight of the train comes out to be
56592
or 566 tons this is on the basis of the
weights of those wagons and is driven by
a wap7 locomotive which is having a
weight of 120 tons so this is also added
in this
56592 train is running at a speed of0
km/ hour so that is given so again using
the same formula which we have just
discussed and when we put the values
here what we get is 99.995 tons or
roughly 10 tons of the resistance
is there in this particular
case now let's talk about another
resistance which is due to the track
profile in the case of track profile we
discussed it can be because of the
gradient it can be because of the
curvature now here you can see that the
gradient is being set so this an angle
Theta at which the gradient is the train
is moving in this direction towards the
up and this gradient can be defined
either by this angle it can be defined
as 1 in N or it can be defined as x%
there are different ways in which it can
be
done now when we talking about this
resistance now the weight is acting
downwards this is a
normal uh Force which is acting with
respect to the surface and it is moving
with attractive force in this particular
form so the resultant RG which is acting
along the surface but in the opposite
direction that RG we are talking and
that RG is W sin Theta or W tan Theta if
the angle of this Theta is very small
usually for the train tracks it is very
less or it can also be return as W into
the percent slope so this is how we can
calculate the resistance due to the
longitudinal gradient so just look at
numerical on this track is being laid
with a gradient of 1 in 200 and uh it is
running on this section and experiences
a resistance of 5.5 tons due to gradient
gradient resistance is already being
given and what we have to calculate is
the weight of the train that can be hold
on this gradient
so we have a formula RG is equal to W
into percent slope the percent slope can
be found out because we have been given
1 in N so it is 1 in 200 so 1 by 200 is
the value so it is and if you talk in
percent so it is multiplied by 100
so5 is 5% is the case so when we use
that 5% here so what we get is 05 into W
and because the resistance is being
given to us as 5.5 tons if we put it
here what we get as W is 1100 tons that
means if there is no other resistance
being offered only this thing is there
then in that case this uh uh locomotive
can haul 1100 tons of the weight so we
close now this lecture what we discussed
was the traction of locomotives the
associated factors their comparisons and
then the resistances which are caused
due to the rolling stocks and the track
profile and specifically the gradient is
this we close it thank you we'll meet in
the next lecture
[Music]
