SHOGUN TV Show Big Historical WEAPON ERROR! Review
The new TV show Shogun looks fantastic, but already I see a BIG historical weapon blooper. Review.
▼3 extra EXCLUSIVE videos each month on PATREON, which make this channel possible:
https://www.patreon.com/scholagladiatoria
▼Facebook & Twitter updates, info, memes and fun:
https://www.facebook.com/historicalfencing/
https://twitter.com/scholagladiato1
▼Schola Gladiatoria HEMA - sword fighting classes in the UK:
https://www.swordfightinglondon.com
▼Matt Easton's website & Pinterest:
https://www.matt-easton.co.uk/
https://www.pinterest.co.uk/matt_easton/_saved/
▼Easton Antique Arms - antique swords for sale:
https://www.antique-swords.co.uk/
#shogun #tvshow #review
just like lots of you out there I am
massively looking forward to watching
Shogun but they got something massively
wrong
already hi folks Mattis here scol
Gladiator now on my channel obviously
you're used to me talking about things
like this uh original Japanese Waka
Sashi here and weapons of uh edged
nature white weapons um edged weapons
rather than firearms and in fact I have
uh examples of rapers and Katana behind
me which actually date to the time of
Shogun which is around the year 1600 now
like many of you out there I'm massively
looking forward to seeing this and I've
got to say overall the trailer looks
amazing and the things that have been
released the Stills and everything else
that have been released look absolutely
amazing and I am a fan of the original
novel as well which I've listened to the
entirety of it's quite long on audio
book as well so I am hugely looking
forward to it so I don't want this to be
taken as in you know too negative light
but there is something they've got
massively wrong already and it's guns
now I'm primarily known for swords and
edged weapons but for many of you you
might not know I am also a fan of
firearms I don't do an awful lot of
firearms content on my channel but I do
actually shoot black pow weapons so I
shoot things like muzzle loading
revolvers and I shoot Winchester lever
actions muzzle loading shotguns muskets
and all sorts of other things like that
as well as modern Firearms as well um
but unfortunately there is a type of
pistol shown in the uh in fact you can
see it just about in the trailer but we
can also see it in some of the Stills
which is basically about a 100 years too
late so here's the important context the
novel by James clavell features The
Adventures of John Blackthorne now he
should be based in the year 1600 now as
far as I've seen so far the Japanese
arms and armor shown in this looks
pretty good for around this year 1600
however uh Black Thorn himself should be
armed with pistols that date to the year
1600 and they should be of an English
design what he's holding do not appear
at all to be Pistols that you'd find in
the year 1600 in fact they appear to be
pistols we'd find from the very earliest
and this this is based on what I can see
in the images presented about 1680 at
the earliest probably more like 1700
1720 for comparison that'll be a bit
like someone running around in the US
Civil War with John cl's Beretta also I
hate to be the person to point this out
but you've got to [ __ ] them specifically
what he's shown holding is essentially a
flint lock English pistol of the 1700s
but he's supposed to be in 1600s so it
just so happens I have a very useful
book here called the complete handgun
1300 to present by Ian V hog uh it's a
quick guide it's not the most in-depth
book in the ball but it's got some nice
images in it and right down here at the
bottom there we have a pist P from Circa
1600 and it's an English dog lock uh
that's right there's various types of
lock which become uh come before Flint
locks um there's um uh snap hunches for
example there's wheel locks and there's
dog locks and of course it's match locks
as well which don't use a flint at all
and what's shown very clearly in the
trailer is what seemed to be a pair of
Flint locks later 1700 splint locks now
the dog lock In fairness does
superficially look very like a lock so I
could excuse that but if you look at the
overall shape of the pistol particularly
with this sort of pommel like sword
likee pommel um extension at the end and
the overall shape of it it's very clear
that what blackthorn's holding in the
trailer and the Stills is unfortunately
a 1700's flint lock not an Elizabethan
or Circa
1600 um dog lock or something similar to
that so there we go it's not a massive
massive thing but for weapon
afficionados I've been asked a lot to
resp respond to the trailer looking at
the swords or the Yari or the naginata
or the armor but the fact is this was
the first thing that caught my eye was
actually that the pistols were wrong uh
so anyway hopefully the rest of the
series is going to be absolutely
fantastic hopefully the Japanese arms
and armor will be great but maybe if you
come back to this channel in coming
weeks as we see more of it I might have
some things to say about both the arms
and armor and the combat featured in the
series but I am massively looking
forward to it so don't be too
discouraged by the fact that the pistols
are terribly wrong um they are pretty
badly wrong but not like horrifically
wrong I will Overlook it I will imagine
it's a dog loock of Circa 1600 as shown
down there anyway thanks a lot for
watching I hope to see you back on the
channel really soon um and uh I I I've
been mat eaten I'll continue to be and
I'll see you really soon cheers
folks

