Pistols & revolvers in the Crimean War & Indian Mutiny (Adams & Colt)
3 Video Views·Nov 2, 2023
A look at the use and effectiveness of revolvers and other types of pistol during the mid-19th century, specifically in the Crimean War and Indian Mutiny, which an original source reading of the ineffectiveness of one particular revolver.
FACEBOOK - https://www.facebook.com/historicalfencing/
PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/scholagladiatoria
ANTIQUES - http://www.antique-swords.co.uk
hey votes Matty stand here scholar
gladiatori so I talked many times in the
past about 19th century warfare which is
my a particular love of mine
particularly a colonial era warfare I
just want to throw in there don't think
that I could any kind of like fantasy
great ideas about colonialism it was
pretty awful but nevertheless for
someone who's interested in military
history a very interesting period to
study and something I've mentioned is
you know why were hand weapons swords
and bayonets and lances why were they
still really important particular in the
mid 19th century and even in the late
19th century to an extent and in fact
they did enjoy another heyday again in a
little bit of a heyday in the First
World War in trench warfare but why
particularly in the mid 19th century
were hand weapons still so important and
it's a very pivotal time in the
development of firearms now in terms of
officers British officers which is the
accounts of which right what I mostly
read and study because obviously asked
to the British military swordsmanship as
the mid 19th century and that mostly or
very largely relates to officers a lot
of the time sometimes obviously cavalry
troopers as well but mostly I'm looking
at fighting on foot so people who
carrying swords on foot usually are
officers and the other thing that they
often carried were pistols but as I've
mentioned in previous videos in the mid
19th century a lot of British officers
didn't have pistols for one reason and
another and even those that did have
pistols lots of them had things like
this this is actually a French officers
pistol a rather lovely piece and
fantastic condition with a Damascus
barrel in a walnut stock in perfect
working order and a lot of the money has
a single-shot pistol now it it doesn't
take your genius to work out that if
you're engaged in a melee of some kind
you know you're fighting in some village
or in some field somewhere and there's
multiple opponents and you've only got
one shot you don't have time to stand
there and take out your particular
little ramrod and get get your powder
horn out and get your or even if you've
got pre-made paper cartridge and then
they're reloading okay if you're in a
melee you have one chance to shoot with
that with that pistol and then if you
have
another one which very often these were
carried embraces in pairs to pull out
that one and shoot that one as well
probably drop it and pick it up retrieve
it afterwards assuming you survive so
you might have one shot or two shots
now when multi shot pistols came along
there were double barreled version of
those that came along that's great
fantastic that's twice as many shots
that's a massive boon and it's like a
double-barrel shotgun compared to a
single barrel shotgun you know it's a
huge advantage but really when a multi
shot pistols came along it was it was a
major thing it really changed and
changed things and so one of the
earliest types to come along with the so
called pepper part or pepper box
revolver and an adaptation of that was
this I'll talk about this more in its
own video later but this is a what's
known as a transitional revolver it's
essentially a pepper part of with a
barrel added on the end and these were
made by people who were already making
in the 1840s basically 1840s and 1850s
people who were already making pepper
pots and once the Colt revolver came
along which really just changed the
whole pistol scene they quickly tried to
catch up and compete with it by adding a
barrel onto the front of essentially the
parts they were already they already
knew how to make and when revolvers came
along this was the first one to change
things in Britain really was the Colt
1851 Navy now these were bought in large
numbers by the military although I say
large numbers large numbers in terms of
a contract but not large numbers in
terms of they didn't like equip everyone
with them or equip all officers with
them and in fact if we look at the
Crimean War for example in 1854 1854 to
1856 we see that actually lots of
officers frantically were trying to buy
revolvers or pistols of any kind really
but particularly the new revolvers they
were trying to buy those so that they
could be more effective essentially at
the frontlines during the Crimean War
and same thing in the Indian Mutiny we
see letters from the Indian Mutiny which
is in 1857 where officers are writing
home going you know for God's sake send
me out at one of these new revolvers
because I don't have one and the other
day I was tapped
and I barely survived and if I'd had a
revolver then I would have unist did a
much better chance of survival and I did
so this colt revolver the 1851 Navy was
one of the first ones that really became
relatively widely available to British
officers but certainly even in the
indian mutiny of 1857 which is you know
six years after this pistol came out
many British officers still didn't have
them by that point they weren't as easy
to get hold of in Europe as they were in
America even though Colt had started up
making them in London at the London
Factory and of course they were
expensive and being an officer at that
time was an expensive business you had
to pay for you even had to pay for like
your accommodation and your food and
everything so in actual fact the idea
that officers will bail often came from
well-off families but they themselves
often were quite impoverished and and
and couldn't afford extravagances life
pistols so they had to rely on relatives
to buy them as presents so what's
interesting is that one of the debates
that came up during the Crimean War and
the Indian Mutiny so 1854 256 and the
nearly mutiny 1857 52 58 so this period
that spans the whole center of the 1850s
was people trying to replace or get
pistols and then replace their old
single-shot pistols with multi shot
pistols and then there was a debate that
ensued between the Colt revolver which
was famous because of course Colt had
really patented in fact and pioneered
this mechanism and the British
competitor the Adams revolver now I'm
gonna do a video particularly comparing
specifically comparing the Adams with
the with the colt this is a reproduction
in certainly by who Bertie this is the
London Navy and so based on pistols from
around the middle of the 1850s and this
is an actual original that was probably
at the siege of Lucknow during the
Indian Mutiny so these in design and to
date basically exactly the same but this
is a British design this is an American
zone Adams got around the Colt Paton I
won't go into too much detail but
because I'll save that for the future
video but Adams got around to call
Peyton by designing a different
mechanism
the main advantage of the atom's was
this it was double action that is that
when you pull the trigger it shoots it
just all you have to do is pull the
trigger and you know bang bang bang bang
bang with the cult you have to [ __ ] the
hammer before each shot right now whilst
that was the main debate in the Crimean
War in the Indian Mutiny and the other
Wars around that period between the Colt
and the atoms and people frantically
trying to buy either of them and get
whatever they could then there were
other types of revolvers and other types
of multi shot pistol around and I was
reading an account which I thought I
would read to you because I thought it's
just quite a funny account and quite
interesting and it is from and I highly
recommend this book if you're interested
in a period under deadly fire by Hugh
goth and Hugh goth was an officer in
where he went through a few different
regiments actually but during the mutiny
he was primarily serving under Hudson of
Hudson's horse and he has a very nice
start of writing it's not a big book
it's fairly quick to read and it's
relatively modern and in its way of
saying things but anyway here's the
account and I think it's kind of
interesting and it illustrates some of
the points that I talk about about the
problems of pistols at this period so
with the detachment of my regimen I'd
come to a village known to have been
actively hostile and my orders were to
burn it
lovely lovely bit of colonial policing
where and I found the village apparently
empty and it sent parties to set the
houses on fire waiting myself outside
attended by one orderly when suddenly a
fakir
which means a like a religious warrior
essentially of color priests fanatics
should we say rushed out from a building
and came straight at me his naked body
smeared with dust and ashes and his long
matted hair he looked a veritable fiend
armed with a lathi or iron bound stick
he bounded at me with a yell of fury
taking me completely by surprise I had
barely time to take out my revolver
which unfortunately was only a toy
weapon presented to me by a lady on my
leaving mirror
when he says toy weapon he means of
small caliber and the only pistol I
possessed I promptly fired at him
hitting him full on his left breast but
the wretched little popgun failed failed
to do more than just stagger him when he
again made it made a bound forward
shouting and this is my pronunciations
gonna be bad dear Hamby moraga saw which
means I I can also strike now Pig and I
had just time to draw my sword and ward
off a terrific blow which almost broke
down my guard that means his parry but
which I returned with such effect that
he turned back and fled into back into
the burning village cursing me loudly as
he went I saw no more of him and I
presume he perished among his gods
without the satisfaction of having
gained his passport to heaven through
the sacrifice of an infidel he was a
gallant scoundrel but I cannot say his
language was that of a holy man which
according to his lights he aspired to be
the harmless result of my pistol shot
which though hitting him directly over
the heart had but staggered him warned
me for the future not to trust in such a
miniature weapon and I took the earliest
opportunity to provide myself with a
good serviceable Colts revolver so there
we go we've got someone serving the time
you know he probably probably what he
bought was a Colt Navy it could have
been a cultural goon which is a far
bigger and heavier version and larger
caliber it's 44 caliber this is 36 we
don't know but anyway he got a Colt
revolver rather than Adams revolver I
have other sources where they say I want
an Adam's rather than a cult so clearly
different people had different
preferences I think in one of his
virtues of the cult was it was famous
and a very tough and reliable and
trusted mechanism so despite the fact
that it was single action I'm so fairly
slow to reload relatively speaking and
it was it was tough and the 36 round it
so if that was what he bought and that
was considered larger than what he tried
to shoot the [ __ ] ear with then
presumably what he was trying to use
with something more like this like a 31
31 Cal appoint 31 caliber pistol which
really would design for self-defense in
urban sea
situations and there was a vibrant trade
making these small caliber pistols but I
find it very interesting that sauce
because it tells us so many interesting
things in such a short piece of text but
it does show that he didn't he was
serving you know he was a frontline
officer in India serving in Hudson sauce
and he had no pistol
apart from this pop gun that some some
woman in Meerut had given to him as as a
gift
presumably or a good-luck thing and so
yeah just interesting to show and also
helps illustrate again why swords were
still so important in mid 19th century
and combat because of course not only
did a lot of them not have pistols or
not have good pistols but pistols didn't
always have the effect they were
supposed to have he only managed to get
one shot off despite the fact it was a
revolver it didn't stop the Matt and the
man still attacked him you can't parry
with a pistol so even if you shot the
person and they're gonna die soon if
they're attacking you with a lefty or a
sword or anything else you need to guard
you need to parry and there he had a
sword luckily to parry with so there we
go I hope that's an interesting anecdote
from history and Hugh Goff amazing guy
him and his brother both awarded the
Victoria Cross they're worth reading up
on and thank you very much for watching
this folks thank you for watching please
subscribe follow us on Facebook you can
buy t-shirts through Spreadshirt support
us on patreon or follow us on Pinterest
thank you

