Axes and swords were both popular weapons during the viking era, and both offer different advantages. But one advantage of the axe that often gets overlooked is durability. Raven's Beak Forge: https://www.ravensbeakforge.com/
Throughout the Viking era of the early Middle Ages the spear and the shield were the primary weapons
But let's look at the secondary weapons compared the axe and the sword the two most prevalent
Backup weapons to the to the spear and let's give it a little bit of justice for one specific reason to the axe
One reason why the axe is a better choice than a sword
Hi folks, so regular viewers of this channel will absolutely know that obviously the spear was the primary weapon used with a shield in fact
Throughout the ancient and most of the medieval world really it was only
Really full plate armour that really changed that scenario
But when you use a spear anyone who's used a spear for any amount of time knows that it's incredibly important if you can to
Have some kind of backup weapon now in the Viking era
so we're talking about essentially the 700s through to the
1000s essentially up to about 1100 and so we're talking about a period of about 400 years
This is the early medieval period but it's later than the migration period. Okay, so this is essentially before knights
But after the fall of the Roman Empire in the West or at least the the receding of the Roman Empire in the West
okay, so the shield is a
Omnipresent factor in this period
Okay
So what you use as a secondary weapon is very much governed by the fact that shields are everywhere and very very prevalent
Maybe not in civilian life, but certainly in military life
So for that reason the primary backup weapons apart from knives like saxes
Were either the sword or the axe now?
Obviously for people who could afford them the swords offer a whole range of benefits and I have covered these in previous videos
But just to quickly summarize you've got increased reach
You've got an object which has an incredibly long edge compared to something like an axe
Which has a very short edge you have the ability to stab or thrust at quite long range
You've got a hand guard. You've also got a balance which is back towards the hand which makes something
Which is quite wieldable and can come around to different targets quite easily and quickly
This is a weapon which even with a push or a pull can give grievous and sometimes fatal wounds
So this isn't necessarily a weapon which needs to be swung with a lot of force in order to have an effect on an opponent
It can be simply done by sliding the blade up. So in most
Applications in certainly in civilian life and even in most military applications
the sword is a very very good backup weapon because it's very easy to be dangerous with it anyone with a
Essentially a giant knife in their hands whether it's stabbing cutting pushing pulling is going to be really really dangerous
It's also difficult to grab this. It's difficult to you know, kind of just grapple with someone who's got a sword
And of course very importantly it can be easily worn in a scabbard so it's completely safe while you're wearing it
But when you pull it out, you've instantly got two to three feet of
dangerous double-edged in many cases and pointed blade ready to go and ready to win the opponent, however
We have in many times in previous videos questioned. Why would you choose an axe? Just very briefly
This is a relatively small axe that I've chosen today
I've got various other axes around larger axes than this
but actually in this period relatively small axes like this were really quite popular and in fact
If we if we look in period art, you can see them being thrown. So this is this is somewhat bigger than a Francisca
This is actually made by my friend Ethan Ravensbeak forge. I'll stick a link below actually to Ravensbeak forge
beautiful eye axe here, but this is actually although this is kind of essentially a
Kind of American Revolution era kind of rifleman's or trade hawk tomahawk
This is actually very very similar to some of the smaller axes that were in use in the Viking era at the other end of
The scale we've got much much bigger axes like this and there's some debate. This is based on one
From I think Czech Republic and there's some debate actually on whether this was a two-handed axe or one-handed axe
So actually I've kind of put it on a medium-sized shaft
But one-handed axes could vary in size from really quite small to really quite long edged like this and obviously they offer different
Benefits that this one is lighter and quicker and you could throw it
This one has got a longer edge more hooking capacity. We'll talk about that in a second and a longer edge
So it's easier to hit the target and you're going to do a longer wound with it
And obviously it goes without saying at the top end of the scale. We've got things like the two-handed
Definitely two-handed Dane axe, but we're not really looking at
Those here. We're just really looking at one-handed axes. So
Here it is without beating around the bush any longer one of the massive advantages of these axes
As opposed to a sword is
Durability. Okay. Now keep that in mind. We'll come back to it
Not to say there aren't other advantages so two of the primary advantages that axes have over swords in close combat and remember
Close combat at this time almost always means with a shield in the other hand
So two of the other advantages that an axe has over a sword is number one the ability to hook
Opponents shields so in a period where everybody's got shields the ability to hook the shield aside is
Really really cool now not to say that swords don't have their own advantage
I'm not saying that axes are better than swords. Just saying they've got different advantages
So overall I would say the sword has more advantages than the axe
But that the axe does have some unique advantages the sword can strike further it can thrust more easily
You know, it's got it's got longer reach. It's fully edged
So anyway, you hit along there is going to do damage if you just hit someone with the shaft of the axe
It's going to hurt slightly if it's not going to do them any damage
You've got to hit with the blade
So these are all pluses and minuses, but that hooking ability is really something very distinct in this period to axes in later periods
It can also be applied to things like war picks and war hammers and things like this
But they don't exist in this period for the most part
Maces do exist just about but they're not very popular. Not very common
Okay, so the first advantage is hooking of shields
The second big advantage is this is better against armor now
This is a somewhat problematic point because in this period most people on the battlefield didn't have armor
okay, so yes male shirts existed even scale armor existed and obviously plate helmets, but
Armor on the torso as far as we can tell from archaeology written sources and also
art
Wasn't necessarily particularly prevalent
but that being said some people did have armor and certainly as we go later into the Viking era and we get towards like
1000 AD and after that it does seem that more and more and more
Soldiers on the battlefield were equipped with a bernie or mail shirt or Horbuck
So in other words mail chain mail armor now against chain mail
That is a really good defense against swords
Okay, if you look at the shape of the points on these swords, they're quite broad. They're designed for stabbing into flesh
straight fairly plain edges without an enormous amount of
Weight or anything like that. These aren't really designed for cleaving through mail
Yes, you can hit someone who's wearing a male shirt and wound them break their ribs break their collarbone break their arm
but you're not going to cut through it, but
With a weapon that is top weighted you have an enormous amount more
Percussive force because of course it's balanced towards the top rather than towards the bottom like a sword and moreover all of that force is
Concentrated into a small surface area. Okay, so because it's focused into there. It's more likely to compromise the mail
it's more like to wound the person through the mail than a sword is this is essentially combines the
concentrated cutting force of an axe
With some effects of the mace even if you hit with the backside of the axe
Which I'm sure some people did do if you would just wanted a mace. Well, you've already got a mace
This is an axe or a mace depending which way around you hold it and obviously later
Things like pole axes have actual hammers on the back
But there's no reason why you can't hit with the back of the socket of an axe as well
So if you don't want to run the risk of damaging your edge bashing into mail or getting it stuck in someone's body
You can use the backside and it's still a very effective percussive weapon
Okay, so now back to this point of durability
So axes have advantages swords have advantages
Obviously, we've also got to put this into the context of the fact that swords are expensive and more high-status weapons in this period
Later on if we get to the 14th century, for example
Just about everybody even a common archer or anyone a billman could afford a sword
But in this period from you know, 8th century through to 11th century
Swords are much more expensive and rare. So
in a period
Where all you can get is an axe
They have this major advantage of durability because if we consider what an axe is made of it's made of a wooden shaft and an iron
and steel head, okay a
Sword might seem more durable because the whole thing is made of steel, but here's the news flash
Swords are not that strong. Okay, so the simple fact is that if you take a sword of the let's say the 9th century
so peak kind of Viking era if you take this sword and
Sharp edged as it is a made of period
Steel, okay
so made a period produced steel which might have a pattern welded core might have steel edges forged welded on and
You take someone's helmet, for example a conical nasal helm and you take your full strength and smash that
Sword into that helmet. There's a good chance
That it could break
Okay
Like a really good chance because the problem is I might blunt reenactment swords sharp swords as soon as they take damage on the edge
And bear in mind these swords are thin bladed and thin edged as soon as they take damage on the edge
They create a chip or a burr or a notch and that is a
Stress riser as soon as you've got a stress riser in the blade and it could just be from parrying someone else's attack
Accidentally or deliberately if someone's weapon comes in at you and you swipe it it you take a nick in here as soon as that's
Happened you have a stress riser in the blade and it's much more likely to break at that point
Number one number two if this is made of period material, it's going to have slag inclusions
It's going to have heat treatment in inconsistencies. If it's pattern welded, it's going to have different
Grades if you want to call it that of steel and iron in the blade, so there's gonna be
Inconsistency in the blade. This is made of the n45 modern spring steel much much more reliable really than
Anything except for an Ulfberht in this period so all other swords that aren't Ulfberhts are not made of crucible steel are not made
of homogenous steel they are made of
Inconsistent steel inconsistently heat treated with slag inclusions
So and you might be thinking well, you just don't hit a helmet. Just don't don't aim in a helmet
Well newsflash for you as I've said all of along
Shields are omnipresent and look what's in the middle of a shield an iron boss. Okay, so you are gonna hit
Great big sheet steel or iron on a regular basis if you're fighting with a sword and it's not just shield bosses
And helmets, it's also male armor. It's buckles. It's
Weapons that might be being worn
It might be the pommel of a sword that's being worn or the spearhead of the of the opponent that's attacking you or anything like
This so there are all sorts of things that can damage this blade and break this blade and moreover
Not even just damaging the edge
But just blades break if we look at even later medieval art from the 15th century when steel overall was much better quality and more
reliable
Even then we see broken weapons littered all over the ground
So I am NOT saying that an axe can't break obviously the wooden shaft can be chopped apart
You know theoretically if it receives enough hits might splinter or crack or break or split
The head potentially could fly off
This is actually shown in the Bayer tapestry of a head coming or a Danax head coming off the shaft of an axe
So, yes, absolutely it can happen
But overall these are much more robust much more durable things and I expect many of you
I mean don't compare fighting axes with wood chopping axes wood chopping axes
Because they're designed to chop down trees and not to fight with are overbuilt. They are heavier
They are thicker and they tend to have thicker shafts than most fighting axes as well
But nevertheless remember that axes can live for many generations being used to chop down trees without needing any type of
Repair I can tell you if you try and chop down trees with a sword even a modern steel sword
It's not going to last very long. So axes are fundamentally more durable objects now
if we think about the the press the melee of
someone like the Battle of Stamford Bridge or Hastings or
All of these kind of you know
Molden all of these big battles or if we go to Charlemagne's wars all of these big battles
Where initially yes
You are in your organized ranks and you've got you've got your spears and your shields and you're fighting as units
but when that breaks apart when the route starts when
When the route starts when the melee starts and everyone starts hacking and slashing with weapons at close range. Bam
Bam, it's gone completely crazy
In that stage if your beautiful sword and which might be carving up enemies suddenly goes
Crap your swords just broken off with only 10 inches of blade in its hand
Yes, you could potentially use it as some kind of hammer
But that is far more likely to happen than with something like an axe. So yes, this has shorter range
And yes, it has a shorter range. And yes, you can't stab with it
But you've got the ability to hook you've got the ability to
Smash and use it as a mace and smash into armor and have more effect than with a sword
But above and beyond all of that
I think the prime virtue the prime advantage of an axe is you can trust it more than a sword
This is this if we look at you know romances and and various sagas from the period
Trustability of swords is a major factor. We see swords breaking in the Arthurian legends
We see swords breaking in the Icelandic sagas
Faith and trust in a sword or a sax
It clearly wasn't always there
They didn't always deserve it but axes much much stronger. So there we go to conclude. I
Obviously have given you a huge amount more context than perhaps was required for this subject
but I want you to go away with the idea that
Fundamentally one-on-one. Yes axes are inferior weapons to swords most of the time in most situations
However in a battle in a war a weapon that you can trust 100% even if it's
overall a less effective weapon in most situations
The fact that you trust it and that this can't really break and even if it does break it's fairly easy to fix later on
But it's far less likely to break in close in combat hitting shields and helmets and armor than the sword is
I think that is worth an awful lot and that's why axes are freaking awesome
I hope you've enjoyed watching this video
I have been Matt Easton in case you didn't know and I will continue to be so hopefully I'll see you back on the
Channel really soon. Make sure you've liked and subscribed
Go in peace and I'll see you back here for the next video. Cheers folks
Thanks for watching. We've got extra videos on patreon. Please give our Facebook alike and subscribe if you haven't already. Cheers folks