FALCHION dominates MACE in Medieval Armored Fighting? With @dequitem
Is the medieval falchion a better weapon for fighting in plate armor than the mace? With @dequitem - his video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JY0E7CCslQc
▼3 extra EXCLUSIVE videos each month on PATREON, which make this channel possible:
https://www.patreon.com/scholagladiatoria
▼Facebook & Twitter updates, info, memes and fun:
https://www.facebook.com/historicalfencing/
https://twitter.com/scholagladiato1
▼Schola Gladiatoria HEMA - sword fighting classes in the UK:
https://www.swordfightinglondon.com
▼Matt Easton's website & Pinterest:
https://www.matt-easton.co.uk/
https://www.pinterest.co.uk/matt_easton/_saved/
▼Easton Antique Arms - antique swords for sale:
https://www.antique-swords.co.uk/
#falchion #medieval #mace
is the falan actually a better armored
fighting weapon than the
mace hi folks matis here Scola Gladiator
now I'm going to try and keep this
relatively concise for one of my videos
and this is partially uh not really a
response but it's inspired by a great
video by deem I'm going to link his
video down below where he basically
ranked the top 10 weapons for fighting
in armor now before I go on I want to
state that that's a really good video go
and watch it I don't necessarily 100%
agree with everything in there um but I
more or less agree I largely agree I
probably would have put the poax high
but maybe we can talk about that in a
future video um and there are also some
things I would say about swords in
general used in armor I also have to say
that deem has more experience than me
fighting in armor simple as that uh so I
actually take his opinions and his views
incredibly ser seriously and I give them
a lot of respect and respect where uh
respect is due my experience mostly
absolutely is in unarmed uh sparring
competition fighting over the course of
20 odd years um so my no no question my
forte is unarmored um heer should we say
rather than armored heer that being said
I'm trying to change that and I'm doing
more armored har and some people call it
armored fighting uh and in intending to
do more in the future but moreover of
course I have spent 30 years studying
the sources and the source material so
what does that mean that means I've
spent uh that amount of time since I was
at University specializing in um
medieval history and archaeology and
looking at arms and armor and getting my
qualification in it looking at Medieval
sources what they say about these
weapons also the artwork and studying
The Originals in museum and that is
really important to this uh to the
answering this point okay okay and that
is because falan in the modern world and
I have mentioned this in a in a recent
video as well falan in the modern
particularly reenactment and boher or
hmb world are rather different to falan
in museums now I'll come back to that in
a second so what is the basic question
here well so deem and other people I
have to say not just uh him have said in
the past that they consider falan better
weapons than maces and in fact if we
look at modern Booher for example
there does seem to be a preference for
falan over um maces now specifically
I'll only talk briefly about this
because I have almost no experience of
bower apart from the fact that I am
friends with quite a lot of people who
do it and uh something which I think is
interesting is in modern boher maces are
usually limited to 1 kilogram so 1,000
gr whereas falion are allowed to be 1300
or 1.3 kilg or um sorry 1300 gram so
actually you can have a heavier falan
than you can have a mace and that
obviously skews the results there's
other things which skew the results as
well boher is a very particular Sport
with specific types of armor being worn
the type of armor being worn in Bower is
generally fairly different to actual
historical armor in some cases it's made
of modern materials like titanium and
things like that but let's just leave it
at that that the armor is somewhat
different and the the way it's worn is
somewhat different to historical
counterparts okay so that's the first
thing and the weapons are different as
well and what you can do with them is
different you can't thrust in Bower um
and various other things um and for the
most part you're hitting the armor a lot
of time rather than necessarily stabbing
into gaps because you can't stab okay so
all of that aside uh We've also got to
say uh what are my framing this in as
armored period so I'm not necessarily
talking here about the age of male I'm
talking about the age of plate so I'm
specifically really talking about 14th
and 15th century so what do the sources
show let's just look at the artwork for
a second well actually fions were pretty
popular not necessarily this type this
is a 13th century type uh by Paul bins
this is a hybrid between the con's falan
and the Clooney fion we'll talk about
those in a second a 13th century type
but actually when we get into um the
15th century we see blades more like
this they tend to be narrower and
pointier and this of course is based on
an example in the Royal Armory in this
part of the windless line which I've
studied the original of and took all the
measurements that led to this um this
replica um so when we look at uh
medieval artwork 14th and 15th century
we do see maces and we do see falan so I
think it's important to state that both
of them were used in armored
fighting however if we look at armored
dueling which is DM's um main focus and
I have to say is often the main focus on
this channel as well so one-on-one
combat we actually don't see falan
featured hardly at all and we don't see
maces featured hardly at all they are
both weapons that appear in Battlefield
art but they don't appear very much in
treeses barely at all in treeses used in
armor um and uh not very much in
accounts of single combat for fighting
in uh single combat the primary weapons
are the poax the spear the sword not
always long sword sometimes an arming
sword but The Sword and the dagger and
decm covers that and his video very well
and I completely agree so the primary
weapons for one-on-one combat in the
14th and 15th century for armored
Knights or Menat arms fully armored guys
in plate armor was pox or spear then
with a backup of a sword of some kind
usually a long sword or an arming sword
and a dagger usually a Rondell dagger so
those were the primary and what seems to
be the most popular weapons so where the
falan and and um mace come into this
well one of the arguments that's been
made is that fans have some advantages
to them in that they've got better hand
protection they're little bit balanced a
little bit more Nimble than maces are um
and they've got a small uh kind of point
of impact because they've got an edge
rather than a large
surface however um as I mentioned in the
previous video there are some problems
with historical fions okay now this is a
13th century type and was clearly a type
that was used predominantly in the age
of male for chopping really really
powerfully not necessarily chopping
through male don't think that happened
uh but it would hit with quite a lot of
force but moreover in the age of male a
lot of soldiers on the battlefield
weren't wearing very much male or any
male at all some of them were wearing
fabric armors such as um gamerson and
acans and things like this so I have
made the argument previously that based
on the statistics of these weapons I
actually think these were for mostly
chopping up the low quality and low
equipped soldiers on the battlefield
these weren't
necessarily uh the the sword of choice
for the armored man to fight another
armored man and in fact the arming sword
was always more popular than the falan
at no point in history was the falan
more common or no point medieval history
was the falan more common than the
arming sword the arming sword was always
the most common type of Sword for all
types of soldier on the battlefield from
Knight to Archer the fou was preferred
by some people for some specific purpose
but we don't really know what it was now
note the shape of this large wide
chopping 13th century falion now go to
another relative of the falion this from
the 15th century look at this Lang
Messer which if it had a pommel on the
end we' call a falum this is a
completely different type of Blade um
it's almost like a large carving knife
basically okay and then now go to this
other type of Blade here an English
falion of the uh mid to late 15th
century completely different blade again
narrower but actually thicker and with a
reinforced point now this is a really
important Point okay there's a big
change in fions here not all fions are
equal uh these are clearly big choppy
things not very good for thrusting
useless for thrusting through male you
are never ever in the world going to be
able to push that point through the
mailed armpit of a of a opponent this
however completely different kettle of
fish so while this is a falan and this
doesn't have anything like the chopping
capacity of that cona type blade this
thrusting blade does much like an arming
sword or a long sword of the period have
the type of tip which is able to
possibly puncture through mail or find
other gaps between plates so absolutely
this is a product of its time this is a
light cuton thrust s
essentially like a little saber that can
be used for stabbing into male gaps and
into eyelets and stuff like this this is
not completely different types of falum
but there is something that all of these
if you consider these opposite ends of
the spectrum the pointy stabby falion
and the big choppy boy
falion they do have something in common
and that is they are light okay every
historical falion that I have looked at
in a museum or I have got the measure me
m of because one of my friends has taken
photographs and measurements of it in
the museum is thin and light these are
not big heavy these aren't estocks these
aren't crowbars these aren't maces these
are very very different to maces so we
must not make the comparison between a
falan and a mace because they're utterly
different they are much more fragile and
they are much thinner at the edge now
let's just talk about the thinness of
the edge there if as I said before if
you are smashing something like this
blade using period 13th 14th 15th
century steel into a hard piece of steel
armor you are going to fracture chip
Bend or break your
blade relatively soon okay using period
and we know this happened it's shown
it's mentioned in written sources and
it's shown in historical artwork so one
of the big problems we've got is we've
got a a data point looking at modern
reenactment weapons which are blunt and
in some cases overweight in the case of
most Bower fions if we look at a bowart
falion of 1.3 kgrs that has a thick
blunt blade it is going to survive
smashing into armor repeatedly and be a
very effective weapon because it has
adopted the characteristics of the mace
so what you've got is You've Made A A
sword-shaped
Mace so in that case you're really
looking at the qualities in my opinions
of a bar what in the makosi Bible or
Morgan Bible for example would be a bar
mace okay so absolutely if you make a
fan which handles like and weighs like
and balance like a mace it's going to
hit like a mace and it's going to also
survive like a mace but that's not what
historical fions usually alike not
saying that 1.3 kg is necessarily a
crazy weight I'm not saying they're
crazy overweight or anything like that
but these are thin
flexible very thin-edged blades clearly
they were not intended even if they were
sometimes used like this they weren't
intended to just be smashed into helmets
as hard as possible every time because
the blades wouldn't survive using period
steel
now again this is in no way criticizing
Deon because he makes some fantastic
points he makes a really good point that
I have to say I'd only vaguely thought
of before but it's a really good point
and that is that you could if you're
hitting a uh softly armored or
non-armored opponent use your thin Edge
to chop limbs off if you're hitting an
armed opponent you could flip this
around and hit with the blunt back Edge
now this is really interesting and I
think he's absolutely right I think this
is probably done and it's one of the
advantages of a single-edged sword is
you've got the ability to hit someone
with the blunt back for a percussive
effect that won't chip your Edge in the
way that if you hit with the sharp edge
it would moreover I suspect this was
probably done because we sometimes see
um
fions where the edge is not on the edge
the sharp edge is not on the edge that
we' expect it to be and I suspect that
this came about originally because
someone realized that hold on I'm
hitting with this side that works quite
well or I'm hitting them with this side
that works quite well because of the
angles of the blade I want my Edge to be
on the other side so I think that's I
think that's quite likely anyway that's
a tangent for another time but
fundamentally the falion in museums I
mean this the original of this is about
800 G if I remember correctly if you
imagine it had a handle on it cuz the
original handle missing this is really
really light okay this is a light
probably Archer or belman's sidearm okay
super super light the con falion is
probably at the upper end of the
spectrum but even this is not very heavy
it's about I think it's about 11 or 1200
G and yes it's balanced quite far from
the hand but it's a pretty light and
quick sword with a very thin blade it
has to be very thin to have that breadth
and not be horribly overweight and when
we look at things like Lessa or various
other types of falion that are around in
the 14th and 15th century they also tend
to have thin light and quick blades they
are not designed primarily for armored
fighting however I'll cave at that point
with the fact that some of them do have
these reinforced points and as decm says
you could absolutely half sword with any
sword you can half sword with a katana
you can half sword with a a rapia it's
shown in rapia text you can half sword
obviously with a long sword everyone
knows about or an arming sword and yes
you can half sword with a falan but bear
in mind half swording into someone's
mailed armpit or into their visor slit
is only worth doing if you have a point
which is capable of getting through the
mail there's no point half swording with
a con's falan because it ain't going to
go through any mail and it's not going
to get through any visor sliit because
the end is too big okay so you've got to
have a relatively small and pointy and
hopefully reinforced tip that will
actually have some effect now coming
back to
Maes so fundamentally you know fighting
in armor which is better out of Mace and
falan it's really down to personal
choice you've got a different set of
options with the falan as you have with
the mace but what I would say is that
when we're making that comparison don't
think about massive striking force of
these falan because they don't have
massive striking Force they're about the
same as an arming sword okay and even
something like uh the con's fan blade
yeah it has more than a it has more than
an arming sword but it is not a
historically made one with a thin Edge
and the correct weight and everything is
not comparable with a mace okay
so final thing to say is I think when
we're making these comparisons uh
between weapons we've got to remember
there are differences in how we use them
in a recreational or a bow hurt way or a
reenactment way or a heema way there are
differences in how we use them we never
really stabbing through mail so just
because I've successfully half sorted
into someone's armpit doesn't mean that
my sword point is actually going to go
through the male in their armpit male
works okay male armor works and they put
male in their armpits and the inside of
their elbows and the back of their legs
and all this kind of stuff because it
works so just because I am able to plant
my point into some part of the opponent
doesn't mean I've wounded them okay
that's the first thing um so I think
that sometimes we get a skewed idea of
the effectiveness of swords and Spears
and even poleaxes in armored
recreational fighting cuz we're not
actually stabbing through armor we're
not actually stabbing into male with a
sharp point we're not we're not
verifying that that stab would have done
anything whereas when you just hit
someone in the helmet with a mace you
more or less see what the effect of the
hit in the helmet with the mace was
because you're not doing anything
different to what you do with the real
mace which is hitting them in the helmet
with a mace so finally I'd just sum up
by saying out of uh falan and mace ramed
fighting my opinion
currently is that the mace overall is a
more effective weapon for armored
fighting against another armored
opponent in a duel one-on-one than the
falan is I think the falan is better
against lighter armored people because
you've got a long sharp edge and a point
and you're more able to more quickly and
for longer without getting tired deal
with a lot of opponents uh and take them
out if they've got lots of exposed you
know if they don't have armor on their
legs or their or their arms or their
face then you you've got more open ings
and more places to easily put them out
of action with this than you do with the
mace and astim says I agree your primary
target with the mace is the head we even
see that in Native American Warfare with
tomahawks the head is the main target
but in terms of Simplicity you don't
have any Edge alignment you can strike
all around all you all you're really
doing is smashing and bashing and um
you're able to sort of basically use
less expert teas I think with a mace and
that was always my argument in the first
place um with the mace than you are with
the um falan but also if we just use
historical evidence it does seem that
Maes and other forms of bludgeoning
instrument like warhammers were more
popular for armored Fighters fighting
other armored Fighters than falan were
but so I think on that basis the mace
probably edges it over the falan but
let's remember that all of these Fall by
the wayside compared to poxes halberts
um two-handed maces um long swords
arming swords rle daggers
Spears uh even glaes partisans these
sorts of weapon seem to have been more
popular so therefore I think we can
probably say they were more successful
and really in the 14th and 15th century
we have to reiterate that the armored
Knights
weapons of choice for fighting another
armored Knight one-on-one are the pox
the spear the long sword or arming Sword
and the rondle dagger the Falon and the
mace seem to have been more Battlefield
weapons and occupied a different space
and as some of the commentators under
our videos have noted it seems in some
cases the mace was a backup to the sword
in case the sword broke which is a very
interesting detail and people shouldn't
underestimate the importance of the a
stock and that's probably something will
come to in a later video and in this
context the nesto is essentially A
specialized thick and thrusting usually
long sword but can be an arming sword
but essentially a specifically thrusting
dedicated stiff long sword which
increases your chances of being able to
get through that male at the armpits or
anywhere else which as I say I think
some thinner bladed swords might
struggle some of the time to get through
good quality male well-made male and we
shouldn't always assume that a Thrust in
an armpit would have the effect that we
hope it would do anyway I hope that's
been thought-provoking remember to check
out de Tim's video down below it's
really cool and also it it relates to
this video very strongly maybe there's
some other things from that video which
I think we can probably um talk about in
the future as well uh but thanks to De
deim for that uh video thanks for
watching give us a like I hope you've
enjoyed this video and I hope I'll see
you back on the channel really soon
cheers folks thanks for watching we've
got extra videos on patreon please give
our Facebook a like And subscribe
subcribe if you haven't already cheers
folks

