We had to call the manufacturer!?

HowNOT2
100 followers
Jan 31, 2024
Titanium wasn't doing what I was expecting. We called Peter Lappas and asked him how he got his numbers. I love how these tests always make me go WOW!
We are the only ones in the USA that stock them currently alongside A LOT of other bolting products
https://hownot2.store/products/titanium-wedge-bolt
The drill-powered pulley you see in this episode is now available https://hownot2.store/products/z2
👉 Learn and SHOP at https://www.hownot2.com/shop
👉 Best EMAILS on Earth: https://www.hownot2.com/signup
👉 SUPPORT US and get gear discounts https://hownot2.com/support
👉 10% off ROCKY TALKIE by clicking https://www.hownot2.com/rocky
so I have a climbing bolt here that's
rated for 29 Kon and when we did our
first pull test we got 23 we're going to
explore why that is today what's special
about this there has been no certified
titanium wedge bolts available for
climbers I'm pretty excited about having
this as an option because sometimes
gluin can be a pain in the ass and if
you need titanium because you are near
the ocean in the type of rock that makes
even stainless corrode quickly uh it's
nice to have a wedge bolt as an option
since the bolt itself didn't fail in our
first test we decided to put the hanger
on a firm surface and remove some
[Music]
variables very similar results very
similar forces the one difference here
is this was a much smaller bolt we were
using but it still failed in the same
way Bobby you pulled it wrong you did it
wrong you installed it wrong it's not
against the right thing it's not against
Rock a and just a triple check we
decided to break it a third
time wow that's actually hot I was
really hoping we you're just hoping it
be just randomly different yeah so we
had something similar happen a few years
ago where we made a video called NBS is
a myth or minimum breaking strength is a
myth now before you throw stones at us
let me explain we would break this
hanger
after clipping a carabiner to it and
pulling at the rate we normally do which
all the other stuff was breaking above
the number but it wasn't breaking at
their numbers so since we couldn't
change the speed in which we pulled
something we decided to put something
very large inside of it to see what
happens we solved the mystery
48.4 or
10,650 lbs of force so we have this set
up with the largest pin that we could
fit in
there that changed the
result like there that whole sea chunk
is somewhere in the lab wow that is such
a different result Size Matters Bobby
now this isn't a contest on how big of a
thing you can fit into something before
you pull it the uiaa has a standard
you're supposed to follow when testing
this stuff and we didn't know what that
was so we looked it up and it didn't
actually have that information in there
refers to an e in standard which is
behind a pay wall which is always super
helpful to know that that stamp you're
indirectly paying for what it means I'll
try not to get into my feelings about
pay walls and the standards in this
video stay tuned so we asked Peter laas
how'd you test it and he sent us a video
which was amazing Bobby and I watched in
single speed the entire thing sitting on
the edge of our seat waiting at the 23 k
Mark to find out if it was going to
break
there they were pulling it 35 mm per
minute so
slow now they don't pull that way so
they can get the strongest number it
just happens to be that titanium likes
that that's how they test all their
bolts so we can't pull it at 35 millim
per minute because it would bore us to
death we decided it would be cool to do
a drop test I want to see if we can
break this in a drop test we are going
to clip this steel carabiner to the
hanger mounted on the steel plate that
we had on the slow pull test and we are
going to use this industrial sling this
spans set because it is static and is
static enough hopefully to give us the
amount of force we want and not break
got about 160 lb of weight and some
fluffed up bark to catch this and if you
want to see how a drop tower tree Works
got a video for you on that we've used
cap stands in the past and my car to
lift up the dummy but now we've got
these Z2
is there's our settings 3 2 1 3 2 1 whoa
Bobby watch out oh the this broke hang
the hanger
2849 which is much closer it's stronger
when you go faster so we got a much
closer to the rating still slightly
below but that's within the the range
and it looks like it broke the same so a
much faster Force seemed to generate
higher results with this titanium hanger
we reached out to our titanium expert
who's also a climber Martin at Titan
climbing and he makes these Eternal
gluin bolts that are titanium and we've
known him for years now and we carry
pretty much all of his products in our
store because I think they're quite nice
and I asked him why don't you make a
titanium wed Bowl now to get inside of
Martin's head he is thinking 200 plus
years as a solution that's his goal but
when we've installed wedge bolts uh we
found that they can work themselves
loose a number of different factors can
cause this mainly uh Big Falls or uh
free saw Cycles The Rock can and the
material can compress and expand and the
hanger can come loose and you'll need to
tighten it down again so this might not
necessarily be a 200-year solution but
we don't know and we're looking forward
to finding out I'm not going to be
around I'm going to be around yeah now
our epoxy 200-year solution epoxies have
not been around long enough to even know
it's all based on assumptions but the
glue is just sitting there it's not
under pressure until you put pressure on
there and the gluin that have been
installed that have been installed
correctly have done great up to this
point M if you know of glue in starting
to like crack fail or whatever and good
glue is used put them that in the
comments below so I thought an
interesting test would be something we
haven't done before is to cyclically
load this intention or straight out to
see if we can get it to work itself
loose okay I want to cyclically load
this thing so we got a 5 to one on the
end of a 2: one so one side is static to
a tree and the other side is the Z2
pulley that we use put a bolt
in 1 and
A2 two stop that's eight a little gu Gap
Gap going on here let's see if the bolt
is bent from that looks straightish
let's pull it
[Music]
again she's loose you know what I didn't
think
about removing this where the Carabiner
is smashed up against is all changed the
shape of that a little permanently
deformed oh my gosh what are the chances
that looks a little bent to me it
engaged better than I thought it was
going to and the solution to it being
loose was maybe just to tighten it back
up so what I'd like to see now is how
much force can we put on this before it
fails Let's test a titanium bolt not the
hardest rock I've ever
drilled my torque wrench is when my
elbow starts to hurt I
stop five I felt something
Shi
10.44 it all depends on the Rock You got
the bolt is fine it's a nice
bolt sad poop huh if you have Rock like
this and you know it's like this that is
where a glue in shines get it it is
engaging both Clips it just it didn't
engage enough oh well that's the problem
yeah it sounded good when I hammered it
even though the Rock's not good let's
see what happens in
Shear it's a four cutter by the
way so we're going to use a new bolt for
the shear test we're reusing this hanger
and this hanger is not horribly deformed
wedge bolts and bad rocks sometimes
won't tighten up it it'll just keep
spinning and that means your rock's
really bad but that tightened up just
fine oh my God the hanger broke it what
force Bobby so on this side of the 2:1
we saw
11.66 um so double that and add a little
bit uh gets us in the ballpark of what
they were breaking at yesterday so like
23 24 K oh that I mean that is
legitimately hot I'm not just saying it
so it got looser so the bolt came out a
little bit came out a little it's not
that bent threads look a little bit
marred over there which you would expect
can we throw a stronger hanger on there
and see what
happens holy moly we broke the actual
bolt that's awesome that's a 12 mil it
it broke beneath the surface of the hole
so where where the hanger wasn't where
it broke no no it's in the hole it's
it's like it's sheared it off it broke
where it was able to bend which that's
lower than the result we got when the
hanger broke wa that is going to be in
there forever literally forever now
making conclusions about this after
testing in some soft rock isn't helpful
or fair so what happens if we test it in
hard rock which we don't have so we
broke out a new toy that our friend
Lucas made us for testing glue inss in
Shear it has has removable cores that
you can glue something into or in this
case just pound it in y it's a tight
enough fit and if it doesn't come out we
were able to test that and
[Music]
sheer wow 30 wait what hanger did you
use a fixed hanger oh I was going to say
how did you accomplish that much that
that's amazing you're not going to get
that with the hanger that you should use
with this the Bold is stronger than the
hanger wicked cool pushed up against the
sidewall of the core what we saw in the
really soft rock it had way less support
and it broke at a lower Force now I
don't want to push my luck and try to
test that intention in the adapter
because that's not what it's designed
for so we went out to the boulder that
still has that bolt in it to try to
remove it and find out how strong it is
in
ttention wow it h so so we got
13.3 here so double that and add a
little bit so that's a higher result
than we've been getting which may be
because we work Harding it we also
pulled it pretty slow but we also did
the same speed out at the other rock
yeah yeah it's a little loose so like it
pulled it out a little pull out yeah I'm
pretty happy with that yep okay what is
the conclusion Bobby this could be a
great bolt in the right set of
circumstances it's not very good in soft
rock even though it's got the double
wedge that might indicate that it is I
am quite happy with this and I wanted to
do our research thoroughly before I even
stock them because they are such a
unique product and I am going to carry
them I am not going to share this video
until they are on our shelves so when
you see this it is on the Shelf now I
like to thoroughly test anything that we
are going to offer as a solution for
bolting I do want a solution for every
problem a Bolter might come across this
is great for hard rock near the ocean
where you need Titan tianium now if you
have hard rock and you're not near the
ocean use stainless and not all spots
near the ocean need titanium you'll know
it if they do so in case you can't tell
this video was not sponsored but I do
appreciate lapas for sending us these
and also sharing his test results he's
got a whole bunch of other products that
we are going to test and potentially
carry as well if you know a lot about
titanium please help make the comment
section as helpful as possible by
sharing what you know and if you want to
go see how the Eterna titanium bolts
break when we break them in real Rock
please go check that video out next and
if you sign up our emails you won't miss
any of the stuff that we are posting
cheers
