We tested quite a few paramotor carabiners and learned a lot about where the strength comes from and why climbing carabiners aren't square. Some of our tests where we pulled them diagonal show how you could get half the strength if your straps aren't wide, the reason for the square design. Our next follow up video will include fatigued aluminum since that is another concern.
So this video was supposed to be a short and 21 break tests later over three months. I
Am still not convinced. I know that much more
I'm gonna take you through the journey of why I decided to
Continue to break and break and break these because these are some pretty interesting carabiners doing some pretty interesting things
But watch the first set of break tests to find out why I kept chasing the rabbit
This oddly shaped carabiner is a paramotor carabiner
It's the only thing holding a stoked paramotorist to their wing and it's not redundant because they have two
It's like half Dundon because the fun goes you're pulling on your wing weird
Imagine looking over to the side and seeing your carabiner not closed
I know I'd have to change my underwear now CT shoot flyer or Brian likes to have steel
carabiners, which ironically this one says 22 kilonewtons and
The aluminum ones that he also sent me these are new is
Rated for 30 kilonewtons. The aluminum one is stronger and it feels roughly about half the weight as the steel one
but where steel does shine is
Typically when it's not closed all the way
It more or less I think performs better, but that's what this episodes about
He was doing wing overs and spirals and that put enough force on this apparently in order to permanently bend this
Enough to have enough deformation in there that it won't close now at all
Let's start with the new 30 kilonewton aluminum one with the gate closed
It's that pin that broke off as soon as it disengages from here
Then it opens up completely and then it breaks it there now. It didn't exactly break at
30 but super close enough fun fact is it did not break where the hole is the stress is over here
So the way I'm gonna set this up is I'm just gonna keep that gate from closing with this sling
Seems to still function just fine
At four kilonewtons, it seems to be
super good enough
Holy crap, it's still working just fine
My god, this thing is still working
It's still
Well, hot damn climbing carabiners say in this case seven when it's open eight of cross loaded
We did a whole cross load video. You should check out but these ones they only say
What it's rated for if you use them, right? So let's just pull it to just pull it to destruction
That's not too bad at seventeen point three seven
All right
So in this case
It did not break the gate because the gate was not being pulled on and it broke on the same side as the other carabiner
Now I want to know how strong this is when it's closed
And if I slowly pull it like I did the last one, it's probably gonna end up doing this
Let's just pull this close and see what happens
Holy shit, what the hell? I'm pretty sure I closed that look at that
That's damaged right that notch just isn't very big but it does plenty good on the aluminum
So look inside of there and you can see
There's lips, right? You look inside of there
It's like missing that thing pulled through
That's not very high like these didn't seem to have a problem
so you can see on this one that that blew out a little bit can see inside of there that it
Chipped it away as it pulled out from the bottom down here
What I don't see is damage on these so I don't think this got pulled out while he was
Flying around let's just
Open that fully and see what happens
Fun fact Dyneema holds its shape
Tell you massage it out
But that opened up just kind of like play-doh
As long as you have a big hydraulic to pull it
So you can see that was about four kilonewtons before like a deformation started to happen in here
So I wasn't quite convinced that I should put out a video until I investigate it a little bit further
And then I look in my email and this guy named Tucker got hit me up
I recently discovered your channel as it was reckoned to me by many of my viewers
I'll have him explain what his question was this all started out when I purchased that
$3,000 Aliexpress paramotor and the carabiners that came on it. I was a little bit skeptical about I decided to swap them out for
Carabiners that I knew I could trust and you guys in the comments recommended that I send the Aliexpress
Carabiners over to Ryan to have him actually break them and see if they would hold up to what they're rated to so I did
Exactly that so the Aliexpress paramotor carabiners came with a branding air extreme air extreme is apparently a somewhat reputable brand
However, if you look closely on those carabiners, it looks like the original branding was scratched off
Painted over and then stamped with the air extreme logo, which is why I was skeptical about them
They claim to be rated to a respectable 21 kilonewtons, but if you look at that logo
It's the same deal scraped off painted over and then printed 21. My buddy Dan did a little detective work
He actually did a reverse Google image search and found that the exact carbon copy of these paramotor
Aliexpress air extreme quote-unquote carabiners were available from Walmart under the branding call for about
$15 the suggested uses ranged from keychains to
Parachuting and they boasted great material in the description. I was skeptical to say the least
I should fire myself for not having noticed that has had paint on it
I didn't know this until I watched Tucker's video of our collaboration break test
You see when I started to scratch it off that it seemed to have the similar printing and information underneath
But then after I used goof off to get off the initial paint
It looks like they just printed it wrong over and over and over
I think this is a good lesson and not buying life-supporting gear from places like Aliexpress wish
Walmart or even Amazon because there's just not the quality control
That you need in order to depend your life on if they can't stamp this correctly. Did they get the right aluminum or steel?
poured into the big vat
Before they poured it into the mold before they made these things. You don't know and neither do I I bet you
They don't know this that notch just isn't very big and that's why it seems to be coming off
This carabiner is never really gonna sit in the center
It's gonna pick this side or it's gonna pick this side and obviously that side's gonna be stronger
I want to see what happens if your setup ends up on this side
That's not the full strength interesting how that pin
Came off whatever but it broke there looks like the
the notches on the inside
Seem to be intact looks like this is where it failed was on the back side of the gate came off the pin
So it was set up like this last time. I'm curious if this makes any difference because it's still pulling on the gate side right here
Is lower what the hell
12.39 if you have any side of your setup pulling on the gate side it is not going to break
At 21 once that gate opens up. There's nothing stopping this from coming apart
So the thing holding this is just this little notch right here, right and you can see that it's sort of
Missing a little bit right here. So this just isn't a good enough notch to hold the gate side
So then we decided to test a steel beater. That was from a quality brand
Here's an Austria Alpine stainless carabiner that has the lock at the bottom you push it in but it opens up here
This seems to have a much bigger notch in order to hold the gate in good for 26
10 open
That's way better no idea where the other pieces okay, it was like this last time let's see what happens when we do this
That was a little lower so a neat thing about steel is it will bend before it just snaps even though we're breaking
Yeah, still less than what it's rated for
So Brian sent me two more steel
Airextreme carabiners and these two tests we are gonna try to pull as best we can on the spine side
And then we'll pull the same way if it works out on the gate side to see if we can actually get 22
Okay, I tried to give this a fair chance and it slid to the gate side
No wonder you guys have horror stories of these things coming open
Not
22 kilonewtons now you might notice when I pull on these carabiners
It has them cockeyed and you're like, that's why they're breaking lower, which is true
But if you take a triple wrapped soft shackle here and you measure it it is
About an inch wide which I notice some straps that are on these carabiners are
Only that wide and this is really helpful to know if you are using a strap that isn't taking up the full width of the
carabiner
But then other straps look like they are taking up the entire width and therefore they are going to be pulling on the gate side
And the strong spine side more evenly
What's funny is whenever I've triple wrapped this in order to break some big carabiners that are for climbing
People say it was too wide and now it's too narrow
So I just got two more of these types of carabiners from Florian in Austria in their woody valley made by camp
They're rated for 18 kilonewtons and seven cross-loaded
He says there is quite some controversy in the community out replacing carabiners manufacturers indicate exchange intervals of two
To eight years depending on the material of the carabiner. However, not everybody respects these intervals
So he used these from 2019 to about 2021 for about a hundred and fifty flights and we're gonna find out how it breaks
When it's pulled on the span set the wide green sling I have on one side and one inch webbing on the other
That's the stress point
Showing the unpolished aluminum on the inside. That's pretty cool. How the anodization starts to wrinkle
That's the way it's supposed to be or not. I guess I should have checked before I broke it
Okay, let's not get into the aluminum versus steel thing yet or just continue to break these
Dimitri from Iris paramotors
Then hit me up and he was like, what about super air carabiners? I was like, why not? Let's see what happens with those ones
Shoot that is damaging that
And that is because whoa, that is really warm
That is that is that is amazing
The notch didn't break
The pin in the back did steel definitely reacts different. All right, let's do an open gate
So if something got pinched in there, let's see what happens
Don't be closing on me. It's supposed to be the open gate test
Provided with the gate open keeper
Okay, okay, okay, I'm not damaging this again so that could be at forces you get
No, I'd shit my pants if I saw this and I was in the sky
super
Rated for 20 KN. Let's find out if that's the case
There's the stress point on that one broke above MBS. It looks like the inside
No
Those don't look too healthy
And see that nose is scratched a bit when it got pulled off
But it's disengaging from here and the second it does that
Breaks on that part. So now let's test this aluminum with the gate open
It's a lot lower
Look at that. Those are fairly solid and that's because it wasn't attached to this at all
That's what a healthy one looks like. I mean, it's not that healthy here though
So the last ones that Dimitri sent me were the sketchy alibaba carabiners
This says Blackhawk 18 KN
Carabiners this says Blackhawk 18 KN
And that's that's it. I mean, what else do you need to know? There's a much more positive notch
and
That's from that side
The locking mechanism seems to be solid
It has a lot of play in it, but that should be fine kind of feels crappy to use it feels a bit cheap
I mean they are boasting 18 KN. So well it did what they said it would do the back blew out from that pin right there
Same result
the pin
Breaks in the back which makes this
this part
super good enough
Because it just comes
Like this until it breaks and then it just flies off. That's the mechanism inside in case you were wondering
That's all it is pretty fascinating unmaking carabiners
This is the longest I think i've ever chased a rabbit where I just keep ordering more stuff and breaking it
I got more Air Xtreme carabiners here. It's rated for 22 kilonewtons
And we're going to give it a more fair chance by pulling it with this two inch wide span set on one side
And this slackline webbing on another which is one inch
So we're not pulling just on the corner and we're going to find out if this notch is going to hold this gate
Super good enough and if we can actually get the 22 kilonewtons they claim
That is not
22 kilonewtons. How on earth are they getting this rating? They don't make this stuff up
How am I pulling it so different that i'm getting half of what they were getting?
It breaks those little tiny wings on the inside
You can see on the right gate that it has those wings on it intact and on this one
Does not
12.90 two for two
Is enough science for me to say that
That's not working. Yep. You can see the little wings inside the gate are broken
So when we broke the first two of these powerfly austria alpine paramotor carabiners
We did not pull on it evenly and we tried it both ways and we were not getting the mbs of
26 kilonewtons. These are steel and steel is supposed to be
more reliable now 17 is not a bad number. It's just
I don't know not 26. So what we're going to do now is tucker sent us another one
We're going to put it on the two inch span set here and we're going to take this webbing
Which is one inch put it on the more narrow side to give it the most even pulling fighting chance
We can to get to 26 kilonewtons
Oh, no
Are you kidding me?
That's supposed to be stronger when it's in a loop
But I have pulled it several times to be fair
Kind of looks like it's the same shape. It was taken over 20
It's working. We are getting more strength out of it. Okay, I doubled it up this time. Let's see how this does
They did it
They broke over mbs
So it looks like that pin sheared off
And then the gate came off
And therefore it was able to stretch
And that does that matches up there
That stretched a lot before it broke good job austria alpine
It looks like you have a pretty good carabiner
You see in this video how you pull it will determine how much strength you will get out of what you are connecting to
I would like to emphasize in climbing that if one of these carabiners magically broke you're still connected and perfectly good
But you are undundant
If you have two of these one breaks and now you're hanging weird off your wing
Oh, but we'll never hit those forces. We only hit 3g. Do you really want your carabiners breaking at 3.1 g?
You don't know what you don't know and so you need some safety margin, especially when you don't have backups
Ah now I don't think i've asked a paramotorist this so i'll ask you guys
What do you think about having a soft shackle because you can get these pretty tiny and they're pretty strong
and like maybe packing stuff up the whole point of this video is because people hit me up because they're
Concerned about these things now if you think the tests were faulty for the carabiners that broke really low
Well, I broke all the ones that broke super good enough
the same way
But now let's talk about steel versus aluminum because the real gear fear comes from aluminum fatigue where you get a micro fracture
Inside of the aluminum here where the stress usually is where steel will take it more like a champ
You basically are not going to fatigue this whereas aluminum
There are micro fractures, I think on this one
Because I have an entire bag of fatigued
Aluminum carabiners from dimitri and this is where I was like stop
This episode needs to end. We were just breaking the strength of perfectly good carabiners
But i've got a bag of perfectly not good carabiners if you've got some fatigued aluminum carabiners
Maybe we should pull test yours as well
You can hit me up at ryan at slackline.com and we will add it to this list and maybe I can break them all
At the same time so I don't have to narrate in between all of them
Thank you. Everyone who sent me something to make this episode happen and thank you tucker for collaborating with me on this your comments
Obviously steer the direction in which a video is made. I don't make paramotor content
But as you see we have a paramotor video now
Let me know how I can make your next paramotor video for the aluminum fatigue the best I can cheers