mod05lec22

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Dec 5, 2023
Carbonate System: Closed System
The lecture introduces the concept of carbonate system and its relevance to the environment; considering a closed system, equilibrium conditions are evaluated; the concept of ionization fraction is applied and VMINTEQ demonstration is provided.
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
hello everyone welcome back so we have
been discussing our acid and base
systems in the previous lecture sessions
right and we have been delving into
greater detail with respect to the
applications and the applications anyway
that we have been looking at was given
initial concentrations of various acids
or bases what would be the equilibrium
concentrations and obviously what would
the pH at equilibrium right this is what
we have been looking into and we looked
into them in greater detail and then we
moved on to log C pH graphs right and as
we discussed the log C pH the graphs
will you an idea about how the system
changes with pH right and again there
were widely used in the past and I guess
still widely used in India as of now but
with your particular knowledge or
background now that you are gaining with
respect to be able to use women tech
right and also with respect to the
mathematical tools available such as
Excel and such you can do other with
what is it now the log C pH diagrams but
again still whenever you are looking for
a snapshot of the system and if you have
one ready V available I'm talking about
a log C pH graph here you can always
have a look at it right so again now we
are going to move further and we are
going to look at a particular acid based
system pardon me which we come across
everywhere right in the natural systems
and in the engineered systems right and
obviously this is a bit curtiss-wright
our omnipresent and what does that mean
at something that's present everywhere
and in consumable concentrations right
and if you haven't guessed it already
it's going to be the carbonate system
and why carbonates physically because
subsurface you have deposits of calcium
carbonate and in the atmosphere you have
carbon dioxide so both of these more or
less will affect your carbonate system
and thirst because both these deposits
and the carbon dioxide in the atmosphere
are ever present that's almost always
going to need to consumable
concentrations of your carbonate system
or the carbonic acid or the bicarbonate
or Co 3 2 - right so we are going to
look at this system in greater detail or
the next two lecture sessions at least I
believe so let's move on to what we are
going to look at here so
what are some of the species that we
look at here right so here is the graph
that we are going to look at so we will
come back to this so the species
primarily r03 - - the carbonate so we
are going to identify the species and
this
in this acid based system so there are
three major species that we are
concerned with that are going to be at
equilibrium in your aqueous phase the
first one is the carbonate the other is
the bicarbonate and the last one is the
carbonic acid and the carbonic acid is
obviously going to stay in equilibrium
with the carbon dioxide in your gaseous
phase so let's go by one by one so c-13
- - an important source of this is your
CSU or three deposits right
and the subsurface or you know in the
ocean and such are the ocean bed and so
on so in general you will have
consumable or considerable source of
caco3 and the second case is going to be
or the second species that we are going
to look at is the bicarbonate the
bicarbonate
and
as you see from this particular logs
here pardon me the speciation diagram
here right at pH 7 right and where is pH
7
you see that the bicarbonate is the
predominant form of the species that's
going to be present right are the
predominant species in the carbonate
system so again at natural pH or neutral
pH pardon me the bicarbonate is the
particular ion that you are almost
always concerned with and that's what we
see here again
let's move on to the last particular
species that's h2 co3 the carbonic acid
the carbonic
acid pardon me so this carbonic acid
which is going to be in the aqueous
phase is going to be in equilibrium with
carbon dioxide in the gaseous phase
right
h2o h2 co3 okay it's bounced
what does this mean now let's say right
let's say if I have beaker of what let's
say and I put it up or you know leave it
open to the atmosphere right what is
going to happen now you have carbon
dioxide in the gaseous phase or in the
atmosphere all around it so over some
time let's say a few days or a day
depending upon the temperature and the
conditions in that particular room right
you are going to have an equilibrium
between the carbon dioxide in the
atmosphere or the gaseous phase and the
carbonic acid in the aqueous phase right
this is the equilibrium phase
equilibrium here again right so that's
going to be achieved over time and
that's the equation that we are going to
look at h2 co3 here right and this is
one particular aspect that I want stress
upon so people might have heard of
global warming right and you talk about
this greenhouse is gas greenhouse gases
carbon dioxide methane and so on but one
aspect that's maybe that hasn't received
as much attention but the scientific
community is acutely aware of it is that
increasing carbon dioxide concentrations
so think of this now other than the
global warming potential one major
aspect that threatens the way of life in
our aquatic systems is going to be the
pH or the change in pH or the drop in pH
so think of this now so you have your
atmosphere let's say Hammond I'm going
to model this with earth and this is
these are your oceans
right and this is your atmosphere
so as the carbon dioxide concentration
in your gaseous phase keeps increasing
right so that's what we are looking at
so obviously there's going to be an
equilibrium with the carbon dioxide in
the gaseous phase
but the carbon dioxide that is going to
be dissolved in your
aqueous phase and obviously as we just
looked at it you know carbon dioxide in
the aqueous phase is going to
stay as
h2 co3 or the carbonic acid
so what does this mean now so as you
keep increasing the concentration of
your or the partial pressure of your
carbon dioxide right what's going to
happen now you're going to increase the
concentration of h2 co3 in your ocean h2
co3 as we know right with our background
and so in the past few classes is an
acid that can donate a proton depending
on the pH right so what's going to
happen here you are going to decrease
the or have a slight decrease anyway
because we are going to look at the
large volumes here and the pKa two is
relatively high so anyway there is going
to be decrease if our unit slight
decrease or there has been a decrease of
the pH of the oceans now and the key
issue here is that most of the aquatic
systems are remarkably or almost all the
aquatic systems are remarkably sensitive
to pH are any change in pH so as the pH
drops let's say even by 0.1 let's say
you know I think six point seven to six
point five or so let's look at the graph
in the next lecture session or the one
after that so if you look at that let's
say the pH has dropped or the increasing
carbon dioxide concentrations have an
effect on the pH of your oceans now and
that has a remarkable effect or you know
a cascading effect on your particular
aquatic systems or aquatic life so
that's something that we need to be
again acutely aware of other than just
the global warming potential right so
again let's come back to our particular
cases here so we are talking about the
carbonate system and why it's ubukata so
it's present everywhere and the three
species that we in general look at are
0 3 2 -
the carbonate and the carbonic acid and
as we just talked about the carbonic
acid
right can stay in the form of
h2 co3 itself and the aqueous phase or
as dissolved carbon dioxide
right dissolve carbon dioxide so in
general when people talk about carbonic
acid they refer to both the dissolve
carbon dioxide and the actual carbonic
acid and in the water right so again
some people use the notation with
respect to an asterisk let's say right
and I'm referring to so whenever you see
h2 co3 with an asterisk this is what it
means to write different what we say
terms more or less or terminology
so now we are going to dig further into
it so again before you go further you
know this is an acid based system right
so obviously what are the major aspects
that you need to emit to think of right
it's going to be the PKA what is the pKa
of the system and as you see it's a
diprotic acid its h2 co3 so it can give
out two protons depending on the pH so
we also are going to look at the pH of
the system and we are going to look at
the two acid dissociation constants
right so as we can see from this
particular graph here it's going to be
around six point three and
ten point three
right but we are in general concerned
with the neutral pH
so as we see right at neutral pH
most of it as in almost eighty percent
of it as you see this is the ionization
fraction and what does what do these
ionization fractions you an idea about
let's write them down alpha naught alpha
1 and alpha 2 that is going to be equal
to h2 co3
the concentration by the total acid or
let me just write total acid here and we
are going to define total acid like we
did elsewhere sum of all the conjugate
acid and base species
all right when alpha 1 will give an idea
about the fraction that's present as hat
co 3 or the bicarbonate I guess a co 3
minus and alpha 2 is going to give an
idea about
the carbonate
fraction or fraction as carbonate right
alpha naught alpha 1 and alpha 2 that's
what you see here see how coming back to
the graph again at pH 7 we have almost
80% of it as hco3 minus and some of it
as I guess the 20% as
your h2 co3 right this is your h2 co3
graph and
that's what you see here so the two
species of the coordinate system that
obviously are present at your neutral
peach pH are going to be at 0 3 minus
and h2 co3 and obviously as you see from
this particular graph with respect to
the speciation you see that the pKa 2 is
10.3 so does the co 3/2 minus is only
going to be present in this system at
the relatively higher pH right and
that's a take-home message here so in
general again we are concerned with hco3
minus and h2 co3 and mostly with hco3 -
right and this particular bicarbonate
ion or the anion is going to affect your
system in multiple ways the applications
of which we are going to look at further
down the line let's see right so
obviously again we are now going to look
at your particular system with respect
to predicting the equilibrium values
right of the various species our
equilibrium concentrations pardon me of
the various species given that you have
initial concentrations of some relevant
components so let's look at that so I
guess there are two aspects we need to
clarify first one that we will work it
out for a closed system and
why are we like working it out for the
space and I guess the question that
should arise is why are we looking at
basically a closed system and why are we
defined that's basically now right as we
just discussed in the last few minutes
we see that h2 co3
right can be in equilibrium or will be
in equilibrium with the carbon dioxide
in the gaseous phase so for example let
say a solution that has carbonic acid or
the coordinate system in it is open to
the atmosphere let's say it's not closed
anymore but it's open to the atmosphere
so depending upon the relevant
concentrations the carbon dioxide in the
atmosphere can either dissolve into the
aqueous phase or the carbonic acid can
reach equilibrium or leave the system as
co2 into the gaseous phase again so
let's just try to represent what we have
been talking about so for example at
saying
you know this is my closed system and
there is a specific concentration here
with respect to h2 co3 head c-13 - and
co 3/2 - let's see alright but later on
let's say I open up the system
do you think the concentrations are
going to stay the same with respect to
h2 co3 hco3 minus and 0 3 2 - no and why
is that because the carbonic acid is
going to be in equilibrium right or the
carbon dioxide in the gaseous phase is
going to be in equilibrium with the
carbon dioxide in the aqueous phase and
what you see here so you can either see
a transfer of co2 from the gaseous to
aqueous or vice versa depending upon the
relevant concentrations and we know that
co2 in the aqueous phase is going to be
in equilibrium with h2 co3 in the
aqueous phase right so that's what we
just discussed so we are going to work
it out for two aspects right and
obviously that's relevant here so
whenever somewhere talks about the
carbonate system let us say out an
experiment involving carbonate you need
to look at you know are they trying to
maintain a particular carbonate
concentration and if so you know would
that stay in equilibrium with the
partial pressure that you would expect
in your particular atmosphere or is it a
closed system if so then that can be
that can go ahead I guess right anyhow
let's come back to our drawing table
here and we are now working it out for a
closed system which is not open to the
atmosphere right and let's say for the
sake of
sample that say we are adding any ahead
co3 and and here to Co three to our
system at relevant concentrations these
are all recipe species our initial
concentrations that we are act adding to
our system same adding any ahead Co
three and an yet to see were three to
the system and I want to know what's
going to the pH and what are the
relevant concentrations of your various
species right that you would expect in
this particular system so let's look at
that again obviously what are we going
to look at the only way to solve these
is going to be the component balance
component balance
right and whenever we look at component
balance we obviously need to define the
species
so for this particular carbonate system
we know that the species are going to be
h2 co3
hco3 minus and 0 3 2 minus the relevant
acid and conjugate bases or acids right
and what else we are always going to
have h plus and whoa h minus and here we
also have sodium so we are also going to
have the relevant sodium the salt here
right and because this is a closed
species we do not have any other gaseous
phase
species such as carbon dioxide here but
if it were an open system which we are
going to work out in the next lecture
session or once we are done with this
particular aspect we are going to list
or we need to list carbon dioxide in the
gaseous phase to write we are looking at
species species as in what is the system
or we are trying to analyze the system
at equilibrium so in this particular
case it's a closed system it's not open
to the atmosphere there is no no chance
of equilibrium with the gaseous phase or
no gaseous phase species in our current
list right and then the key is to choose
the components and what is the
components obviously we always try to
choose the H+ or the proton and then the
most deprotonated form of the acid and
that's going to be 0 3 2 minus and then
the salt or the sodium here right and
then the formation equations let let's
list them out please
the formation equations
so I'm going to first list all species
here so I'll go with the easier ones
first and here plus h plus h minus c
were three two - head co 3 minus and h 2
Co 3 right so let's see how can I form
them I need one component of any A+ to
be able to form any plus I need one
component of h plus to be able to form h
plus i need a minus one component of h
plus to be far able to form which - I
need one component of Co three two - to
form Co three two - I need one each of H
and C were three - - to be able to form
hit 0 3 - and similarly I need
two components of H and one component of
co 3 2 - to be able to form my
particular h2 co3 here right so I'm done
with the formation equations here so
obviously the next step would be the
tableau right and first year we are
going to list the components they are h
plus and what else please co 3 - - and
na plus again I'm going to list the
species so any R plus h plus
h minus 0 3 2 -
head 0 3 - and
h2 co3
right and the tableau though we are also
always going to have to list our
receipe species or the species that we
are adding to the system initially and
these are the two species here and what
are they here please and yeah hco3
not or the initial concentration of any
ahead co 3 that we are putting in and
and yet to see what 3 not so again we
are we have a closed system you are
adding and your head co 3 and na2co3
initially and they are that's going to
dissolve or both those compounds are
going to dissolve and then they are
going to form new species which we just
listed right and then here we are trying
to predict the concentration at
equilibrium right so again let's move on
here and from the formation equations i
am going to write this down it's going
to be 1 0 zero zero zero and zero and
it's going to be one component required
here and two components of sodium
required here right and here we have six
and six we are done there this is going
to be 0 1 minus 1 0 1 & 2 and where do
we get these values from obviously from
your formation equations here right if
you look at the coefficients here of the
relevant components that's where we get
them from and Co 3 2 minus here it's
going to be you need 0 of 0 3 2 minus 0
components of CO 3 2 minus 2 for many a
plus 0 components of CO 3 2 minus 2 form
h plus similarly with whoa h- but with
respect to C 1 3 2 - you need 1 same
case with hco3 minus and h2 co3 and now
coming back to your particular initial
species and for Co 3 2 - it's going to
be again 1 here and 1 here and here it's
going to be 1 and
0 right so we'll neglect any a plus
because usually place little-to-no for
the role right it's a salt it doesn't
play for the role so we are going to
only look at the total component balance
with respect to the H and with respect
to the co 3 2 - right so we'll work that
out further and see how we can analyze
the system and understand what are the
relevant variables that we are going to
have to consider in a closed system
right so let's move on let me see if I
can remember so H total is going to be
equal to h plus - or H -
and what else do we have I believe we
have hco3 minus and we will certainly
have 2 times
h2 co3 and that's going to be equal to
what now your any
hco3
not right so let me see if we miss
anything so 1 2 3 4 species are going to
be contain the component h plus and
that's going to be equal to nu hco3
naught 1 times right and same case with
0 3 2 - so the co 3 total component
bounce is going to be equal to what now
peace concentration of CO 3 2 - plus
concentration of H 0 3 minus
plus concentration of h2 co3 and that's
going to be equal to and you had Co 3
that you are putting in initially and
also the na2co3
that you are putting in
initially right
so let's go back and that's what we have
here so again what do we have here we
are balancing the component with respect
to H here and the only source of that
component is the initial any ahead Co 3
that you are putting in and same case we
are balancing the co 3 total here in the
second equation and the only source of
your particular co 3 in your system is
the Enya has Co 3 and na2co3 that you
are plugging in initially right so here
I believe we have around 6 species but
with the sodium balance we were able to
or we can calculate the sodium
concentration so let's remove that as an
unknown so we are left with five
variables right but here we have only
two component balance equations that we
have only two equations here so for five
variables we have two equations and
thirds we are still looking for the
other three and obviously here we are
looking at the equilibrium solution
right so obviously we the answer lies in
looking at equilibrium or the relevant
equilibrium constants so look at let's
try to write down or figure out what the
relevant equations are obviously because
these are acid and based systems we will
have the relevant acid dissociation
equations right so let's write them down
so you know that h2 co3 can dissociate
into what now H+ and heads Co 3 - we are
going to have that and again head co 3 -
can further dissociate or will stay in
equilibrium with h+ + Co 3 2 - right h2
co3 will stay in equilibrium with hco3
minus and 0 3 2 - and obviously will
always have water dissociation right
h+ + h - and so i'm going to list the
relevant equilibrium conch ka 1 and ka 2
for the two
protons that can be released by h2 co3
and the water dissociation constant kW
and the K 1 is going to be equal to the
activity which I'm going to approximate
by h+ h+ into head co 3 minus
by concentration of h2 co3
right and similarly I'm going to have ka
2 equal to h plus
in to see both 3/2 minus
by concentration of hco3 minus
and KW is going to be equal to the
concentration of h+ into the
concentration of O H minus right so
obviously all these need to be defined
in terms of activities right but we are
assuming that the ionic strength is
relatively less and Thurs we can
approximate activities by the
concentrations right so that's what we
have here and now we have three
additional equations right and so we can
solve for our five unknowns yes so
earlier we had two component balance
equations right our two equations from
the component balance of H total and Co
3 total and now we have three further
equations from the relevant acid
dissociation constants right our
equilibrium coefficients too and that's
the general term yes so let's see how we
can analyze this further but for now we
are going to concentrate obviously on H
total I guess right so obviously as we
discussed earlier to write and we looked
at the ionization fractions two dead
were derived using these three equations
right so you will have alpha naught is
going to be equal to what now h2 co3
times the concentration of h2 co3
plus hco3 minus
plus concentration of CO 3 2 - right and
that
as you can see the denominator what is
the denominator equal to now right and
that's going to be equal to or similar
to this particular variable here so it's
going to be equal to the co 3 total
right and
we are going to use that further
similarly alpha 1 is going to be equal
to h 0 3 minus
by symmetry total and
alpha 2 is going to be equal to 0 3 2 -
by Co 3 total again where do we have
this from Co 3 total it's from this
particular equation here right anyway we
are done with that for now so let's try
to analyze our solve for this particular
equation here H total so I'll move on to
the next slide here so
H total was equal to concentration of H+
minus concentration of H minus plus
concentration of H nu or 3 minus plus 2
times the concentration of h2 co3 right
so that's what we have here and we know
that this is going to be equal to ne
hco3 that we had initially right and now
taking it further or simplifying it so
that we have it only in terms of h plus
i am going to have it as
KW by h plus and has Co 3 - what do we
just have here I guess and hit Co 3 - we
have here so third head co 3 - is going
to be equal to alpha 1 into c bo 3 total
right that's what we just had looked at
in the earlier slide plus 2 times and
what is h2 co3 h2 co3 we can get from
this particular equation here that's
going to be equal to alpha naught into
Co 3 total right so 2 times alpha naught
0 3 total
the thoughts we are going to arrive at H
plus minus kW by
concentration of H+ plus
alpha 1 plus 2 alpha naught into
Co 3 total and this as we know for
anyway for our particular system because
we are initially adding and your head co
3 so that's going to be equal to ne
ahead co 3 not right so again we are
looking at the coordinate system why
because that's wicked us and that's
going to be present in
most or almost all your Inuit systems
and certainly in the natural systems
right and we try to analyze it for a
closed system when it's not open to the
atmosphere and here we have the relevant
particular variables so let's look at
what they are so in general the relevant
variables you need to consider in your
carbonate system which is closed for a
closed system what are the variables h
total Co 3 total and pH right and this
and all your variables are going to
depend upon these three factors and
that's obviously apparent from your
particular equation here so we just
looked at how to analyze the closed
system right by hand and now we are
going to move on to analyzing the system
by our particular software we mean take
and for this let's look at a particular
values with respect to our receipe
species let's take any
hco3 naught is equal to 5 milli molar
and letters for sake of ease also take
any R 2 Co 3
not to also be
5 milli molar right
so again here we are trying to work it
out by women Tech and we are saying that
both the recipe species or the compounds
you are putting in or adding to the
solution initially which is and you had
Co 3 and R which are and yet to head Co
3 and na2co3 are both equal to 5 milli
molar concentration right so again
before we plug in women take right we
always want to understand or try to
predict the
species or at least certainly the pH so
let's try to take a call on that so keep
in mind that we are adding high Co 3 and
I believe Co 3 2 minus sources of hco3
minus and Co 3 2 minus and we are doing
that at relatively the same
concentration right so more or less we
are adding the conjugate acid and base
right so we are adding that at the same
concentration the key is that we are
adding them at the same concentration so
third what would you expect that the pKa
would be equal to the pH right as we
know
when the protonated form and the
deprotonated form are at equal
concentration when is that that's only
going to the case when pH equal to pk
and I think the PK was around or ten
point two or ten point three so let's
see your where we are going to be right
so first we need to define our hitch
total and that I believe is equal to ne
ahead Co three not right and that's
going to be equal to five millimolar and
what's our Co three total that's going
to be equal to n your head CO three
naught
plus na2co3
naught and that's going to be equal to
ten milli molar and
the sodium total sodium is going to be
equal to ne hco3 naught
plus two times and yet to see were three
not so that's going to be equal to 15
milli molar all right so five ten and
fifteen so now let's plug this in into
women Tech and here we have pH to be
calculate from mass balance and
explained to be calculated so I'll use
the units as milli molar and first we
are going to add H+ or I guess initially
we have C here so we are going to add Co
three to minus and we believe we had
that to be 10 millimolar all
concentration right so I'll have that at
10 and add that to the list and next up
should be H and that we said was going
to be equal to 5 milli molar that's
going to be 5 milli molar and we have
sodium and
that we said was going to be equal to 15
milli molar and that's going to be add
to the list so let me check or confirm
that all the three are the relevant
concentrations that we want so the three
compounds for H at 5 milli molar Al
Sieber 3 at 10 and any a total at 15
right so we are on the right track and
I'm going to go back to main menu and
run min Tech and so obviously the pH is
now nearer to the pKa value of 10 point
2 or 10 one three so that's something we
are fine with and we see that we have
different concentrations here right and
one reason why the pH might be slightly
off is that the ana strength is
relatively high so that's going to
affect your particular concentrations
and that's what you see here I guess
four point two here and two point four
here and so on and more importantly let
us look at the species distribution what
will that give an idea about it will
tell you in what forms or in what
percentages is co 3 total or Co 3
present as so it looks like it couldn't
present as as we know co 3 2 minus h co
3 - right and looks like nothing will be
present as h2 co3 why is that because
the phe is 10 point 7 so it looks like
42% is present as co 3 2 - right and 51
percent is present as hco3 minus and one
particular species that we missed was
any co 3 i believe that the KA value for
this or the equilibrium constant for
this would be relatively less or
negligible but that seems to be a minor
error there or minor assumption that
shouldn't have been taken so anyhow
women take confirms this so that we have
42 percent as co 3 2 - and 51 percent as
had co 3 - and why do we have slightly
higher concentration of hco3 - compared
to see were 3 2 - that's because the pH
is 10 point zero 7 and the pH is 10
point zero 7 and the pKa is ten point
three right so which one will
predominate now the protonated form will
predominate and the protonated form in
this case for that PKA - is head co 3 -
so head 0 3 - is that is slightly higher
concentration right and then compared to
the co 3 2 minus concentration and I
believe that's what we are going to see
here hu or three - is slightly higher
than co 3 2 - right and I guess with
that we'll be done with today's lecture
session so in the next lecture session
or couple of lecture sessions anyway we
are going to try analyze the open system
right and with that I will end my
session for today and thank you
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Music]
