Mod 03 Lec 15

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
1 Video View·Dec 4, 2023
Pile Foundations under Lateral Loads: Conventional and Elastic Methods
Prof. B. K. Maheshwari
Dept. of Earthquake Engg.
Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee
Roorkee -247667
[Music]
[Music]
so
i welcome you again for this nptel
lecture on earthquake resistant design
of foundations
and under this ah course
as we discussed earlier we have five
modules and we are right now
working on pile foundations and during
the pile foundations we have already two
lectures on the pile foundations and
what we have covered
is piles for vertical loads
and we when it is subjected to static
loads only so we have not considered
today what we are going to consider
is perhaps the most important part of
this course
on earthquake resistant design of
foundations
as i mentioned earlier that pile
foundations
are the important to be used during the
earthquakes or lateral loads so the the
design of piles when they are subjected
to lateral loads we are going to
consider
and today we are going to talk about
that so when we talk about lateral loads
and piles
these are the issues which we are going
to talk first thing is we are going to
talk about introduction
then we are going to talk conventional
methods of analysis
then elastic methods using winkler
approach
later we are going to talk about
solution for pilots and cohesive soils
solution for piles in clay and then
design processors and numerical examples
so when we talk about let us talks
introduction on lateral load and piles
you may be aware that pile foundations
are subjected to lateral load and
movements
which comes due to wind loads or seismic
forces in buildings
earth pressure and retaining walls and
abutments
it could be due to water pressure in the
water front structures
or offshore structures which is also
subjected to lateral load so what we are
going to talk
is not will be applicable during the
earthquake
but it will be equally applicable for
any type of lateral load whether it is
due to wind whether it is due to water
ah pressure or it may be due to earth
pressure on
retaining walls the conventional
analysis
which assumes that piles do not resist
any load in the bending and the soil
reactions to piles due to lateral
movement is negligible
so this is the in the conventional
approach
that means the flexoral rigidity of the
piles is not considered
as well as the piles will not be able to
carry
the lateral load this is a conventional
approach however
according to this approach conventional
approach the vertical piles cannot
resist
lateral loads and as a result you
require
inclined piles or what is called
battered piles
are necessary to resist the lateral
loads but
this this approach is unrealistic
and how why it is unrealistic let me
explain to you
actually you know that this is similar
to what you can consider like a column
when you talk about column column is
free it is not supported by the soil
it may be only but pile is not free it
is supported even if you have vertical
pile
is still in fact it will be able to
carry some lateral load
it is not necessary to carry the lateral
load that you require the inclined pile
because simply the pile is supported by
the soil
and whatever the soil capacity is there
between the when you apply some lateral
load on the pile
ah soil will provide the support so that
support is considered
in the latter theories while in
conventional theories
this is neglected and ah
so later theories account the bending of
piles as well as
that lateral support of the soil so when
we talk about the latter theories these
available approaches can be grouped into
two categories
one is based on elastic theories another
is based on plastic theories
so we are going to talk in detail
those approach based on elastic theories
plastic theories will be little
difficult to cover because that will be
based on finite element analysis and
plasticity models
so lets talk about conventional approach
and then
so continue with this when we talk about
elastic theories
which is most famous theories for
lateral loads is called by reach and
matlock
proposed in nineteen fifty six
which assumed the soil to be replaced by
a series of closely spaced
independent elastic springs which is
called winkler's assumptions
the equation for a beam on elastic
foundations
utilizing the concept of subgrade
modulus has been
sold for different conditions
and after solution known dimensional
solutions have been given
for a laterally loaded vertical piles to
determine the variation of deflection
bending moment shear force swell
reactions etcetera
along the entire pile length and while
calculating this this require a
knowledge of
elastic constants of the soil which is
young's modulus e and poisons ratio so
for calculation of deflections
bending moment and shear force naturally
we require
two basic soil properties one is young's
modulus or may be shear modulus and the
poisons ratio
so once you know the young's modulus in
shear modulus ah shear positions ratio
then you can get the shear modulus
so that is important so this was the
introductory part of the
python lateral loads now lets talk about
conventional method
when we talk about conventional method
the conventional methods are
ah we are going to discuss it into two
part
first one is of when piles are subjected
to moments only
and piles are subjected to lateral load
q so in this case i will like to explain
that ah the pile which is subjected to
moment is basically equivalent to
ah a vertical eccentric vertical loads
so this is if you recall we have already
discussed so this is uh
in case of cello foundation we have
discussed but for pile the same thing
will be applicable
let us say this is pile though this is
diamond and if i apply
a central vertical load here
v and a moment m
now this can be replaced by
ah i can have this equivalent moment so
you will have
ah this
this can be simply replaced by ah
central line this one so a vertical load
acting
at an ascent city e so this will create
a moment basically if i ah like do this
apply and then this will create a moment
acting like this
so in this case the moment should act in
this direction
and so what you will have e will be
simply
ah m by v so this is equivalent
so whether we say spile subjective
moment
or what we call a centric
vertical loads
so load is not centric so this is the
same case
this thing we have discussed in detail
when we talk about ah
shallow foundations so and then the
second this
is pile subjected to lateral load so let
us discuss that when the piles are
subjected to moment first
so what are the assumptions first
assumption the pile cap is assumed
as regist pile cap what is we already
discussed
the load on each pile due to moment is
proportional to its distance from the
centre of gravity of the pile group
the settlement of pile is proportional
to the load acting on this pipe
so for example ah lets so this is we
have a pile group
ah four piles are there in a row this is
the center of gravity of pile group here
and then what you have ah
that in this case you have the
loads are acting here downwards so what
you have is ah
this is subjected to a vertical load as
well as moment
so here the figure shows a pile group
subjected to
vertical load and the center of gravity
of the group and the moment
reaction in each pile is caused by a
vertical load as well as moment as is
shown in the figure
one b and one c so this is due to this
ah
the first figure shows the reaction cars
these are this is the plan
basically this is the plan ah which is
obvious to you
and this is elevation of the and
then you have this this shows the
load in each pile due to vertical load
and this figure shows
the load in each pile due to moment m
now what will happen
the total load coming on each pile will
be the combination of
this this diagram and this diagram which
is shown here ah so you will get maximum
on this side and minimum this side
and this is due to you can say that
eccentricity
if you recall that ah whatever we have
discussed in the solo foundation
similarly so
ah because this moment is acting this
direction that means
this will be equivalent to a load acting
at eccentricity
ah this will be the similar to acting at
so in this case this will be equivalent
to a load vertical load and this can be
replaced simply by this
a vertical load or i can say that sigma
mv
is acting at an eccentricity e
where e is summation of e is given by
this relation
summation m or summation of v
so because one of the assumption is here
one of the assumptions we have assumed
is that
from static equilibrium summation of
moment should be zero and summation of
moment about what
summation of moment about the center
points c g of pi
group about this point should be zero so
here
you take let us say finally we get this
bending moment
p one p two p three ah p one p two p
three p four
are the loads on each pile due to this
moment
m and these will be proportional to the
distance of the
point from the cg that means where the
at the center of gravity
there will be no p due to the moment
so this will be zero here and as you go
away its value increases
so total will be ah if we take the
moment about this
cg so what will happen so this c g
will be that ah p one into ah d one plus
p two into d two plus p three into d
three
plus p four d four so you have this
second equation gives you the total
moment
and then the these are the linearly
distributed that means p one and
p two p three p four are in proportion
of their distances so equation three a
will be holding
for the linear distribution of the loads
and then what we can have from equation
three a can be written
in another form that p two p three p
four can be found in terms of p one
and then finally we put all these
numbers in ah equations two
and we get equation four a which is
summation of m
in terms of p one so solving this p four
a we can get the value of p one in terms
of m so you get summation for m d one
and summation of m d square so here ah
d square is a distance square if this
was the case for first pile
so when you keep two three four the so
this generalized form
of this equation can be written as p n
equal to summation of m
this is for one direction suppose if
this where n is
strained for the number of piles if the
moment
summation of m is acting in another
plane also in that case
you may have the similar equation as
shown in four d
and finally due to the moment as well as
due to the
ah vertical load the total pressure
coming on any pile can be find out from
this relation
where you have this p equal to summation
of v by n plus summation of d square d
n plus d m so where n and m is
your number for which you want to find
this so
ah this load ok let us have one
numerical example and it will clarify
that
ah that how this can be processed here
you have a pile group of ah eight piles
ah in a row you have four piles and you
have two rows of the four piles each
the spacing between piles on x direction
is one meter
while in the y direction is also ah
along the y axis is also one meter
now this pile this is in the elevation
in this direction
ah this vertical load applied is 500 ton
and a moment is applied which is about
about you you have this one so this is
about
this moment will be acting about y axis
so about y axis five hundred ten meter
per meter and
about x axis it is two hundred fifty ten
meter it is shown here
so now these two moments are acting and
the vertical load is acting so the pile
is subjected to one vertical load and
two moments
we need to find the load coming on each
pile
ah one two eight and so that can be sold
like this
ah for n equal to eight summation of d
n square will be like you know that this
here how this is calculated
you have for this ah ah
here if i talk that being the
symmetrical about this axis if i take
the
distances n is measured from this side
so you have point five for these two
piles
and then you have one point five and the
same thing is here and the two rows you
have
so this can be calculated two times four
point five square plus one so ten meter
square
same thing is when i have here along
this axis there are eight piles
and each one have the distance 0.5 meter
from this axis
so it is 2 meter square and then you put
the numbers all the numbers 500 by 8
and 500 into 1.45 is the 4
ah the maximum load will be subject to
pile number one will be subjected to
maximum load and pile number eight will
be subjected to minimum load how this
comes
actually if in this equation if i use
plus
here and plus here then that will give
the maximum load if i use
minus on both place then you naturally
will get the minimum value
so using the plus sign here so you have
plus sign both the cases
then you get two hundred ton if i use
the minus sign then you get minus
seventy negative sign shows that is bc
this is
basically this is uplift so the pile one
will be subjected ah
it will be here sorry this will be pile
eight so this will be pile eight p
eight will be there so you have this
ah ah this minus seventy five ton so you
get here for uplift
then continue with this what you have
the pile subjected to lateral rods
and ah earlier what we have considered
the piles which was subjected to
ah piles which are subjected to the
moment only
now we are going to consider the piles
which are subjected to lateral load
and in this case ah at the
vertical load is applied and a
horizontal thrust is applied
ok so a vertical load and horizontal
thrust
if i combine both these loads then you
will get an inclined
loading and inclined load use is shown
in this figure as
r ok and r
is shown here how we can do this one
this can be done what is using this ah
graphical method
and the solution can be find out using
the graphical method and that is called
coolmens graphical method coolman's
graphical method is used
so using this ah let us let us say this
is the problem given here
and ah and piles are grouped
so what is done here piles are group
according to their slope that the piles
in each group is subjected to equal
axial loads
the ah and the steps which require first
of all dry dimensional sketch of the
pile foundation
locate the center line of each group of
parallel piles so what is done here
you have let us say one two and three
section so one
may represent a pile group itself where
the center of each pile group is passing
through this
rotate line for two inclined and three
four vertical
so now you have in this case let us say
three pile groups or three piles
where the center lines are known to us
so locate the center line of each file
group of parallel piles the next step
draw the resultant r
of all action applied on the pile
foundation r intersect to the center
line of the piles in group three at
point a so what is done
this is the r so the the value of r
is given to you as well as this location
where it is acting at the on the pile
cap is also known
so r is completely known so what we do
we extend the
vector of r and wherever it is cutting
is called point eight so this is the
point a here
ok and the an another thing what we do
ah so point a is will be the point
of direction of r wherever it intersect
the center line of pile three
ok then pile one and two we extend the
center line of each
and the intersect at point b so simply
extend here so now you have a and b
and then we combined direction a b so
what we do now ah we resolve the
comp the force r into q and v
where v is the vertical and q will be
have the same parallel to
a b ok so now this
r load is divided into part
v will be carried by pile group three
while q will be carried by the combined
pile group one and two then you resolve
again
into q into two components one is q one
and another is q two where q one ah
you have this is acting ah here and q
two
is acting downward so what you have q
two and q one
so ah q one is vertical
and q two is parallel to this direction
of center line of two so q one load
will be sub the for group one and q two
will be
for group two so this is how ah this
resolving the different components are
we could find
what the load sharing mechanism will be
by pile group
one two and three if you have more than
three pile groups
then similar approach can be done so
what we do we have one pile group
and then three are combined and then
eliminating like this
so this is ah more than three direction
the pile directions are compounded
further
the analysis described this ignore the
capacity of soil to withstand the
horizontal loads
and the capacitive piles to withstand
bending hence these are
not realistic analysis so in the
conventional method
there is a major drawback so basically
the conventional method will be
very uneconomical it is conservative
method
it assume that soil is not providing any
support to the pile
and not the pile do not have the bending
capacity
so both of these are unrealistic
assumptions because soil provide the
support to pile and the second thing is
ah the
this pile being mostly of concrete they
have good bending capacity or flexoral
rigidity
so due to this ah limitations these
conventional methods are now getting
obsolete for pile design but still for
the simple cases
these are can be used for to work out
the pile load capacity or at least
to check the results from that so any
any anything which is a design from
other methods
like you know that should can be checked
that approximationally that how
it perform using conventional method
so now we come ahead from the
conventional method
then other methods elastic methods yeah
and then one part before elastic method
is limit analysis
and the in the limit analysis what is
done it is assume that the maximum soil
resistance
acts against the pile as shown in the
figure so you could see here
p one is the lateral load applied on the
top of the pile
so what will happen ah so the soil will
try to provide resistance so the
this resistance which is provided by the
soil was neglected by the conventional
method
in fact in the modeling for soil pile
the soil is replaced by spring and
dashboard and
spring particularly ah if you do not
consider the damping
so but in the conventional method the
soil is neglected
here so reaction which is when i apply
some lateral load in this direction
so soil will try to resist it and this
resistance may be this side and then
ah then there could be like you know
that on another side depending on this
so when the lat now here is the case
the second case when the pile is
subjected to
vertical load lateral load as well as
moment so you could see it is subjected
to p m q all three forces
which is the very general case and what
will happen
they will try to differ ah you know
deflect the pile as well as bend
so pile will undergo bending as well as
deflection so you have this ah the
reaction soil reactions at each point
will be
simply p into k x over y x what is y x y
x is the
deformation at that particular depth x
where x is ah
like a different locations so i think
yeah this is something
here in this axis there is something
wrong this is x axis
and this is considered y here it is
other way
because y is the deflection in this
direction and x is the depth
so along the depth so this is here
and when you apply this load
so so then you can have this deflected
shape of the pile
so this was for the limit analysis but
for the limit analysis
that it is considering the limiting
values of the soil
then more realistic analysis is called
plastic method
using winkler approach and this elastic
method using winkler approach
we are going to discuss in detail
a laterally loaded pile often treats as
a beam
on an elastic foundation ok so this is
the case
and according to winkler the elastic
soil medium is replaced
by series of infinitely close
independently elastic
springs so this will be you know an
elastic is
springs not one a number of springs will
be there
so the stiffness of these springs may be
written
as ah so ah this this will be again
springs may be written as
k equal to p by y so what you have here
this is the you could see this is a pipe
actually pile is vertical
right so for understanding what we did
we have ah you know that ah so you can
understand like this
in this case this was your pile and
soil provide the support from both sides
but timing assume that the soil
support coming from the soil is all
around the pile
and the whole support is represent on
one side
so we have one side soil and one side
pile the one side soil support which you
are considering is
ah representing whole support all around
the pile
then now if i this is vertical if i
do that i made this horizontal soil is
this side
and then i put like this so what will
happen
now your pile become a kind of a beam
which is supported
by soil which is shown here
so this is beam of and the rigidity of
the beam is e i
where e i is the flexural residue which
is the same of the so instead actually
ah the difference this is a let us say
pile if i do like this this is
can be considered like a beam which is
supported on the soil springs
so which is shown in this figure so what
we can do here
what will happen when you apply the load
from the top so the
w what is w w is like a lateral load if
it is a
lateral load is acting like this now i
can consider like this so w is acting
downward and this will try to deflect
the pile
and when the it is try to deflect the
piles you will get the you know that
because it is concentrated load at the
center so maximum deflection is expected
at the center
and it will get decrease and soil will
try to push it
soil will provide some support reaction
now this soil reaction the value of the
soil reaction
depend on the deflection and in this
case
it is expected that deflection is more
at the center
less at the edges so the spring constant
or spring value which is going to come
at the center
is expected to be more than the at the
aces because it will be
so basically ah this stiffness of these
springs
is written as k equal to p or y p into
ah
p ah divided by y so the soil reactions
what will be the sole reaction soil
reaction is ah
load per unit length that is kilo in
kilo newton per meter
so what is expected for the if you have
keep the same deflection
and the soil properties are also same
then p will be also throughout same
but deflection is not being expected to
be same
so p is going to be more at the center
for the same soil property
if i assume that all the springs have
the same value of k
so naturally y is increasing at the
center so you will get
the more value of your sole reaction at
the center as the aces so depending on
that
so so anyway so what is this here the
stiffness of the spring may be written
by this way this way
and this stiffness is basically soil
reaction
divided by the deflection and soil
reaction
is in kilo newton per meter and
if i divide this with the deflection
then you will get
the value of k in kilo newton ah per
so stiffness of soil is termed as the
modulus of horizontal sub grade reaction
and the unit for k is in kilo newton
per meter square and the values of k
now the k which is said to be spring
constant
it is not constant even if you have
let us say because this is not the
horizontal case actually pile is like
this
so again we consider like this so what
is expected
that ah if we go down and down here and
the diff
the deflection may normally if your soil
get higher harder
and denser then the deflection may
reduce at the down
so depending on the like you know where
you are applying the load and
so what happens here the values of k
varies with the depth that means the
values of
a spring constant is not constant with
the depth
rather for the sandy soil it is expected
that
the values of this spring constant are
increasing with the depth
but normally the variation is not so
much in the
case of clay or cohesive soils so let us
first talk about
kind of variation so this equation here
ah shows the values of k varies with the
depth and you could see k
x equal to k h into x l s over n where
what is n
n is your some coefficient and the value
of n
is more or less near by one it could be
one
it could be little less than ah it may
be less than one or it could be greater
than one
so even some cases n may be zero so it
may be zero to one
and then when you on the higher side it
could be one point five or so but
not more than two should not be
considered so basically the range of n
may be between zero to two
but most of that cases it will be around
one so
maybe more than one or less than one or
less
so and it depends on the value of n will
depends on the type of soil
so what is here k h k h is value of k at
pile tip
at x equal to l s so what you can have
so this equation can be basically
represented if i consider
n equal to one ah so ok in the next uh
it is shown here
so what you have for different cases
here it is shown here
so tarjay what does jackie have
recommended he have recommended n one
n equal to one four sent and n equal to
zero for clays so you could see
ah that this is for the sand this
variation is linear
for the sand variation of k h is linear
while for clay it is constant
ok so you have this one for the sand if
we i assume n equal to one then i end up
in this equation k h into x by l s
so if i divide k s by l s then i get
another coefficient
which is called constant or coefficient
of modulus of sub grade reaction
and its unit is kilo newton per meter
cube so nh
and this is mostly applicable for sand
for clay
n may be 0 and once you assume n equal
to 0 then k x may be equal to k h that
means
the value of this this k
x is the same as the from top to bottom
linear
so this is the case here and this these
three figures are showing
ah good variation for this this value of
k
so now this ah this coefficient of sub
ah modulus of gradation eta h it is
very important and we are going to use
for in further analysis this coefficient
and before that let us work on that what
is this
this how this what is called
characteristic length of the pile
so there is one term called
characteristic length of the pile
and which is ah defined ah using what is
called
ah l alpha and what is that we try to
understand this one
what has been what is the theory behind
this the prakash
and sarn in 1967 ah
that reported test data on modal piles
subjected to horizontal load at five
centimeter above the sand surface
the pile lines are here ah what the
pylons they have considered for the
testing ten centimeter twenty seven
thirty forty fifty and sixty centimeter
the the deflection of the piles at the
ground level are shown in this figure
it is seen that as the pile length
increases the ground deflection of a
pile of constant cross section
decreases at the same load and the
length l alpha is defined
as the infinite length of the pile
and this will obviously be a function of
the pile stiffness e i
and soil stiffness k so
what is happens here you could see this
in this figure
10 20 30 40 50 60 okay
now what is happening that if i see
there is a gap
between 10 20 20 30 40 but the 50 and 60
curves are very close that means for a
given load for example if i assume
for the load eight kilogram force then
if i draw a line so you could see
that ah when the deflections are
decreasing when i go from twenty two
it is decrease very much when i go to
twenty thirty but then rate of
reflection decrease becomes very less
here and and then there is hardly any
difference so that means
ah there will be length of the pile
after which there is no not much
difference on the deflection
and if you are no change in the
deflection even if you are keeping
ah keeping going to increase the pile
length and that the
length will be defined as infinite
length of the pile and this length will
depends on stiffness e i and soil
stiffness k
so that means it will not only depends
on the
ah the properties of the pile but it
will be depending on the soil properties
also
and this is of ah
represented later on using a relative
stiffness factor which we are going to
talk about
when we talk about vertical pi under the
lateral load
then this stress strain and load
deformation relationships are invariably
non-linear
as shown in this figure four nodes of
less than one third to one half their
ultimate values
the load deflection curve can be
adequately expressed by a tangent
modulus as shown here
so that means what what is you could see
here actual cases this is
but for the initial part up to this
point it is almost linear
so we can have load deflection
relationship up to this point
ah that means the slope of this line
curve is a constant
and which can be represented by tangent
modulus however
after that this is not constant and
the slope is varying at different values
of reflection and other things
so you need to find the value of modulus
at different location and secret modulus
which is simply so what you have in this
case second modulus
just joining this point and this point
you get the second modulus
and once you have this ah that
this will keep varying so it is
difficult that ah when you
you work with the second modulus so then
every time it will keep changing
so therefore application with linear
velocity solution is not ah justified
and we need to account for the normality
for the load and pile deflections
and for this either we may employ
repeated of the elastic theory
and the or the relationship between the
second modulus and the modulus can be
defined in terms of strain level
so these things we are going to discuss
later
in the next part of the presentation so
like ah this will be ah up to this point
and i i will talk about this how to
apply
whatever we have discussed in this
lecture for particularly
modulus of sub grid reaction and that
need to be applied
for when you have ah piles are subjected
to
the lateral loads so what let us in
what we have covered so i summarize it
before i
end today's lecture here is the topics
which we have talked today this these
are given here
so what we have already talked about
introduction conventional method of
analysis
elastic method using winkler approach
and
then we have this ah talk about
so these things are over up to this
point we have finished
and in the next lecture we are going to
talk on the topics solution profiles in
cohesion less soils
and poison clay and then some design
processor and numerical example
thank you very much for your kind
attention thanks
[Music]
you
