Lec 12

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Mar 1, 2024
[MUSIC]
[MUSIC]
Hello, welcome again.
In this lecture on Principles of Management, a course under the Maksh initiative of the Government of India, today
we are on lecture number 12 where our focus will be on
economic decision making, the
modules discussed in this lesson. What is happening is
shown here and you know we are
currently discussing construction economics
so in the last lecture we had
discussed the calculation of interest and various factors as far as single payment
is concerned compound amount Factor Present
Worth Factor,
Compound Amount Factor, Present Worth Factor, Equal Payment Factor,
Sinking Fund Deposit and Capital
Recovery Factor, we had considered all these,
now by using them,
how can we take a decision or
take a decision on this. We will discuss today.
To do this, let us take an example. It was mentioned
last time also.
Suppose there are two projects A and B.
Project A has higher initial cost and
annual maintenance cost is lower whereas
project B has lower initial cost.
But the annual maintenance cost is high.
Being an investor, on which project to choose,
we made a cash flow
diagram and saw that as long as
we want and the net present worth is there or there is some
other way. It is difficult to choose among these options
and in this context the concept of time value of money should
also be kept in mind
so let us go ahead and
see a list of the criteria which are used to take the general decision. Payback
Period Return on
Investment In these two methods the
time value of money
is not taken into account whereas in these two methods Discounted
Payback Period Net Present Worth Method
Internal Rate of Return Method and Equivalent
Charge Equivalent Annual Charge and Cost
Benefit Ratio
In these we take into account the Calculations are done keeping in mind the time value,
so let us
consider them one by one.
First of all, payback period is the time
or the period in which the investor's investment
is returned i.e.
in which period and for how much period. In this, an
investor gets back his invested money.
This is pay back.
In this, the time value of money is not taken into account
and among the various available options, the
project with shorter payback period will be
considered better or will be preferred. For
example, Generally, if we see that a
company has two options, A and B, the
initial investment in both projects
is Rs 5000. Project A is expected to return Rs 0000 in the first year,
Rs 0000 in the second year and Rs
000 for four consecutive years.
If we look at Project B, the
initial investment in Project B
is Rs.0000 but the return expected in all the six years is Rs.000.
Select the best option using payback period approach. So if we use payback period in this
Want, we had said last time
also that whether it is 5 thousand, whether it is
any return of any year, whether it is
100 thousand, 15000 or 200 thousand, there is a
component of uncertainty in it too, but
in this course we will talk about that uncertainty. We will
not consider it because
bringing it into consideration complicates the matter further, so
in this initial discussion, we are
not considering that uncertainty and are
moving ahead considering these figures as accurate,
so let us consider the cash of Project 1.
Look at the flow, the initial investment of Rs. 0000
which we have plotted on the negative side
below and this is the expenditure and
our revenue which is plotted above
so according to every year it was given
that in the first year Rs. 10000 in the next year 20000 in a year
and 15000 for the next four years so
after plotting this we
can see the cash flow of project B where against the
same Rs 50 haj the
revenue of Rs 10000 is expected every year continuously for the next six years.
Hopefully so now If we
want to calculate the payback period, then the
payback period is for
This 10, 20, 30 and 15 means
he got 45000 in three years. Now for 000,
we will assume that in
how many months will he get this 000 which is being received in one year,
the mathematics is shown here
and it is simple. That if we are getting Rs. 000 in a year
then it will take 1/3
i.e. 4 months period to get Rs. 000, then the
payback period of this option can be considered as 3 years and 4
months. Keep in
mind that here we have taken the time value of money.
What has been ignored has not been taken into consideration.
We have not said
what is the present value of this Rs 10000 or
what is the present value of this Rs 20000. Without calculating this,
we have simply said
how much time will we need to recover this Rs 50000. It
will take and that time comes out to be 3 years and
4 months For Project A For Project B
it is quite straightforward because there is
expenditure of Rs 0000 and to get income or return of Rs 0000
we will take 5 years
Payback period of A is 3 Year and 4 months is the
payback period of B. If it is 5 years then which
project is preferred?
A should choose Let's
move towards Return on
Investment Return on
Investment is the
ratio of profit to the average assets of the manufacturing company. Generally
ROI or Return on Investment
can be evaluated on the basis of information available in the account statement of the company.
Time value of money is
also not taken into account so let us see an example
that the details of assets and profits of the company at different times are
given below and
in this we have to consider what will be considered as ROI.
We have been given a table
in which we can see what the assets of the company
are in 2000, 2001 and 20023
and this data is available to us.
If we look at the profit in thousands, it is
given to us for every year, then we can get these
If we see how much ROI we get in a year,
then how do we calculate it?
We say that we will look at the average profit
and the average asset value and
take their ratio and calculate the return on investment.
What is the average profit? 15 of these figures.
If we take the average of 20, 30, 30 and 30,
then it comes to 25000. Similarly, if we take the average
of assets, we get Rs.
1 lakh, then by taking their ratio and
doing percentage, it comes to 25, so our ROI is at 25. It
can be believed that in this
very simple
way we can estimate the ROI
if we have the data available in that form.
Now it comes to those methods or
systems in which the time value of money. So the
first system that we will
consider is the discounted payback period i.e.
discounted payback period. So
we have considered the payback period. The discounted part of this i.e.
the part in which we will include the time value of money.
This is same as the payback period.
Only the time value of money is
taken into account. A problem for you to do yourself
or an assignment to illustrate the payback period.
In the example discussed, if a discount rate or rate of
interest of 10 is assumed, then discounted
payback. What will be the duration?
To give you reference, let us show you that slide
again that a company
has two options A and B and the
initial investment in those projects is Rs 50000 and A and
B have different returns so the returns of A
Here again we show
that in the first year it is Rs 10000 and in the second year it is Rs 20000
15000 15000 15000 15000. So now to calculate the
discounted payback period,
we have to calculate the present
value of this Rs 10000, the present value of this Rs 20000, the present value of this Rs
15000 and calculate this. When
we reach the figure of Rs 50,000,
that period will be the discounted payback period. Now
consider again that the payback period that we came up with
without taking the time value of money into account
was probably not a year and four
months. Now if we calculate it at 10 If we
go by discount rate or rate of interest, will the period come, will it be less than this
or will it be more than this, it is true that it
cannot be equal to this,
think for yourself and once you
do the calculation yourself then you will know. It will work out that
if our payback period was three years and four
months, then what is our discounted payback period,
what is it, then the difference between this
discounted payback period and the mere payback
period, to what extent
depends on the rate of interest, now we are
at 10. We will calculate it, which we are not
doing, we have left it to you, you
do the calculation at 10 per cent, you do it at 15 per cent, you
do it at 5 per cent and then see to
what extent this discounted payback period depends on this rate
or how sensitive it is. We
leave this as a home assignment for you
and move on to find out the Net Present Value.
NPV or Net Present
Value is the sum of all the cash flows at the present time t = 0, keeping in mind the time value of money.
Mathematics
If we look at it in this way, then we can show NPV in this way
and
we have also discussed where this formula comes from.
This is the term which is
one of the terms in interest rate when we discussed it.
Which term is, I leave it up to you.
You can figure out for yourself
what we will do to get this CFT here.
When we were discussing the calculation of interest rate,
we noticed two things
that We have a value at present
and what is its future value, the
way to calculate it and the future value is
given, the way to calculate its present value,
so for both these calculations
we had given you formulas,
this is one of those formulas, you can use it. If we
see again, you will understand a little that
what is A Pavi, all these types of arrows, whether
it is in this direction or in this direction, that is,
whether it is expenditure or income,
when we bring it at t = 0, then this
formula will be given. We can bring it using 'NPV'
and their sum will be called NPV. So by adding this
entire
investment which includes 'V' and also the revenue,
we
can get a Net Present Worth. So this
thing is shown here and we can use it. It is
natural that if the NPV i.e.
Net Present Value is more than zero then the
project creates value for the investor.
After all, what is NPV? Time value is the sum of the
expenses and revenues during the service life of the project.
Looking at the off money, when we bring it here, it is
called NPV, so if it is more than zero
then it can be assumed that overall
value is being created and it can be recommended to
implement that project.
Generally options are
evaluated on the basis of their NPV. Let
us see this through an example.
If we are given
that the cash flows for eight years
are in this table that initially we will spend ₹ lakhs.
And after that from year one to seven
we will get Rs 35000 and in the eighth year we will
get Rs 37000. Keeping these amounts
in mind we have to find out what is the payback period
and
what is the NPV of cash flow at the interest rate of 15% when we calculate the NPV. If we
find out, we will also know whether it is more or
less than zero and on the basis of that
we can recommend whether the
project should be implemented or not. The
first thing to be done is to make
a cash flow diagram using the data given in this table. If
converted into rupees, this is the expenditure of ₹ lakh
and this is the income of 335000 and finally the
income of 37000. If
we calculate the payback period through this diagram,
then you will notice that in the payback period,
we do not have to take the time value of money, that is,
only We have to find out
how much time will it take us to recover this ₹ lakh.
If we look at this diagram, to
recover ₹ 200, it is 35 * 5 i.e.
175 and then 25, so to recover ₹ 25,
something like 35 in the sixth year. The fraction will be taken and
that fraction will be linear interpolated in the manner given here
and we will get the answer which is
roughly 5 years and 9 months so the
payback period of this project is 5 years and 9
months and what is this 5 years and months this is the
period In which we will get back the two lakh rupees that we had
invested. We proceed keeping
in mind the estimated revenue
and we try to calculate the NPV. The
formula of N
is as follows and we will consider the interest rate at 15.
Where will we start from, we will show this cash
flow in this row minus 200 then
35 35 35 and finally 37 in this row we have
shown SPP WF i.e. Single
Payment Present Worth Factor. You
will notice that when we discussed that There
is a factor which helps us to find out the
present value of each subsequent figure.
We
use the Single Payment Present Worth Factor
and this factor is available in all the tables.
From those tables we will see that one
year two From year three to year eight,
this factor
becomes 87, 7565 etc. up to 32.
If we multiply these factors with the estimated revenue given here,
then
our present value of Rs 35,000 will be
30.4 5 Here 35,000 The value of this
35 here is 22.75 and the
value of this 37 here
is 11.8 f. Now to calculate the Net Present Worth,
we will
take the sum of all the figures given in this row and see that
it comes to minus
4361. So Minus 4361 means that it is not
generating overall value, NPV
is negative and hence this project
cannot be recommended for implementation. So
this is a
calculation. Now moving forward, let us divide
this 15 by 10. But the calculation of what will happen then is
shown in this table.
Here the same SPPWF is
given once again and these figures
are more than the previous table. Keeping this in mind,
if we again calculate these 35
Multiplying 35 35 by these factors and writing it here and
then taking its sum, we will see that the Net
Present Value is my 4110, that is, there is some
improvement, some improvement,
earlier we were at minus 4361 while we had
taken the interest rate of 15. Now when We have taken it at 10, so we
are at - 4180, so still it
cannot be recommended to implement this project,
but we have come very close to it, that is,
if it is said in different words,
if the interest rate is at 10, If there is a nearby area, then
perhaps this project
can be implemented. Once again, let us do this exercise by
reducing the number of 10 to 5. Then what happens is
shown in this table and
we will have to take these factors again
from that table which is We will
take the factors from the table written on 5
and then we will recalculate these values
and then we will see that our Net
Present Value becomes plus 2390. So
notice that now the sign of NPV has changed
which was earlier. What was negative has now become positive and
it can be said that this investment
can be implemented as a colliery.
You can also say or
see that there will be an interest rate
where the NPV is zero. Because when
we took the interest rate at 15, our
NPV was - 43000, when we took it at 10,
it became around 4000, now when we
took it at 5, we reached plus 26000, so there is
a difference between 10 and Pa. There is definitely such a situation, there
is definitely an interest rate where the
NPV will be zero. What is the importance of that interest rate?
We define it as
Internal Rate of Return. So what is Internal Rate of
Return? Internal Rate of Return is the
parameter on which the interest rate is calculated. NPV of cash flow
is zero. As a picture
if we see then NPV and discount rate
or interest rate if we plot then IRR
is coming here.
As homework I would request you to consider
in this example IRR
Try to find out and try to calculate it.
You may have to iterate once or twice between 5 and 10 points.
As far as the formula is concerned,
this formula is supposed to be used to
calculate IR. So here This rate of
return, where this sum is reduced to zero
or this sum becomes zero, we
call it IR RR. This IR R is called trial
and error. The way we just did it,
first took it at 15, then took it at 10 and then
Similarly,
by the method of trial and error, we can determine whether the
option with higher IRR
is better or preferred for any company,
then if we have two options, a
company has two options. If one has IRR
at 6 and one has IRR at 8
then the company should choose the option with IRR at 8.
Let's go ahead and assess the options using NPV. Let's take a
contractor as an example. A work is
given which requires purchase of a tool.
Two brands
of tools A and B are available to do the work. The
initial cost or initial investment of A
is Rs. 7 lakh and the cost
of B is Rs. 4 lakh but after three years. For
their maintenance cost is
only 3 lakhs in A while it is 5 lakhs in B.
So the question is which equipment should we or that contractor
buy, A or
B? Use the given information to make this decision. If
we
draw the cash flow diagram of Brand A, then we have
initial cost of Rs 7 lakh and maintenance cost of Rs 3 lakh.
Note that these four values are
plotted at the bottom because all four
are expenses. Similarly, we will graph the cash flow of Brand B.
Where
initial cost is 4 lakhs, maintenance
cost is 5 lakhs every year, we have to bring their present
value and then we can compare A and B,
then calculate NPV,
for this we will use E
PP WF i.e. Equal Payment
Present Worth Factor: We had also discussed this last
time, here equal payment
has evolved, we are investing or spending Rs 3 lakh for every year,
here the
same amount is not 3 lakh, it is 5 lakh but the
principle is the same. So, to calculate what is the present value of these 5 lakhs or these 3
lakhs, we will
use EPPF, where we know A, I
know A, and
we want to find out how much is P. So we assume
that I i.e. the rate of interest is at 8, then
our A for three years is 3 lakhs, then the
fact that you will
see in the table is EP P WF, if there is something like 2.58 2.59,
then using that we will calculate NPV. Of A
i.e. on purchasing A brand equipment, the
NPV comes to 14.7 lakhs. Similarly, if
we calculate B, our
initial investment in B is 4 lakhs and the factor
remains the same, it will be 5 lakh times, then our
NPV comes to
16.95 lakhs. So now 14.7 Sa and
16.95
because 14.7 Sa is less
so it can be
recommended that Equipment A be
purchased So this was an example in which
we compared two options
based on the calculation of NPV and it Having seen
what equipment should be purchased, let's
go ahead and see how this system
or this system would evaluate the options with unequal life spans.
This time, to
simplify the calculation, we have
taken the step of 3 and 5. It is necessary that It is
not that it has to be constant, then if it is
not constant or there is a
difference of three or four years between the two, one equipment
may work for nine years while the other equipment
may work for five years, then what do we have to do.
In most of the situations, the options are similar.
Do not have the same life span or do not have equal maintenance
cost. To be
fair with the ranking process of the alternatives, the
life spans are or should be modified in such a way
that they are equal. For this,
two common processes are done. One
is common Multiple Method And secondly, then we
try to do the work in some other way,
so as far as the Common Multiple Method is concerned,
in this method to evaluate the options, the
life span of the options is
calculated by summarizing the least common feature of
life span. The period is chosen as for example
if we have one equipment which will
last for three years and another equipment which will
last for four years then to compare them
we will assume that if we take a period of 12 years
then that 12 years In this, A will have to be
changed four times while B will have to be changed only three
times, so whether the cash flow diagram
is of A or B, we will
make it separately and thus the cash flow diagram of A and B will be made four times
or three times.
After making it, we will come up with the NPV and
keeping in mind the period of 12 years, we will compare
that A and B, which one will be
better, this is the case of Common Multiple
Method, as far as other methods
are concerned, sometimes
A study period is selected depending on the length of the project and
sometimes by selecting the shortest life span among the options as the
study period and
doing calculations we make a decision.
Moving on to the next parameter which
we call economic What we use in decision making
is Equivalent Annual Charge
or EAC. What we do in this is that the
present value of the EAC project is
distributed equally over the lifetime of the project,
that is,
we
take all the expenses or revenues and then
here But
after calculating this NPV, we distribute this NPV
equally over the lifetime of the project,
whether it is plus or
minus,
this gives us a rough idea
that ultimately this NPV is As far as the
method of its calculation is concerned, the
formula shown is that PV is the
present value, N is the life
span of the project in years, K is the interest rate and A
is our annual charge. So it is The
method of calculation is shown here.
Another method which is sometimes used
is the Benefit Cost Ratio. What is the
profit generated i.e. the present
value of the benefit which we have called PVG divided by the
present value of the investment which we have
called PV I. Its
ratio is till now, when we have
calculated the NPV, what we have done is that we have taken
together the expenditure and the revenue and have
tried to sum them up and added them to
get the cost benefit ratio. For this,
we find out the NPV here separately and the NPV here
separately and take its
ratio. If we take its ratio, then the PVG which is mentioned here
has to be calculated using the same formula as a single payment factor. Similarly, the
investment is also calculated as a single payment factor.
Here we have to bring the single factor method and take its ratio,
PVG divided by PVI, this
will be the benefit cost ratio, then PI, this is the
ratio, if it is less than one then the investment will be
rejected and if it is more than one
then So in
today's lecture
we decided to discuss about some common decision making
criteria:
Payback Period Return on
Investment Discounted Payback Period
Net Present Value Internal Rate of Return
Equivalent L Charge And benefit cost
ratio, our discussion of these is over.
In the next lecture, we will talk some more about
depreciation of equipment. So,
given in this slide are some published books
which will give you information about the topics being discussed not only in this lecture
but in this entire course. Will
prove helpful in understanding more. We will meet you again
in the next lecture. Thank you Jai [
Music] [
Music]
[Music]
Hindi
