Lecture 8: Dimensional analysis

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
3 Video Views·Dec 4, 2023
Prof. Pradeep K. Jha,
Department of Mechanical & Industrial Engineering,
IIT Roorkee
[Music]
[Music]
welcome to the lecture on dimensional
analysis so we talked about the
similarities now what we do normally in
the case of dimensional analysis it is
frequently used in the process
engineering to represent the physical
phenomena in terms of mathematical
equation that is essentially
dimensionless so basically if we have
these equations we thought if you know
the equations governing the fluid flow
or heat transfer also so in those cases
what we do is normally we try to you
know have this equation in the
dimensionless form for example if you
talk about the fluid flow equation so
what we do normally is you have V so we
are expressing it by dividing with a
characteristic velocity similarly P star
will be you know that is P minus P
naught by P v square so this way you get
you know you have again T star so T star
will be T into V by L so your
characteristic length you have a
reference velocity so similarly you know
X star will be X will be divided by a
characteristic length then you have Y
star again why write Y by L or jet star
will be dead by L then you get you have
you know the my operators you know point
where this they also need to be you know
Express so so that starter I mean that
will be you know L times grad so that
will be again you will be using so you
will have Delta 1 times similarly you
will have a star star square so that
will be L square and that will be Delta
square so you will have dou square by
dou X star square like that so you
we'll have those square by dou X in this
case you will have dou square by dou X
square + + Delta 1 multiplied by that so
that way you do and then once you put
them into the equation for the
continuity and also the momentum
conservation so in that case also if you
you must have done that and in that case
you get you know the two kind of you
know number dimensionless numbers and
that is one you are getting as it and
also number that is LV Rho by mu and
then you are also getting the Froude
number that is v square by G L so this
is how you know that is used for that is
the use of these non dimensionalizing
and then on both the sides when you do
so you get you know you'll be having the
expression coming up like the whisk you
know start by DT so and it is start so
that will be coming as minus of that
star P star so that's what you do
normally you have the first term and opy
do X or so and then you get the term
like mu by L V Rho and that multiplied
by grad star v square V Star and then
you get you know GL by v square and then
you get you know that that is multiplied
by Rho G so so G G Star is coming so
basically what you see you are getting
these two terms so so that's what it is
coming you you get these these
non-dimensional quantities that's what
you are getting what I mean to say that
normally we try to convert these
equations that is essentially
dimensionless now this technique which
is generally applied it is to work out
between the various measurable
quantities in a system so what we is
there that if you talk about any system
so you will have one variable that will
be represented in terms of other you
know parameters are the variables so you
will have to have a particular
relationship and you determine the
minimum possible number of variables
required to define the geometry and also
operating conditions in the system and
then you go for scaling down or scaling
up of the system so that's the you know
the way you that there's the technique
which is normally applied so the first
method which is used for such approach
is the you know release method of
indices now what they'll is method of
indices say that in this case the
dimensional analysis will be based on
the method of indices so you know what
happens that the relationship between
different physical quantities can be
expressed as the product of power
functions so what you do here that you
have X naught suppose this is a
dependent variable and that is expressed
in terms of C 1 into X 1 raised to the
power a X 2 raised to the power B and
similarly F 3 raised to the power C and
and so on so suppose C 1 is expressed
you know C 1 a B and C all these are the
constraints so now you know if you try
to have the dimensionless groups
so if you see further if you have the
you know from this place onwards again
you can have the capital X 1 capital X 2
and a capital X 3 so they can even be
expressed you know you can have these
you know dimensionless groups defined
that is capital X naught similarly
capital X 1 capital X 2 and X 3 so they
also can have
with the different constants capital ABC
you can express them so you can further
you know express like if you have non
dimensional group so that is X naught
can be expressed as the c1 prime and you
have the you know x1 raise to the power
a and similarly X 2 raised to the power
B similarly X 3 raised to the power C so
these are the non dimensional groups
that can also be expressed you know in
terms of these indices and that will be
going on
so here again c1 prime then a B and C
they are again the constants so and then
you are you know we will see that they
will be no further acquitted on both the
sides and you can have the U deep you
know valuation of these constants and
you can see that how they can be
expressed another method which is also
used is the you know Buckingham PI
theorem so now in this case it is
normally used in the dimensional
analysis to determine the number of
dimensionless groups that one can expect
in the analysis of any given physical
phenomena so here what you do is
normally you are having the number of
the dimensionless groups you are trying
to deter mine and that will be depending
upon you know the value that will be
equivalent to the e minus F so you have
basically F that will be representing
the total number of primary quantities
the which is required for you know the
expressing and then the e value is will
be representing the total number of
independent and dependent variables
which will be governing the process so
II minus F will be basically telling you
the number of those pipe you know groups
and then this way you can have those
dimensionless you know numbers
coming into existence so that that can
be found out so what you do in this case
you have f of pi 1 PI 2 pi 3 that will
be so in the case of pi theorem you will
have the PI 1 PI 2 and PI 3 so they will
be equal to 0
so there will be basically they are the
independent you know products of the you
know arguments that is there which is
dimensionless and you know now you you
find these no common numbers will be
there that will be equal to e minus F so
this way you try to have you know the
calculation of these you know PI groups
so for example if you look at one of the
problem like you have to have the you
know rising velocity you know to have
this for this problem rising velocity of
spherical shaped particle a spherical
shaped inclusion in a stationary fluid
so suppose you have to have the you know
calculation of the dimensionless you
know these groups so what you do you can
have the use of this bucking of mam pi
theorem and what we see that normally if
you talk about the rising velocity which
is just because the this is a problem in
the case of steelmaking where the
inclusion if it they are there they are
normally lighter and they have the
tendency to float you know towards the
upper side so normally your V rise so
this Vedas will be a function of the
weight of the particle then you have the
density of the particle you have the
coefficient of viscosity of the medium
and also the density of the medium so
normally
it is a function of you know weight of
the particle WP you have diameter of the
particle you have the coefficient of
viscosity of the medium and the density
of the medium now if you use this
Raleigh's method of indices so you can
write a functional relationship of the
type so you will have realized it will
be c1 times you know W true so that will
be power 8 and DPS to the power B then
you have mu Z to the power you know C
and similarly you raise to the power D
so that way you can have you know you
can these are the indices which are you
know these so you will have the to know
the what are the dimension of these you
know variables suppose your variable is
your rise velocity so you are you know
symbol is you have VR and it's unit is
it is velocity so it will be meter per
second and if you have the need to know
the dimension so it will be al t minus 1
similarly you have the weight of the
particle and the weight of the particle
you do it by W P so it will be you know
normally kg meter per second square and
you will have ml t minus 2 then you have
the density so if you talk about the
density of lead so you have that is Rho
so you will have kg you know per meter
cube and it will be ml minus 3 so then
then comes your alpha density you have
the diameter of the particle so you have
D P so diameter will be in terms of
meter only
so so you'll have em I know this is L
and then the last is your mu so that is
coefficient of viscosity and you know
that is mu and that will be you know kg
you know that is if you look at that
will be kids meter per second and you
will have ml minus 1 t minus 1 so once
you know you you must have the idea
about these dimensions and you have to
you know equate or known on this side
you have to find the number of Pi which
is required you know in that case now in
this case if you look at the number of
you know primary quantity is 3 so number
of primary quantity will be 3 and if you
look at the independent and dependent
variable that is w PDP muru and V so
that is your 5 so E is 5 and F is 3 so
in that case if you go for a - f e- f
will be 2 so you will have to have you
will have to you know independent PI
groups that you can form so you will
have two independent PI groups and that
will be required for the representation
you know you know that is in the
dimensionless form so you can write you
know that f you know prime PI 1 PI 2
that will be equal to 0 now what you see
is that if you equate on both these
sides so you have to have the dimensions
on both the sides so you have you know
in earlier K this is LT minus 1 so you
will have M 0 l and t minus 1 so that is
and that will be that we have seen that
you will have the four parameters and
that tone that happening this is a B C
and D so so those values are WP on that
ad PB and view and see Andrew on D so
you will have those expressions so you
will have ml t minus 2 that will be a
similarly you will have L that is on B
similarly you will have ml minus 1 so
you will have those values so you will
have then mu mu will be ml minus 1 and
at t minus 1 so on that so we have taken
rory's to the power D so Rho is your ml
minus 3 so you will have ml minus 3 and
you'll have the ml minus 1 t minus 1 so
M L minus 1 ml minus 3 so kg per meter
cube and then you will have M L minus 1
t minus 1 and that residue C and D so
basically you can have you know you can
do the the the equation can be equated
so decided is 1 and if you look at here
it will be 1 so that is a plus B and
then you have minus 3 C and you have
minus D so that will be 1 so 1 will be a
plus B minus 3 C minus D so similarly
now you have T is you know M is 0 so 0
will be equal to you know if you look at
the M so it will be a and then you have
plus C and here also plus D so this way
and and if you go for T so it will be T
is minus 1 on this side and on this side
if you look at it
we you know tease here it is - - we and
similarly you will have T as minus D so
you know ml so that way you will have
the equation so that you can come and if
you equate you know these equations so
you will have that is - - way and you
will have further - D so you can have
you know you can find these ABC and you
have D so if you manipulate these
equations then you can have you can find
the value of B as -1 and that you can
have the expression of you know C and D
are expressly in terms of a below your
three equations and four unknowns so you
C and D can be expressed in terms of a
so you have C as a minus one and D as 2a
plus one so we can have that minus 1 as
2 minus 2a minus D so you get B as minus
1 that by manipulation and then you get
the C and D express in terms of a and
you can have you know no further you can
express you know the in terms of the two
quantities that will be F of Rovira is
DP upon mu and you know WP Rho by mu
square so that will be equal to 0 so
basically you are in a position to
devise to kind of you know non
dimensional numbers that is for these
inclusions when you do that include
analysis and the two groups which you
get will be that will be Rho V rise you
know DP upon mu and the another group
which you get by - it will be
P then into Rho and divided by mu square
so now what you see now if you look at
these numbers what you see this is
nothing but this is the number which is
analogous to the Reynolds number which
we have studied Rho VD upon mu so and
this is another you know dimensionless
group which you are having in in that
case so this way you try to have the the
solution of these you know equations so
you have to first write down these two
equations on both the sides you have to
have the indices you know being equated
you have to solve and then you get these
expressions and further you are having
you know these values of these two PI
groups so so so that is how you get
these non-dimensional you know numbers
and they have their significance when
you are trying to you know analyze that
system that time you try to have the use
of these numbers so you may have
different types of you know you know
dimensionless groups which are used in
the case of tundish modeling and you
know like when you go for the fluid flow
type of you know cases so in the case of
fluid flow you have the group is your
Reynolds number and that is by Rho L you
know you upon mu so that's how you have
these you know dimensionless number
group that is so this is your
application and
that is how you define so this is your
definition and this is the group
similarly if you go for the wave and
surface behavior so in that case you
know what you do or when you are going
to use for the pudding stream so in that
case you have that value is U square by
GL and that is your Froude number so we
have seen this this number you know we
have talked about we have dealt with
this number earlier so that is your
Froude number similarly you go for you
know the the force convection of mass
transfer so in those cases you have a
number that is your peclet number and
the peclet number will be you know I'll
you upon alpha or and u upon D so that
we you know it's basically the ratio
between convection and diffusion so that
we you get these peclet number defined
similarly you know when you have the
atomization of liquid jets in those
cases you come across the number that is
your Weber number so there you have the
surface tension term coming into picture
then many a times in in the case of
force and free convection you come
across the group and that is your
Prandtl number and the prandtl number is
defined as mu CP by K and in the case of
mass transfer when you will deal with
the you know concentration equation or
ever solving for the scalar you know
transport equations in those cases you
have
Smith number so that is Smith number and
you know that is the group is mu by Rho
D so that is you know you know that is
also user so normally you have certain
value assigned to it we assume so
basically these are the different type
of you know groups which you normally
come across so you also will also come
across other numbers like you come to
for the attorneys Richardson number when
we talk about the the convection or
natural convection especially when we
deal with the heat transfer cases so in
those cases those numbers also are you
know coming into picture and these are
you know the groups so that is you are
you know they are they are going to be
dealt with when we you know deal with
these cases then you know their you know
that is normally used now these values
also it has been reported that when you
use these various dimensionless numbers
or groups so normally you go for the
water modeling in the case of the
tundish system so the steel is basically
replaced with water because their
kinematic viscosity is same at the
melting temperature of steel and at
normal temperatures in case of water so
normally you have when you go for the
full-scale model so when you have this
so if you talk about these numbers and
you have a you have the steel system so
and if you go for the full-scale you
know you know water model so if you see
that when you talk about this Reynolds
number
so you do there's no similarity so in
that case if it is one so normally it is
reported you know in that you know by a
question exactly that normally we sort
of report it to be one point one for the
Reynolds number in steel system it is
one so full scale water modeling you can
have one point one similarly you can
have for the Froude number so if it is
one so you are here also you keep one so
that fraud you know fraud similarity is
normally you know it kept in mind so
that is you know he in the steel system
which is one then full scale water model
also you keep it as one so similarly for
the you know Weber number if you talk
for Weber you know it is if it is one so
in that case it is will be three point
one so similar to that you have you know
other numbers like you have sometimes
the the motor number so motor number is
the one which is used for the velocity
of bubbles in the liquids and that is
normally used for the two phase flows a
multi-phase flows when we do in the
tundish so in those cases for the this
is the dimensionless group is the
immortal number and that is you know G
mu you know so you have expression for
that and for that the for the full-scale
water model that ratio becomes Sakuma
close to if it is one in steel system it
is coming close to you know 45 in the
water model so these you know these
numbers so that needs to be kept in mind
when you are doing the water modeling
and how you know that full-scale water
model how these you know numbers know
how these for the for the steel as well
as full-scale more model what numbers
you know should be there so that you
need to know so that can be taken as a
reference from the literature also and
this is how typically
the VD so this is about you know the
dimensionless you know doing the
dimensional analysis in the case of this
tundish system and we will when we will
be doing that discussing about these
water modeling or this scaling so at
that time we will have the introduction
to these numbers especially the Reynolds
and the fraud so you will have the
similarity based on these two that's
what we have already discussed and also
their you know significance in those
cases thank you very much
[Music]
