گفتگو با بهزاد مهرانی؛ رد پای مائو در انقلاب ۵۷

Epoch Times Persian
88 followers
16 Video Views·Oct 22, 2023
مخاطبین عزیز لطفا نظرات و پیشنهادات خود را برای ما کامنت بگذارید
سایت اصلی اپک تایمز فارسی
http://persianepochtimes.com
لطفا ما را در شبکه های اجتماعی دنبال کنید
اینستاگرام:
https://www.instagram.com/epochtimes_persian/
تلگرام :
https://telegram.me/EpochTimesPersian
توئیتر:
https://twitter.com/EpochTimesPer
فیسبوک:
https://www.facebook.com/EpochTimesPersian
What was the voice of the revolutionaries in 1957?
Where was their city of Arman?
Why could they see the traces of leftist ideas in the faces of the revolutionaries?
When you read the memories of the revolutionaries in 1957,
you see that the voice of the revolutionaries in 1957
was either Mao's China, or Fidel Castro's Kuwait, or Stalin's Soviet Union.
These were their images.
They claimed that they wanted to bring about a proletarian dictatorship.
Today's guest on the program is Behzad Mehrani,
a political journalist and activist.
He was released from the Green Movement
and after 45 days in solitary confinement and a year in prison,
in 1990, he was released from the country.
Behzad Mehrani says that although the voice of the people of Iran
does not reach the ears of the people of Iran,
they have been victorious.
In the past year, they have achieved the victory of dialogue.
When they put everything aside, I think that revolution has begun.
If you ask me, I would say that the revolution has won.
That is not the voice of victory.
It is the victory of dialogue.
The people of the left have tried very hard,
with the slogans of Nasheh and Nasheh,
to bring about the economic upheaval that the people are experiencing.
But the people say that our enemy is also here.
Welcome to the third episode of Negah Sevom.
I am Shahrzad Ghanei.
Mr. Behzad Mehrani, a political journalist and activist.
Thank you for taking the time to talk to us.
I would like to thank you for inviting me.
Mr. Mehrani, you say that the Palestinian dream is similar to the 1957 revolution.
What is the similarity?
If you look at the dream of the 1957 revolution, there are several things in common.
One is Western citizenship.
The other is Israeli citizenship.
In most of them, the citizenship is with women.
These are the common faces of the 1957 revolution.
If you pay attention to the revolution that is still alive today,
if you pay attention to their writings in recent days,
you will see that they have tried very hard to expose Hamas and its crimes.
Why do they do this?
Why is it important?
Why is Palestine so important for the revolution?
In China, they are trying to restrict the Muslims of the United States.
They have even sent them to forced labor camps.
Are they not Muslims?
Yes, they are not Muslims.
They are Muslims in other places.
Why is the Palestinian Muslim so important for the 1957 revolution?
It is just an excuse for the West.
If the revolutionaries said to Israel,
the dog of Zanzibar is the dog of imperialism,
before and after the revolution,
this shows that they know Israel as a partner with the West,
and they are trying to bring the West closer to Israel.
A few days ago, I was reading about a group called Palestine.
The name of the group is Palestine.
Before the revolution, this group started to participate and fight.
They went abroad, to Lebanon and Iraq.
They learned from the Palestinian terrorists.
They carried out terrorist activities inside Iran before the 1957 revolution.
One of their main leaders was executed in the 1960s.
Even during their reign, they carried out these armed activities.
If we put all these groups together,
we can say that Palestine was a Maoist group.
It was a Marxist-Maoist group.
It was a group that used the Maoist teachings,
the Chinese Shivas, to win the war.
If you look at Mr. Khomeini,
he is a very religious person.
He is the most moderate of the Taliban.
If you look at him,
he supports Fidel Castro.
He even says that Fidel Castro's cry against the West
is the same cry of Allah Akbar that we say.
There is no difference.
He even uses religious rhetoric against something against religion.
These theories were inspired by the communists
who knew Israel as an important point
to confront the West and the United States.
In the Western media,
the term the Red and Green Union is often used.
It refers to the communist factions
such as Palestine and Hamas.
It also refers to Yasser Arafat,
who saw his teachings in Moscow.
As a representative of Moscow,
he came to Palestine to form groups
against Israel, against the communists.
How can you say that Hamas can be a communist?
Let's go back to the revolution and the 50s.
The photos of Yasser Arafat,
his love for the West,
of Ibrahim Yazdi, Ahmad Khomeini,
Massoud Rajavi, Khomeini, Taleghani,
all of them were fans of the Palestinian movement and Arafat.
Let me tell you that these are theories
based on the communist theories.
The red and green reaction
reminds me of Shah Fakir's words,
that the reaction is black.
Black is the symbol of the religious reaction.
It is also related to the communists.
These are the differences
between the communist and the Sunni.
One is that the communists are atheists.
We know that the Sunnis and Shias are Muslims.
But what makes them so close to each other?
The West and the Israelis
want to benefit the West.
They see themselves as a common force.
The combination of these two reactions
has led to great disasters in the world.
The origin of this is the revolution of 1957.
It created a view of religion,
a view of the West and the communists.
If you look at the Taleghani book,
which is a religious interpretation,
it says that Khomeini and Taleghani
are the exception of Hosein.
In reality, they were the product of the West's ideas.
The West had a great influence on them.
These ideas were not based on jurisprudence.
Jurisprudence does not necessarily lead to something better.
But it should be said that these ideas were based on jurisprudence
and were used in Marxist books.
For example, Bahman Bazargani,
one of the Mujahideen,
says that he had meetings with the Mujahideen
and he was one of the founders of the Mujahideen.
His brother was even executed.
He says that in his classes,
he did not read the Koran as much as he read Mao's books.
He did not read the Ten Commandments.
I would like to say that these ideas were influenced
by religious interpretations.
For example, there is a book called
Abuzar Khudaparastane Soosyaliste.
Abuzar is not historical at all.
It has nothing to do with history.
But it is about a warrior who fights against the West.
If you look at these ideas,
they were influenced by different ideas.
As I said, they were based on
a deep intellectual interpretation of the West's ideas.
They learned how to fight against the West.
Based on books by Lenin, Marx, and Mao,
they combined their ideas.
The same goes for Hamas.
The same goes for the Palestinian forces.
These ideas are based on the West's ideas
and they are influenced by religious interpretations.
In the talks, it is said that Israel
is being likened to the Islamic Republic.
For years, they have put Hamas and Palestine under pressure.
The Islamic Republic has even published a video
in which they have killed children for years.
The attack on Israel by Hamas
was a pressure that they have been
putting on the people of Iran.
Do you see this as a similarity?
No.
The people of Iran have been fighting
against the Islamic Republic all these years.
Where have they gone wrong?
I don't want to defend one side of the argument.
Even though I am on Israel's side,
and if I am criticizing Israel,
it is important to know where we stand.
Who are the supporters of Hamas?
Who are the supporters of Palestine?
North Korea, China, Russia,
the Islamic Republic, Cuba,
all of them are against human rights.
On the other hand,
those who support Israel all over the world
are generally democratic countries.
We cannot say that...
It is right to criticize Israel.
Many people say that Israel should return to the borders of the Islamic Republic.
How logical is this?
How much of a threat are the terrorist forces
who do not want Israel to feel safe
and want to return to the borders of the Islamic Republic?
The result of this is that
political pressure is created
to attack and kill people.
If this is the case,
then all these 44 years,
all the groups that have been
belittling and belittling the Islamic Republic,
should now be the most aggressive political actors
against the Islamic Republic.
This is not the case.
In Hamas,
not only Israel,
but also the Jewish citizens.
I do not want to investigate the Jewish-citizenship of Israel.
The Jewish-citizenship of Israel is the continuation of the Jewish-citizenship of Israel.
These people cannot be compared to the Islamic Republic.
Those who compare themselves to the Islamic Republic
want to eradicate the terrorist groups
and give them a more normal state.
This is their goal.
No.
This is a completely different situation.
At that time,
the youths were revolutionary.
But they were not Islamists.
They had leftist and communist views.
Now, after 44 years,
they believe that the Islamic Revolution
has stolen the revolution they wanted to organize.
If the revolution they wanted to organize
had come into being,
it would have brought freedom and welfare to the people.
What is your opinion on this?
Khosrow Golosrokhi,
who was a communist,
was in a meeting with Sevil Banaghoosh
and told him,
I share the dreams of Imam Hussain and Ali.
I share their dreams of freedom.
They had a connection from the beginning.
The communist and Islamist forces
were in conflict with the Shah.
I think the conflict with the Shah
was between the revolutionaries
and their critics.
A person like Zendayat Bakhtiar
was a critic of the Shah.
Shahzad Ezza Pahlavi
in his book, Zaman-e-Intikhab,
has repeatedly criticized his father's
commitment to the Shah.
So, I support them.
I support the revolutionaries.
They were the ones who believed
that the Pahlavi regime should come back.
Now, the alternative regimes
that were taken over by the communists
and wanted to take their place.
These forces were in conflict
with parts of the Shah
who had different views on food.
The Shah had a strong position.
The Shah had the right to vote for women.
Khomeini protested against this.
The Shah had the right to reform the land.
These were some of the critics.
The Shah's westernization
had a connection with the United States
and the free world of the West.
Now, five or six decades have passed.
Look at the state of the world
under the rule of Mohammad Azza Shah.
These positive aspects
of the world
were opposed by the revolutionaries.
I always tell young people
who ask me
what books to read
in order to get to know
Mohammad Azza Shah
and the revolution.
I always tell them
that you don't need to read
the books of the supporters of the Shah
or the books that defend the Pahlavi regime.
You should read the books
of the opponents of the Shah.
You should read the memoirs
or the books of the opponents
of the Shah or the Pahlavi regime.
You should read the books
of the supporters
of the Shah.
If you read the books
of the supporters
you will see that
we were lucky
to fall into the hands
of the state after 1957.
Because, you don't need to read
the books of the supporters
of the Shah
They also said at the beginning of the revolution that we have to send the rich people to Iraq.
By rich people I don't mean people like Elghanian.
I'm talking about people who had two apartments.
At one point, they were considered rich because they were attacking empty apartments.
They said we have to build forced labor camps and send the rich people there.
They were calling on the revolutionaries of 1957 to say that they were not as powerful as the people of Bazargan.
Mr. Payman told the people of Bazargan that they were not as powerful as the people of Volkswagen.
The people of Bazargan were happy to say that they were not as powerful as the people of Volkswagen.
They said they had imperialist roots.
They said that if they had such ideas, they would have acted worse than the people of Rouhani.
When the revolution was stolen, it was a lie that they repeated over and over again.
It's not like that at all.
When you read the memories of the revolutionaries of 1957,
you will see that they were the role models of China, Fidel Castro and Stalin.
They wanted to take us there.
They claimed that they wanted to send the people of Iran to the dictatorship of the proletarians.
Even if they had the will to do so,
Mr. Ghulam Hossein Saeedi, the author of the book,
said that there was no country where everyone was a guest.
He said that we should kill all the imperialist families, even their children.
It's like Russia.
Yes, it's like Russia.
It's like Hamas.
It's the same ideology that was manifested in the revolution.
What was your will during the reign?
What were your policies and strategies?
This is a very challenging question.
One of the great wills was to create a border with those who were communists.
Those who wanted to take Iran.
Terrorist groups would be arrested with weapons and sent to prisons for a short period of time.
This is one part of it.
The other part is the same as Shahzada Reza Pahlavi said in her book.
Shahzada would criticize a single-party party.
And other issues.
It's very difficult.
After 60 years, you are in the countries of the region,
the dictators of the region,
and you see what Bashar Assad has done to power.
I don't know about other people,
but when you see that these Mohammedans have easily
left the country,
you know, and your country,
as Shahzada Bakhtiar said,
I leave it here, you know,
and this country,
where did this country really end up?
It was a confrontation with the Rouhanis.
Of course, there was a lot of threat from the communists in the international community.
Even the kings of the Shah's time
didn't feel threatened by the revolution.
They were convinced that since the Rouhanis were against the communists,
there was no threat to them.
The threat of religious fundamentalists was not as serious as it is today.
But perhaps, if there had been a greater strength,
they would have been able to resist even more.
And these terrorists,
who had the intention of winning the government,
had a very important front.
The Pahlavi government,
with all its intentions,
was a train that was moving forward on a railway.
The Islamic Republic came and pulled this train,
and sent it up to Nagorjabad.
So, when we talk about the will of the Shah,
we have to be very careful about what we say.
In the modern world,
you live in North America,
which is a capitalist country,
and perhaps the most advanced country in this field.
Many people criticize this,
saying that they don't like living in a capitalist country,
and prefer the form that Europe has taken for itself,
which is socialist with social welfare.
What is your opinion on this?
If we want to compare living in European countries
with living in a capitalist country like America?
I believe that the European regimes,
like Germany and France,
have been formed on the basis of the free market.
They cannot be taken as an example of socialism or communism.
They have not taken any of those countries as an example of socialism.
Today, the system is a system in terms of capital.
But it has different forms.
America has a population of 300 million.
They have come here from all over the world,
with different ideas,
and different religions.
It is different from a country
that has a population of 9-10 million in Europe.
What I can say is that a lot of people
like to live in European countries,
like America.
This country has its advantages.
But the capitalist system,
to my knowledge,
is the best economic management system in the country.
I believe that the Iranian opposition
should pay attention to the economic aspect.
When a government comes to you
and tells you that it intervenes in the economy,
and as a citizen,
it says that it has the best identification
and that you can spend your money in a better way,
I think this is unfair to human nature.
The capitalist system,
in my opinion,
is more fair to human nature.
The capitalist system should pay attention
to the bad nature of human nature.
The capitalist system should pay attention
to the bad nature of human nature.
The government should not be a traitor,
nor should it be a gambler.
When a government becomes an economic gambler,
it should be able to play with the balance.
It should be able to play with the balance.
We have seen examples of government intervention
and communist systems.
The capitalist system,
in my opinion,
is a system that should have a guarantee.
The capitalist system,
in my opinion,
is a system that should have a guarantee.
There is also a danger.
A few days ago,
I was reading a book by a U.S. professor.
He was talking about a few dangerous professors
who want the economy of this country to become communist.
They want the government to supervise it.
Where does a government get its money from?
It gets its money from finance.
The government that can do this
is a government that is a gambler
in the eyes of the people.
The capitalist and capitalist system
is a gambler.
Do you think the Islamic Republic
is a communist system?
I don't want to give a specific name.
It is a system that wants everything.
It is a system that is a threat
to the lives of the people of the city.
It is a system that is a threat
to the lives of the people of the city.
If you look at it,
you will see that there is nothing in Iran
that prevents the government from intervening.
I mean the government.
There is nothing that prevents the government
from intervening.
Why is a girl like Armitage
fighting for her life
in a hospital bed?
The reason is that the government
says that it identifies the cover-up.
The Islamic Republic is a system
that is a threat to the Muslim Brotherhood.
Do you remember Khamenei?
He was one of the people
who translated the book Seyed Qutb before the revolution.
The Muslim Brotherhood.
The Muslim Brotherhood,
along with the communists.
If you look at the basic laws of the Islamic Republic,
or at other laws,
you will see that it is a system
that wants everything.
It is a system that is a threat to the people of the city.
In my opinion,
the communists are the masters of this system.
They are a threat,
as you said,
a threat to the communists
and to religion as an ideology.
The power that the government has now,
which controls everything,
and which knows Seyed Qutb
as the Marx of the Islamic world,
may have led to the result
that all the communist elements
that are operating in different places
in the Islamic Republic
may have acted.
Like the government,
nationalization of everything.
The movement that started last year
was called the Mahsa Movement.
Why do you think it is moving forward now?
This movement actually started in 1996
in Pasargad.
The cities were nationalized.
The government always tried
after the revolution
to say that Khomeini's nationalists
were against Islam.
Or that the forces that came
were nationalistic.
They were nationalistic
because they had a problem
with the concept of Islam.
Iran was after Islam for them.
But this new generation
that has come to Iran
and these people
what they have realized
is that this is something
that can make the people
of Iran a democratic country.
It is a nationalist move.
It is a move towards Iran.
It is an Iranian movement.
It is an Iranian city.
It is a friendly Iran.
This is a very blessed event.
If you look at the slogans
in the recent days
when the topic of Palestine
has become hot again
if you pay attention to the slogans
of the people
neither Gaza nor Lebanon
nor the Arab world
they are very neutral.
You compare this to the revolution
of 1957
which was the pursuit
of the dream of Palestine
and the promise to the people
of Israel
and the backbiting of the West
and this led to a very
We have reached a point where a generation is saying that we have revolutionized.
What have we done wrong?
It is clear that even the biggest economic crises that the people are facing
if you look at the slogans, they are not just economic slogans.
The slogans are political slogans.
People have realized that if they don't have food on the table,
if they are suffering from poverty,
the reason for that is foreign policy.
Political slogans are foreign policy,
they are Islamic, they are philistine,
they are spending people's money.
When you put all of these things together,
I think that revolution has begun.
And if you ask me, I think that revolution has won.
We have just heard the sound of victory.
The victory of dialogue has been achieved.
In other words, that left-wing dialogue,
they have tried so hard that the slogans of Nashah and Nasheh,
even the communist slogans,
have entered the economic crisis that the people are facing.
But people are saying that our enemy is here,
farmers, workers, not just the youth.
The youth have come to the conclusion that we have revolutionized.
What have we done wrong?
And I think that this revolution,
the national revolution of Iran,
with its opponents,
is a victory.
The concerns that exist are that
when there is a lot of talk about nationalism,
or whether nationalist movements will take place,
the concerns are that these are some right-wing,
individual groups,
and it will be a violation of nationalism.
Does nationalism have anything to do with this violence?
Look, Mohan,
one thing that many intellectuals and activists have done,
the things that have happened in the West,
they have thought that this nationalism,
the 19th century nationalism,
is not a nationalism of other citizens.
Even though the Iranian nationalism has been attacking for 44 years,
it has been attacking in history,
but these 44 years are the continuation of the attack
on Iranian nationalism and nationalism of the people.
But the people do not have the nationalism of other citizens.
And they have shown this.
You can even see in places where buses are in danger,
people come and protect them,
so that they don't get beaten up.
What kind of violence is this?
What kind of nationalism is this?
What kind of nationalism in Iran has committed violence?
This should not be compared to,
I don't know,
because some of our intellectuals feel that
if we bring in something from a Western country,
a name, a school,
they would do this.
For example, the existence of Jean Paul Sartre in the West
attracted many people.
They thought they should translate this
and bring it to Iran.
And if a place has made a conclusion,
it will definitely have a consequence in Iran.
And if it has a bad result,
we are definitely in a place where
you look at the United States,
and you will see that
there is a lot of violence,
a lot of violence against the United States.
How is it that for them,
this nationalism,
this patriotism,
was not a blessing for us?
No, it is not like that.
The nationalism that we have,
with the nationalism of the 19th century,
with the nationalism of other citizens,
is definitely different.
It is a way for us to free ourselves
from the ideas of the urban Iranians
and the Iranians in general.
Thank you Mr. Behzad Mehrani
for your time.
Thank you for having me.
