Is Plasma just as good as Amsteel? They are both dyneema so we tested them with button knot soft shackles on the slack snap machine and filmed it in slow motion. We also test different configurations to see strength comparisons depending how you use them. Thank you Matt Stolling and Lorenzo Demuro (@thezenlunatics) for helping break stuff. Thank you Sean Simmons (@seansimmons93) for sponsoring this video with the Plasma. Thank you Matthew Warwick (@matwick_uk) for giving us the modified girth hitch idea. You can buy Plasma at https://www.ropeinc.com/cat-new-england-spectra-poly3.html Best price I have found for Amsteel Blue is https://www.go2marine.com/product/38345F/samson-amsteel-blue-rope.html-790235412 NO ROPE COMPANY SPONSORS THIS VIDEO.
All donations go straight back into making this channel better. We put donors names in the ending credits and give them exclusive access to the SlackSnap Raw Data spreadsheet + corresponding footage associated with each break. This all couldn't happen without you!
How strong are button knot soft shackles made out of plasma?
Check it out on this episode of How Knot to Highline.
Hi, I'm Ryan Jinks, and I'm here today with Matt Stolling and Lorenzo DeMuro,
and Sean Simmons bought us some plasma, which is a Dyneema, instead of Amsteel,
it's Plasma, it's a different brand, just to see if it was similar in strength.
So we made a handful of soft shackles out of them, and we're going to test them today
in different configurations to see how strong they are.
So we have six samples we're going to break today.
They're all the same plasma material, which is kind of what we want to test,
but we also want to see how strong button knots are.
Plasma is the high molecular poly weight, the metal ethylene or something.
Anyways, it's ******* Dyneema, okay?
It's the same stuff as Amsteel, but it's a different cute color.
So we're going to find out if it's just as strong,
but mostly we're going to test different configurations.
What we have here is a normal button knot with a normal noose that goes over it.
And we have two of those for a control sample,
since this is the thing we want to know the most.
But this is also the same way we did it, however, this is locked.
So instead of putting it right over the top, we go under itself,
and then make it kiss its own ass.
So we have found these.
These make people feel better about not coming apart.
However, we are finding they break significantly lower.
So we're going to test that.
We're going to test tails not being buried and see if that makes a difference.
Because the noose going around four strands of Dyneema,
because it generally breaks right here, is what makes it strong.
Not the fact that the tails are not going to come out of this knot.
So in theory, that should be just as strong.
However, it's not very pretty.
This, we never did set the knot.
This is a squishy, soft knot.
And this should deform the button knot and come off significantly lower than a set knot.
Setting your knots on button knots is very important.
And our sixth test is a unique idea that Matthew Warwick told me about,
where instead of doing the ice slice, where the noose is normally just that,
is you put it in a second time, and then you have this girth hitch, sort of,
that you can put over the noose.
And it makes you also feel better about it not likely to come off.
However, you have two strands spliced through the same
Amsteel that is split six strands and six strands.
We have a feeling like this might break pretty low.
But it's interesting because it always breaks right here on the noose.
So in theory, this part would be stronger, but it's pulling pretty unfavorably right here.
So let's start breaking this thing on the slack set machine.
So our slack set machine is basically a dynamometer fixed to this side.
And then we have this shackle that is attached to this 10 pulley system for our 20 to 1.
And Lorenzo apparently doesn't know how this works because he's trying to pull
it apart instead of using the button, which is conveniently right here.
Which pulls 20 strands of 6 millimeter Dyneema rope.
Amsteel. We're using Amsteel to break Amsteel. It's very cannibalistic.
We're just curious what the last point is holding.
We have a whoopee sling to extend because I'm too cheap to buy a long enough rope.
Aluminum non-locking carabiner, which is so classic.
And these are the fixed pulleys on this side.
And our winch pulls it in, double spool, double strand.
So that means it's coming in twice as fast at a 10 to 1 speed,
even though it is a 20 to 1 strength.
We use this to catch it so it doesn't fly all over the place.
And it basically pulls this apart from the other one until things go snap.
18,050 pounds broke the noose.
Last strand of our 20 to 1 is only 5 kilo.
That's 1,000 pounds. That's pretty legit.
Something else interesting about our first sample here was this strand right here is
Amsteel rarely breaks clean all 12 strands of the 12 braids that it is.
Another interesting thing is this button knot had some broken strands
start to happen inside of it. Not quite sure how or what.
This is just normal use softshaddle.
What does it read at?
16,000.
Whoa, 2,000 pounds less than the other one.
That's quite a bit different, but plenty strong still.
So this locked softshaddle is stiff, super, super stiff.
It broke at the noose like it's supposed to and pretty much doesn't have too much damage.
And I don't think it broke anything in the button knot this time.
Whereas the last two, it did perform pretty good.
It did break 1,000 pounds lower than our lowest normal sample.
But you're talking about such high forces relative for our highlining needs.
It doesn't matter.
So something super interesting about this locked softshaddle is it takes up quite a bit more
distance of your softshaddle to tie it off.
So this distance was really hard to connect to this shackle and this one and get it installed.
Even with the two shackles touching,
you would definitely have to make these kind of longer if you wanted to do a lot.
11,650 pounds for sample 230, which is our tails not buried.
I understand why the tails need to be buried.
Ooh, feel, you want to feel my knot?
Oh, wow.
That's warm.
Whoa, 95 degrees.
97.
And it was normally 60 to 64 degrees.
And after it's cooled off quite a bit.
It came totally undone.
It didn't break the noose, it broke the knot.
Oh, it's okay.
It's reading different.
So that's 82.
Oh, it gets hot.
Oh, at the top is where it's hot.
Oh, the noose broke.
It's supposed to deform this and slide off.
That knot though.
Yeah, that is normally.
I've had this happen in the past where the noose slips off because it deforms.
Yeah.
And then it becomes like this.
And it kind of looks like this, but it ends up slipping off the top.
It actually happened to one of these big guys.
Not this one particularly, but it did look.
It looked like a snake head when I was done.
Something this big, this thing slipped off of it because clearly I'm not going to break this.
But it slipped off and the dynamometer hit the tree that I was using.
So that was quite unpredictable and scary.
And I was expecting that to do the same.
So what was the reading on this?
Yeah.
What's the dyno say?
We're at 1630.
300.
16.
What?
An unset knot at full strength?
Huh.
So we can tell before we've really even put significant tension on this,
that because of the captive eye here and the way it extends in both directions from it,
this strand is already seeing the majority of the load.
I cannot bend that with my fingers no matter how hard I try.
But this one still has a noticeable amount of play in it.
So this one is seeing much higher tension than this one.
Sometimes Amsteel will correct itself by just slipping.
Uh, 15,000 even.
Huh.
That's not too bad.
No, I think it melted it together.
Wait, I think I know what happened.
This would be like a normal girth hitch.
And like usually, you know, this bridge is keeping everything on.
But we've gone through.
And so there's only half of this strand holding these in place.
Yeah, because our saw shackle has the six strands on this back side as well.
Yeah, and so essentially this outside part just broke.
And the whole thing was now as if it was this.
And it just came open.
And like...
Yeah, because this thing...
There's six strands still in contact and six that are broke.
Wow, that is unique.
It actually did not lower the breaking strength.
It is probably more difficult to undo and set and reset
because the way it girth hitches it together, you really have to loosen it up.
If you're really worried about soft shackles coming undone,
I guess this would be your way of doing it because it's apparently strong enough.
Since the point of this episode is to compare plasma with Amsteel,
we repeated all those breaks with Amsteel.
And to spare you from having to watch all of that,
here is a chart with all that information.
And yes, it has kilonewtons.
You're welcome.
The biggest difference that I noticed between plasma and Amsteel
is that plasma is very stiff and Amsteel can do this.
Plasma is very stiff.
It feels like Amsteel after you've pulled it real tight
and it has that stiff feel and you got to massage it out.
It's how it feels all the time.
It's kind of not that great to work with.
But if you like purple, you should buy plasma because they basically are the same.
As far as the configurations go, basically everything's pretty strong.
The normal ones have quite a variation in them.
That's just kind of what happens with soft shackles.
But the safety ratio is so high for our use as highliners
that I'm not worried about these at all.
It was kind of enlightening when we did the locked test on our Amsteel, this kind.
And it basically, it's pulling so aggressively right here
that it slipped off the head when we tested this one.
And which this is how I used it in the past
is I put it between two sewing loops to get rid of that knot.
So it's not in the way.
But it slipped off this head.
And I definitely always bury my tails and definitely think you should too.
Even though it did break high,
I don't like how the Amsteel is pulling through the knot while you put tension on it.
So it's definitely do it the proper way even though we did test it.
I just wanted to see what worst case scenario is
in case people don't do things right to see where the catastrophic failure would be.
Now, unset knots are a little interesting
because they do basically, if they break at the noose,
will break at full strength.
Or in our Amsteel case, more than full strength,
more than I've ever gotten in the past at 19,000 pounds.
However, if you don't set your knot properly,
it can get deformed and the noose can slip off significantly lower
than what you're hoping it holds.
Now to set the knot, we have discovered after doing a lot of tests
since even making this video earlier,
that we only set it by doing this.
And ironically, we pull on it, which is the opposite of what you would think.
But we pull on it like this.
And if you don't have a slack snap machine in your garage,
just go to the park with your pulleys
and take a 15 to 1 pulley system for like long lining and pull it by yourself.
And then what you do is you flip it 180 degrees and put it on there again.
So you're pulling the knot in two directions
and pull this again, but even harder.
And then do it one more time
and get three of your friends to pull on the 15 to 1
and then flip it again one last time.
And you're going to achieve about six, seven or eight kilonewtons
when you have three of your friends pulling.
And that is more than you'll ever get on a highline with these.
And they'll be set rock hard every single time.
It's how we set all of our set button knots for these tests.
As far as the girth hitch thing goes, I'm not sold on it.
It's a clever idea that Matthew Warwick brought up.
I don't think it really achieves anything.
It takes more am steel.
And you could always take this and create a loop like that
and then stick it over the head, which we also did test,
but I didn't want to get any more variations in the video.
And it doesn't pull the strands evenly in that configuration.
It doesn't solve anything.
Even an unset knot, we tried to see if it helps prevent it from slipping off.
It basically does nothing.
It takes a little bit more am steel.
And if you do it the way we spliced it for this video,
it's limiting to always having to do that with your soft shackle.
If sometimes you don't want to, you'd be screwed.
Anyways, let me know what other kind of am steel tests you want to see,
and we will put it on the slack snap machine.
Now, all of these connectors are really strong and float in water,
but we get a large variation in our results.
Therefore, you shouldn't highline.
Hey, thanks for watching.
But don't be an idiot and try highlining with things you made from home
without going with somebody who knows what they're doing the first time you go out.
A great way to meet people is to go to Slackline Festivals,
which we have all over the world now.
Slackademics.com, which is where you'll find that chart,
also has a list of over 1300 Facebook groups
that you can connect with slackliners near you.
And if you're in the Lodi, California area,
you can message me and we can possibly go out for a private lesson.
And thank you again, Sean Simmons, for supporting this episode
by buying the plasma that we broke tests.
And it really helps if you get involved being a patron with $1 per episode
or just a one time donation on PayPal.
It really helps us justify breaking a bunch of perfectly good gear.
And if you do contribute to this channel in some way,
then we give you the entire chart of Slack Snap
and all the video files correlated with it.
And we just last night passed over 500 break tests
and we have all sorts of things on there.
So you can nerd out for days if you're interested in that.
Until you have a chance to make some soft shackles,
check out our other videos and like, follow and subscribe
and hit that bell button.
So you get to see all the next ones.
Cheers.