We all know friction in a mechanical advantage block and tackle pulley systems can reduce output, but I haven't heard anyone talk about stretch. I am always using semi static or climbing ropes, which have a lot of stretch. We test all the way up to a 13:1 with dynamic, semi static and 0 stretch dyneema. We did NOT use multipliers or brakes to simplify this already long experiment. *All numbers are in kN. Trying to keep a lot of data easy to look at! ►►►DYNAMIC ROPE ►1:1 pulleys n/a - 1.34 INPUT x 1.19 OUTPUT / 100% vs Actual 88% ►3:1 with pulleys - 1.13 INPUT x 2.26 OUTPUT / 300% vs Actual 200% ►3:1 without pulleys - 1.19 INPUT x 1.99 OUTPUT / 300% vs Actual 167% ►5:1 with pulleys - 0.89 INPUT x 3.84 OUTPUT / 500% vs Actual 431% ►5:1 without pulleys - 1.39 INPUT x 2.38 OUTPUT / 500% vs Actual 171% ►9:1 with pulleys - 0.85 INPUT x 5.92 OUTPUT / 900% vs Actual 696% ►9:1 without pulleys - 1.12 INPUT x 2.38 OUTPUT / 900% vs Actual 212% ►13:1 with pulleys - 1.01 INPUT x 5.04 OUTPUT / 1300% vs Actual 499% ►►►SEMI-STATIC ROPE ►1:1 pulleys n/a - 1.62 INPUT x 1.26 OUTPUT / 100% vs Actual 78% ►3:1 with pulleys - 1.31 INPUT x 3.46 OUTPUT / 300% vs Actual 264% ►3:1 without pulleys - 1.72 INPUT x 2.48 OUTPUT / 300% vs Actual 144% ►5:1 with pulleys - 1.10 INPUT x 5.15 OUTPUT / 500% vs Actual 468% ►5:1 without pulleys - 1.18 INPUT x 2.67 OUTPUT / 500% vs Actual 226% ►9:1 with pulleys - 1.31 INPUT x 7.48 OUTPUT / 900% vs Actual 696% ►13:1 with pulleys - 1.4 INPUT x 6.98 OUTPUT / 1300% vs Actual 498% ►►►DYNEEMA ROPE ►1:1 pulleys n/a - 2.33 INPUT x 2.07 OUTPUT / 100% vs Actual 89% ►3:1 with pulleys - 1.34 INPUT x 4.04 OUTPUT / 300% vs Actual 301% ►3:1 without pulleys - 1.47 INPUT x 2.97 OUTPUT / 300% vs Actual 202% ►5:1 with pulleys - 1.67 INPUT x 6.71 OUTPUT / 500% vs Actual 402% ►9:1 with pulleys - 1.47 INPUT x 9.62 OUTPUT / 900% vs Actual 654% ►13:1 with pulleys - 1.51 INPUT x 8.54 OUTPUT / 1300% vs Actual 565% ►►►THOUGHTS: *** % wasn't that different but my input is so much greater not fighting stretch ***9:1 is better than a 13:1 and might be worth using, but a 5:1 is the most optimal to get as close to theoretical as possible
😀😀😀DISCOUNT GAME: 👉 24% off all pulleys for 24 hours on https://www.extremegear.org/shop/hardware/pulleys 👉 Discount code is found in the book of numbers in the Bolting Bible https://www.hownot2.com/boltingbible 👉 10% of your purchase (of non-sale items) supports this channel and the rest goes to Cave Exploration Society, the non-profit that owns and operates ExtremeGear.
Mechanical advantage is a myth.
Now hear me out.
I got more fours with a nine to one.
When you see those diagrams where you have a three to one
or a five to one with a hundred kilograms on this side
and it puts three or 500 kilograms on the output.
Yeah, we all know that if you add friction to that,
you're not gonna get those results.
That's theoretical, perfect math or science.
However, nobody really talks about stretch.
And as I'm trying to tinker with a pulley system
that I can go out side of the lab
and break all sorts of things that we have planned.
I need the perfect pulley system to get the most force
I can get with just me or another person pulling.
So that's this video,
exploring how mechanical advantage really works.
Now we're not gonna add multipliers to the system
because that complicates the crap out of it.
All we're gonna do is pull straight
and a three to one, a five to one, a nine to one.
And what I thought was clever, a 13 to one
until I realized it's not, spoiler alert.
And then we use a dynamic rope, a static rope
and Dyneema, which is zero stretch
in order to see how much stretch affects each one.
So stay tuned and watch the shit show
while we have all these numbers we're gonna spray you.
If you want, you can see it in the description below.
I'll lay it out nice and easy for you to read.
We're just gonna try to keep this video fast paced.
Stay tuned.
Our first test is a single strand
of about five meters of dynamic rope.
Let's see if we get the same output as I give the input.
So I got a little bit less here than what I was pulling.
So now I've added two pulleys to the system,
giving me a one, two, three to one.
And here we have a nice SMC three inch pulley
and over there kind of a crappy one inch pulley.
And this gives us three times more dynamic rope
in the system or about 15 meters.
Hmm, that's not 3.3.
This should be 3.3 if it was a true three to one.
Now this isn't the best pulley on this side,
but that's a pretty good one.
Friction's not my problem in this case, it's stretch.
Now I'm gonna add friction to the system.
I took both pulleys out and we're gonna see
if this three to one gives me a lot less over there.
Fingers are gonna wear out.
A little bit less, but not that much less.
What was it before?
2.26.
So friction did decrease my output from my input.
So now I'm doing a five to one with five times more material
than our single pull.
We got one, two, three, four, five with no pulleys
to see what friction does.
1.39 input, 2.38 output.
That is not five times more.
It's not even two times more.
You've made it worse.
I've made it worse.
And a three to one.
Let's add pulleys.
Feel like I'm gonna spring forward or backward here.
Getting better, but that's not five times 0.89.
One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine
to one with nothing but carabiners.
I don't even know if it's gonna work
because it's all pinched together,
which is more of a demonstration
on why there are rigging plates
than a demonstration of friction.
Not even getting anything, damn it.
Yeah, that's no different than the five to one result.
That's because I was only getting five to one
working with me.
The other rest were just loose.
Let's just add all the pulleys in now.
Five, six, seven, eight, nine to one with pulleys.
5.92, not quite nine times more, but it's close.
Let's try a 13 to one.
I added little pulleys on the tail end of the big pulleys.
So now I've got 13 strands here
and I've used all of my dynamic rigs to do this.
We got five.
That's less.
Less than half.
Well, you got 8.89 on this last time
and you got almost six last time.
Really?
So that did not increase the force by adding those pulleys.
It decreased it.
I have a theory on why that happened.
I added another four passes of rope.
So my nine to one to 13 to one,
that's just that much more rope.
It's just nothing but bungee cord
I'm working with at this point.
I bet if the rope was super static, it would give me more.
The next test we do, we use a 10.0 semi-static rope,
the kind that you would haul a bag up El Capitan
or possibly jump off of a thousand foot cliff with.
Don't jump rope with static ropes.
That was a very specific thing.
You've got to check out our Dan Osmond math videos
coming out on that.
Make sure you subscribe and hit the bell notification
so you get notified when the videos come out.
You don't depend on the algorithm
because you'll miss deals like this we keep doing.
24% off for 24 hours from the time I post this video
on pulleys on ExtremeGear.org.
These double SMC pulleys,
the three inch ones you see in this video
are like $120, $130 each.
If you bought a set of these, you could save over $60.
So we're giving away all our profit on these flash sales.
So you'll learn about ExtremeGear.org,
which supports me 10%, whatever you buy there.
That's not on sale.
So if you buy climbing, caving, canyoning gear,
then please buy it there.
They do ship worldwide.
It really supports this channel
because living off of YouTube ads is also a myth.
I will tell you where the discount code is
for the 24% off at the end of this video
because I really need the watch time.
Now for the 10.0 static rope test.
We're gonna work backwards with our static rope.
We're starting with our 13 to one,
since it was already reaved,
with a 10.0 semi-static rope.
It's interesting, I got a lot more
because it's not springy on me.
Not exactly 13 times 1.4.
This is a kilonewton more
than we got on any of the other ones.
We have now downgraded or upgraded,
depending on the results,
to a nine to one with 10.0 semi-static rope.
I got more force with a nine to one.
With less input.
WTF, with less input, oh my god.
So now we have a five to one
with the 10.0 semi-static rope.
Dun dun dun, dun dun dun.
We're getting closer.
Five to one with no pulleys.
Pulleys are pretty cool.
Pulleys are pretty, okay, friction's a thing.
I'm not saying friction's not a thing.
I'm just saying stretch sucks.
Three to one with pulleys.
Perfect.
Hey, that's almost like a three to one.
Three to one with just the carabiners.
No pulleys.
Oh, I got 1.72.
Not bad for just carabiners.
Yeah, but it's not double.
So I'm pulling the static straight with no pulleys.
Get it, it's straight.
And I'm using a tree to one.
Get it?
Ow, shit.
I'm gonna lose my fingers.
This is what I was pulling.
It's exactly the same if you're dyslexic.
Welcome to tomorrow.
We now have five millimeter, 12 grade Dyneema,
SK75, not that that matters.
And I'm going to start with a 13 to one
and we'll work our way down.
Pretty hard to do the first thing in the morning.
1.51.
That's the highest result we've got.
That's pretty good.
It's definitely not 13 times.
Pretty good.
And I think that's also the highest force input.
So we've reduced this down to a nine to one
and Bobby thinks it's gonna just be the same result,
which I'm afraid he might be right.
Which actually it's less rope to deal with.
More pulleys, every pulley is supposed to reduce friction,
but it always, there's always a little bit.
You add four more pulleys in the system,
you're gonna get friction.
How did he die?
Got skewered by a dog.
Is that higher?
Higher.
Is that, that's higher?
With the same input.
No.
That's getting closer to nine to one.
No.
Well, hot damn.
That's pretty good for a five to one.
If my math's correct, that's close.
Three to one.
A lot less give in the system.
Holy jeez, Derek.
Fun fact.
This has the same coefficient as Teflon,
which means it's slippery.
So it's made out of 100% dolphin skin.
It's not, so I can't say it.
If it was, I couldn't say it, that'd be bad.
Dolphin tears.
That's worse, man.
Three to one, what's this times three?
Did I get exactly 300%?
You're a lot closer, yeah.
Yeah, pretty much.
I mean, I'm no mathematician, but that was dope.
That was literally exactly a three to one,
and our stretchy rope was not.
Mechanical advantage is a myth.
If you've used stretchy stuff, we wouldn't disappoint.
Three to one with no pulleys.
That hurts really bad.
See what we just had.
All right, so less than a three to one.
There's friction, friction's a thing.
So now I'm gonna pull straight with the same five meters.
We've got the best pulleys in our system.
Bobby thinks you might enjoy that joke more than he did.
Please tell me if you like that joke.
It'll help disperse all the comments
of how I'm doing this wrong.
Let's do the three to one.
Ouch, oh, look at that.
That's a three to one right there.
Huh, it's not 100%.
I could have sworn it would have been 100%.
So for this break test,
we settled on a five to one pulley
because that is a lot less rope,
and I'm trying to go as lightweight as possible
to carry this stuff whenever I travel somewhere
or hike it somewhere.
And I put the line scale three in a protective case
so if it does go flying,
I don't break yet again more line scales.
And our test that we're trying to break
is a 16 kilonewton climbing carabiner from Amazon.
It is some of the leftovers
from the video we're making about that
where we broke test 16 kilonewton carabiners
that are advertised for climbing.
So I got really tired of pulling samples while Ryan filmed.
So I made him buy us a new toy.
This is a portable winch.
This is a capstan winch that is battery powered.
So you wrap the rope around this
and as long as you're taking slack out of the system
on this side, it pulls.
As soon as you stop doing that,
it just spins underneath the rope here.
And what else did we discover it was great for?
Pulling samples up on the drop tower.
And what are we trying to now discover
what we can do with it?
So we're trying to discover if when they say
you can pull 2,000 pounds with it,
that's actually correct.
Should we bring up soft elevator music
so people don't have to listen to this?
Dude, my whole van just shifted.
Was that as good for you as it was for the tree?
It's still shaking.
This tree is shaking.
Where is it?
It's clearly not on here.
The thing about taking stuff outside the lab
is you've got a much bigger area to find stuff.
Yeah, dude, I have no idea.
I could look at the slow-mo.
So apparently in 81 to 100 miles an hour,
81 to 101, which is how I was trying to break things before,
as I'm sure you can see how bad that is now,
with a static rope, isn't gonna get me very far.
I'm glad we did this test.
This is the kind of stuff that I go through
to learn how to make these videos
and how to break stuff in all sorts of situations
because we want to do a lot of tests.
Yes, we will do V threads in ice,
but I really need this to work first.
And in that case, we can just have a snowmobile,
ATVs, cars pull at the tail,
or five dudes pulling the tail of something.
I just need more input and accept the fact
that the output can only be so much
when I'm using ropes and pulleys.
The discount code for the 24% off for 24 hours,
which is on extremegear.org,
the discount code is actually gonna be found
on the Bolting Bible on hownotto.com.
And I don't even ask for your email.
It's a free book.
I just want you to learn about bolts more than you do.
So if you head to the book of numbers
where it shows all the break tests we've ever done,
super organized in charts,
we're eventually gonna add graphics and screenshots later,
but there's a lot of good information in there
and we're gonna be making more videos about that.
So head over to the Bolting Bible on hownotto.com,
grab the code for extremegear.org.
It's important to hit the bell notification
when you subscribe so you get notified when these come out
because we're coming out with some really good stuff
I know you're gonna love to see.
Thanks for watching to the end.
Cheers.
Look what we found behind the tree.
That's amazing.