Are you UNKNOWINGLY climbing on homemade gear???

HowNOT2
100 followers
3 Video Views·Jan 3, 2024
Are homemade permanent cable quickdraws safe? Should anyone make gear other people trust their life to unless they can test it?
Sponsored by the big cable dog bone industry 😂
Not really but we do sell some at https://hownot2.store/collections/quickdraws?filter.p.m.custom.sling_material=Steel
👉 Learn and SHOP at https://www.hownot2.com/shop
👉 Best EMAILS on Earth: https://www.hownot2.com/signup
👉 SUPPORT US and get gear discounts https://hownot2.com/support
👉 10% off ROCKY TALKIE by clicking https://www.hownot2.com/rocky
Safety first. We're gonna test some... I'm assuming some pretty strong stuff today.
These are homemade perma-draws. Things you can leave outside because you're technically not
supposed to leave nylon quickdraw dog bones outside and leave them out all the time to just
rot in the weather in the UV. This is supposed to be, you know, something that lasts a long time.
So this perma-draw is by Climtec and they're either hard to get or they cost a bunch and so
my buddy decided to make a whole bunch of these. Now, if you have a caliper just sitting around,
you'll see that this is measured at about 5.6 millimeters and the cable my buddy used is
six and a half millimeters. So it's a full millimeter thicker of a gauge which is
probably gonna break a lot stronger no matter how he did it. That's not true,
it's all in how you swage it. Now you'll notice this thing doesn't have any thimbles whereas
these do. Now some of these don't have a thimble, other ones have a light duty thimble, and this one
has a heavy duty thimble. And the point of a thimble is to have a nice bend radius so the
cable doesn't get pinched which makes it weaker. We want to maintain as much strength as possible
from these. Now, first of all, does it matter? Because your carabiner you're clipping to this
is only rated for about 20-ish kilonewtons. If we're gonna get 60 and I hope to god we don't,
does anything matter at that point? Now this is a homemade dog bone that we tested and it broke
half of what a rated dog bone is for. Now the variable in these cable draws instead of stitches
is the swages. Now all of these have four crimps on the swages but some of them are
muscle mental, some of them are really good, and we're just gonna go through them and see if any
of them make a difference. Because if you can just crimp it and call it good, can you make your
own? A permanent draw is permanently up which means other people depend their lives on it.
It's one thing to do something nuts, but if it's your own life, it should be pretty reliable if
other people rely on it with their lives. Let's go break stuff. Heavy duty thimbles, bad swaging.
Let's see what happens. So in English that is 36 kilonewtons. Wow, that's a heavy duty thimble
got crushed. Oh wow, the cable broke. Even though this is a quote-unquote bad swage job, it broke
the cable. It's not like it came out. So I don't know if we're gonna get better results out of the
other dog bones. I guess we'll just have to stop the video here. So most steel carabiners do not
like to go above 30 kilonewtons and if they do go above 30 kilonewtons, they don't always work. So
we use these chain shackles and the pin inside of this is about 12 millimeters which is super
close enough to a carabiner. So we're comparing the right diameter in these thimbles. Heavy
duty thimbles, poor swaging on one side and the cable is short. Wow, that's almost the same result.
Oh, it did what Dyneema does because it has the one random strand sticking out of the other. Ouch.
Careful, we got some frayed cables around here. Pretty much broke in that. It's not like it came
out. And this heavy duty thimble is crushed. Light duty thimbles and a super good enough swage.
Different result. Oh, that is a different result. Hey, the swage does matter. The light duty and
the heavy duty I don't think matters when you're pulling it up to its final breaking strength.
The swage he thought was good is the one that slipped. This one has good swages,
light duty thimbles, and it's got heat shrink. Need a weapon? There you go.
These ones are excellent with a light duty thimble.
Now we know the MBS have heat shrink. I hate consistent results. It makes
the video way more boring. Number six is an eight out of a 10 swage with a loose thimble.
Don't take any 35 kilonewton whippers. Oh, wow. It still wiggles.
So this one had no thimble and you can see that it had such a
big effect on that. I mean, this is kind of cool. It is different than what I normally break.
So this last one also has good swages and the eye on one side is small with no thimbles.
7,700. So this mostly broke where the swage was except where it didn't. Now for the grand finale.
We have one of the Climtech rated ones for 22 kilonewtons. It is a millimeter thinner, but I
think it's still going to break higher than 22, which would be ideal.
The swages is just one big fat crimp. So it is different and it has no thimbles.
Who knew hitting that peak force number was so important. Whoopsie. Uh, based on my load cell in
my ears, that definitely broke lower. Probably more around what it was rated to 22 kilonewtons.
Look who came to visit. We have some dog bones from other manufacturers. We have a camp one
and a fix one. And I will hit peak force this time on the load cell. So we know what they
actually break at since I want to know what a, um, professionally made rated dog bone breaks at.
So our first one is the Camp Cable Express. It is 18 centimeters long. It is rated for 23
kilonewtons. It has a thimble and these are still available on the market. Unlike Climtechs.
That's a good guess. I like that margin. Overkill is underrated. So a lot of extra material here
in case you're one of those people that grabs the dog bone. So it's got a thicker plastic covering.
Yeah. Protects the cheaters. The next one is from Fix. 36 centimeters long. It's a little
bit longer, which is why we carry that since Camp didn't have one that size.
And this is rated for 22 kilonewtons and it has a thimble in there as well.
This kind of just shows how much difference you can have in the swaging. And it came out. It
didn't break above its rating. That's all I guess it needs to do. In our test, thimbles did not make
any difference with the ultimate strength. But that's not their only purpose. They are a wear
component. So if your dog bone is hanging here and wearing. Is that what it looks like when it
blows in the wind? Yeah. Or you're falling on it a bunch. This metal here is going to take the wear
and not the strands of the cable, which can break one by one and eventually fail. Yeah. Thimbles
are a great wear component. So the conclusion to my other video where I tested homemade sewn dog
bones out of nylon, not for permanent application, was that don't make stuff at home unless you can
test and verify it, because it was breaking at 11 K and when it should be breaking at 22,
they thought it was going to break in the 20s and it didn't. And that's scary that they didn't
know that. And I think that is a great conclusion for this video. There are a number of ways to
super good enough, but there are also ways that they'll fail really low. There are several climbing
manufacturers, small batch stuff. They were selling stuff that were swage that were failing
way lower than they thought they should because their machine stopped working and they weren't
doing the proper tests to make sure it was giving a good product. And the biggest beef I think I
have with this is when you're making gear that other people are going to be depending their life
on. I'm all about doing sketchy stuff for stuff I do, but when it's something else other people
are going to pin their life on like a permanent dog bone should be super duper good enough. Brought
to you by the big cable industry. They don't want you making this stuff at home. Now that's probably
not the case. No one's probably getting rich off of this, but if you are going to buy permanent dog
bones or any other climbing gear, please do it at hownotto.store because that supports what we're
doing here. Thanks for watching. Cheers.
