Mechanicals on ELK... Should You Let's have a discussion...

Defending with Past Crossbows
3 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 27, 2026
Mechanicals on ELK... Should You Let's have a discussion...
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
This video you're about to watch I didn't know was being recorded. It was at the elk immersion
experience and the reason why I'm publishing it is for a couple reasons. One, it's that time
a year where we all take to the field to go elk hunting. Number two, there's two guys in this
video. One is myself and the other is this guy named Bill from Colorado who's killed over 50
elk with a bow and he's 72 years young. We're sitting down, I'm giving you context now, we're
sitting down at an archery target, an elk one, and going over shot scenarios and how to react to
those, which shots are higher percentage. Both Bill and I share the same sentiment. You may not
share the same sentiment and I want your comments to reflect what you feel is right so that we can
have an honest discussion on what to use not only when it comes to broadheads for elk, arrow weight,
penetration, two holes, as well as shot angles, and how to react to those. So let's get a healthy
conversation going in these comments. It's timely. Attendees recorded it and sent it to me and I was
like, you know what, this video has a lot of food for thought that we could have a healthy discussion.
I don't want you to get angry. I just want your comments to be passionate and justified and share
your observations. Comment below. Let us know what you think, what is best, and then ultimately you
make the decision on what to take to the field that gives you the most confidence. I think we
all can agree that elk are tough. They're hard to take down with a bow and arrow. When done right,
it's easy. If you make a mistake, it's an uphill battle and we owe it to these animals to prepare
and be ready, which is what this channel is all about. Separations and then preparation.
Enjoy the video. I look forward to reading your comments. I shot that, um, I shot a Utah bull last
year probably about here and I got this much penetration, so this much arrow sticking out.
That's with a iron will, which is like a really good penetrating arrow and what ended up happening
is I just hit the top of the lungs. The lungs are like a balloon that neck down and I nicked with
one of the iron wheels. I nicked where it necks down, so he was still getting oxygen. He went 70
yards, laid down. I watched him die for 52 minutes. I hated it. I hated myself, but I made,
I mean, what I thought was like a, like, oh, you're done. And then I watched him lay down. I didn't go
and put another arrow at him. Couldn't sneak up on him. He was fuller, just tipping his head up for
52 minutes. What's he doing? He's drowning slowly in his own blood. He's coughing up blood. He stood
up once, coughed up more blood, laid back down and then tipped his head and finally laid down.
I cried like a baby when he finally laid his head down. I felt bad. I don't want him to suffer.
So, and that was with a shot that wasn't really that high at all. So I really want you to go
middle of the body using a fixed broad head. So if you hit the scapula, it doesn't matter.
It's still going to get into the lungs. And even if you don't get a pass through,
or if you directly even hit a rib, it's not a big deal. You're still going to punch that rib,
break it in half, even the center of it and get both lungs. The heart's kind of down in here,
obviously. So I would say aim for top of the heart, never middle or bottom, but air on the
side of tighter to the shoulder than further back. If you do hit liver and everything in here, it is
definitely a dead bull. I just don't know how long it'll take. Seen it be an hour, seen it be six
hours. You can go up to 500 yards if you bump it, then you're screwed. So if you're a little bit
back, but you see blood coming out, especially dark blood, I mean, it's just like, okay, I got
him. I just need to back off and I cannot have him smell me. Typically when I shoot,
I'm pretty excited, but I've done it enough to now where I stop. I bust out my phone. I take
a photo. I take a video, both of where he's standing. I bust out ribbon. I ribbed right
where I was standing and I checked the wind. Depending on the shot, I'm probably most likely
not going to go look for my arrow. I'm going to go back out where my wind's not going where the
direction he ran and I'm going to go chill out for 45 minutes to an hour. Then I'm going to come
back and go find that arrow. That arrow should tell you a lot, right? But I'm using an iron
wheel wide, single bevel, and I'm shooting 80 pounds. My arrow's going 290. I'm going to
penetrate. If I was like, had a mechanical broadhead, then yeah, you should probably aim
for the middle. Hope for the best, you know? I've had a lot of bad luck with mechanicals.
That's because you know stuff, Bill. They just don't work. Anybody thinking about doing it, let me talk
you off the ledge. I can do it privately. I can do it publicly. Whatever you want, but please
use a fixed sharp two or three blade chisel tip, whatever, what have you. Do you keep a couple
of mechanicals for follow-up? I do. I keep two in the very back, so I'm using the Beast this year
for my follow-ups. Let's talk about frontals. I'm just going to go to the most controversial shot.
Frontal would be like the same deal, but you just go up here. How many of you have never killed an
elk? So you don't get to take this shot until you've killed one and cut one up in real life.
The end. I'm five for six on frontals. They're all in North Idaho. They're probably all under
10 yards, but even then, I still don't have, I'm not batting a thousand, okay? They aren't usually
frontal. They look frontal. They're usually not. You'll find out. Have you used frontals?
I haven't ever used a frontal, but you know, it's a cantaloupe-sized hole, and if everything
isn't just perfect, they're surrounded by bone and armor, and you're not going to do anything
but mess him up. So it's the only shot you want to take if there's nothing else you can do,
and it's perfect. And you've killed an elk. I'm adding that. That's one of my requirements. And
the other thing is, is what he's pointing out there too, is when the elk's standing there,
you can see the front of their chest here, and it looks like that's where you want to be,
but it's not. It's higher up. You've got to go to the center of the body
in both directions. You almost feel like you're throat punching it. Yeah,
you look where the change in color is, and you go just above that change in color,
assuming everything's level. It's a tough shot. It's a heartbreak shot. Now, also,
when the thing's frontal, Bill, so it's facing you and you're at full draw,
what happens if you don't take it? You're still going to probably get a shot. You might.
There's a very good chance that he'll turn, and in fact, as I was sitting on a log, and I had a
five-point bull walk right up to within 10 feet of me, and I'm just sitting on the log stationary,
and he's right here, and he looks down at me, and then he kind of looks up and looks away,
and then he looks back down at me again, and you can see, you know, his head kind of cocks,
and you can see the wheels are turning, and he's saying, there's something not right here,
and so he spooks. He runs straight away from me. When he runs straight away, I pull, come to full
draw, 35 yards, he turns broadside to look back to see what the hell that was, and I poked him right.
If you wait, and they bust, and you cow call because you have a diaphragm in your mouth at
all times when you're in on elk, you stop, and now you got your quartering away shot,
slightly quartering away, which is my all-time favorite. That's like highest odds is that
slightly quartering away. I don't like majorly quartering away. What's in their stomach in the
morning, especially after all night? Grass. Hay, a hay bale, so you gotta go through a hay bale,
and then it's so hard to remember in the heat of the moment that you're not aiming for the 10 ring
on those severe quartering away, and you end up doing that subconsciously, or you block out,
you punch it, you might hit one lung, and you're not getting a bull. Usually, you don't get bulls
on one lung, you know what I mean, and they don't always live, but they usually live long enough for
you not to find them, and that's heartbreak city. Do you know how many direct messages I get a year
after September about someone's sob story? I've had hundreds. I wonder how many people
wound elk a year, okay? A lot. How many broadheads have you found in elk you've killed? I've never
found a broadhead. I've done three. You've done two? Two different bulls. Two, three. I mean,
----'s happening. Now, this right here is the spinal column right here.
So, what is right here? That's a really delicious giant back strap, right? That's where I found
the two or the three broadheads evolving up in here, okay? Now, Joel Turner will tell you
all that calling stuff. He'll also tell you that there's no distance between the lung
and the top, like there's no such thing as no man's land. You're still going to hit
some sort of part of the lung. I don't buy that. I don't buy that. I don't buy that either,
and I argue with him publicly about that, but maybe on inhale. Yeah, exactly. You got a dead
zone in there. Regardless, even if you did hit that lung on the full inflated lung,
you're probably not going to get that bull, and you're going to get a little excited because you
might find some blood with some bubbles that you're like, oh, I didn't get that. Well,
you got to pop that balloon, okay? And then remember, if you hit below the lungs and you
hit that brisket, get another arrow in him and make sure it's a good one. I have brisket shot
a bull, and he was like dizzy and all drunk. What was that all about?
Yes, I dropped his BP like that, firefighter, and so he's like, whoa, and he was like that for two
minutes, but I thought I'd smoked him, and he stood there and was like, I better put another
one in him, and I did, and I got him because I did, and if I had not, I would have not gotten
him. And then the classic is a little bit of fat, some darker blood. The brisket can trick you into
not, so just keep shooting into your quiver until they're hitting the ground. So severe cornerway,
not a huge fan because in the heat of the moment, you really got to know where to aim,
and it's a little bit tricky to aim for the back of the rib, but it's a damn good shot.
Broadside's awesome, slightly cornerway. Frontals are not for virgins. The other thing about
mechanicals, a lot of times you don't get an exit. I want two holes. What are we killing
animals? What is the cause? Who's my firefighter? What is the cause of death on, with archery?
Which is, so you're either, I mean, it's either you're looking at like hypoxia, so you pop a
hypovolemic shock. Can we just call it that? Oh yeah, blood loss.
Leaving the container. This is the container. Two holes makes blood leave the container faster.
Also better for tracking. Okay, so who was thinking about using, and don't lie to me,
who was like, okay, I was going to use a mechanical this year?
Like I'm taking the time out of this to like present to you this information that it's going
to catch up to you. You're going to get one, and it's going to be like that. Mechanical was the
one thing that prevented you from probably finding your out. Was it the tuning? Is it because you can
slap them on your fill points? No, I had a fixed blade and a mechanical in my quiver. I just shot
them with a mechanical. Okay. I shot two bulls in three days with mechanicals and never recovered
either one. And the one bull was a bull about like what this is right here. He was 12 yards away.
The arrow went through and stuck in his offside shoulder, and it was a two blade mechanical,
and I never recovered that bull. And I kept looking for him for three weeks, and I bumped him
three weeks later, and he went up a mountain that I couldn't follow him up. He was dragging a leg on
that offside because that arrow was in there, and it was working on that leg. And so first he was
walking on it, and by the time we got up there a ways, he was literally just dragging that one leg.
But he was going up a hill that was, I want to say, it's like a 60 degree incline. You could
just reach out and touch the hillside in front of you, and he was heading out, and I never got
close to him again. And that was three weeks after I shot him right through the boiler room
with that mechanical. And after that, I said, never again. So I've got to that point where
that's why I'm so passionate about doing this conversation. I've been there. Never again. Sure
it works out, and until it doesn't. You know what I mean? These are the toughest guys. These do not
want to die, especially when they're all running up. The hide is so thick that with your mechanical
broadhead, you lose over 20 percent of your energy on the skin. So Iron Will did a study
where they had a force plate. They pushed the arrow and whatever was on the end through hide
and a scab, and they measured the foot pounds. So like Iron Will took like 70 foot pounds.
The Grim Reaper Micro Hades is a good one. Three or four blade. It took like maybe a hundred
QAD, hundred. The mechanical got to 400, 400 foot pounds, and then the material broke in the
broadhead. So it never even penetrated. So it's just the energy it takes. And then if somebody
will tell you, well, like Bodie Turner will tell you he's going to use the Beast on Elk this year.
Well he's Bodie Turner. He's going to probably put the arrow right where he shot placement.
Shot placement is going to be money. I know my shot placement is not always perfect.
And it affords me as a solo elk hunter to do more. Like I will take frontals and some good
angled frontals with an Iron Will 2 blade solo because I'm going to, if I call one in and I,
you know, if I feel good about the shot or whatever. So quartering twos are tough too.
I mean quartering twos is just such a tough shot. And a lot of times, especially my early years,
I don't know if it's happened to you Bill, but I called in a lot of bulls solo in that state
and I thought they were broadside. And I would take these shots. And when I would come up to
them, I'd be like, Oh, I hit one lung in the liver. It was quartering two. I could have swore
it was broadside. It just comes with experience and reps and whatnot. So I don't know if that
argument is compelling, but I'm trying to really convince you to go. The other thing too is with
a fixed blade broadhead, I've never had not had a pass through, never not had a pass through,
which means I got two holes. So they go less distance. And particularly with that fixed
blade, because it's going through both sides and that thing fills up quickly in both lungs. So
I shot a cow at 30 yards, 70 pounds, 31 inch draw with a three blade mechanical.
And the arrow went in, I want to say eight inches. The broadhead stuck in the tip of her heart
and broke off. And I watched her go over and tip over, but I didn't get with that three blade
broadhead more than that at 31 yards of penetration. They just don't work.
So what's, if you go in through guts and you crush the lungs or hit lung liver,
break through the diaphragm, you're stuck in the offside shoulder,
where is the fluid going to leak out of the animal? You're not going to get blood here.
So you're going to have to be a hell of a tracker or have a tip over in front of you. It's going to
be a tougher animal to find. You've got to kill it. Well, I was asking because Bill, he shot that
one in the offside shoulder. I don't know if it was the broadhead, but the one that dragged himself
up. Oh yeah, he definitely hit the shoulder. I shot right through the lungs, but when he was
coming along the hillside and then he came down through some brush and walked right out in front
of me on a trail at 12 yards, but I waited until the shoulder that was closest to me, till he took
a step. And then I tucked it right in that armpit and the arrow went through and hit this offside
shoulder and didn't come through. So this leg was still back. And so the, you know, the shoulder
blade and all of that stuff's back in the way this front one was forward. And so I was able to
just tuck it right in there. So like if you shot that elk right there, right in that crease, you'd
hit that offside leg from this angle that I'm standing at. And it's a perfect shot, but you
still may not get a penetration out the other side. You want to be dead center in here someplace.
And this gives you the largest margin of error. You're excited, you're wound up, you're going to
jerk the thing, you're going to puncture trigger or whatever else. But you know, you've got the
most forgiveness everywhere around for that shot. So this liver and diaphragm, you guys know the
diaphragm of a deer, right? You cut through that. That's, that's a mouth, liver, they're going to die.
But what about, and we told you how long to wait on a liver? Five hours. Yeah, Dirk, Derm and I did a
pod that you should save to your phone. We made it an hour on purpose and it goes over a bunch of
Go download that and then that's your play. You play that after you take your photo, video, flag
it back out, listen to it for an hour, then come in. Because remember, it's a CSI crime scene.
And I talk about how to track for blood, read tracks. And if you have a partner, if you were
the shooter, but you're all emotional, you can get out of the way, stay back at last blood, let the
other guy who's not emotionally attached to the animal do the tracking, blood confirmed. We went
through all that, but what if you hit guts? Like it could happen to you. This is the ---- show part.
Okay, this could be taking 24 hours, longer. This is where you're going to have to put another one
in them. This is where you're going to probably have to back out for a day. There are dogs
in certain states that will gladly find your elk easier if you shoot them through guts and they die
because it's more scent on the ground. They go to water when they're shot, I guess. Yeah, so
Colorado's legal, Idaho's legal, that is Wyoming. Utah's legal, Wyoming, I don't know. I did a podcast
with a guy who's in charge of this whole federation. So if you get in a jam and you know you got shot
and you know you're not going to. I know there's a vehicle. No, no, it's an entity. Yeah, and it's legal.
So yeah, Wyoming's a yes. So one of the things Dan hasn't mentioned in any of this and I think it's
really important because it was a serious lesson for me. The biggest bull I ever shot
was 41 yards away and he's walking at a really, really fast rate down the top of a ridge
and I know that I can't hit him. He's walking too fast
and he's 41 yards and he finally slows down to just almost a snail's
pace and I think okay that's doable and I took my time. I really aimed. I didn't lead him at all.
I shot the shot and it hit over a foot back because even hardly moving that elk traveled so
far in the time that I fired that arrow to the arrow actually made contact that I hit him clear
back in the liver and so the elk ran up the hill to about 60 yards and a bunch of quakies and stood
there for 20 minutes because he's so sick and then he walked off and so I had a friend and we had to
go to work the next day and so I called him and I said you better get over here and help me track
this bull because otherwise we're not going to make work. So he came across but unfortunately
he came across to where he was right below the bull came right up and blew the bull out we never
saw him again and I should have shot a second shot at 60 yards because what the hell. Yeah why not?
Yeah and I didn't because I'm thinking I got him and then the other thing was is if an elk is moving
you probably can't hit where you want to hit. You need to stop him. You didn't cow call and stop him?
Nope. Did you have a diaphragm in your mouth? Nope. So I just kind of want you to have that diaphragm in
your mouth wear them out especially when you're in tight with elk. Most of the elk I've shot have the last
thing they heard was me trying to make an elk sound with the diaphragm pretty excited and it
can be ugly too but they'll stop and look. Yeah. Stop them. Always stop them. Give them the yo.
Give them the yo. Whatever but it's nice having you here dropping knowledge like that is wisdom.
Okay so hopefully we sold you on really dependable three or two blade broadheads that fly well
maybe a mechanical for follow-up for that 60 yard shot but I think a broadhead a fixed
broadhead could do that shot. I do carry a mechanical for follow-up I made a follow-up
like 88 one year and it was sick it was like it was a nice shot him through the liver
he was slightly moving just like you said I did cow call but I still he still was moving when I
broke he ran down a cow called again stopped him 80 yards grabbed a grim reaper and dotted
him through the neck and that's all I had it's not like I was like it was just a neck shot
and that sealed the deal you know what I mean so we shoot until they hit the ground. That's right
until your quiver's empty or they're or they're on the ground. This is a good part of camp that
we try to do is get you guys just top thinking about this because you are going to take that
you are going to take that quartering too and yeah don't start and so many times I've seen
somebody shoot them and it looks like a great shot and then they start celebrating and the
elk's still there and the celebrating isn't over until you walk up and touch the horn.
Thanks for watching that guys now hopefully we didn't ruffle your feathers and if we did that's
fine again healthy discussion let's recap this video I do want to say Bill I haven't met a lot
of guys who have killed that many elk with a bow and there's definitely people who have killed more
and there's a ton of you who've killed elk with mechanicals and had great success and you feel
confident with that you do you the group that we were speaking to were largely newer elk hunters
a lot of them had never killed an elk or if they had they have never had consistent success year
over year elk are tough I think we all can agree their height is thick and the height is getting
thicker by the day in September they're losing that summer coat the bull I killed last year in
had multiple gore wounds that were super deep and he was super healthy they're just they're
built for war if you've ever seen two large adult male elk mature fight it is like a collision it
is violent and they're built for that I think you owe it to yourself to make sure that your bow is
extremely tuned that you can use a fixed broadhead if you can't get it tuned and you've got to drop
down to an expandable I would recommend a couple options that I've used on non-elk but have some
confidence in the beast would be one of them I don't work with them at all so I have an unbiased
opinion also the sever the titanium I like the newer one with the bleeders and that's why I keep
a follow-up mechanical in the back of my quiver because I have made those shots where maybe I
didn't hit perfect and I got another shot opportunity at a pretty long shot yeah I'm
going to reach for that expandable for that flight that long distance flight to try to get one more
and I owe it to the animal to empty that quiver until they're on the ground I think the takeaways
are that broadside shot you definitely got to find the sweet spot where that arrow is not going to
hit that offside shoulder so that you can get two holes we want to steer you away from frontals
you'll watch youtube you'll see guys take them and you're just going to be like oh I know I can
do that in the heat of the moment it's really hard to decipher if they're up down turned even
slightly just get one on the ground before you take a frontal and really cut open that animal
and study and you'll see what we're talking about is where all the ribs come together in the sternum
it's like they are an armor truck up front and if you do make a frontal and you do it perfect they
they will almost certainly die right in front of you but it's just again I have wounded elk and it
sucks I wish it upon nobody and I want you to not have a miserable experience that haunts you
potentially the rest of your life obviously the rest of the season potentially monkey on your
back for years to come this video is tough to make I didn't like I said I didn't plan on making it
I didn't know that was being recorded and when the gentleman sent it to me I watched it I was like
okay this will make some people mad but it'll make most people think through some of this tougher
stuff to talk about and we as bow hunters don't live in a perfect bow hunting world and we all
know that bow hunting is not perfect this world's not perfect but we try our best to make the most
perfect humane one shot one kill and honor that animal and I know that we preach working hard 365
so that you're prepared and you're ready to go in the video description I'm going to leave that
podcast we did a couple years back Dirk Durham and myself it's about an hour long listen to it
after you make your shot make sure you get your wind your scent out of the area do the things I
said take a photo video of where you stood where the animals stood flag where you shot don't go
looking for your arrow especially if you're not certain on the shot get back out listen to that
entire pod take notes and then go recover your animal and get that meat out get that hide off
quickly get the meat cooling get it on ice as soon as possible elk hunting is special we're
passionate about it I look forward to reading the comments this whole video was coming out of a place
of love and I love that I had Bill a guy with a lot of wisdom to share whether you agree with him
or not or whether you agree with me or not we don't have to agree on everything we can disagree
but we can all come together and know that we want to head to the mountains with as much confidence
as we could possibly have in ourselves and our equipment separations in the preparation
we'll catch on the next one
