Are there alternatives to the Amazon Web Service, Android and iOS? In this period of digital apartheid, how shall we prepare ourselves? Do we need alternative high tech platforms and financial systems? Will the digital apartheid serve as an evolution pressure to drive the change? Can we use RICO Act or Anti-Trust to protect ourselves in the lawfare? In this program, I talked to COL John Mills (USA Ret.) about these issues.
Hello everyone, welcome to Global Watch. This is Dr. Sean Lin. In the last few months, I think we
already changed our habits, how we use our social media. We start to pay attention to what we can
post on Facebook. We start to grind our mind to choose words, not to use those sensitive words
on the YouTube. We start to think, oh, will my teeth, will my tweet still be existing after
a few hours? We start to think this way because we've been changed because of the digital appetite,
because of the political digital appetite that we are experiencing right now.
And how should conservative voice respond to these kind of censorship? Or it's kind of like
social credit systems in communist China. How do we deal with this kind of pressure?
So in today's program, I invite Colonel John Mills to join me to discuss about these issues.
Colonel John Mill is a senior intelligence officer from the US Army. He has retired,
but he has decades experience in different areas in terms of national securities,
cybersecurity, and national intelligence. So Colonel John Mill, thank you for joining me on
today's program. Thank you, Sean. It's an honor. It's good to be with you again.
Thank you very much for joining. Colonel Mill, so I know you're writing an article for Epoch Times
regularly and be a very respected columnist on the Epoch Times as well. And so you're writing
the article regarding about the digital appetite. So at first, I want to ask you, because most
people, when they think about appetite, immediately think about South Africa. So can you talk a little
bit about why you call it a digital appetite? Well, we're in a brave new world, Sean. We've
never experienced this before, and we've never been there before. I've been involved with social
media, Silicon Valley, the business of cyber, cybersecurity for a number of years. And I kind
of saw this coming in a number of ways. We really, through the willful surrender of our data,
the convenience and the service that these environments offered us, it was always very
concerning because it was always clear that they, these different, some of them
successful companies, they had different worldviews than a lot of their users. At some point in time,
there was going to be a collision. We're at that point of collision now. So this is very disturbing.
They have successfully, again, we allowed this to happen, and we have to figure out what to do
about it, because it affects the way we live, we communicate, we do business. And if they, as we saw
after January 6th, we saw a coordinated effort, coordinated effort, and that is extremely
important when applying some of these laws, is are they coordinating? Are they sharing information?
Are they sharing lists of people or groups to exclude? Parler thought that,
okay, maybe they would be the alternative. They were ready, they were ready to go. Well,
the way they were set up, guess what? They were still extremely vulnerable to essentially
shutdown, because their app, they were, depending on their app, being provisioned,
being displayed, being offered, and being supported. You can't, you can sell an app,
you can release an app, but it has to be maintained over time. And so they very effectively
shut down Parler. Yeah, and because they used Amazon's cloud-based web service, right? So
if Amazon takes you down, you cannot easily come back, because you have to find other
service that can be strong enough, can be wide enough to support your large data volumes.
But that's another challenge. So you mentioned about these coordinated efforts, and you mentioned
you sense these trends coming, right? And so do you think they've been planning this for a long
time? This collision is actually being incubated for a very long time, but we just didn't realize,
we just get used to, you know, using it conveniently for all these digital tools.
Yes. Did they plan on January 6th to do this 10 years ago? No. But clearly, and again,
being fairly familiar with this culture, a number of these companies, there was a curious hard edge
of beliefs that, in many ways, were not in sync with the founding of this country, with the
beliefs of our constitutional republic, and frankly, out of sync with a lot of their users
and customers. We'll just make it as simple as that. So they were maneuvering for years on this
topic. This was essentially a, was it first degree? Was it second degree? It was, they saw
their opportunity and they lunged at it. And now, from this point on, there is no, it is totally
out in the open, overt, and there's no debating that they are asserting essentially a political
agenda and essentially a party line that everybody must adhere to. So do you think, actually,
we as public, we also kind of indulge in this for such a long time, you know, even just for
the last few years, when, for example, when President Trump's tweet was deleted, most people
didn't take any proactive actions against Twitter, right? We just get used to it. We know
we can't control it. You know, they are the platform. They are not publisher. We can't do
anything like that. But at the time, people didn't sense it can be such a severe situation, right?
We just made, basically, we desensitized ourselves to this kind of abuse. So it's our own fault too,
right? It absolutely is. We did not spend time or energy. There were titans that established
dominance in this market space. And we just adhered to it. But the good news here
is that actually, it wasn't that long ago. And the duration of market dominance of many of
these firms is actually not that long. Now, I don't want to get into the naming a whole lot
of names on either side, either current that dominate, everybody kind of knows who those are.
A lot of up and comers in both the data hosting environment in a lot of times will be expressed
as the cloud, which is really data centers. That actually is a very positive upside here is there
are many alternatives to the big name offers in data hosting. So the question is, why in the world
was Parler hosting their data and depending on the AWS when they knew that the owner of that
company had certain political viewpoints? I'm sorry, that is actually one of the more easy to
address situations is it was the data hosting the cloud environment. There are many other
alternatives. So I think that was a very bad business decision for Parler to bet the future
on writing on the AWS environment. I'm sorry, I don't know why they if they're going to say
they were part of free speech, they should have put two and two together and said,
we need to host somewhere else. Yeah, you need to be free all the way, right?
Even from your basic business model, need to choose a very good platform. But I'm curious as
well. Parler been gone for a few weeks now. Why haven't they managed to find a good alternative
to the AWS? I don't know what's going on inside their business or I don't know what's happened.
Essentially, data hosting, there are highly qualified who specialize in this and moving
data, large quantities, maintaining what we call in the IT world of confidentiality,
integrity and availability, the three critical aspects of service. This is kind of
rote at this point in time. So the inability of I don't know if it was a contractual issue.
I don't know if the staff just up and left at Parler. I don't know what happened.
But moving data in mass like this is actually not that big of a deal. And maybe they don't have the
A team. Maybe they don't have the B team. I don't know. But there's lots of C and D teams out there
that can do this. I'm not sure what happened. And it's almost easier to just start from scratch.
But there is an agglomeration. We have to be honest, for the immediate time being,
a lot of the A team is in the majors of the Silicon Valley Titans. But there is a rapid
evolution in this market space. We should never assume that those big name companies are going to
be dominant even a year from now. We were talking earlier and how in the mobile, a little more
harder to address is the mobile environment. Our smartphones. Right now, the Android essentially
dominates about 75, 76% of the market, which is really on two or three major phone offerings.
Okay. Wow. But we said, oh my gosh, how are we ever going to do this? But remember,
even this market space changes rapidly. It wasn't long ago that Nokia was the dominant provider.
Yes. Maybe 10 years ago. Yeah.
You mentioned earlier Palm Pilot. I mean, Palm.
BlackBerry, Palm Pilot. Yeah.
It changes rapidly. So this is a market for money to be made in. That naturally attacks talent.
That naturally attracts ability. We can do this. And there are up and coming, I don't want to
start listing some of them, but there are up and coming offers
that I think everybody's going to be surprised in a year or two about this market space.
So it is not the end of the world. We got caught. We willfully went on the cattle cars here. We
willfully went on into the cul-de-sac. We willfully went into the alley and surprise, here we are.
So we willfully entered the cul-de-sac and we're not really prepared. But I think you make a very,
very good point here is that there are definitely alternatives and the markets change very fast to
adapt to these situations. And so besides this good news, you also mentioned this kind of
situation. It's kind of like in a monopolies. So do you think on the legal aspect, we can use
anti-trust laws to counter against these tech giants? Yeah, absolutely. Oftentimes,
maybe it's just the conservative, Republican. I'm not saying this as a partisan person. I'm just
making an informed observation. But it's the nature of conservatives, Republicans, libertarians
to just kind of, they just want to live their lives. They just want to take care of their
families, do their thing. And they're not busy bodies like the other side. They're constantly,
constantly having to manipulate, push, dominate, change. And one of their forms of warfare that
they have developed to great effectiveness is their use of lawfare. I would say we have very
good legislation and very bright legislation in the 1964 Civil Rights Act. That was good law. It
was brought in and enacted for a reason. We had oppression in this country. Over time though,
I will name one organization, the Southern Poverty Law Center, which has become essentially,
I'm sorry, there's just numerous cases and their financials are extremely disconcerting on how
much money they have on the books overseas. And they're supposedly supposed to be there to
represent the black community, yet they have internal issues in their own organization
with a huge lack of black African-Americans on their staff. Yet, the Southern Poverty Law Center,
they were supposed to be there essentially to help enforce the 1964 Civil Rights Act.
So they've taken a good law and in many ways perverted it. So we need to get better about
lawfare. And I think one of the daunting thing that deters oftentimes Republicans,
conservatives, libertarians, is this perception that to do anything legal, you have to be,
one, you have to be a lawyer. Okay. No, you don't. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. There's a lot of
non-lawyers who understand law better than lawyers. I'm sorry. It's very true. But you just
have to establish the legal predicate and argument, and you have to be relentless about returning over
and over and over again. And if it doesn't work here, find another jurisdiction. In the federal
level or on the state level, you just have to keep on doing it, and then you achieve success,
and then you build upon that. And when you flip, you achieve success in one court, it unlocks the
doors in a number of other jurisdictions. So you have to establish that argument, you have to be
persistent, and you just have to not take no for an answer. And you just have to return over and
over again. So you actually did touch upon one critical issue. It's about people's
strong will on this kind of issue, right? You need to have this strong will because
under current climate, political climate, I remember I saw the news, even the two lawyers,
President Trump chose to defend him on his second impeachment trial next week.
Both of them were threatened, and their legal license or maybe revoke, or even their law degree
may be rescinded by their home universities, law schools. And so a lot of the lawyers,
they were afraid to get involved in this kind of lawfare that you mentioned. So is that the reason
you're suggesting even people not lawyers can get involved into this lawfare?
Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I mean, there are certain points in time where you do need a
professional lawyer to come in. But we need to do that. And that is just incredible intimidation.
And that's something that we're facing is this sudden, and Time Magazine just had a report about
it, we're beginning to see the giddy, gleeful release of some of the members of this broad
coalition that conspired to throw this election. And they've been very good at intimidating and
silencing others. But they're kind of piping up now slapping themselves on the back. That in itself
gives opportunities. Well, really? You really were? I mean, if some of those things in that
Time Magazine article are true, I think some of these folks might want a lawyer up. Because
they're saying things that potential RICO violations, potential antitrust,
potential violation of the Civil Rights Act. Now, Civil Rights Act at the federal level
does not protect political viewpoints. However, at the state level, at a number of states,
actually, political viewpoints and political speech actually are protected classes. So you
can achieve some wins in different states. California, of all places, California protects
political speech. So that would be very interesting to see some state cases be brought up
in California. And some think it's how it's lost in California because of the vast
exodus of population, because of a number of things. Actually, you saw the return of a number
of Republicans. And again, I'm just doing this as a political observer, informed observer,
not as an advocate for one party or another. But you saw a return of a number of Republicans to
seats in California. So it is not over. And if you want to look at this as a defeat,
I'm not sure I'm looking at this defeat. This was a massive coordinated effort,
which I think actually opens the door to opportunities to really, okay, really,
you guys want to pat yourself on the back about a coordinated effort?
Guess what? That begins to smell of RICO. That begins to smell of antitrust.
I want to rethink making some of these comments in public.
Since you mentioned about RICO, can you elaborate a little bit more on that part? Because I think
a lot of times people, when they think about RICO, they think about organized crime here,
right? And so how does this law will be applied to these kinds of situations?
Yeah, I think the wording on RICO, it's not necessarily organized crime,
it's ongoing criminal activity. That doesn't mean you have to be organized crime. Now,
RICO has been used against other organizations. It was used to some level against those in the
pro-life community. So if you establish that a member of such a group committed a criminal act,
that begins to open the door to the application of RICO. That does not necessarily mean
kind of your Hollywood characterization of what organized crime is or isn't.
So yeah, absolutely, RICO can be applied if you could establish a criminal act took place
and criminal activity is taking place. It doesn't mean it's, again, kind of stereotypical
organized crime. I see. And so at the same time,
I think there's another big question is whether you can find a good judge, a jurisdiction
that can really deal with these cases in a fair way. Because we see so many cases,
maybe in the Ninth Circuit or other places may not be truly be impartial in this kind of
situation. So what's your suggestion on this kind of situation? People should just try in different
jurisdictions? Well, yeah, you have to begin to establish a list of different listings of
different court jurisdictions that may be sympathetic to your argument. Again,
law in some ways is more of an art form. And a lot of these judges and court systems,
they'll be very open-minded if you work on your argument and return. A lot of times they're kind
of given their findings and their statements and their opinions. They're in some ways kind of,
sometimes the term is foot-stomping or hinting to you what you need to do to get your argument
straight and return. So pay attention. Just because you're rejected doesn't mean that's it.
It's over. It means they're actually kind of giving you a hint on how you need to approve
your argument and try it again. That's a good point. And so besides this aspect,
to have an alternative choice on this digital platform, so another very, very important factor
is on the financial aspect, right? Because you can see these big tech giants have so much funding
supporting them. And during their growth, they also acquire more funding in this process. And so
for the alternative choice to grow even faster, they need to secure more funding as well. So
how about the financial sectors? How can they get more support from the financial industries?
Yeah. I mean, access to capital is the lifeblood of a capitalist economy. And so it's critical.
Now, we've seen financial organizations, banks, lenders, hedge funds over the years,
essentially start to develop essentially political positions. And I don't know. I think
from a business model, that starts to get very dicey because you start to be exclusive. If you're
going to be exclusive, if you're going to make statements, that means you are excluding a portion
of your market base. So I don't think that's really a good idea, but companies have done it.
Now, and there's also the factor of some of these activist groups. I'll point historically to
Jesse Jackson's Rainbow Coalition during the 70s and 80s that really, and there was a book on him
called Shakedown. And it really reflected how effectively activist groups can work these
essentially intimidation, coercion, and then coercion. There you go. That's a word that
starts to have some applicability to RICO and antitrust issues and things like that. So some
of these groups are potentially running afoul of some of these laws, but they've learned how to do
this. And one of the things they've really started to target is the financial organizations.
It's a really bad idea. And I will, because it was out in the news, Bank of America,
sharing lists with the FBI. Yeah, that's very disconcerting on several fronts. I'd like to see
the American people own this government. You cannot slap classified on everything. I spent
35 plus years living in that world. We cannot use classification to keep information from the
American people. And we need to know the reason behind this sharing of information. Very disconcerting.
Yeah. Since you mentioned the case, can you explain even why FBI made this kind of request
to Bank of America? And should Bank of America willingly collaborate or even offering these
data? It's unclear. Don't have enough information at this point in time to understand. I mean,
it's unclear that the FBI actually even made a request. It's possible Bank of America volunteered,
which is even worse. So what's going on here? And so these financial institutions, this is really
the lifeblood. And these activists have really learned how to reach out to these financial
institutions and intimidate. So we have to start setting up our own financial systems.
Well, that's an interesting concept. So maybe even in the future, there will be
another stock exchange market only for the alternatives?
You know, I don't like these apartheid type systems and attitudes. I think that's wrong.
That's not America. So I don't like it. We didn't cause this. We didn't start this being foisted
upon most of America. And remember, most of America is still the majority. So all these
institutions, they are not the majority of America. Even all of these activist groups,
they do not represent a majority of the American people. But I don't think it's right. We didn't
start this, but it is being foisted upon us. And perhaps for the short term, we do need to
set up alternatives, market alternatives. This is a market-based system. Let's set up, okay,
that they want to play these games of exclusion. Fine. Let's set up market alternatives and let's
consumer vote. I don't think it's going to end up well for those who want to play the apartheid
game. I think you're going to see in the end, the dollars will flow to the correct and right side
on these topics. But again, even in the financial sector, there is massive and quick evolution of
the environment. So certain institutions want to behave like this. Believe me, there will be
market opportunity for others. So it can happen. It can happen. Bank of America, my grandfather
worked for Bank of America in many ways, the golden age of Los Angeles in the 30s before the
Second World War. Bank of America was a big deal. Working in a bank was a big deal. And it was
amazing. And the history of Bank of America is essentially, it was created by an immigrant to
make sure immigrants had access to capital. And because in some ways they felt like they were
being excluded. And here they are, a hundred years later, excluding. Not a good thing.
Yeah, this reminds me about the social credit system that the Chinese communist regime setting
up, right? Because if you did not tow the party line, they can give you a bad credit and you may
not even get along. You may not be able to assess the capital. It definitely reminds me about the
communist regime. I was so surprised, actually, that the pace towards socialism is so fast
in the United States. Yeah. Well, this is interesting. I'm an optimist on this. I didn't
like the way certain things turned out recently, but I'm an optimist in the end on this.
I think a totalitarian system, communist China, totalitarians usually overplay their hand.
Usually they do themselves in, in many ways. And it's funny because communist China likes
to pretend it's a capitalist system. I think this is an extremely important point. Communist China
is not a capitalist system. They are crony capitalists, okay? That means the government
decides who wins or who loses. That is not capitalism. That will ultimately always fail.
And it's funny how characters such as Jack Ma, who until recently was such a towering personality,
who knows where he is now. He made his decision on which side he was going to align with. It
doesn't look like it turned out well for him. Yeah. Eventually he had to take the consequence
when he chose the side, right? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's a Kai-Fu Lee, another personality.
Microsoft. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. He's made a decision on which side he's going to be on.
Guess what? That has a price. Eventually you'll get cross-threaded with the communist system.
I guarantee it. And when you get cross-threaded in those environments, you just kind of go away.
And who knows where Jack Ma is right now. Yes. Since you mentioned about the communist
regime's current situation, I want to ask you one question I didn't plan before,
because recently there's a lot of discussion about whether the Chinese communist regime will
take military actions against Taiwan. Since you are the national security expert,
I want you to share a few words regarding your analysis on these issues.
Well, I mean, the Secretary of State nominee Blinken has actually been quite clear in many
ways. And I believe it was just this morning made a statement on holding China accountable
for stability in the region. So there's been a number of reasonably positive comments
coming out of some. The challenge is, I'm just, they're still not there yet
on their capabilities, on their mass of force, on their operational art. I think it would be
a bloody mess. And I don't think that would turn out well for anybody, especially the chairman
of the Chinese communist party. It will not be a cakewalk, even if they are ultimately successful.
But I just, I don't see it yet. But we should continue to be clear and unambiguous.
There are partners in the region that together, we, along with the American forces in the Pacific,
and we can shift more forces over there relatively fast, that we actually numerically,
quantitatively, qualitatively, I think that would be a very unwise decision for the chairman
of the Chinese communist party. And again, he has to be looking over his shoulder, because
when you're in those kinds of totalitarian positions, you always have to be looking over
your shoulder at your inner circle, because they're the ones you have to be most concerned with.
Well, thank you for your analysis on this issue. I think probably even the top leaders in the
communist regime, or the People's Liberation Army, they know their own true capabilities.
Just a lot of time, they have to show their muscles in order to gain some additional
bargain chips when they deal with the United States. And so hopefully this is the same
situation. I definitely hope there is no war, no military conflict in the Pacific regions.
Go ahead.
I hope so also. I think it'd be very unwise. I don't think anything good would come out of this.
And so I think it would be much better for calm and reasoned minds to address this matter.
Okay, so back to the digital appetite issues. And I think another issue I want to bring up
is regarding about the cyber warfares, the United States being constantly defending
ourselves against the communist party's cyber militaries. So on this aspect,
how should the United States have to have better preparation? Because
there's so much evidence that the Chinese government's military has been doing this
consistently. Even new evidence, the military's cyber warfare unit may be even involved in
hacking the U.S. election systems too. And so how can the U.S. defend ourselves better in these
digital realms? Well, I believe it's Michael Solmire. Dr. Michael Solmire is going to assume
or has already assumed a position essentially as the cyber czar at the White House.
So I had a chance to work with him some earlier when he was in DOD. I think he's
very solid and high quality. And I think he'll be very good at coming up with
the right policies, the right to address some of these matters. One thing during the final year
of the Obama administration, there was a great level of frustration with China. The OPM breach,
the Office of Personnel Management breach was catastrophic. It was bad. And it really,
in many ways, the challenge is a number of the officials, they wanted to kind of stay
at the level of the abstract and address a number of these issues in kind of theoretical policy
language that did not really have actionable outcomes, actionable ways ahead. That in many
ways communicates lack of resolve, lack of interest. So I think very important,
the public communication is extremely important on these topics. It has to be clear. It has to
be unambiguous. If we're lecturing other countries, no matter who they are, that is
a challenge. And that is not the best way to deal, especially when you're dealing with a
totalitarian system. Lecturing in the abstract is counterproductive and is a green light to
totalitarian systems to essentially do what they want to do, because it shows just a lack of resolve.
So now there was one activity that had some levels of effectiveness and was not
unwise or unreasonable, but that was the public indictments of a number of Chinese officials.
But it seems like this kind of punishment is so minimal, so trivial. I mean,
it didn't really hurt the Chinese PLA's cyber warfare units.
Well, yes, yes. And without demonstrative follow through. So if a communist Chinese
official is named, that's kind of put the skin at concern. What happens if I travel outside of
China? So even if I go to a conference in Europe, does that mean I have to worry about the FBI
arresting me? And I apologize, I don't believe we actually ever did that, but it does put a
marker down. So it does have some effect, but we need more than that. And there was always this
essentially ideology that it was like, if you fight these cyber intrusions, you create more of
them. Kind of like sometimes the analog is toward the war against extremists. If you fight extremism,
you create extremism. But at the same time, I mean, the rationale is also kind of a loophole
in it, right? You cannot just sit there waiting the extremists to go even to the next scale,
right? So if you don't take a proactive action, if you don't take the offensive actions,
you just will be bombarded by all these kind of cyber attacks all the time.
Well, again, there was great frustration in the final year of the Obama administration
against the Chinese, because they just were not doing... And the simple summary was,
we had done everything to be nice to them, and they weren't being nice to us. And it's like,
I'm sorry, you're dealing with a totalitarian system. You have to invert your psychology on
this. They only understand... They were nice to the wrong people.
Absolutely. Absolutely. I'm sorry. These are totalitarians. They only understand one thing,
and that is winning over us. So get past this abstract. Get past lecturing. Aggressive
speech-making and lecturing, again, only encourages. So there has to be demonstrable
effect. It could be financial. It could be economic. It could be any kind of others,
a number of others. There's a whole menu of opportunities here. But the major thing was
the indictment of the officials, and that was it. I don't believe there was actually ever any
arrests, extraditions, etc., etc. So that's one thing. We need a lot more than that. And so I am
hoping that there is a more informed, a more assertive... And again, it cannot be lecturing
in the abstract. We have to get past that. So it has to be clear effect. It has to inflict pain
on the communist Chinese, or they're not going to pay attention.
You just need to be very, very clear who you're dealing with. You are not dealing with any
regular or normal government agency. You're dealing with the communist regime. It's a totally
different situation. So just like in the war, you need to know your enemy first.
Otherwise, you always use the wrong strategy or tactics.
Absolutely. Their goal is simple. They want to win. They want us to lose. It's no more complicated
than that. So you don't have to wrap yourself in circles, analyzing the situation. We know them.
We know who they are. We know what they want. You have to treat them as such. It is unambiguous
what their goals are. And I believe Blinken had mentioned, and others, like addressing the
Uyghurs. I think there's the Falun Gong, others that we need to be making vocal, clear, unambiguous
statements about. We cannot have genocide against them also. And we need to hold China accountable.
Communist China has to be held accountable. We cannot lecture countries on human rights,
and then ignore essentially the largest on-scale genocide that is going on in the world. And that's
essentially in communist China against a number of groups. We have to address that.
We need to take action. Just talking tough is not enough. So I definitely hope the new
administration can understand this and take action. Well, Colonel Mill, thank you so much for
joining me on this program and share so much insight from your decades of experience.
Thank you so much. Thank you, Dr. Lin. It's always a pleasure to be with you.
All right. We invite you again in the near future. Stay in touch. Thank you very much.
All right. So this is today's program. We cover several aspects. We talk about digital advertise.
We talk about the Bank of America collaborating with FBI. We talk about the communist regime's
nonstop cyber attack on the United States, and talk about the genocides happening in China.
We're just in such a difficult time. So many things happen around us. They are not happening
in the direction that we want. And so what can we do? How can we have a very clear mind? How do
we choose the right side? Do we want to be like Jack Ma, you know, maybe repenting on his decision
right now? And so I hope everyone make the right choice and important historical moment. All right.
Thank you for watching today's program. This is Shan Lin. We'll see you next time.