World Health Organization (WHO) just sent an expert team to China to investigate the origin of COVID-19 outbreak in China. Will it be an independent investigation? Will they be able to access previous research documents that were not allowed to be published? Who will write the report when the investigation is done? Should they go to the current outbreak hotspots like Hebei Province?
Will WHO Team Find Out the Origin of COVID-19 in China? | Global Watch | Dr. Sean Lin
Hello everyone, welcome to Global Health Watch. I'm Dr. Sean Lin. Because this is a new channel
and I also speak Mandarin, so I'm actually producing two versions of the program. One in
English, one in Chinese. So if you are my subscriber, if you receive the Chinese programs,
don't be surprised. And so I also put these programs in two separate playlists. And so if
you want to look back for my previous program, you can check a different playlist. So today's
program is about WHO, World Health Organization, sending a team, a so-called independent team,
to China to investigate the origin of the COVID-19. So this was a team that was supposed to
go to China last year because in last May, under the pressure of 110 countries
leaded by Australian government, the WHO agreed to have an independent investigation
about the origin of virus and into China. But Chinese government keep delaying in a negotiation,
in authorization of these teams. So finally, January 2021, there's a team going to China and
they landed in China on January 14th, Thursday. So the members of the team will first be quarantined
in China for two weeks and then they will conduct their own investigation in Wuhan.
So people questioned, what kind of result that this team can get? Will their investigation be
genuinely independent? So bottom line up front, I will tell you, my observation, my concern is that
this is more like a political show than an independent investigation. Why? So first, the timing, right?
This team supposed to be in China early last year or even the latest in last summer, but now
this is January 2021, they are too late. Right now, if there's an independent investigation team in
China, they should go to Hubei province, they should go to Liaoning province, where the
Chinese government has locked down more than 10 million people in these provinces, in these cities.
And the outbreak in those regions are very, very severe. And the government has initiated screening,
nuclear test screening for all members in those cities, in this province. It's a large-scale
screening. And you can see many of the photos, videos from China, people, you know, line up,
crowded in those testing sites or in the travel, like, gate. And it's chaotic situation, and many
people were even forced to lock down in the driver's cabinet, in the trucks. And it was
chaotic situations, and many of the communities have to be gated, and even people only allowed it
to shop for their daily needs once in a week. So it's a very, very devastating situation in many
cities in China right now. So if you have a team from WHO experts, including virologists,
epidemiologists, right now you should go to these cities, not Wuhan. You know, Wuhan is no longer
the hotspot, it's no longer the ground zero. And you should go there to investigate whether the
Chinese government have sufficient resource and efficient measures to contain the outbreak in
those cities, right, in Hubei province. Not in Hubei province, but in Hebei province now.
So the timing is definitely wrong, and their mission is questionable right now. And also,
will this team be able to conduct genuine independent investigation? This is fundamental,
because Chinese government has been controlling the propaganda, controlling their messages in
terms of where the origin is. We can clearly remember, right, last year, at the beginning,
they blamed the Huanan seafood market was the original outbreak spot in Wuhan city. And then
later on, they changed their story, they're blaming other countries, bringing the virus into China.
So right now, will they allow these team members to truly conduct independent investigation? I
question about that. And later, I will talk about the independent, you can say clandestine
investigation conducted by AP. I'll talk more about that later. But another major question
about these WHO team is, who gonna write the report? We probably remember, there was a team
from WHO went to China in last February. This team only have one day in Wuhan.
But they have a full report. And by the report was composed half by the Chinese scientists or
Chinese officials. And then some of the report was written by the experts from outside China.
So it was a joint report. And you can even find clearly, you know, Chinese official languages
in that scientific report. So kind of like a very, very funny, you know, propaganda tool,
you can find it saying, under the Chinese Central Committee's leadership, we have
fined these disease. It was so interesting to read that. But let's just tell you, that report
is not independent. It was, you can say, it's prepared, it's cooked together by the Chinese
government. So right now, you have a new team going to China. Will Chinese government allow
you to publish anything that's contradictory to the government's official tone? Who will control
the publication? Who will censor some information in your report, right? So this is a big question.
That's why I feel right now, when you have a team going to China to do this investigation,
it's more like a political show. It's not a genuine independent investigation.
And also right now, more importantly, whether the virus originated from Wuhan or not,
is not that critical anymore. Because under Xi Jinping's leadership, Chinese government have
pushed every province in China to establish, to build up new P3 lab or even P4 lab in certain
locations. The Chinese government is making a great leap forward movement regarding building
the P3 or P4 lab. And you probably remember last year, the Department of State has informed the
public that they want to send the team, an expert team, to Wuhan Institute of Virology on 2018.
And the report came back regarding about the safety and security procedures in Wuhan Institute
of Virology was very worrisome because they see even the top research institute in Wuhan did not
follow very well in terms of lab safety, lab secure protocols. So how can you expect the newly
established, newly built lab in different provincial level can truly follow safety procedures?
China may not have enough time to train enough lab safety personnel to manage these P3, P4 labs,
right? So it's like China is building more Pandora box and you are facing more virus leak from the
lab. So that's an even bigger problem. And many of these province from their hospital, they can
easily collect COVID infected patient samples. They can grow up the virus easily in this kind of lab.
But who will control the safety of the lab? This is a big issue. That's why I call it, it's like
building more Pandora box in China. So if you have a team from WHO, you need to investigate
these problems, right? You need to find out whether China can enforce very strict rules in these kind
of P3, P4 lab. And you have to see whether they have enough personnel that can do it.
So, but right now this team is going to China, say we're going to investigate the origin of the
virus. So one of the experts from this WHO team is named Dominic Doyle. He's a virologist from
Sydney, Australia. And he clearly told Australian broadcast company, Australia's ABC, he told them
their mission is not to find out who's the patient zero. And they only expect to find out
whether this outbreak was amplified in Wuhan, whether the outbreak may have started from
somewhere else in China. And they want to find out whether there will be an intermediary animal
host. And also they want to find out what's the role of laboratories in all of this. So you can
see these experts, they know it's very hard to find out who the patient zero is. So this is actually
clearly telling the Chinese hospitals in Wuhan may not collaborate with these WHO team in a
full collaboration pattern, right? Because we, from Chinese internal document, we know the Chinese
government, Chinese National Health Commission, as well as Hubei Province
Health Commission has already ordered all the hospitals in Wuhan to track back patient records
all the way back to September 2019 to see if any of the patients showing symptoms similar to COVID-19.
So this is government secret operation that has already conducted last year. And now they want
releasing information to the WHO team members. So of course these experts from WHO, they know
they cannot find this kind of information. They don't expect to find who will be the patient zero
in 2019. So what they can do, right, maybe simply just collect some animal samples and try to find
some animal being infected by the COVID-19 and having additional animal to be suspected as a
intermediate reservoirs. Because Chinese government has already pushed out different
series, right, the bats or maybe the penguins last year, even though there were publications in China.
But later on, many people questioned about the studies regarding penguins could be a potential
animal reservoirs for COVID-19. So right now, it's really, really too late for the
international society to try to find out what will be the animal reservoir for COVID-19. Because
if Wuhan is the outbreak, because if Wuhan was the outbreak center in 2019 and early 2020,
the Chinese government has already collected enough animal samples. Because there were so many
top virologists, epidemiologists in Wuhan, they definitely know they need to collect animal
samples. They already test different animal samples, but they probably just cannot tell the
public regarding what they found in animal samples. One report I did see is from Dr. Shi Zhenli
from Wuhan Institute of Virology. Her team collected samples from cats, whether it's
wild cat or domestic cats. She collected cat samples and clearly her results showing that
cats can be infected with SARS-CoV-2. So that report did not make clear conclusion whether
people can transmit the virus to the cat or whether the infected cat can transmit the virus
to human beings. But it's clear the cats can carry the virus. So right now for international
experts going to Wuhan, what kind of animal sample you can collect additionally? The Huanan
seafood market is probably no longer there. And what can you do? Collecting more samples from
other animal market in Wuhan. So I really doubt that any concrete result can be made from this
WHO team. And also another big question, if you want to understand animal reservoir, if you want
to understand animal origins, you definitely need a research team to follow your investigation.
So even if you collect samples in China, who's going to conduct the experiment? Will you bring
the samples out of China to do independent research, to do sequencing? Or will you rely
on Chinese scientists to conduct this research? This is another question. So anyway, I'm not
optimistic at all in terms of the results coming from a WHO investigation team because
I'm questioning whether they are independent or not.
So also another reason that I really doubt the effectiveness of this WHO team is because I read
a recent report. It was about a clandestine investigation conducted by Associated Press.
And this report was published last year, December 30, 2020. And from that report, we can clearly see
even for Associated Press, a major news agency with many resources,
they cannot conduct very effective investigation, even clandestine investigation in China.
They went to Wuhan. They were managed to interview one of the vendors, owners,
originally working in the Huanan seafood market. And that gentleman told the investigators how he
originally identified some people who got sick. And some of his friends even died because of COVID-19.
But how did it start? That person has no idea. And the investigation team also went into Yunnan
province, that's on the southwest of China, where there were a lot of caves
harboring bats, potential animal reservoirs for SARS-CoV-2. But the local authorities,
the county authorities, the police were ahead of these investigation teams.
They were quickly blocking the reporters to assess the caves or the mine shafts.
One of the reports from Dr. Shi Zhenli from Wuhan Institute of Virology, clearly indicating
that one virus strain named RATG13 was collected from a mine shaft in Yunnan province in 2012.
So people questioned about the validity of that particular virus strain, the RATG13. But even if
it's true, the investigation team from Associated Press cannot assess the cave, cannot assess the
mine shaft because local authorities blocked it. So China is already in a surveillance state
situation. There are so many cameras everywhere, they can easily track where you go.
As a foreigner, even if you conduct clandestine operations, the communist regime is very easy to
pinpoint where you're located, what you want to do. So they can effectively block
this kind of clandestine investigation. So for an investigation by the WHO team and need approval
from the Chinese government, what kind of freedom you might have in China? Can you really conduct
independent investigation? I fully doubt it. Anyway, I just want to share with you my observation
regarding WHO's team, which is going to China to conduct an investigation regarding the origin of
the virus. Originally, I thought this is purely a political show and nobody is interested. But
yesterday, I was invited to join John Bechler's show together with Gordon Chong, and we were
discussing about this issue. So I feel there's a point I need to share with everyone in terms of
how the Chinese government is covering up the situation. Also, the Chinese government has been
implementing very strict rules, strict policies in terms of scientific publications
regarding the virus origin. The Associated Press investigation also were able to
collect some of the internal documents from Chinese state councils or from national health
commissions. And those secret documents clearly indicating the control was implemented all the
way from the top, from Xi Jinping, and then come down to provincial level, to city levels.
And they ordered all the scientific research, all the hospitals. If you have any publications,
you need government agencies' approval, not just a scientific approval process. You have to get
government propaganda bureaus' approval. Anything, any results that's contradictory
to the government's terms will be censored. And the government can find the scientists who want
to back up the government's official term to have publications, for example, showing maybe
they can identify COVID-19 on the outside of frozen food packages. And those packages were
imported from other countries. So if the government won these kind of propaganda schemes,
they will be able to identify scientists to publish this kind of data. So that's how it
works in China. So the Associated Press investigation report clearly gives you this
kind of picture. And it actually reminds me, you know, I cannot just look at a scientific report
from China. I need to think about what the government's propaganda at that time,
where the report actually basically wants to support the government's term.
In China, everything is political. Everybody needs to keep this in mind. It's not purely
scientific research in China. So anyway, that's all I want to share today. So basically,
my conclusion is I don't trust the results coming from the WHO's investigation team. What they can
find is very limited, maybe very biased, maybe only show you a little bit of the results,
but it won't give you the full picture about what really went wrong in Wuhan in 2019. I
don't think they will find anything very valuable. And it's around timing. And
what we should focus on is what went wrong in Hebei province, in Liaoning province,
what kind of mutants is circulating in China. The Chinese government is not releasing this
kind of critical information. And these are very, very important. And not only important
for the American people, for the world, and for Chinese people, they also deserve to know
the true situation in China. If the government locked down the city or even the province,
doing nuclear screening for everyone in the city, in the province, that suggests the situation is
much worse than what was reported on the local health commissions or national health commissions.
So be alert. The very dangerous mutants has been popping up in many countries right now. We know
in South Africa, in Japan, Brazil, in Nigeria, in Russia, very dangerous immune escape mutant
has been identified. And China, they also have one case in Guangdong being reported. But
the full sequence, the full mutation profile was not reported. So we definitely need China to
be more transparent in terms of the new mutants that emerge in China, or even already become
dominant in some of the northern province in China. I think Chinese people deserve it,
and the world need to know it more. All right, that's my conclusion. And thank you for watching
today's Global Health Watch. This is Dr. Sean Lin. If you like my program, please help
share it out, and please subscribe, and hope more people can benefit from my program.
Thank you very much for watching. This is Sean Lin. We'll see you next time.