Why Medieval Knights OFTEN Did Not Bother with FACE PROTECTION
▼3 extra EXCLUSIVE videos each month on PATREON, which make this channel possible:
https://www.patreon.com/scholagladiatoria
▼Facebook & Twitter updates, info, memes and fun:
https://www.facebook.com/historicalfencing/
https://twitter.com/scholagladiato1
▼Schola Gladiatoria HEMA - sword fighting classes in the UK:
https://www.swordfightinglondon.com
▼Matt Easton's website & Pinterest:
https://www.matt-easton.co.uk/
https://www.pinterest.co.uk/matt_easton/_saved/
▼Easton Antique Arms - antique swords for sale:
https://www.antique-swords.co.uk
#medieval #helmet #knight
let's talk about openface helmets in the
late medieval
period hi folks mat here scholar
gladiatoria now many of you will have
watched my videos in the past on Armor
where I've talked about some of the
virtues of more convenient types of
helmet and it should be obvious to
anyone if you've watched my recent great
bassinet video that the great bassinet
whiler is absolutely optimal in terms of
protection so cly for fighting on foot
and if you were jousting something like
a frogged mouth Helm would be the
ultimate level for that neither of those
are very convenient helmets to be
wearing in a day-to-day kind of on
campaign
basis they need to be secured to the
Cass um so you need someone to help you
do that you can't get them off very
easily by yourself I won't say you can't
do it but it's not very convenient by
yourself especially ones which is
strapped at the back you literally can't
do that yourself but moreover even just
you know Bend down to pick things up or
eating or drinking um various types of
you know various types of everyday
activity on campaign they would not be
convenient to wear whereas very
obviously a helmet like this uh which
we'll talk about what it is in a second
um is really really convenient in fact
functionally this is really not very
different to a modern helmet that you'd
find a modern Soldier wearing obviously
it's made of steel rather than Kevlar or
anything else but fundamentally it
leaves the same amount of the face open
and lots of people go oh well you know
isn't your face really really vulnerable
well you could say that with modern
helmets as well but people don't wear
full face protection in the modern world
for a whole bunch of reasons one of
those being that you have to operate a
rifle and if you've got full facial
protection not very compatible it can be
done with different types of sites and
and goggles and other types of things
that's something probably for another
Channel let alone another video but the
fact is that open face helmets are the
most practical compromised design for
head Protection Plus being able to do
your job now I think most people will
realize that people like crossbowmen or
Gunners or archers very often need
openface helmets but what about Knights
well often they do as well and in fact
it's incredibly common in the uh 15th
and 16th centuries to find an armor
equipped with a selection of different
helmets so just because you have full
plate harness on your body doesn't mean
you're always going to wear your most
protective helmet your close helmet your
armut or your great bassinet or your
jousting Helm with that armor in all
situations if you're just on General
campaign often a salot and this is this
doesn't have a Visa again we'll come
back to that in a second um a visor
salad or an unored salad or a chapel
defer is going to be more practical so
those are all kind of obvious things
right very briefly what is this helmet
and why does it look like this so this
is a type of open faed salad um that was
popular in England burgundy Flanders and
France as well relatively now a lot of
people would describe this as an English
salad and in in a sense they're correct
because this is actually made by Ash
armor Services historical um based on a
number of English effes there's about
six that fall into this group um and
they were also shown in Contemporary Art
French Burgundian Flemish art as well so
we know that these weren't only worn in
England but probably some of them were
made in England by English armorers and
were worn with English armors but
equally there's a lot of um commonality
should we say between armors found in
France and the low countries and
burgundy which owned some of the low
countries at that time and England and
of course remember the historical
context so obviously up until 1454 the
English were in France they owned big
chunks of France and were also allies of
the burgundians those burundians who
caught Jon of AR and gave her to the
English um those burundians that when um
Edward IV Was Defeated and ran away with
the Duke of gluster and his and his
buddies they ran away to his sister who
was married to the Duke of burgundy
gathered an army and then came back and
fought at the battles of Barnett and
tuxbury in the wars of the Roses so the
burgundians in the English were
inextricably closely linked right that I
could do a whole probably hourong video
by itself but that's just a brief
tangent so this is a type of open
openface salad you find in England
France burgundy so on so forth and it
would be completely normal for someone
on campaign a knight a lord even a king
to have a helmet like this that they
would wear some of the time instead of
their armor their great Basset or
whatever their heavy helmet was so
having a heavy helmet and a light helmet
sometimes maybe even having a spectrum
of helmets a super light helmet um and a
sort of medium level helmet maybe a
salad without a bever or salot in a
bever and then a heavy helmet for
mounted work you might even have
different helmets for foot and mounted
so you might wear an armet on Horseback
and you might wear a great bassinet on
foot so a bunch of different helmets and
that's what I'm going for essentially so
this is my campaign helmet made by Ash
polished up by me it was originally in
sattin finish and I have um mirror
polished this to match my new armor
which as aforementioned will become
unveiled soon right so let's just shed
this for a second and talk about the
issue of open face versus closed face
and actually a sense of perspective so
people always say Matt isn't your face
massively exposed with an open face yes
that's the compromise you're making
however remember that a very big
percentage of the soldiers on the
battlefield also have open faces okay so
that's the first thing is that modern
soldiers have open faces World War I
soldiers had open faces most other
periods of soldiers have open fa Roman
soldiers mostly had open face helmets
but even in the medieval context most
soldiers be they Billman archers
crossbowman Gunners whatever on the
medieval Battlefield have to some degree
an open face secondly this can be worn
with a bever so that you can close up uh
half of the face with this and just
leave a section open in the middle okay
so that's the second thing to mention
but here's the point I really wanted to
make and I don't think I've ever really
put this in a video before let's take
the visor from my great bassinet so
there's the detached visor it attaches
by pins on the sides you can put
different types of visors on we're going
to see a different visor in a second um
and this seems like a closed face visor
however it does have openings and that's
really important because you need
openings to see and to breathe now while
these openings might be minimized and
kept relatively small so we've got lots
of small circular
holes difficult for things to get into
those although not impossible and then
you've got these slits here it is
absolutely not impossible for weapons to
come into those so if you're being shot
with arrows the fact is that if an arrow
manages to find one of those um
breathing holes or Vision holes they're
actually both there is a chance that it
can penetrate through the visor here and
we find this mentioned in FASA the
French Knights at puer feared the storm
of English arrows hitting them
particular from the flanks they feared
that they would penetrate their visors
specifically visors not the rest of
their body visors so even a closed visor
can be penetrated by weapons and I think
people often forget this because they
look at things like bowart videos where
thrusting is not allowed and obviously
there's no arrows um or they look at
reenactment where for the most part
thrusting at faces is not allowed and in
anyway the weapons are all blunt and
those big blunt ended weapons for the
most part won't go and go through the
gaps here anyway but if you're talking
about sharp weapons arrows daggers
Spears swords they can go through these
gaps now for illustration I have a Todd
Cutler dagger here this is a rondle
dagger this is modeled on Fred Frederick
the victorious' great Basset so it's
historically accurate the slits are the
right size and everything else I could
grab one of my salats and do a similar
thing to this I can't see where they are
right now um but here we go
nasty so if you get into close combat
with someone two things to bear in mind
first of all if you're really up close
and personal there's always going to be
gaps there's their groin there's the
inside of their armpits and elbows back
of the legs uh back of the neck behind
the helmet inside the gauntlets both the
palm and inside the cuff and these holes
can be compromised even really narrow
slits on salet and armets are enough to
let a blade through if you get close
enough to stick it in there so not only
can you deliberately stick a blade
through the gap of a visor you can also
find other gaps to stab anyway or
potentially you can open the visor or
pull a piece of plate off and stab into
there we see this in Palace uh Palace
Cal's um treaties um where a pauldron is
cut off and stabbed into um but
additionally just accidentally so if
thrusts are constantly coming in from
Spears arrows all sorts of other things
there is a chance they will penetrate
this anyway so
in a nutshell even if you have facial
protection yes it increases your odds of
not getting stabbed or shot in the face
but it is never an absolute protection
now I'm just going to briefly we'll talk
about this more in a future video I know
I say that's a lot on this channel but
here is a different type of visor and
clearly that's got big old holes in it
now this is called in German a CN turnia
Helm but we will call it a tournament
visor
and you see these in Rene Don's
manuscript and this is the alternate
visor for my great bassinet and you'll
notice yes it's gilded which gives you
some clues about the rest of my armor um
so this is an alternate visor visor for
um tournament use and I can also use it
for hea use so long as the weapons don't
have pointy ends on them which for hea
they don't usually so this is very
useful for fighting with wooden clubs or
blunt swords which have wide ends and
can't go through those holes and it
brilliant for seeing brilliant for
breathing it's similar to a fencing mask
in principle but much much stronger bars
and bigger holes um so you couldn't use
this for rapia because they go straight
through and sub you in the face now
clearly these aren't great for war
because you'd be shot through them but
here's the thing you do see these in
manuscripts warn in war so sometimes
some people somewhere because of the
added breathability and vision of this
would have chosen to wear the tournament
visor instead of the so-called War visor
because yes indeed arrows can come
through and swords and other things and
obviously something like a dagger so at
the end of the day it's all about
context and compromise because you can
never have all things for all people at
all times at once you've got to make
your choices what is the specific um
tactical and strategic scenario uh what
is required of my armor what am I going
to wear clearly this is the best option
for a uh club or blunt sword tournament
as seen in Rene DJ's tournament book um
and clearly on the battlefield usually
if not always usually this is the best
choice but don't think for a second that
just because you have a visor it will
always protect you against all things it
won't the French Knights at patier were
scared of it and we know that people did
get wounded and sometimes killed through
visors moreover just have a look at
Medieval art the number of medieval
illustrations there are where the helmet
be it a a um a salot or an armet or even
a great bassinet has a visor but in the
art the people are fighting with their
visors just pull this up up like that
okay so if the people are fighting with
their visors up like that well at this
point they've essentially got an open
face so yes they might have advanced
into the arrows into the so-called Arrow
storm or they might have charged in on
Horseback with their Lance with their
visor down but as soon as they get into
melee the ability to see and breathe
more more important so
absolutely obviously when you're wearing
helmets like this number one yes your
face is more exposed but you gain a lot
from that secondly most soldiers on the
medieval Battlefield had open faces
thirdly just because you have access to
full plate and visors and heavier
helmets you very often would choose this
type of helmet for standard campaigning
and sometimes deliberately for for close
combat and we know that English knights
in the of the Roses very often fought
with open faces remember Henry the at
the Battle of shobby back in 1403 I
think it was shot in the face with an
arrow Oho he had an open face or his
visor up thanks a lot for watching I
hope this has been interesting and
thought-provoking if you've got any
specific questions on this topic which
might spur me into making future videos
in a related thing maybe something I've
never covered in a video before then by
all means get posting down below thanks
a lot for watching I have been mat e and
I will continue to be and I hope I'll
see you back on the channel really soon
cheers folks thanks for watching we've
got extra videos on patreon please give
our Facebook a like And subscribe if you
haven't already cheers folks

