NOT THUMB RINGS! Renaissance Daggers with @tods_workshop
Please stop calling these side rings "thumb rings". They are not. Tod's video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ukeUbtGWEg
▼3 extra EXCLUSIVE videos each month on PATREON, which make this channel possible:
https://www.patreon.com/scholagladiatoria
▼Facebook & Twitter updates, info, memes and fun:
https://www.facebook.com/historicalfencing/
https://twitter.com/scholagladiato1
▼Schola Gladiatoria HEMA - sword fighting classes in the UK:
https://www.swordfightinglondon.com
▼Matt Easton's website & Pinterest:
https://www.matt-easton.co.uk/
https://www.pinterest.co.uk/matt_easton/_saved/
▼Easton Antique Arms - antique swords for sale:
https://www.antique-swords.co.uk
#rapier #fencing #renaissance
this is not a thumb ring stop calling it
a thumb ring I'm going to give you five
reasons why you shouldn't be calling us
a thumb ring and why it's not a thumb
ring hi folks Mattis here Skol I'm only
making this video because last night
Todd of Todd's Workshop put up a
fantastic video where he came to my
Fencing Club in London I've got two
actually but the London one and he did
some filming looking at the sword
breaker left hand dagger very very Brey
for anyone who doesn't know daggers were
often used in the off hand should we say
the less dominant hand so for me the
left hand uh in conjunction with rapers
and side swords and other sorts of
Swords particularly in the 16th and 17th
centuries you kind of find it at the end
of the 15th a little bit as well but
primarily it's a 16th and 17th century
thing so Rapier and Dagger is a very
common combination and daggers work very
well with rapers and in the video with
Todd we looked at a specific type of
leftand dagger called or sometimes
referred to as a sword breaker probably
more correctly described as a sword
catcher um and I'm going to s a link
below to Todd's video If you haven't
seen this already uh please go and have
that uh have a good look at that one but
in that um that particular saw breaking
dagger only has teeth on one side and it
has a normal Edge on the other side so
there is some question about which way
around you should be holding the edge
and the teeth and of course what does
does that affect it affects a huge
number of things because if you've only
got teeth on one side which with that
type of dagger you can only have you
couldn't have teeth on both sides
because it would just break in the
middle um you've only got teeth in one
side so that means you can only catch or
bind on one side of your dagger not on
the other but in the context of that
video therefore we had to decide which
way around you have the teeth and
looking at the originals in the museums
it was dictated for us by which side
this side ring as it's called not a
thumb ring thumb ring is a different
thing for a different type of Sword
maybe we'll look at thumb rings in the
future used on things like polish shaer
and things like that but not on leftand
daggers on left hand daggers we have a
side ring and this is something we first
find in the 15th century applied to the
side of arming swords and later long
swords as well so that is to protect one
side of the hand and later on you get
double rings on swords but we don't find
those on the left hand daggers on left
hand daggers they're only on one side so
how do we know that they are supposed to
be held that way and not that way with
the thumb up inside in other words the I
I'm asserting that the ring is to be
held away from you towards the opponent
not towards you with your thumb through
it here some people say this is for
protecting the thumb they are so wrong
and I'm going to give you five reasons
now why they're so wrong so number one
reason why I can assert with absolute
certainty that they are categorically
wrong is because we've got fencing
treates showing them being held on this
side like I won't quite call them
instruction manuals but they kind of are
um certainly they show pictures of
people using rapers and daggers and
fencing with them and they show us how
the swords are held they even show uh
details about where the finger is placed
over the Quillon or not in some cases
some treaters is don't put a finger over
the Quillon of the sword some uh later
Spanish ones put two fingers over but
nevertheless with a left hand dagger
they show the ring towards the opponent
on the what I would call the front of
the hand and you will notice that very
often but not always very often the
thumb is placed up the back now there
are certain types of Spanish leftand
dagger which actually have a special
thumb Placer either on the blade or they
have a little plate coming up here from
the guard specifically showing you where
to put your thumb it's like Point
towards enemy thumb on back um and that
is to consist in essentially parrying
and potentially catching the opponent's
blade but basically controlling and
defending and the thumb on the back
means that instead of holding it like a
you would hold a sword with the edge
towards that way you actually hold the
edges sideways like this because you're
using the guard and any other teeth for
example in the sword catching dagger in
order to control the opponent's sword so
this is primarily a parrying device
rather than a weapon although you can
also use it as a weapon and therefore
you're holding it with the Flats towards
them with the uh ring the side ring
pointing towards them not pointing
towards you and not with your thumb
through it now I suppose that some
people got the idea that this was to put
the thumb through and protect the thumb
somehow because they knew that the thumb
was up the back of the dagger so they
thought oh well wouldn't that provide
great protection to the thumb no but
we'll get to that later um in fact there
is another very good reason so this is
reason number two why we know that
that's not what they were designed for
this one is an open ring but not all of
them are I've got another example here
which is a prototype of the upcoming
second batch for the Royal armor
windless line that I work on with them
and this has what's called a closed Port
you will notice it has a big big side
ring on the side there um but it has a
plate in it and this is not uncommon we
find quite a lot of examples with a
plate on the inside there so clearly you
can't put your thumb through it cuz
there's a plate in there so clearly they
weren't intending it for that purpose
and in fact The Originals unlike a lot
of replicas the grips are quite short on
these so actually you're obliged to put
the thumb on the flat of the blade up
there and behind the blade because you
wouldn't be able to fit it just on on
the grip down here so there is no way
that you could put the thumb up through
there one thing I just briefly mention
is that sometimes if you look at the
treat disas the blade isn't held this
way uh with the flat towards the
opponent sometimes it is held with the
edge towards the opponent and in those
cases again if we go back to number one
reason and we look at the treaters is we
can see that the ring is on the outside
of the hand not on the inside of the
hand so the next reason that we know
that the ring is to be held towards the
opponent or sometimes outwards over the
back of the hand here is because of the
quillons that is these hook- like guards
that come up here now there is a
specific feature of leftand daggers and
that is that the quillons unlike a sword
aren't usually in line with the blade
they're actually tilted to one side we
can see this even more dramatically in
an exaggerated form with this replica
from the Royal armories where the curved
quillons are way off to the side why is
that that's to catch an opposing Rapier
blade so as the blade comes in here the
idea is in parrying you can hook the
thing and control it like that now just
as a brief tangent I would point out
that this is actually quite a reliable
way of catching opposing Rapier blades
more reliable than the toothed leftand
dagger and this is a point I left out in
Todd's video which is why it's important
hopefully that you've seen his video
before you see this something that I
regretted not mentioning at the time was
that these quillons like designed like
this are actually far more reliable at
controlling and catching opposing Rapier
blades in my experience than tooth
blades are however tooth blades are
probably better at catching cuts from
flatter cutting swords so there we go
make of that what you will back to to
the main topic so the fact that we've
got these quillons tilted forward tells
you that that is designed to be towards
the opponent okay they only make sense
in that direction you wouldn't have them
pointing back towards you and we notice
on all of The Originals the curve of the
quillons matches the side that the side
ring is on so that tells us yet again
that the side ring is either to be held
over the back of the hand if the edge is
pointed towards the opponent or with the
side ring and the quillons pointed
towards the opponent if the thumb is
placed on the reverse flat now the
fourth reason we know that these thumb
ring people are completely wrong and
talking nonsense is that not all daggers
only have quillons and a ring for hand
protection some of them particularly in
Spain but also in England and various
other places sometimes in southern Italy
have a form of sail guard or bars okay
so there's also you might have heard
something called an ale housee dagger so
these are I won't say they're related
weapons but they're similar conclusions
to a similar problem how do you protect
the hand more when you're holding this
out using defensively against someone
who's cutting or thrusting at you and
the solution is to either have a sail
guard or bars now these weren't actually
statistically very common in the age of
the rapia they were very popular in
Spain after about 1600 they weren't
really very much a thing before the year
1600 and as I say they were popular in
England and a few other places but they
were always in a minority so the
majority of left hand daggers usually
only had guards and a side ring some of
them didn't even have a side ring or
some of them had a very small side ring
why why not have tons of hand protection
because it's a real pain in the butt
literally to wear so bear in mind that
you're wearing a leftand dagger in a
Scabbard and it's going to be for the
most part sometimes on the side but
usually at the back here where you can
reach it easily so if you're walking
around with a dagger stuck through your
belt or your sash on the back there you
don't want a massive on it because let's
face it you're going to spend hours and
weeks and months of your life wearing
this thing and you might only ever use
it in combat never or once or twice if
you're unlucky or lucky depending how
you look at it um so basket hilts or
swept hilts rather um uh sail guards and
and things like this a bit cumbersome
and they also make the weapon heavier
and therefore a little bit more slow in
dealing with the main things which are
thrust up your body and head anyway
that's a topic for another video
probably um so the fact is that when
they have sail guards or bars on them
they are on the same side um as the ring
and in fact some of them even have bars
coming down from the ring so that again
tells us we know that is not supposed to
be held on the side of the thumb it's
supposed to be held either towards the
opponent or at the very least out to the
side either straight to the side or 45°
to the side or straight towards them
like that so it tells us it's not a
thumb ring it's a side ring so the fifth
and final reason why we know that this
isn't a thumb ring to protect the thumb
is because it's an idiotic suggestion
and it doesn't hold up to reality if you
actually fenc with left hand daggers and
rapers you realize that doesn't really
work it doesn't really achieve anything
and it's unnecessary okay why quite
simply this ring is there primarily if I
just grab a short blade rather than
raping because it's easier to
demonstrate if we're parrying with this
and the blade slides down here it's to
protect that uh back of the hand the
knuckles there if you're holding the
blade forwards or if you're holding it
to the side to protect there this is the
side that blades will predominantly come
from if the blade is on this side of
your um uh dagger then you turn the
dagger this way and it's still in front
here there would be no point it
protecting on the inside of the thumb
here because if the blade is that side
you're defending that way notice the
ring is then on that side if the blade
is this side you're defending that way
in which case the ring is still on that
side it would make no sense at all
having the ring pointing towards you
instead of pointing towards the enemy
because whether you're defending to the
left or to the right the ring is always
pointing either towards them or their
blade okay so having it round here it
achieves nothing secondly it doesn't
protect the thumb if we put the thumb
through here first of all the thumb is
behind the blade you'll notice okay my
thumb is protected because it is behind
the blade now this is a fairly narrow
one because this is a practice flexible
practice one look at this broad one with
my thumb behind the blade you can't see
the thumb if I'm defending there or
there then my thumb is protected by the
blade already it doesn't need a ring but
secondly even not only does the ring
isn't it necessary it doesn't provide
any additional protection anyway if I
stick my thumb out here the dangerous
the bit of uh the bit that's at Danger
on my thumb is the tip and being through
the ring doesn't provide any protection
to it because it's in the wrong place it
just makes no sense so to conclude this
is a side ring it is not a thumb ring it
is to be held towards the opponent or to
the side at the least or if you're
paring on the inside it could be that
side but it is not at all to be held
towards you with your thumb through it
even if you do that you've now lost a
load of protection from the front of
your dagger you it doesn't protect your
thumb any more than it already was
protected it provides no additional
protection whatsoever and your quillons
or your sail guard are now pointing in
the wrong direction because we know that
on all of The Originals in museums if
they have curved quillons they always in
the same direction as the um as the ring
or indeed if there's a sail guard it's
in the same Direction's ring so it is to
be held that way towards the opponent or
outwards protecting the big meaty back
of the hand not protecting the little
thumb at the back anyway thanks a lot
for watching I hope you've watched
Todd's video as well by now um I have
been Mattis and obviously I will
continue to be and I hope I'll see you
back on the channel really soon cheers
folks thanks for watching we've got
extra videos on patreon please give our
Facebook a like And subscribe if you
haven't already cheers folks

