Are maces bad weapons in medieval armoured combat? Short maces were widely used from the 11th to the 16th centuries, but perhaps not in the same ways across that period. This video is inspired by @dequitem video response to me ( https://youtu.be/TbiGZNNs2oI?si=LN_S_LubqFXCCq_I )
contrary to what lots of people believe
is the mace actually really bad for
armored Combat on foot this is a
response to deem and also looking at the
subject of armored
[Music]
combat hi folks Mattis and here schol
Gladiator now first up this is a
response to deem link below to his
channel fantastic channel uh to his
response to my video talking about why
basically are maces easier to use than
swords and to cut a long story short if
you haven't seen my previous video the
pertinent part of that video which
applies here is that my conclusion was
that they are aren't inherently easier
to use than swords learning to fight is
learning to fight and you learn to do it
with various different weapons but
within the specific realm of armored
combat you could possibly class these as
easier to use than swords because
fundamental Mally you can bash people in
armor with maces and have some effect
through the armor whereas with the long
sword or any other type of Sword it's
more precise if you just bash the armor
with a sword uh you're probably going to
damage your sword but you're not going
to damage the armed opponent very much
and it's mostly about getting points
into gaps like armpits or Vision slits
or wrestling and this is more Technical
and more difficult so for that reason I
concluded that within the realm of
armored combat the mace arguably could
be said to be easier to use because you
can just bash really really hard with it
and have some effect on people in armor
or can you well this is the where we get
into the really interesting realm of
back and forth between different experts
and different opinions different sources
that we're drawing upon and also
different experiences now deem again
link below to his channel and it was a
great response video he actually agrees
I think with most of the points I made
in the video but he makes a very
interesting point which I thought it was
very much worth unpacking here because
fundamentally he argues that the
onehanded mace or indeed Warhammer and
you could extend this to something like
an axe as well is actually a poor weapon
not a very effective weapon fighting
onfor in armor now what is his frame of
reference well he does heemer in armor
commonly known as harness vecton in
German and um excuse my German
pronunciation I'm sure it's quite poor
uh but basically he specializes in
armored fighting and it must be said
while I do some armored uh harness
Vector not armored fighting in heemer
without doubt my what I spend 95% of my
time doing is unarmored heemer De qum
absolutely does over there in Germany
specialize in armad heemo which is
fantastic and this is something that I'm
intending to spend more of my time on in
the future and there will be videos
coming about that actually in my plans
for that but anyway uh that's a future
video so is the one-handed mace
essentially a crap weapon for fighting
on foot in armor first of all why does
he argue that well he draws some
parallels both from heema armored
fighting so harness vecton and also
boher where he argues that the ma is not
very effective against armor what are we
talking about armor we're talking about
full plate harness here we'll we'll kind
of specify a bit more about the armor in
a minute so you know we're talking about
things like um these gauntlets full arm
harness pauldrons uh full curas and
helmets uh like my uh salot which I
showed here and he fundamentally argues
and I'm not saying that I disagree he
fundamentally argues that strikes with a
mace don't have an awful lot of effect
on joints or through plates um on on
bits of plate armor because plate armor
is really really effective against
protecting against these sorts of
weapons
now do I agree with that well let's
let's unpack it a little bit
fundamentally I sort of agree that plate
harness is very very good at protecting
you against uh swung weapons lances
arrows all kinds of stuff so we have to
kind of start from that basis that I
think it's a bit unfair to say that
maces are uneffective against plate
armor and therefore they're not good
weapons for fighting in armor because
fundamentally most other weapons are
also not very effective against PL armor
because plate armor is so effective so
in fact jousting you could say is the
Lance an ineffective weapon against
plate armor because we regularly joust
and break glances on plate armor no it's
still an effective Weapon It's just that
plate armor is really good are long bows
and crossbows ineffective weapons
because they don't very often penetrate
plate armor no they're still effective
weapons it's just that plate armor is
very effective and it goes on like this
and in fact we come to sord and this is
one of the interesting things is that
deem argues that the sword is actually
easier to use I think I think I'm
getting him right in this the easier to
use an armor than a mace because you can
stab into gaps with this which you can't
do with a mace and whereas with the mace
you can strike the armor that's not very
effective stabbing into gaps is very
effective and that actually makes the
sword a better armored fighting weapon
than the mace we will come back to that
point in a minute before we go into that
I just want to briefly focus on the mace
so if we were to accept for example the
premise that this is a poor weapon for
armored fighting and that in fact the
sword is a better weapon for armored
fighting then the fundamental question
we have to ask is well why does the mace
exist why why why is the mace a thing
and we're not just talking about a
simple stone on the end of a stick hip
if we go back into the Stone Age or
indigenous cultures that don't have
metallic weapons we're talking here
about something like this 15th century
flanged mace and there are spiked
versions and various other versions but
these are expensive highly crafted um
High status in many cases objects why
did these objects exist if they were
ineffective compared to a sword given
that people have already got swords why
would you additionally carry a mace when
you could just carry a sword in armor as
an armored man at arms as a knight um
why would you carry this if it wasn't a
useful object for fighting an armor well
we have to go partially back to the
origins of the mace not the far far back
kind of Stone Age Origins or even Bronze
Age Origins but in fact the medieval
Origins now one thing that I think gets
overlooked in the discussion of maces is
in particularly in this one anyway is
that we're focusing on the 15th century
and perhaps 14th century so we're
focusing on the age of plate armor when
maces first appear you can see them in
the beot
1066 uh you can see them in Crusader
period art of the of the 12th and 13th
centuries when we see maces used there
they are predominantly being used
against people wearing male male AKA
chain mail now that's very interesting
because I think most people recognize
that swords of that ER era aren't
effective at cutting through male um but
nevertheless because people have to hit
each other if they're wearing armor
um thrusting aside they do nevertheless
hit into male now if you are habitually
hitting people in male armor that's male
over an A gamerson or aaton then in fact
a very topheavy weapon like this becomes
super effective because you're now
delivering more impact energy into the
Target and I don't think anybody would
disagree with the fact that in terms of
impact energy something which is
topheavy is going to hit with more
energy that some something that is Hilt
heavy heavy so although you might be
striking with a slightly larger surface
impact area than the narrow bladed sword
if you're striking someone wearing male
a mace or an axe or a Warhammer has very
clear advantages for breaking bones
which you absolutely can do through male
and gamerson so in the 11th 12th 13th
centuries the ma is very clearly
effective against maed people
moreover there was some interesting
feedback from boher people um in the
comments underneath DM's um video now
what's interesting to me and I didn't
know is that in modern boher actually
the weight of uh maces is actually
restricted somewhat I think to a
kilogram in most rules whereas falion
for example now Bower falion are not
very like real falion for the most part
so most historical falion have very thin
blades very fine edges they're not
particularly heavy um they're about the
same weight as an arming sword so
they're more like a meat cleaver or a
machete than they are like a mace uh but
if you make a blunt reenactment version
it will end up being like a bar mace
essentially because of having to have a
thick uh edge and a rounded point and
this kind of stuff and not very much
distal taper so fundamentally what's
interesting is in boher we get false
data feedback because in boher you can
have a 1.3 kg uh falan but you can only
have a 1 kg mace now that's very
interesting why did they introduce that
my understanding is it's partly for
safety reasons because if you make a
really heavy mace and you hit someone as
hard as you possibly can do in the limb
or in the head very often people are
going to be uh concussed they're going
to be knocked out they're going to have
bones broken um and the fact is even
with a helmet uh and also Bower helmets
tend to have more uh padding inside them
than historical helmets do and they tend
to be made of thicker gauge steel as
well which decm mentions himself
actually so the fact is that hitting
heads specifically with a mace uh I
think in any era whether it's the you
know the Norman ERA with a conical
helmet with a nasal and you've got face
at a Target there as well but later on
with great Helms and later on things
with bassinets and salads hitting really
hard into the head could be very
effective when you've got a very top
heavy weapon um but some people might
dispute that with reenactment experience
but bear in mind in most standard
reenactment people are pulling their
blows and not hitting as hard as
possible in boher where people are
hitting as hard as possible they have a
1 kg weight limit for maces which again
I find very interesting so in the age of
male I would say Maes are clearly very
effective as we go into the age of plate
we have to State something clearly okay
and this something this is something
that completely hands up I wasn't clear
about in my PR previous video the fact
is that in the 14th and 15th centuries
we do not see one-handed maces used on
foot very much anymore okay we usually
see these used on foot we see forms of
larger two-handed they might be doing
the same kind of thing as a mace but you
got a huge amount more leverage uh
you've got two ends you've got the fact
that you've got a shaft here to defend
and lever with you've usually got
thrusting points you've got other
options so there's various types of
Warhammer and polex and Morning Star and
you know Spike club and stuff that are
two-handed okay so as we get into the
certainly the second half of the 14th
century so 1350 to 1400 and into the
1400s and thereafter for fighting on
foot fully armored people usually chose
something like this rather than
something like this these exist this is
a 15th century star mace but these are
usually used on Horseback we'll come
back to that point in a minute so
mounted combat aside just for a minute
as I say I'll come back to that are
swords actually more effective on foot
well I think different people will have
different opinions on this but one thing
I want to make clear is that to
reiterate my previous Point fighting on
foot with a sword in armor bashes while
they can have some effect they can set
up faints they can have some percussive
effect they can sometimes disorientate
people if you hit someone hard enough in
the helmet there are a few things about
bashing with swords in armor which I
want to make clear the first thing is
that with a sharp edged sword bashing
armor will damage the blade now I don't
particularly care that the blade gets
damaged but that hugely increases the
risk of the blade breaking now if you
take something like this sharp albian
long sword this is made of modern 5160
steel even with modern steel even with
modern heat treatment if I take the this
sword and as hard as I can give an obal
or a fendente straight down onto the top
of this salot there is a fairly good
chance that I'm going to break the sword
if not with the first blow with the
second third or fourth blow okay and the
reason for that is that when you have a
sharp edged sword you will take a chip
or a curl or a notch in the blade which
will create an immediate stress Riser
which means even if it doesn't break on
the first blow it's very likely to play
to break on one of the next blows so
just striking into play Tom with a sharp
sword is very lik to break it and that's
with modern steel if we use medieval
steel with slag inclusions irregular
heat treatment probably being generally
softer and certainly not being a modern
uh sort of spring steel uh comparison
you're far more far more likely to break
it okay so just striking into armor is
unlikely to have a huge effect on the
opponent and is very likely to break
your sword and this is probably one of
the reasons we see it practically not at
all in the treatises if you can find an
example of cutting hard a into armor in
any of the 15th century treatises show
me I do know there are a couple of
examples out there but they are rare
okay that is not how swords are shown
being used against armor certainly in
the age of play in the 15th century the
way they are shown being used is being
used as levers sometimes admittedly
being used as a a mace to hit with the
back end but predominantly being used to
thrust now is this easier than striking
with a mace I would argue no for two
very important reasons one which is
obvious and one which is less obvious so
most obvious one I already mentioned
before just hitting someone repeatedly
with an object is way technically easier
than while they're moving around and
trying to do to the same to you trying
to get your point into into a gap or
indeed holding the sword conventionally
and thrusting into gaps this way okay
that is easier than thrusting I would
argue deam might disagree but that's
fine we can there's room for
disagreement here but here's the big
thing even if you think that thrusting
into an armpit or towards someone's face
or into the inside of their elbow
whatever is
easy the problem is is that in hea we
are not using sharp swords and we are
not penetrating male AKA chain mail
we're generally speaking using a sword
like this which is blunt and when we get
a hit into their armpit and we get a
little bit of flex on the blade we're
going ha I scored a point but did you
here's the problem in reality what you
actually have to do is when you stab
into the armpit you have to not only
just get the point into a ring you have
to burst the ring you need to get the
point into the body and and prevent them
from doing the same to you at the same
time and that might not put them out of
action so here's the problem a lot of
armored harness Fon or heer classes a
scoring Point as a Thrust in the armpit
or inner arm or wherever or even
somewhere on the face but you don't know
that that would have done anything at
all to the opponent okay the fact is
that when we strike someone really hard
with a mace or a a poleax we can see the
effect if they get concussed and fall
over they get concussed and fall over
because a strike is a strike but the
problem is when we're using blunt
weapons and we're not penetrating male
in the voiders and gaps we're not
penetrating eyelets and helmets we don't
really know what effect our strike would
have had on the opponent okay so to
finish off that particular part of this
uh discussion I think it's very
difficult comparing which is easier out
of stabbing in gaps versus just hitting
the armor bashing the armor with
something because we can see a bash on
the armor but we can't always analyze
whether a Thrust in the Gap was actually
effective and would have gone through
the chain mail or male that is in the
voider or in the Gap so coming back to
that mounted Point what were these short
maces and warhammers predominantly for
in the 15th century they were
predominantly for horsemen for this
reason these are sometimes referred to
as Horsemen's maces or Horsemen's
warhammers so I'm just trying to work
out where to stick my pox here uh one of
life's problems in my world um so when
you got a short um you know Warhammer or
mace like this these are usually seen in
Period art in the hands of Horsemen so
why did they have short ones well quite
simply cuz they couldn't Carry long ones
where would you if you were on Horseback
where would you put that you'd need a
squire basically riding behind to take
it for you we do actually have records
of knights um having a poleax ready obv
obvously being carried by someone else
um but by and large if you're on your
own horse your primary weapons are your
Lance and your sword now the great thing
about sword is it can be worn in its
Scabbard at your belt so that's always
ever ready but if you want to carry one
of these these usually carried in the
saddle bow maybe occasionally with a
hook or a ring at the belt as well those
are other options but these are
Horsemen's weapons so they are not in
this period necessarily expected to be
good weapons in fighting armored on foot
if you want to fight armored on foot
things like this or the glaive or the
two-handed sword are actually usually
regarded as the best weapons for
fighting on foot in armor so why did
Horsemen pick these in addition to a
sword okay well I would argue that
actually again it comes back to armor
what's most effective on Horseback you
can't really be half soring very easily
you can't be very accurate with your
thrusts into armpits and gaps so
actually if you're riding around and we
could get someone like Zack Evans or
Jason Kingsley to weigh in on this so if
you're watching this video then I'd be
very happy if you do if you're
maneuvering around with your horse you
know absolutely you can hit someone we
see this in the strees you can just hit
another arm a person with your sword or
you could try and hit their horse or
stab their horse you could try and stab
towards their armpits and we see this in
Palo or Cello's Battle of s Romano but
with a weapon like this you're going to
have more percussive effect you're more
more likely to knock a person out of
their saddle or disorientate them or
concuss them with a top heavy weapon
that you can just take a big old swing
up as you ride past with your horse bam
in the in the helmet that's likely to
have more percussive effect than a sword
is and remember the point I made about
swords breaking and we see this in
medieval art we see broken swords little
lited around these weapons are less
likely to break than an actual period
sharp sword are so on Horseback I I
think there's a number of reasons why uh
mounted men carried these partly it's
for fighting other armored mounted men
because these are more effective against
other mounted armored men but also it's
the backup idea I mean bear in mind
you're not going to have only this or
this you'll have both so actually you
might keep the sword in it Scabbard
start out using these and if one flies
out of your hand gets knocked out of
your hand or breaks or whatever you
still got another thing as well so
you've got backup things but equally
this might be better against lightly
armor tro who you can run through as you
ride past or slash across the shoulder
or whatever but if you come up against
another armored Horseman cassia
essentially as we see with the Polish
Lancers then with their specialized
weapons like maces and concers and
indeed the uh otoman Janis eras as well
They Carried mes specifically for
armored opponents so it kind of backs up
this theory is that these are like if
you come up against another heavy guy on
horse then this is going to be a better
striking weapon to try and smash them in
the head with than a sword is and again
I want to reiterate swords break if you
hit as hard as you physically possibly
can with a ottoman uh kich or a a
knight's arming sword there's a good
chance if you're hitting the helmet
you're going to break the sword less
likely with a mace or a hammer so to
wrap up and once again thanks to deim
for making his video because um it's a
great Channel go and check it out
there's some awesome armored fighting in
there and it re really made me think
about this topic a little bit more
deeply and actually it made me realize
some of the points I hadn't quite made
in the way that I perhaps should have
done um I could have made them more
clearly but also I think I I left people
with the impression that these were sort
of supreme optiman armored foot fighting
weapons of the 15th century they were
not okay these were primarily used by
Horsemen these short ones if you are
fighting onfor in armor in the 14th or
15th centuries poleaxes glaes and other
two-handed weapons that have the ability
to strike very powerfully and have reach
and have thrusting points and have two
ends these are better weapons no
question and these were used in battle
and they were used in nightly duels okay
they were the optimum armored fighting
weapons and as backups to those you
almost always had a sword and a dagger
like a rondle dagger um however do I
think that maces are terrible armored
fighting weapons no I think in the
earlier period when we're talking about
male and great Helms and shields when
you've got a shield Animas I think
that's a very good combination and
particularly where the opponent has male
on their arms and legs and you can smash
them in the knee and break their knee or
smash them in the elbow and break their
elbow mace super effective because that
has greater percuss of ability than a
sword would do as we come forward into
the 14th and 15th centuries there's no
question that these short percussion
weapons become less important and in
fact not very important in fighting on
foot and if we look at armored duels in
the 15th century the standard weapons
were the spear the poleax the long sword
and the dagger sometimes there are other
weapons sometimes in Trea as we see
these there's a Warhammer and a mace uh
shown in in talhoffer for example but by
and large on foot the weapons you choose
to fight with on fo are the spear the
poleax the long sword and the rondle
dagger these were pretty much the best
weapons and the standard battle weapons
throughout the 15th century for most
knights fighting on
but these were very popular armored
fighting weapons for horseback fighting
I believe because they offer a whole
bunch of advantages that you don't get
from the others and you can't use the
big twoand PX although you occasionally
see it in art by and large you can't
really see these used on Horseback in
fact sometimes we even see these cut
down so we even see shortened versions
where they've just got a normal pole Axe
and they've swn off the shaft so you can
use it as a one-handed axe or even a
almost like a long sword ax
from horseback but these were by that
point more specialized Horseman's
weapons so I hope that's um been
intriguing interesting thought-provoking
if you massively disagree that's
absolutely fine as always get posting in
the comments Below have I missed certain
points other things I've overlooked
things I've overplayed things I've
underplayed what would you like to say
maybe you'd like to see decm and me do
some more collaboration and some more uh
interaction if if you've got suggestions
for that things you'd like us to test
let us know thanks a lot for following
the channel I hope I'll see you back
really really soon I have been Matt
Easton and I'll continue to be cheers
folks thanks for watching we've got
extra videos on patreon please give our
Facebook a like And subscribe if you
haven't already cheers folks