The Mark of Amsterdam: Decoding the Iconic Triple-X Walloon Hilt Sword

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
2 Video Views·Mar 27, 2026
In this deep-dive, we tackle the popular, yet potentially incorrect, name given to this iconic 17th-century sword type often linked to the Amsterdam militia: the Sword of the Amsterdam City Guard.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Today we debunk the myth of the Sword of the Amsterdam City Guard.
Well, more than debunk, it's going to be a bit of an open conversation on this very unique,
very beautiful and very iconic typology of sword and on its colloquial naming,
which kind of refers it back to the Amsterdam Militia, let's say.
And we'll also discuss why this name may be incorrect, in fact.
But as is the case with most sword things,
the more doors we open, the less absolute conclusions we can draw from it.
So debunking, yes, but I think this video is going to leave more questions open than answers.
But let's start from the beginning.
What are we talking about when we refer to, whether correctly or incorrectly,
the Sword of the Amsterdam City Guard?
We're looking at a sword which is commonly grouped in with the Walloon Hilted Swords.
Now, whether or not this grouping is correct is up to your individual
interpretation of a Walloon Hilted Sword.
I will say, for my part, there are definitely many characteristics
that place it squarely into the group of the Walloon Hilted Swords.
However, there are also some differences that could lead
some of you to kind of distinguish them a little further.
So in terms of common characteristics, we have, I think, one that is not even aesthetic,
but has to do really with its function.
Walloon Hilted Swords are often broad, heavy swords used by cavalry.
We have a bunch of different variants to them, of course.
But they're often military swords.
They're not extremely fancy.
They're very practical and tend to be, as I mentioned, broad and authoritative.
And this sword definitely fits that characteristic.
You'll see the size of the hilt simply is rather impressive.
The blade matches that kind of heft.
And so its function would have been very similar to what we would see
in the most stereotypical Walloon Hilted Swords.
We also see certain characteristics in terms of the hilt itself.
It's fixed to the pommel with a screw, which is very common of this type of sword.
It has the... let me see if I can show you...
Yeah, it has the double-valved guard, which is pierced in this case,
as is the case in many Walloon Hilted Swords as well.
It has a knuckle bow, which is common of many Walloon Hilted Swords.
So the framework, you could say, of the hilt is very similar
to what we see on the stereotypical Walloon Hilted Swords.
However, there are some elements that kind of make it a little bit different.
And perhaps the most striking of these is the lack of one characteristic
that for me makes the Walloon Hilted Sword,
which is the sidebar here to protect the outside of the hand
and the extra crossbars that kind of connect that sidebar to the knuckle bar.
This kind of makes for a bit of a skeletonized, perhaps,
basket hilt, like a very minimalistic basket hilt.
But when you do grip a Walloon Hilted Sword with these characteristics,
you actually have the feeling of your hand being very snugly and comfortably protected.
I'll show you, actually, I have one here.
So you'll see that the hand kind of fits,
even though there's more open work than metal there, it feels very protected.
You feel like you're inserting your hand into a sort of protective structure.
Now, this is completely lacking, you'll see, on this sword,
which is way more open and protection is essentially limited to the knuckle bow and the shells here.
But since we're comparing them, let me quickly just show you even the similar characteristics.
So you'll see here the similar style of guard, the pierced effect.
You'll see the fixing in place.
Well, the screw is missing here, but there would have been a screw.
So very similar, but very different.
You'll also see the size.
This one has a smaller hilt, of course, but overall the blades are quite similar.
In fact, I'll have to measure these, but they're more similar than I thought initially.
Anyway, this is not a comparison of Walloon Hilted Swords.
This is a talk about the Amsterdam City Guard Sword.
But why focus so much on the specific characteristics of this type of sword?
All Walloon Hilted Swords come in a variety of shapes and sizes and flavors.
Isn't this just one of the many variants of an otherwise rather broadly described type of sword?
Well, the answer is no.
It's important to understand the characteristics of this type of sword,
because there are actually a lot of examples of it and they all bear the same characteristics.
This leads some support to the idea that this may be an early type of regulation sword.
And when I say early, we're talking here about 17th century.
So if you consider that, for instance, the first regulation swords in England
come to be around the turn of the 18th century.
And the first ones we can see maybe for Prussia,
we've seen earlier in other videos, can be maybe around the quarter of the 18th century.
Here we're talking about a hundred years earlier, almost.
So this is really, really interesting.
And there are a lot of these swords surviving.
Not a lot that they're cheap and easy to find, of course.
They're still relatively rare and relatively valuable.
But enough that they are not a rare sword.
And enough that we are able to look at their characteristics
and determine that they all seem to show all of these characteristics,
with some minor variations when it comes to the blade, I would say.
But why is it called the Sword of the Amsterdam City Guard?
The reason is one simple mark.
Sometimes it can be more than one.
But let's say it's a couple of marks that you will,
in almost all cases, I think all cases I have seen at least,
I'm sure there's some exception, there always is.
But let's say in the absolute vast majority of cases, of examples of the sword,
you'll find around the ricasso here, right at the shoulder,
and sometimes kind of embedded between the blade and half covered by the hilt here,
you'll find the symbol of the city of Amsterdam,
which are three X's vertically aligned.
And these are under a crown.
So this, of course, has led a lot of people to hypothesize
Amsterdam origin for these swords,
which honestly is not a baseless hypothesis.
The reality is that beyond this mark,
there isn't much that lends credence to the idea
that this may have been used by Amsterdam militia,
or another hypothesis is that it could have been used,
for example, by North Holland,
well, the province of Holland in general, military troops.
In fact, it's quite the opposite.
A lot of other clues point towards it not being the case.
So I'll give you a brief rundown of what these are.
Keep in mind that a lot of this is speculation,
a lot of this is opinions people have,
and there's nothing conclusive to determine things one way or the other.
So on the pro side, we have this mark we have seen.
On the con side, we have that there are too many of these swords actually in existence
to kind of justify their use by what would have been essentially a private militia
in the case of the city of Amsterdam,
or a rather small army in terms of European armies
if we consider the armed troops of Holland, for example,
or North Holland specifically.
As I mentioned, these swords are not uncommon.
And these are a good example of what I would call munitions-grade weapon.
If you have curiosity about that term, I made a video about it some time ago.
So they're very utilitarian, they're beautiful, they're well-made, of course,
but they don't have a lot of personalization to them.
They're not made with richly crafted materials or decorations.
These are made for military troops and use,
and this is confirmed by the amount of them we still have.
The problem is, though, Amsterdam at the time
wouldn't have had a need for so many of these swords.
Moreover, when we look at iconography, for example,
when we look at paintings depicting these city militias,
we never see them with kind of military gear.
We don't see them with munitions-grade gear, essentially.
We see them depicted with beautiful rapiers.
We see them sometimes with small swords, early small swords.
We see them occasionally with scarf swords.
We see them dressed up in their best attire.
Even in portraits of militia men who are wearing armor,
so we see them with their cuirass and with their helmet, for example,
usually when we can see a hilt of a sword at their side,
it's usually not, well, it's never, as far as I've seen, this.
It's always a very fancy sword.
This, of course, is biased by the fact that
if you were at the point of having a portrait taken of you,
you probably had the means to show off,
and you would have in the portrait.
You wouldn't have come with the sword you'd use on the battlefield.
However, it's very interesting, at least,
that we have no depiction of this sword being carried by a militia man.
Although there's, as I mentioned, an explanation for that.
And this is really the main con argument.
So on the pro side, we have the mark.
On the con side, we have the, well,
there's too many of them to justify a use by a militia.
In between, we have a whole bunch of other hypotheses.
So most of the blades are Solingen made.
Most of them, at least, are marked with a sahagum or sahagum.
I don't remember which version of it there is,
but that's a typical mark you'll see from Solingen makers.
Some, as in the case of this sword, have a Mefecit Solingen or Salingen in this case.
And there are a few other versions.
In fact, the sword illustrated by Paupe in his book has none of the two.
It has another inscription that I don't remember.
In any case, they would have all been Solingen blades.
Most of them also sport the Passau wolf mark.
So we can be fairly sure that the blades were German in origin.
We can also be fairly sure that the assembly was probably not done in Solingen.
Well, we can be sure because of simply the common practice of the time.
But if you think back to what I was saying earlier,
the fact that the Amsterdam mark is often half covered by the hilt
means that this mark wasn't applied, let's say, after the purchase of the complete sword,
but was applied to the blade before assembly.
So one of the hypotheses is that these marks may be,
rather than an arsenal mark, so to speak, they may be a trademark.
So we know that a lot of swords were sold, for instance,
to the English during the English Civil War.
So one hypothesis is that these swords could actually be,
and you find some of these, or many of these, actually in England as well today.
So one hypothesis is that these could be a kind of a distributor mark.
So the Amsterdam Guild of...
I don't know if there was a guild, so I'm hypothesizing here.
But let's say Amsterdam Trade Unions or Guild would have applied this mark
before assembling the swords and then shipping them, for instance, to England.
Now, there are a number of other possible marks that can or may not be there,
usually near the Ricasso, and they're usually some initial under a crown.
So this may be an inspection mark or a further trademark, for instance.
I'm not exactly sure.
And for these, I don't know if these also happen to be overlapped by the hilt.
So it's possible that these instead were applied later on.
And then one last mark that is commonly found, although not on all of them,
is a sort of clover on the side here of the quillen.
So in terms of marks, this is all we have.
One last point I want to make, speaking of Walloon hilted swords,
is that this may very well be the prototype, actually,
of what became the Walloon hilted sword in general later.
We know that the French found these swords or, well,
faced these swords during their campaigns in Wallonia,
so the current south of Belgium,
and then brought them back and adopted them as their own first regulation model
or one of the first regulation models, at least.
So it's very possible that the first Walloon hilted sword,
that first archetypical Walloon hilted sword that the French found named Walloon
because of where they kind of encountered it and then adopted,
is this version of the Walloon hilted sword.
However, as I was saying, all of this is shrouded in mystery and in uncertainty.
So I'm just kind of reporting what I can on these swords
and the rest of the work is up to you
and draw your own individual conclusions on what you think
the origin and actual use of this type of sword is.
But with all of the history and possibilities out of the way,
I think it's time to get into the close-ups.
Okay, so we already saw the measurements and details of this sword
in the previous video where I compared it to other Walloon hilted swords,
but just as a reminder, the weight is 993 grams, if I'm not mistaken,
and the length of the sword is 106 centimeters
with a 90 centimeter blade, more or less.
So let's start with the hilt.
I'll hold it here, unfortunately, with my left hand
because I'm on the wrong side of the camera here,
but you'll notice the hilt is massive.
This sword is meant to be used with a glove or even a gauntlet, perhaps.
It would definitely fit a kind of hand protection,
which perhaps justifies the fact that it doesn't have the level of protection
other Walloon hilted swords have.
So again, if we compare it to this other one that I just showed you,
again, I'm holding it with the wrong hand,
so it's not a... well, I should probably hold it with the correct one.
But you'll notice that this one, while it would fit a glove,
it will not fit a gauntlet.
It will not fit some kind of super heavy armored kind of protection.
So maybe, I don't have any confirmation about it,
but my impression, just handling it,
is that this would be made to be used with a well-protected hand.
So let's start from the pommel here.
You'll see the pommel is rather massive.
It has this rounded shape, but it's not a fully spherical kind of pommel.
You'll see it's rather flat on this side.
Not completely, but it's kind of squashed on this axis.
So this is a characteristic that you'll fairly typically find.
The blade isn't peened directly into the main body of the pommel here,
but the pommel has this kind of protruding section,
and the peen happens here.
You'll see the screw I was mentioning,
which connects the knuckle guard to the pommel.
You'll see it's an old kind of screw,
so it has a rather thick slot,
and it's not perfectly machined, I would say.
Although the sword in general has a very standardized feel.
I've been able to handle a couple of these,
and they all feel very similar.
In terms of the grip, this one is in surprisingly good condition.
We see it has the turk's head knots at the top and bottom here,
and then we have this wire wrapping with two different kinds of wire, essentially.
We have a very thin wire there,
that kind of goes in because it's braided,
and it seems to me like it goes in two opposite directions.
Then at regular intervals, we have this thicker wire,
which is not braided, it seems to be just kind of a twisted wire.
So a pretty elaborate grip binding,
although elaborate still in a very munitions-grade sense, I would say.
The grip itself is more in the direction of being squared in section,
or rectangle rather than round.
It's definitely comfortable,
but it's not as cylindrical as you will see it,
or as oval-shaped as you would see in other sword grips.
You see the angles, you see the edges here of the core,
so I find that very interesting.
It's still very comfortable.
This one is slightly loose, it has a little bit of rotation here,
but it's nothing too extreme.
In fact, I have the feeling that the grip here
may be broken in a few sections perhaps,
because you'll see that when I move one section,
only a little bit of the wire binding seems to rotate with it.
So I'm not sure what's going on there,
and I definitely will not be taking apart that binding to find out.
The knuckle guard is fairly simple,
so we'll see it kind of moves out here,
and then flares up around the center to then narrow down again.
This is different for sure,
but it's not completely alien to what we see on other Wollon Hilted swords.
For example, even here you'll see that at the center of the bar here,
there is a flaring.
In this case, it's more three-dimensional,
and there's this groove,
which kind of gives the impression of two elements uniting,
but it's not dissimilar in, let's say, absolute,
in pure terms from what you see here.
Although here you'll see the bar is rather flat.
Now moving on to the guard,
you'll see that in this case,
one of the shells is unfortunately missing.
This is not uncommon on a lot of Wollon Hilted swords.
It feels like this was a bit of a weak spot.
In fact, I can actually show you.
You see the grooves here in which the shell plate would be fixed.
So this wasn't, let's say, an integral part of the guard,
as you will see in other models of swords,
but these plates are kind of applied and therefore easy to pop off,
which kind of leads me to a bit of a thought now,
which is, I wonder if these were maybe removed purposefully.
I've never seen any idea kind of suggesting that or supporting that feeling,
but granted, this has this dome so your hand fits comfortably,
but I wonder if at any point in time there was the need,
maybe using a gauntlet,
you need a little extra space to grip it a bit better.
You see, if I kind of grip it really tightly here,
my knuckles here kind of protrude a little,
so I wonder.
But of course, this is just speculation,
and I'm sure there are many examples also with the left guard missing.
But one of the interesting things, if we look at the remaining guard here,
you'll see that unlike many Wollon Hilted swords,
which have a rather crude piercing,
in fact, again, to compare,
I'll just show you this one really quickly.
It just has a couple of holes punched into the guard there,
which you'll see here.
And there's, again, a characteristic that is very typical
of this specific variation of the sword,
this model, we could say,
is the kind of sun or star pattern piercing you'll see here.
So you see these bigger holes are punched,
and they're basically sun or star,
depending on how you want to look at it.
And then in between them, they have this pattern of simple dots.
So this is a way more finely decorated guard,
and I think it's rather beautiful,
and it's very unique to this model.
If we look at the blade, which I'm sure we all want to,
you'll see that this is a very typical Wollon Hilted blade.
We have this small fuller at the start,
which kind of goes up to the first fifth, perhaps, of the blade,
and then it transitions into a lenticular section,
and then moves all the way up.
Very simple, up to a spear point.
The blade is solid, especially given its size, of course.
There's no flex here at the bottom,
but as you move up, it becomes a little more flexible.
And once you reach the tip, I have to say,
it has sufficient flex to not be, let's say, a pure slab of steel.
And just to compare it, again, to this blade,
which we were just looking at,
you'll notice that the characteristics here are very similar,
both in terms of width.
The length of the fuller is very similar.
There's, I don't know, here there's some remain of inscription,
so that we can't analyze.
The cross section is very similar.
This one is a little more flat,
and also here we move into a spear tip.
So, essentially, a very traditional Wollon Hilted blade.
But what makes this one unique, as we've discussed already,
is the markings and inscriptions on this model.
So, we'll start by looking at the fuller here,
and hopefully it comes through.
But you can see Mefecit here,
and then there's a couple of Xs there, it seems,
three Xs, perhaps,
which would not be out of the theme of the sword.
And then you'll see here a Salingel,
I hope that comes through.
You can check it on this side,
which is actually, I probably should have done it earlier,
because it's more visible.
As you'll see the Mefecit, a bunch of Xs.
Actually, it seems like it's four Xs in a cross pattern.
And then Salingel, and then we have some Xs here as well.
And here at the start as well.
The Passau Wolf is at the end of the fuller,
in a position that is not uncommon.
So, you'll see him or her there.
Running, but as I mentioned,
this is not the most typical inscription on the sword.
The vast majority of these have a Sahagum, or Sahagom.
Again, I don't remember the variant.
So what does this point to?
It could mean that there were a variety of different batches
of these swords, perhaps.
It could mean that the vast majority were ordered
from whichever maker used the Sahagom mark,
but then occasionally some were outsourced
from other producer who had the Mefecit Salingen
or other variants as well.
We don't really know.
But all of these, as I mentioned,
do come from the Salingen production area.
In terms of the marks that kind of determine this model
as a unique model, we can see them here.
So in this sword specifically,
you'll see that they are a little worn by now.
You can see here there's a crown there,
and then we have one X.
We would have had three Xs vertically kind of moving.
This would be the top of the mark,
and this is the bottom.
And we also see that there's a mark
somewhere under here as well.
We see a crown, and then the mark moves underneath
in this direction down the guard here.
So this kind of matches what I've been talking about
throughout the video.
We have these multiple Amsterdam marks,
some of which are visible,
and some are kind of semi-hidden
under the hilt assembly.
On the other side of the blade here,
we seem to have one of those letters
I mentioned under a crown.
And as you'll see, this one here
is not covered in any way by the hilt.
So I wonder if this was applied later.
So perhaps this was the merchant's or the trade mark.
And then once the sword was assembled,
this may have been an acceptance mark or a proof mark.
Hard to say.
I don't have information on these,
but it's something that if someone wanted to look into,
would definitely be a good avenue of research.
In this case, what you see here seems to be a P to me.
It seems like a P under a crown.
The blade is not sharp, I would say.
Well, it was sharp at some point.
Well, I don't know.
But I don't think it was a service sharpened.
It's like on the verge of being sharp,
but I don't see any marks of the final sharpening
before going into battle.
And then the last mark I wanted to show you
is here on the quill.
And this is this kind of clover I was telling you about.
It could be a cross too, I suppose,
but it looks more like a flower or a four-leaf clover.
This one is present, again, in the vast majority,
but there are examples of the sword without the clover mark.
So I hope this was an interesting video.
I know I focused way more on the historical aspect
than on the features of the sword,
but I think that is because the features of the sword
are so standardized
that you can find high quality pictures
wherever you want on the internet.
Whereas perhaps the historical interpretation
of what it may be
is maybe what makes this sword so interesting.
I hope you enjoyed the video.
I hope you like this model of sword.
If you do have a chance to pick one of these up,
I absolutely suggest you do,
because this is a sword that should fit in any collection.
It just deserves that spot, I think.
But if you don't, I hope this video will suffice.
Thank you for watching,
and I'll see you soon in another sword video.
Oh, and if you've made it until here,
please like and subscribe,
because it really helps the channel.
Bye.
