Leaf Blades: How Good are They, and Why Did they Disappear (Mostly)?

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
2 Video Views·May 9, 2026
Leaf-bladed swords are quite popular with collectors and overall in fantasy movies, video games, etc. One of the most iconic blade shapes for sure. They were also dominant in some parts of the world during the Bronze and Iron Age. However, they basically disappeared later on in history, with a few exceptions here and there. Why is that?
AI Generated·May contain errors
All right, let's talk about leaf blades.
I've got Matt Easton here to provide some context.
Thanks for joining, Matt.
My pleasure, Scott. Thanks for having me.
So this is something that people have often asked about, not just me,
I'm sure you as well, because leaf blades seem pretty popular
generally, like in fantasy in particular, and a lot of people like the look.
And no surprise, it's quite unique.
So the question is, why did they fall out of favor?
They used to be quite popular.
If you look at the Bronze Age, you find plenty of leaf blades.
And the Greeks used leaf blades in the form of the Xiphos.
Some types of Roman Gladius were leaf blade, like the Mines.
Even the Pugio is the leaf blade, etc.
But overall, it seems like they fell out of favor.
So the question is why?
I have some ideas.
I'm sure you have some ideas.
So I'm going to let you start.
It's actually quite a complicated subject, isn't it?
So when we first started talking about this, I kind of thought,
you know, it's a type of Bronze Age sword that went out of use.
But then, as you say, you mention the Mines Gladius or the Gladius Hispaniensis.
And we're going to look at later examples as well.
I'm going to make the argument that they
didn't disappear, but we'll get to that later.
I was hoping for that.
Yeah.
But overall,
you know, this type of bronze leaf blade
was extremely popular in the Bronze Age.
Now, there's all different.
This is the Wilburton pattern.
There's the Ewart Park and various other ones that are usually named
after the place that that type was first discovered.
You'll find this type all over Europe.
But the first of the kind of the typographical, I think it is.
But the one that they sort of named the type after was found in Wilburton,
which is presumably somewhere in England from the name.
So they were clearly extremely widespread and popular in the Bronze Age.
And I think that's probably where we have
to start is why did that design come around with bronze as a material
specifically, because obviously the big change here that we're looking at is a
cast, relatively softer material bronze, and then later on iron and then steel.
And obviously those materials give different strengths and weaknesses,
but also they're made in a completely different way.
You know, bronze things are cast.
This might be some forging in terms of the hardening the edges.
Yeah, it's a cast object,
whereas an iron or steel object is forged, so it's made in a different way.
I think for any viewers who maybe aren't
aware of this, bronze swords, I've just got a different model here.
Carp's tongue type can be extremely complex.
And some of the cross sections and fullers and midribs and,
you know, some of the design features you get on Bronze Age swords,
we really don't see again for hundreds and hundreds of years,
in some cases until the 19th century, because they're so complex,
because you can cast them in a clay or stone mould in ways that would be way
too laborious in the Iron Age for people to make with iron blades.
So for the most part, iron blades are way simpler than Bronze Age blades were,
which might be an element behind answering the question.
I find that pretty interesting,
because when you think about the limitations of bronze, you know,
it being relatively soft, I mean, compared to iron, especially steel,
at least, I mean, I guess early iron, not so much.
Also, it depends on the alloy of bronze.
Of course, it depends. It always does.
So when it comes to those limitations,
I think the more thrusting oriented designs that you see make a lot of sense
to me personally, what's sometimes called rapier.
I hate when archaeologists use that term for those swords, but it's used.
So narrow blade, pretty thick central ridge,
which makes sense because that way you give it plenty of rigidity.
It's not going to bend because that's
that's mainly what's likely to happen with bronze swords.
They tend to bend, which is better than breaking.
But anyway, so that makes sense.
But a leaf blade is very different in that regard.
I mean, the one you have does have that thickened central ridge.
So it still does that.
But the leaf blade in and of itself, in that sense, is independent of that.
Your part that I used to have doesn't
have that, so it doesn't have the rigidity from that thicker center.
So in that case, it can bend more easily.
But they clearly consider that worthwhile.
And I'm guessing in that case, it's mainly a matter of very limited armor.
I mean, they had quite massive bronze armor.
The dendra armor is the main example
of that is basically plate armor from that type.
And it's quite tanky.
But generally, you wouldn't expect that much armor for the most part.
I mean, again, it depends.
The Greeks had quite a bit.
Well, and also what's interesting is,
you know, Mycenaean swords follow a different sort of evolutionary track
than northern European swords.
And so, you know, these types of swords found in Britain,
what's now Britain and France and Germany and Scandinavia,
these are a kind of different family of swords.
And these did make it down south.
But if we like the dendra Penelope, for example, would have been used
with shorter Mycenaean types of almost functionally more
like a little gladius, actually, or pugio.
So probably they are more thrusting swords in general.
As far as northern Europe is concerned anyway,
you know, if we're talking about Britain or Scandinavia or Germany,
we don't really know if they wore any form of armor.
We know that there were some types
of helmet for all we know they were wearing leather or other organic material armor.
And we know, for example, like I mentioned, the shields made of tree bark.
I mean, they they could have had some type
of breastplate made of wood or tree bark or whatever.
We just don't really know.
Yeah, we just we just don't really know.
We don't have the evidence for it.
But of course, absence of evidence isn't evidence necessarily of absence.
Organic materials, you can't expect much to be preserved.
Yeah, but I think generally if we look at this type of sword, as you say,
moving from the thrusting rapiers to this, the natural conclusion would be
that they're thinking about lopping bits off each other with these,
because you and I both know from using leaf blades of various sorts that they
function pretty much like a falchion or a machete, don't they?
They're good choppers, but they're not very nimble.
The point of balance is, I mean, you know,
this is a very accurate replica made by Neil Burridge by steel sword standards,
by later period sword standards, having a point of balance that's like 10
inches from the hand, really far forward, especially relative to the total length.
Yeah, exactly.
So this isn't a heavy or unwieldy sword.
No, they're quite overall.
Yeah, but the point of balance is, I mean, that's whilst you can stab with it.
This isn't, if we compare to other swords of other periods,
you don't pick this up and think, well, there's a, you know, there's a rapier.
You pick it up and think there's a there's a chopper.
It seems like a lot of people see the leaf blade as particularly good for thrusting.
Like I see it as primarily optimized for
cutting, even though it is a cut and thrust blade, no doubt about it.
But some people think that the point of it, no pun intended, is mainly thrusting.
And it's an interesting thought, because I don't think it's really wrong as such.
With a thrust, you produce a much broader wound because it widens so much.
Right. So it really tears soft tissue open.
Right.
But of course, because it broadens so much, there's much more resistance.
So it's not going to penetrate as deeply as a narrow blade.
I mean, there's there's a reason why rapiers do so well
in the thrust with their super narrow blade for the most part.
Right. And this is a very different take on it.
So
what's what's better?
What do you want? Is a deeper thrust better or a shallower
thrust that produces a larger wound, which also doesn't get stuck as easily?
Right. What's your take on that?
I think you covered it all.
Is that, you know, do you want to penetrate through things?
I mean, it's very clear that you develop something with the cross section
of a rondel dagger or an estoc if you want to punch through mail, for example.
That's a very specific type of point.
But then we've got to mention spears.
And one thing that I can't help thinking
with these leaf blades is we think of these as a sort of thing by themselves.
That's a sort of, wow, amazing invention, a sword that's leaf bladed.
But we forget that leaf blades had existed on spears for a long, long time.
That's right.
You could say that what they've actually done is they've made an elongated spear
head and put it on a short grip instead of a shaft.
So you could flip it around and say, well,
why do spears have leaf shaped blades? Right.
And presumably the answer is nothing to do with cutting.
It's to make a bigger hole in the thing that you're stabbing.
And sometimes you do want to limit over penetration.
That's why you have on a boar spear,
you have the luxury of wings or whatever.
In some cases, you absolutely do want to limit that.
And also to have the ability, I presume, to push the enemy away.
Like if you stab them and to prevent them from keeping coming,
you can actually control them and actually push them.
And that's going to work quite well
because it's not going to really keep going past a certain point.
There's a funny thing about rapiers as
well, that I think most people think of rapiers as being very long and narrow
with a small point, but looking at antique rapiers.
And I've seen that they've got a group
of them in the Royal Armouries, actually, in the storerooms.
There are a family of rapiers which have a little leaf.
Oh, that's right.
I've seen that. I mentioned that to you before.
Yeah.
On one hand, you could say so there's this kind of stramatonia,
I think it's called a type of sort of tip cut.
And, you know, if you're aiming at the inside of someone's leg,
artery, side of the neck, artery, this type of stuff, you're more likely to open them
up than if it was just a small, you know, very narrow, non-cutting tip on a rapier.
So it could be for that.
Or is it to make a more dangerous hole when you stab?
We don't know.
And, you know, you look at arrows, you look at spearheads.
We've got a whole family of weapons which
only thrust that they're not cutting, at least not cutting it in the way
that the sword would, not chopping.
When with those, the leaf shaped tip can
only be to make a bigger channel when the thing goes in.
So I think maybe maybe we don't have to choose one or the other.
Maybe it's both.
Maybe they're like, well, it makes a bigger hole that way and it makes a bigger
Yeah, it is sort of.
Yeah, it is maximizing wound size.
That you can definitely say either way
against armor, not so good.
I mean, if you were to thrust into mail with a leaf blade
because it tapers like that, it would break the rings open.
It would lever them quite effectively and open them up.
Then you're not going to get very far.
Like it doesn't really help you if you
destroy the rings, if you only get like a fingernails length into the target.
And you mentioned falchions and in a way,
when you look at the profile of a leaf blade, you can sort of imagine two falchions
spine to spine, if you arrange them a certain way, if you morph them a little bit.
That's kind of what you have.
Yeah, I mean, that's a very extreme case.
Yeah, we want to go for a hugely extreme example.
And I mean, obviously, this is a different type of sword for a different period.
And I've made the argument this isn't
an anti-armor sword because the surviving
originals of these, of which this blade is very closely modeled on the Cognus falchion.
They're thin, they're really, really thin,
thin like a machete for chopping small branches and saplings.
So it's going to be very effective against flesh, horses,
potentially cloth armors like gambesons and things like this.
But really, it's not going to be very effective against even mail.
It's not going to be effective at all against plate.
I've made the argument that these are
swords for knights to chop up levied peasants with, basically.
And I think, you know, yeah, it would be effective on a horse as well.
And yeah, you can hit someone very hard.
But like you say, in terms of the basic function of delivering
a lot of cutting power out near the center of percussion,
they're achieving a similar goal, but with a slightly different shape.
Yeah. I mean, generally for most blades, where the center of percussion is,
usually that's the widest part of the blade, on a leaf blade, typically.
You have some blades that stay pretty wide throughout,
where the center of percussion is further out and whatnot.
But generally, you maximize the cutting power because the wider it is,
the more mass you have to begin with, but also the wider the blade is,
the more gradually you can taper it to the edge.
It can be a really effective cutter.
A lot of it, I suspect, is just cultural norms of the time.
Yeah, so the Greek Xiphos is an interesting one because
within its own period,
it seems to have been very much considered a cut and thrust sword.
Generally speaking, the Greek Xiphos is bigger than the Roman Gladius.
It's a longer sword
and it's got that more accentuated leaf type shape.
As far as I'm aware, really, the Greek and Roman swords,
let's be clear, the original Roman sword was the Greek Xiphos.
So what they were using before the Gladius,
the Gladius Hispaniensis was the Greek sword.
In fact, some of the best surviving
examples we've got of the Greek Xiphos are actually from southern Italy.
I think that in its own time was considered a cut and thrust sword.
And they are quite pointy, much like the Gladius.
And the reason I say that is because in contrast, we've got the Copis or Machaira
or in Spain, we could compare it to the Falcata.
And it's interesting that in period sources,
they regard those swords often shown in the hands of Persians
and other enemies as well, actually, as sort of really like beast mode choppers.
Yeah.
So they're kind of like, you know, it's a giant cookery.
It's taking it to the absolute max.
And, you know, I think this is a period where, yeah,
if we look at hoplites or at least if we look at well-equipped hoplites,
then, you know, they've got a bronze helmet,
they've got a bronze cuirass, later on a line of thorax.
They've got a bronze covered large shield.
They're very well armoured.
But a lot of the people they were fighting
against really had minimal armour, cloth armour at best, you know, a lot of the time.
The Persians, for example, not to say that all Persians lacked armour,
but most of the Persian army seems to be very lightly armoured compared to the Greeks.
And so I think in that context,
very powerful chopping swords are like this.
And again, if we bring this to northern
Europe in the Bronze Age are a very quick way of putting someone out of action.
I think a lot of people fixate on
thrusting, the thrusting point being more fatal,
whether we're talking about rapiers or
later 19th century cavalry or going back to the Romans.
But as we know from so many written sources,
someone who's stabbed very often doesn't really go down or doesn't stop fighting
back in a way that if you lop part of them off, then they do immediately stop fighting back.
Thrusts have high lethality,
but low stopping power, unless it goes in the head or something or in the spine.
Yeah. Whereas a powerful chop into a neck or
an arm tends to immobilise people, even if they survive, you know,
even if they lose an arm. They don't fight effectively anymore.
Yeah, exactly.
So it mechanically stops them rather than sort of medically stops them later on.
And you could compare this, I'm sure,
to gunshot gun calibers and everything else.
So I wonder if these swords were particularly popular, these relatively long,
for bronze anyway, leaf blades were very popular in northern Europe
because most people didn't have any form of armour.
So a quick way of taking them out is with a very powerful chop.
And then we've got to factor in the shields and the spears as well.
So how the shields and spears, you know, spears were everywhere.
They're probably the primary weapon for most people.
And obviously, everybody at least intends to have a shield.
That doesn't mean they necessarily always have a shield in hand.
So they might lose it or might break or whatever.
But I think how these interact with the shields might be interesting as well.
I wonder if these are better at destroying shields as well.
Yeah, I mean, are they easier to remove from a shield?
Yeah, maybe, maybe you don't want to.
Yeah, if you chop into I mean, it depends on what it is.
If it's if it's metal reinforced, it's not an issue.
But if it's just wood or wooden leather or hide or something,
then it might get stuck and that could be a problem.
Maybe a leaf blade does it less.
I mean, I don't really see why it would,
but maybe it would have to go in deep, isn't it?
So I think I think it's in that sense.
If you thrust. Yeah.
I mean, you look at those Bronze Age rapiers, they're super thin.
And in fact, funny enough,
archaeologically, we have loads of them which are broken or damaged.
So we've got bent ones.
We've got snapped ones, a lot of them because they the early ones,
at least, are only connected by a line of rivets here with much tack.
They're sheared off.
And you can you can it's funny because we
look at them and go, well, that's clearly a thrusting weapon.
But I can think of at least one example
in the London Museum found archaeologically in London
where you can actually see the rivets
had been torn out of the bronze in such a way because it clearly hit.
Now, the problem is we get into was this
ritually destroyed because obviously often Bronze Age swords and Iron Age
swords were sometimes deliberately broken and then thrown into a river or whatever
or buried or put in a cremation.
So it's possible it was deliberately done.
We see ones we've talked about edge
damage before and we see the ones with lots of edge damage.
Is that combat or is it them
destroying the weapon before then burying it?
But it's possible that, you know,
it's human instinct, I think, a lot of the time to just hit,
even if you've got a savvy thing to just sort of do this.
So it's possible it was someone who was just like, well, yeah,
I've got this bronze rapier, but I'm panicking smack.
Oh, the blade just snaps off.
Yeah, that's the thing.
We tend to ascribe a lot more rationality than people have.
There are muskets found
that have like three charges in them where someone just panicked and just kept
ramming another ball out and didn't even fire another one.
It's people do weird things sometimes.
I wonder if these big long leaf blades were so popular at the time just because
they're a quick fire way, a bit kind of like a shotgun approach,
just really taking someone out really quickly.
But it is interesting to me that in
Southern Europe and the sort of Levant and North Africa and stuff,
we tend to get usually, usually shorter, more thrusting models of sword.
And this has to have some sort of relationship with armour and shields.
Possibly these were found to be good against
spears.
We know that in Northern Europe they weren't, at least most of the time,
they weren't using particularly big shields.
Whereas if you go to Southern Europe,
it seems that on average the shields are bigger.
So if you're using smaller Taj sort of sized shields,
then generally speaking, that goes in collaboration with a longer blade.
And, you know, again, I think there's a I think there's some
kind of relationship between the type of shields, type of armour,
type of sword being used.
But in terms of.
Them going out of use, which is where we started this video,
so clearly they did hang around into the Iron Age, and I would say the latest
clear survival, as you say, is in the Greek Xiphos and then
with the early forms of the Roman mines, Claudius, for example.
And clearly that flair is designed to give you still got a pointy blade,
but you've got enhanced cutting ability.
And as you say, this any kind of flair at the end is going
to take the mass distribution further from your hand like an axe,
but therefore cut more effectively, just like a cookery, just like a falchion.
So this is a recurring theme we see throughout the world, throughout history.
Even if the end product doesn't look
exactly like that, the theory is kind of the same, isn't it?
And that was the first thought that I when I thought about this,
you know, what would be potential reasons why they mostly fell out of favour?
And that would be to think of the increase in armour.
So at a certain point, like, I mean,
you see that generally in swords in the early Middle Ages, you still have mostly
cutting oriented swords and then they become more and more thrust centric as
you get more and more plate and all that.
But of course, they still had cutting and chopping blades of various kinds.
They still had falchions.
They still had other types.
And
it's also it's not like a leaf blade can't
thrust, depending on exactly how how pronounced you make the curvature.
And there's so many things that go into that.
But I feel like just the armour itself is probably not enough to explain that.
Also, because, again, not everybody always had armour.
It became more and more common, even for commoners.
But still, not everybody would have had it.
So you could still make an argument for a chopping oriented blade.
But for some reason, it just wasn't that much of a thing anymore.
And already in the early Middle Ages,
when you still had cutting oriented blades, you didn't really have leaf blades anymore.
Right. So that's odd.
I think the material always has to be considered.
And I think if we if we compare like with like rather than going on,
if we stay in a narrow period of history in a narrow geography.
So if we look at northern Europe,
northwestern Europe in the shift from the bronze into the Iron Age,
we the one thing to mention, of course, is we do have other bronze swords,
which aren't leaf blades. Yeah.
And so in the late Bronze Age,
we do actually start to see parallel parallel edged swords and things
like this carps tongue and stuff like that.
So that's the first thing.
So there isn't necessarily a kind of black and white switch.
But secondly, if you've got an iron sword,
there are certain it's very clear that iron blades started to be made longer.
Not that they have to be,
but they could be made longer than a bronze sword for a couple of reasons.
One, because it seems that
well, for a start, iron is lighter.
So so bronze is, I think, about 15 percent heavier than iron.
And so that's for its size heavier.
But secondly, if you make the blade longer.
But you have a leaf blade,
but it's iron and it's not yet sprung steel.
The iron has to have a certain amount of thickness to it.
Otherwise it will just bend too easily.
And in fact, of course, we have these famous sources.
I think it's Julius Caesar referring to the to the Celtic swords,
to the Gallic swords bending.
If you make a long iron sword and it's just essentially mild steel,
it will keep bending.
And of course, if you've made it flared at the end,
it's going to be even more like that because you pull that mass out of the tip.
So I think the material plays a strong part here.
And it's interesting, I think,
that the iron blades which retain the leaf shape,
the Xiphos and later on the early Gladius are relatively short.
So that length isn't an issue, whereas it's clear that in northwest Europe,
they, for whatever reason, wanted their blades to be longer.
The interesting thing when it comes to the material is that there wasn't really much
of a revival later when they pat steel, even in the Renaissance,
when, of course, they were looking back at antiquity.
So that's when you would think, oh, there might be some kind of revival.
The thing, of course, we have to keep in mind here is we
might be attributing too much deliberate choice here to that.
Like the question of why did they not bring that back?
Back then, if you asked someone, they might have been, why would we?
We have these swords, you know, like it's not always.
You can't always expect people to always keep bringing things back or,
for example, to invent something earlier than they did.
And just, well, they just didn't, you know, for whatever reason.
Yeah, although, I mean, they did to some degree.
So first of all, if we fast forward to us now in the 21st century.
Yeah, of course, the leaf blade has come back
in movies and in modern replicas.
So if you want to buy, you know, an Angus trim leaf blade,
you can go and buy one right now or at least go on a waiting list for,
you know, we've got Lord of the Rings and we've got various fantasy.
I mean, I remember back in
the 90s when I was getting into, you know, Games Workshop, Warhammer stuff.
Leaf blades were really popular.
It was seen as an elven style of blade, I think, at that point.
And yeah, leaf blades were definitely kind of
embraced by by fantasy art.
But that does have a basis in at least the 19th century.
And so there's a few examples to mention.
So first of all, you've got the French
gladius or cabbage chopper, as it's sometimes known.
And that's essentially, it's actually a late 18th century type of sword.
It's also a Napoleonic era sword.
But most that you find surviving are later 1800s versions.
And they are leaf blades.
So why did they choose a leaf blade?
Well, I think there were a number of things.
One, it was a period of national revival in France.
And so they were looking for things which they perceived as sort of Gallic.
But also in the same way,
they're choosing certain helmet styles and other things as well.
So I think partly because it was seen as
Gallic, partly also because it was seen as Roman.
It was alluding to the, you know,
that it's very clearly modeled on their idea of what the gladius was.
And, you know, he was, you know, Napoleon was an emperor.
And so were the Napoleons that came after him.
So they were just kind of revival of imperial kind of
sort of symbols.
But also mechanically and having used them for this,
they work really well for chopping stuff up.
And of course, that is an artillery sidearm, you know.
So the reason that the gunners carried
these sidearms was largely for chopping up wood and for clearing spaces so they
could have a clear field of fire to operate their artillery or making,
you know, defensive works and stuff like this.
So having something that's a weapon,
but you can also chop wood with, quite useful.
And they are very effective for chopping.
They work well.
But in addition to that, I've got an example of a sword here.
And I don't know if you know this type of sword,
but this is actually a British sword that came around in the
towards the end of the Napoleonic Wars by a guy called Crosser,
who was an English sword maker.
And if you look at, so it's a sabre, so it's a pipe back blade.
So we've got a rod section along here and the rod section continues like a midrib
all the way to the tip.
But if we just isolate that blade there, you will see some pattern.
Now, this is based on, this is very clearly based on or inspired by the Turkish
sword, sometimes known as Pala or Kilic.
So what this actually is, it's not inspired by an earlier Celtic leaf blade.
It's actually inspired by Turkish swords,
because at this time there was a big rise in Orientalism,
as they used to refer to it due to the campaigns in what was formerly or still
currently, in some cases, the Ottoman Empire, Egypt, this kind of stuff.
And actual Ottoman swords were very
highly prized and often carried by high ranking officers.
And so when they came to design this style of blade, they kind of went, well,
you know, we want a sword that's basically a sabre but can thrust well,
but creates a bigger hole basically when it goes in.
So it's essentially it's a spear tip with this big sort of flange at the back,
sometimes referred to as a quill point.
But the end result is something slightly akin to a leaf blade.
Obviously, it's not as wide, but it increases the amount of cutting
inertia, momentum you've got up here, but still leaves you with a good thrusting
point there. It's a really interesting example.
I haven't seen this type before.
That's quite interesting.
Yeah. And, you know, this is a this is a one that dates to about 1830.
But the earlier ones, the Napoleonic ones,
which I don't have an example of in hand at the moment, are wider.
So if you imagine the sort of 1796 light
cavalry sabre, they're that wide.
But with that style point on them, they're really, really cool looking things.
I have to say from personal experience,
they're quite fragile because they've got a mid rib and then very thin steel
either side of that so that they're quite easily damaged.
But you can have a really like razor sharp
edge on them because they're super thin.
And then finally, we've got World War Two
example of this, which some people watching might know is a smatchit.
Now, it has been claimed.
So this was used by the British commandos in World War Two.
Some people claim that this is based on the Welsh sword, the Welsh Fusiliers
sword of World War One. In my opinion,
it's probably more inspired actually by Filipino Barongs.
When you actually put this side by side with a Filipino Barong, it's reverent.
Yeah, I mean, even down to the the Welsh
Fusiliers sword is double edged sword with a with a mid rib like that.
Whereas this is a single edged.
It's actually only edged towards the tip on the back of it.
It's got a long edge up here and this is completely blunt right up here.
So that is far more similar to a Philippine Barong.
And it was designed by Fairbairn as in the Fairbairn Sykes dagger.
And Fairbairn before he was
before he was training British special forces in World War Two,
he was in the Shanghai police based out in China.
So he would have been very familiar with Asian weapons in general.
He probably would have seen these used as weapons in his policing career.
Barongs that is.
So, yeah, I'm pretty sure this is based on a Barong.
But those are all forms of leaf blade, in my opinion.
And like you say, we could look at certain forms of falchion and say if you put two
falchions back to back, it's a bit like a leaf blade.
But I think there's even more explicit
examples from the 18th, 19th and 20th centuries.
Yeah. And if we include fantasy, the 21st century.
So when it comes to the fantasy leaf blades, if I was asked,
are leaf blades overrated in fantasy,
I would actually say, if anything, they're underrated in real life.
Kind of like if I wanted to
design a sword that maximizes cutting power as much as possible.
You know, there is, of course, a number of ways you can do that.
Most of the work is done in the cross section, really.
But there's also some in the profile, of course, making it wider and all that.
And recurves, recurve edges cut really well,
especially things like fabric, you know, fabric, armor, stuff like that.
They add a very pronounced slice.
And again, they widen the blade where it counts, where you've got the impact.
Right.
So this is really the ideal way to maximize all of that.
So just on paper, as a like looking at it as a design
of itself, it's quite outstanding, in my opinion.
Yeah, I mean, I completely agree.
And, you know, the people have made good
quality, you know, like Angus Trim, for example, have made good quality leaf blades.
They cut like beasts.
I mean, they really perform well.
And you've got the advantage of still having a good point for thrusting.
You've got two great cutting edges.
And of course, you've you could view it
essentially as a broad, a very broad bladed sword.
But you've taken away the mass from the part of the blade where you don't need it.
So actually, what you've done is you've made a really broad sword,
but reduced its overall mass, which is, you know, it's a win win, isn't it?
I think looking at the real world,
the historical world rather than modern recreations and fantasy,
I think we get the same result from certain other blades.
One of those would be, for example, the Barong, which just they just cut
fantastically, but also the Kukri, for example, or the Falcata or the Kopis Makara.
There are these swords which tend to be
single edged, which because of their curve forward and their belly at the front,
like a bolo, cut really fantastically well.
And they're still pointy.
You can even say the Turkish Yatagan to an extent.
So anything which tilts forward.
Yeah, so it kind of comes back to what you're saying, like
this is a little bit like two falchions stuck together.
Whenever we min max anything, you know, there's no question if we're cutting
stationary targets, if we're doing a test cutting video or, you know,
you just want to chop the most.
This is an awesome sword for making big holes with thrust, big cuts.
However, imagine you're 1v1, you're in a duel with a shield.
Are you going to use the big tip heavy,
very powerful chopper or are you going to use something which is a bit more
balanced towards the hand? It's still good enough.
But, you know, it's comparing the lighter,
more nimble a sword that can still cut and can still thrust
with the one that's been maxed out in one way or another.
In a melee, you very well might choose an axe.
In a duel, you probably won't choose an axe.
You know, so who knows?
If you want to put it in RPG terms,
you could sort of shift the stats around because even with that,
like not every leaf blade is made the same.
Some are much more pronounced than others.
Some only have a fairly slight leaf shape.
And then that's just the profile.
Now you're also working with the cross section and things like distal taper.
I mean, the distal taper can heavily
counteract the effect of the profile taper, right?
If you make it substantially thicker at the base, now it may not even be as tip
heavy, but then chances are you have quite a thin blade up top,
which, again, is fantastic for cutting, but it's not going to be as durable.
So depending on what you prefer, you can always kind of
mess with it and tweak it a little bit here and shift it around in such a way.
So there are many ways to make a leaf blade, right?
Which is also part of why I find it so
interesting that they were not as popular anymore in later times.
Something can still function like a leaf blade, in other words,
have all the advantages of a leaf blade without necessarily looking the same as this.
Right.
And so, you know, the example of things like cookries and
single edged blades, which still have this flare.
So if we cut this blade down the midrib,
actually, there's a whole bunch of swords and knives that from around the world
that do actually look like one half of this leaf blade.
So flipping that around, given that whether you're casting or whether you're
forging, in other words, casting in bronze or forging in iron and steel,
it is generally speaking easier to make a single edged blade than a double edged blade.
We could reverse engineer the question
and say, why did they make double edged leaf blades?
Why didn't they just make what was essentially like a single edged,
you know, what what became like the copious essentially or a cookery or a Yatagan?
Why, why, why did they make these double edged?
And then
having thought about this before, my my answer would be perhaps we need
to look at the material again, perhaps if the shift here is from bronze to iron.
And I'm not saying it necessarily is.
It could be that bronze edges get damaged,
dulled more quickly and two edges is really advantageous because we don't see
an awful lot. There are bronze, there are single edged bronze swords.
But it is interesting to me that most like overwhelmingly bronze age swords are
double edged. Right. Why? Why?
I don't know.
Whereas, you know, when we get into the Iron Age, we start to see a much greater
number of single edged blades as far as I can see.
Maybe that's because with casting, you can cast two edges.
You're just pouring molten lead into a mold.
Whereas once you're forging things, well, it's like, well, I forged one edge out.
That'll do.
I don't know.
Yeah, particularly also because making it single edged would sort of counteract some
of the downsides of the material, it being softer.
You can just make a thicker spine and that's going to give it more rigidity
and going to make it less likely to bend.
And they literally do that with Wootz blades in the Ottoman Empire.
The Turks do that.
The Indians do that with almost a T section blade.
So you've got this stiffening rod or rib at the back.
And then the rest of it, because Wootz wasn't usually spring tempered,
it was usually just edge hardened.
So much like a Japanese blade, if you bend it, it will stay bent.
So you need that rigidity of that rod up the back to keep it from bending all the time.
So, yeah, I think the materials play a huge part.
Yes.
Yeah, I think it's likely a number of factors.
I mean, when isn't it?
But like material is probably a factor.
And with that may very well also be a cultural tradition.
There may be certain ideas that they develop when working with one material
that just kind of solidified as kind of the standard and stuck around,
even when they later had a different material where it didn't apply anymore.
But they were just used to it at that point.
Right. So that's possible.
Then there is, again, the factor of armor.
The more armor you have, the more you might want
a narrower, thicker, stiffer thrusting blade, perhaps.
And then
there's also just fashion, things like that.
Sometimes there's just not really a specific reason for something.
Sometimes you have straight, sometimes you have curved.
And there's oftentimes not really a clear case of this is better than that.
It often tells you more about the people than about the design is what I would say.
But what do you think about that?
Do you have anything to add or do you disagree?
Yeah, I mean, I think the whole I think it's really, really complex topic.
And, you know, despite the fact I've shown
some examples of where I think that forms of leaf blade did survive into the age
of steel weapons until quite recently.
It is interesting to me that if we take medieval, late medieval swords, for example,
we get them trying to achieve similar goals, in other words,
having a greater cutting potential, but also being able to thrust,
but ending up with completely different shapes.
Why didn't they ever, as far as I can think,
during the medieval period, ever really have steel leaf blades?
Why did, you know, for example, when we start to get more tapered blades,
why is it that a type 14 or a type 15 or a type 18,
why do they have their broadest points at the base and then taper up like this?
And I've had I've tried to answer this question in my own videos in the past.
And only one possible reason I could say,
apart from things like weight distribution and things like this,
potential advantages is perhaps to try and fail safe the material.
So if you are fighting in an environment
where people you might be having to parry a poleaxe swing at your head or you might
be hitting a steel helmet, then you want a sword which is as
robust at the base as possible, because if it was narrow,
that's where it's most likely to break.
But all of that aside,
given that we know that modern made steel blades,
which are essentially replicating that, but longer on a medieval hilt,
they look super cool and they work really well.
So why didn't they do it?
Well, you know, I guess there are many
things in history we can say, why didn't they do X, Y or Z?
They just didn't.
Now we look back at history at the totality.
Like we look at all the different designs and oh, why didn't they do that?
For one, at a given time, depending on when and where,
they wouldn't have known anywhere near as much about what came before as we do now.
So they weren't aware of the entire catalog
of options, particularly when it comes to things from all around the world,
from all kinds of time periods and everything.
They would have been exposed to some,
but they wouldn't have had this grand overview that we have now,
this sort of top down view.
Then also there's so much stuff and nothing is perfect.
There's so much good stuff.
They can only make so much at a time.
Like they can't have like the entire,
the world's entire arsenal in just the mid 15th century or whatever.
So, of course, there were so many things that they didn't do, right?
That doesn't necessarily mean that the things they didn't do in a certain,
at a certain time, in a certain place were bad.
I often wonder when they when they
occasionally came across one of these in the medieval period,
what they thought about it, why, you know, why are they going to go,
well, that's a pretty good shape, that'll work, that'll work pretty well.
Or, you know, I just I think it's a fascinating, I suspect.
In fact, I know this from the later period.
I've seen an 1800s archaeological report
clearly with a drawn picture of a bronze sword that was found during a dig.
And they describe it as a Roman sword.
So it's very likely actually they went, oh, well, there you go.
That's a Roman. That's a Roman gladius, you know.
So
but then why didn't they try to replicate it?
They were so obsessed with the Renaissance.
Right. Why, you know, it's a good question.
Why doesn't why doesn't a Cinque Terre,
which is the kind of, you know, archetypal Northern Italian
civilian Renaissance sidearm, why doesn't it look more like a gladius?
Yeah. Why they didn't do that in the actual
Renaissance when they were so obsessed with this stuff?
And you know what?
This kind of thing is what I think is important to just acknowledge when we don't
know for sure, just be like, hey, here's some speculation.
Here's some possible reasons.
But we don't know for sure.
Nobody can really
be 100 percent sure.
I mean, maybe there's somebody who has
studied this topic in depth, like absolute laser focus on leaf blades,
who has a really well developed hypothesis.
Maybe. But that's what we can come up with.
Yeah. And my strong belief is there's no
simple answer. If there was a simple answer, we would have come up with it.
Yeah, it's like I think it's all of the things
we've mentioned and probably five other things we haven't thought of.
All combined together.
But
it is a fantastic.
I think it's one of the most beautiful
sword shapes that's ever been designed in history.
And I think the fact that it has been
revived in fantasy art is evidence of that.
It's kind of like you look at it, you go, yeah, that looks really cool.
Let's stick it on a long sword hilt and have a high elf wielding it.
And it's like, yeah, that looks badass.
And it does.
That's where we can that's the conclusion we can draw.
Leaf blades are badass.
Well,
thanks for chiming in on that, Matt.
And I hope you enjoyed it.
Let me know what you think.
And until next time, take care.
