Testing Milton Friedman: Free Markets - Full Video
The late economist Milton Friedman was one of the boldest and most provocative figures
of our time.
He was born in 1912, making this the 100th anniversary of his birth.
Milton Friedman received the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1976, and as a professor at the
University of Chicago, he transformed a generation of economists.
It's safe to say his work influenced the entire field.
He was an author and an advisor to several presidents.
His ideas won him millions of advocates and opponents all over the world.
While some place a greater emphasis on financial equality, Friedman advocated economic liberty.
In 1980, he shared his ideas with millions of TV viewers in the landmark PBS series Free
to Choose.
Hi, I'm Emily Rooney, and here, surrounded by images of the University of Chicago, Milton's
intellectual home, we'll engage four distinguished guests in a discussion of the relevance of
Friedman's ideas today.
Major funding was provided by CME Group.
For more than 160 years, through continuous innovation in trading and technology, CME
Group products have provided businesses with the opportunity to manage risk amid the changing
financial landscape.
BP is dedicated to helping meet America's energy needs.
Our investments support jobs across the country and reaffirm our commitment to the U.S. that
began over a century ago.
Additional funding was provided by John A. Gunn and Cynthia Frey Gunn, the Melvin S.
Cohen Foundation, FedEx Corporation, the Ellie Phillips Family Foundation, and Corett Foundation.
Milton Friedman believed free markets were the key to economic prosperity.
He also argued that free markets were the surest path to both personal and political
freedom.
It was these very opportunities that prompted Friedman's parents to immigrate to America.
That story of opportunity was part of Friedman's 1980 landmark series Free to Choose.
But do Friedman's ideas still hold up today?
Are they still relevant?
Those are the questions we will pose to our panelists today.
Joining me are Kevin Murthy, professor of economics at the University of Chicago, Brad
DeLong, professor of economics at the University of California at Berkeley, Raghu Rajan, professor
of finance at the University of Chicago's Booth School of Business, and Danny Roderick,
professor of political economy at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government.
Welcome to all of you.
All right.
But first, here are some thoughts from Milton Friedman himself in 1980, introducing his
theory on the power of the market and the allure it held for his immigrant parents.
For the immigrants who were welcomed by this statue, America was truly a land of opportunity.
They poured ashore in their best clothes, eager and expectant, carrying what little
they owned.
They were poor, but they all had a great deal of hope.
Once they arrived, they found, as my parents did, not an easy life, but a very hard life.
There were many rewards for hard work, enterprise, and ability.
Life was hard, but opportunity was real.
There were few government programs to turn to, and nobody expected them.
But also, there were few rules and regulations.
There were no licenses, no permits, no red tape to restrict them.
They found, in fact, a free market, and most of them thrived on it.
This is exactly the same kind of a factory that my mother worked in when she came to
this country for the first time at the age of 14, almost 90 years ago.
And if there had not been factories like this here then, at which she could have started
to work and earned a little money, she wouldn't have been able to come.
And if I existed at all, I'd be a Russian or a Hungarian today instead of American.
Of course, she didn't stay here a long time.
She stayed here while she learned the language, while she developed some feeling for the country,
and gradually she was able to make a better life for herself.
Similarly, the people who are here now, they are like my mother.
A place like this gives them a chance to get started.
They're not going to stay here very long or forever.
On the contrary, they and their children will make a better life for themselves as they
take advantage of the opportunities that a free market provides to them.
But in the past 50 years, we've been squandering that inheritance by allowing government to
control more and more of our lives instead of relying on ourselves.
We need to rediscover the old truths that the immigrants knew in their bones, what economic
freedom is, and the role it plays in preserving personal freedom.
Raghu, Milton Friedman speaks of the virtues of these sweatshops, of these factories, you
know, the family history there.
But if you walked into any one of those shops now, these aren't people who are here for
a short time and they're going to move on.
They're lifers.
They would say to Milton Friedman, what are you talking about?
They could, but I mean, I think you need places where people who don't have skills can start.
Hopefully they go on from there to better places.
If you're required to start with that these places have to be really well equipped, have
a lot of safety standards, they really can't get the first footing on the road to economic
progress.
I think that's important.
When you look at some of these third world countries, people don't get jobs if those
jobs require the kinds of safety standards that we have in first world countries.
That's why it sometimes pays to say, okay, let's reduce regulations a little bit here.
Let these people get on board.
Over time, they will demand better regulations.
Because weren't his parents the exception rather than the rule of moving on and getting
an education?
Well, look around the United States.
The level of regulation now, the safety standards, much better than anywhere else in the world.
Look at U.S. companies working in other parts of the world.
They are in some sense pressurized by people in the United States to have better standards
there.
And they are lifting standards there.
But to demand that of everybody right off the get-go will actually keep a lot of people
out of jobs that could, in the longer run, make them much better off.
On the other hand, Milton Friedman was also saying the virtues of no regulations when
his parents came to the country and he was saying, well, yeah, we actually need them.
We need them certainly in the factories.
I guess the key is we need to strike a balance between taking care of things where regulation
can work and where regulation reaches too far.
And as Raghu said, I think it can reach too far and really squelch opportunity rather
than foster opportunity.
But you also have to remember, and I think Raghu was right, people move on.
And it's not just them that move on, but it's their children.
And the children of many people today who are very successful, went to college, are
people whose parents had far less opportunity.
You can look at all the Asian immigrants to the United States, many of whom are Indian
immigrants who came to the United States, who might own a convenience store.
And their children become doctors, lawyers, move on.
So that story that Milton told still holds true today.
And it's a big draw for people, not only because they themselves can move forward, but even
more so because it creates the opportunity for their children to move forward.
In some ways, I think the regulation, no regulations, cutting the joint, not cutting at the joint.
I think if we had Milton here today, he would say that what the sweatshop does not need
is an OSHA inspector coming through every month to see whether it meets requirement
at X, Y, Z, and W. What he would say is what the sweatshop needs is strict liability for
industrial accidents on the part of the manufacturer and a generous system of compensation for
industrial accidents in order to give the manufacturer who has the knowledge for how
to design a safe and productive workplace the incentive to design a safe and productive
workplace.
You don't need the OSHA, Milton would say, but you do need the liability system in order
to make the incentives lie where they ought to.
I think we all agree that we don't want to have the regulations in the United States
of 2012 and take them as a package and apply them to either in Hong Kong in 1980 or for
that matter in Ethiopia today, that these, what we see in the West as sweatshops are
really truly the first steps to increasing economic opportunity.
It's a first step of transformation when you take basically people off the farm, peasants,
and put them into urban areas where actually they do make a better living and that's why
they actually moved from the farm.
And the trick, and I think that's the difference between countries like Hong Kong and United
States in an early area that managed this transition, the trick is to get these simple
garment factories then to turn them into textile factories and then to chemicals and
then simple electronics and increasingly up in this stepping stone process of economic
development.
And there I think the government actually does have a role to play because in all of
these transitions there has been mixed economies that have achieved that.
Milton Friedman, as I was saying, in many ways we're kind of misstepping, we're not
taking the stepping stone, that we're squandering our inheritance.
What does he mean by that?
I think what he's worried is that in some sense we've, you get rich, people demand a
lot more and in that sense they demand safer working conditions, they demand better environments.
So for example one of the things you find as countries get richer is that they demand
more environmental improvement and that's a strong trend in that direction, that initially
as countries industrialize maybe the environment goes down but then people get richer, they
demand more.
What he's worried is that there's sort of a feedback effect, will we go too far?
And that very things that got us rich become imperiled by the regulations that we demand
because we're rich.
So there's kind of a push and pull there that I think he's focusing in on.
In 1980, Friedman, he's just lived through the 1970s, the world price of oil tripled
in 1973 and the immediate political reaction wasn't to say, oh oil is now an expensive
commodity, we need to let its price rise so that people have the right incentives to figure
out how to move to a more energy efficient economy.
The initial reaction was, well it's not fair that the oil companies make an awful lot of
money off of this.
And so throughout the 1970s with this bizarre and complicated regulatory regime during which
there was old oil and new oil and old oil was sold at a different lower price than new
oil and the whole thing got substantially bollocked up.
It's reacting against that kind of political climate in which the first reaction to a change
in supply is to do something to keep it from showing up as a change in price.
That's making Friedman fear that we were about to squander the advantages that the market
economy had given us.
So it wasn't just that, as Brad says, that there was some overshooting in the kind of
government regulations that were going in many ways in the extreme direction.
It was also that I think Milton Friedman was worried that whenever the government acted
in the interests of certain people that it would close off avenues of opportunity for
others, so that the workers who want better conditions for themselves might then prevent
others off the farm or from coming in and having the kinds of opportunities that they
had earlier.
So it wasn't, in his view, it wasn't just the shouldn't of government, that government
shouldn't, but it was also that couldn't in the sense that the government couldn't actually
act in the common interest in some sense.
And you have to think about who sets regulations, and that was a big issue that Milton Friedman
focused on. Often it's the big incumbents in an industry.
I mean, think about the airline industry, which was, clearly we had wonderful service
at that time.
We did.
But it was very expensive. Very few people traveled for some, but it wasn't a mass market
industry.
And what deregulation of that industry allowed was a whole set of new entrants to come in
who could cut price.
You wouldn't have seen Southwest flourish as it has done in those times.
And similarly, I think across the board, there are a number of industries which were over-regulated
in the 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s.
And in the 70s is when people started saying, this is perhaps a little too much.
We need to reduce regulations so as to increase growth.
Trucking was an example.
Airlines another example.
And at the end of it, there are mixed opinions about whether everybody likes what happened,
but by and large, it has helped the broad masses in the economy.
Yes, so I would add to that.
Milton was influenced a lot by his colleague, George Stigler, who realized a lot what we're
saying here, which is that once you get into regulation, even if people think of Milton
as sort of pro-business, but he recognized that business would be one of the first people
to take advantage of regulation, and they would use regulation to exclude their competitors,
to entrench their position in the business, and to do other things.
And he was very aware of that, that that was one of the things that would happen.
So he sort of saw regulation as it would end up being as opposed to what you might perceive
you could do.
And he had a very much, you know, be careful what you wish for, because it's going to bring
a lot of other things with it.
I'm not sure he could have foreseen what's happening here.
The wave of deregulations.
We had telecommunications, we had trucking, we had air travel, we had energy, we had finance.
I say we'd do four out of five have been good things.
Four or five have been good things.
I think the big puzzle here in some sense is looking at it from what Milton, from the
perspective of what Milton Friedman was saying and what we've been discussing here, there
are all these many ways in which government regulation can go wrong, yet which are the
most successful societies today in the world?
Which are the countries that have grown rich and wealthy?
These are the countries where actually the role of the government is much more important
than the poorer parts of the world.
These are the countries where public expenditures, government taxation, are much higher than
in the rest of the world.
In some sense, the lesson of history is that, broadly speaking, governments and markets
have expanded together rather than in opposition to each other.
I can't move off this segment before we bring up the issue of immigration.
I'm not sure Milton Friedman could have anticipated, although he saw what was happening, certainly
in the sweatshops and all across America in terms of people coming here.
Whether legal or illegal, the role that the immigrants have played in changing the face
of our economy.
I think Milton Friedman would say if you move someone in a sewer tunnel from south of the
U.S.-Mexico border to north today and let them stay there, you've just boosted their
lifetime income by half a million dollars without doing much, if any, damage to people
on the north.
That restrictions on human movement are, Friedman would say, one of the very biggest sources
of both inequality and inefficiency in the world today.
Just on these points, I don't think any of us dispute the fact that we need a balance.
It's not zero government and all markets, or all government and no markets, but getting
that balance is really very, very hard.
That's really what it's all about.
Take the one industry that I believe Brad doesn't think should be deregulated, finance.
Yes, we have seen some excesses there, and of course one can debate for a long time how
much was regulation or deregulation.
But imagine finance before it got deregulated, when instead of interest payments, we got
a toaster.
I do remember that.
That was also problematic.
So we need to know how we get the balance right.
All right.
Moving on here.
Back in 1980, Milton Friedman thought there was no better example of the power of the
market than the bustling city of Hong Kong.
Let's take a look.
If you want to see how the free market really works, this is the place to come.
Hong Kong, a place with hardly any natural resources.
About the only one you can name is a great harbor.
Yet the absence of natural resources hasn't prevented rapid economic development.
Ships from all nations come here to trade because there are no duties, no tariffs on
imports or exports.
The power of the free market has enabled the industrious people of Hong Kong to transform
what was once barren rock into one of the most thriving and successful places in Asia.
Aside from its harbor, the only other important resource of Hong Kong is people, over 4.5
million of them.
This thriving, bustling, dynamic city has been made possible by the free market, indeed
the freest market in the world.
The free market enables people to go into any industry they want, to trade with whomever
they want, to buy in the cheapest market around the world, to sell in the dearest market around
the world.
But, most important of all, if they fail, they bear the cost.
If they succeed, they get the benefit.
When a businessman faces trouble, a market threatens to disappear, or a new competitor
arises, there are two things he can do.
He can turn to the government for a tariff, or a quota, or some other restriction on competition,
or he can adjust and adapt.
In Hong Kong, the first option is closed.
Hong Kong is too dependent on foreign trade so that the government has simply had to adopt
a policy of complete non-interference.
That's tough on some individuals, but it's extremely healthy for the society as a whole.
In all this, the government of Hong Kong has played an important part, not only by what
it has done, but as much by what it has refrained from doing.
It has made sure that laws are enforced and contracts honored.
It has provided the conditions in which a free market can work.
Sometimes it looks like chaos, and so it is.
But underneath it's highly organized by the impersonal forces of a free marketplace.
So Kevin, what do you think his larger point was by going to Hong Kong?
What was the lesson for America?
I think, you know, probably that there was a lesson for America, but probably a broader
lesson, which is really that, and we kind of got into this in the last session, which
is matching the level of government involvement to your situation.
For example, if you contrast Hong Kong to a number of other countries around the world
where they have regulations that have the effect of forcing people, for example, to
go into the informal economy, because they have regulations that don't fit the economy.
So we talked earlier about, you know, there has to strike a balance.
Well, if you have a world in which a vast number of people are being forced to go to
the informal economy to avoid the regulation, I think you know which side of the balance
you're on.
That doesn't mean you have to be Hong Kong, but you have to be aware that you can go too
far.
And even if you're trying to do good things, like put in safety regulations and all kinds
of other things that you're requiring firms to do for their workers, if that means the
workers don't work there and they work someplace else in the informal economy, you've gone
too far.
And so I think that's the lesson that I would take away.
But Hong Kong is interesting.
It's interesting that Milton Friedman focuses on Hong Kong.
It is clearly, with the exception of the government's role in public housing, which has been extensive,
Hong Kong is a free market economy.
But there aren't that many other places you can go to to find that.
And if you can just go next door to Singapore, which is an economy that is equally dependent
on trade, has developed at an equally rapid pace, is roughly as rich as Hong Kong is,
you have a government that has behaved in a very different way.
In fact, the government has led in investing in new industries and diversifying the economy.
That's not to say that the Singaporean model is for everybody.
I agree with Kevin that all those countries have different circumstances.
But I think it would be wrong to say that a particular model that worked in Hong Kong
that is so reliant on the market and just basically says the government shouldn't do
anything to restructure economies necessarily fits all other countries.
Do you agree with that, Brad, that the non-interference of government is the key to the success of
Hong Kong?
I remember thinking back when I first saw it that it was a little too clever.
I was thinking not only of Hong Kong, but also of Singapore, and not only of Singapore,
but also of Calcutta, and the fact that the government of Hong Kong was the British Empire,
and that up until 1948, the ruling legal regimes in Hong Kong and in Calcutta were the same,
as they were both parts of the British Empire.
And yet, one, you have extraordinary development success, even by 1948.
And in the other, in Calcutta, you have a much more fraught and much less successful
situation, even though the underlying legal market order is the same.
One of the things you want to ask is how much competition played a role in Hong Kong as
opposed to the size of the government, and clearly an economy which is so exposed to
trade as Hong Kong was, unlike Calcutta, which is part of a bigger hinterland, a bigger country.
The other thing is, you have to be a little careful about Hong Kong.
There's a lot of control over land, which becomes a big source of the government's revenues.
And it's not entirely free, the way that land is actually maintained and sold.
So you have to be a little careful about going too far and calling it entirely free.
That said, I think the role of reducing the regulation on opening businesses, as opposed
to countries that have enormous amounts of regulations on how to start businesses, I
think that's one important lesson the world can learn from places like Hong Kong.
Free up the process for new companies to start.
Well, what about that?
On that point, I'll ask you about taxation, because Hong Kong taxes its corporations at
roughly half of what America does.
Is that part of the impetus for new business and corporations?
I'd say part, but I'd say a relatively small part.
I mean, we don't manage to tax to collect a lot of money from our taxes on corporations.
That's true.
But I do say I'm reminded of a paper Danny wrote about cashews in Mozambique quite a
while ago, about how the government of Mozambique decides it would be very good to encourage
its cashew processing industry.
And so passes laws to say that Mozambican cashew farmers aren't allowed to sell their
unshelled cashews to India, where there are existing Indian factories that could produce
them more cheaply.
And say that kind of micro-development decision by the government of Mozambique, whether it's
made out of a desire to actually help Mozambique grow faster, or just because certain politicians
have had cocktails with certain South African investors in local businesses, that's the
kind of thing that I think has broadly been destructive over the past hundred years.
And that's the kind of thing that Hong Kong avoided.
Are you as dismissive of the tax structure as Brad is?
I agree that actually taxes, I don't think, are the overwhelming determinant of industrial
development or where investments are made.
There are much, much more important factors, both in terms of how government-friendly,
the market-friendly, business-friendly the government is, as well as what the profit
opportunities are, which are really, of which taxes are only a small part.
If you're in a poor economy, where most of the people are in agriculture, you have very
few industry, the first entrepreneur that's going to invest in a garment plant faces inordinate
risks.
He doesn't know whether he's going to succeed, whether he's going to have the inputs that
he needs.
And in those kinds of environments, it's very important to encourage people to undertake
those kinds of investments.
Sometimes, as in the case of Hong Kong, the market incentives are enough.
But in many other cases, I think the government actually needs to nudge entrepreneurs by providing
them with some incentives, by providing them sometimes with a little bit of protection
from too much competition.
Because competition is great, but if you put a kid into a classroom with people whose abilities
are just a little bit better than his, maybe he will work harder.
But if you put him in a classroom with people who are four or five grades ahead of him,
he might just as well give up and say, you know, I will never succeed, given the difference.
So I think there's a lot of countries that have grown up very rapidly, Singapore, South
Korea, Taiwan, and China, of course, being a hugely important example, are countries
where governments have given market forces a gentle nudge, if you will, to make this
process go.
I think the difficult task there is when to bring in competition, and often countries
don't bring it in.
And those are the countries that don't grow.
Yes, they nudge, but they nudge too much.
They protect their producers, and they don't move on and open up to competition.
The ones that have been successful, and you read backwards, it looks like they did wonderful
things with the government, then they opened up at the right time.
Now there are these fantastic countries like Singapore, Malaysia, Taiwan, and so on.
But it is an experiment that has not worked a lot of the time.
I do want to go back to one point about Hong Kong.
Milton talked about contracts being enforced, that courts were important, police is important,
roads are important.
In other words, the point that Danny made earlier, there has to be an equal development
of the government enforcement process in a way that is effective, not too burdensome.
That's what also helps growth of the economy.
We're going to hear more from Milton on Hong Kong, because he actually didn't at all shy
away from the ugly side of Hong Kong either, the abject poverty, the slums, but still,
he believed even poor people were ultimately better served by a free market economy.
Here's Milton again.
Of course, many of the people who pour into Hong Kong will end up in conditions that most
of us in the West would find appalling.
Hong Kong is very far from utopia.
It has its slums, its crime, its desperately poor people.
But the people are free.
That's after all why so many of them have come here.
Here, they have the freedom and the opportunity to better themselves, to improve their life,
and many succeed.
There's appalling poverty in Hong Kong, it's true.
But the conditions of the people have been getting better over time.
And that poverty, appalling to us, because we're accustomed to much higher standards
of life, is not poverty as viewed by most of the people in the world.
It's a poverty to which they would aspire, a state of affairs that they would like to achieve.
There is an enormous amount of poverty in the world everywhere.
There is no system that's perfect.
There's no system that's going to eliminate completely poverty in whatever sense.
The question is, which system has the greatest chance?
Which is the best arrangement for enabling poor people to improve their life?
And on that, the evidence of history speaks with a single voice.
I do not know any exception to the proposition that if you compare like with like, the freer
the system, the better off the ordinary poor people have been.
When people are free, they are able to use their own resources most effectively, and
you have a great deal of productivity, a great deal of opportunity.
The major beneficiaries are always the small man.
The man who has power, who's at the top of a society, he's going to do well whatever
kind of a society you have.
It's the society which gives the small man the opportunity to go his way, which is going
to benefit him the most.
Well, Brad, you brought this up before.
I mean, in the 1980s, Hong Kong was under British rule.
Now it's the People's Republic of China.
Milton Friedman believed that...
Well, it's still one country, two systems.
Yeah, well, but he believed that once you had economic freedom, you would have personal,
social, political freedom.
That is certainly not the case in Hong Kong now.
The link between, or at least the inevitable march from economic freedom to personal freedom,
social freedom, and political freedom does seem to have gotten itself interrupted over
the past generation and a half.
And I'd say the verdict of history is that Milton was much too optimistic about the extent
to which growing and developing economic freedom would carry personal and political freedom
and, indeed, democracy with it.
But he had fairly good reason for his judgment, that that was essentially the process that
first the Netherlands and then Britain and then France and other Western European countries
had followed, by which economic development and the rise of the middle class had been
followed by the fall of aristocracies and kings from political participation and the
steady onward march to democracy.
That's something that seems to have stopped, or at least to have slowed down, outside of
Latin America over the past 40 or 50 years, and I don't think I understand why.
Well, still, I mean, I think with the exception of oil countries, there's scarcely any country
in the world that's rich and hasn't become democratic at the same time.
I think what happens, as Brad says, that once you have the makings of the middle class,
the middle class wants not just the material goodies, but they also want to have a voice,
they want to have control over their political futures, and they don't want to be ruled by
dictators and their cronies.
This is what, of course, we've seen in the Arab Spring.
Maybe quite surprisingly, the countries where the revolution started were the countries
that were doing economically better, like Tunisia and Egypt, not the backward ones.
That's why I think why China is quite worried about the copycat effect, and I think ultimately
China will not get rich until it becomes democratic.
But the question is, what's the best way to get there and what the role of the markets is?
I think what we've seen is a mixed economy actually has made that transition more likely.
Also, I think we've seen tremendous economic growth at rates which didn't exist in the past.
So if you look at Britain's expansion, economic expansion took two centuries,
political expansion took a century.
What Britain did over that time, China's done in 30 years.
It may be that it takes longer for political expansion to happen,
and I have no doubt for the reasons that Danny mentioned, but also the fact that at some point
to get further economic expansion, you need people to have ideas.
And ideas often require a freer spirit.
That means political change, and you can see that happening in China,
especially with the new technology that we have, Twitter, Facebook, or their versions of it.
There's a lot more discussion, and I'm hopeful that over time
you will see the democratic expansion across the world.
So does either one of you believe that you can have a successful capital economy
and an authoritarian rule?
You know, it's not, I think there are two links.
You can think about running from success to democracy and from democracy to success.
The consensus of the work in the academic literature,
and I think the consensus among economists,
is there's a strong link from success to democracy.
And this is what Danny was talking about, people get wealthier.
One of the things you want when you're wealthier is you want a voice, you want a democracy.
The link in the other direction, there are countries who have been very successful
without necessarily freeing things up first.
So I say the link is stronger running from success to democracy
is probably the side of the equation.
Now, what I would like to stress what Raghu just talked about,
which is the two work well together.
That is, if you have freedom, that helps you run a free market economy,
that people are able to take advantage of the things.
And if you have a free market economy, you don't have to control people
to the extent you do if you have a less free market economy
where you basically have to tell people what to do.
So it's hard to really...
They're complementary, I guess, the way economists like to talk about.
They work well together.
And that's why we think a place like China, as it gets richer,
it's likely to become freer.
And it's going to be hard to keep getting richer if they don't get freer.
Yeah, because when you look at Hong Kong,
it really looks like the majority of people live in the ugly side,
in this abject poverty, the slums.
That's the way, certainly back when Hilton Friedman was there.
And for him to say that some of these people
subscribe to being like that,
like that's the way they want to be, that's hard to...
They were vastly richer than their parents and their grandparents.
And they became vastly richer still,
because today's Hong Kong is not the Hong Kong that we saw on the screen.
It's vastly richer today than it was then,
and they've continued to grow.
But it is the argument that if you don't have
places where people without industrial skills
can work productively
and learn the skills of handling machinery
that you need for an industrial economy,
then if you get rid of those sweatshops
and get rid of those occupations,
you won't have a situation
in which everyone's an upper-middle-class denizen of Chicago.
What you'll have is a situation
in which you have a huge number of unemployed
or informally employed people
who are even poorer than the people of Hong Kong.
They're just out of sight.
So what you need, in some sense,
is as you grow richer,
you have to give people the capability,
the ability to increase their capacities,
to get better education, to get better health care.
And so again, this goes back to both things have to move together.
But as you get richer, you have the wherewithal
to acquire those things, to spend for those things.
And I think that's what you see.
Both the quality of government
and the quality of products
that the government ensures for you
as well as the private sector
tend to grow together.
Let's not forget that in 1980,
the Berlin Wall was still up.
What Milton Friedman is saying here
is a debate about systems.
There is still the question
of whether the capitalist free market system
will be the system of the future
or whether the communist system will win.
From today's vantage point,
that question has completely disappeared.
And it's no small tribute to Milton Friedman
that when the Berlin Wall fell down,
there was no question as to which direction
they were going to go to.
They were going to go in the direction
of having some version of a free market economy.
So I think today it's no longer
is it a centrally planned economy
versus a market economy?
Is it an authoritarian system
versus a democratic system?
I think largely those questions have been settled.
And I think the issues are getting the balance right.
So that we live after the end of history, in a sense.
Well, it turns out there's been a lot more history.
In which case it would have been nice
if Milton Friedman had also talked
not just about the free market
but about universal education
and infrastructure.
And, I don't know what,
cheap broadband for all.
But he did talk about those elsewhere.
He talked about universal education
and relying on the market
to try to create that.
And I think
that message is very much alive today.
That we know we need to do something
to improve our education system.
This is now getting away from
other countries and back to the United States
because we have a
very important issue
where we have large segments of our economy
people who are not receiving
the kind of education they need
to succeed where our economy is now
let alone where it's headed to.
Should the government intervene in that?
The government is intervening.
The government is in some ways the problem.
I think that's right.
And I think if you say
what's the solution here?
I think the solution is
we have to get more competition
and more ways to get
people what they need
because the people want it.
If you talk to parents,
there aren't parents out there
by and large who don't care
about the education of their children.
They just are in a system
where they don't have the best opportunities.
But unlike in Hong Kong,
people here have the personal freedom
to make change,
but many of them don't.
There's a question about whether
parents are in fact the best advocates
for their children or whether all parents
are the best advocates for their children.
And there are also the questions of
what's the government's role in education
and how should it be structured?
Should it provide incentives?
Should it provide funding?
Should it actually run schools?
And I'd like to hear Kevin on this
because he's the only former educational bureaucrat we have.
I guess what I would say is
I think about and you should say
well, let's take education.
Should the government provide education
or should we do like Milton advocated
a more of a voucher type system?
And I would just say
think about the contrast between
a rich suburb where
you've got a really good choice.
You can go to the private school
or you can go to the public school
and you're going to get a great education
either place you go.
In the inner city,
a lot of the best opportunities for people
are the Catholic schools and other schools
that are there because the public schools have failed them.
Failed them miserably.
So, you know, people always think
the government is the great equalizer
but I would say there's probably more inequality
between the suburban public school
and the urban public school
than there is between the suburban private
and the urban private.
So rather than
in that case being the great equalizer
the government actually seems to be
fostering inequality.
Even though the money is roughly the same.
Right, but it's not money
that does the trick. It's education
that does the trick.
Alright, well, on to our next segment.
Milton Friedman borrowed this next story
from Leonard Reed's eye pencil
because he thought no story better illustrated
the meaning of Adam Smith's
invisible hand at work.
The idea that people will come together
to do the right thing
at the right price.
Look at this lead pencil.
There's not a single person in the world
who could make this pencil.
Remarkable statement?
Not at all.
The wood from which it's made, for all I know,
comes from a tree that was cut down
in the state of Washington.
To cut down that tree, it took a saw.
To make the saw, it took steel.
To make the steel, it took iron ore.
This black center,
we call it lead but it's really graphite,
compressed graphite.
I'm not sure where it comes from
but I think it comes from some mines
in South America.
Literally thousands of people
cooperated to make this pencil.
People who don't speak the same
language, who practice
different religions,
who might hate one another if they ever met.
When you go down to the
store and buy this pencil,
you are in effect
trading a few minutes of your time
for a few seconds
of the time of all
those thousands of people.
What brought them together
and induced them to cooperate to make this pencil?
There was no commissar
sending out orders
from some central office.
It was the magic of the
price system.
The impersonal operation of prices
that brought them together
and got them to cooperate
to make this pencil so that you could
have it for a trifling sum.
That is why
the operation of the
free market is so essential
not only
to promote productive efficiency
but even more
to foster harmony and peace
among the peoples of the world.
So Danny, would you agree
with that, that this is the best example
of the free market system coming
together, trading goods and services,
the ability to do
something, the right thing at the right price.
Is that a good example?
It's a wonderful segment, isn't it?
It goes on and on, by the way.
That's an abbreviated segment.
I didn't bring a pencil with me.
I actually don't use a pencil,
so I had to ask my daughter to give me one
before I came here.
I knew that it was going to be made in China.
Indeed, it is made in China
as most pencils today in the world are.
I think today
a modern day Milton Friedman
would want to ask,
why is this pencil made in China?
Clearly some of it has to do
with the private initiative,
entrepreneurship, hard work and thrift
of the Chinese people. Maybe most of it is that.
But it's not
that China has
the best graphite in the world.
There's much better graphite in South Korea
and in Mexico.
It's not that
wood is
more plentiful in China
than it is in Indonesia
or Brazil. There's much better
technology in pencil making
in the United States or Germany.
I think it's one major reason
why most pencils today,
just like so many manufactured goods
are being made in China,
which is that the Chinese government
has had a very concerted
policy of
stimulating industrialization,
of supporting industries.
In the case of pencils, it's been partly
environmental policies
that have kept the price of wood cheap.
It has been export subsidies.
It has been the role of state investments
to
transfer technology
and train the initial batch of workers.
It has been intervention
in foreign currency markets to keep
the Chinese currency
cheap so that they can
compete in dollar terms.
So it has been
today,
this is just one example, but
the reality of the world today is that
all these mechanisms
of market allocation
have in them the role of the government
completely mixed up.
You're going into any Walmart, and it's not just a pencil.
It's three quarters of the goods
are made in China.
Largely because the one thing you didn't mention was
the abuse of
workers there. I mean, they're paying pennies to
some of these workers on the dollar, and they don't
care about their work environment.
I think there's some of that,
but I don't think it's changing.
Increasingly, it's not China anymore.
It's Vietnam, it's Cambodia, it's Laos,
and sometimes India
where this stuff is coming from. Why?
Because Chinese wages have started
going up, and the Chinese
worker now no longer wants those rock-bottom
wages, is no longer content
having an undervalued renminbi
because when they go outside, they can't buy stuff.
So China has a decision
to make at this point. Stay the old course
and see eventually its markets wither
away, or move to a
new structure where it
starts buying more, consuming more. And that,
to my mind, is something we have to remember.
That our future in
industrial countries
is going to be exporting
to countries out there as
their demand increases, as they become richer.
And so this is a time
it's tempting to look at the
policies there and say they were awful,
but they were policies that industrial
countries also followed when they were poor.
But they changed. And you have to
change to a more market-oriented policy
if you are to continue
growing. And I think China,
if it doesn't realize that, had better realize
it soon. And if it makes that change,
it will be a great force
for the kind of cooperation that Milton
talked about in the segment.
Yeah, I would say
if he was doing that example today,
he would probably use something other than a
pencil. There's been some recent work, people
have talked about the iPod and where
the iPod's made around the world. And
officially it says made in China, but
that's where it's assembled.
But in fact, the vast majority
of the value is actually created elsewhere
in the United States
and in Japan and everywhere. And I think
somebody calculated the Chinese contribute
$6 of the value of a $300
iPod, even though it says made in
China. And that's even a
greater example of Milton's
kind of specialization.
And I agree with Raghu that
you really have to focus on
these people have
had low wages, but they're
much better than their wages were before
where they were in rural agriculture. And there's
been a tremendous movement
of people in China from
being very poor
to being poor. And they're getting
to be not so
poor. What have you got on your iPhone there, Brad?
The other one's blank. It's Greg Linden
and company at UC Berkeley.
Yay Berkeley that did it.
Although the iPod does tend
to undermine the argument that nobody
plans this because
a bunch of somebody
certainly did plan this
even though they didn't centrally
plan it in the sense that Apple has
all these market interfaces with
its huge number of suppliers, customers
and so forth. This thing was
still designed rather than a spontaneous
creation. But for
the China point, I would say
that the reason that 60%
of the items on sale in Walmart are
from China are because
we made a conscious decision that
a strong dollar was in America's interest
and that China should sell
us manufactured goods while we would sell
them bonds.
And that was
a decision on our part
about how to use the
market to our long run national
advantage and prosperity. Are you concerned about the
loss of jobs here? Yeah, I'd say it's
a decision, a policy that's ten years
after its sell by date.
That to say a strong dollar is
in America's interest is one thing when
it's the 1990s and everyone wants
to invest in the emerging technologies
of Silicon Valley and we're at
full employment. It was a policy that
Hilton Friedman would have approved of
wasn't it? Because after all it is
the US just let the dollar determine
in free markets for currency
and didn't intervene and that's why it
got the dollar that it did. Well, there's a
question as to what a free foreign exchange
market is at a very deep level.
But the point is of course that
it was a country like
China and maybe
Vietnam, a few other East, South, East Asian
countries that could take advantage of this
and they had the right policies
in place to do so. I mean if people are willing
to loan you money at very low rates
and sell you goods to buy with
that money at very low prices
you generally think a free market
will take advantage of that.
Going back to what Kevin said earlier,
they're making the pencils.
We're selling them legal services, consulting
services, professorial services and
getting a lot more per hour than they're
getting. And this is what we need to
make sure that the rest of the people, the people
that Kevin talked about who are being left behind
can actually do which is improve the
quality of the output
of the capabilities of people in
industrial countries so that they don't see those things
as a threat. They want to make the pencils great
but they have to pay me much more
for what I'm producing. That's
a grand bargain. Right now it's bonds we're
selling but it'd be great if we could sell stuff
that was not debt.
That actually employs people.
What about the role that trade plays
in ensuring world peace?
I mean let's face it, China couldn't
afford to go to war with us and we couldn't afford to go
to war with them. So does
trade on that magnitude
ensure world peace? This was an argument
that Norman Angell made back before World War
I and it was a very good and a very convincing
argument but it was totally
wrong. I mean he
argued huge books about how
war was so expensive that only
an idiot in a government would
launch one and lo and behold we've had
lots of idiots in the 20th and
21st century. The First World
War came at the end of
the flowering of
the first great era of globalization
and I
think we would be making a mistake
to believe that
just because we live in this era
of globalization that we've put
behind
international conflict
behind us. And Second World War
followed a very different region so
the linkage is pretty weak between
those two things I think we conclude.
There is a broad point that
let's say go back to Adam Smith
back in 1760 Scotland
and you know
north from where Adam Smith lives near Edinburgh
and there are people who will if they
see you they may kill you because you're a clan
enemy or they may befriend
you if you're a clan member
or you may be a stranger to them in which case
they'll just steal from you.
And that's an uncomfortable world to live in.
By contrast we live in a
world in which practically everyone
we interact with
wants to sell us something.
We want to sell them something or they want to
sell us something and we'll both
go away happy and so most of
our interactions are with people who are going
to do something for us.
So we are going to do something for them
and that makes for a much more peaceful
and friendly world than one
in which you're, I don't know what, a Douglas
and you're scared of the McConnels
down the road. There's one place where I think
increasing growth and trade
creates frictions and that's for resources.
And right now we
see a lot of competition for
resources. It's business
like, it's genteel, but it could
turn ugly. And especially when you
think about resources like water
where, you know, it's life
or death whether you have access to water. And that
may be where the frictions
get more over time
even when we have such a globalized world.
So tell me, does global warming
mean there's more or less
snowpack in the Himalayas?
More or less water in the great river valleys
of Asia? When people listen
to this today are going to be saying, oh this is
all great and good for China and the free markets
and everything, but there are people out in the Midwest
and, you know, industrial
complexes, farmers, they're thinking
I'm unemployed. I'm never going to
work again. Nobody's going to come in and rescue
me. I don't have a skill.
I'm not going to be, I'm not going to morph
into the next thing. How does that
translate into... Well, no one really thought he had an answer
right? That he thought that if all you did
was have the Federal Reserve
make sure that the money supply grew
at 5% per year, year
in and year out, that we wouldn't
have large business cycles.
And wouldn't have large episodes
of cyclical unemployment and big
depressions. All we'd have would be the normal
background of frictional
unemployment as people moved from job
to job and spent some time unemployed
in between. And it's
that, I think, that
has me at least most
shocked right now.
You know, that kind of eight years
ago I would have agreed when
Kevin and Rajen's colleague Robert
Lucas said we had solved the problem
of depression prevention. And I'm
still not sure how it has
gone so wrong. Any final words, Danny?
Well, I think we need a mix of policies
and I think they have different time
range. So we talk a lot about education
and increasing
the skills of our workforce.
But that's really going to
take time. So education cannot be the
solution to the present
generation's problems. So I think there
also has to be some short term remedies
and that will
require taking care of the
basic industrial base of the
country and caring
about what the value of the dollar is
and what U.S. trade policy is.
All right, we're going to have to end it there. Thank you all.
And my thanks, of course, to Kevin Murphy,
Raghu Rajan, Danny Rodrik
and Brad DeLong. I'm
Emily Rooney.
Thank you.
Major funding was provided by
CME Group.
For more than 160 years,
through continuous innovation in trading
and technology, CME Group
products have provided businesses
with the opportunity to manage risk
amid the changing financial landscape.
BP is
dedicated to helping meet America's
energy needs. Our investments
support jobs across the country
and reaffirm our commitment to the U.S.
that began over a century ago.
Additional funding
was provided by
John A. Gunn and Cynthia Freigun,
the Melvin S. Cohen Foundation,
FedEx Corporation,
the Ellie Phillips Family Foundation
and Corrett Foundation.

