Milton Friedman Speaks: Is Capitalism Humane?
It is my very great pleasure
to present to you our
speaker today, Professor
Milton Friedman.
What I want to talk about
is really an issue which
is very much related to
the whole problem of
human freedom. It has to
do with the question of
whether capitalism is
humane and what you mean
by that. I am sure many
of you have heard the
old story about the two
poles who met one another,
and one pole said to the
other, tell me, do you
know the difference
between capitalism and
socialism? And the other
pole said, no, I don't
know the difference. And
the first pole said,
well, you know under
capitalism man exploits
man. The other fellow
shook his head. Well,
under socialism, he said,
it's vice versa. Now that,
as a matter of fact, in
the present intellectual
atmosphere of the world is
a relatively favorable
evaluation of capitalism.
The interesting thing to
me about this is that the
arguments, the issues in
this debate which has been
going on for so long about
the form of government
have changed. The argument
used to be about strictly
the form of economic
organization. Should we
have government control of
production and
distribution, or should we
have a market control? And
the argument used to be
made in terms of the
supposedly greater
efficiency of centralized
government and of
centralized control. Nobody
makes that argument
anymore. There is hardly a
person in the world who
will claim that
nationalized industries or
socialism as a method of
economic organization is an
efficient way to organize
things. The examples of
Great Britain, the examples
of Russia, the examples of
some of the other states
around the world that have
adopted these measures,
plus the domestic-grown
examples of the post office
and its fellows, have put an
end to that kind of talk.
But the interesting thing
is that nonetheless there is
widespread opposition to
capitalism as a system of
organization, and there is
widespread support for some
vague system labeled
socialism. The most
dramatic example of the
change in the character, the
argument, and the paradox
that I'm really bringing out
is Germany. Here was
Germany, which experienced
all the horrors of the Nazi
totalitarian state in the
1930s. Here is Germany,
which after the war, under
the Erhard policy of
Sozialmarktwirtschaft,
social market economy, had
an economic miracle with an
enormous rise in total
income, enormous rise in
the well-being of the
German people, of the
ordinary people. And yet in
Germany, despite the
demonstration of the horrors
on the one side of a
totalitarian state, and on
the other of the benefits
of a relatively free market,
here in Germany you will
find a very large fraction
of all intellectuals not
only remain, have become
even more strongly
anti-capitalist, have
become proponents of
collectivism of one form or
another. Only a small
number have gone into the
more extreme versions that
you've been reading about in
the paper of the terrorists,
but a very large fraction of
the intellectuals, those who
write for the newspapers,
those who are on television,
and so on, are fundamentally
anti-capitalist in their
mentality. And the question
is why? What is it that has
produced this shift? Now what
is it that produces this
consistent attitude of
anti-capitalism on the one
hand, and something called
collectivism on the other
among intellectuals? One of
the most interesting
analyses of these problems I
know is by a Russian
dissident mathematician
named Shafarevich. His essay,
which has never been
published, needless to say,
in Russia, but it appears in
English translation in a
book called Under the Rubble,
which has been edited by
Alexander Solzhenitsyn, and
I strongly recommend that
particular paper to you. In
it, he discusses the appeal
of socialism over the ages.
He goes back a thousand or
two thousand years and he
comes out with the
conclusion that just as
Freud pointed to the death
wish in individuals as a
fundamental psychological
propensity, the appeal of
socialism and the
opposition to capitalism is
really a fundamental sign of
a death wish for society on
the part of intellectuals.
It's a very intriguing,
strange, and at first sight
highly improbable kind of an
interpretation. Yet I urge
you all to read that essay
because you will find that
it is very disturbing by
having a great deal more
sense to it than you would
suppose such a position
could possibly have. I'm not
going to take that line.
Maybe he's right, but I
think there's a very much
simpler analysis, a simpler
reason for this, and that
simpler reason is a
combination of a supposed
emphasis on moral values
and ignorance and
misunderstanding about the
relationship between moral
values and economic
systems. I may say the
emphasis on moral values is
almost always on the part
of people who do not have
economic problems. It's not
on the part of the masses.
But the problem with this
approach, the problem of
trying to interpret and
analyze a system, either
pro or con, in terms of
such concepts as the
morality of the system or
the humanity of the system,
whether capitalism is
humane or socialism is
humane, or moral or
immoral, the problem with
that is that moral values
are individual. They are
not collective. Moral
values have to do with what
each of us separately
believes and holds true,
what our own individual
values are. Capitalism,
socialism, central
planning are means, not
ends. They in and of
themselves are neither
moral nor immoral, humane
or inhumane. We have to
ask what are their results.
We have to look at what are
the consequences of
adopting one or another
system of organization.
And from that point of view,
the crucial thing is to
look beneath the surface.
Don't look at what the
proponents of one system
or another say are their
intentions, but look at
what the actual results are.
Socialism, which means
government ownership and
operation of means of
production, has appealed
to high-minded, fine
people, to people of
idealistic views, because
of the supposed objectives
of socialism, especially
because of the supposed
objectives of equality and
social justice. Now those
are fine objectives, and
it's a tribute to the
people of good will that
those objectives should
appeal to them. But you
have to ask the question,
does the system, no matter
what its proponents say,
produce those results? And
once you look at the
results, it's crystal clear
that they do not. Where are
social injustices greatest?
Social injustices are
clearly greatest where you
have central control. The
degree of social injustice
and torture and incarceration
in a place like Russia is of
a different order of
magnitude than it is in
those Western countries
where most of us have grown
up and in which we have
been accustomed to
regarding freedom as our
natural heritage. Social
injustice in a country like
Yugoslavia, which is a much
more benign communist state
than Russia, and yet you
ask Gelas who languishes in
prison for having written a
book, you ask the people at
the University of Belgrade
who have been sent to
prison, or many others who
have been ejected from the
country. Social injustice
in China, where you have
had thousands of people
murdered because of their
opposition to the
government. Again, you look
at the question of
equality. Where do you have
the greatest degree of
inequality? In the social
states of the world. I
remember about fifteen
years ago my wife and I
were in Russia for a couple
of weeks. We were in
Moscow, and we were going
with our tourist guide and
I happened to see some of
the fancy Russian limousines
up there, the Zivs. They
were sort of a take-off on
the 1938 American Packers.
And I asked our tourist
guide out of amusement,
how much do those sell for?
Oh, she said, those aren't
for sale, those are only
for the members of the
Politburo. You have in a
country like the Soviet
Union enormous inequality
in the immediate literal
sense that there is a small
select group that has all
of the services and
amenities of life and very
large masses that are on a
very, very low standard of
living, indeed in a more
direct way. If you take the
wage rate of foremen versus
the wage rate of ordinary
workers in the Soviet Union,
the ratio is much greater
than it is in the United
States. I am reminded again
of another- I seem somehow
to be referring to Poland,
but on this same trip that
we took to Russia we stopped
in Poland, in Warsaw for a
while, and we met there a
marvelous man, a man by the
name of Edward Lipinski,
who was in this country a
year ago at the age of 83
or 84. I believe he was
arrested when he got back
to Poland because he had
been one of those who had
signed and authored a
declaration against the
suppression of freedom of
thought and speech in
Poland. But at the time we
met Edward Lipinski he
seemed to be fairly free.
He was a man who had been a
socialist all his life, and
this was really very hard
for him. He was now in his
seventies, I may say. When
we saw him he was retired.
It was a very hard thing
for a man to go back on all
of his lifelong beliefs.
And so he said as follows
to us. He said, you know,
I used to believe in
socialism, I still do, but
socialism is an ideal. We
can't have it in the real
world, he said, until we
are rich enough to be able
to afford it. And he said,
socialism will be practical
when every man in Poland
has a house and two
servants. And I said to
him, including the
servants? And he said,
yes. Now capitalism, on
the other hand, is a system
of organization that relies
on private property and
voluntary exchange. It has
repelled people. It has
driven them away from
supporting it because they
have thought it emphasized
self-interest in a narrow
way, because they were
repelled by the idea of
people pursuing their own
interest rather than some
broader interest. Yet if
you look at the results,
it's clear that the results
go the other way around.
It's in the capitalist
societies of the world only
where capitalism has
prevailed over long periods
if you had both freedom and
prosperity. The greatest
measures of freedom, if you
look at the Western
countries where freedom
prevails, it doesn't
prevail perfectly. We all
have our defects, but by
and on the large, few would
deny that in the United
States, in Great Britain,
in France, in Germany, in
Western Europe, we have a
greater degree of freedom
on an individual and
personal level than you do
in most other places around
the world. In Australia,
Japan, to a considerable
extent today, though not
two hundred years ago, if
you look you will find that
freedom has prevailed where
you've had capitalism and
that simultaneously so has
the well-being and the
prosperity of the ordinary
man. There has been more
social justice and less
inequality. Now the
question is that you have
to ask, and you have to
ask the proponents of
these two systems, has
socialism failed because
its good qualities were
perverted by evil men who
got in charge? Was it
simply because Stalin took
over from Lenin that
communism went the way it
did? Has capitalism
succeeded despite the
immoral values it pervaded?
I think the answer to both
questions is in the
negative. The results have
arisen because each system
has been true to its own
values, or rather a system
doesn't have values, I don't
mean that, has been true to
the values it encourages,
supports, and develops in
the people who live under
that system. What we are
concerned with in
discussing moral values
here are those that have to
do with the relations
between people. It's
important to distinguish
between two sets of moral
considerations, the
morality that is relevant
to each of us in our
private life, how we each
individually conduct
ourselves, behave, and
then what's relevant to
systems of government and
organization are the
relations between people.
And in judging relations
between people, I do not
believe that the
fundamental value is to do
good to others whether they
want you to or not. The
fundamental value is not to
do good to others as you
see their good. It's not to
force them to do good. As I
see it, the fundamental
value in relations among
people is to respect the
dignity and the
individuality of fellow
men, to treat your fellow
man not as an object to be
manipulated for your
purpose, but to treat him
as a person with his own
values and his own rights,
a person to be persuaded,
not coerced, not forced,
not bulldozed, not
brainwashed. That seems to
me to be a fundamental
value in social relations.
In all systems, whether
you call them socialism,
capitalism, or anything
else, people act from
self-interest. The citizens
of Russia act from
self-interest in the same
way as the citizens of the
United States do. The
difference between the two
countries is in what
determines self-interest.
The man in the United
States who is serving as a
foreman in a factory, his
self-interest leads him to
worry about not getting
fired. The man in Russia
who is acting as foreman in
a factory, his self-interest
leads him to worry about
not being fired at. Both
are pursuing their own
self-interest, but the
sanctions, the effects,
what makes it in their
self-interest is different
in the one case than in the
other. But self-interest
should not be interpreted
as narrow selfishness. I
quote a man who speaks
much more eloquently than
I can. This is Thoreau and
I quote him from Walden.
Here's what Thoreau said
about unselfishness as a
moral virtue. He said,
There is no odor so bad as
that which arises from
goodness tainted it. If I
knew for a certainty that
a man was coming to my
house with the conscious
design of doing me good, I
should run for my life.
Philanthropy is almost the
only virtue which is
sufficiently appreciated by
mankind. Nay, it is greatly
overrated, and it is our
selfishness which overrates
it. If anything ail a man
so that he does not perform
his functions, if he have a
pain in his bowels even,
for that is a seat of
sympathy, he forthwith sets
about reforming the world.
Being a microcosm himself,
he discovers, and it is a
true discovery and he is the
man to make it, that the
world has been eating green
apples. To his eyes, in
fact, the globe itself is a
great green apple, which
there is danger awful to
think of that the children
of men will nibble before
it is ripe. And straight
away his drastic
philanthropy seeks out the
Eskimo and the Patagonian
and embraces the populous
Indian and Chinese villages.
That's Thoreau on
unselfishness as a moral
value. More important and
more fundamentally,
whenever we depart from
voluntary cooperation and
try to do good by using
force, the bad moral value
of force triumphs over good
intentions. And you realize
this is highly relevant to
what I am saying because
the essential notion of a
capitalist society, which
I'll come back to, is
voluntary cooperation,
voluntary exchange. The
essential notion of a
socialist society is
fundamentally force. If the
government is the master,
if society is to be run
from the center, what are
you doing? You ultimately
have to order people what
to do. What is your
ultimate sanction? Go back
a ways, take it on a milder
level. Whenever you try to
do good with somebody
else's money, you are
committed to using force.
How can you do good with
somebody else's money
unless you first take it
away from them? The only
way you can take it away
from them is by the threat
of force. You have a
policeman, a tax collector
who comes and takes it from
you. This is carried much
farther if you really have
a socialist society. If you
have an organization from
the center, if you have
supposed government
bureaucrats running things,
that can only ultimately
rest on force. But whenever
you resort to force even to
try to do good, you must
not question people's
motives. Maybe they are
evil sometimes, but look at
the results of what they do.
Give them the benefit of
the doubt. Assume their
motives are good. You know,
there is an old saying
about the road to hell
being paved with good
intentions. You have to
look at the outcome, and
whenever you use force
the bad moral value of
force triumphs over good
intentions. The reason is
not only that famous
aphorism of Lord Acton.
You all know it, you've all
heard it, absolute power
corrupts absolutely. That's
the whole aphorism. That's
one reason why trying to do
good with methods that
involve force lead to bad
results, because the people
who set out with good
intentions are themselves
corrupted. And I may add,
if they are not corrupted
they are replaced by people
with bad intentions who are
more efficient at getting
control of the use of force.
But also the fundamental
reason is more profound.
The most harm of all is
done when power is in the
hands of people who are
absolutely persuaded of the
purity of their instincts and
of the purity of their
intentions. Thoreau says
that philanthropy is a much
overrated virtue. Sincerity
is also a much overrated
virtue. Heaven preserve us
from the sincere reformer
who knows what's good for
you and by heaven is going
to make you do it whether
you like it or not. That's
when you get the greatest
harm done. I have no reason
to doubt that Lenin was a
man whose intentions were
good. Maybe they weren't,
but he was completely
persuaded that he was right
and he was willing to use
any methods at all for the
ultimate good. Again, it's
interesting to contrast the
experience of Hitler versus
Mussolini. Mussolini was
much less of a danger to
human rights because he was
a hypocrite, because he
didn't really believe what
he was saying. He was just
in there for the game. He
started out as a socialist,
he turned to a fascist, he
was willing to be bribed by
whoever would bribe him the
most. As a result, there
were at least some
protections against his
arbitrary rule. But Hitler
was a sincere fanatic. He
believed in what he was
doing and he did far
greater harm. Or, if I may
take you on to a minor key
in which you may not join
me, I realize, Ralph Nader
is a modern example of the
same thing. I have no doubt
that Ralph is sincere. I
have no doubt that he means
what he says, but that's
why he's so dangerous a
man who is threatening our
freedom. In the past few
decades there has been a
great decline in the moral
climate. There are few
people who doubt the
decline in the moral
climate. We see evidences
of it here. The lack of
civility in discussions
among people, the resort to
chance instead of
arguments, these are all
evidences on one level of
a decline in moral climate.
But we see it also in the
rising crime statistics, in
the lack of respect for
property, in the kind of
rioting that broke out in
New York after the
blackout, in the problems
of maintaining discipline
in elementary schools. Why?
Why have we had such a
decline in moral climate?
I submit to you that a
major factor has been
because of a change in the
philosophies which have
been prominent in society
from a belief in individual
responsibility to a
supposed belief in social
responsibility, from a
tendency to get away from
the individual, from his
responsibility for his own
life and his own behavior.
If he doesn't behave
properly, that's his
responsibility and he's to
be charged with it, to a
belief that after all it's
society that is responsible.
If you adopt the view that
everything belongs to
society, then it belongs to
nobody. Why should I have
any respect for property if
it belongs to everybody? If
you adopt the view that no
man is responsible for his
own behavior because
somehow or other society is
responsible, well then why
should he seek to make his
behavior good? Now of
course, don't
misunderstand me, on a
scientific level it's true
that what we are is
affected a great deal by
the society in which we
live and grow up. Of
course. All of us are
different than we would
have been if we had grown
up in a different society.
So I'm not denying in the
slightest the effect on all
of us of the social
institutions within which
we operate, both on our
values and on our
opportunities. But I am
only saying that a set of
social institutions which
stresses individual
responsibility, which
stresses the responsibility
of the individual given the
kind of person he is, the
kind of society in which he
operates, to be responsible
for himself, is a kind of a
society which is likely to
have a much higher and more
responsible moral climate
than the kind of a society
in which you stress the
lack of responsibility of
the individual for what
happens to him. Let me note
the schizophrenia in the
talk about social
responsibility. There is
always a tendency to excuse
the people who are harmed
by what happens, or the
people who are regarded as
the victims. There is
always a tendency to excuse
them from any
responsibility. They didn't
riot in Harlem because they
had no control over their
emotions, because they were
bad people or because they
were irresponsible people.
They rioted because of what
society did to them. That's
the argument. But nobody
ever turns it around and
argues the other way. If the
people who rioted are
innocent of guilt because
society did it to them,
then aren't the people who
are singled out as the
oppressors also free of
guilt? Do you hear these
same people say, Oh no, we
mustn't blame those bad
people who trample the poor
under their feet because
they're not doing it out of
their own individual will?
Society is forcing them to
do it. If you're going to
use the doctrine of social
responsibility, you ought
to be even-handed both
ways. It excuses both the
victim and the person who
is, I can't say
responsible because that
would be inconsistent, the
person who is alleged to
be responsible for the
victimization. Similarly,
you must be even-handed on
both sides. We must all of
us be individually
responsible for what we do
to our fellow men, whether
that be harm or good.
There's an additional
reason why you've had a
decline in the moral
climate. You'll pardon me
for returning to my
discipline of economics,
but there's a fundamental
economic law which has
never been contradicted to
the best of my knowledge,
and that is if you pay more
for something there will
tend to be more of that
something available. If the
amount you're willing to
pay for anything goes up,
somehow or other somebody
will supply more of that
thing. We have made
immoral behavior far more
profitable. We have, in
the course of the changes
in our society, been
establishing greater and
greater incentives on
people to behave in ways
that most of us regard as
immoral. On each of us
separately we have all been
doing it. One of the
examples that has always
appealed to me along these
lines is the example of
Great Britain, not now but
in the nineteenth century
and eighteenth century.
You know, in the eighteenth
century Britain was
regarded as a nation of
smugglers, of law avoiders,
of people who broke the
law. In the nineteenth and
early twentieth century
Britain got the reputation
for being the most
law-abiding country in the
world, an incorruptible
civil service. Everybody
knew about the fact that
you couldn't bribe a civil
servant in Britain the way
you could one in, say,
Italy or New York. How did
that come about? How did a
nation of smugglers with
no respect for the law get
converted into a nation of
people obedient to the law?
Very simply, by the
laissez-faire policy
adopted in the nineteenth
century which eliminated
laws to break. If you had
complete free trade as you
did after the abolition of
the Corn Laws, there was no
more smuggling. It was a
meaningless term. You were
free to bring anything into
the country you wanted. You
couldn't be a smuggler. It
was impossible. If you
didn't need a license to
establish a business, you
didn't need a license to
open up a factory, what was
there to bribe a civil
servant for? The civil
servants became
incorruptible because there
was nothing to bribe them
for. Now, of course, these
patterns- there's a
cultural lag, as you have
all learned in your
anthropology courses- and
these patterns, once they
develop, last for a while.
But what has been
happening in Britain in the
last thirty and forty years
is Britain has been moving
away from essentially
laissez-faire and toward a
much more controlled and
centralized economy. This
reputation for law
obedience is disappearing.
You have had repeated
scandals about ministers of
the government, about
members of parliament,
about civil servants who
have been bribed, about the
rise in gang warfare and
the rest. Why? Because
you're establishing an
incentive. You've got more
laws to break now. It's
much more fundamental. When
the only laws are those
laws which everybody
regards as right and
valid, they have great
moral force. When you make
laws that people separately
do not regard as right and
valid, they lose their
moral force. Is there
anybody in here who has a
moral compunction to
speeding? I'm not saying
you may not have a
prudential objection to
speeding. You may be afraid
you'll get caught. But does
it seem to you immoral to
speed? Maybe. If so, you're
a small minority. I have
never yet found anybody who
regarded it as immoral to
violate the foreign
exchange regulations of a
foreign country. Here are
people who would never
dream for a moment of
stealing a nickel from
their neighbor, who have
no hesitancy on
manipulating their income
tax returns so as to
reduce their taxes by
thousands. Why? Because
the one set of laws have a
moral value that people
recognize independent of
the government having
passed these laws. The
other set do not appeal to
people's moral instincts.
So I believe- well, let me
give you some more
examples from the United
States. Prohibition of
liquor, which was
attempted, as you know,
had disastrous effects on
the climate of law
obedience and morality.
Something which had been
legal, to buy and drink
some alcoholic beverages,
became illegal, and you
converted law-abiding
citizens into bootleggers.
I heard over the 60
minutes on the program
last Sunday night a great
story on butt-legging.
This has to do with the
fact that the New York
State tax on cigarettes is
very much higher than the
tax on cigarettes in the
state of South Carolina.
So you have people going
down to South Carolina and
buying the South Carolina
low-taxed cigarettes and
smuggling it into New York
State and forging New York
State tax stamps on it and
then selling it publicly.
A large fraction of all
cigarettes sold in New York
State are butt-legged.
Now there you've provided
an incentive for people to
break the law, so they
break the law. It's like
prohibition in a different
form. The obvious answer
is for New York State to
lower its taxes and you
will eliminate butt-legging
overnight and be able to
take whatever may be the
number of policemen who
are devoted to enforcing
that kind of thing, you
will be able to take them
and turn them to useful
work. I go back, however,
to the essence of
capitalism and its
relevance to the question
of humanity. As I say, the
essence of a capitalist
system in its pure form is
that it is a system of
cooperation without
compulsion, of voluntary
exchange, of free
enterprise. Now I hasten to
add, no actual system
conforms to that notion. In
the actual world you are
always dealing with
approximations with more or
less. In the actual world
you always have impediments
and interferences to
voluntary exchange. But the
essential character of a
capitalist system is that
it relies on voluntary
exchange, on your agreeing
with me that you will buy
something from me if I will
pay you a certain amount
for it. The essential
notion is that both parties
to the exchange must
benefit. This was the great
vision of Adam Smith in his
Wealth of Nations, that
individuals each separately
pursuing their own
self-interest could promote
the social interest because
you could get exchange
between people on the basis
of mutual benefit. Now I
want to emphasize to you
here for this purpose that
this notion extends far
beyond economic matters
narrowly conceived. That's
really the main point I want
to get across here, and I
want to give you some very
different kinds of
examples. Consider the
development of language,
the English language. There
was never any central
government that dictated the
English language, that set
up some rules for it. There
was no planning board that
determined what words
should be nouns and what
words adjectives. Language
grew through the free
market, through voluntary
cooperation. I used a word,
you used a word. If it was
mutually advantageous to us
to keep on using that word,
we keep on using it.
Language grows, it
develops, it expands, it
contracts through the free
market. Consider the body
of common law, not
legislated law which is a
very different thing, but
the body of common law.
People voluntarily chose to
go to a court and allow the
court to adjudicate their
dispute. In the process
there arose and developed
the body of common law.
Again, no central plan, no
central coordination. You
are here in an academic
institution. How did
scientific knowledge and
understanding arise? How do
we get the development of
science? Is there somehow
or other a government
agency that decides what
are the most important
problems to be studied,
that prevents cooperation?
Unfortunately there are
developing such agencies,
but in the history of
science that isn't the way
science developed. Science
developed out of free
market exchange. It
developed on occasion with
the patronage of an
authority, but voluntary
cooperation among the
scientists. I read
voluntarily the work that
is done by economists in
other lands, they read my
work, they take the parts
of it they like, they
discard the parts they
don't. In the process you
build a more and more
complicated system through
voluntary, free voluntary
exchange based on the
principle of mutual
benefit. Similarly to a
free market in ideas,
again, that is a free
market of exactly the same
kind as the economic
market and no different,
and the two are very
closely interrelated. Is
it a violation of the free
market in goods or the
free market in ideas if a
country, as Great Britain
did immediately after the
war, has exchange control
under which no citizen of
Britain may buy a foreign
book unless he got
authorization from the
Bank of England to acquire
the foreign currency? Is
that a restriction on
economic freedom or is it
a restriction on ideas, on
the free market in ideas?
I want to give you a final
example which goes back to
the fundamental question
we've been raising, and
that's voluntary charitable
activity. I want to ask you
a question. Go back to the
nineteenth century in the
United States. It was a
period when you had about
the closest approximation
to a capitalist society you
can imagine, in which the
federal government was
spending an amount equal to
roughly 3 percent of the
national income, almost
entirely on the army and
navy. State and local
governments were spending
about 6 or 7 percent of the
national income, mostly on
schooling. Very little of
what has come to be
regarded as welfare
activities, yet the
nineteenth century was a
period of the greatest
burst of voluntary
charitable activity that
we have seen in this
country or any other
country at any other time.
When was Cornell
established? How? It was
established by the
voluntary benefaction of
the man who gave you your
name, sometime in 1860
something. That period of
the nineteenth century saw
the emergence of a host of
private colleges,
universities throughout the
country. My own University
of Chicago was established
in 1890 by voluntary
eleemosynary activity. It
was also the period which
saw the growth and
development of the
non-profit charitable
hospital. It saw the
establishment of foreign
missions, of the Society
for the Prevention of
Cruelty to Animals, of the
Boy Scouts, you name it.
There is hardly a
voluntary activity. The
Carnegie Libraries, the
Free Public Library. Why
was it that voluntary
activity flourished?
Because again, the free
market, voluntary
cooperation among people,
cooperating to pursue their
common interest, is a far
more effective and
efficient way of producing
charitable results than any
other known to man. I ask
you, what is a common
element in all of these
cases I've mentioned?
Language, common law,
scientific knowledge,
ideas, charitable
activity? The development
of an elaborate and
complex structure without
any central planning and
without coercion. No
central planning in
language, in common law,
in scientific knowledge,
in ideas, in voluntary
activity. And yet you
develop complex mechanisms,
complex structures with
order, with structures
which after the event you
can analyze in logical
terms without coercion.
You have progress through
harmony rather than the
attempt to impose progress
through coercion.
Capitalism is often
reproached as being
materialistic. It's often
reproached as erecting
money as a chief motive.
But yet again, look at the
facts. I may say, you
know, money is not a very
noble motive, but it's
cleaner than most. But
look at the facts. Who has
produced the great
achievements of mankind?
Can you name me a great
play that has been written
by a government
committee? Can you name me
an invention that was
produced by a government
bureau? The great works
that are the great
achievements of mankind
have all been the
achievements of
individuals, of a
Shakespeare or a George
Bernard Shaw. George
Bernard Shaw is a
beautiful example because
of course, as you know, he
wrote the famous book, The
Intelligent Woman's Guide
to Socialism. He regarded
himself as a socialist,
but his career and his
performance is a striking
demonstration of the
virtues of the capitalist
system he opposed. Again,
in science it's Einstein,
Copernicus, Galileo who
are the great contributors
of scientific ideas, not
through government
central organization but
mostly in spite of it. In
Galileo's case, as you
know, despite persecution
by the centralized
authorities of his time.
Again, in the areas of
charity, Florence
Nightingale was not a
government civil servant.
She was a private
individual, a human being
who was seeking to achieve
the objectives she held
dear. She was pursuing
her self-interest. The
plain fact is that in any
society, whatever may be
its form of organization,
the people who are not
interested in material
values are a small
minority. There are no
societies in the world
today that are more
materialistic than the
collectivist societies.
It's the Russian societies,
it's the Chinese societies,
it's the Yugoslav
societies that put all
their stress on
materialism, on achieving
economic goals and
five-year plans that
destroy the non-
materialistic achievements
of mankind. Why? Because
they are in a position to
suppress minorities. What
we want for a society that
is at once humane and
gives opportunity for
great human achievements
is in a society in which
that small minority of
people who do not have
materialistic objectives,
who are interested in some
of these other
achievements, have the
greatest degree of freedom.
And the only society that
anybody has ever invented,
that anybody has ever
discovered, that comes
close to doing that, is a
capitalist society. When
you hear people objecting
to the market or to
capitalism, and you
examine their objections,
you will find that most of
those objections are
objections to freedom
itself. What most people
are objecting to is that
the market gives people
what the people want
instead of what the person
talking thinks the people
ought to want. This is
true whether you are
talking of the objections
of a Galbraith to the
market, whether you are
talking of the objections
of a Nader to the market,
whether you are talking of
the objections of a Marx
or an Engels or a Lenin to
the market. The problem is
that in a market society,
in a society in which
people are free to do
their own thing, in which
people make voluntary
deals, it's hard to do
good. You've got to
persuade people, and
there's nothing in this
world harder. But the
important thing is that in
that kind of society it's
also hard to do harm. It's
true that if you had a
concentrated power in the
hands of an angel, he
might be able to do a lot
of good as he viewed it,
but one man's good is
another man's bad. And the
great virtue of a market
capitalist society is that
by preventing a
concentration of power, it
prevents people from doing
the kind of harm which
really concentrated power
can do. So then I conclude
that capitalism per se is
not humane or inhumane.
Socialism per se is not
humane or inhumane, but
capitalism tends to give
free reign, much freer
reign, to the more humane
values of human beings. It
tends to develop a climate
which is more favorable to
the development on the one
hand of a higher moral
atmosphere of
responsibility, and on the
other to greater
achievements in every realm
of human understanding.
Thank you.

