Testing Milton Friedman: Equality of Opportunity - Full Video
The late economist Milton Friedman was one of the boldest and most provocative figures
of our time.
He was born in 1912, making this the 100th anniversary of his birth.
Milton Friedman received the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1976, and as a professor at the
University of Chicago, he transformed a generation of economists.
It's safe to say his work influenced the entire field.
He was an author and an advisor to several presidents.
His ideas won him millions of advocates and opponents all over the world.
While some place a greater emphasis on financial equality, Friedman advocated economic liberty.
In 1980, he shared his ideas with millions of TV viewers in the landmark PBS series Free
to Choose.
Hi, I'm Emily Rooney.
And here, surrounded by images of the University of Chicago, Milton's intellectual home, we'll
engage four distinguished guests in a discussion of the relevance of Friedman's ideas today.
Major funding was provided by CME Group.
For more than 160 years, through continuous innovation in trading and technology, CME
Group products have provided businesses with the opportunity to manage risk amid the changing
financial landscape.
BP is dedicated to helping meet America's energy needs.
Our investments support jobs across the country and reaffirm our commitment to the U.S. that
began over a century ago.
Additional funding was provided by John A. Gunn and Cynthia Frey Gunn, the Melvin S.
Cohen Foundation, FedEx Corporation, the Elie Phillips Family Foundation, and Korat
Foundation.
Americans are universally committed to the idea of equality, but in practice that means
different things.
Some think equality means little without equal outcomes.
Others like Milton Friedman believe equality means equal treatment before the law and spoke
out against government attempts to guarantee equal outcomes.
He argued that only equality of opportunity would lead to freedom and prosperity.
So what is equality?
In his 1980 landmark series, Free to Choose, Friedman wrestled with that question in a
program called Created Equal.
In the next hour, we will, too, with our panelists, Walter Williams, a professor of economics
at George Mason University, Matthew Iglesias, a fellow at the Center for American Progress,
and Sheikha Dalmia, a senior analyst at the Reason Foundation, and John Bowman, president
of the Sargent-Shriver National Center on Poverty Law.
So welcome to all of you.
All right, well, first, Milton Friedman went to Thomas Jefferson's home, Monticello, which
vividly illustrates Jefferson's contradictions over the meaning of equality.
It was Jefferson who wrote these words.
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed
by their creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty,
and the pursuit of happiness.
What he meant by the words equal can be seen in the phrase endowed by their creator.
To Thomas Jefferson, all men are equal in the eyes of God.
They all must be treated as individuals who have each separately a right to life, liberty,
and the pursuit of happiness.
Of course, practice did not conform to the ideals in Jefferson's life or in ours as a nation.
He agonized repeatedly during his lifetime about the conflict between the institution
of slavery and the fine words of the Declaration.
Yet, during his whole life, he was a slave owner.
During the 19th century, and especially after the Civil War and on into the 20th century,
the idea of equality came more and more to mean that everyone should have the same opportunity
to make what he could of his capacities, that all careers should be open to people on the
basis of their talents, independently of the race or religion or belief or social class
that characterized them.
This concept of equality of opportunity offers no conflict at all with the concept of freedom.
On the contrary, they reinforce one another, and it is no doubt the concept that even today
is most widely held.
But in the 20th century, beginning especially abroad, and at a later date in this country,
a very different concept, a very different ideal has begun to emerge.
That is the ideal that everyone should be equal in income, in level of living, in what he has.
The idea that the economic race should be so arranged that everybody ends at the finish line
at the same time, rather than that everyone starts at the beginning line at the same time.
This concept raises a very serious problem for freedom.
It is clearly in conflict with it, since it requires that the freedom of some be restricted
in order to provide greater benefits to others.
The society that puts equality before freedom will end up with neither.
The society that puts freedom before equality will end up with a great measure of both.
John, do you think that's true?
Milton Friedman was saying that in the 1980s, that our ideal was that everybody should have
equal income, equal living circumstances.
Do you think that's true?
No, I don't think so.
I don't think there was, and I don't think the sort of ideal, as he calls it, of equality of outcome
ever had any serious force in this country.
I think mostly what people were arguing for, that he might call equality of outcome,
is just the government involvement in the guaranteeing of equal opportunity
and the removal of barriers to equal opportunity.
And it's where you get in that gray area between the sort of ideal extremes
where you actually advocate for one thing or another
and develop the role of government in the guarantee of equal opportunity.
That's when you start getting into the arguments about who's right or wrong
about the role of government.
And whether the outcome should be equal as well.
Well, I think that the only kind of equality that is consistent with personal liberty
is equality before the law.
But however, looking at equality of opportunity as a concept,
it really just doesn't tell you very much.
The answer to that is, I don't have an equal opportunity to be a great boxer.
I don't have the equal opportunity to be a great basketball player.
And I don't have the equal opportunity to do many, many things.
So I think that the only kind of equality we should be striving for is equality before the law.
Well, just to respond to John's point,
I think when Milton Friedman made this clip,
affirmative action was at its heyday.
And affirmative action, which started off as equality of opportunity,
had actually morphed into, and still has morphed into,
something like equality of outcome.
Because if you look at the admission practices of a lot of universities,
what they are trying to do is get proportional representation
by ethnic group, by various different criteria.
And that's because they feel, unless they arrange for equal outcomes,
there's no way to measure equality of opportunity.
The only way to measure equality of opportunity is through equality of outcomes.
And so they have prearranged the outcomes.
And I think that's the kind of mindset that Milton Friedman was talking about at the time.
I thought it was interesting that Thomas Jefferson was invoked in this context.
Because Jefferson, at least as I recall it,
had a fairly robust sort of conception of equal citizenship.
Where it was important not just for people to have a sort of formal, hollow equality,
but he wanted to see a society of sort of farmer-owner practitioners.
It's difficult to know what that would mean in the modern context.
But the idea is that everyone needs to have access
to certain kinds of economic resources,
to have real opportunity to be a meaningful participant in society.
And not, I think, just a sort of empty legal equality.
Going back to your point, though,
Thomas Jefferson had slaves.
And the free market essentially created slavery.
But the free market wasn't going to take that away.
It wasn't going to take discrimination away.
It wasn't going to take Jim Crow laws away.
So without some kind of government intervention,
why wouldn't that have continued?
Well, I don't think slavery is consistent with the free market.
That is, the free market has something to do with private property rights and self-ownership.
And slavery is a violation of the essential principles of free markets.
So slavery is more, it's something like
the forcible use of one person to serve the purposes of another.
And that has to be offensive to anybody who believes in personal liberty.
But it took government to fix it.
The market itself wasn't going to fix it.
It wasn't going to sell for it.
If you equate freedom,
it's difficult really to understand what Friedman meant by freedom here.
That's a very mushy concept.
Everybody gives up some freedom.
We pay taxes.
If you're a policeman, you submit to discipline,
so you do the job well.
And so the issue isn't,
is there some pure freedom, unfettered life
that is even possible for anybody?
But where are we going to draw the line?
In a very pragmatic sense,
there's a tension between personal freedom
and the common good.
And I think they're both important, laudable goals.
And the idea is to seek the balance there.
And in the question of slavery,
you had to have a government role
in order to bring it to an end.
The market wasn't going to do it.
Do you agree with that?
Well, no.
I actually think the reason we needed government
to get rid of discrimination and slavery
was because government had created the problem
in the first place.
It was the government that was enforcing,
even during Jefferson's time,
the idea of enslavement,
that one person could own another person.
That was a government-enforced institutionalization,
which is why we then had to,
a whole culture developed around
certain government practices,
which then you needed a violent government action,
like the Civil War, to get rid of.
And then later on, of course,
we still didn't have equality.
We still had Jim Crow laws in this country,
which required a further government step,
which was the Civil Rights Act,
to get rid of that.
But this was a problem.
Slavery was a government-created
and supported institution,
and it had nothing really to do with the free market.
But I think, however you construe
the origin of the problem,
it's still the case that the Civil Rights Act
involved some significant curtailments
of private property rights,
but I would say, and I think the vast majority of people
would say that it was good for freedom
in any kind of meaningful sense.
No, I don't think it was good at all.
That is, I think that when the Civil Rights Act
was written, I think that instead
the government should have said
that the Constitution applies
to all Americans, and that was it.
But however,
I think one of the points that people
fail to take into consideration
that, as was said earlier,
that most of the problems
that black Americans faced
in our country
then and now
is a result of government.
Its root lies with government.
And you disagree.
For example,
if I were the Grand Dragon of the Ku Klux Klan
and I wanted to
sabotage black academic excellence,
I couldn't find a better way to do
than the government schools.
Can you?
No, but I don't think the conclusion
is to shut down government schools
or get the government out of schools.
The conclusion is
to do a better job in schools.
How long have we been doing that?
What about the issue of affirmative action?
Does it disenfranchise anyone?
Milton Friedman says
you shouldn't be restricting the personal freedoms
of a few to benefit
others. Isn't that what
affirmative action does?
Essentially, I think that's exactly what it does.
Now, I think, you know,
we have affirmative action in this country
not just for people
at the lower end of the strata.
We have affirmative action for people
at the upper end of the strata.
A whole host of universities use legacy preferences,
which is affirmative action for the rich.
Again,
it goes back to Milton Friedman's point
that we are trying to arrange equality
of outcomes because we want
X number of people
who are in the upper echelons
of New England to go to
Harvard and a certain number of Jews
to go to Harvard. There were quotas against
Jewish people in this country
at Harvard for a very long time.
Affirmative action
is very much
an equality of outcomes.
The point of it was to create equality
originally for African Americans
because of the legacy of slavery.
That was the idea that it would give
equal opportunity where
it didn't exist before.
Was it necessary?
In my view, it was not necessary.
In fact, if, you know,
Abigail Thornstrom and Steven Thornstrom
have done some wonderful work
in which they have actually documented
how black progress
in universities,
both in terms of attendance and graduation
rates, had been going up
quite rapidly until the 1970s
when affirmative action became
really big and at that stage
actually blacks started doing worse
because they were getting into
universities without being
properly prepared.
So they were going to universities
Affirmative action
actually is
a cause of
keeping blacks back
to some extent rather than their progress.
When we get into talking about education
though, you two have both very quickly
sort of abandoned this first principles
you know, the government has to stay out
of everything and you're instead trying to
mount some empirical arguments.
You're saying, well, maybe the government schools aren't very good
and maybe affirmative action didn't do what it was
supposed to do. But that means that we're having
a conversation which is about
how do we actually equip children
with what they need to have a fair chance
at succeeding. And that does require
we seem to be agreeing that some
kind of meaningful shot at getting
quality education really matters.
I think there's a lot of things about pre-natal
and neo-natal health care. Would you just accept
the achievement gap going forward? There's a profound
achievement gap. It grows bigger and bigger every year
between white and Asian
American students
and black and Hispanic. It's profound.
I don't accept it, but that doesn't mean
that affirmative action is necessary.
Look, for example
at one time, blacks were not allowed
in basketball. Today
80% of professional basketball players
are black. And it didn't happen because of
affirmative action. It happened because these guys
could do a 360 slam dunk
in your face and you couldn't do anything about it.
The same thing in baseball. The same thing
in football. 66%
Are these results of affirmative action?
Moving on. Okay. Alright.
In a world where children are
born into radically different circumstances
Milton Friedman wrestled with
what it means to provide equal opportunity
and how to best
provide that. Milton?
The Hootie Menuhin School in the south of
England is also a place of privilege.
Musically talented children
from all over the world compete
for a chance to come here to study.
Much of the moral fervor
behind the drive for equality
comes from the widespread belief
that it is not fair that some
children should have a great advantage over
others simply because they happen
to have wealthy parents. Of course
it's not fair. But is
there any distinction between the inheritance
of property and the inheritance
of what at first sight looks
very different? These youngsters
have inherited wealth
not in the form of bonds or stocks
but in the form of talent.
Or look
at the same issues from the point of view of the parent.
If you want to give your child
a special chance, there are
different ways you can do it.
You can buy him an education, an education
that will give him skills enabling him
to earn a higher income. Or you can
buy him a business. Or you can
leave him property, the income from which
will enable him to live better.
Is there any ethical difference
between these three ways of using
your property? Or again,
if the state leaves you any money
to spend over and above
taxes, should you be permitted
to spend it on riotous living
but not permitted to
leave it to your children?
The ethical issues involved are
subtle and complex. They are not
to be resolved by resort to
such simplistic formulas
as fair shares for all.
Indeed, if you took
that seriously, it's the
youngsters with less musical skill
not those with more, who should
be sent to this school in order to
compensate for their inherited
disadvantage.
Well, he's got a lot of thoughts in that
one piece, but Shigot,
is he saying that
education is the basis
of all equal opportunity?
I'm not sure he's saying exactly
that. I think what he's saying here
is that
you know, we all have different
endowments and
you know, whether they are
inherited endowments
or whether they are in terms of
what our abilities are
or whether we've inherited
wealth. And what matters
is not what the initial
distribution is. What matters
is that we should
be allowed to make what we can
or whatever that
initial distribution is. So here
he is very much talking
about, again, the equality of
opportunity
to allow whatever
hand life has dealt us
as best as we can, as opposed
to...
But I hear him saying that is it our obligation,
the government's obligation, the citizenry's
obligation to provide education
first?
Well, what he's
saying, the government's obligation
is to try and make sure
that we are able to use
our endowments as best as we can
without being prevented
by other people from doing so.
So, you know, in feudal societies
the debate in history
has been how do we redistribute
income according to
some formula. So in feudal
societies, the aristocrats
had the right to
extract labor and
therefore wealth from the serf class.
And in super progressive societies
you have, you know,
the poor or the relatively
less well-off trying to extract
wealth from the rich. And what he's
saying is that kind of society
will inevitably lead to
you know, a whole host of
curtailments of freedom as opposed
to, you know,
an equality of opportunity, which is what
he is interested in.
I think he's setting up kind of an extreme
straw man in order to make an argument
against the estate tax, basically.
Which we're still having that debate
right now.
And, of course, the equal
shares I don't think was ever
a serious proposal.
But it's sort of an extreme way to portray
an argument about the estate tax.
But I
think it's perfectly consistent
with notions of freedom and
passing along
you know, a good
inheritance to your children
to have an estate tax.
That it doesn't matter
I heard Bill Gates Sr.
say once, it doesn't matter if Junior
is going to get $8 million out of a $10 million
estate or $6 million out of a $10 million
estate, he's getting a nice inheritance
that he didn't earn himself
and he can go off and do what he wants with it.
So it's hard for me
to see exactly what point Friedman
was making here other than the one that we all have
different gifts and fine and we should have
the ability to do what we
can with them. Equal opportunity
again. And I don't think
any of us are disagreeing with that.
What's the difference between bequeathing
your children
a million or two million dollars
in cash and bequeathing
them a superior I.Q.
or high height
that translates into
differential
advantages in the market. That is
Will Chamberlain surely had
greater chances in the market than
I did and it was bequeathed from his parents.
But you know
the difference, I mean the reason we have
taxes is to raise revenue
because we can do things with the revenue.
So I mean the idea
of taxing certain kinds of very large
bequests is not just that
we are mad at the kids
who are getting the money. It's that
we're thinking that the money can be put to use.
We can for example help make sure that people
have schools and have education.
And that's very fundamental.
I mean I think he seemed to indicate
that it would be somehow absurd to be giving
extra violin lessons to the less
talented children which is
an interesting example. But I think it's
quite natural to say that well
if some children are born blind that we give
them some extra assistance because there's
an unusual difficulty there. That we need to give
health care to the people who are in need
of the health care rather than just hand it out
equally or hand it out to the people of the leader.
But he was also suggesting...
Very important distinction between
what you just said and the conception
of equality
which is what you're talking about
and Milton Friedman actually conceded that
when you have people
who are in distress
then you do have a responsibility
to do something about them.
That's alright. What is not
alright is income
redistribution for its own sake
because we just don't like inequality.
Well where is that money going to come from?
Where is it going to come from?
Is it a tooth fairy or Santa Claus?
No it's not.
The only way...
See what I find pretty offensive about
many of these programs is the
forcible use of
one person to serve the
purposes of another. I think that
is immoral.
Unless you think it's
moral.
That's what
slavery was. The forcible use
of one person to serve the purpose
of another. And I find that offensive
in any degree. I think this is the real concept
of equality that I think is left out
of this opportunity and
outcome. Dichotomy is the idea that
policy should take the interests
of all the citizens equally seriously
when you're making these things. And that
means you can't put undue burdens on any
particular individual. You have to let people
lead their lives. But it also does mean that
if arrangements can make large numbers of
people better off by calling for some
sacrifice, that's a good idea. That we can
build a better world that way. So you believe that
people should be forcefully
used to serve the purpose of others?
I believe that institutions should be set up
according to whom?
We talk here about distributive
justice, redistributing income
based on poverty
and wealth. In Plato's
Republic, he thought a
proper idea of distributive justice
would be that goods go to people
who deserve them. So if you're a great piano
player, then you should
be entitled to pianos, not
whether you are rich or poor. And that
thought experiment led straight to
an extremely
oppressive communist society.
Plato led straight to extremely...
That's his thought experiment in the
Republic.
Which goes to Milton Friedman's
point that if
you are going to be interested in questions
of distributive justice,
you are going to have to curtail
people's freedom to such an extent
that you will get a great deal of
oppression. And
the final outcome will be you will distort
people's incentives to produce.
Why is it that we have to leap from extreme
to extreme? I mean, we're living in a society
today which is not a communist
dictatorship, it's not an
unfree dystopia, but it also is a
society that has taxes, it has
programs, it has some social insurance,
it has some retirement benefits.
Insofar as, look, insofar
as it doesn't make equality
an end in itself,
and simply a means to removing
certain extreme forms
of distress, that would be
alright. But that's not actually
what happens these days.
When you listen to
President Obama,
when you listen to President
Obama, he talks about
spreading the wealth for its own
sake. Now that's a very problematic
idea. We are talking
about repression because
if I say to the federal government
I will pay my
share of the
constitutionally mandated functions
of the federal government, I will be happily
but I will not have my earnings
go to farmers, go to bail out
big banks. You'll see all the
intimidation threats and oppression
that I would want to see.
America meets any normal
person's basic definition of
we are living in a free society here. This is
not Plato's Republic. This is
not the Soviet Union. We're not living in a free society.
Well, there you go.
If you equate paying taxes
for things that the political
establishment has set up that you don't like,
if you equate that to
involuntary servitude, then
I guess you have a problem.
We're going to move on to the next segment.
Milton Friedman understood
and accepted, as we were just saying,
that life is unfair.
That some people will be born into wealth,
others into poverty. But, he said
trying to redistribute that wealth
would be unjust to those who work
hard to earn their money.
From Victorian novelists
to modern reformers, a favored
device to stir our emotions
is to contrast extremes of wealth
and of poverty. We are expected
to conclude that the rich
are responsible for the deprivations of the poor.
That they are rich at the expense of the poor.
Whether it is in the
slums of New Delhi, or in the
affluence of Las Vegas,
it simply isn't fair that there
should be any losers.
Life is unfair. There is nothing
fair about one man being born
blind and another man being born
with sight. There is nothing fair
about one man being born of a wealthy
parent and one of an impecunious parent.
What kind of a world would it be
if everybody
was an absolute identical duplicate
of anybody else? You might as well
destroy the whole world and just keep one specimen
left for a museum.
In the same way, it is unfair
that Muhammad Ali should be a great
fighter and should be able to earn millions.
But would it not be
even more unfair to the people
who like to watch him?
If you said that in the pursuit of some
abstract ideal of equality, we are not
going to let Muhammad Ali get
more for one night's fight
than the lowest
man on the totem pole can get
for a day's unskilled work on the docks.
You could do that.
But the result of that would be to deny
people the opportunity to watch
Muhammad Ali. I doubt very much that he
would be willing to subject himself to the kind
of fights he's gone through if he were
to get the pay of an unskilled docker.
Matthew,
Milton Friedman is saying that
inequality is a fact of life.
Deal with it. Do you agree?
Sure. I think there's always going to be
some inequality in life. But, you know,
there's an option between
do nothing
regarding Muhammad Ali and prevent him
from fighting. And it's the system that we have
now, which is where you have an income tax
and people pay it. And even after
taxes, many people are much richer
than other people. But it allows us to get
some revenue, to fund some programs, to take
care of some problems, to create the infrastructure
of society that we have, and to express
some concern with the level of inequality
and to try to make a society where
we have prosperity for everyone
and where we have broadly shared economic growth.
I think that's common sense.
And it's gone sort of a little bit missing
in that dialogue.
I think that what we need to do,
we need to pay more attention to
the rules of the game.
That is, what creates some
of the inequality that we see.
That is, for example,
in New York City,
the price to get a
license to own and operate one taxi
is $603,000.
In Chicago, I believe, it's something
like close to $200,000.
And many,
many restrictions for
people at the bottom of the
economic ladder to get their feet on the
bottom rungs of the economic ladder, those
are the kind of things that we should look
at. What are the rules
of the game, and how can we change
the rules of the game? Doesn't the free market control
that too? No, it doesn't. It's government.
It's government. That is, people
who are on the inside,
let's say their income,
use the example of taxes
in New York, the people who own these
licenses, they're able to rig the economic
game against the outsiders.
That is, the insiders want to keep
the outsiders out, so the insiders
can charge higher prices
and earn more income.
And those are some of the systemic
issues that we need to look at.
Just to pick up on Walter's point over here,
Milton Friedman was making an extremely
important point. The point that he was
making was, how do you create
the incentives in society
to get the maximum possible
wealth generated so that everybody
can be better off?
It's all
very good to say, well, you know, we
can just sort of redistribute an X amount
of wealth and still everybody
will be prosperous. But people
don't become prosperous through redistribution.
People become prosperous through
creation of wealth. The minute
you start to take away Muhammad
Ali's incentive to
go and fight and
make seven or eight million dollars, or
however much he makes, you take
away the incentive of the producers
to keep generating that wealth.
That's what Milton Friedman is talking about
over here. And so Walter is
making an extremely important point. What we
need to do is look at
the regulations and the disincentives
for wealth creation that keep
people on the lower rungs of society,
at those rungs, and deal with those
rather than redistributing wealth.
These are good
points, but let's remember that
the people who are benefiting
from the high prices
for taxicab licenses
isn't the government. It's
the entrepreneurs and the capitalists
who run the taxicab companies.
We're going to infringe on their freedom?
The point is that the government
has to figure out how
to arrange this so that there's
as much opportunity for as many people as
possible. There's a role for the government
in regulating things and setting
fair rules within a
fairly open capitalist system.
And maybe
they haven't drawn the line in the right places
here, but I don't think that's an argument against the
role of government. Milton Friedman also supported
a negative income tax.
He was thinking that would be an exchange for
programs like welfare
or food stamps and that kind of thing, but
it's essentially the same thing. Do you think
that's a contradiction to be in favor of a
negative—I'm going to ask you that, John—
a negative income tax, which basically says
at a certain point you stop
paying in and you get more back?
Well, I just
I think it needs to be
all more on a
practical level. If that
produced enough revenue
to run the important
functions of government, then
I suppose it's as good as anything
else, depending on
the given—
The point is you need revenue to do
the important functions of government.
The argument today
my life is spent
in the actual give and take of trying
to argue these things in
public policy debates, and
not in the relatively clean
academic arena where you can argue
ideals and extreme positions.
My question is, was this a contradiction
in ideology? Because basically
it's a social
welfare program by any other name. We
have it now with—
Just to bring a little context over here,
the reason Milton Friedman
advocated
the Earned Income Tax Credit scheme,
which is I think what you're talking about,
he felt if there was going to
be a welfare state, that was the most
efficient way to arrange it
where the money
that needed to go to the
recipients of welfare would go directly
to them. That's given that you're going to have
a welfare state. That's given, but he didn't
advocate a welfare state, so that's a
very important difference to keep in mind.
Going back to John's point over here,
I just hear you guys
slipping between two things. It's one
thing to tax people
in order to function vital
functions of the state,
which are equally used by all.
It is quite another thing to tax
rich people to give that
money to a certain subset of people,
whether they are the poor or the talented
or the untalented. Those are two very
different things, and that's
a beautiful persuasion. It's the latter
that Milton Friedman was opposed to.
We hear here, Muhammad Ali, he's so great.
Wouldn't it be terrible if someone stopped him from
boxing? And I agree, that would be terrible.
Muhammad Ali was great. Great fighter, great career.
But of course, he was paying
income taxes. Very high
income tax rates, as I recall, back when he
was boxing. You were talking as if
that would just destroy it, and there would
be no athletes, there would be no businessmen.
You and I can sit and debate
what is the optimal level of taxation
after which the tax becomes a
disincentive to the producer, but
there is such a point.
There absolutely is.
So the point is
that
if you are a central planner
and you have infinite wisdom, you know
exactly where that optimal point is.
It's a different thing.
I don't believe that kind of knowledge is possible.
This is what I'm saying about the switching now.
No, I would much rather
leave as much money as possible
to people to use as they choose.
Let me ask, Walter. At what point does inequality
income inequality
create just a huge
social and political problem?
There's so much resentment on the bottom.
What is the government's role
then to
help mesh that?
I don't believe that
government has a role whatsoever
in getting rid
of inequality. See, the point that you
have to recognize is that
there's no tooth fairy or
Santa Claus, given the congressman
the money. So the only way
the government can give one American
citizen one dollar is to
first, through intimidation, threats, and
coercion, confiscate that dollar
from some other American. Now, you
should not confuse my disagreeing
with the redistribution
with my saying, well, you shouldn't take care of
people who are in need. I believe
in helping your fellow man by reaching
into your own pockets to help your fellow man
is praiseworthy and laudable.
Reaching into somebody else's pockets
to help your fellow man in need
is despicable. And for the Christians
among us, when God gave
Moses the commandment, thou shall not
steal, he did not mean thou
shall not steal unless you got a majority
vote in congress.
And by the way,
if you have a majority vote in congress, it isn't stealing.
Yes, it is.
It's legalized stealing, but it is stealing.
To your point,
there's resentment
against the wealthy. Actually,
there is not. The Pew Economic Mobility
Project did a survey not
too long ago, actually within the last six months.
One percent of Americans
put income inequality in their
top ten issues.
A more pointed question about
whether they resent somebody's
income versus theirs.
You can do amazing things
with numbers and polls.
Yes, exactly.
But I actually don't
disagree over here. Let me agree with you for a second.
The Pew Economic Mobility Project
is no bastion.
No, I get it.
I actually was trying to agree with you there
for a second.
I don't think
income inequality is resented
that much by people.
As long as there's fair
opportunities on the front end,
people understand.
I represent a lot of poor people
for over 30 years. Most of them
are just fine with the fact that they're not going to
end up making as much money as someone else
if they feel like they haven't been blocked
unfairly or that there haven't been conditions
that have gotten in the way.
They actually admire and love to follow
the people with money and so forth.
That's an important part of American life,
that you can strike it rich.
People love that. Even poor people love that.
On to the next point by Milton Friedman.
Not everyone will win,
but Friedman believed that
when a few win big, it ultimately
helps the losers.
That may sound like a contradiction, but
I'll let Milton explain.
Cards are coming out now.
Highways are playing, saying they have
nothing. Banker has two draws.
When the evening started, all of these
players had about the same
number of chips in front of them.
But as the play progressed,
they surely didn't. Some won, some
lost. By the end of the evening,
some of them will have a big pile of chips,
others will have small ones.
There'll be big winners,
there'll be big losers.
In the name of equality, should
the winnings be redistributed to the losers
so that everybody ends up
where he started? That would take
all the fun out of the game.
Even the losers wouldn't like that.
They might like it tonight, but
would they come back again to play
if they knew that whatever happened,
they'd end up exactly where they
had started?
But what does Las Vegas have to do
with the real world?
A great deal more than you might think.
It's one very important part
of our life in highly concentrated
form. Every day,
all of us are making
decisions that involve gambles.
Sometimes they're big gambles,
as when we decide what occupation
to pursue or whom to marry.
More often, they're small
gambles, as when we decide whether
to cross the street against the traffic.
But each time,
the question is, who shall make the decision?
We or somebody else?
We can make the decision only
if we bear the consequences.
That's the economic
system that has transformed our
society in the past century
and more. That's
what gave the Henry Fords,
the Thomas Alva Edisons,
the Christian Barnards the incentives
to produce the miracles
that have benefited us all.
It's what gave other people the incentive
to provide them with the finance
for their ventures. Of course,
there were lots of losers along
the way. We don't remember their names,
but remember, they went in with their eyes
open. They knew what they were doing.
And win or lose, we,
society, benefited from their
willingness to take a chance.
All right, Walter. Interesting concept.
Do losers
benefit when a few
people win big?
Well, if it makes the pie bigger,
they do. But I think
one of the things we have to recognize
is that winnings
are a result.
That is, you cannot judge a game
by the results. For example, if you
look at the poker players coming out of
Las Vegas, some
have won a lot of money, some have
lost a lot of money. Now,
by just knowing the result,
you can't tell whether there's been
poker fairness or poker justice.
What you have to do, you have to say,
we have to look at the process. We have to look at the
rules of the game. And if the
cards were dealt evenly from the top of the deck,
if nobody was cheating,
then any outcome is consistent
with poker justice. And that's
what we have to look at with the income distribution
in our country. It is a result
of something. So what people have to
ask in advance, is the game
being played fairly?
Does everybody have
equal access to the market?
And there are many, many restrictions
that we mentioned tonight
where people don't have equal access
to the market. You mean you can buy your way
in? I mean, which came first?
He uses the example of Henry
Ford. What about
Gates or Steve Jobs,
Bill Gates?
I actually don't have anything
to quibble with
what Professor Williams just said.
If everything is fair,
then the outcomes are the outcomes.
Except to the extent that
there are, if some of the outcomes
are sort of things that society
doesn't want to have, like abject poverty
or people in dire need.
I think for the government to
ensure fairness and so on,
I think you need some
taxation in order to have revenue to do
these functions. The functions of
which create the conditions where a guy like
Gates can strike it
rich by his own account or Warren Buffett.
But presumably he had a leg up.
He had investment money. He had something
that a lot of people don't have. Same with the guy at the
poker table. If I come in with a million dollars
and you come in with ten, my chances of winning
more are greater than yours.
And I think that's why you have things like small business loans
and stuff. I mean, there's the government attempting
to level that playing field somewhat.
But somebody's still got to take a risk.
And I think that's okay.
I mean, that's the kind of life
we have here. The issue
about government regulation and taxation
is the one where it's not
all or nothing. It's finding the right
tipping point. And it's a thing
where there's always going to be tension.
And there's always going to be forces pulling one way
and forces pulling the other.
One of the questions is, should we do anything to protect
losers? I mean, the vast majority
of these people in the country who go
bankrupt, they go bankrupt because of some
catastrophic health situation.
Do we want to be in a situation where
we're seeing American families
lose everything they have because
somebody has cancer? Should the government
be doing, well, we are. We're trying to do
a universal health care.
I think we
ought to do something. I mean,
Milton Friedman's talking about
incentives and how you have to have
incentives for people to take risks. And I think
that's completely true. That's why you don't want to have
a completely flat society.
At the same time, people can take more
risks and can be more entrepreneurial if
they know that their downside losses are
bounded to some extent. People know,
if people know that they will be treated
when they fall ill, that makes it a lot
easier for them to go start their own business,
something like that. If people know that
some retirement benefits are going to exist
as long as you participate
in society, that lets you go
do things. Can I just say that we actually
just tried. I want to address one of the points
about government. Today,
the federal government is close to 30
percent of the GDP.
Between 1787
and the 1920s,
the federal government is only 3 percent of the GDP
except during wartime.
So one has to ask the question,
how in the world
did we go from a third world country
in 1787
to the richest country
in the 1920s
without all the programs that you
are saying are absolutely necessary?
There were different programs at that time. There was a
large-scale government program to
appropriate land in the West and hand
it out to people. And it was a great
program. It was hugely successful
and it built exactly as you said.
When the poor Irish were landing here in
the 1840s, fleeing the potato famine,
when they got off the ship,
was there a food stamp program for them?
There was different programs at that time.
And if there's not a food stamp program, how in the world
did they make it? What there were were, there were no
government programs at that time. What there were
were private mutual aid
societies that actually
were really...
That took care of their own.
And the government was giving people
free land.
There was a large-scale program. There were
land-grant colleges, there was a transcontinental
railroad, there was...
Those emerged much, much later.
Do we have any application...
Between 1860 to 1960
That's when they emerged.
In the 1860s and 70s.
Let me ask a question. This is what we were talking about.
We were talking about gambling. Let's get back to that metaphor.
Do we have any obligation to
protect losers? Well, two points over there.
The gambling, the casino
situation, there's a huge disanalogy.
Because in a casino, you go and play
a zero-sum game where there are winners and losers.
In a free market economy,
there are no...
It's a win-win situation because people
are trading with each other
voluntarily, and you are
constantly increasing the pie
with the result that even the
poorest over a period of time
do better. And this is
not a historically disputable fact.
I mean, countries that have free
markets have done much better by the
lower rung of society than
countries that don't have the free market.
As far as protecting
the losers... Can I just make one more point?
As far as protecting the losers, Matt's
point that there should be protection for losers,
that actually has been
tried, and it was tried with Fannie Mae
and Freddie Mac, where
the government essentially
bailed out
or gave a guarantee against
bad subprime loans, and
look at what we got.
When you have a guarantee against
losses,
you encourage undue risk,
and that's the problem.
So this is the thing. You talk about
Henry Ford, talk about how America became
such a wealthy society, and
this is the system, he says, that we've had for the
past hundred whatever years. But the system
that we had during that period
was not a pure free market system.
It was a mixed, regulated economy.
It had progressive income taxes.
It had Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
It had Social Security. It had Medicare.
It had Medicaid. Now, obviously,
no one is going to say that every
single government program is a great idea,
and I would say
that there's some programs we ought to have, but
it's very strange to look at the
success of a regulated,
welfare state capitalism, to point
to that success and then use it as evidence
for how we should deregulate everything
and eliminate redistribution.
One of the things we have to look at, in your city of
Chicago, if you go to the poorest
neighbors in Chicago, you'll
see some people will have some nice
cars, some
nice cell phones, some nice
clothing, but no nice schools.
Why? How come
not at least some nice schools?
Well, it has to do with how
cars, clothing, and cell phones
are distributed through the market mechanism
and how schools
are distributed through the political mechanism
or through the government
mechanism.
Whenever goods are allocated
through the government
mechanism, you're going to find
that the people at the bottom are going to be
worse off than they otherwise would be.
The basic problems of poor people
in our country, particularly poor black
people, represent the failure
of government, whether it's in
education, whether it's even
just things as police protection.
It is the
failure of government.
What a lot of people are saying, well,
in light of this great failure of government,
we're asking for more
government.
I think we should move in the opposite
direction.
I think the argument would be
for better government, do a better job.
It isn't necessarily more.
I don't think the answer
to the school problem is to pull the government
out of schools.
I think
to have better schools and to try
new things and so forth,
I'm fine with that.
There are some nice schools in a number of Chicago
neighborhoods, by the way.
Some of them are experimental.
They're trying new things, but they're not pulling the government
out of it. They're just
loosening the reins and letting people try things.
Before we close, we wanted to
give Milton Friedman the final word
and perhaps the defining ethos
of his economic theories.
Milton. The society
that puts equality before
freedom
will end up with neither.
The society that puts
freedom before equality
will end up with a great
measure of both.
All right, so let me repeat
that. The society that puts
equality before freedom
will end up with neither. The society
that puts freedom before equality
will end up with a great measure
of both. Final thoughts
on that, Matthew?
Well, you know, I don't think it's a real either-or
decision. I think that a free society
is part of a society that treats
all of its citizens equally and with equal
concern for all of their interests.
Yeah, and
I think it's hard to...
It sounds great, but it's hard to know
exactly what he means by it.
I think a more productive juxtaposition
is the interest
of the common good versus the
interest of individual freedom.
And there has to be a balancing point
for those. Those are both valuable
goals. There has to be a balancing point
for it in order to maximize both of them
consistent with an ordered society.
You know, I think the historical
record is extremely clear.
I grew up in a country like
India, which was socialistic
for most of the time that I was
there, and the poor only got
poorer in India.
You know, the great gains
in eradicating poverty in India
have come after it liberalized
its economy. 300
million people lifted out of poverty
within, like, less than two decades.
So I think, yeah, the historical
record here is extremely clear.
Countries that put
freedom ahead of equality
get a great measure of both.
I think he's absolutely right, and I think
that freedom
is very, very important for
economic growth and human welfare, and
its main ingredient is
limited government, as our founders envisioned.
Do you think America today has
a great measure of both, freedom and equality?
I think we're losing it.
We still have a whole lot, but we're losing it.
We're losing it. That is,
as Thomas Jefferson said,
the natural tendency for government
is for government to gain ground and for
liberty to yield.
Anybody differ with that?
America, freedom and equality.
I think this is a free country.
I think it's obvious
to everyone. I think we're doing a good job
with it, and we have the struggle with this tension
between these two poles, and
I think we do a good job of finding
the compromise points and trying to move the
ball forward on both.
Yeah, no, I am with Walter on this.
I think we are losing it. We are
tipping the balance much more
on the side of so-called equality,
and the tragedy is going to
be that we'll get less equality and we'll
get less freedom. Through government programs?
Through government programs, through universal
health coverage, which is just going to
keep increasing the cost of health
care to a point that it'll become less
affordable to more people,
to just use one example.
I wish we had more time to debate that one.
You would drop
all of these programs. You would drop
them all, you would keep them. I mean, simple
as that. Yeah, I agree with him
about the taxis, though. The taxis?
And the other areas of
licensing as well. What about education?
I mean, that's another area where the government
has a very heavy presence, and
the outcomes keep getting worse and worse,
and the achievement gap keeps getting
greater and greater. So, you know,
every industry in which the government
is involved, whether it's health care
or education, you see the gap
between the so-called
winners and the so-called losers just
increasing. You know, I'd rather see the focus
on
trying to figure out how to
address big problems
rather than on
kind of ideological concerns about
the way we go about it. Look who we're talking about.
The big problem that plagues every
single kitchen table is
health care, and the cost of health care
and the cost of health insurance.
We know what people are against, but
they never talk about how you solve
this problem.
And we are not going to solve it
right now either. All right, thank you all
for being here. My thanks to Walter
Williams, Shikha Dalmia, Matthew
Iglesias, and John Bowman.
I'm Emily Rooney. Goodbye.
...
Major funding was provided by
CME Group.
For more than 160 years,
through continuous innovation in trading
and technology, CME Group
products have provided businesses
with the opportunity to manage risk
amid the changing financial landscape.
BP is
dedicated to helping meet America's
energy needs. Our investments
support jobs across the country
and reaffirm our commitment to the
U.S. that began over a century ago.
Additional
funding was provided by
John A. Gunn and Cynthia Freigun,
the Melvin S. Cohen Foundation,
FedEx Corporation,
the L.E. Phillips Family Foundation,
and Corrett Foundation.

