Milton Friedman on Self-Interest and the Profit Motive 2of2
I have just one more. This has to do with the Ford Pinto. I'm not sure if you're
aware of the recent revelations that have come out about the production of
that car. Ford produced it knowing full well that in any rear-end collision the
gas tank would blow up because they had failed to install a $13 plastic block in
front of the gas tank. And Ford estimated in an internal memo that that would cost
about 200 lives a year. They estimated further that the cost of each life would
be $200,000. They multiplied and they found that the cost of installing those
blocks in each of the cars would be more than the cost of saving those 200 lives.
And over the past seven years the car has been produced and over a thousand
lives have been lost. Seems to me that Ford did what would be the right thing
according to your policy and yet that seems to me to be very wrong.
Well let me ask you, let's suppose it would have cost a billion dollars per
person. Should Ford have put a million nonetheless? You know that you're really only arguing about price.
You're not arguing about principle. No, no, no, because nobody can take the
principle. Nobody can accept the principle that an infinite value should
be put on an individual life because in order to get the money involved, in order
to get the resources involved, it's not money. In order to get the resources, they
have to come from someone. And you want the policy which maximizes the
situation overall. You cannot accept the situation that a million people should
starve in order to provide one person with a car that is completely safe.
That's absolutely right. Right, and therefore you're not arguing anything about principle.
You're just arguing whether Ford used $200,000 was the right number or not.
No, I'm not arguing that at all. Suppose it were $200 million. No, no, no. Suppose it were $200 million, what should Ford have done?
$200 million for what? Suppose it would have cost $200 million per life saved.
Should Ford still have spent that $200 million? You mean per? That's not really the question.
Yes, it is the question. Because that's the principle of the question. That's the only principle involved.
I don't know whether Ford came to the right answer or not.
That's the question of whether these numbers are valid numbers for the relative costs of different things.
You're not arguing about a principle if you once agree with me that if it had been $200 million,
the cost per life saved would have been $200 million. You would not argue.
Look, let me go back for a moment. Can I say something in response to that?
If Ford had not been able to market those cars in the same kind of economic bracket
because of the price of installing this one plastic block, that would be a different question.
Maybe Ford could have considered redesigning the whole car so as to make it cheaper.
But what we're talking about is balancing advantages and balancing principles.
Of course, and that's why you're only talking about...
Just a minute. I'm a supporter of abortion. Therefore, I don't believe that every single human life is sacred.
I believe that principles have to be balanced.
And yet I don't see Ford spending $13 less on each car at the cost of 200 lives a year
as being a principled position to take, and yet I think your logic requires it.
Suppose it had been one fewer life a year.
So that the $13 per car, so that that one life, instead of being 200 times...
What's 200 times 200,000? It's 40 million.
Suppose it had been one life a year, so that it cost 40 million.
Would it then have been okay for Ford not to have put in that long?
You can't predict that one life is going to be cost because of a physical defect in the car.
This was a clear mechanical defect.
I know, I know, I know, but you're evading the question of principle.
No, I'm not. I'm saying that they knew before they put the car out that there was a mechanical defect.
Look, excuse me. You know, when you buy a car,
you know that your chance of being killed in a Pindo is greater than your chance of being killed in a Mack Truck.
No, I didn't. I didn't know that the gas tank would rupture.
Of course it is a question.
Every one of us separately in this room could, at a cost, reduce his risk of dying tomorrow.
You don't have to walk across the street.
Of course. The question is, is he willing to pay for it?
And the question here he should be raising, if he wants to raise a question of principle,
the principle he should raise is whether Ford wasn't required to attach to this car the statement,
we have made this car $13 cheaper and therefore it is one, whatever the percentage is,
it is one percent more risky for you to buy it.
Now that, then he would be arguing a real question of principle.
Why should they do that? Doesn't that interfere with the free enterprise system that you're touting?
No, no.
Why not?
Because the consumer should be free to decide what risk he wants to bear.
If you want to pay $13 extra for that, you should be free to do it.
Excuse me, we have to keep it to the audio over here.
So then the government does have the right to require information of corporations.
No, no.
Is that right?
No, no. The government has a right to provide courts of law in which corporations that deliberately
conceal material that is relevant can be sued for fraud and made to pay very heavy expenses.
And that is a desirable part of the market, of course.
What I'm trying to say to you is that these things are really a little bit more subtle
and sophisticated than you are at first glance.
Believe there are no, you can't get easy answers along this line
because your way of putting it really only doesn't really get at the fundamental principles involved.
The real fundamental principle is that people individually should be free to decide
how much they're willing to pay for reducing the chances of their death.
Now people mostly aren't willing to pay very much.
I personally regard this as very, very illogical.
I see people on all sides of me smoking.
Now there's no doubt, nobody denies that that increases their chance of death.
I'm not saying they shouldn't be free to smoke, don't misunderstand me.
I just think they're fools to do it.
And I know they're fools because I quit on the basis of the evidence 18 years ago.
But that's the real issue.
And if you want to be rate forward, you ought to be rated on those terms,
not on the ground that you don't think they use the right numbers.
Now look, I don't think we can keep on going very much.
I'm afraid we're going to run out of tape and I'm afraid I'm going to run out of voice.
So I think I'll call it done. Thank you.

