How to Choose the Right Student Loan Repayment Plan

Finance Lenders
2 followers
20 Video Views·Oct 14, 2025
Stanley Tate and attorney Joshua Cohen break down what’s really happening with the SAVE plan, PSLF buyback, IBR vs. RAP, and what it means for your path to forgiveness. They explore tough scenarios, like single borrowers hit with massive payment jumps, families adjusting to higher IBR bills, and people stuck in default trying to choose between consolidation or rehabilitation. They also cover what IDR forgiveness really means, how litigation is reshaping options, and when bankruptcy might actually make sense. If you’re trying to make sense of your student loan repayment strategy in 2025, this conversation is for you.
All right, so welcome back.
So Josh, I brought you in again today
because I wanted to go over some of the questions
that we've been getting a lot of over the past month
as interest on SAVE has resumed,
as the one big beautiful bill
that start to set in a little bit more,
and things have kind of quieted down in student loans,
but now we're able to kind of assess more on where we're at.
So let's just go ahead and dive right in right now
with the SAVE plan interest resuming.
What does that actually mean?
Does it mean that borrowers have to start paying?
Does it mean that they're gonna be kicked out?
They have to recertify?
Let's just start with what is interest resuming
on SAVE mean?
So I think rule number one for all borrowers
is stop reading into things.
It literally says interest will start accruing,
and that means interest will start accruing.
It doesn't mean you have to start repaying.
It doesn't mean you're getting kicked out of SAVE.
Is there a point behind it?
Yes, the Department of Ed would like you voluntarily
to leave SAVE, that's their motivation,
but you're not required to.
It just means interest is going to start accruing.
That's it.
All right, and so interest is going to start accruing,
but what about your, say,
borrower who has a recertification date,
say, of next November, 2026?
Does that mean that they may need to recertify early,
that that date will stay the same or that it'll be extended?
We don't really know.
I mean, nothing needs to be done.
You're in forbearance.
Nothing happens when you're in forbearance.
The only decision a borrower needs to make now is,
okay, it's the clash.
Do I stay or should I go?
That's what it is.
Should I stay in the SAVE forbearance or should I go?
And if I'm going, where am I going?
Okay, so when you think about where are you going,
like with SAVE, what kind of plans
are you thinking through with people?
What are the factors you're considering?
Is it just purely what's the monthly payment going to be
or is it more of a aim of, hey,
are you working towards PSLF forgiveness or IDR forgiveness?
How are you looking at this
from just components of the decision-making?
I always like to start with, what is your goal?
You, the borrower, what is your goal?
And then is that achievable and how do we get there?
So for some people, it's,
I just want a low monthly payment.
For other people, it's, I want forgiveness.
It's, how do I get PSLF going?
How do I minimize the interest?
Now, some of this is doable, some of it isn't.
You can't minimize your interest.
That's gonna happen.
For a lot of people, it's getting back on track,
whether it's an IBR payment plan or a standard plan,
and making sure it's affordable.
That's really it.
At the end, it's really a personal choice.
I'm not wearing your shoes.
I can't tell you what's the best for you.
All I can do is lay out the plates.
Here's the buffet.
Take what you want.
You like black licorice?
It's all yours.
I don't, but some people like it.
And that's what I'm doing.
Here are your numbers with IBR.
Here are your numbers with standard, and a one-up it.
Let's talk about RAP because it's coming,
so at least you can have a 12-month forecast.
That's where I'm starting these conversations.
Yeah, and that's exactly how I've been thinking
about it as well, is that if I have someone come to me
with SAVE and they are asking what to do,
the very first question I wanna know is,
okay, what is our goal in terms of forgiveness?
Because implicitly, if you're doing an income-based
type plan, then you're working towards forgiveness
of some sort, at least for now.
And what I'm seeing are that with borrowers in PSLF,
we actually have a second kind of underlying factor
to consider is, should they leave today
or should they stay where they're at
and then potentially be able to use PSLF buyback
down the line to buy back this time?
But then that consideration that's inside of there is,
will PSLF buyback even exist by the time you get there,
right, which is the total unknown.
And I've been trying to factor that in by saying,
okay, here are your monthly payments under RAP.
Here are your monthly payments under IBR,
whichever one it is, 10% or 15%.
And if you make the payments under IBR
that you have remaining towards your finish line,
here's the projected total cost.
And then we kind of layer in, too,
that really you may only need to do this IBR payment
for a year and then when RAP comes over,
if that's cheaper for you,
then you should consider switching there.
I've been thinking about it along the same way.
It's something different as well there.
That's really it.
And I will tell you, I know you have this too.
Most people don't trust the government
and they don't trust that buyback will stick around.
So most people, if they have buyback,
remember the threshold.
They've got to be at the 120.
Assuming they're at the 120, I say go for it now.
Well, let's dig in here.
I want to make sure,
because I actually saw some confusion online
and actually with borrowers as well.
When you say at the 120,
what do you actually mean the 120 for PSLF buyback?
So great question.
And I want to make sure we're breaking this down
as best possible, okay?
Remember, you need three things for PSLF.
One, the right kind of loan, which is a direct loan only.
So that's an entry threshold.
Two, you need the right kind of job,
a qualifying employer and qualifying payments.
Many people understand qualifying employer.
It's a government or a nonprofit
or certain not-for-profits, fine.
And then you need qualifying payments.
That's the sticking point
because maybe you haven't been making payments,
you have the COVID pause, you have all this stuff.
Most of that got corrected under the Biden administration
through the IDR account adjustment.
What's screwing everything up is the save forbearance.
So what I want to know is,
do you have 120 months of qualifying work?
Because if you do qualifying employment and you've got that,
then to me, you're probably at the 120.
If you've got 120 qualifying employments
and you're not there because of payments,
because of the save forbearance,
it sounds like you're at the finish line,
you're at the 120.
And the whole point of the buyback
is to bring the payments equal to your employment
so they're both at 120, boom, you get forgiveness.
Before we start this call,
I promise I wouldn't dig too much in the PSLF buyback
just because it is sort of this
not well-defined black box of information that we get.
And it's more anecdotal
is the information that's kind of doling out.
But what I do think is a fair question to ask is,
what are you seeing with your borrowers
who have done PSLF buyback and are in save,
what is that payment amount being calculated
after that buyback period?
Excellent question.
Now, we need the disclaimer here.
Just because we're seeing it now
doesn't mean it's gonna continue.
But surprisingly,
my clients are getting save-equivalent payments for buyback.
Now, let me pause there.
Are they getting save-equivalent payments for buyback
for the time that save was in existence?
So say that they were buying back a period
from August 2024 through today,
or are they also seeing it for earlier periods,
say going back to 2014?
That I don't know.
I can't tell you because the majority of my folks,
they're only missing the save forbearance.
And that makes sense because all the other forbearances
should have counted under IDR account adjustment.
So they really should only have to buy back
for this administrative forbearance.
Right, and that's what I'm seeing as well too,
is that just what should be the case
is that you're buying back those time
for the save plan forbearance,
or maybe you had a random three, four month period
where you weren't in save plan forbearance
and you're in this different period there
that you're buying back,
but it's post 2024, well, 2024 summer
that you're trying to buy back.
So maybe you submitted the application for save
but weren't put in there,
and there's like a six month gap of no qualifying payments
and you're putting in a request to buy back.
I am seeing that bought back at the save amount calculation
is what I've seen there.
All right, and then I don't wanna,
I wanna get us out of the buyback arena there.
And I'm sure someone who's in the comments like,
oh, I wish you would have answered this,
but I wanna go to this question
of save plan forbearance people
who have a very low payment today
because maybe they haven't recertified in years.
And so they're originally revised pay as you earn
and got flipped over in COVID to save
and hadn't had to recertify or submit their income today.
And now they're expecting the huge jump.
I just had a client, an attorney out in California,
her payment's at $50 a month
and now she's making $200,000 a year
as a single person in California.
Her payments are going to be roughly $1,800.
Is there anything that person can do
to mitigate that payment at all
and still stay on an income driven plan?
No, look, I'm not trying to be unempathetic here.
But it does feel unfair to a certain extent.
If you look at it through a very narrow lens of comparison
of comparing your payment now to what it's going to be,
it seems unfair to have a 1,800 type X jump.
Okay, so here's where the unfairness comes in.
It's because debtors,
not through their fault, are unprepared.
This is exactly what happened when the COVID pause ended.
There were those people sleeping under a rock
that didn't even know payments were gonna happen again.
Like, oh wait, I'm not prepared for it.
I'm not saying you got caught unaware,
but here you did and you're just not prepared.
Mentally, you're thinking, oh, it's safe.
Do you know what a safe payment is for $200,000?
It's still high.
But yes, IBR is higher.
But I gotta tell you,
I've been doing this student loan stuff
since before IBR existed.
This is still a godsend.
It's a matter of perspective.
There is no way to make it less painful.
Yeah, the attorney,
she was hitting me with all types of questions
about related towards any actionable rights she may have
because it's just, to her, it felt patently unfair.
And where I pushed back at was that,
number one, arguably, you've been benefiting
from this $0 payment this entire time.
You could have been setting money aside.
And these payments have been forecast to you.
So ordinarily, you would have to recertify your income
on an annual basis.
And if you had an extreme jump from one year to the next,
your payment still would increase
despite all this litigation anyways.
So I'm not sure that there's actually a real argument there
that you somehow have been harmed.
That said, I can acknowledge that going
from a super low payment to a really high payment
in a short period of time can shock the budget
and also shock the middle,
how am I going to make it all work?
And cry for me to make $200,000,
but that's not really the point.
We experience it across the board.
Can we bring a different example
that might be a little easy?
Okay, so the family of four that's making,
actually, I'll give you the example.
The family of four.
Well, see, the family of four problem
is a little bit different though
because they get this added bonus
of the family size reduced their payments.
But when you're a single person with a high income,
you get hammered despite living in a high cost area.
Okay, so you brought another factor in there.
They're in a high cost of living area.
Okay, move to Kansas, I'm joking.
But what I think, I think the best example here
for, oh my God, this is unfair.
The Biden administration touted a family of four
that made $64,000 a year
would have a $0 payment under save.
Now that's gone and they're in IBR,
which at $64,000, I'm guessing is about a $450 payment.
On an income based repayment at 238 a month
and under wrap, they're going to be about 225 on there.
And they wouldn't have zero.
So a $200 payment jump is still a high thing.
It's $2,400 for the year.
But do you have to do that right now?
I guess is the question because you know the math now,
you know what the number is going to be.
Then you can wait to leave say for a few months
to give yourself time to adjust your budget.
You could, but Stanley,
what about the interest that's accumulating?
Okay, stop.
The interest thing is interesting to me
because I am numb to that part of the math
because there has to be some type of trade off
with these plans.
You're paying less than the monthly payment
you're paying based off of your income,
your discretionary income in this case.
And part of that is interest is going to accrue.
And part of that agreement is that your balance
is going to grow because we had really bad policies
that affected that math.
However, wrap does away with that
and it gets rid of that interest building.
So there's a fairness here that's happening.
There's just a trade off now that is going to come
with five more extra years towards forgiveness.
And this is a great example of why it's important
to take your time and run the numbers.
You're saving, what, $15 a month on wrap versus IBR,
but that interest is a huge factor.
The principal reduction is a huge factor.
So run the numbers.
What makes more sense to you?
I can't tell you which is better because I'm not you.
Yeah, I mean, that's what I did with the attorney
with 200,000.
I said, look, here are the numbers
that you're gonna pay monthly payment wise.
And arguably you should be able to afford this.
It's going to be less than $24,000 for the entire year,
which is roughly less than 15% of your overall salary.
Now it doesn't account for the high cost of living
where you're at, unfortunately,
but it's not the end of the world.
And what does it look like compared to our standard plan?
How close are you to forgiveness?
And that's where we had to do the math too
to get into those numbers
because what is the alternative here?
The alternative is if you can't afford
this income-based option,
you're going to pay whatever your standard amount is,
whatever that term is, the extended or graduated plan,
or you're just not going to pay,
then you will potentially deal with wage garnishment
down the line of up to 15% of your check.
Right, or you go into bankruptcy,
and I don't know how that helps you today
in terms of your balance fully,
but that's a conversation about how Chapter 13
is helpful or not here.
So we can step aside from that.
Look, the only time default might be okay,
and I don't want to use the word okay.
If you're self-employed,
if you don't have wages that can be garnished,
you're too young and you're not getting Social Security,
what are they going to do to a self-employed person?
And honestly, I still don't like that answer
because, Stanley, what can they do to you
if they can't garnish
and they can't get your Social Security?
What are they going to do?
Well, I mean, we could see the return of proactive litigation
by the Department of Education where people are sued,
which is something that we have seen slow down
from 2006, seven, eight, nine, 10
when it was at the peak of these lawsuits,
but that could easily return,
and that gets us into another mess.
I was talking to someone about this the other day,
like, so they sue me.
I'll just say, oops, I'm sorry,
and I'll pay it off.
Like, no, it's not like any other debt.
Once you're in a lawsuit,
you've got DOJ or their private attorneys
breathing down your neck.
You can't just say, oops, forgive me.
It's, oops, here's my checkbook.
Let me write you a check.
That's the only answer,
and if you don't like that,
then it's not a choice.
Find a payment plan that works.
All right, let's pivot out of kind of this question
of what do you do when your payments are super low now,
but you're facing at a much higher payment,
and the answer is you have to prepare,
and the consequences are going to be really,
they can be drastic depending on your situation,
but I want to move into this intersection of IDR plans
and forgiveness under those plans.
Now, a lot of people,
they're surface level familiar with this.
When we talk about IDR forgiveness,
what do we actually mean, Josh?
I'm confused by that question
because it seems so simple to me.
When you say forgiveness, you mean forgiveness.
Your loan goes away.
The interest that's accrued goes away.
There is no hanging chad here.
It is, it goes away.
There's no catch.
People, and what you're stuck on
is what people are stuck on is there's gotta be a catch.
Okay, the only catch that I can think of
is the potential tax consequence.
Right, so setting aside tax consequences,
what we're saying with IDR forgiveness
is that your balance can be forgiven,
and that includes principal and all interest,
and potentially you may have to pay tax on that,
but we'll set that part aside.
I want to back up and go to the first part
of that IDR forgiveness.
What is IDR forgiveness?
Is it the same as SAFE forgiveness?
Is it the same as IBR forgiveness?
What does that mean, IDR forgiveness?
All right, so what you're doing is alphabet soup
and breaking things down
so people understand how they're connected.
Thank you for that.
Because I love when I tell people you should apply for IBR,
and someone emailed me and said,
I only see an IDR application, not one for IBR.
That's common, so let's go back to basics.
IDR, income-driven repayment,
is a hub term for any payment plan based on income.
IBR, ICR, pay, save,
all of those are included within IDR.
So when you say IDR forgiveness,
you mean forgiveness under any of those plans
I just mentioned.
Right, and that's always a stumbling block for people,
and it makes sense, though, too,
because servicers like Mojila will send you out a letter
and say, congratulations, you're enrolled in your IDR plan,
but they don't tell you what plan that is,
and they don't explain it.
IDR just simply describes your words, hub.
What I typically tell my clients is,
it's just a category, much like citrus.
If I say, hand me a piece of citrus,
you're gonna say, okay, what do you want,
an orange, lemon, or lime?
And that's what this is, it's just a category.
Now, go ahead.
If it's Mojila, they'll give you a banana.
This is fair.
All right, so for IDR forgiveness,
now, of those different repayment plans,
are all of them available for forgiveness today?
So for example, is SAFE plan forgiveness still available?
Is income contingent repayment forgiveness still available?
Is pay-as-you-earn forgiveness still available?
No.
All right, so here's the deal.
The SAVE litigation out of the Eighth Circuit
stops forgiveness on every plan except IBR.
The injunction in place in SAVE litigation
means no SAVE forgiveness, no pay forgiveness,
no ICR forgiveness, only IBR.
And they specifically said,
this lawsuit doesn't touch IBR.
So income-based repayment forgiveness is available.
The others are not,
which is another reason why maybe
you wanna switch out of those.
Right.
Now, this actually gets us to an interesting question.
If IBR forgiveness is paused,
does this mean that you have to restart your 20-year
or 25-year timeline if you switch from SAVE to IBR?
No, because the word is paused, not reset.
They are pausing forgiveness for nefarious reasons.
And they're not awarding forgiveness yet.
We're waiting for them to reopen that.
But IBR forgiveness is still available
and the pause doesn't do anything.
It freezes you.
You're just treading water,
waiting for the helicopter to pull you out.
All right, now, what if I'm somebody who is in SAVE
and I was on track for forgiveness
after 20 years or 240 months,
and I am going to move to the SAVE plan?
I'm sorry, to IBR.
Does that mean that I will have a 240 forgiveness timeline
that all my credits will pull over
and then my loans will be forgiven under IBR at some point?
Or does something else happen?
Okay, so take that apart.
Number one, when you switch from SAVE to IBR,
you keep the credit you've earned.
The only thing that resets your clock is consolidation.
So pay attention to that.
Switching plans doesn't reset your clock.
That's the important part right there.
The question of do you have a longer forgiveness clock
on IBR than SAVE is based on when did your loan,
when did your very first loan originate?
The very first loan that you're still getting
forgiveness on.
If, actually even that's muddled.
If, I'm gonna make this very simple.
If you owed a penny on any loan as of July 1st, 2014,
IBR is a 25 year clock and it's a 15% formal.
But is that true if I only borrow loans for undergrad?
It doesn't matter what you borrowed it for.
It matters if you owed a balance on July 1st, 2014.
Because IBR doesn't differentiate
between grad and undergrad.
And that's where I see people get confused too
is that especially if they find themselves
looking at the tracker online when it was available
or the back door is that they'll see
their payment counts broken down and say,
oh, I'm over 240 for SAVE, my loans are forgiven.
And I would say if SAVE were to still exist,
then yes, that would be true.
But in your particular case, you have to move to IBR
to get your loans forgiven based on how things
have shook out.
And given your facts that you borrowed a loan
before July 1st, 2014, and you owed money on that loan,
then you're going to be on a 25 year or 300 month clock.
And it always seems unfair to them.
And I have to remind them that SAVE didn't exist
as 20 year timeline didn't exist
when you took out your loans to begin with.
This was an added benefit that came
and now it's being blocked.
So arguably you were never really given that to begin with
when you borrow this loan.
This is just going back to what was there before.
Yep.
And yeah, it's, you know, it's the government
giveth and they taketh.
They do, but I want to clear something up.
Now you mentioned that consolidation resets your clock.
What if I consolidated to take advantage
of the one-time account adjustment?
If I change plans today, does that mean
I lose all that forgiveness credit?
Okay.
Consolidating now resets the clock.
Consolidations before June of 2024.
Yeah, June 30th, 2024, yeah.
Consolidations before June, 2024 or before July, 2024
were entitled to and should have received
the income driven repayment account adjustment.
Anything after that, you probably reset your clock.
Now, and there's a caveat there too.
Switching plans doesn't reset your clock.
Consolidating after July, 2024 reset your clock
except because we're lawyers, we like that word.
PSLF, specifically PSLF does have a weighted average
if you consolidate after July, 2024.
Yeah, so let's clean that all up
and let's just put it all together.
If you're someone who consolidated last year
to take advantage of the one-time account adjustment
or sometime before then,
you're going to keep your forgiveness credit moving forward
no matter which plans you change into,
you will have that credit.
And I think of it as a race where you're holding a baton.
You have this baton, that's your forgiveness credit
and you will keep running towards forgiveness
and getting close to that finish line
when you're in that plan.
And if you change lanes to go from save to IBR,
then you will keep getting that credit and stays with you.
The only thing that changes potentially
is your finish line gets pushed a little bit further out
just based off the rules, but you will stay where you're at.
Yes.
And even if you leave an income-driven repayment plan
to go to say the extended or graduated plan,
if you come back to IBR before the gates on that close,
you'll pick back up where you left off.
Yeah.
All right, so we have that part down.
So it's safe for you to change plans today
assuming those plans make sense for you,
but it is not safe to consolidate today
and keep your IBR account credit, forgiveness credit.
PS left is a different story.
We, and it's just because of how things shook out.
Other question here that I have,
what, and this is a little bit more,
I think this is a more straightforward,
easy answer here for you, Josh.
What is the difference between administrative forbearance
and general forbearance for IBR processing
and IBR forgiveness?
One is administrative and one is not.
One, honestly, I don't know that I care.
I mean, the administrative forbearance was forced on people
because of something else going on.
The processing forbearance is because
they know forbearance while they're processing you.
You know what?
I'm gonna turn the question back to you.
Is one of them eligible for IDR credit?
So I think the way I look at this is that historically,
we didn't care like the category of forbearance
because it didn't count for anything.
Like it didn't count towards PSLF.
It didn't count towards IDR forgiveness.
And it wasn't until the safe plan litigation happened
that we began caring about the category of forbearance.
And I said that a little bit slower
because I was trying to think if we cared about it
for the IDR account adjustment.
And no, because your forbearance is all count
no matter what they were,
so long as they lasted 12 straight months or more,
or cumulatively 36 months or more.
So the only time we started caring about
how the designation of forbearance mattered
was related towards income-driven repayment processing
post safe plan injunction.
And to break that down, what I mean is
there is an administrative forbearance for borrowers
in safe, and then there's an administrative forbearance
for borrowers who submitted an application
to change income-driven repayment plans,
recertify, whatever, and there was a delay on processing.
And during that delay on processing,
for those first two months,
you got credit towards forgiveness
without having to do anything.
And so I think that's really all I focused on there.
And so the general forbearance
will not give you credit toward forgiveness for IDR.
I believe the administrative forbearance
would for that first 60-day period.
And then for PSLF purposes,
the administrative forbearance gives you that credit
for the first 60 days, the general does not,
but then you can get PSLF buyback
to buy back both types of forbearance anyways.
Sometimes I break my brain trying to break this down.
Move on, next question.
All right, next question.
And we're gonna close out with two questions here.
And I wanna move into default here,
just from the standpoint that we have borrowers now
who are working to get themselves out of default.
And let's start by answering real straightforward.
What are your options for getting a federal student loan
out of default today?
On the surface, without knowing details,
you can either consolidate out of default
or you can rehabilitate, that's it.
Well, and there's compromise, but-
That's not curing default,
that's paying the loan.
That's just paying the loan off, exactly.
So to get out of default, to bring your loan current,
you have consolidation or loan rehabilitation.
Now, can you explain what consolidation
and loan rehabilitation means
in this context of getting out of default?
All right, when we talk about consolidating out of default,
the process and the end result
is no different than a regular consolidation.
It's the same thing.
The difference is in default, your loans are in default,
you're paying off the defaulted loans,
you have a brand new loan.
The nice thing about a federal consolidation
is it's not based on credit.
So all of you saying, well, I can't afford it,
I have terrible credit.
The government doesn't care.
They're refinancing.
And in many, many cases,
all they're doing is moving money
from one column to another column.
It's still a federal debt,
it's still a federal student loan.
But it's a new loan, it's not in default.
That's the simple part of it.
There is one caveat, an important caveat
that for most people isn't obvious anyway,
which is you must elect to repay under an IDR plan,
meaning you're gonna go into IBR via that consolidation.
Wait, wait, wait, let me make sure I have this right.
So there are two options to get out of default,
consolidation and loan rehabilitation.
Consolidation is where the government buys your debt
and issues you a new loan,
and it's not based on your credit.
And you didn't say this, but I'm saying it now.
The interest rate that you get
is also not based on your credit,
it's based off the weighted average
of the rates you already have.
So you don't lose anything there.
But in order to consolidate,
you're going to have to elect
to do the income-driven repayment plan.
But what if I don't want to sign up
for an income-driven repayment plan?
Can I still consolidate out of default?
No, correction.
You can, but you have to have an agreed,
you have to have an agreement with the debt collector
to make three voluntary payments first
before they process your consolidation.
And my response is, don't do that.
Why not?
Why shouldn't I make those three voluntary payments?
Because despite what you think,
you're not paying down your loan with that.
You are, but not really.
Okay, because how the money that you pay
is divided up is as follows.
When you're in default,
the first 25% of your payment goes to a debt collector
who's done nothing to help you.
And then it goes to the new monthly accrued interest,
and then it goes to the arrearage interest,
and chances are it'll never touch principal
when you're in default.
So those three voluntary payments,
you're losing 25% of your payment every month
to someone that didn't do anything for you.
In my opinion, if you have the money
that you don't need an IBR,
that you're going to pay it off,
then elect an IBR anyway.
Make those three payments under IBR,
which might be higher,
but 100% is going towards your loan.
And after three months of IBR payments,
you're allowed to terminate income-based repayment.
So really what you're doing
is you're making those three voluntary payments,
but you're making them after default,
after you're out of default,
and 100% is going towards your loan.
Yeah, that was always interesting for me
because for the past decade of doing this,
I can probably count on one hand
the number of clients that did the three,
made the three voluntary payments
instead of just consolidating right out.
And that was because they had already started doing it
before we met each other
because it never really made sense to me,
but I understand how they get there
because there was some person helping them
either at the private collection agency
or default resolution group
who said, this is the way you need to consolidate
and not having presented them the option
that you can just go consolidate freely
and just elect an IBR plan or IDR plan, I should say.
And actually, I'll tell you, financially speaking,
for me, all of the clients where the IDR didn't make sense
is because back in the day, they didn't qualify for IBR.
They made too much money.
They were going to pay off their loan.
So I would actually put them in ICR
because ICR has two different formulas.
And one of them is a 12-year amortization,
which is not much different than their 10-year amortization.
So I put them in ICR.
They didn't lose any money to the debt collector
and they're paying a little bit more for ICR
than their regular payment.
And for those people to keep it non-complicated,
they would just pay their 12 months of ICR
and then discontinue it.
If they wouldn't recertify,
they'd be kicked into a 10-year amortization
and they'd be on their way and paid anyway.
But very few people fit that mold.
But this all comes back to what you've always said, Stanley,
we've got to run the numbers and understand it.
This is a question about whether to choose
to consolidate out of default
or to rehabilitate out of default.
When do you lean more towards one or the other?
Why don't you come back to that question
after we tell the folks what rehab is?
Well, actually we didn't talk about rehab.
So let me go ahead and define that.
So consolidation is where the government buys your debt
and gives you a new loan with basically the same interest rate.
Loan rehabilitation is where you're gonna make
nine voluntary monthly payments over a 10-month period
to get your loan out of default.
Now, historically, you could not consolidate the loan
if you had an active wage garnishment against you.
So that only left loan rehabilitation as the option.
And then when you go to do loan rehabilitation,
they're gonna calculate your monthly payment
based typically off your adjusted gross income
and the family size claimed on your tax return.
And then if that payment is too high for you,
you can have a payment as low as $5 a month
based off of what your income expenses and family size are
based on the county of where you live at.
And there's a whole spreadsheet of information
we had to supply to get that payment amount.
Now, the question that I was asking is
when do you choose one or the other,
consolidation or loan rehabilitation?
Because loan rehabilitation seems to me
not that great of a deal
because I make nine monthly payments.
Those nine monthly payments don't work towards
counting towards forgiveness.
They don't help me with that.
And they delay me getting out of default for nine months.
And so what is the real benefit there
other than this perverted idea
that it's somehow better for credit than consolidation?
So to me, and this is something we have to think about now
that we haven't had to think about before
is how much IDR forgiveness credit
do you already have racked up on your defaulted loans?
Because if you consolidate out,
you scratch it all and you go to zero.
If you rehab, you get to keep it.
So that's one reason to do loan rehabilitation
over consolidation is that
if you already have forgiveness credit on your loan,
then it may be worth it to you
to choose rehabilitation over consolidation
so you can preserve that credit.
What's another reason to choose
loan rehab over consolidation?
Assuming you have a choice.
Remember, you don't have a choice, but try.
Assuming you have a choice.
Assuming you have a choice, okay.
What if it's an FFEL that's in default?
You might wanna do a consolidation
because it makes it a direct loan,
which could make you eligible for PSLF.
And I'm gonna flip the question back to you, Stanley,
because I don't know that we ever touched this.
Are FFEL loans eligible for RAP?
My reading of the one big beautiful bill
is that it uses the language direct loans
and talking about it, these loans.
Because we had the same conversation
about FFEL Parent PLUS loans
are eligible for income-driven repayment plans
moving forward.
But for FFEL loans, are they eligible for RAP?
My understanding is that the prefix used
was direct loans on it, but I need to verify there.
But backing up, one benefit of loan rehabilitation
is that it preserves credit
that you've already accrued towards forgiveness.
You then said that one reason to consolidate
a vote in favor of consolidation
is if you have a FFEL loan
that has no credit toward forgiveness anyways,
and you wanna make it eligible
for better repayment options
and potentially start earning credit toward forgiveness.
But sticking with the rehabilitation,
is there another reason
where you would choose rehab over consolidation?
There's a credit reason.
You want me to dive into that one?
No, not, well, sure, we can do the credit,
but I think what I'm actually,
what I'm thinking of is capitalization.
And so I have some clients who,
they plan to pay the loan off,
but they're not yet ready to do it today,
so they can't afford to compromise amount.
And their goal is to pay the loan off
in the very near future,
but they wanna get the debt,
get their loans out of default for whatever reason
instead of letting it sit in a collection status.
And so they look at the accrued interest,
and they'd rather avoid capitalizing
where the interest is added to the principal balance
as part of consolidation.
So then we do loan rehab to keep things as they are,
and then they preserve this right
to be able to pay this loan off into the future
without having to pay interest on interest.
Now, I think that's a very like,
not that great of an argument,
it's very specific to those individual borrowers.
So I can't think of another reason
to choose loan rehab over loan consolidation,
except for this perceived notion
that somehow rehab is better for your credit score
than consolidation is.
Now, can you explain how that works, Josh?
All right, so the question is what happens to your credit
when you get out of default, okay?
If your default is younger than seven years,
it's on your credit.
We're gonna assume first that it's on your credit.
If you consolidate,
your old trade lines show that you're paid off,
you get a new trade line for this consolidation.
If you rehabilitate, it's the same trade line,
and eventually the default ages off
after seven and a half years.
So there, there isn't too much
of a benefit consolidation versus rehab.
You've got the defaults are still there
and they eventually age off.
But where rehab can make a difference for credit,
and I don't use this as a sales tactic,
but some people care.
Imagine you've been in default for 15 years.
I don't know why, but you are.
And you can consolidate, which gets a brand new trade line.
The old one is off.
It just shows a brand new loan that you just opened up
for however many thousands of dollars you owe.
If you rehabilitate, however,
it brings back the old trade line without negative,
without anything negative, because that fell off,
and it says this loan has had good payment history
for 20 years.
You're bringing back a much older debt,
and that can have some good ramifications for your credit.
It shows long credit history with no negatives.
Yeah, I always thought the concept of this,
I guess this value of rehab being better for credit
to be such a nominal thing.
And I think there was a report put out
by TransUnion and other credit bureaus
where they show that really what mattered
was getting out of default as fast as possible
was better for your credit score overall
than the actual methodology
of getting the loan out of default.
That's interesting.
Now, I actually wanna close out here
with presenting to you a scenario
that I'm dealing with now with a client
that we're, her and I are gonna talk about this
next week when we meet.
She is someone who is in default,
has been in default for several years.
She's a single person high earner.
She makes about $150,000 a year,
and she has department held direct loans
and seeking to get out of default.
So she has high expenses based off
of where she lives in the county and things like that.
So we reject the initial payment offered
under the loan rehabilitation.
Mind you, she can't consolidate out of default.
Let me say that.
So loan rehabilitation, the payment was too high.
She couldn't afford it.
So we go through the expenses.
And when we go through the expenses,
we detail everything, medical, car,
utilities, all that good stuff.
And the payment comes out to about $880 a month.
And she looks at it, she's like, I can't do that.
She was like, I make $150,000 a year.
I can't do this $880 a month.
And that gave me pause,
because if you can't do this payment here,
which is based on your expenses,
and this is the only time that the government
cares about your expenses on a repayment plan,
save this very, very, very narrow exception
of repayment plan that I'm sure you'll tell me about.
Then we have to ask ourselves,
what is the value of getting out of default?
Because all I'm doing is setting you up
for failure moving forward,
if you truly can't afford this reduced payment amount.
And that's where I'm at,
but I wonder, am I missing something here
in my thought process?
So, and to say it plainly,
her IBR payment would be even higher.
Yeah, her payment under IBR would be closer to $1,400.
Her payment under WRAP as a single person
with no dependents at $150,000
would be 10% of her adjusted gross income.
So it's also going to be nearly double this reduced expense.
So where I always start those conversations is,
can you survive after default?
Because I don't want to go through all this work
if you can't.
So, you know, and I always talk about that is,
what is your payment gonna be when we're done?
Cause this is temporary.
So that would have been an interesting conversation,
but the fact that she can't even afford
to get out of default,
and she won't be able to afford it
once she's out of default,
I assume she's not very close to IBR forgiveness.
No, because she's been in default for so long.
She's had the loans for 20 plus years,
but she's been in default like 13 of those years.
How old is she?
Rough.
Not old enough yet.
She's in late 40s.
Single, no kids?
Single, no kids, $150,000 a year,
high cost of living area,
high expenses because she has some medical issues
that don't quite rise to being
a disability type issue where it prevents her from working.
And obviously a six digit balance?
Yeah, a couple hundred thousand dollars.
I'll tell you what I would think about.
Because to me, this screams budget issue.
Whether it's legitimate budget issue
is not for me to decide.
Okay, and we know, we've seen those.
But when I have someone that has a budget issue
that is going to get in the way of student loan payments,
I think two letters.
BK.
I think bankruptcy.
And I'm wondering if a chapter 13 bankruptcy,
I don't wanna talk about bankruptcy,
but I wonder if a chapter 13 wouldn't help her
reorganize her finances,
especially with the medical debts and other things,
and we don't worry about getting out of default.
Actually, I'll get to that in a minute.
We don't have to focus on the default,
we focus on her budget
so that when she comes out in five years,
she's in a better position that she can afford the loans
because everything else has straightened out.
And there are two benefits to the chapter 13 as well.
One, depending on where she is,
we can include plan language
that allows her to get out of default during the bankruptcy
and continue getting credit during the bankruptcy, maybe.
And number two, I'm gonna monitor her for those five years
because maybe she does become a good case
for an adversary proceeding
for at least a partial discharge of her loans.
We can't help but talk about bankruptcy here,
but that's the conversation I'm leaning,
that I plan to have with her is that
the math says you should be able to afford this payment
even if you live in a high cost of living area,
there may be some budget scale back some things
that you have to do to a certain point.
But if it gets to where you're saying,
no, there's actually, I don't have credit card debt,
I don't have this, I don't have that,
I literally have my rent expense or mortgage,
my car note that is reasonable considering on everything,
but I'm getting hammered by these health choices
I have to make that don't prohibit me from working,
but they do come with a lot of supplements,
they do come with a lot of therapy that I may need.
Okay, see, I don't mind that
because to me, you know what I'm hearing,
I'm hearing the potential for a discharge.
I mean, and honestly, whenever I weigh those,
the question is, is it going to affect your cashflow?
It might not, in which case maybe we don't wanna do it,
but there's also that mental weight, okay?
And I did just do this for someone,
they walked into bankruptcy owing $367,000.
And I said, you're still gonna have a high payment,
you make six digits,
but the idea of slicing that debt in half
was worth it to her, it's a conversation.
I think what people need to understand bankruptcy
in context, bankruptcy is a backup,
but it is also a shield, it's a five year shield
that at least you can focus on what's in front of you
and reorganize, that's what a chapter 13 is,
it's reorganization.
Yeah, I'm definitely thinking about that
because there's also the part of it where the emotional,
I feel like I'm failing part of this
that you have to kind of deal with there.
And because these people, you work hard as hell,
like you finally get to the point where like,
man, I've got the income that feels right,
I'm doing these things,
but I'm still battling this debt from 20 years ago
and it's hampering my life
and it feels like I actually can't quite get ahead.
And I feel for this lady because like,
yeah, like you wanna do the right thing,
you wanna get out of default,
but they're not gonna give you something
that you believe is more affordable for your budget,
like $200, $300,
like it's gonna be something more expensive.
And then we have to figure out, okay,
what's really your ability to afford
and how do we make that happen for you?
And if it is bankruptcy, cool,
if it's not, cool, we'll figure that out.
But it just sucks to have that conversation.
It does.
But we also, we glossed over the other part,
which I know that you've already addressed,
but for the audience is,
is her income really that high?
Is it all base salary?
Is there commission?
Is there bonus?
Is there capital gains?
Is there any way to handle it?
Is she a W-2 versus self-employed?
You know, there are ways.
There are definitely ways to look at the income coming in
with a more,
I would naturally lean to say creative,
but then I hear Adam Minsky in my head
coming up with something more acceptable to say
instead of creative.
You're allowed to manipulate.
Maneuver, not manipulate, maneuver.
You're allowed to maneuver.
Yeah, definitely think about that,
but we have examined all those options as well.
It just gets really tough when you're,
I think of all,
and to bring this to a close,
of every repayment option that exists
for federal student loans,
it can be really challenging to pull those payments off
as a single person with no dependents
or a small family size,
if it's just you,
because you don't get these added deductions
that help lower your payment down as other people.
And chances are,
if you do have a six-figure income as a single person,
you're typically living in an area
that costs more than other places to live at.
And your rent is gonna be somewhere between 2,000 and 3,000.
And if you're in New York,
like one of my clients,
she pays $4,400 a month rent for a 500-square-foot unit.
And again, that's why,
and I will tell you this,
I have had people where I start the conversation
with bankruptcy and like, oh, no, no, no.
But when you get down to it,
once they understand,
once you, as a credible source, explain the value of it,
it's not a bad idea.
I'm all about at least learning what's on the buffet table.
Yeah, that part.
All right, Josh, great job as always.
I want us to reconnect here in the future
to actually dive into some private student loan questions,
because I know that is going to continue to be an issue
that isn't highlighted the same way
as these federal student loans.
And that's just sheer volume,
because 93% of all student loan debt
is federal student loan debt.
Well, and that'll be converting soon.
Soon.
All right, Josh, thank you so much, man.
And have a wonderful day.
Cut out.
I'll see you next time.
Bye for now.
Bye.
