Join us for a special live recording from FinCon as we pull back the curtain on what’s happening with student loans right now. We're talking about the current state of federal programs, what's working, what's not, and where things might be headed — especially for those of you dealing with big debt loads from professional and graduate programs. If you're a doctor, lawyer, or other high-earning professional trying to make sense of all the policy changes and figure out your best repayment strategy, this behind-the-scenes conversation will give you some clarity on what to expect and how to navigate your options moving forward.
Key moments: 00:00 Introduction 01:33 Payment counts will likely be wrong, requiring borrowers to self-advocate for corrections 03:53 Without SAVE, deciding when to repay student loans vs. going for forgiveness is more complex 11:52 Confusing times ahead as borrowers navigate between old grandfathered rules and new regulations to figure out which rule sets apply to them
Hey, everybody.
Welcome to the Student Loan Planner Podcast.
It's Travis.
Megan and I are doing this live at a conference, and I thought, you know, we'd only have about
20 minutes to talk, so I just thought it'd be cool to riff about the current state of
student loans, where things are at right now, and then maybe talk a little bit about the
future state of student loans, and we're going to focus on, you know, obviously our folks
in the professional and graduate school space for the most part.
We've been talking about that a lot as a group at this conference, so it'll be fun to give
you a peek under the curtain.
So like current state right now, we have people waiting around forever for PSLF buyback.
That's a big thing, because everybody had like a year of the save forbearance, where
they were at $0 a month payments, or a lot of people did, right?
So that's a big focus.
But then also, I think what's going to be even more interesting is this IVR payment
calculation they're doing right now, because they're trying to figure out basically how
do we assess how much credit somebody should have, because the IDR account adjustment happened,
right?
Towards the longer term forgiveness.
Right.
So PSLF, interestingly, PSLF is getting processed.
We're seeing some PSLF forgiveness cases come through in our Facebook groups, and folks
emailing us saying that they got PSLF, they've seen their green ribbons, right?
So that's exciting.
But the IVR forgiveness, longer term forgiveness, we haven't seen any of that in a really, I
mean, it's been six months.
Well, it makes sense, because there's a mechanism for PSLF forgiveness, where you have an application
that tracks how much credit people actually have towards, you know, getting it discharged.
A PSLF payment tracker.
Right.
So like that didn't get undone from the PSLF waiver era.
So all that credit just got put in transparently for people to see.
And then now they have it.
It's there.
But like with the Biden administration, last second, they did the payment count tracker.
And that was based off of like the IDR account adjustment rules.
Yes.
But we saw a lot of mistakes with that.
Like we saw a lot of people get too much credit, not enough credit.
Yeah, I was going to say, it was good and bad mistakes.
Some people had a lot more credit than we thought, and we're like, that's a little...
This doesn't make sense.
We can't calculate how they calculated this.
Yes.
And then some people had way too less, not enough credit.
And we're trying to figure that out too.
So yes, Department of Ed, it looks like is going back.
And like you said, is doing their own counting, which could be good and bad too.
Well, I mean, I think what's going to happen is they're going to come out with what they
think everybody's payment counts are, and they're going to also be wrong, right?
Like a lot of them are going to be incorrect.
You're going to have to be able to advocate for yourself and say, this is why I think
I should have 12 years of credit, right?
This is why I should have X amount of credit.
And I think that, you know, people are going to have to be educated to know how to do that.
Right.
Or, you know, we're obviously, you know, we do that for people, you know, calculating
it.
What's great is there is still the NSLDS file that you could still download yourself.
We have a little converter that we use that counts up the estimated amount of months in
repayment and estimated amount of months in forbearance.
It will identify like what months you were in deferment or grace period, like if you
just graduated, for example.
So we can make some educated guesses, which is great because that gives us like a ballpark
on how much you should have.
So we know if it's way off or if it's pretty close to what it should be.
Well, and you know, with the changes going on in student loans, I think the way we should
think about it is if you're going for PSLF, go for it just no matter what.
Like if you're already if you're already at a not-for-profit or government employer anyway.
Yeah.
That's what you want to do in your career.
You like your place enough or you could see yourself going to another place that's still
eligible.
PSLF still makes a ton of sense for those that are in that field.
And if you have even a little bit of credit already built in for PSLF, then just finish
it out.
Right.
Like that's because you can now do the cap payments on IBR.
There's no downside to just doing that for people in the private sector going for forgiveness.
Here's kind of how I've been thinking about it lately.
I've been thinking if you're eligible for new IBR, you're if you owe more than you earn,
go for go for the new IBR program.
Right.
And like that's 20 years for long term forgiveness and it's 10 percent of discretionary income.
So it's still like a really nice plan.
And a lot of the newer borrowers have access to this because you borrowed, let's say, after
2014.
That's kind of the threshold, the year that we need to know about there.
Yeah.
And it's like if you are somebody who has borrowed a debt to income ratio that is.
So if you're if you're on the new system, right.
You're taking out the RIP loan max of 200K, let's say it's 200K that you leave with.
I've been thinking a little bit, Megan, about like who should pay it back and who should
not.
We used to have like we used to say like some of our old if you listen to our old stuff
before, it was like, you know, at one point we said, if your balance is two times your
income, definitely go to forgiveness.
And then we started dropping it because SAVE came out.
More generous stuff came out.
Yeah.
And then it was like it was 1.5.
Yeah.
It was 1.5 for a while.
And then it dropped with the SAVE plan, it dropped to one.
So one.
Yeah.
If you had a lot less than your income in student loan balance, probably just need to
pay it off.
And now those like rules of thumb have changed a little bit again, because now SAVE is gone.
We're having to factor in what the RAP calculations are going to look like, which the RAP calculation
payment, it is similar to SAVE and new IBR.
It's going to be a little bit more.
It's not capped.
So the payment can be as high as your income is.
But it's a 30 year timeline to forgiveness, which is a long time.
I think the way that I think about this is if you have a debt to income ratio above 1.5
to 1, and you're under the grandfathered rules where people can borrow for those three years
after 2026, right?
Like you're already in school, you're finishing out your program.
I think that it's 1.5 to 1 debt to income ratio where people can go for forgiveness
if they have more than that in debt, like their debt to income ratio is more than that.
But then I think that if you are in that 200K world of RAP, like essentially once people
are fully borrowing under the rules of RAP, whether you can take out 50K per year for
professional school, 20K, 20,500 per year for non-professional schools.
So I think that those people, I think it's more of a debt to income ratio.
I think it's honestly a two to one kind of debt to income ratio.
I think that if you have less than that, you probably will need to pay it off.
I think that a lot of people that are going to have, they're going to have the RAP eligible
loans.
I think that there's not, it's not a bad idea if you owe more than what you earn to try
to maximize interest subsidies for like the first couple of years out of graduation.
Yeah, because there are still the interest subsidies with the RAP plan where you get
a discount on interest.
So if you just decided to go borrow private, private loans are not going to have interest
subsidies, right?
They're going to charge what they charge and that's what you're paying.
But RAP does have those subsidies that could be taken advantage of.
And RAP is still, I still lean towards, it still makes sense to borrow what you can federal
because there's still more flexibility.
Like you still have the access to the income driven plan RAP if your income isn't what
you thought it was going to be, or you have to take a sabbatical for some reason.
There's more generous forbearance rules still when it comes to, you know, needing to take
time off from payments.
There's still the death and disability discharge, like that is not existent with private loans.
So some folks might be thinking, well, with these new borrowing limits in the future,
should I just borrow all private?
Like is it all just about the interest rate?
And I think the answer is still no.
It's not just about the interest rate at the end of the day, but you may be someone who
is probably long-term going to refinance and pay off your loans.
Well, I think about this like at a higher level for the future of student loans, like
who should borrow, who should go to graduate school, who should go to professional school,
right?
Like, I think that the reality is, is if somebody's taken out a bunch of loans to go be a dentist
or a veterinarian or a lawyer, does that make sense at a base level?
And the answer is yes, it does.
You're going to make more.
The only time it doesn't make sense is if you are really like struggling, like you're
unsure of what you want to do with your life.
You're not sure that you want to do that.
You think you might career change later.
Like if that's you, go travel around Europe.
Like do what I did at the Backpack Travels in Latin America.
You know, like go make some some silly mistakes.
Go, go surf down a volcano.
That was the thing that people did when I was in Nicaragua and I was in my mid-twenties.
People were getting on like skateboards and like surfing down like a Nicaraguan volcano
or something.
I'm like, that seems like crazy, but you know, I think you do that to get out all of your
like angst and fear in your life and you try to find yourself.
And then if you find yourself, it's like, well, you're going to commit to doing something
in your career, right?
You're not going to commit to doing nothing.
So what do you enjoy the most?
What do you enjoy about a profession?
You know, do you think you would more often than not like the work that you get into in
the profession, right?
You can intern and so there, you know, you could be a vet tech, see what it's all about
going into the vet office.
If your heart is calling you to be a vet, you could go work as a receptionist at a dental
office like a firm or a law firm, like figure out if that's what you actually want to do.
Like test it out first, because that is a big investment.
I think I think the way we have to think about the new rules of student loans is if you take
out RIP max of 50K a year, you're going to need most people are going to need somewhere
between 10 and 30K extra per year.
And so you're going to graduate your professional school program, something between 50 and 100K
on average of private loans.
That's going to be the new model, plus the federal.
The federal is still a percent of income.
It's still 10 percent of income.
So it can't wreck you by definition.
But you have to balance both payments, though.
You do.
So I think the angle is attack the private like your life depends on it.
After you graduate, pay off all the private loans and now you basically have freedom.
I guess maybe throw on a six month emergency fund.
Yeah, right.
Because I mean, I was like when I was backpacking in my 20s, like there were people that completely
ran out of money and they had nothing to go home.
Well, they didn't go home.
They they like found a hostel that would let them stay for free.
Yeah.
And they would like find like it was just funny, like they would just do odd jobs like
around the hostel for like a little spending money.
And they would just stay in the hostel for like months until they like like really ran
out of money.
And then they had to like call mom or dad to get a plane ticket home, you know, after
they were desperate.
But like but so I guess the thing is, like, you know, I think so.
I think here's the here's a thought, right?
So many people are so fearful in their lives from all the changes in the world and the
economy.
Right.
Like and people feel stress.
We're on our phones all the time.
Like we're dealing with social media stuff, doing scrolling.
And it's not good for us.
Right.
And how do we have positivity in our lives and how do we get some encouragement in our
lives to say, hey, you know what?
If you go to law school or vet school or dental school, like as long as you don't borrow more
than, let's say, two and a half times your income, you know, you'll be fine.
Like we can help you.
We can figure it out.
Like you might have to go through some periods of sacrifice to pay off your private loans,
especially.
But then it's going to give you the life that you want.
Exactly.
And you're going to have the flexibility to work three days a week if you wanted to in
some situations.
Right.
There's still ways to build in like financial independence, financial flexibility, like
even if the structure is going to be a lot different than what we've experienced in the
past.
Yeah. And it's like, what kind of life do you want?
Like if you want to live in, you know, D.C.
or, you know, New York or something, maybe you're better off going to a top law school
where big law is like that's the center of big law and you can get a really high paying
job there, you know, or and if you want to be, you know, in health care, like maybe go
somewhere, you know, where some of these podcasters say go where they ain't, you know,
like if you go somewhere like, you know, I'm going to never forget, like we have all these
orthodontist clients, right.
And in Kansas City, you know, suburbs are making 400,000, 500,000 a year in like, you
know, New York, New Jersey suburbs, maybe they're making 250, right.
And it's a higher cost of living area.
So it's sort of like, you know, what kind of life do you want?
And think about do your professional school ambitions match the life you want?
Right. And that's a real mature kind of decision.
Yes. It's a lot better than I think what we have had historically.
It was like, well, I'll just go to school because people told me I need to go to
school. Yeah. Like, I mean, if we think about it, like with the pharmacy schools that we
were, I always use this example because pharmacy school publishes a bunch of statistics
that's transparent. And in 2003, there was like 43 pharmacy schools, I think, and it
was a 34 percent acceptance rate, something like that.
And then it grew to having like 140 schools with an 87 percent acceptance rate.
Is it good that pharmacy school has a policy of if you have a pulse, we'll let you in?
No, I mean, no, it's not because you're preying on people.
You're preying on, you know, people's dreams and stuff.
When maybe some of those people would be better off not getting into a field that
they're not super passionate about.
Right. Yeah. So I don't know.
It's going to be, you know, a wild, wild west situation with, you know, with
professional school this coming fall.
And I think that we can be helping people think positively about it because it's the
only constructive way to think about it.
Yeah. You know, I have to move forward.
And it is going to be a confusing time, especially over the next four years, because
there's rules that are grandfathered.
But then there's new rules that come in and we have to figure out where do you sit
when it comes to borrowing at that point?
And people are going to be in a hybrid situation, right?
Yeah. Which is, you know, usually I love hybrid approaches because it means we've got
like a foot in the door.
We've got some options, but I don't quite love that.
Well, what's going to happen?
What's going to happen is they made all the rules and we haven't seen the negative
impacts yet. And usually in politics, when you see a bunch of negative impacts on
things, that's when something changes, changes.
Right. So I think that if you start seeing programs close, there's going to be a
little bit of a freak out.
Right. Yes. And there's going to be a recession at some point.
And then in a recession, the private lenders are not going to be able to make the
loans. People need to go to the schools.
And so at some point, right, you will see an increased, you know, an increased role
for government again in the private and in the student loan market.
As soon as Democrats have universal control of Washington, it's going to go back to a
lot more similar, similar arrangement to what the same plan was.
I think, yeah. So I think people just have to take a deep breath, know that this is a
time transition. It's a time of stress for a lot of people and know that there's
going to be some some negative outcomes for some people.
But to know that, you know, ultimately you do have the power to make good decisions.
Yeah. And you can make the best decision that you know to make today and then make
sure you've got ways to pivot to.
Yeah. And, you know, when we look at people's finances, the vast majority of them are
not coming close to optimizing everything.
Right. But they're leaving a hundred K in a bank account, earning zero percent or two
percent or something. Yeah.
They're getting an old 401k account or they're not invested.
Dependent care FSAs for their kids to pay for, you know, daycare with pre pre-tax dollars
or they're forgetting that 8606 form when doing backdoor Roths and having to redo
taxes. And they're not aware of their marginal tax rate.
So you're working five days a week but not realizing that you're getting taxed at a
higher rate on that like last thousand dollars of income compared to the first thousand
dollars of income. Right.
So like a lot of people, a lot of times they've got a car payment or something.
Hey, what if you like drove a 2012 Camry and had no car payment, you could work four
days a week instead of five. Right.
So there's all kinds of positive thinking that I think people can do and their
finances to optimize things.
And also, you know, so many people are living and living in such fear.
Right. Like when I talked to a lot of the professional school people there, I'm like,
what if you went down to part time?
What if you took a break from work?
Would you be able to get another job?
And then usually their answer is like in a heartbeat.
Yeah. And I'm like, OK, why aren't you using your power?
You know, why aren't you using your leverage and your control that you have over your
life situation to live the life that you want to live?
We want to get that's really our mission.
Ultimately, how do we do this?
You don't put on podcasts. Why do we keep coming back for more pain?
You know, in this on market.
Right. It's I mean, shoot, like true crime is more fun.
I'm convinced. But like, you know, I think it's just like it's because we love helping
people achieve their potential and their calling in their lives.
We love that. And we think more people deserve to live that.
And you deserve to live that if you're watching this.
Right. So, I mean, any last thoughts on current state or future state for student loan
borrowers? Stay tuned.
You know, we'll continue to cover these things.
I think it's interesting that schools are quiet.
We talked about that. Schools are so quiet.
Lenders are so quiet. There's no one talking about like the borrower limits that are
changing. So there's going to be some like, I think, stuff that's going to come out in
the future that we'll have plenty of.
Well, and my last thought is just, yeah, this coming fall, next fall is going to be
chaos for a lot of schools and for schools and for people going to school.
And if you're an existing borrower, just know that you need to deep breathe, focus on
your plan. It still works.
You know, the strategies still work.
It's only around the edges that we might have to have certain people, you know, pay off
their loans, certain people not.
And, you know, we can have those conversations if we need to.
We can make some pivots.
Yeah. Folks, if you have any questions you want to ask us, go to studentloanplanner.com
slash voicemail and ask your question.
You can press the record button on your mobile phone and we'll love to get your
questions for some future pod episodes.
But thank you so much for listening to the Student Loan Planner podcast, and we hope
you have a great rest of your week.
Thanks for hanging out with us.
Are you on the free Student Loan Planner email list?
If yes, you could upgrade your experience and discover student loan loopholes so
good, they might get repealed if I talk about them publicly.
Find out my very best thought leadership that I really just can't be super open about
anymore, unfortunately. If you want to get our very best tips, not just the ones that I
can share for free, then go to studentloanplanner.com slash insider to get a special
discount for your year membership.
That's studentloanplanner.com slash insider and get our very best dozens of bonus
content and tips that's going to save you money and get you out of student debt faster.
And if you're already an SLP insider, please reply back to those emails and let me
know how I can make it even more valuable.