RAP vs. IDR: Who Should Switch & Why This New Plan Might Save You Thousands

Finance Lenders
2 followers
10 Video Views·Aug 5, 2025
Stanley Tate and Atty. Joshua Cohen breaks down the new RAP student loan repayment plan. They explain how RAP compares to SAVE and IBR, what’s changing with family size rules, and who should consider switching. If you have Parent PLUS loans or a high balance, there are deadlines and trade-offs you need to know. Start planning now before RAP goes live in 2026.
All right. Now, I want to make sure I clarify one thing here. You said it was the Republican plan. Can you kind of tell us why it's a Republican plan or the conservative plan?
This was this is what was offered by our conservative majority Congress.
And that's all I got for you.
I think what I what is noticeable in this without making political just saying facts is that this is one of the only plans that we have introduced where there was no bipartisan support for it.
There was not a single Democrat who voted for in favor of the plan. Now, to be fair, this plan was part of a much larger bill that did not lead itself into voting for it on an individual basis. It was all or nothing type thing.
But I wanted to just make sure we clarify that point now. So wrap is this plan that exists for student loan repayment moving forward. And we got here through the one big, beautiful bill.
What does this wrap plan actually mean in terms of student loan repayment.
So it is an income plan. That's number one that is based on income. It is simplified from what we're used to. There's no poverty index part of this.
Your family size loosely plays a role in this. It is it is what the conservatives have asked for. It is a simplified income plan.
All right. And how does this plan work in comparison to, say, the same plan or income based repayment plan?
OK, so the similarity is they both start with the debtors adjusted gross income.
They both allow. And when I say both, I mean, income driven repayment that we're used to versus wrap.
Both of them allow for married filing separately if you don't want to use your spouse's income.
One key difference in order to use your children as a factor in family size for wrap, they must be an actual dependent listed on your tax return.
You are taking them as a dependent. And if you do, you get to subtract fifty dollars a month out of your base payment.
So, again, different than how it's used for income driven repayment plans.
And the formula is simplified. It is a matter of looking at your adjusted gross income and there is a sliding scale of percentages.
Percentage of your AGI is used to figure out your base or annual payment.
It's very simple. You could use an advocate as cake.
Yeah, it actually is a really simple plan because under the existing income driven repayment plans, which I also would argue is actually quite simple as well for most of them, except for ICR.
That you would just simply look at the poverty guidelines by that year and then add a multiplier of either one point five or two point two five in a case of say, and then do a little bit of extra math from there and spit your monthly payment.
But that family size part, I think I always want to pause there because I think that is the under reported part of rap is how it drastically shrinks what we.
Historically have meant by family size.
And can you kind of dive into a little bit more for me?
OK, so let's start with income driven repayment that we're used to.
You, as a person, count your number one for your family size.
If you're married and you're using a married file jointly tax return, your spouse becomes person number two in your family size.
That does not happen with rap.
That doesn't matter for family size, whether your family one or family two, because you're married, doesn't affect the end result.
OK, for IDR, they ask how many children are in your family that you support at least half time?
No real proof is required for that.
For rap, it's how many dependents do you claim on your taxes, period?
So the proof is your tax return.
And one of the questions I have, I'm going to slide this in here is if you have someone not using their taxes as proof of income, do you lose the deduction?
Do you lose the ability to use your child if you're not using your tax return as proof?
That is a question we don't know.
We don't know that answer yet.
Right, and then so what we're saying is that under rap, the difference in how family size is defined, it not only affects the count for when you are married, but it also affects the count for children.
And before under these income driven repayment plans, you can claim a family size of your kids that live with you or that live outside of the household that you provide more than half the support for.
So IE kids away at college, IE, you have shared custody with another parent.
So you have those instances, but then also you have the family size for other adults living with you as well that has been taken away from you under rap.
And if you could speak a little bit more to that as well, please.
So it wasn't uncommon to have a situation.
Their adult children were living with them for whatever reason, maybe they're building a house and staying with them for a while.
So now they've got their adult children and their grandchildren, and that would have counted for family size under IDR.
It won't count for rap unless somehow you're claiming them on your taxes as deductions.
And for some people, you're talking about reducing a family size of five down to one or two.
Yeah, I think about I have one of my clients where she is in San Diego, she makes about one hundred twenty thousand a year, but she is the only person in our household that works.
She takes care of her brother, who is disabled, but does not draw significant disability monies.
She takes care of her mother, who was on a fixed low Social Security income.
And then she takes care of her sister's kids as well.
And so she's the only one that's really generating any income here.
And under this kind of formula moving forward, she may lose access to under wraps.
She will lose access to her mother.
She will lose access to her brother.
And she may or may not lose access to claiming the two children's part of the family size unless she can also claim them as dependents on the tax return.
And that matters because there are two real levers to lower your payments here for student loan purposes.
Either you decrease your adjusted gross income or you increase your family size.
And under wrap, one of those levers is being targeted in a way that makes it less effective to lower your monthly payments.
And the last scenario to point out is in utero would count on income driven repayment.
There's no way to make it count under wrap because you can't take a deduction.
Right. So if you're currently pregnant, you get to claim them as part of income driven repayment plan, but you can't do that under wrap.
And so family size is drastically different under wrap than it was under income driven repayment.
So that that is a downside of wrap.
And I don't want to hammer it at home too much, but I think it does matter that we laid it out.
But there are some benefits under wrap that make it really attractive to borrowers.
Can you talk through those options?
So and and what I think is even more important to highlight here is remember, wrap is a conservative offered plan.
These are the same people that attacked save and sued, saying save was too generous.
And yet they took one of the biggest benefits of save.
Wrap has an interest waiver.
If your payment doesn't cover interest, any of that unpaid interest is waived.
Save is too generous, but hey, let's take this from it.
What? Yeah, OK.
And so so that's one.
And they got even more generous.
What? Conservative and generous.
You don't often hear in the same sentence, but here we have it because there's also a principal reduction.
If your payment doesn't reduce your principal by at least fifty dollars, the government will kick in however much is needed to
make sure your principal is reduced by fifty dollars every month.
All right. So we have the drawback of wrap is that the big one is family size changes.
But then the upside is that they waive the unpaid interest.
And then there's a secondary benefit with payment toward principal as well that helps drive down the balance.
That's the benefit or those are the main benefits in setting aside having the lower monthly payment option.
One thing we hadn't discussed yet, though, is cost of living adjustments.
And I know that word isn't really used in terms that phrasing isn't used in terms of these repayment plans.
But income driven repayment has this adjustment on an annual basis based off of the poverty guidelines where it's
every year it increases that protects more of your income to keep up with inflation.
Does rap have something similar?
Not that I read. I didn't I didn't notice anything.
No. Right.
And so that's one of my concerns is that you may have a teaser rate that I'll call it under wrap that may appear that is lower in years one, maybe lower in years two, but may actually get prohibitively more expensive over time
depending without such an adjustment is a concern of mine.
But I truthfully, I haven't modeled out all scenarios here.
Well, and I think and I'm just going to throw this out here.
Being a very tax novice is as standard deductions change from the IRS.
That is where I guess you catch it, because remember, our pain is based on AGI and that's affected by deduction.
So maybe that's where we see some some.
Maybe that's where we see, but then arguably under you already had those standard reductions helping you out under income driven repayment to drive down your AGI.
So you're still losing it anyways under wrap because you no longer have that discretionary income modifier that's there on an annual basis.
All right. So we have it.
We have our ground laid.
We have some pros of it.
We have some cons of it.
But now we need to kind of dive into who actually needs to choose rap.
So if I'm a current borrower and I am currently enrolled in either save or IBR, do I have or pay as you earn or income contingent repayment?
Do I have to move into rap?
No, you never have to move into rap.
And I think we should say based on our date, rap is not yet available.
It will be available by July 2026.
We don't really know when I get the feeling that Ed's going to speed it up, but it's good to make the decision now to start running those numbers now so that you're not going, oh, my God, it's available.
What do I do?
Plan, OK, so you don't have to sign up for rap today.
More importantly, you don't you are not going to be forced into rap either.
Correct.
What you will have to do talk about decisions is eventually all of the income driven repayment plans will be crunched into income based repayment.
There will be a day, I believe, by July 1st, 2028, where pay will go away.
ICR will go away and you will be funneled into income based repayment.
That is, to me, the point at which you need to decide, do I want to stay with IBR?
Do I want to switch to rap?
Yeah. And right now I can imagine people are like, OK, especially with the safe plan with interest resuming, they're probably like, what does that mean for me?
And what I would say there, for those of you who are the day we're recording this video is July 23rd.
As of right now, interest is going to start resuming on your safe plan payments come August 1st.
But payments aren't going to be resuming.
And you also aren't being forced to make a choice on your repayment plan today.
So just to be very clear, if you're someone in any income driven repayment plan today, you do not have to switch to rap today.
And more importantly, you can't even switch to it because it's not ready yet.
But you don't have to switch to it.
It is your choice when it becomes available to do so.
Correct.
All right. Now we have that part set up.
Now, what if I'm a borrower who is not in an income driven repayment plan come the time rap becomes available, say July 1st, 2026?
Will I still have access to income driven repayment or rap?
Or do I only have rap at that point if I have not enrolled in an IDR plan yet?
So it is my understanding and I say this with a grain of salt because I'm happy to be overruled on this one.
It is my understanding you must pick an IDR plan by July of twenty twenty eight.
You've got to be enrolled.
If you want IDR after that, you've got to be in it by July twenty twenty eight.
That's when the gate closes.
You're either on it or you're not.
So you've got time.
So you'll have two years to compare rap to IDR where you want to go.
And so, again, if you want IDR, you've got to be on it by July twenty twenty eight.
I think I think that point matters, though, because if it does work out like that, where you're someone who are is allowed to stay to prolong your choice of signing up for IDR.
I could imagine someone who is at the peak of their earning, but they're getting ready to retire in the next couple of years.
And so they may be better served with an extended or graduated plan during this time to get a lower payment, let alone a forbearance as well, potentially for the next couple of years before switching into an income driven repayment.
Because arguably their IDR payment would be higher today than the extended or graduated plan would.
Right now, there is a caveat here, which I think you want to bring up.
Parent plus loans.
Exactly.
Tell me more about this.
Okay, so parent plus loans can have an income driven payment plan if and only if those parent plus loans are inside a consolidation.
They have to be inside a consolidation.
That consolidation does have a deadline.
And that deadline is July 1st, 2026.
So we are now 11 months, 10 months away from that deadline.
Your loan needs to be fully funded, fully consolidated on June 30th, 2026.
You want to know that it's done.
That means to me, you want that application in by, I'm going to say, February 15th, 2026, because I don't know how long these things are taking.
But parent plus loan borrowers, so anyone with a parent plus loan today, only has until June 30 of the next year to get into an IDR plan.
And for those of you who have not yet consolidated, consolidation typically takes in good times, six to eight weeks.
But what we've seen, at least in my practice, is sometimes it takes upwards of three and a half to four months to get done, depending on who the loans are getting paid off on the underlying side.
So if you want to make sure that you're in an income driven repayment plan, as someone parent plus loans, I think the latest you can wait is until mid February, as you said, to start that consolidation process.
But keep in mind, you only need to worry about this if you're not yet consolidated with parent plus.
And if you don't mind, I think we should talk about the reasoning behind that.
It sure.
Yeah, I think we can talk about there because next I want to get into like the whole point of the video, which is like who is wrapped good for.
But let's kind of make sure we hammer home just why that exists for parent plus loans.
Right. And to be clear, across the board, here's why any new loan originated July 1st, 2026 or later.
No matter what kind of federal loan it is, whether it's a brand new Stafford or a consolidation loan, cannot have these traditional income driven repayment plans.
You are locked out if you have an origination date, July 1st, 2026 or later.
Thus, a parent plus loan that needs a consolidation must be completed before that deadline.
That's why this is not targeting parent plus loans.
It's because of the underlying reason that origination date.
Absolutely. All right.
And I guess to fully close that loop, is it your understanding that the only the consolidation needs to be completed by June 30th, 2026?
Or does it need to be fully dispersed and enrolled in an income driven plan by that date?
It must be fully funded.
You must have a brand new consolidation originated, meaning funded by June 30th, 2026.
You can do IDR later by 2028, but you've got to have a qualifying loan that consolidation before that deadline in July 2026.
All right.
And we'll definitely come back on a later video and dive into the parent plus loan intricacies here because there's going to sure to be a lot of concerns over the next several months.
But I want to set that part aside.
And I want to now dive fully into this kind of math you've been doing because I posed a question to you and to others.
Who is RAP good for?
If you are an existing borrower on an income driven repayment plan, who is the right person to switch into RAP?
Because I can't figure it out.
Who could it be?
So you've done some work here.
You've kind of come up with an avatar for this.
Sort of.
And I think and so it's interesting for income driven repayment.
When we talked about, OK, who is this good for?
It was pretty much good for everybody.
We had a rule of thumb with IDR, which is if you owe more than you earn, IDR is for you.
Makes sense.
Well, that rule of thumb still works for income driven plans in general, whether it's IVR or RAP.
But it doesn't help us discern IVR versus RAP.
If we want to get into that comparison, it is a matter of both how much you earn and how much you owe.
And that's where it becomes a little wonky.
I don't know that I have a solid avatar, but I chose to dive into it because.
Whether I like RAP or not is immaterial.
What I want to know is how does it work and when does it work and when it works, how good is it?
And my my finding is, wow, when it works, it really works.
It works well.
OK, so what's the easiest question to answer?
So look, the bottom line is when we do this, we need to be running numbers for both income based
and RAP.
You're going to have to look at them back to back.
And on the surface, you're going to see, well, which is the better payment plan?
Which is cheaper?
We can talk about the lowest end.
IVR still allows a $0 payment if your income is low enough.
RAP has a floor of $10.
OK, 10 versus zero, not much of a comparison, but it is still important to realize you will
have a payment with RAP.
It will be at least $10 a month, which means for those of you that are senile or those of
you that aren't good, you know, controlling your finances, IVR is nice because you can
skip a $0 payment.
You could forget to pay it.
It's zero.
You can't forget to pay your $10 RAP.
So it's a small management issue.
But think about it.
I have seniors where I'm talking to their kids who say, my dad's going to forget to
make a payment.
Well, it's zero.
I'm not worried about that.
With $10, I am.
But I guess the reverse of that is the whole point of putting in this minimum payment is
to have people actively engage with the system instead of being passively engaged with it
on an annual basis.
And the underlying theory, I guess, is that with that active engagement, they're more
likely to properly manage their loan and not default.
But I think you and I have been at this long enough that we can just foresee a series of
people, maybe not necessarily defaulting, but with severe delinquencies, tarnishing
their credit over time by maybe the ATM card they tied it to changed.
Or maybe they just simply forgot to update and do these other things.
And now they have this penalty that has these long, far-reaching consequences.
But all right.
So that is that minimum.
But I still don't think I know who is it good for or when does it actually work?
When does it really work?
I guess what's the easier question to answer?
Here's what I found.
I think the balance is a much larger factor for WRAP and this comparison.
OK, tell me more.
How does that work?
OK, the reason I say it's a factor is because, again, WRAP has that interest waiver.
Now, when we grew up, I say grew up our practices with IBR, interest would still accrue.
And you would have, I love this word, negative amortizing loans.
What the hell is that?
Negative amortizing means your payment doesn't even cover interest.
Now, where in the real world would we ever allow that?
We wouldn't.
But federal loans allow it.
Hey, make your payment.
That doesn't even cover interest.
We don't care.
You'll get it forgiven eventually.
That was always our line.
Don't worry about interest.
It'll be forgiven.
Well, WRAP went a step further, borrowed from SAVE and said,
not only do you not worry about your interest, it'll never negative amortize.
If you don't cover your interest, we, the government, will cover it.
So now, so we go back to the balance and the interest accrual compared to your payment.
With IBR, if you're not covering your interest, your loan grows.
We hear about this all the time.
But with WRAP, it won't grow.
If you start with the loan balance.
What is the problem with it growing though?
So what did I owe $150,000 today and $300,000 later with interest?
So long as I can afford my bills and I'm not defaulting my credits,
okay, and it's going to be forgiven anyways.
Why does the balance matter?
Tax bomb.
There are those people worried about the tax bomb because remember,
and here's something else they didn't really publicize.
WRAP comes with forgiveness.
What?
Yes, conservatives are also going to forgive our loans.
It's a longer time.
It's 30 years, but you still get forgiveness.
So now there are tax bomb implications.
If IBR makes your loan double versus WRAP where your loan sits and treads water,
there could be tax bomb implications down the road.
Now, why do you say could be?
Well, we are hoping that Senator Durbin and others on both sides of the aisle
will continue the conversation of making these forgivenesses non-taxable.
Before this particular Congress, there were good discussions on both sides of the aisle
about making this forgiveness non-taxable, in which case interest wouldn't matter.
Yeah, I think my historic bias has been when it comes to my clients, for the most part,
I don't care about interest because many of them aren't in financial positions
to make other choices.
They really need to optimize for the lowest payment possible.
And so you have to deal with the fallout of that choice is that
there may be some tax liability on the back end.
And I've always been comforted by the fact that A,
taxes are dischargeable in bankruptcy after three years from the date of filing.
B, you can set up a payment plan with the IRS as well for that,
whatever that taxable amount is, which is still gonna be cheaper than the overall student loan
payment that you were making or the balance that you had forgiven.
And C, there's an insolvency exemption as well for certain borrowers.
And I've always kind of posited that the same way we set up Medicaid or Medicare
trust, we can take advantage of those to also shield ourselves from tax liability
as well to create an insolvency.
That's a separate conversation.
That's a lot more technical.
You're correct.
Absolutely correct.
But I always just thought taxes, I always think the tax bond implications is kind of
overblown.
I agree.
A very real fear.
Very real.
I don't wanna discount it at all.
But you don't know what the future is going to be 10, 20 years from now,
and you're just trying to survive today.
You are absolutely correct.
So I answered your question, but I also wholeheartedly agree with what you just said.
That is so far down.
I love that people say, what about the tax?
And my response is, you don't have a choice because you can't afford the standard payment.
So take what you've got, survive, enjoy, raise your kids.
They're gonna be taxed when you're retired.
What are they gonna get?
But now you have a choice.
You have a choice to flip from IDR plans, income driven repayments, save IBR, et cetera,
to wrap that will not do anything about your existing interest, your existing balance,
but it will stop it from growing and becoming a larger problem in the future,
which can have some financial protection, but also has a very real emotional protection as well,
not seeing your balance below.
It has the emotional, but there is also the small credit factor.
Your credit isn't going to show a loan growing, which for some people.
Well, see, I think the credit part is always kind of overblown because I've
seen clients who have million dollar balances and 800 credit scores.
Yes.
What people always forget.
Okay. Number one, the credit score is marketing garbage.
We both know that as consumer attorneys.
It is.
It's not what the creditors see anyway.
And two, it's not about the full balance.
It's about your monthly payment, your debt to income ratio on a monthly payment.
But I do get that wrap is going to stop your balance from growing.
And there is forgiveness after 30 years for all borrowers.
And you get to bring your forgiveness credits you've already accrued,
whatever that total number is, which we don't know since they haven't released the tracker yet.
But you will bring that credit forward into rap if you so choose to move into it.
And that balance will be forgiven at the end of 30 years.
And you may or may not owe taxes on whatever that amount is.
And so from your position, you're positing that someone with a much larger balance
actually can benefit more from rap than they otherwise would under, say, IBR.
Right.
And again, so so that that additional factor when comparing IBR to rap is going to be
what is your current balance and what's your interest rate?
Okay.
A 3.5 interest rate is not going to be as big a deal as a 6.8.
That those of us who are at 9%, right?
Oh, you know, we should mention this.
Parent plus borrowers can't have rap.
There you go.
Yeah.
For that part that parent plus loan borrowers don't actually have the choice for rap whatsoever.
What about though?
Clear this up.
What about those borrowers who are under the impression that by double consolidating,
they remove the parent plus loan label from their loan?
So technically, they no longer have parent plus loans.
Are they eligible for rap?
No, because the government fixed the glitch in the system.
They can tell if you have a parent plus ever.
If it's part of this new consolidation that you've doubled that you've done three times,
they can still see it.
They will stop you from having rap.
But, but while we're there, you don't need the double consolidation anymore because of
the announcement last week.
If you consolidate your parent plus, you can have IVR right now.
Yeah, there's a whole parent plus loan conversation that happened here.
I was just thinking I was going to interrupt you because I was, I actually did a triple
double consolidation for a client where he wanted all three of his daughters to have
their own separate double consolidation loan for their own debts.
It was the worst thing, bro.
It was like 12 different consolidation loans.
That's good for you.
But the fallout is every daughter now has their own loan that they can look and say,
I make the payment for this, even though the obligation is still his,
they now know what their payment is.
All right, digression aside.
Getting back to rap.
We are saying that it can be super beneficial for someone who is worried about the balance
growing that is, has a high balance with a high interest rate with, and then they have
a longer time toward forgiveness beyond the five years.
Maybe they are six, seven, eight, nine, 10, 12, 15 years away from their finish line today.
That'd be super beneficial for them to switch over.
It could be.
I mean, look, as we tell everyone, your unique circumstances are going to help us figure
out what works for your unique answer, but the trend, I know you're burning for this.
What's the trend, Josh?
The trend that I'm seeing is middle income with higher balances, not high, but higher
relative to their interest rate.
So give me a, give me a, a kind of a concrete example that you want.
So I ran two examples.
So I ran one example of a single person with no dependents that's earning $50,000 a year.
Okay.
A general example.
And that's in this spreadsheet here.
Yes.
And they, they earn 50,000, but they owe a hundred thousand.
Okay.
In my practice, that is not, that's common.
I see that all the time.
All right.
So we're talking at line 24 example, single earning 50K owes a hundred K at 6.8%.
6.8%.
Yes.
This is actually my generation.
That's what I'm seeing.
Okay.
All right.
So that person would pay 352 under IBR, but under WRAP their payment would be 167.
Which is already half.
Okay.
That's a 50% discount.
So it's already a no brainer, but let's talk about the benefits of it.
Not just cash in your pocket, right?
So with this payment, the, the monthly interest on this is about 575 a month, 574 to be exact.
Okay.
That means your IBR loan is not paying $222 of your interest under income-based repayment.
Your loan grows by $222 a month.
Your loan's getting bigger.
That could, that feels weird.
With WRAP, you're paying even less interest.
You're missing $407 of interest a month, but the government's going to pay it for you.
So your loan isn't going to grow.
So you're paying less and getting a larger interest waiver.
Two benefits, more cash in your pocket and your loan is not growing.
It stays at the a hundred thousand that you stayed at.
That that's, that's just a no brainer.
Now.
So the question then is, yeah, but Josh, I'm going to have to pay for five more extra years.
All right.
You don't, you, you don't have to be a mathematician to see you're already going to win here.
Yes.
You pay for five more years, but you've been paying half of what IBR would have been.
So you still come out ahead.
I did run the full numbers.
All right.
So IBR paid after 25 years.
You, and again, this is just assuming the income is flat because it's hard to model
it out over 25 years.
But if we just keep the numbers the same, they're going to pay back $105,000.
So they'll pay back slightly more than what they borrowed.
Exactly.
With WRAP, you'll have only paid $60,000.
So you paid a lot less, even though you're paying for five more years.
So this is an example where WRAP wins and down.
Yeah.
And I guess like, if I kind of extrapolate this out, this model assumes someone's income
is staying flat over time, which would not align itself with a new graduate leaving college
because we expect their income to grow over time.
What this does show is maybe you are someone who borrowed later in life for education.
And now you're on a fixed income moving forward.
And you, or you've already passed the peak of your earning potential, et cetera.
So we can predict your income moving forward without these huge increases that this can
work out for you, especially if you're single.
But again, this, it's a single, and this again was just my attempt at looking at, well,
where does WRAP really shine?
And here's an example.
It shines here.
And I absolutely agree with a situation like this, where we have kind of this, a very static
income situation.
I think, and the whole purpose of WRAP, I shouldn't say think, the whole purpose of
WRAP is to capture more of someone's peak earning potential over time.
And so obviously the government wants to pay more when you're at your highest earning
potential, so then they could better fund this system moving forward, which is a very
sound policy.
And yet it doesn't become, it doesn't become all that helpful to you when you're like,
you are starting a family in your 30s, because that's when we start families now.
You're buying a house at 38, because that's when we're buying houses now.
And your payments are also increasing in coordination with your income increasing.
And maybe it doesn't look as beneficial to you, especially when you count that it doesn't
have the same family size contribution.
It doesn't have the same cost of living adjustment on an annual basis.
Right.
Which is to say, this is all very impossible to really say who's it right for, for those
people who have the choice.
I mean, look, you're gonna, I mean, the reason why we're modeling it now is because you are,
you do need to make that choice in the next three years.
Yeah.
So who do you feel most comfortable with today, kind of leaning towards rap as a choice?
I think for me, it is, it is, I think from my first rough overview, it is people that
earn, it's almost that same rule of thumb, earning less than or equal to what they owe.
I think that's going to be it.
Because again, you, you, you, here's the real question.
How much of your IBR payment is covering, rephrase, how much of your interest is covered
by your IBR payment?
Because I actually picked an example.
The second example that I have is a family of four.
They're married and they have two children.
They earn 75,000, but they owe 75,000 with an interest rate of five and a half percent.
Okay.
Now what's interesting here is the difference between IBR is 375 rap is 338.
That's only $40 a month.
Okay.
It's only a $40 a month difference.
So now we still want one of them because their standard payment is 461.
So we still want one of these income driven payments.
Okay.
Now, what I found here is the accrued interest per month is 344.
So your income payment, your IBR actually covers interest.
And we'll pay an extra $31 a month of principal $31.
So, but, but the point is this, this IBR still moves your loan forward.
Whereas wrap doesn't cover the interest wrap is 338 versus your interest or three to 44.
So here there's $6 a month of interest not being paid.
The government's going to waive it.
So with wrap, you stand still with IBR, you're paying a little bit of the principal,
but here's another benefit.
Not only are you saving $40 a month on wrap.
Remember there's that $50 principal reduction that the government gives you.
So with IBR, you pay $31 of principal with wrap.
You don't even touch principal, but the government will subsidize and pay down $50 a month.
So your loan is reducing more, even though you're saving $40 a month in your pocket.
Here again is where wrap is a clear winner, not just the $40 a month,
but it's actually a value of, of $90 a month.
You're saving 40 and your principal is reducing by 50.
It's just, but the trade-off is over five more years, I'm gonna pay $9,000 more.
Your model shows wrap I'll pay back 121,000 under IBR, I'll only pay back 112,000.
But I guess the difference then is if you assume a tax liability on the back end,
that I'm actually being taxed on less because the government's only forgiving under wrap
57,000 under IBR after 25 years, they're forgiving 112,000.
Exactly.
Sorry.
The IBR balance on this one after 25 years is 65,000, 65,000, because you have paid a little.
IBR paid, sorry about that.
You're paying back 112,000.
So it's kind of apples to oranges here.
I mean, dollars to dollars, kind of the same thing here, 57,000, 65,000.
Yeah.
That's being forgiven.
So maybe the real trade-off then is just that extra five years.
Yeah.
The trade-off is, and look, we can't use this as a firm model because we expect this is a static
model.
When you start building in cost of living and are they, look, the kids are going to move out,
we hope, right?
Which means this won't be a family of four forever.
It'll be a family of two.
Maybe they get to more than a family of one.
Yeah.
It's so hard to model it out.
Yes.
And this is where I instinctively, I am defaulting back to, I just want my clients to do IBR
unless there's someone who has a very rigid situation that we don't anticipate changing over
time.
Right.
And only people I can think that fit that description are my retirees on social security.
And we can model that out because there's less dynamic factors happening here.
And so, yeah, I mean, one of the questions, how old is this family of four?
Are the couple 50 years old and they're only 15 years away from retirement?
Or is this a brand new family?
And unfortunately, there's no calculators out there that's really going to do this
because you have to try to, it's all a guesstimation, all approximation of it.
And then what's not being factored into these models either is kind of the emotional weight
because what you pointed out is that the 10-year standard actually costs this family
about a hundred bucks more a month.
But they're done with the loan in 10 years and they're not carrying it for 25 years.
Actually, this isn't a 10-year standard.
I made an assumption on the standard that they're all consolidated.
So in balance, it's a 25-year standard plan.
Okay.
So under a 25-year standard, they pay it in full, no tax liability,
but they're paying back a higher monthly payment over that time.
And so one of your other questions is what's the break even?
At what point is Wrapper IVR more than 461 a month?
If it's only like, you know, an earning of a hundred thousand a year, guess what?
They may hit it in two years.
All right.
And before we wrap and close this out, because I know we've been going a minute here.
Do you actually think people are making the best financial choice based on the math?
Or do you often see that people are making choices that
feel best for their financial situation today and their emotional situation today?
I hope I'm framing it the right way for you.
I will tell you this.
I feel like people pick student loan payments the same way they buy cars.
They don't care what they pay over the life of the car.
They want to know what's my monthly payment.
Can I afford the monthly payment?
Yes.
Great.
I want a dually that costs me one hundred and five thousand total, but I'm only paying
750 a month.
That's I feel like it's the same thing.
It's can I survive it?
And does it make my emotions calm down because my lifestyle won't be affected?
Yeah, and that's why that's where I arrived at, because I was actually having this
conversation with Travis Hornsby recently on the video we did and for student loan
payment.
I was telling him, I said, you know, your clientele is generally someone who's going
to be a higher earning individual that actually gets to make choices about whether to
aggressively pay off or stretch things out.
And they're making a mathematical, purely mathematical decision oftentimes versus a
lot of people I meet with.
They would love to not have to deal with the spillage of this interest rate in these tax
bond questions.
But the reality is they need the lowest payment possible to be able to run everything
else because they're either living kind of like under resourced, trying to make it
happen, or they are highly leveraged because, yeah, dude, I look good on paper, but I
moved to this neighborhood.
Now I'm paying for this private school and my kids can't really go to the public school.
They got to go to the private school and I got to make all these other choices that make
that kind of collapse on things that make it, dude, I just need the most affordable
payment.
Yeah, that's really, I'll deal with the interest later.
I actually heard something interesting.
And for those people that come to me and say, gosh, I wish I had choices.
Here's a choice I've heard from wealthy folk, which is don't pay off your house.
Go ahead and finance it because that money is in your bank collecting interest and you
can use it for other things.
So these are wealthy people saying just because you have the money doesn't mean you should
pay things off.
They understand the power of leveraging debt.
And so feel like you're empowered to, you may not have the choice, but you're still
doing it the same way a wealth wise person would do, which is it's okay to leverage that.
There's definitely conversation to be had around there in future talks about that.
I guess as we draw to a close here, I guess what would be your main takeaway for someone
with RAP and kind of where we're at today as you kind of contemplate your choices with
repayment plans?
I think it's important to get your ducks in a row now.
One, do you need a consolidation before the end of, before mid 2026?
If so, get it done.
Two, start running your numbers.
IVR versus RAP.
You don't have to make that decision, but start looking at it, but also look at the
bigger picture.
Where are you trending?
Are you, have you hit your peak and you're heading towards retirement or are we just
growing?
And three, breathe, damn it.
You're going to survive.
It's okay.
Look, I've had student loans.
I'm not just the president.
I'm, I've also been a client of mine.
You know, my family members are clients.
We're in this together.
And so just breathe, damn it.
I don't think I could have said it better myself, Josh.
Thank you for your time today, Josh.
And we'll link resources down below along with Josh's contact information.
And if you all have questions, feel free to reach out.
Josh has consultation hours and a way to get in contact with him.
That will include below.
You can also reach out to me for help as well.
With that said, we'll see you next video.
