Am I ruining my life by taking out $140,000 in student loans for a $60,000 salary? What repayment strategies actually make sense when interest keeps growing and forgiveness feels out of reach?
In this video, student loan attorney Stanley Tate and attorney Joshua Cohen respond to two real borrower questions from Reddit. They break down the risks of borrowing six figures for graduate school, explain how interest builds on large balances, and explore whether programs like IDR, RAP, IBR, and PSLF can provide meaningful relief.
They also cover consolidation, refinancing, default, rehabilitation, and whether bankruptcy is a realistic option for student loan borrowers in 2025. Beyond the numbers, they talk about the emotional weight of carrying heavy debt and how to align repayment strategies with career goals.
If you are weighing graduate school loans, struggling with repayment, or trying to make sense of forgiveness programs, this conversation will give you a clear understanding of the trade-offs and real options available.
All right, Josh, so we're back and we have the first question of today.
And Sharp Word asks, am I ruining my life by getting a $140K loan with a $60,000 salary?
And so what they're saying is they're starting their master's program, and at the end, they're
going to owe $150K. They are getting a degree, their master's in landscape architecture.
They love the program, they love the field, and they're wondering, should they do this?
So I ask you, Josh, what would you tell Sharp Word here?
So I noticed an edit in there. He wanted to go to grad school before the grad plus loans
are taken away. This answers my first question. Are we talking about federal loans or are we
talking about private loans? Because that in itself is a huge differentiator.
So why is that a huge differentiator?
It's a differentiator because of repayment options.
OK, explain to me more about what you mean there.
OK, private loans are very simple. Private loans are like any other debt. You borrow it,
you have to pay it back. The repayment plan is an amortization of paying it back over the term,
and most private loans are 15 to 25 year terms.
Right, but federal student loans operate by the same principles.
No, they don't.
So why does that make them different?
No, they don't. OK.
What do you mean they're not different? They're a loan, right? An interest accrues,
and you have to pay them back.
Do you have to pay them back? Yes. Do you have to pay them off?
Aha. Big difference. Federal loans have flexibility. We have income-driven repayment
plans. Even the new budget gives us an income-driven repayment plan.
Right, right. I thought they were getting rid of a lot of these plans. I hear all this talk,
they got SAVE going away, they have the Pay As You Earn plan, income contingent repayment going
away. This administration appears to be getting rid of these income-driven plans.
They are getting rid of some, but they offer a new one. Here's what people need to know.
Even our most conservative Congress has given us a plan that is based on income and has forgiveness.
But wait, it gets better. This new conservative plan, RAP, Repayment Assistance Program,
comes with an interest waiver if you're not covering the interest. How progressive is that?
All right, so we still have repayment options for federal student loans that are based on income and
lead to forgiveness. And you're saying that those two differences make federal loans entirely
different from private student loans. Yes, simply because you can always have a plan
based on your income. All right, so going back to the sharp word situation where
they're about to borrow up to $140K for their master's program, are you saying you'd be more
in favor of this if they're going to take out federal student loans than private loans?
Okay, again, because the federal loans, he knows his income is going to be about 60. There are
calculators out there. He can see what is his payment plan going to be. Look, the biggest
problem with student loans versus any other loan is that forecasting. When you go into a car
dealership and they tell you what it costs for the car, what's the first question that you ask?
What is my monthly payment going to be? When you get a mortgage, what is my monthly payment
going to be? That never happens with the student loan. You go into the financial aid office and you
say, what is my monthly payment going to be? And their response is, don't worry, you'll make enough
to pay it. That's not an answer, but that is the problem. But with federal loans now, there are
calculators out there. Okay, I'm going to borrow X. I expect my income to be Y. What should my
payment look like? Boom. Now, the other thing is people aren't paying attention, but your private
lender tells you what your payment is going to be on the Truth in Lending Act disclosure, the TILA
disclosure. So this guy can go right now, use the calculators out there and say, what's my private
loan payment going to be? What's my federal loan payment going to be? And then he's got a number
and he can decide, does that number work with my income of $60,000 a year? That is probably the
best way to analyze this and decide, am I okay paying that much or not?
Right. But see, I guess the way I think about it is this person is signing up for a career where
they're starting off at 60K and they're borrowing 2X more than that in order to get this degree.
On its face, does that make sense? Look, I am going to come from this from a
very different side, which is you need to do what you really want to do. I mean,
our generation is caught between you go to school, you pay your bills, you get a job,
life happens, versus the dreamier generations behind us, which is, I want to do this,
I want to do that, blah, blah, blah. Costs be damned. And now we're getting caught in the middle.
My generation and the younger generation, they survived the foreclosure market back in 2008,
2009, 2010, and watched their parents lose houses, so they're very concerned about finances.
I refuse to let someone plan their future purely on finances. The bottom line is,
if you're only concerned about finances, go to law school, go to med school, go to a degree
that you know you're going to make money. You're probably going to hate it, but you'll make money.
This is a guy saying, look, I'd really like to do architecture. I'd love to do this landscaping
stuff. 60,000 isn't something to sneeze at, depending on where he's living, but it's a
starting salary. It's something he wants to do, which means he's probably going to be good at it.
And if you're good at it, you tend to make better money, which means he can deal with the loans.
I am so tired of people picking something simply because, well, this will pay my bills and I'll be
good. If you want to do it for a living, fine, but I can't tell you, and Stanley, you can talk
about this too, how many lawyers hate being lawyers and only do it because, well, it pays
for the roof over my head. That's a terrible reason to be a lawyer. There's truth to that,
that when we make decisions based off of what the market will reward from a financial aspect,
that tends to be like a Faustian bargain. It's a bad bargain for you. And yet it's very real
that this person is going to have a debt looming over their life that will cause them to believe
that certain things can't happen or make them more challenging to do. And they have to balance
that with, I at least love what I do for a living, assuming they go federal student loan.
So we're backing up. We're getting back to the sharp word. We're saying that if you are entering
into this grad program and you're borrowing solely federal student loans to do this,
and you have the ability to do so, you should based off even after these rule changes,
then yeah, go ahead and do it because you're going to have the option for
income based repayment or the repayment assistance plan. But if you're going to take
out private student loans, no matter the interest rate for the most part, I'm guessing your thought
would be that, no, don't do that. Not necessarily. I mean, look, my concern is how much is private
loan. If you're taking out 140,000 in private loans, that's a problem. If you're taking out
50,000 in private loans, that may not be an issue. Again, what's the payment? I want to find
a comparison to mortgages. A mortgage is typically the largest debt people ever take out. The thing
is they justify it saying, well, it's a house and everyone deserves a house. And they also
differentiate, I don't think consciously, but they differentiate, well, if you get in trouble
with the house, you can file bankruptcy and you're okay. Student loan, you can't. But we,
in what we do, see so many people that are house poor. They buy a house because they think they
should, but they were never ever able to afford it. And that's probably a dumber decision
than student loans because you have the numbers in front of you and you know you can't afford it.
You just can't accept it because it's a house. And I think people really need to take an honest
look at their finances holistically. I agree with that. And along those lines of looking at the
kind of the holistic finances, one of the things I like to do when I'm thinking through with clients
about the investment in their careers, I always like to go see kind of what does the department
of labor statistics, the Bureau of Labor Statistics show for like this career path.
And so this is all like publicly available information that our government puts out. Now,
labor statistics has come under heat a little bit lately, but I think we can still go with
these numbers here where the median pay for 2024 is about $80,000. And so I'm assuming this person
may be in a different area where just the starting pay is lower, but there is career growth opportunities.
Now, if we click over here on pay, we can start to see kind of a breakdown.
We can see that landscape architects for government facilities gets about $103,000. So
this is one place where the government actually pays more. And then architectural engineering
related services close to $81,000, retail trade about $64,000. And so this doesn't appear to be
like that bad of a decision because we're saying that's the average, which means you may come in
at the lower scale, but over a course of time, you should be able to increase as these numbers grow
here. And that can make that return better for you, especially as you kind of plot out your future.
You may start off here where you're struggling to kind of pay all the bills and everything,
but federal student loans will be there for you to have a lower monthly payment.
And then over time, you may continue down the road towards forgiveness,
or you may decide that you make enough money where you can start aggressively paying off the loans,
especially as you marry, engage with a partner and kind of couple your finances,
you're able to subsidize from there. So I think bottom line, Josh, for someone going back to
sharp word here, what's your advice about taking out this loan?
If you want to do landscape architecture on the face of this, I say do it. I'm an optimist. I say
do it. I'm going to say both. So long as we're talking about primarily federal student loans,
primarily for me is closer to like 85% of that is going to be federal student loans.
Then I say do it. The trouble with private student loans is, and you have to keep this in mind,
interest is always going to accrue on both of these loans throughout the process.
But when those private student loans, especially if you kind of aren't paying on them in school,
they become even that much more challenging to dig yourself from out under them, because your
payments are going to reflect that balance that built up during this two to three-year program
that you're in. All right. Enough about that one. Let's move on to the next one, Josh.
All right. So this next one here is from Coconutty Water. Coconutty Water owes 100K
in debt as a jobless and broke new grad. They need advice. So basically they graduated from
private university with computer science degree. They have no job. They have no money saved up.
They owe about 31K in student loans. We don't know if they're federal or private.
And then they have parent plus loans for their mom of roughly 39,000 and another 37K in parent
plus loans for their dad. And so combined is about 100K. The monthly payments break down like this.
Coconutty Water's payments about $300 on their portion of the debt, $200 for their mom's portion
of debt, $400 for dad's portion of debt. And his interest rate is about 9% on his loans.
That total is about $1,000 a month. Right now, this person has less or has about three digits
in their pocket, whatever that is. They're not sure what the best approach is for payment plans.
And importantly here, Coconutty Water feels responsible for making the payments on the
debt. So maybe they have some type of situation where they told their parents, I will pay this
back. And so they don't know which is the best repayment plan. And they don't know if there's
a way to lower the monthly payments. They're looking at different side hustles, selling their
things and finding ways to earn money while trying to find a full-time job. They feel helpless
and discouraged. The job market is trash. They know that whenever they do find a job, the payments
will feel less stressful, but right now they feel stuck. All right. Based off of that right there,
what are your initial thoughts, Josh? I'm doing some predictive analysis here. I think in 31K,
it's federal student loans because the limit for undergrad federal student loans is about 32,000.
So he probably maxed out his federal loans. That sounds fine. I don't see anything here
that indicates private student loans because they have, they maxed out their parent plus.
So let's take this loan by loan or sorry, debtor by debtor. He owes 31,000 with the assumption that
they're federal loans. You're going to agree with me on this one. If you're unemployed,
your income is zero. And in fact, the comment right underneath says it, you should be in an
income-based payment for zero, not a forbearance. You're in a payment plan for $0 a month,
which is marching you towards forgiveness. Does the interest increase? Yes. Do we care? No,
because you're trying to- Well, why don't we care about the interest increasing?
People need to understand priorities. Your priority now is to survive now and apparently
help your parents and worry about what's coming down the road later. Okay. And right now you need
to get rid of that $300 payment for your loans by getting it on zero. If you're paying 300 a month
and you're unemployed, where the hell is this money coming from? Number one. And is there a
better use for it? Number two. And number three, what happens if you don't make those $300 payments?
You default. There's no reason to default when your payment should be zero. Is interest accruing
and building? Yes. That's called collateral damage. But to me, I don't know how long you're
going to be unemployed, 12 months, 24 months, two months. Worry about now, get onto a $0 payment
plan, which takes the stress off of you so you can focus on dealing with your parents' loans
and finding a job. I totally agree with that because interest is going to accrue. But even
if you're making a monthly payments, if you are struggling to take care of yourself on a daily
basis and your lifestyle has to be subsidized by others, that's its own form of stress as well,
because there's just this lack of independence. Why did I even go do all this school in the first
place? So for me, I would prioritize an income driven repayment plan on their loans today.
Of those plans, I would do IBR 10% since they're a new grad. And then when wrap rolls around,
I may consider switching into that. And yes, interest will accrue. However, what I would do
here is make sure you file taxes. Even if you're unemployed right now, file your tax return.
And what that's going to help you out with here is you'll have a $0 payment locked in,
not only for this year, but also for next year as well. And so now you have two year buffer there
to kind of get your financial foothold together. And then if you're saving all that extra money,
then you can start making aggressive payments to tackle that interest that you were worried
about accruing. But today we have to kind of triage this, which is take care of yourself first
and get this $0 payment, interest be damned, and then we'll come back to it in a year or two once
you are employed in your field, which is our hope. Now that I think takes care of coconut water,
which is a very simple solution here. But let's move into mom and her $39k apparent plus.
All right. So mom and dad, we look at the same way separately, but the same way.
Okay. Mom and dad, they both have $39k. Mom has $39k. Dad has about $37k. So for S&Gs,
they're basically the same. So we need to look at what would their income payment be based on
their income. Now, now you're, you're emphasizing there. Why are you saying there?
Okay. So let's back up to basics. Parent plus loans mean the parent is on the hook for it.
The mom took out parent plus loans. Dad took out parent plus loans and the student is never,
ever on the hook or liable for parent plus loans. Maybe you have an under a table agreement with
your parents that, Hey, I'll deal with it. But legally speaking, mom is responsible for those.
Dad is responsible for his. And because of that, those loans can have income payments based on mom
and dad. It's their loan. Now, if dad's making 80,000 a year, you may not qualify for a nice
income plan, but you have to do the analysis first. I don't know how old mom and dad are.
I'm assuming if you're a new grad, then mom and dad.
What they do say here though, is especially with my family's financial instability,
there's no way they can help me with this. So that's, that's a very loose term. What is
financial stability here? Because we don't know if that means they're highly leveraged and they
they're high income, but they are leveraged to the tilt or their income is variable,
but let's just, let's tease it apart. So let's assume that mom makes more than she owes in
student loans. Is income driven repayment a good option for that person? It might be,
we don't have the numbers in front of us. I mean, if she owes 39, if she makes 45,
she probably can still get onto an income plan. If she makes 80, maybe not. I mean,
we don't have the numbers and that's something I don't want to speculate on. But what I do want to
say concretely is need to have a financial analysis because just like coconut water,
we need to get the cheapest payment possible. And there's something to highlight here,
a new opportunity that the department of ed just rolled out three weeks, two weeks ago,
is that parent plus loans for the first time are eligible for income based repayment, IBR.
Now, again, you're, you're emphasizing here. And so to clean that up,
income based repayment, is that the same thing as payments based on income?
Yes. Okay. How so?
So, all right, we have income driven repayment. Income driven repayment is a
hub term for any plan based on income that would include.
So at any time that you're making payments based on your income, you are making an
income driven repayment. You're part of that hub of payment plans. But does that tell you
anything about what plan you're in? No, no.
Okay. So.
So then in this case, you're saying income based repayment is something different. It's
something unique inside of that hub. It's the particular payment plan. So here,
here's what we know. Okay. You've heard IBR, income based repayment. There's ICR,
income contingent repayment. There's pay, pay as you earn. And there's save, which is dead.
We don't talk about save anymore. It's dead. Okay. It's just like Bruno. We don't,
we don't talk about it anymore. So ICR was popular because until a few weeks ago,
it was the only plan that parent plus loans could have. However, the department of ed just
opened up this, this gate and said, parent plus loans, you can now have income based.
And that's important because IBR is a friendlier formula than ICR. That's all.
Until you do an analysis, you don't know which is better.
Right? So we're in a situation where we're a bit blind on the best solution for mom and dad,
because we actually don't know what financial instability here means. But if we assume mom
earns more than what she owes in student loan, income based repayment may provide a cheaper
option than the current monthly payment, which is $200 for mom. But it's really hard to tell
without looking at the numbers of what mom earns. Similarly, dad earns, I'm sorry, owes 37 K
his monthly payment is $400. But I guess his interest rate is higher than her than mom's.
We, it's hard to say what they should actually do, but I think the baseline is run the numbers
under the income based repayment plan to see if that's an option for them. And if not,
we may also look to consolidate the loans. Because if we consolidate them, that may lead to a longer
repayment term, which then stretches that payment out a little bit lower, just simply through
consolidation. And let's clarify, when we say consolidate, we are not mingling the loans.
Mom can consolidate mom's loans. Dad can consolidate dad's loans. Coconut water and
coconut can, can put their loans together. There is no putting this all together.
Yeah. And that's the thing, I guess that's actually a good point because sometimes the
parents will say, I need you to get me off of these loans. And the only way for coconut water,
any child to do that is to have the parent refinance with a private lender to transfer
those over, but who's going to refinance an unemployed person with no income. So it's simply
not an option. And even if it were, it's often not a good idea to do that. Why isn't it a good idea?
So I'm usually against it because you're taking on someone else's legal obligation,
and you're also giving up their repayment terms. And depending on how close mom and dad are to
retirement, they may be on a pathway to where they'll have minimum payments based off of their
social security, which may be less than a hundred bucks a month. And that may be more affordable for
that person. So I'm almost never in favor of refinancing someone else's debt to put in your
name and obligate yourself while also giving up all these benefits. I agree. I completely agree.
And I, that's a point to hammer home. I, I don't know that I have any situation where refinancing
a federal loan to a private makes sense. Interest is a red herring. Affordability is what you need
to focus on. Yeah, and definitely. And so in Coconut and Water's case, consolidating the loans
with the federal government, so mom consolidates hers, dad consolidates his, that could stretch out
the repayment term that lowers the payments that way. And there's no cost to consolidating the,
the one con would be capitalization of the unpaid interest that would be added to the principal
balance thereby causing you to pay interest on interest moving forward. But that trade-off may
be worth it today. But there's one other thing that we didn't talk about as a solution here,
seeing how this may just be a temporary problem because Coconut and Water just hasn't found a job
yet. What else can we do for mom and dad's loans here, Josh? Well, there's always a forbearance
you can do, and that's, that's temporary. Okay. A forbearance is a temporary cessation
of your regular payments and be careful which forbearance you ask for, because many times if
you do it on the phone, like, okay, we'll give you 60 days. No, you don't want the 60 day forbearance.
That's for processing your application for IBR and stuff. You want the 12 month, I can't pay it
forbearance. Now here's the problem. However, you only get three years of forbearance for each
particular loan. And I don't think we want to ride out those three years. We want to use them
sparingly so that you can get, you can focus on landing a job and easing the burden of starting
to make payments. Right. And that's exactly where we're at right now. Coconut and Water
is trying to find a job. And this is, I think you'll kind of share the sentiment with me is
that we have a situation where you are a recent college grad coming out of COVID. The job market
right now, as you said, is trash. It's horrible. And yet that has been true for grads for several
years, like from throughout time in Memorial, even because I guess we came up like for me,
2008, 2009, 2010, I saw that, you know, the recession. And what I always see is that for
the most part, it takes people about 10 years to get their financial footing and kind of get
things together. So those first years after graduation are hard. And not only are they hard
just from in terms of finding a job, then there's finding the right fit, like for you. And then
there's like getting paid what you what your worth is as well. But it's around year 10 that things
kind of chip in. I don't know if you kind of hold that to be true in your situation. What you see,
Josh? Yeah, yeah, that's, that's, yeah. All right. So then in this situation,
coconut water, all we're saying is, I know 10 years feels like a long time.
I am saying and we are saying that for your loans, income driven repayment plan right away,
file taxes as well too. So you can have a lower return for multiple years. That'll give you a
lower monthly payment. And then for mom and dad, Josh, what are we gonna do there?
We're going to again, run the numbers to see if we can get on an income based plan,
or we can consolidate and stretch out the term for a lower payment and backup, I think it's
a forbearance. And I think that solves your problem is freeze up $1,000 that you were spending right
there. And then that allows you to focus all of your efforts on finding a job and not be under
the stress and the weight of the debt. Now, this may be a hard sell for your parents not making
the payments. But I think at a certain point, you have to say, look, here are the available options.
I'm trying my best. And I want to put my focus here. Let's do that. And we need to have those
conversations as a stakeholder family. So coconut water, I hope that helps you kind of deal with
this particular situation, or anyone else kind of going through that as well. All right, Josh,
that is all for today on these threads. And if you were or someone else in your family has a
financial situation deal with your student loans that you want us to discuss, feel free to email us
we'll leave all the information down below and we'll bring it up the next time. Until then,
I'll talk to you later. Peace.