We’ll look ahead at major changes in student loan repayments under the new Trump administration, with potential IDR recertification deadlines and implications of the 8th Circuit's decisions. Plus, I’ll share a personal story about an investment mistake that cost me thousands and tips so that it doesn’t happen to you.
Key moments: 00:00 Introduction 01:28 Student loan collections are restarting: what it means for your credit and forbearance 03:49 What cost basis is (and a personal story about how ignoring it cost me thousands) 09:49 Are AUM fees worth it? Breaking down the math 15:06 Understanding technical investing strategies can give you an edge in wealth-building
Welcome to another episode of the Student Loan Pender Podcast.
I hope you had a wonderful holiday season.
I, as I record this, still have some family staying over in the room that I use to record my podcast.
So this is going to be a quick episode today.
I thought I would sort of reflect on a few things about student loans for this coming year that we have ahead of us.
And also I wanted to reflect a little bit on something kind of weird and technical that I think could save you a lot of money about investments.
So the first thing I want to talk about is just the year ahead that we've got for student loans.
One big change is all the stuff that President Biden did.
I think that the reflex in the Trump administration for Department of Education is going to be, you know, Biden did this equals bad.
Biden did this equals change, right?
The catch is going to be if something's super technical, I think they'll probably ignore it.
So what I mean by that is collecting student loan payments.
This has been put off over and over and over again during the Biden administration.
They were supposed to resume collections and collections on student loans is pretty intense.
They'll garnish Social Security checks, for example.
They'll garnish tax refunds, for example.
So that was going on until the pandemic put a halt on all those things with the CARES Act protections.
And then the Biden administration was supposed to start collecting student loans again in a normal way.
But right before the election, they said, you know, screw it, let's not do this.
And so they kicked the can down the road on that.
And so with this new Trump administration, Department of Education, you will see student loan collection machine restart again for the first time since early 2020.
And what that means is, you know, you can no longer just get on a forbearance, you know, for however long you want with no consequences.
You know, you will see negative credit information reported to the bureaus if you don't make payments.
Now, you can apply still for forbearance in the same way that you did, you know, before COVID.
But it is a discretionary forbearance that's at the discretion of the servicer as to whether or not they give it to you.
Now, my experience, they almost always give it to you if you ask.
You can cite pretty much any reason.
You can cite a truthful reason, which is just I don't, you know, want to make a payment right now.
Or I'm having a hard time making the payments right now with everything else I've got going on.
You know, you can be vague and be truthful, of course, and they'll generally approve it if you need one.
But that is going to be changing.
Now, one thing I think will change is income-driven repayment recertification dates.
I do think that once the new Department of Ed folks get in there and get installed, they're going to think, huh, this is kind of weird.
We're not asking anybody to tell us what they're making for their income-based repayment until 2026.
Maybe let's change that.
So I do think that you might see some guidance that people have to very quickly recertify their payments.
Now, this might happen for borrowers in the sense of if you get a clear ruling from the Eighth Circuit that comes down that says X, Y, and Z plans are illegal,
it might force borrowers to recertify their payments under a different repayment plan,
in which case this whole idea of this IDR recertification date being kicked down the road and whether or not it will be,
that point would be moot because if everything except for IBR was found to be illegal, well, pretty much everybody is on pay or the save forbearance, right?
Very few people are on pure IBR these days.
And so that would effectively force everyone to recertify their payments even if they didn't want to.
So that might be kind of a backdoor way to end this IDR recertification pause that's been also lasting as long as the pandemic has been.
And I think that, you know, depending on what the Eighth Circuit ruling gives us,
we might see President Trump's administration try to come out with their own version of income-driven repayment,
but that depends on whether or not the courts find this whole ICR statute to be illegal or not.
So those are some predictions on student loans.
I wanted to cover something kind of random and interesting, I think,
that could save you money on taxes and make you more money on investments real quick.
And this is something that actually I have some personal experience with,
and so I think it's kind of interesting to share something that personally impacted me in a negative way so that it doesn't happen to you,
and that's paying attention to your cost basis.
Now, you might think that because I have a podcast, I'm some sort of genius,
and therefore you never make investment mistakes, and you'd be wrong.
I'm just a person with more training in investment management,
more professional experience in investment management than most other people, but I still make mistakes too.
And one of the mistakes I made when I first started out investing in mutual funds is I didn't realize that the average cost basis method
is how mutual fund companies report on what your cost basis is when you go ahead and sell shares.
Now, let me explain what that is.
So what is cost basis? What does that even mean?
So let's say you put $1,000 in a mutual fund, and it goes up to $2,000 because of the market going up, right?
Your cost basis would be $1,000, and the market value of everything is $2,000.
So let's say that you put in $1,000, now it's worth two, and let's say that you wanted to,
your favorite college football team's in the playoff, or Taylor Swift's doing a concert,
and you needed to raise money to go do that thing, right?
So you need to sell something.
So you go in your $2,000 market position of stocks, and you say, let's say you want to sell $1,000, let's say, okay?
So if you want to go in and sell $1,000 of your $2,000 position, what they're going to ask you is,
well, what cost method do you want to select?
So if you do, now if you do, the better way to kind of describe this is usually when you invest,
you invest over a long period of time, right?
So you might be investing $1,000 a month for, you know, say, 10 years, or maybe it's $100 a month for 10 years, right?
And so you're going to have a huge number of different individual positions,
and then at times you might make big lump sum contributions, maybe when you're getting a bonus or something.
And so you put all this money in, and you're going to have all these different kind of times that you bought investments, right?
And eventually you want to use this money.
Eventually this money is meant to be used, right?
So when you go and take that money out, let's say you pull your $1,000 out.
Let's say instead of this example where you had one purchase, let's say that you had a bunch of purchases,
and you're pulling out $1,000 at any given time.
Well, if you use that default method, which if you do not select out of it, if you do not opt out of it,
any mutual fund, generally speaking, is going to hit you with this average cost method.
It'll cost you tons of money in extra taxes you don't need to pay.
So instead, you could use a different method, such as basically last in, first out, or highest priced shares are the first out.
You could do first in, first out, or you could do specific identification of shares where you get to pick which one you're selling.
Now, if you have the opportunity to select what method you use when you do investments and sell stuff,
you want to use specific identification every single time if you can help it.
The reason is you could pick the investment that has the smallest gain in any position,
and when you sell it, you'll incur less taxes.
Now, if you're donating shares, you want to go with the thing that's got the biggest gain because you can get it out of your portfolio.
Let me give you an example of how this bit me in the foot, so to speak, in a recent thing that I did.
Because I didn't realize that I had been using average cost when I first started investing,
and I switched over to this specific identification of shares,
basically because of some stuff I did where I was doing tax-less harvesting, trades,
I was doing conversion of old mutual funds, ETFs, I was doing a lot of stuff, right?
And I noticed, oh, wait, my price per share is all the same until a certain date.
And so generally speaking, when you're donating shares, you're donating shares that have got the biggest gains.
You want to donate the shares with the biggest gains?
Those are usually your oldest shares because the market tends to go up over time.
And so because I had not been investing the right way early on,
I was not able to select the shares that had the biggest gains,
which happened to be during the trough of COVID, right, when the market was really down.
And so that caused me to not be able to donate the largest gain positions to get those out of my portfolio.
Well, eventually, I'm going to go want to use some of that money in my portfolio,
and when I go to sell it, I'm not going to be able to get shares out of my portfolio
that have the gains that I really wish that I had.
What it's going to mean basically is it's going to cost me a lot of money in taxes.
And I think this happens to a lot of people that listen to this podcast and they don't even realize it.
What I mean by that is you go in, you hear index funds, right?
You hear in an internet forum, paying an AOM fee is bad.
That's dumb. Don't do that. That's only dumb people do that.
And you think, well, I'm a really educated professional. I shouldn't need help to do this.
It's easy. Just do index funds, right?
And then you put the money in a brokerage account and then you go turn around in five years
and put down $100,000 deposit in your vacation home.
And because you didn't change your cost basis method, something that's technical, annoying,
what even is this that Travis is talking about?
This is kind of a weird concept.
When you don't make that selection to switch that cost basis method
to the thing that gives you the lowest tax bill,
then instead of a $100,000 sale for this deposit you need for your house,
maybe that $100,000, the way you sell it, gives you a $50,000 gain,
but maybe it could have given you only a $10,000 gain
if you'd selected the right shares that have the lowest gains over time that you've been investing.
And so instead of incurring a $10,000 gain, you incur a $50,000 gain.
You have to pay capital gains tax on this on $50,000 of gains instead of $10,000.
Well, maybe you're in an income-driven repayment plan.
Maybe you are in a state with an income tax.
Maybe let's say it's a 5% state income tax, 10% IDR.
Let's say you're in a 24% bracket for capital gains roughly,
including the ACA tax.
That's basically 40%.
So 40% of $50,000 in gains is $20,000,
and 40% of $10,000 gains is $4,000.
So that's a $16,000 tax bill that you incurred that you could have avoided.
Now if you think about a $16,000 tax bill that you could have avoided,
well, what about AOM fees?
I heard those are bad, right?
So let's say you have a million-dollar portfolio you're paying 1% on.
That's $10,000 every year, right?
And you might say, well, that's exponential.
Well, the math mistake people make is it's only $10,000 a year
if you already have a million dollars.
If you don't have a million dollars a year already,
then 1% of not a million dollars is not $10,000 a year.
So if you think about an accumulator,
I think the way that somebody would really get hosed on an AOM fee
is if you pay that AOM fee for decades
and you have multiple millions of dollars
and you never hit a breakpoint.
Well, a breakpoint is essentially if you have above a certain amount of money,
generally speaking, that AOM fee can be lower the more money you have.
That's what a lot of places will do, right?
And then I think a lot of folks hear AOM fee,
but what kind of happens is a lot of people charge like an AOM fee
that's basically just they pick a bunch of active mutual funds
to make things look complicated.
They pick 12 different or 15 different funds
to make things look impressive,
and they charge not 1%, they charge 1.25 or something like that
and don't add a lot of value,
and then that kind of fee structure seems like it's a ripoff, right?
I think that what helps is when you have the interest yourself
to pay attention to weird technical annoying things like cost basis
where you're paying attention to what are the tax implications
of when I go and sell something
and eventually want to use my money, right?
I think that's worth a lot of money,
and the question is as long as you're saving more
than the cost of getting that advice,
if you feel like you need that advice,
that's probably a good deal, I think.
Now, in terms of all the different ways
that you can cost yourself money in investing,
I think the thing that people don't realize is
what amount of investment taxes you're paying at age 60
actually does have a lot to do with how you handled things
when you were age 30 and 40 and age 50.
So in other words, it's kind of like,
I don't know, I'm not a medical doctor,
so I'm going to get in trouble here, right?
But if you're 60 years old,
a lot of the stuff that you did back when you were younger
has this huge impact on your arteries and your heart health
and how clear the arteries are
and stuff like that probably, right?
So I think it's something similar with investments.
The stuff you start doing, the habits you have
when you're younger and the way you pay attention to details
when you're investing, when you're building wealth
really do matter.
And something as arcane and weird
as selecting your cost basis,
and if you have a mutual fund,
opting out of average cost
into specific identification of shares,
you can do that, by the way,
if you already have mutual funds.
It doesn't matter for retirement accounts
because you don't pay taxes
when you sell on retirement accounts,
but a brokerage account, a taxable account,
which you can touch before age 60,
you absolutely need to be paying attention
to that cost basis method.
And if you have ETFs or stocks,
then you need to make sure you select
out of the first in, first out method,
which tends to result in higher tax bills
and switch over to specific identification of shares.
What's the point of this?
So you can use your money better.
So you can take that money and actually spend it
in a way that results in lower taxes,
which means that you have more money to keep
and spend and enjoy how you want.
And eventually, you'll probably have so much money
that you'll want to be charitably inclined,
and the smart way to handle donation of money
is not writing a check.
It's identifying in your portfolio,
what's the largest gain that I have?
What's the stock with the biggest gain?
Taking that stock,
donating it directly to a donor advised fund,
I use one called DAFI,
Vanguard Charitable, Fidelity Charitable
are also options,
and then you essentially get that full value,
market value of that donation
right away when you donate it,
but you also don't have to pay tax on the gains.
It's a brilliant way to get huge gains
out of your portfolio
and then take the cash
that you would have cut a check for to the charity
and then go put it into your portfolio
at a much higher cost basis,
which means when you go and sell that stock
to use it one day,
you'll pay tax on a way lower gain.
So this is what I mean by paying attention to detail.
As long as you're aware of these things,
you'll save a lot more money
than probably somebody that's not aware of these things.
And you might say,
what even is this?
And what I'm saying is,
this is kind of bizarre, right?
But my total stock market index fund,
back in the day,
if I had been paying a competent financial planner
back in the day
when I first started investing
to help me understand cost basis
and to help me select the right cost basis,
that would have more than paid
for most any AOM fee
because of the tax consequences
that I'm incurring today
because I didn't know that years ago.
So that's just kind of an interesting personal story
that I thought y'all would be
at least intrigued by
and find it interesting maybe.
But one thing that I'm kind of looking at doing
for the business overall this year
is to try to focus more
on how to help our listeners grow well.
Obviously, we're doing another episode on every Friday.
We're doing a Wealth Financially Free Fridays episode.
We're intentionally doing that
to try to give student loan borrowers
and professionals more ideas
on how to grow their wealth
and how to achieve financial freedom, right?
And if you listen to this stuff,
I think that you probably enjoy
some of the weird technical things
we like to cover sometimes.
We like to keep it kind of like not too technical
but just interesting enough
that you might find it enjoyable.
And I do think that,
obviously, if you have a professional degree
or graduate education,
getting a little technical sometimes
is probably a good thing
because it shows you new things
that maybe you didn't think about
or know about as deeply
as you might have wanted to know about.
So, cost basis, look it up.
Look up the different types of cost basis methods.
Realize that the default method for you
is actually pretty bad for most investors.
The DIY method of investing
that somebody says,
index funds, I make great returns
in my total stock market index.
That's all I need to do.
Well, actually, nope.
You need to pay attention to taxes.
You need to pay attention to cost basis.
You need to pay attention to
how you're contributing
and what are going to be the tax consequences
when you inevitably withdraw money.
Those things matter.
So, hopefully, you had a good holiday again.
Hopefully, you're cool
with a little short and abbreviated episode today.
If you have student loan questions,
usually my Tuesday episodes
are more student loan themed
but I just thought I'd go on a cost basis rant
because, you know, why not?
But if you have a student loan question,
go to studentloanplanner.com
slash voicemail
and just press that record button on your phone
and ask whatever's on your mind.
It's going to be a really intense year
on the student loan front.
We're going to see a lot of changes.
I know that for sure.
The question is, what will they be?
I don't know.
But we'll cover things in the pod
so you don't have to worry about it.
Thank you, everybody,
and have a great rest of your week.