Insider reveals a PERFECT move for the Red Sox...
Nov 15, 2026
The top MLB insider covering the game of baseball,
Jeff Passan, released an article Tuesday morning
putting out his perfect offseason moves for 17 major league teams,
including the Boston Red Sox.
For those Boston Red Sox, it ended on four words.
Sign catcher Ryan Jeffers.
A catcher for a team that sent four players
and a player to be named later to Baltimore
earlier at the major league trade deadline back on August 3rd.
The player coming back, Adley Rutschman,
the former number one overall pick just a few
years ago to the Orioles,
and he was supposed to be the answer behind the plate for the
Red Sox for years to come.
Now we have to look at the reason Jeff Passan gave
for adding Ryan Jeffers this offseason
as Adley Rutschman could become a free agent
as soon as next winter if not extended by
this Red Sox organization.
He also went on the injured list three separate times
this year before he ever caught a pitch
in Boston.
And not to mention the player Jeff Passan mentioned
in Ryan Jeffers out hit him at the
plate this past season.
So is Ryan Jeffers the insurance policy or is he the guy that ends up
taking the job in Boston behind the plate?
Adley Rutschman's contract ends at the end of this
season. He's going into the final year of arbitration
and coming off the year he just had
tells the whole story.
He finished 2026 with a 740 OPS and just 13 home runs.
That's up from 673 in 2025, so he's coming back,
but it isn't the bat Baltimore used
to build around back when he
was drafted number one overall just a few years ago.
And the bigger problem is the lack of games he played
and the lack of attempts he got
on the diamond due to the injury history.
He went on the IL with a sore left ankle in April,
then a concussion in June.
By the time Boston traded for him on August 3rd,
he had been on the injured list since
July 20th with left wrist inflammation, his third stint of the year.
Boston did the deal anyway
because he's a three-time all-star who was still hitting .251
at the deadline. While he sat,
he spent the time getting to know a pitching staff
he had never caught for.
He made his Boston Red Sox debut on August 11th,
and a few weeks later, he was sitting again with a sore right elbow.
That one blockbuster trade
the Red Sox made for Adley moved the entire catching group at once.
Carlos Narvaez, someone that was looked
at as the face of the catching position in Boston,
was going to Baltimore.
Jake Rogers came over after hitting 161 in Detroit and a hurt Rutschman
joined the staff in the middle of a playoff race.
Boston ended up going 87-75 with that group,
finished third in the AL East and went out in the wildcard round.
And now the clock is running and
running fast for the guy they went out
and paid for in blockbuster fashion.
Our cap sheet estimates his 2027 salary is about $8.5 million.
And after that,
he can walk to free agency if not extended.
Behind him, the only catcher on Boston sheet
is Connor Wong, arbitration eligible at about $1.8 million.
But Connor Wong had a 655 OPS this
season with only four home runs.
So if Adley Rutschman goes down with another injury or
Walks in free agency next offseason,
that is the big void behind the plate and that is
exactly the hole Ryan Jeffers would be filling.
Jeffers spent 2026 with the Minnesota Twins,
and Twins Daily called it a career year.
Their headline that day worried he'd turned
into a free agent Minnesota might not be able to afford.
He hit 14 home runs in just 92 games and drove in 56 runs.
His OPS was 814 up from the 752
line that he posted the year prior.
His WRC plus was 128, where 100 is the league average.
So he created 28% more runs than average now put
Put that OPS next to Boston's catchers,
Rutschman at 740 and Wong at 655,
Ryan Jeffers looks like the best option available.
Now, I do still have faith in Adley,
but you have to point it out
when the stats make it abundantly clear.
The free agent Ryan Jeffers
out hit the all-star catcher Adley Rutschman,
and it wasn't necessarily close,
and the power Jeffers maintained wasn't luck.
15.9% of the balls he put in play were barrels,
the hardest and best angled contact there is.
That's the 93rd percentile in all of baseball.
Rutschman sat at 64th. His average exit velocity
was 91.4 miles per hour, which ranked in the 84th percentile.
His isolated power slugging
minus batting average was .205,
which ranked again in the 82nd percentile. So the hits he got
went for extra bases.
Not to mention Jeffers also walked at a 12.5% rate
which ranked in the 88th percentile which
is how he got on base at a .353 clip.
The second job in Passan's idea is the bat. Another powerful
right-handed bat who can also play DH if need be.
Over his career Jeffers has an .838 OPS against
left-handed pitching that comes with 28 home runs
in 712 plate appearances against lefties.
So when the Red Sox go against a lefty starter,
you can see Jeffers catching behind the plate
and Rutschman getting reps at DH or vice versa.
Back in October, the Red Sox stats account looked
at the hitters Boston gave up young talent for, Rutschman and Mead.
The closest match to their
profile in the whole league was Ryan Jeffers.
Jeffers is the same type of hitter. The Boston
Red Sox have already made abundantly clear that they want,
and this one doesn't cost any prospects.
And there's a reason why Jeffers,
who has a bat like this, doesn't get talked about
like a star, and it's because of the glove, and really mostly his arm.
On stolen base throws,
Statcast had Jeffers at minus six runs this season. That number is
measured against an average arm,
so it means about six runs handed to the other team on the bases
over a season. That was tied for the second worst mark
of any catcher in all of the majors. His pop
time from the catch to the ball reaching second base
was roughly 1.96 seconds. His framing came
at minus one, so he isn't stealing strikes for his pitchers either.
One thing does work.
He won 61% of his challenges under the new ABS system,
which could be a huge plus.
And that's why the DH half of Passan's idea matters
as much as the catching half for Ryan Jeffers specifically.
Boston wouldn't be paying Jeffers to catch 130 games
with that arm and lack of defensive
metrics behind the plate.
They'd be using him as a bat in the DH spot
with the ability to take on two to three reps
a week at behind the plate in order
to get Rutschman the overall rest he so desperately
needs like we've witnessed over the last year
and some change as the injuries are starting
to pile up for the all-star catcher.
If he goes down again next summer,
the emergency option is already sitting in the dugout.
with an .814 OPS instead of a .655 OPS.
The bat absolutely fits exactly what the Red Sox want
and absolutely need.
Now is the price.
And before Boston can even make an offer to Ryan Jeffers,
he has a huge decision to make.
The Twins gave him a qualifying offer of one year $23.15 million.
That's more than double
what Rutschman and Wong are estimated to make in 2027 put together.
Granted, both of those players
are still in arbitration years for the Red Sox.
He was one of eight players to get it, and he has
until 4 p.m. Eastern Standard Time on November 17th to take it
or walk away to free agency.
Twins Daily reported on Tuesday that Minnesota is engaged with him.
Jeffers has said he loves
the idea of going back to Minnesota,
but he wants to see what else is out there for him.
If he takes the offer, he's a Twin for one year
at a $23.15 million price tag and is a free agent
again next winter. Which is the same winter Adley could walk
to the open market via free agency,
which would leave Boston chasing a catcher with both
of them out on the open market at the same time
If he turns it down, Boston won't be alone in the bidding.
Just Baseball lists the Twins,
Yankees, Cubs, Phillies, and Angels as all fits,
and we all know the Yankees will be in on Jeffers
because at the MLB trade deadline,
everyone expected Jeffers to be in pinstripes before
the deadline actually expired.
You might have noticed Boston wasn't on that list of teams, but
Losing him to New York,
whether it was via last trade deadline or in free agency now in this
winter, it would sting twice for the Red Sox.
Signing him after he turns down that offer would
also cost the Red Sox at least a draft pick
on top of the contract. On the open market,
Just Baseball projects him to sign two to five years
from anywhere from $12 to $18 million a year.
That could be considered a lot for a big market team whose
ownership Passan says operates with mid-market sensibilities.
The Boston Globe puts the Red Sox at about $258.5 million
in luxury tax commitments for 2027
already. The tax line was 244 this year
and Boston went over it in 25 and again in 26. Nobody knows
next year's line yet because the labor deals run out on December 1st.
And every dollar Boston adds
over that actual tax line gets taxed on top,
which fits Passon's opening with if they decide
to actually spend.
which we're accustomed to seeing the Red Sox not do.
Going back to just last winter and last
offseason, the Red Sox only made one free agent signing.
Various trades, but only one
offseason signing via free agency.
Passon doesn't even rank Jeffers first. His perfect
move for Boston is an impact bat on the trade market. His name
Ketel Marte at second base and even another run at Corey Seager.
Jim Bowden reported that the Red Sox
are prioritizing offense with free agents
Teriyaki Soto and Brandon Lowe named as fits.
None of those names fix the catching clock
and every trade costs prospects
after Boston already sent four players to Baltimore in August.
That's the real choice.
Pay money and pick up Jeffers or pay the prospects for another bigger
bet. So is this an insurance move or are they going out
and getting their next heir to the
catching position in Boston?
The length of the deal that Jeffers would get from Boston would
answer that question. If it's a one-year deal for Ryan Jeffers,
first of all, they would probably
have to beat the $23.15 million offered
by the Minnesota Twins and if it
It was that one year deal.
Not only would they have to probably spend more than
that number, but they would also
have the same problem if they didn't extend Adley Rutschman
this season, next offseason
when both of them become unrestricted free agents once again.
I honestly like this idea,
getting Ryan Jeffers as an insurance option behind the plate to give
Adley Rutschman days off,
especially with the amount of injuries that have piled up over his
career up to this point,
especially in the last 15 to 18 months that he's gone through. Getting
him would give you another legitimate arm behind the plate.
Again, defensive metrics wouldn't be
great, but it would be the bat that you would be adding to this lineup.
Not to mention right-handed
Maintains good power, smashes lefties.
Checking a lot of boxes here for the Red Sox
if they were able to actually go out there and sign
him. If they did give Jeffers a two-year deal,
that would bring them to 2028. And if Rutschman
one prices himself out of consideration with the Red Sox
or the injuries continue to pile up,
Jeffers is already the starting catcher in Boston.
With good prospects behind him
that they didn't have to spend in order to get him
in this offseason.
And in best case scenario, they bring Jeffers in.
Adley comes back.
He looks good.
He stays healthy.
The bat turns back on and the defense is still one of,
if not definitively, the best in the
league behind the plate.
Then you have a win-win.
You have Adley available and a switch
hitting catcher with great defense.
Jeffers can DH and absolutely mash left-handed bats,
or excuse me, left-handed pitching.
This would be a perfect scenario for the Red Sox.
Either way, the Red Sox have a massive decision
on their hands with a premier position defensively
with the catching spot.
Let me know down below.
Do you think the Red Sox should go after someone like Ryan Jeffers
this offseason, or should
they just continue to bet on guys like Connor Wong and Adley Rutschman?
Let me know down below your thoughts and opinions,
and I will see you guys on the next episode
of Red Sox Digest.

