Yankees make sneaky PERFECT signing...

Yankees Digest
1 follower
Nov 16, 2026
He got left off the New York Yankees wildcard roster,
and he also gave up 12 home runs as a
relief pitcher this year. But the New York Yankees
just brought him back, and I think that it is
exactly the right call. Tim Hill, one year, $2.5 million.
By the end of this video,
you'll see why this is a smart, cheap move,
even after the season that he just had.
Think about how this looks from the outside.
A reliever finishes with a 4.60 ERA,
his worst number as a Yankee, and the front office sits
down with him in November.
Most fans would call that a mistake before
the pen hit the paper, but the Yankees looked
at the same numbers I did, and they saw something different.
They saw a lefty who gets lefties out,
for the price of a rounding error.
Let me walk you through it.
And yes, I will show you the ugly numbers too,
that is the only way that this argument
works.
We're going to start with the money here,
because $2.5 million, the Yankees paid him
$3 million this past season,
so this is a pay cut for a guy who just threw 58.2 innings
in 67 games.
Know where he came from as well.
He debuted with the Royals in 2018,
spent four seasons with the Padres from 2020 to
2023, and was a White Sox reliever
in 2024 before they let him go in June and the Yankees
picked him up.
That's a guy who has been written off before.
It's also only one year.
He's gone after 2027, if this all goes wrong.
There's no second year to regret for the Yankees,
and we have to put this into context.
In 2027, the Yankees already have Cody Bellinger, Aaron Judge,
Garrett Cole, Max Fried, and Carlos Rodon on the books
for a combined $175 million.
Hill's $2.5 million is about 1.4% of that.
It will not move the luxury tax needle,
and it does not touch the big decisions.
Look at what he's done in pinstripes.
The White Sox released him in 2024 and the Yankees picked him up
and he posted a 2.05 ERA over 44 innings and 35 games.
In 2021, he won 70 games with a 3.09 ERA and 15 holds.
Add 2022 and that's 169 innings over three Yankees season for a lefty
who costs about what a middle reliever on a bad team costs.
Here's the real reason to keep Tim Hill though.
Overall, left-handed hitters cannot hit this man at all.
In 2022, they hit a .213 average against him with a .265
on-base percentage and a .346 slugging percentage.
That's a .611 OPS over 137 batters that he faced.
Right-handed hitters, they do hit .293
with a .908 OPS against him and 104 batters faced,
so the job is clear. He is a lefty specialist, not an every-inning arm.
And he was already used that way.
137 of the 241 batters he faced this year were left-handed,
that's about 57%. The Yankees did use him strategically.
This is not a one-year thing.
In 2025, lefties hit a .181 against him
with a .224 on-base percentage
and a .220 slugging percentage.
That's a .444 OPS with 134 batters faced.
Go back to his 2024 time in New York,
and it's the same story.
Lefty's hit .187 against him
with a .452 OPS and 81 batters faced,
three seasons as a Yankee,
and in each of them,
Lefty's had an OPS of .611 or lower.
So the question for Aaron Boone is simple.
When does he come in?
The answer is when a lefty is due up in a big spot,
not when the inning needs to be finished,
no matter who's hitting. That one rule
is the whole difference right here. And every contender
has lefty sluggers in the middle of the order.
Having someone built to get them out for $2.5
million is far more than just a luxury.
It's also just insurance in a general sense. So that is the
first reason. He gets hitters you need him to get.
And overall, it works. And
Outside of that, let me show you
the part of his game that makes it work,
and it's not what you would guess from the radar gun.
The second reason is where the ball goes.
His ground-out-to-air-out ratio this year was a 3.73.
That's the best of any season in his career.
It was a 2.52 in 24 and a 2.20 in 20-25.
So, back in April, Baseball Savant had his ground ball rate at a 78.8%,
that was the highest in the majors at that point in the season.
He also does not strike anyone out.
He just doesn't.
Overall, he had 25 strikeouts in 58.2 innings
and Baseball Savant had his...
...or puts his strikeout rating in the first percentile of the league.
But he only walked 13 guys in those 58.2 innings,
and his walk rate is in the 93rd percentile.
Here's why that works.
He's not overpowering anybody.
Baseball Savant has his fastball velocity in the first percentile
and his fastball spin in the seventh percentile.
His sinker is not about speed.
It's about movement and weak contact.
And he throws it again and again, and it works.
And that's the trait.
He gives you the contact on the ground with almost no free passes.
In a ballpark with a short porch and right,
A ground ball is one of the best options you can ask for.
Now, I don't want to sell you a fairy tale.
At the end of the day, this chapter
is the one where I say this could go wrong
because a smart signing is one where you know the risk
and the price still makes sense.
And there is an ugly part to this.
He had a 4.60 ERA this year after a 3.09
and a 2.05 in the two prior years.
He gave up 12 home runs after 8 in 2025 and only 2 in 2024.
He was left off the wildcard roster as well.
One report citing Yahoo Sports had his ERA at 1.37 at one point
and then a 6.23 after May 22nd.
So his second half was a real problem.
And I'm not going to pretend that it's not.
He also got used a whole lot
because of how good he was in the beginning of the year.
And look at who did the damage.
Right-handed hitters had 7 of his 12 home runs,
and overall, it's not surprising to see that.
They had a 9.08 OPS against him.
Against lefties, he's held them to a 6.11,
but again, righties hit him.
And the 104 batters faced against right-handed,
out of the 241 total, take even half of those away,
and the season looks a lot different.
It's not a guarantee, it's a plan.
And a plan is more than you get from most cheap signings, especially...
When you do have a lot of free agent guys coming out of the bullpen.
So there's a real risk here.
And it's also age.
He's 36 and the velocity is already at the bottom of the league.
A lefty who leaves on sink
and or who lives on sinkers does not really have much room to lose.
And overall, the fix is not really the pitcher.
It's the role.
Use him against lefties in the sixth or seventh inning.
And the 6.11 version of him will show up.
And one of you on the Grisham video I did a while ago,
GitmoBob1714,
wrote that Boone keeps running veterans out
of there because they are veterans.
Fair or not for Grisham, Tim Hill is the opposite.
He got benched when he stopped working.
And this is the part that a lot of people miss.
A $2.5 million lefty means the Yankees can stop spending big
on a problem they've already solved.
They can already put real money and trade chips into the rotation,
a lineup, or late inning right-hander.
Now,
On top of that, a right-handed closer,
that type costs real prospects and real dollars.
It's likely going to be David Bednar again,
a lefty specialist who held lefties
to under a .611 OPS in each of the three seasons,
costs a roster spot and $2.5 million.
One of those is a plan, the other is a gamble.
And think about how he fits with the rest of the bullpen.
If Hill takes the left-handed hitters
in the sixth and the seventh,
the best arms do not have to be spent there.
That's how a bullpen goes deeper
without adding a big contract.
Especially when you're likely gonna have
to give one to Bednar.
And the Yankees are not alone here at all.
I mean, when we look at Tim Hill,
he certainly had a market for himself
as overall the Guardians, the Mets, the Giants,
and the Dodgers all were in the mix for Hill.
Four other teams looked at a 4.60 ERA,
saw a lefty they could use,
and the Yankees didn't wait around.
They got it done at 2.5 million.
Lefty relievers who could do this
aren't sitting on every street corner.
When five teams are on the same player,
The price goes up quickly, and the Yankees paid $2.5 million.
If this went to a bidding war, they weren't getting that number,
and that's how the bullpen gets built.
Not with one big headline, but with arms like this one
to keep the sixth inning from turning into a crisis.
So, was this the right call?
Let me know in the comments down below if you think so,
or you think this was a bad contract.
And guys,
Overall, let's run it back for a second.
Three seasons as a Yankee, lefties at a .452,
a 444, and a 611 OPS in those three years.
A ground out to air out ratio of 3.73 this year,
a 2.5 million price, one year, no strings.
It makes sense.
I get it.
A 4.60 ERA doesn't make anyone feel good,
but we're talking about 2.5 million for one
season.
A lefty with three straight years of getting
lefties out and a clear way to use them.
That's not a gamble.
That's a good bet.
And it's not a headline signing, but...
Great signings are not always loud.
This is a lefty who held lefties to a .611 OPS,
keeps the ball on the ground,
and costs almost no money with no second year attached.
If Boone uses him the right way,
it's one of the best cheap moves of the winter.
If he doesn't, you lose $2.5 million
and a roster spot for a little bit
before maybe you get DFA'd if you play badly.
But there's no reason to believe he's going to play badly.
He's mainly been great with the Yankees.
And DougLegend-01J with the comment of the day wrote,
the problem with the Yankees,
they rely too much on the home runs.
He is right about the home runs.
It is why a ground ball pitcher matters,
so they do kind of have the versatility with pitching.
And if you want more on how the Yankees
are building the rest of the bullpen,
the next video you can watch is on the screen right now.
