This Mets Signing Is PERFECT....

Mets Digest
1 follower
Nov 15, 2026
Against right-handed pitching this season, Juan Soto put up a .983 OPS.
Against left-handed pitching, that number fell to .777.
The best bat in this lineup loses more than 200 points of OPS
the moment a lefty walks in from the bullpen.
And over at first base, the Mets went from second in the majors in 2025
to 28th in OPS this past year.
There's two holes in this same lineup,
and the free agent who could both cover each of them
is sitting directly on the free agent market right now.
He bats right-handed.
He just had the best year of his career,
and his old team already said it doesn't plan
to chase a long-term deal.
The Phillies are talking about him,
and the Royals say they need a right-handed hitting outfielder.
Nobody has put his name, curiously, next to the Mets.
But if the Mets sign Randy Arosarena and move Juan Soto to first base,
they fix both problems with one contract.
And they might walk out of this winter
with the best outfield in all of baseball.
First base was supposed
to be the easy part after Pete Alonso signed with Baltimore.
And as we all know, the Mets gave Pete Alonso no contract offer
and instead gave Jorge Polanco
a two-year $20 million AAV for $40 million total to take over,
even though he had never
started a game before at first base.
By April 18th, he was hitting 179 with one home run.
And then...
He went on the injured list.
After that, the job went to whoever was healthy
and hitting that particular week.
Jared Young started 46% of the games at first
and finished with a 759 OPS.
Mark Vientos took 36% of the starts,
and his OPS was more than 100 points lower at 652.
Now, Vientos did hit 13 home runs,
but the rest of his at-bats dragged that OPS down
to the bottom 15% of hitters.
Put it all together and Mets first baseman finished with a 667 OPS.
A year earlier with Alonso there, that same spot was at .860.
So the Mets lost close to 200 points
of OPS at one position in one season.
Their latest reported interest at the position is Ty France,
a first baseman who fixes first base and nothing else.
France would be another stopgap, and look,
I like Ty France, and I think he would be
a good addition to the Mets,
but the Mets already tried a stopgap this year, and that's
when they signed Jorge Polanco.
The bigger problem with this lineup isn't the glove at first,
necessarily, it's which
side of the plate, the addition to the lineup,
that that bat comes from.
And frankly, going back to that Juan Soto split?
It explains exactly why the Mets need to prioritize
the handedness over the position fit.
When an opposing manager sees Juan Soto coming up in the 7th inning,
he goes and gets his lefty.
And Soto's OPS drops from .983 to .777.
That's the reason the name the Mets are most linked to this winter.
Teruaki Sato, as good as he is,
he doesn't necessarily solve that problem.
Sato just won the Triple Crown in Japan.
Hitting .306 with 39 home runs and 106 runs batted in for Han Shin.
He is a real hitter, but that line came in Japan's Central League,
and he bats left-handed.
Steamer projects him for a .782 OPS in his first big league season,
a long way from the .991 he put up in Japan.
He also struck out 27% of the time in Japan,
and that number usually climbs against big league pitching.
Put Sato behind Sato, and the same lefty out of the bullpen
gets to face both those hitters, perhaps in consecutive order,
in the middle of the Mets lineup.
There's also a real chance the Mets don't chase him hard,
since Will Salmon reported they're less inclined
to with Bo Bichette coming back in 2027.
The cheaper right-handed option is Alec Boehm,
projected at one year and $12 million.
Boehm's career wRC+ is 130 against lefties,
but just 88 against righties.
And this is why it makes him
a platoon bat more than an everyday answer.
What this lineup needs is a bat
from the other side that can still hit lefties.
Rosarena hits from the right side
and his OPS against left-handed pitching this season
was 954. That's 177 points better than Soto against
the exact same hand of pitcher. Over
198 plate appearances to his 168.
He even strikes out less against lefties. 20% of the time against
22% against righties. So there's no platoon hole in his game.
But he brings exactly the right-handed bat this lineup is missing.
With this kind of season behind it,
it's hard to say no to the prospect
of Randy Arosarena as a New York Met.
Randy Arosarena just had the best season of his career in Seattle,
and that is a tough place to hit.
He hit 26 home runs and stole 26 bases with an OPS of .865.
He scored 113 runs, the second most in the majors.
His 5.7 wins above replacement at the plate
ranked in the 96th percentile of qualified hitters.
And so does Soto...
It was 3.0, albeit in an injury-shortened season.
Soto still has the better bat by OPS, .908 to .865 this past season,
so that WAR gap comes from everything else Arosarena does.
It was also his sixth straight season
with at least 20 homers and 20 steals.
The Royals' GM says they need
a right-handed hitting outfield bat this winter,
the same thing that this Mets lineup is missing.
Jon Heyman put it simply on MLB Network.
He's at the top of that market.
Chandler Rome went further.
He's 20-20 every year, multiple all-star teams.
Seattle made him the $23.15 million qualifying offer,
and he has until November 17th to accept it.
He's expected to turn it down,
and the Mariners don't plan to chase a long-term deal after that.
If he does, signing him costs the team
that lands him draft pick compensation,
which is part of the price here,
which leaves one question for the Mets.
Where would he even play with Soto already in left field?
Soto started 66 games in left field this season
and 43 more at designated hitter.
Moving to first, and Arosarena takes over left,
the same spot he played in Seattle.
His bat at first would be a 9.08 OPS,
replacing the 7.59 Young gave them.
He also walked in 16.2% of his trips to the plate this season,
in the 98th percentile.
And that on-base skill doesn't care what position he plays.
The risk is real, because Soto has
never played first base in the majors.
He has the athleticism to learn it.
As a Met in 2025, he hit 43 home runs and stole 38 bases.
Nobody has reported a Soto move to first base.
So this is our idea and not a report.
And his contract pays him $51 million a year through 2039.
The Mets need that lineup for every one of those years.
And first base ranks as one of the biggest holes on this team.
And it's also going to ask a lot less out of his legs
than chasing balls in left field every single night.
If you'd want to see Soto at first base next season,
please be sure to hit the like button and subscribe.
Because guys, Mets Digest
is the highest quality Mets videos you will see on YouTube.
And if you don't agree with me, that's fine.
But engage in the comments and let them know where I am going wrong.
Now, let's just, you know.
For argument's sake, picture the outfield with this move.
Carson Bench in right, A.J. Ewing in center,
and Randy Arozarena in left.
Picture the outfield that move leaves behind.
Arozarena in left, A.J. Ewing in center,
and Carson Bench in right put up 4.2 WAR,
and that's from Soto alone at the plate
in right field this past season.
Ewing added 3.1 more in center, along with 25 stolen bases.
And if you add Arozarena's 5.7,
and that's 13 more at the plate from three outfielders,
and every one of them can run,
you have nothing short of an elite outfield.
Probably, in my estimation,
the best one in all of Major League Baseball.
That is exactly the case for the best outfield
in Major League Baseball.
And it adds this right-handed slugging bat
without taking Juan Soto out of the lineup,
which obviously is not an option.
It also turns Jared Young and Mark Vientos into bench bats.
And after a 7.59 OPS from Young and a 6.52 from Vientos,
that's where their numbers say they belong.
Not in the everyday starting lineup.
The catch is the money, with Tarek Skubal still on the table.
The Mets already have $234.9 million committed for 2027
and they missed the 2027 playoffs.
That's just under the $247 million tax line before about $47 million
of projected arbitration
raises gets that added on top.
So the Mets are paying tax on whoever they add this offseason,
whether it's Seager or
Arozarena or both.
And because they're a repeat payer,
the penalties make every one of these dollars cost more
than it would for almost any other team.
The Mets free agent reports this week have leaned towards pitching.
Seager plus relievers like Alex Vesey and Tim Hill.
One top 50 free agent rankings projects
a Rosario at 4 years and $90 million.
That's $22.5 million a year, a little less than
the $23.15 million Seattle offered him for one season.
The same ranking has Skubal at 8 years and $352 million,
so a Rosario's whole deal would be about a quarter of this.
Add Skubal at about $44 million a year
and a Rosario at $22.5 million,
and the 2027 commitment lands close to $350 million.
That sounds like a lot until you remember the Mets ran
at a $350 million payroll this past year.
Soto is projected five years $115 million,
plus a $19.125 million posting fee to Hanshin.
That's about $134 million for a hitter
who hasn't played a big league game yet.
The best argument for Soto is age.
He'll be 28 on opening day, and a Rosario will be 32.
Soto has the longer runway,
but a Rosario has already done it in the majors,
for six years in a row.
A four-year deal covers his age 32 to 35 seasons,
which is exactly why it shouldn't go a year longer.
It would also run through 2030,
one season after Soto's opt-out following 2029.
Soto, I should say.
So the Mets' next big decision will line up then.
None of this waits long because the labor deal expires on December 1st,
and a lockout would stop free agent signings.
Soto's clock is even tighter.
His posting window would run December 16th.
But the lockout cuts about two weeks off of that.
So here's where I land.
Sign a Rosario, move Soto to first,
you fill two holes with just one contract.
Soto is the one I'd want if I could pick here.
28 or upside, but he bats left-handed,
and the Mets are reportedly less inclined.
And while I disagree with that, if we're being real here,
then we gotta work with what we got.
The right-handed bat here matters the most.
And 9.54 OPS versus lefties
to the Mets better hitter on the team, Juan Soto.
Posting just a 777 last year.
And here's where we have to doubt everything.
Randy Arozarena does turn 32 in February,
and Soto's never played first base before.
So, the answer is four years max.
I'm not going over that.
And Soto's bat, even if he isn't great at first base,
you know it's going to play anywhere.
And you'll figure it out.
That might be optimistic, that might be idealistic,
but we've heard rumblings about him moving to first.
Why not move him now?
What we're going to have to watch is November 17th,
the qualifying offer answer, and December
1st, the lockout.
So, let me turn the question over to you guys.
Who would you rather see the Mets sign this winter?
Randy Arozarena or Juan Soto?
Let me know in the comments, guys.
Let me know.
And as always, let's go Mets.
