Get to Top 1% Health in my community: https://www.skool.com/top1health Timestamps: 00:00 Intro 00:55 The runner's paradox: fit but with plaque 01:40 The type of plaque in athlete's 03:41 Why athletes still get plaque 04:00 Do athletes get more heart attacks and strokes 04:45 Effect of cardiovascular fitness and activity on cardiovascular events 06:20 Effect of exercise intensity on atherosclerosis 07:17 What determines if someone gets plaque or not 08:27 What happens if you train to run a marathon 10:00 What happens if you run marathons every day 11:18 Diet quality 12:04 Main takeaways and practical points
P.S. This is not professional medical advice and should not be taken as such. The creator of this video is not held accountable for your health. Consult your doctor first.
AI Generated·May contain errors
A very surprising finding
is that lifelong endurance athletes often have more plaque
in their arteries, despite having
a generally low-risk cardiovascular disease risk profile.
It's not just one or two studies,
but it's quite a consistent phenomenon.
Even more surprising is that despite the higher amounts of plaque,
these athletes still have lower rates of heart disease
and they're less likely to die to heart
disease. And recently there was another study finding
that training for a first marathon
was seen to be associated
with a four-year reduction in estimated aortic age.
So how does that make sense? It's kind of a paradox.
More plaque but lower risk of dying to it.
The answer involves three different things.
Number one, arterial stiffness and blood pressure.
Number two, coronary plaque and plaque composition.
And number three, actual cardiovascular outcomes.
So in this video, I'm going to go through all of this.
Why our masters athletes seem to have
more calcified plaque in the absence of other risk factors,
how dangerous it actually is,
other ways to prevent it, and how
should it change your exercise routine.
So, why do these masters athletes tend to have more plaque?
One of the first major clues came from Germany in 2008.
Researchers examined 108 apparently healthy
male marathon runners, aged 50 and older.
Compared to men their age, the runners had
a better cardiovascular risk profile.
Their estimated 10-year coronary risk was lower.
The researchers used two different control groups.
Compared to men matched by age alone,
the runners had approximately the same coronary
calcium burden.
A median score of 36 in the runners versus 38 in the controls.
But compared to men matched by both age
and a similarly low cardiovascular risk profile,
the runners had significantly more coronary calcium, 36 versus 12.
In 2017, two larger studies added to that picture.
In the first one, they compared 152 experienced endurance athletes
with 92 controls who had
similarly low estimated coronary risk.
The athletes had trained for approximately 31 years,
and most of them were runners.
Among the men, coronary plaques were found
in approximately 44% of athletes versus 22%
of the controls.
Most of the athletes still had a calcium score of zero,
as you can see from the graph, but
male athletes were more likely
to have substantial coronary calcium or detectable plaque.
The plaque composition was also interesting and quite revealing.
The athletes had predominantly calcified plaque
that gets picked up by a CT scan.
However, the regular people had a much higher prevalence
of non-calcified plaques, which
is called soft plaque.
The soft plaque is the earlier stage
of the plaque becoming calcified eventually.
This soft plaque is actually the more dangerous kind,
because it's more volatile and can
lead to a rupture and stroke,
whereas a calcified plaque is stable and sealed off.
A non-zero calcium score is associated
with a higher risk of heart attacks, but it's
a little bit safer than the soft plaque.
So what this means is that the athletes have
more calcified plaque that is more stable
and sealed off, whereas people of the same age
who aren't athletes have more of what's
called soft plaque.
Another study examined 284 middle-aged male athletes.
Among those who reported lifelong exercise volumes
above 2,000 MET minutes per week, approximately
68% of them had detectable coronary calcium,
compared to 43% among those people who reported
less than 1,000 MET minutes per week.
Plaque was also more common in the most active group.
However, among participants with plaque,
the most active athletes were more likely to have
exclusively calcified plaques and less likely to have mixed plaques.
Other studies find that lifelong athletes still have more
of all types of plaques.
In the 2023 Masters at Heart study,
they compared 191 lifelong endurance athletes,
191 athletes who started later in life,
and 176 healthy non-athletic controls.
Lifelong athletes had more coronary plaques,
including calcified, mixed, and non-calcified plaques.
Now none of these studies prove that running
or endurance exercise causes these plaques,
but it of course is concerning and it does deserve some investigation.
One explanation is that atherosclerosis,
and these plaques develop with age regardless of what you do,
is a common phenomenon of human aging.
Athletes aren't immune to this, but they develop more
calcified plaque rather than soft plaque.
Now the calcified plaque is a bit more positive,
but any non-zero calcium score still involves some risk
of a heart attack in the future.
So does this higher amount of plaque
then translate over to more cardiovascular events?
This is where it gets interesting
because the higher amount of plaque in these athletes
doesn't seem to increase the risk of getting heart attacks
or other cardiovascular events.
One study followed 8,425 men for an average of 8.4 years.
During that time,
383 cardiovascular events occurred.
More coronary calcium was associated with more events, but
greater cardiorespiratory fitness was associated
with fewer events across the calcium score categories
After adjusting for calcium burden,
each additional MET of fitness or metabolic equivalent was
associated with an 11% lower risk of cardiovascular events.
One MET of fitness corresponds to approximately 3.5 mL
per kg per minute of oxygen consumption
in VO2max.
This means that having a higher cardiovascular fitness still
is protective even in the presence
of having plaque.
And the athletes who do have higher
fitness see fewer cardiovascular events.
Physical activity levels also have an effect.
A 2019 study followed over 21,000 men for
approximately 10 years.
Those who reported at least 3,000 MET minutes of activity per week
were slightly more likely to have
a coronary calcium score of at least 100. However,
high activity levels were not associated
with significantly increased cardiovascular or
all-cause mortality, even
when they saw substantial coronary calcium. So therefore,
over 3,000 met minutes per week of physical activity
in the presence of a calcium score of
Over a hundred.
Seems to reduce the increased risk of cardiovascular disease events,
whereas having a calcium score
of over 100, while also having less than 1500 MET minutes
per week of physical activity increases
the risk.
So how do you get 3000 MET minutes per week of physical activity?
Brisk walking for 1 hour every day gives you 1500 MET minutes per week,
you're already halfway
there.
Lifting weights for 1 hour 3 times a week equals 750 MET-minutes per week.
If you do Zone 2 cardio for one hour
at a speed of around 10 kilometers per hour,
That gives you 588 metminutes per week.
Doing it twice a week is around 1176 metminutes per week.
In total, if you follow this workout plan,
you're going to get over 3000 MET-minutes per week quite easily.
So this means why the calcium is there matters a lot.
And exercising more necessarily doesn't
translate over to higher calcium.
Because as you saw from these studies,
people who were fitter and people
who had higher levels of physical activity
actually had fewer cardiovascular disease events.
And they were less likely to die to heart disease.
Exercise intensity also appears to matter.
The Mark 2 study followed 289 middle-aged and
older male athletes for approximately 6 years.
Total exercise volume wasn't associated with
changes in coronary calcium or plaque.
But a greater proportion of very vigorous exercise,
which was categorized as over 9 METs,
was associated with greater progression of coronary
calcium and calcified plaque.
Vigorous exercise in the 6-9 MET range was associated with less
So if you do a lot of high-intensity exercise...
After a certain point of that,
you do start to contribute to more calcium, whereas doing
more moderate intensity exercise does not appear to do so.
Another 2024 study on over 8,700 people followed
for 8 years found that physical activity volume
or how much exercise you did wasn't associated
with coronary calcium progression.
This means that it's not how much exercise you do,
but how much intense and very vigorous
exercise you do is what matters.
There are also other factors besides the exercise itself
that determine whether someone gets plaque
or not. Because as you saw from one of the earlier studies,
almost half of the athletes didn't develop
any plaque. Things like diet quality, stress levels,
performance-enhancing drugs, how much you sleep,
magnesium deficiency, inflammation, as well as genetics,
determine whether someone gets plaque
or not. So so far the things that you do want
to pay attention to is aiming for getting a higher
cardiovascular fitness, because people
with higher fitness had fewer events even in the presence of
And also doing over 3,000 MET-minutes per week of exercise,
which is quite easy to do.
It doesn't take that much time.
Rather than doing a lot of intense exercise,
you also want to incorporate more moderate
exercise, which is one of the changes
I've made over the last few years.
Rather than just doubling down
and doing more intense exercise, lifting more weights, doing
more HIIT cardio, et cetera, I incorporate
a lot more moderate exercise while capping
my high-intensity exercise at a reasonable level.
I've personally increased my VO2max from 53 to 66,
reduced my ApoB from 85 to 58,
and lowered my visceral fat from 359 grams to just 54 grams.
If you want to improve your own cardiovascular
fitness, body composition, and longevity,
then check out my top 1% health community.
Inside, you'll get access to my training,
nutrition, and other protocols,
plus weekly coaching calls where I help you put
these strategies into practice.
The link to join is in the description.
Now the takeaway for this video isn't
that you shouldn't do any endurance exercise. Actually,
short-term endurance exercise can actually help
with a lot of heart disease risk factors.
Researchers just recently looked
at 138 first-time marathon runners age 21 to 69 before and after
competing in the London Marathon.
Over approximately six months, their central systolic blood pressure
decreased by around four points
and diastolic blood pressure decreased by around three points.
Parts of the descending aorta also became more flexible. These changes
corresponded to approximately a four-year reduction
in their estimated aortic age.
Older participants, especially men with slower marathon times,
saw even greater benefits.
Now this study didn't look at calcium progression in the arteries,
and you wouldn't expect calcium
to also progress within a few months only,
but it might give us an explanation why these athletes
still have fewer cardiovascular events.
Their blood vessels and overall cardiovascular system
compensate for the increased plaque that they might experience.
Their blood vessels become
supple, more flexible, they even dilate,
they become wider, so it's a compensation mechanism.
Yes, the plaque might increase in some individuals,
but overall their blood vessels become healthier.
Which reduces the total risk of heart disease.
And the answer is obviously also how
much exercise are we talking about?
Most people watching this aren't endurance athletes
and they're not ultra endurance athletes.
Most of the masters athletes
who are studied exercise like 10 plus hours a week and they
do 10 plus hours of cardio per week.
So if you do zero cardio, then you shouldn't
be afraid of cardio because of these people
who do 10 plus hours per week.
You're not going to see any calcium progression
if you do one to two hours of cardio per week.
That's just ridiculous.
What about the athletes who do marathons every day?
An unusual study followed participants in the race across the USA.
This was a 140-day event.
The finishers averaged approximately 26 miles per day,
six days per week. Eight runners completed
the study and they went through coronary CT imaging before
and after the race. Out of eight,
four had no detectable coronary disease at baseline
and they remained at zero afterwards.
The other four already had coronary disease.
All four showed increases in plaque volume.
In three of them, the increase was predominantly non-calcified plaque.
Those three also showed increases in the inflammatory marker CRP.
Existing plaque influences whether someone
progresses further with their plaque if they
do a lot of endurance exercise.
If you already have pre-existing plaque then the likelihood
that it's going to progress is much higher compared
to someone who has zero plaque and
as we saw from the study four people out
of these eight didn't progress at all in the calcium because
they had zero at the baseline.
The other four who had pre-existing plaque did see progression
mostly in the non-calcified plaque
which eventually will become calcified.
Pre-existing plaque can exist because of many reasons.
Some people have a history of unhealthy lifestyle or even pre-diabetes,
which increases plaque accumulation.
Some people might have genetic factors
that increase their atherogenic lipid burden.
And there are others who are less likely
to develop plaque because of genetics
and other protective factors.
One thing to also consider is the diet quality
that these masters athletes might have.
If you are exercising a lot,
then you have a lot of calories you can consume every day.
You can eat a lot of food without gaining fat,
and you can eat unhealthier food without gaining fat.
So, as a result of that, these athletes might
just have slightly worse quality in their
diet.
They might eat more processed food just to get the calories in.
If you combine that with the higher amounts
of stress from too much exercise, then you
get a recipe for more plaque development.
Because their cardiovascular fitness
and arterial function is still very good from the exercise,
they're really good at repairing the damage and calcifying the plaque,
and because their blood flow is excellent
and the blood vessels also expand thanks to the exercise,
their total burden of cardiovascular disease
is not much higher compared to the general
population who doesn't exercise.
So what should you do with all this information?
Here are some main points. Number one,
training for a first marathon was associated with lower
blood pressure and improved aortic flexibility.
This means that exercise, even if you exercise
for something like a marathon,
certainly has beneficial effects on cardiovascular function,
no doubt about that. If you don't exercise for a marathon,
then you shouldn't even worry about it,
because you're not exercising that much.
Number two, some lifelong male endurance athletes
have more coronary plaque than less active plaque,
specifically more calcified plaque.
Number three, higher cardiovascular fitness
is associated with better cardiovascular outcomes,
including in people with coronary calcium.
So number four, you should build your fitness and
assess the other parts of cardiovascular health.
You should pay attention to your blood pressure,
lipids, blood sugar, smoking history,
as well as genetic family history.
My main takeaway from all of this is that exercise
is so good for your heart health
that even if lifelong endurance exercise does appear
to increase the risk of calcified plaque,
it compensates greatly for it
by still reducing overall cardiovascular disease events.
And you can greatly reduce the risk
of the plaque development by paying attention to
other risk factors and also not doing something like ultra-endurance.
As I said earlier, if your takeaway
from this is that cardio is bad for you because
these endurance athletes who run 10 hours a week have more plaque,
then it doesn't really apply to
you because you're not training that much.
If you do one to two hours of cardio per week,
that's not too much exercise.
That's a reasonable amount of exercise. You don't need to do ultra
endurance exercise to improve your aerobic fitness
or to get the health benefits from exercise.
Fortunately, most people watching this,
they don't train that much. So these findings don't
Don't really apply to you.
In fact, you don't need any more than just a few hours of exercise
per week to increase your VO2max and other fitness metrics.
Check out my video about how I increase my VO2max
from 53 to 66 with only 3 hours of exercise per week.