Deep And Cunning Schemes - Why Was Tran Binh Favored By Liu Bang More Than Truong Liang?

History & Culture of East
10 followers
93 Video Views·Jun 15, 2026
Chen Ping, a strategist with extraordinary intelligence, used bold and unexpected tactics to help Liu Bang overcome perilous situations. Battlecry - A journey to discover how Chen Ping resolved political and military crises during the Han-Chu era.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedChen Ping was a master strategist of the Han Dynasty who specialized in pragmatism and subversion. By sowing discord among enemies and navigating treacherous court politics, he played a pivotal role in Liu Bang's rise to power and the early stability of the empire, though his legacy is often debated through the lens of his devious methods.
Chen Ping was a brilliant strategist, resolving deadlocks for Lu Bang and the Han forces.
While Zheng Liang excelled at grand strategic planning,
Chen Ping was the master of tactics, solving immediate, pressing crises.
He used subversion to drive a wedge between Xiang Yu and Fan Zeng,
and orchestrated Ji Xiyan's sacrifice to save Lu Bang.
Thus, history says, planning like Fan Zeng, scheming like Chen Ping.
Early Life
Chen Ping was from Yanwu, southeast of Yuanyang, in modern-day Henan.
Neither the records of the grand historian nor the Book of Han detail his lineage.
Noting only an older brother, Chen Bo, he was described as tall, handsome, and eager to learn.
While Chen Bo farmed, Chen Ping focused solely on books, avoiding labor.
Chen Bo worked hard to support his brother's long-distance studies.
His sister-in-law despised his lack of industry and showed him contempt.
Chen Bo even divorced his wife, fully believing in his brother's potential.
Despite his looks, wealthy families refused to marry their daughters to him.
Yet, he deemed poor women beneath his station.
Eventually, a wealthy man named Xiang Fu had a daughter widowed five times.
As every husband she married passed away.
After the fifth husband died, no one dared to approach her, except Chen Ping.
Xiang Fu, being perceptive, saw Chen Ping as the only ambitious youth,
well-read in the classics and distinct from others,
who only knew manual labor, so he grew to respect him.
He ultimately gave his daughter to him in marriage.
As Chen Ping was poor, Xiang Fu provided the funds and silk for the wedding.
He often provided funds for his studies.
Joining Xiang Yu
Late Qin era, rebels rose across the land.
The most prominent was Chen Xing and Xu.
Chen Xing proclaimed himself king, fighting Qin and inspiring others.
In Wei, Wei Jiu was installed as king by Chen Xing's forces.
Chen Ping saw the chaos as his chance for glory.
He left home with friends to join Wei Jiu's army.
Wei Jiu disregarded him, swayed by slanders.
Fearing for his life, Chen Ping fled Wei.
Years later, Xiang Yu marched to destroy Qin.
Chen Ping joined him and was recruited.
With Qin fallen, Xiang Yu and Lu Bang fought for power.
By 205 BC, Lu Bang secured the Qin south.
His strength grew, and he marched east.
Sima Ong of Yin defected to Han.
Xiang Yu sent Chen Ping to attack.
Chen Ping led his loyal followers into Yin territory.
He forced Sima Ong's surrender and was rewarded with gold.
But soon, Han forces advanced, and Sima Ong defected again.
Enraged, Xiang Yu ordered an investigation into the campaign.
Suspecting the commanders of prior collusion.
Xiang Yu's irrational anger terrified Chen Ping.
He fled from Chu to the Han camp.
Before leaving, he sealed the gold Xiang Yu gave him.
Returned it, and escaped across the Yellow River.
The boatman saw the handsome stranger traveling alone and assumed he was a deserter.
Suspecting he carried golden jewels, the man plotted to kill him.
Chen Ping sensed the danger, stripped off his robes, and rode alongside him.
Seeing Chen Ping had nothing of value, the boatman let him be.
That was Chen Ping's life before joining the Han.
He was brilliant, flexible, and adapted to every situation.
He never clung to rigid political loyalties.
But acted according to the times, unhindered by tradition.
Such a pragmatic mind was perfect for Liu Bang's camp.
Chen Ping joined the Han through Wei Wuxi's introduction.
Liu Bang enjoyed their first talk immensely.
Knowing his past, Liu Bang made him a commandant,
sharing his chariot and military command.
Many Han generals were displeased by his rapid promotion.
In 204 BC, Liu Bang's eastward advance was crushed by Chu at Pengcheng.
The weakened forces were forced to retreat to Xinyang.
Liu Bang realized he lacked military genius and must rely on his subordinates.
He appointed Chen Ping as a senior advisor, commanding forces at Guangwu.
Zhou Bo and Guan Ning seized the chance to slander Chen Ping to Liu Bang.
They accused him of corruption.
A furious Liu Bang summoned Wei Wuxi to explain.
Wei Wuxi argued that if Chen Ping's schemes benefited the state, that was enough.
Petty grievances should be overlooked.
Liu Bang softened but still confronted Chen Ping, calling him disloyal.
Chen Ping replied, I served Qing Wei, but he ignored my plans, so I left for Xianyu.
Xianyu distrusts all but his own kin and brothers-in-law.
He wastes talent, so I left Chu to follow you, great king.
I heard you were a wise ruler, so I risked everything to come here.
Without the gold, I would have had no means to travel.
If my plans have any merit, great king, please use them.
If they are useless, the gold remains intact.
I shall return it to the treasury and resign my post.
Liu Bang was convinced and personally apologized to Chen Ping.
He appointed him commander of the central army, silencing all slanderers.
In 204 BC, Xianyu besieged Xinyang, with defeat imminent, Chen Ping devised a ruse.
He had Ji Xiyin, who resembled the king,
dress in royal robes and exit the east gate to surrender.
Xianyu's troops, distracted, gathered at the east gate to see the king.
The west gate was left unguarded, allowing Liu Bang and Chen Ping to escape.
Chen Ping's brilliance proved more effective than an army of 100,000.
That same year, Liu Bang sought peace by ceding Xinyang, but Xianyu refused.
Chen Ping advised using gold to sow discord among Xianyu's ranks.
Agreeing, Liu Bang granted him 4,000 caddies of gold without hesitation.
He was given full discretion to spend it as he saw fit.
In Chu, Chen Ping used the wealth to bribe informants within the ranks.
Rumors spread that Fan Zheng, despite his service,
was discontented and planned to defect to Han for a fiefdom.
Xianyu, suspicious, sent an envoy to Han, Liu Bang feigned surprise.
I thought you were sent by Fan Zheng, not Xianyu.
This implied Liu Bang expected an emissary from Fan Zheng, not the king.
The envoy reported this, framing Fan Zheng as a traitor to the Han cause.
Xianyu grew suspicious of his advisor, just as Chen Ping planned.
When Fan Zheng urged a final assault on Xinyang, Xianyu refused to listen.
Curious, Fan Zheng left for Pengqing and died of illness on the way.
Chu lost its greatest strategist, like a pillar crumbling away.
By now, the Chu forces were weakening and no longer matched the Han.
Liu Bang had also eliminated his greatest threat, Fan Zheng.
Following Chen Ping's plan, Liu Bang sent 2,000 women through the east gate of Xinyang.
The distracted Chu forces converged on the east.
Liu Bang and Chen Ping slipped out the west gate to regroup.
The Plot to Capture Han Xiyan
In 203 BC, General Han Xiyan occupied the Qi state and declared himself king of Qi.
He sent envoys to Liu Bang, who was besieged by Xianyu at Xinyang.
When Han Xiyan demanded a royal title, Liu Bang was curious at his refusal to send reinforcements.
Chen Ping stepped on Liu Bang's foot to signal him to stay calm.
They sent Xiang Liang to acknowledge Han Xiyan as king.
This maneuver proved critical before the Battle of Geisha.
Grateful, Han Xiyan joined Liu Bang, Ying Bu, and Ping Yu to defeat Xiang Yu.
In 202 BC, Liu Bang defeated Xiang Yu and ascended as emperor.
In July 202 BC, Chen Ping accompanied Liu Bang to pacify the Yan state.
In 201 BC, Han Xiyan was accused of treason, the generals urged an immediate attack.
Liu Bang, eager to eliminate Han Xiyan, was stopped by Chen Ping.
Chen Ping asked if Liu Bang's troops matched Han Xiyan's.
Liu Bang admitted they did not.
Chen Ping then asked if his generals were stronger than Han Xiyan's.
Liu Bang replied, how could they be?
Chen Ping warned that attacking with weaker forces would only drive Han Xiyan to rebel.
He advised a secret plan to capture Han Xiyan instead.
Chen Ping argued that none in the Han army could defeat Han Xiyan on the battlefield.
He proposed pretending to tour Yunmeng Lake to lure Han Xiyan into a trap.
Liu Bang succeeded, demoted Han Xiyan to Marquis of Huayin, and made Chen Ping a Marquis.
Chen Ping suggested rewarding Wei Wuzhi for recommending him.
Liu Bang agreed.
A plan to save the emperor.
In 201 BC, the Xiongnu invaded the Han territory.
In 200 BC, Emperor Gaozu led his army against the Xiongnu.
But they were defeated and besieged at Bidang for seven days.
With the troops exhausted, Chen Ping offered a scheme to the emperor.
He sent an envoy to gift the Xiongnu Chanyu's wife a portrait.
Depicting the most beautiful woman in Han to plead for peace.
The wife grew jealous and urged the Chanyu to retreat, lifting the siege.
Later, the emperor toured Cuny, impressed by its landscape.
Granting Chen Ping 5,000 households there as the Marquis of Cuny.
This replaced his previous fiefdom at Hudu.
Arresting Fan Kuai.
Chen Ping helped suppress rebellions by Qin Shi and Ying Bu.
His six secret plans succeeded, earning him repeated promotions.
Yet, his strategies remained so clandestine that few ever knew them.
In 195 BC, Liu Wan, king of Yan, rebelled.
Emperor Gaozu, being ill, ordered Fan Kuai to suppress him.
Slanderers claimed Fan Kuai plotted treason,
so Liu Bang sent Chen Ping and Zhou Bo to execute him.
He ordered them to behead Fan Kuai immediately upon arrival.
They captured Fan Kuai, but Chen Ping realized the emperor was dying.
Fan Kuai was married to Empress Liu's younger sister.
Fearing the empress's wrath, he spared Fan Kuai and escorted him to Chong'an.
He left Zhou Bo to pacify Yan, proving Chen Ping's cunning adaptability.
En route, hearing of Gaozu's death, he rushed to the capital, leaving Fan Kuai behind.
Empress Liu ordered Chen Ping to Xinyang, but he returned to Chong'an to mourn Gaozu.
Moved, the empress made him chamberlain and tutor to Emperor Hui.
Fan Kuai was eventually pardoned and had his titles restored.
In 189 BC, Grand Chancellor Chaoshan passed away.
Empress Liu appointed Wang Ling as right Grand Chancellor.
Chen Ping was appointed left Grand Chancellor.
In 187 BC, Emperor Hui of Han passed away.
The empress installed the young emperor and sought to make her king kings.
She consulted Wang Ling, who vehemently opposed her.
The empress then asked Chen Ping and Zhou Bo for their opinion.
They carefully answered to appease her desires.
The empress was pleased, but Wang Ling later rebuked them.
Chen Ping said, we cannot match your courage to defy her in court.
But in protecting the Liu clan's legacy, you cannot match us.
In the eleventh month, the empress demoted Wang Ling to a powerless tutor.
She made Chen Ping right Grand Chancellor and Shen Yiji the left.
She then elevated her relative, the Marquis of Li, to king of Liu.
She also named her brother, Liu Tai, king of Liu Su.
She purged the Liu kings to replace them with her own kin.
Her sister, Liu Su, was Fan Kui's wife.
She hated Chen Ping for his past schemes against her husband.
She constantly slandered him to the empress as a drunken lecher.
Chen Ping feigned decadence, the empress dismissed him as harmless and unfit to oppose her.
She encouraged him to ignore Liu Su's malicious words.
The Purge of the Liu Clan
In 180 BC, the ailing empress Liu appointed Liu Lu as general-in-chief of the northern army.
She appointed Liu Chan to command the southern army to prevent the ministers from seizing power.
She made Liu Chan chancellor and married Liu Lu's daughter to Emperor Hou Xiao to cement her control.
That same year, Empress Liu passed away, and the Liu royal clan began to rise in rebellion.
Liu Zhang, Marquis of Zhuxiu and grandson of Gaozu, sought to eliminate the Liu clan.
He aimed to place his brother, the king of Qi, upon the imperial throne.
He urged the king of Qi to march west, defeat the Lius, and claim the empire.
Marquis Zhuxiu and Marquis Domo would serve as insiders with the court ministers.
Facing the Qi forces, Chancellor Liu Chan sent Guan Ning to suppress the uprising.
Instead, Guan Ning encamped at Xingyang and pledged to join the king of Qi against the Liu clan.
Chen Ping and Zhou Bo pressured Li Ji, who was close to Liu Lu,
to convince him to surrender his command.
The Liu faction hesitated, fearing they would be betrayed if they relinquished their power.
Liu Lu and Liu Chan considered a coup but were paralyzed by indecision and fear.
Meanwhile, Zhou Bo used an imperial mandate to seize control of the northern army.
He then sent Li Ji to persuade Liu Lu once more to yield his post.
Liu Lu relented, surrendered his seal, and handed command to Zhou Bo.
With the northern army secured,
Chen Ping helped Zhou Bo eliminate Liu Chan and the entire Liu clan.
Chen Ping averted a civil war, securing the throne for Emperor Wen without spilling blood.
The Era of Emperor Wen
Emperor Wen sought to grant Chen Ping the highest honor in the empire.
Chen Ping realized that outranking the other officials would invite jealousy and danger.
He feigned illness, arguing that Zhou Bo deserved the top rank for leading the purge of the Lius.
He yielded to Zhou Bo, who was made senior chancellor, while Chen Ping became junior
chancellor. The emperor rewarded him with a thousand caddies of gold and increased his
fief to ten thousand households. However, Zhou Bo was a military man,
unsuited for the complexities of civil administration. Unable to manage court affairs,
Zhou Bo resigned in shame, leaving Chen Ping as the sole chancellor.
At this point, Chen Ping finally consolidated total power.
Chen Ping passed away in 178 BC. His son, Chen Mai, succeeded him as the Marquis of Chuanai.
Two years later, Chen Mai died, and his son, Chen Hui, succeeded him as the Marquis of Jian.
Twenty-three years later, Chen Hui passed away, and his son, Chen He, succeeded him.
In 130 BC, Chen He was executed for stealing another man's wife, and his title was abolished.
This incident is linked to a well-known legend.
Chen Ping once said his reliance on devious schemes would eventually exhaust his family's
fortune and prosperity. In Taoist philosophy, open schemes benefit all, while devious schemes
harm others for personal gain. Knowing his methods were ruthless and sacrificial, Chen Ping foresaw
this inevitable decline. Later, his great-grandson, Chen Zhong, lived during the reign of Emperor Wu
of Han. Chen Zhong tried to restore his family's nobility through the emperor's favored Wei clan,
but failed. Sima Qian offered this evaluation of Chen Ping.
Chen Ping was a scholar of Taoist teachings from his youth.
He showed great ambition early on, navigating the chaos between the Chu and Wei states.
He joined Emperor Gaozu, providing the strategic brilliance to resolve crises and protect the
state. During Empress Lu's turbulent era, he survived and secured the imperial ancestral
temples. He died with a virtuous reputation, was his life not truly complete? Without extraordinary
intelligence, how could one achieve such a legacy? Yet Lu Bang once remarked that while
Chen Ping was clever, he could not govern the state alone. Conclusion. Chen Ping stands as a
master strategist of the Qin-Han transition. His many ingenious schemes were vital to establishing
the 400-year Han dynasty. After his rise, Lu Bang purged heroes,
forcing men like Xiao He and Zhang Lian to hide or flee.
